HomeMy WebLinkAbout08-18-2015 Civil Service Commission.O_
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
Tuesday, August 18, 2015
8:30 AM
Emma Harvat Hall
City Hall
410 E. Washington St.
Iowa City, IA
1. Chris Buckman Appeal Hearing
2. Old business
3. New business
Any late handouts will be included in the meeting minutes.
f\J
BEFORE THE IOWA CITY CIVIL SERVICE CONEMISSION a-
c_
NOTICE OF APPEAL OF CHRIS BUCKMAN: od
ca
1. Chris Buckman, Lieutenant of the Iowa City Fire Department was
terminated on July 7, 2015
2, Iowa Code Chapter 400.18 provides that a person holding civil service
rights shall not be removed arbitrarily.
3. The removal of Lieutenant Chris Buckman was done arbitrarily and
without sufficient basis in violation of Iowa Code Section 400,18.
4. The arbitrary removal was based upon a policy established by the City of
Iowa City requiring certain residency requirements.
Said policy is arbitrary and capricious and beats no rational relationship to
the job duties required of an Iowa City Fire Fighter.
The policy fails to define "residence" so as to alert a firefighter as to what
behavior is proscribed. The definition was not provided to the firefighters even though
requested.
Chris Bruckman did not violate the City of Iowa City's policy regarding
residency as the City is unable to establish that Chris Bruckman's residence is at a
location other than 2233 91" Street, Coralville, Iowa.
8. Chris Bruckman did not violate the other policies specified in the
document dated Judy 7, 2015 entitled "Investigative Findings"
9. This Appeal is timely
10. Appellant requests that this matter be set for proceedings pursuant to Iowa
Code Chapter 400.
Nazette, Manner, Nathanson
&Shea L.L.P.
615 tad St. SW
P.O. Box 74210
Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52407
Phone: (319) 366-1000
Fax: (319) 364-1116
Crystal. usher(:(�nazettela w.conT
41NIS',e21
r AT0008023
ATTORNEY FOR CHRIS BRUCI MAN
0('ris
ruc Tan ---
Tho Undarsi9 ed cCERertifies hat the foregoing j stnm
served upon all partim to the above cause to each of tn.
of record herein at their respoctivo addrosses chsclo
Pleadings on
BY:!J Overnight Coudor 20/
LJ Hand Delivered ❑ FAX [ b_
[j Cortifle 61a11 0 us. mail
Signature can ed
C.C'
ch
C
71
.�
ca
n,
BEFORE THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION FOR IOWA CITY, IOWA
IN RE: THE DISCIPLINARY
DISCHARGE OF LT.
CHRIS BUCKMAN
APPELLANT
V.
CITY OF IOWA CITY, IOWA,
IOWA CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT, and
JOHN M. GRIER, FIRE CHIEF,
APPELLEES
CITY'S SPECIFICATION OF CHARGES
w
COME NOW the City of Iowa City, Iowa, the Iowa City Fire Department and John M. Grier,
Fire Chief, Appellees in the above -referenced matter, and hereby specify the charges and
grounds upon which Lt. Chris Buckman (hereinafter, "Buckman") was terminated, stating as
follows:
1. Living within a specified distance of his place of employment has been a condition of
Buckman's employment with the City of Iowa City since he was hired as a firefighter. At
the time Buckman was promoted to lieutenant, the requirement was included in the job
description. The City's Administrative Regulation on Residency Requirements, which
took effect in May, 2015, actually loosened the Fire Department's earlier requirements.
2. On December 17, 2013 Buckman filed an Address Change Form, reporting that he lived
at 2233 9th street in Coralville, IA. He also verbally stated to Chief Grier, on multiple
occasions, that he lived at this Coralville address.
3. The Fire Department received information indicating that Buckman was living outside the
boundaries of the City's Administrative Regulation on Residency Requirements, while
claiming to reside at 2233 9t' St. in Coralville, IA.
4. On or about June 17, 2015, Buckman was provided a Summary of Charges outlining the
policy requirements in question, a copy of which is attached hereto and incorporated
herein. He was also provided a Notification of Administrative Proceedings Rights, a
copy of which is attached hereto and incorporated herein, which stated that Buckman
was obligated to answer all questions truthfully, and that failure to do so would serve as
a basis for discipline, including discharge.
5. A formal investigation was conducted into the matters, including use of a private
investigator to explore the issues of residency. That investigation revealed that
Buckman was not living at the Coralville address he provided.
6. An interview of Buckman took place on June 19, 2015. At the beginning of Buckman's
interview, he was again verbally reminded that the City was exploring both the issues of
residency and integrity.
7. During his interview, Buckman initially claimed that he lived at the Coralville address, but
eventually conceded, in response to a question from his union steward, that he did not
live in Coralville. Instead, he was living with his fiancee in Marion, IA, outside the
residency boundary.
8. The investigation concluded that Buckman not only violated the City's Administrative
Regulation on Residency Requirements, but also lied about his residency, attempting to
cover up his actual residence, and coming clean only when confronted with water usage
records at the Coralville address.
On July 7, 2015, Lt. Chris Buckman was discharged from employment with the Iowa City Fire
Department for misconduct based on the above, and for the following violations of Iowa City Fire
Department General Policy and the City of Iowa City Personnel Policies:
Iowa City Fire Department General Polices:
ICFD General Policy No. 150.02-Residency Requirements, which has been superseded
by the more generous May, 2015 City Administrative Regulation on Residency
Requirements.
City of Iowa City Personnel Policies
City of Iowa City Personnel Policies Section 8, b (6), "violation of departmental rules,
City Personnel Policies or any other rules, policies, or regulations promulgated by the
City."
City of Iowa City Personnel Policies Section 8, b (7), "Lying or providing false,
inaccurate, or incomplete information either verbally or in writing."
Original: Iowa City City Clerk
copy: Crystal L. Usher
Attorney for Appellant
Respectfully submi
Q�
ohn M. Grier, Chief > > c-,
Iowa City Fire Department" '' f
'i
l
Tro undersigned hereby oerAbs th& true
wadserved
upon each of thof the e®pates or their attorneys of
record to the above-enthled cause In person
or at their respectilve addresses as disclosed
by the pleadings of record herein on
� - `t by
,a. MCA
g 4 0FOX
•
�' Overnight%.Y
I
IOWA CITE' FIRE DEPARTMENT
410 E. Washingion Street —Iowa City, IA 52240-1821
Phone: 319.356,5260 w\vw.iceor.i rc FAX: 319.356.5269
Date:
June 17, 2015
...�ri
To:
Chris Buckman, Lieutenant
From:
John M. Grier, Fire Chief
y.-
CJ
Re:
Summary of Charges
The department has received information indicating that you have been living outside
the established residency boundaries, while claiming to reside at 2233 9ei Street in
Coralvllle, IA.
As a basic requirement of your position as a Fire Lieutenant, you are required to
maintain residency in the boundaries outlined in ICFD General Policy No. 150.02—
Residency Requirements, which was superseded by the May 2015 City Administrative
Regulation on Residency Requirements, and the Fire Lieutenant Job description. Failure
to maintain residency in the defined boundaries is a direct violation of the established
residency requirements policy, Furthermore, the City of Iowa City's Personnel Policies
Section 8, b (6) states that violation of rules, policies or regulations promulgated by the
City and Section 8, b (7) states that lying or providing false, inaccurate, or Incomplete
information on a City record are grounds for discipline.
Consider this a summary of the charges to be Investigated as well as notice that a formal
investigation will be conducted. During this investigation, you will be ordered to answer
all questions truthfully, under potential penalty of further disciplinary action, and none
Of your answers may be used against you in any subsequent criminal proceeding.
You are mandated to attend an administrative Interview to be held on Friday, June 19,
2015 at 2:00 PM in the Human Resources conference room,
Notification of Administrative Proceeding Rights
You are being advised of the following;
I_ This is an administrative hearing during wine), you will be interviewed regarding events
which may be used as the basis for disciplinary measures including discharge or suspension.
Any admission made it, the course of any administrative hearing or interview may be used as
the basis for disciplinary measures, including discharge or suspension.
2. You have the right to have legal counsel present, at your expense, during your interview. In
addition, you have the right, at your expense, to have a union representative present during
the interview or, if not a member of a union, you have the right to have a designee present.
3. You have no right to remain silent at this administrative proceeding. You have an obligation
to truthfully answer questions put to you. Untruthful answers constitute a violation of the
Policies of the Iowa City Fire Department and the City of Iowa City and will serve as a basis
for disciplinary measures, including discharge or suspension.
4. If you refuse to answer questions put to you, you will be ordered by a superior to answer the
questions. If you persist in your refusal to answer after the order to answer has been given to
you, or if you do not answer a question truthfully, you are advised that such refusal or
untruthful answer constitutes a violation of the Policies of the Iowa City Fire Department and
the City of Iowa City and will serve as a basis for which your discharge may be sought.
5. You are further advised that by law any admission made by you during the course of this
proceeding cannot be used against you in a criminal proceeding.
6. Your interview will be audio recorded, as required by law.
7. Prior to your interview you are being provided with a written summary of the complaint made
against you,
I, the un rsigr , do hereby acknowledge that I have been informed of the above rights.
-- J/Rts70PNl,� �txKwAr�
rgnatitre Printed Name of Employee
Date:
Wi
r„
u� i mw
€:i
1. L
v"
.r r
y W
Administrative Regulations
City of Iowa City
Title: Residency Requirements
A,R. Number; Effective Date: 2/15 Page: 1 of 2
Supersedes: N/A A.R.: N/A Dated: 5/15
^r
CI71' or low'\C ml
I. Purpose
The following represents a policy establishing the maximum distance police officers,
firefighters and other critical municipal employees may live from their place of employment per
Chapter 400,17 of the Iowa Code.
II. Policy
Employees holding the following positions shall be required to live within 17 miles of the
corporate limits of Iowa City, Iowa within one year of appointment to the position:
Deputy Fire Chief
Fire Battalion Chief
Fire Captain
Fire Lieutenant
Firefighter
Police Captain
Police Lieutenant
Police Sergeant
Police Officer
Animal Shelter Supervisor
Maintenance Worker I — Streets
Maintenance Worker 11 (Signs) — Streets
Maintenance Worker II — Streets
Maintenance Worker III — Streets
Maintenance Worker III (Lead Sweeper Operator) — Streets
Senior Maintenance Worker — Streets
Maintenance Operator — Wastewater
Maintenance Worker II — Wastewater Treatment Plant
Maintenance Worker Ill — Wastewater Collection
Senior Maintenance Worker — Wastewater Collection
Senior Maintenance Worker — Wastewater Plant
Senior Treatment Plant Operator — Wastewater
Assistant Superintendent — Water
Maintenance Operator — Water
Maintenance Worker I —Water Customer Service
Maintenance Worker II — Waster Distribution
Maintenance Worker II — Water Service
Maintenance Worker III — Water Distribution
Maintenance Worker III — Water Service
Senior Maintenance Worker — Water Distribution
Senior Maintenance Worker— Water Plant
Senior Treatment Plant Operator — Water
Treatment Plant Operator — Water
This policy supersedes any residency requirement policies adopted at the Department level.
Employees in positions covered by this policy who were in compliance with a Departmental
residency policy upon the adoption of this policy will be considered grandfathered under the
prior documented departmental policy. Grandfather status will be lost upon relocation to a
different residence which must satisfy the requirements of this policy.
III. Regulation Update and Responsibility
Periodic review, updates, and questions of interpretation of this policy are the responsibility of
Human Resources. Department Directors shall be ultimately responsible for
ensuring/monitoring compliance of employees in positions subject to this policy. The City
Manager or designee shall be responsible for final interpretation and application of this policy.
Any waivers or extensions of this policy shall be subject to the approval of the City Manager or
designee.
Approved
r
City Manager
i
IOWA CITY lC7[RE, D]LPAR1[N[ENT
General Policy No. 150.02
SUBJECT ORIGINAL ISSUE
Residency Requirements May 1993
LAST AMENDED MANDATORY REVIEW DATE
June 2015 April Annually
1. PURPOSE:
The following represents a policy establishing the boundaries in Which a person must reside
while ill the employment of the Iowa City Fire Department.
II. SCOPE:
All personnel assigned.
III. POLICY:
Effective May 2015, fire department employees shall be required to live wilhin17 miles of
the corporate limits of Iowa City.
A. If living outside these boundaries when hired, a person will have twelve (12) months
ill which to comply.
B. Waivers of extensions to these requirements nest be requested ill writing to the
Chief for submittal to the City Manager for approval or disapproval.
C. Employees who Nvere in compliance with the departmental residency policy
(residing Within the boundaries of Johnson County or within an 18 mile radius of
Fire Stalion 1 or by issuance of a waiver) Will be considered grandfathered under the
prior departmental policy. Grandfather status will be lost upon relocation to a
different residence Which must satisfy the requirement of this policy.
D. City of Iowa City Administrative Policy on Residency Requirements at
htlw./haw_w2icgov,ore/site/CMSv2/Iile/emPRes/adminPolicies/Rcsidcnc� ltcquiremc
nls. xlf establishes the maximum distance firelighters may live from their place of
employment per Chapter 400.17 of the Iowa Code.
1 of I
SUBJECT
Residency Requirements
LAST AMENDED
April 2002
IOWA CITY FIRE, DEPARINVIENT
General Policy No. 1,50.02,
ORIGINAL ISSUE
May 1993
MANDATORY REVIEW DATE
April Annually
I. PURPOSE:
This policy describes the boundaries in which a person must reside while in the employment
of the Iowa City Fire Department.
II. SCOPE:
All personnel assigned.
III. POLICY:
The required boundaries for residence while employed by the Iowa City Fire Department
are within the boundaries of Johnson County or within an 18 mile radius of Fire Station I
(Appendix No. G1)-150.02-01).
A. If living outside these boundaries when hired, a person will have twelve (12) months
in which to comply.
B. Exceptions to these requirements must be submitted in writing to the Chief for
approval or disapproval.
I of I
3 0
Residency Requirements
SOurco: Produced by Johnson Counly Information Services usir
12 Mlles 2000 Census T43FRI1.1110 Piles.
J
Date printed: May 5, 2002
Appendix No. CY-•150.02-01
BEFORE THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION FOR IOWA CITY, IOWA
IN RE: THE DISCIPLINARY
DISCHARGE OF LT.
CHRIS BUCKMAN
APPELLEE'S WITNESS LIST
APPELLANT
V.
CITY OF IOWA CITY, IOWA,
IOWA CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT, and
JOHN M. GRIER, FIRE CHIEF,
APPELLEES
COME NOW the City of Iowa City, Iowa, the Iowa City Fire Department and John M. Grier,
Fire Chief, Appellees in the above -referenced matter, and pursuant to the direction of the
Commission at their August 7, 2015 meeting, hereby specifies the Appellees' Witness List as
follows:
John Grier, Fire Chief. Chief Grier will testify as to his position as Fire Chief, the rationale
for having the fire department residency policy, before it was superseded by the more
generous City-wide policy, and his prior conversations with Mr. Buckman regarding his
residency, in which Mr. Buckman claimed to be living in Coralville. He will further testify
about the investigatory interview of Mr. Buckman, which took place on July 7, 2015, at
which Mr. Buckman eventually admitted that he did not feel he lived at the Coralville
address, after first claiming that he did. Chief Grier will testify that he made the decision to
terminate Mr. Buckman, based on both his failure to comply with the residency policy, and
his repeated dishonest statements about where he lived.
Karen Jennings Human Resources Administrator. Ms. Jennings will testify as to the
history of the residency policy for the fire department, and then the City more broadly,
authorized by the Civil Service Code, specifically Iowa Code section 400.17(3). She wit
further testify as to the contents of the job description of fire lieutenants, including the
residency requirement. She will also describe the Change of Address Form filed by Mr.
Buckman, indicating that he lived at 2233 9" St., Coralville, and the interview of Mr.
Buckman on July 7, 2015, at which he admitted that he did not feel he lived at the
Coralville address.
Jeff Marlin, Private Investigator. Mr. Marlin will testify that he was hired to investigate the
residency of two Iowa City firefighters, including Mr. Buckman. He did not track either
firefighter, but interviewed neighbors to ascertain whether either lived at 2233 91' St.,
Coralville, IA, the address at which both claimed to be living. His investigation found no
evidence that Mr. Buckman lived at that address.
Florence Cox, Coralville Utility Billinq Coordinator. Ms. Cox will testify as to normal water
usage, and the water usage at 2233 9'h St., Coralville, Iowa, the address at which Mr.
Buckman initially claimed to be living. Normal usage is 50-75 cubic feet per person, per
week, or about 200-300 cubic feet per person per month. Usage at Mr. Buckman's
claimed Coralville residence, in the last six months available before the July 7, 2015
interview, was 300 cubic feet total, for an average of 50 cubic feet per month, including
three consecutive months (January through March of 2015) of no usage at all.
• The Appellee reserves the right to call rebuttal witnesses to rebut any testimony put on by
the Appellant.
Respectfully submitted,
Eric R. Goers AT0002835
Assistant City Attorney
410 East Washington Street
Iowa City, IA 52240
icattomey@iowa-city.org
(319)356-5030
(319) 356-5008 Fax
ATTORNEY FOR APPELLEES
Original: Iowa City City Clerk
copy: Crystal L. Usher
Attorney for Appellant
BEFORE THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION FOR IOWA CITY, IOWA
IN RE: THE DISCIPLINARY )
DISCHARGE OF LT. )
CHRISTOPHER BUCKMAN, )
APPELLANT )
V., )
CITY OF IOWA CITY, IOWA )
IOWA CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT, and )
JOHN M. GRIER, FIRE CHIEF, )
CHRISTOPHER BUCKMAN'S
WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LIST
COMES NOW, Lieutenant Christopher Buckman and hereby notifies the commission that
he intends to call the following witnesses:
I. Christopher Buckman: He will testify as to his lease with Paul Suedkamp and
documents establishing his residence as 2233 V' Street, Coralville, Iowa 52241 and other facts
setting forth the amount of time spent at the residence at Coralville, Iowa.
2. Brandon Pflanzer, Union President: He will testify to the policies and the exceptions
made to the policy surrounding the residence of Fire Fighters at the Iowa City Fire Department; his
research regarding residency and what it takes to establish residency; the Fire Department's policies
regarding "call back" and the reasonableness and the rational basis for the residency requirement as
applied to the Iowa City Fire Fighters.
3. Paul Suedkamp: He will testify as to the lease agreement between he and
Christopher Buckman, activities he and Christopher Buckman did at the home located at 2233 9'
Street, Coralville, Iowa 52241; his period of lengthy absence from the home; Mr. Buckman's extra
jobs and the affect those jobs had on usage of the home during daytime hours; and necessary
repairs to the plumbing at his residence.
4. Kevin Bigger, Supervisor of Corridor Construction Service: He will testify about the
amount of time Mr. Buckman worked for his company when Mr. Buckman had days off from the
Fire Department.
5. Lance Carolan: He will testify as to Mr. Buckman grooming at the Fire Department
and Mr. Buckman leaving the Fire Department for his employment with Corridor Construction
Service.
6. Robert Henry: He will testify as to the exception he received to reside outside of the
residence limitations; the reasonableness of the residency requirement; the rational basis for the
residency requirement.
7. Alecia Buckman: She will testify to Christopher's residence; the time he spent at her
home; the time she spent at his home
U, XIIIBITS
Copy of envelope and check to Buckman Construction
2. Copy of envelope for Sprint
3. Copy of envelope for Capital One statement
4. Copy of envelope and check from the Treasurer of the State of Iowa
5. H & R Block 2014 State and Federal Income Tax Return
6, Room Rental Agreement between Christopher Buckman and Paul A. Suedkamp
7. Photographs of Christopher Buckman building deck at Paul's May 27 and
photographs of Paul's driveway while shoveling
8. Paul Suedkamp e-mail to John Grier dated October 19, 2014
9. State Code Provisions with regard to residency (400.17)
10. Emails between Brandon Pflanzer and Eric Goers
11, Various definitions of legal residence
12. Mr. Beckman's driver license and registrations
13. Mr. Buckman's voter card and concealed weapon's permit
14. The first page of Mr. Buckman's bank statements from December 2014 through Rlae
2015,
15, Envelopes from City of Iowa City
16. E-mails to and from Eric Goers from Brandon Pllanzer
Respectfully submitted.
Nazette, Marner,
Nathanson &Shea L.L.P.
615 2" `f Street SW
P.O. Box 74210
Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52407-4250
Phone: (319) 366-1000
Fax: (319) 364-1116
Crystalmsher a nazcttclaw com
G�
41stalL. Usher AT0008023
ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT
crarru� u5l rf: or ssuvlcr:
The undersigned certifies that the foregoing instnonent
was served upon all parties to the above cause to each
of the attorneys of record herein at their respective addresses
disclused oa the pleadings on August 13, 2015
BY: _. U.S. Mail _ FAX
—I land Delivered Overnight Cornier
Certified Mail XX Other: Email
Signature _