HomeMy WebLinkAbout1991-10-01 Bd Comm minutes
~~~) .
n I lOb
II
DRAFT
MINUTES
IOWA CITY HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION
SEPTEMBER 23, 1991
SENIOR CENTER CLASSROOM
MEM9ERS PRESENT:
Roy Holnos. Chlo.Halng Lu, Fred Mimi, Jalon Chon, Haywood
Bolio, Alllon Amu.Golllld, ROllo Slorr
MEMBERS ABSENT:
STAFF PRESENT:
Terry Pow all, Dorothy Paul
Alice Harrll, AMO Burnsldo
RECOMMENDATIONS TO CITY COUNCIL:
None,
REOUEST TO CITY MANAGER FOR INFORMATION OR STAFF ASSISTANCE:
Nono.
LIST OF MATTERS PENDINO COM~ISSIOf;J/COUNCIL QlSCUSSIQti:
None.
RECpONlIlPN Of ~pLlC AND NEWS MEOlA:
None.
&1HJ1MARV OF DIS~U~SION AND FORMAL ACTIONS TAKE~:
A VOIO wOllokan 10 OPPfOVO posting of notlco In tho AlborhllkV VI, Groan ClIO. There wu
o unonlmouI daclalon 10 opPfova notlco,
CALL IP OBDEB:
Tho mooting wu callod 10 order bV Chalrporlon RoV Halnol, Tho nO~1 Commission moollng
I. .chodulad fOl OClober 28, 1991. at 7:00 p.m, In Iho Sonlor Conler Clouroom, Motion wal
modo bV Ballo to approvo mlnulOl of AuguSl 28, 1991. Chon IOcondod, Motion corrlod.
CASES fE~pINI1:
Horrl. reportad thoro ore Ion omplovmont CUOI, and Iwo publiC accommodation CII.. under
Involtlgollon.
Team A roport . no roporl, Toam B . no roporl, Team C . HalnOl roportod conclllollon ollorto
ero underway on COIO EID 703.9004.
1~70
n I I 0 '-1
,\
I
Humon Rlghll Commllslon
SOPlOmber 23, 199\
Pogo 2
REPORTS OF COM~SSIONEBS:
Ccmmllalono, Lu roporlod thol ho will be lpeoklng .1 tho upcoming moo ling 01 tho UnlverallY
'Soclol CommItmonlond Sutvlvol SkllIl fOltho 1990'.'. Novomber 15.17. Commlulonor
Chon WII oliO 10 be on lho p.nel bul ho hod ptlor commltm.nll, Commllsloner Mimi will
oliO plrtlelpal.1n thll ptoglom,
NEW BUSINES~:
Horrll OMOUI\Cod oword. brookfolllllchodulad fOl OClobor 22, Only Iwo nomlnollonl woro
lubmlllOd. Horrl.11 going to glvo 0 ptmnlOllon 01 City High 019:00 on S,plomber 27, Sho
II ollondlng on ADA Conleronco on SOPlombor 19 In Codor Ropldl, Sha oMounc.d Iho
Roglonol bocullvOl Council on Civil Rlghllll holding 0 ..mlnar on Iho ADA on Novomber 13,
141n KonlOS Clly, MiIlOUlI, Sho oliO oMouncod 0 houllng lorum 10 bo hold In 001 MoInOl
on OClobGr 10,
AmOl,OolllOd modo 0 POllOI fOllho brOOklOII, Sho 0110 Illpoerhoadlng on opon fOlum 10
be hold .tlho Ubrory on AIDS oduclllon,
QLD BUSINES~:
H.lnol movod thai 0 VOIO be Ilkon 10 opprovo Iho notlco 10 bo pOlled In Iha public oil/co In
Iho AlblLhllkv v. Greon houllng dllcrlmlnollon complolnl, Tho Commlsslonero unonlmously
VOlod 10 OPptOVOlho nollco wllh Iho chango ollho word. 'Bon.Alro Mobilo Homo Lodgo' 10
'Bon'Alro Mobllo Homo COUll'.
PUBLIC DISCUSStQH:
Nono.
Tho mooting WII odlournod,
\IIlcOo2J.mlft
/67~
--~
---~ ......
n I I [I EI
~~\
,\
I
HINUTES
PARKS , RECREATION COKHISSION
SEPTEHDER 4, 1991
HEHDERS PRESENT. Bl11 Drandt, Daryl IIonry, Karan IIradak, Dill
Stoinbrach, Dao Vandorhoot, John Watoon, Hary
Woldalan, Todd Wolk
HEltDERS ABSENT. Craiq Willill
STAFF PRESENT. IIowoll, ROblnoon, Truoblood
GUESTS. Darrol Courtnoy, Naoli Novick
FORMAL ACTION Hovad bY Stlllnbrllch. lIacendad by Brandt. t~
TAKEth DDnrOVft tho minuteR ot tho July 10. 199
santino 8ft written, Unnnl!loUfI.
COMMISSION TIHE. IIonry Itatod ho raco1vod a call trol on
individual who rOllidaa ctt ot Halrola Avonua 1
noar Drookland Park, 110 Ita tad tha drlvoway I
Into tho park wall an aya loro, IIowoll I
,
axplalnod that It wall nocollllary, In ordor to I
I
qot lalntonanco oquiplont Into and out ot tho
park, Truoblood Itatod tho COlllll1ion could I
drlvo bl thla araa on tho tour ot Parka and
Rocroat on tacllltloll, i
i
110 aloo Indlcatod ho thouqht tho ahowora In
tho lon'a lockor roau woro to bo raplllcod
durlnq tho racont two wook alllntonanco/ahut
down, Truoblood atlltod IItlltt raquoltod a
carryovor trol tho FY9l bUdyot tor thia
purpooo and could not procood w th tho ahowor
roplacolont until tho budqot carryovor waD
opprovod, 110 notod Dtatt rocolvod
notlt1cation only rocontly ot Itl approval,
and tho ahoworl would bo roplacod 01 loon al
POllliblo,
CHAIRMAN'S REPORT. NatIon roportod on tho tollowlnq.
Iowa City BeYlI DlIlIaball ADlIoolllt~. Dllrrol
Courtnoy, Truoblood and ho lot wlth board
lolboro ot tho Iowa Clty BOYI Baloball
AOloolation ro concornl oxproolod by Jll
I Kindhart and Booky IIonlol at tho COlllaolon'1
I JUlr 1Il00ting. Tho board 1Il0lllborl indioatod
, , tho r willlnqn088 to opon up and tormallzo tha
board proco08. Thoy allo Indlcatad thoy would
allow gir18 to partloipato it thoy protorrod
boooball, all oppollod to tho Glrlll' Sottball
Progralll.
/(, 7/
n I I [I q
,I
I
Saniol' Ci~hon llillcoun~. A potition froll
.onior citizono roqardinq tho obo1ilhaont of
tho .onior citizon dilcount wao rocoivod.
Thil Ilattor will bo roviowod at tha OCtobor
aaatinq,
DIRECTOR'S REPORTI Truob100d roportod on tha followinql
50 state Society. Tho Nationo1 Rocroation and
Park AIsociation has introducad a proqrsll
ontit10d "50 Stato Sociaty." Thoy aro o.kinq
oach Itato to "dona to" ona acro of oxiltinq
parkland to thOll, which would thon bo 10alod
back to tho City in porpotuity for $1.00, 110
indicatod part of tha rationa10 WOI to
prooorvo parkland, but in reality it wal Iloro
of a fund railor. Tho national orqanization
will loll ownorlhip to one Iquaro inch of oach
parca1 in ovory Itata to intoroltod porlonl,
and tho Ilonoy will qo towardl vorioul offortl
that doa1 with porkl and rocroation (roloarch,
10qi81ation, etc.). lie olkod that tho
coulealon roviow tho ilOilO and infol'llation
.ont to thoa roqardinq this proqral, with
furthor diocu.o1on to tako. ploco at next
10nth'l lootinq,
ADJOURNMENT I
Movod bv stoinbrach. Beconded ~y WoldOI!" to
~, Unanimous. Tho Iloatinq adjourned at
5125 P,Il" and tho couiolion dopartod for itl
annual tour of various park faoi1itio.,
I
!
,
I
,
t.
-2-
/67/
~~~\
I
i
I
,
i
I
n I I .1 0
,I
I
KlmlS
IOWA OITY AIRPORT COKNISSION
TOISDlY , loaOST 20, 1"1 - 4100 '.K.
IOWA OITY TRANSIT rlOILITY
KIKDIRS PRISINTI Richord B1Ul, John Ockontoll, Pat FOltor
KIIIDIU USIH'l'I Robort Hickl
STllr PRISIH'l'I Anno Burnlido, Ron O'Noil
aOISTS PRISIH'l'I ail Jonol, Scott Lolnot
OlLL 'fO ORDIRI
Chalrponon BlulI callod tho 1I00tin9 to ordor at 41U p.lI. A quOrull
Val prOlont.
APPROVAL or MIHU!ISI
Tho ainutol of tho July 12, 1991, and July 16, 1991, lootingl woro
opprovod 01 prolontod,
lOTlORllATION or .IPINDI'ORISI
.
O'Noll prOlontod a Ult ot tlCponditurol tor tho lonth. FOltor lado
a lotion to approvo tho Ult, Oelkonf.ll locondod tho lotion and it
val approvod 3-0,
PUBLIO DISCUSSION - I'EMS Nor ON AalHDAI
No itOll1 voro prolontod,
ITEMS rOR DISCUSSION/ACtION I
a. Buq qUIt.r prlOoDtatloD - Scott Loonot, froll KUlcatln.,
prolontod information to tho COllllillion concornin9 hang qlidin9 in
Iova. A vid.o Val roviovod .xplaIning tov Un. han9 9Udin9,
LOInot roquOltod pormiol1on to lot up a Itatic dllplay at tho
Aviation Fair on Augult 25. 110 allo roquoltcd pormlll1on for a
flight dOlonltration at thl Aviation Fail', FOltor lovod to allov
the han9 qlidorl to tly, contingont upon tho alount of aircraft
tratfic on Augult 25. Ockontoll locondod the lotion, During
dilcullion of tho iOIUO, tho City Codo and COllllillion policy VOl
rovial/.d. Th.ro appoar.d to bo no l.gal barri.n to allowinq
qlidar flight, Tho 1I0tion palood 3-0,
b, AlP Projoct 3-1'-0047-02 - A r.quoot for paYllont val prolontod
by ail Janol. Approxilatoly ono third to ono half of tho patChing
hal boon cOlplotod at thll tlllo. Tho roquOlt froll SlWIonl
Conotruction il for $54,701.77 of tho total $341,203.70 controct.
Ockontoll lovod to apPrOVO tho roquolt tor paYllont. Footor
Ilconded the lotion ond it wal paoled 3-0.
167~
n I I .1 '1
,\
I
e. Bylaw rlvl.loD - 0'"011 .tatod that tho bylaw. .hou1d bo rovi.od
to allow tho appointDont ot a non-votin9 co..i..ion 10lbor, Thi.
chango would rot10ct tho chang. lad. to tho Coda ot Ordinanc...
Tho 10lbor would not r..id. within tho corporat. boundary ot tho
City ot Iowa City. FOltor lovod to oDond tho bylaw. to allow tor
an additional non-voting Co..illion IaDber, Ockonto11 oocond.d tho
lotion and tho Dotion paoood 3-0.
d, 81141 .bow prlooDtatloD - B1u. dotorrod tho pro.ontation until
atter tho 10lting. .
CBAIRMAK'I RltoRfl
D1um r.vi.w.d tho p1anl tor the Aviotion Foir on Auqult 25, 1991.
AU .pacI in the .xhlbit t.nt hu boon r..orvod, B1uI and
OCkent.1. will be r.opon.lb1. tor all air-.id. trattie, OCk.nt.1.
vi11 lona9' 9round control on Unicol. Th. civil Air Patrol vl11
a..ilt OCk.nto1. vith aircratt tratUe control. Oth.r d.ta11. vorl
diaCUllod,
COIOfIBBlON M!HUIlI'8 I'I'!H81
No Ito.. v.r. di.cu...d,
lDMII18!lA'I'IVI RIPORfl
OINo11 reDl'nd.d tho co..i..ion that the lito .oloetion .ubco..ittoo
and tho ICFS 1.... .ubco..ittoo vould n..d to l'Ot In tho n.ar
tutur. to vork on th.ir projoct.. Ockonto11 and Dlul are on tho
.it. .ol.etion lubco..ittoo ond FOlt.r and Hick. are on tho l.a..
,ubcouitto..
Sov.ra1 1.ouo. .hould be r.vlovod vith tho city Counol1. Alon9
tho.. are tho Airport Hana90rl. job do.oription, diacu,lion ot
part-ti.. airport o.ployoo" a l1ido ohov prel.ntation and tho lito
.ol.etion procol., o'N.il vill Ichodul. tiDO at a Council vork
.00.10n a. .oon al it i. avai1ab1..
IIICUfIVI 118810NI
OCkonto1. lad. a lotion to adjourn to .xocutivo 1010ion to dilCUl1
.tratoqy ot 1iti9ation, Footor locond.d tho lotion, D1u.
e1ar1tiod tor tho record tho ,,"ion VII caUod bocauoo ICFS
indicat.d that tho upcolin9 1.a.o tOl'llll vould be I.ttled only
through arbitration,
Tho couillion Dovod to ox.cutive ooolion on a 3-0 vot.,
Th. roqular 100tin9 val roconvonod at 6153.
81f Hilt MltrlNGI
Th. noxt r09ular lootln9 11 ochodulod tor Soptolbor 17, 1991, at
4100 p..,
II, 7;..
n I I .1 I~'
I'
ADJODlHMIN'rI
rOlter lovld to adjourn tho looting ot '109 P,I, Ockontoll
locondod tho lotion and tho looting val adjournod.
~.-~
1~7~1
~~\
I
I
I
j
.
r,:
n I I .1 ~I
MINUTES
IOWA CITY PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION
SEPTEMBER 19, 1991 .7:30 P,M,
CIVIC CENTER COUNCIL CHAMBERS
,I
!
MEMBERS PRESENT:
MEMBERS ABSENT:
STAFF PRESENT:
CALL TO ORDER:
AM Bovblorg, Sally Dlork., Dick Gibson, Nancy Rold, Tom SCOll
Cuoy Cook, POlO Cooper
Mlklo, Schoon, Frenklln, Chtlltlanlon, Naif
Cholrporlon SCOll callod Iho mooting 10 Older 01 7:43 p.m,
aECOMMENDATIO~S TO CITY COUNCI~:
Rocommond approval, by 05.0 vOlo,thol Socllon 38.11(01 of tho RM.12 Zono bo omondod
10 rood: ~, Tho following loblo of dlmonslonol roqulromonll sholl
bo appllcoblo 10 tho USOI of tho zono, bUI dool nol pormlllho croutlon of 0 non-conlormlng
10110 olloln hlghor donlll/as of dovolopmanl,
PUQlIC DISC~ION OF ANY 'TEM NOT ON THE AaE~lM:
Thero wo. nono,
CONSIDERATION QF Tl;jE MINUTES OF THE SEPTEMBER II. 1991. MEETINQ:
Dlorkl movod to opprovo tho mlnulOI of tho SOPlombor 5, 1991, mOIling 01 omandod ond
clrculolod. Bovb)org locondod, Tho mollon carrlod 5.0,
DEVELOeME~:
1, V.9 1 o~, Public discussIon 01 on oppllcotlon Iubmlllod by Marvin Horlwfg for tho
vocollon of Iho Iron logo rood IOCOIOd bOlwoon Hlghwoy 1 WOII ond CO/GUsol MOlorl,
Miklo roportod Ihol 0 IOllor hIS baon ,ocolvod from Iho oppllconl roqualllng wlthdrowol
of thIs requasl.
Public d1,culalon WOl oponad 01 7:45 p.m.
Thoro was nono,
Pub/Jo df.culllon WOI clolOd 01 7:48 p.m.
~:
1. Z.9101, Public dllcusslon 01 on application lubmlllod bV Iowa Clly Londscoplng 10
rozono LOI 22 of Bolloy ond Dock Addlllon 110m RS.8 to C/.1.
161'
.- "--T"""'" -
n I I -I LI
Planning & Zonlng Commllslon
SOPlombor19, 1991
Pogo 2
,\
I
Schoon ropOllod thai 11011 mall wllh tho oppllcanllo discuss Iho nood for londscop/ng
on tho ptoporly lhal 'I curronUy In uso ond whal condillonl mlghl be p1ocod on
rozonlng 01 LOI 22. Ho Indlcolod IholO rovlsod mil repOlI would bo ovollablo for Iho
Commission ollho OClobor 3, 1991, mooUng,
Dlllko movod 10 dofor Z'91D1 10 OClobor 3, 1991. Rold socondod, Tho moUon
corrlod 11.0,
2, Public dllcusslon of omondmonll 10 tho RM.12 zona .nd tha non-conlOlmlng 101
rogulollonl of tho Zoning Ordlnonc..
Miklo Indlcalod tholaloll now rocommondllh'llhe propolod omondmanlto chango
tho 101 wldlh roqulllmonl for duplexuln Iho RM.12 zono bo wlthdrown ond thai
Socllon 38.11/0' 01 Iho RM.12 Zono boomondod 10 road: Dlmen!lonel Reoulrement!:
The following lobla of dlmonslonal requlromonllshall bo appllcoblo 10 Iho UIOl ollho
zon., bUI dool nOI pormll tho crOlllon of 0 non-conformlng 101 10 olloln hlghor
danllllu of dovolopmonl, Ho lold WI chango WOI noodod 10 clorlfy Ihalanguog. of
tho ordlnanco, bUI would nOI chongo tho (ntonl.
Publlo dllculslon WOl cpon.d II 7:43 p,m,
Thall WOl nono,
Publlo dlscusalon WIO cloud 01 7:43 p,m.
Bovb/org movod Ihol Socllon 36.11(01 of Iho RM.12 Zono bo omondad 10 road:
~: Tho fOllowing loblo of dlmonalonallOqulromontlshaU bo
oppllcoblo 10 Iho UIOO of Iho zona, bUI dool nol pormll tho croollon of 0 non.
conformIng 10110 Iltoln hlghor dons/lIOI of dovalopmonl. Glblon socondad,
SCOll commondod 11011 for Iho rOlolullon Ollhlllssuo,
Tho mollon carrlod 11.0.
3, Public dIscussion of 0 Clty.lnlllolod omondmonl of Iho ZonIng Ordlnonco 10 ombllsh
o ConllOl Buslnoll SupporllCB.SI zona,
Mlklo oxplolnod thatlho proposod CB.S zono would ollow for olllco and commorclol
USOl wllh rosldonllal USOI pormlllod .bovo tho ground IIoor, Ho IndlCOlOd thol 0 floor
1101 lOtio lFARI of throo WOl proposad and thai an FAR oll/vo would bo pormlllod In
tho CB.S zona IIlho dovolopor Is owardad bonusol, Ha explolnod Plozo Coni II Ona
lion oxomplo of 0 building ochlovlno 0 IIoor orOl rollo 01 nOlrly flvo, Miklo IIOIOd Ihol
litho CB.S zono II proposod, thoro would bo lomo IIoxlbllllY rogordlng parking wllh
tho Clly rolOlnlng lomo conlrol ovortho locollon 01 porklng, Ho nOlod thallho vlobl/ilY
of tho public porklng oarogolln lho downlown oroo mUll bo consldorod ollhould Iha
posslbllllY of tho City cOnllrUCllng now parking gorogolln Iho downlown orOlln tho
fUluro, Mlklo Indlcolod Ihollho gonorol doslgn guldollnol allow for f10xlbllllY and Ihol
I~?J
n I I -I ~I
Planning & Zoning Commission
Soplombor 19, 1991
Plgo 3
bonus provlllonl would pormll I dovolopor 10 roach I floor Orol rallo up 10 flvo, Ho
laid thai bonum would bo glvon for tronlloroblo dovolopmonl rlghll, tho UIO of
masonry construcllon and Olhor public omonltlOl, Miklo Ihowod slid.. 10 tho
Commission 10 damonllrolo Iho olomonll of Iho dOllgn Guldollnol,
In rosponlo 10 0 quolllon from Dlo,kl, Miklo oxplalnod thai In order 10 oncourogo Iho
prOlOlVallon of hlllorlc ItruClurol, 0 proporty owner could 101llho OXCOII davolopmonl
rlghtl of 0 hlllorlc proporty 10 onolhor proporly owner In Iho OliO, Chrllllanlon
oxplalnod thai lomo communlllOl ollow Iho lrenlfor of dovolopmonl rlghllln nOl,by
arm whilo othor communlllOl only ollow for Iho lronller of dovolopmonl rlghll 10
largalod Oroll. Ho laid 11011 Is conlldorlng having Iho CB.5 zona bo bOlh Iho 10U'CO
01 tho dovolopmont rlghtl 01 wollII Iho lergolod oroe. Reid IIkod If tho CB.5 zona
01 propolod would oncoullgo Iho olderly 10 IIvo nooror 10 Iho downlown oroo, Miklo
,ospondod thallho erOl loulh of Court StrOll would bo mOil Itrlclly rosldonllal, bUI
would nOI bo Ipoclflcally dlllgnod for ony ono group of rOlldonll, Ho nOlod lhaltho
now roqulromonll for handlcoppod accosslblo opanmonll would apply 10 dovolopmonl
In thll oroo ond 1I/0I10d thai 2" of tho parking muSI ba dOllgnod for handlcappod
drlverl,
Pul:llc d1lculalon WII oponod 01 B:08 p,m.
~ Ilalod thai hll oxperlonco In tho oroo IhoWllhol unloss
I resldonllal UIO II buill Ipoclflcally for tho olderly, thon II will bo populatod by
Iludonll, HI oxprmod tho concorn Ihol 314 parkinG unlls por dwolllng unllll nOI on
odaquolo parking roqulromonl fo, thll oroo, Ho IndlcolOd Ihol ho would axpocllhal 011
dovolopmonllhal occurlln Ihll eroo would hovl dwolllng unIll abovo tho filii floor,
Ho laid lhaltho pallorn for Iho IOCOllon of olllco dovalopmonllllo locall outsldo 01
tho downlown oroo, Ho cllld Wall 001 Molnll 01 on oxomplo of thll pallern, Ho
Itrmod thai ho louthll trond In 10wI CIIY 10 would find lito bo unroollstlc 10 oxpOCI
olflcollO dovolop In Iho downlown 0100, Honohln exprOllod tho concern thai 0
morkol sludy WII nol conduclod 10 oxplore tho fOOllbllllY of tho proposal, Ho nOlod
Ihol on FobruOlY 4, 1988,IIall recommondod thOI 0 markollludy loka pia co bofore
ony chongol wore modi In Iho zoning of tho 0100, Honohon reponad Ihal ho hod lomo
,osoarch dono cn ronlal UIOI In Coder Ropldl which showod thll Ihll typo 01
dovolopmanl would roqulro ronll of .30.35 por YOOl porlquore fOOl, Ho nOlod thll
thll may nOI bo axoclly compareblo 10 Iowa Clly, bUlllIOllod thlllhll would bo
exponslvo renl. Honohon omphoslzod thallho Iyplcol rani In Iowa Clly II ono.thlrd of
whol his rosoOlch had Indica lad, Honohon IIOIOd Ihal ho would OXpoclthl1 Orol 10
davolop 01 0 rOlldontlol 0100 for Iludonll, Ho II/iliad Ihallludenll bring carl and
010 tho worll Group nOllO provldo parking for.
In rOlponsllo 0 qualllon from Olblon, Honohan Indlcolod Ihot ovon Ihl proposed rOlall
UIDI would croolo parking probloml. Ho laid ho would expecI 0 markollludy 10
provldo Inlormollon rogordlnG who would 10CIlO In Ihll 0100 and whOllYPol of ronll
thoy would bo willing to pay,
...........- -,...... -
1~73
n I I -I b
Planning & Zoning Commlulon
Soplombor 19, 1991
Pogo 4
I
I
WIllroda ~loronYmu!_ 3322 Museorlno Avonua, olkad why dovolopmonlln lhll lono
would bo limltod to 0 horghl of thtoo Ilorfol. Miklo relpondod lhallho proposod holghl
IImlll. 85 foal, nOllhllO Ilorlol, and IhOllho propOlod floor eroa rOllo II 3-S In
ComPOrflon 10 tho curronl FAR of 2. H/eronvmul laid Ihore Illho pOlllblllly that
olderly houllng would dovolop In thl. oreo and tho olderly would IIko 10 bo obovo tho
,oof IIno. Sho .trollOd Iholland costlln thll or.. require lhal building I bo more Ihon
IhtOl 'lorlOlln holghl, Sho .old 0 merkol 'Iudy II unnocOllory bocouso no ono will
dovolop land Ihollhoy COMOI morkOI, Hleronymul IOld Ihol Iho hoaro oboullha
poulblllllo. of oddlllonol parking bolng provldod In tho downlown alia, bul upllllOd
o concorn IholthOlo parking propolOll ore nOI YOlln ploco. SholndlcalOd Ihalllnco
1973 .ho hOlluggollod thallho only woy 10 oxpond Iho downlown 1110 tho 10Ulh,
Sho laid II Iho downlown I. nOI oxpondod, than olflcos will be fOlced 10 locola away
from Iho downlown alia, Sho IOld Iho prefero nOllO 100 0 101 01 rlltrlcllonl on
dovolopmonlln Ihll oroo and dooln'l undorllond Why tho holghllhould bo restrlclod,
Hloronymul Indlcotod Ihol Iho dOli nOI vlow thll 01 0 dOllrebla OliO for ollordobla
hOUllng, In IOlponlO to 0 quolllon Irom albson, HIOIonvmus Ilalod thai tho COil of
land In Iho eroo and tho nood Ihol fomlllol hava fOllpaco would prevonlll from bolno
doslreblo for IlIordablo housing,
albion olkod whol Iypo 01 dovolopmonl Hloronymus fooll II noodod In Ihls eraa
becoulO of Iho high vlluo of Iho land, Hleronvmul IIspondod thollho voluo of Iho
land will conllnul 10 IncllllO II more oportmonll ora builtin Ihll 0101, Sho IOld Ihot
Iho faolllOlldontlol davolopmonllhould OCCUl 10 Iho north of tho downlown eroo ond
Ihal 'OIldonllal dovolopmonl In tho oreo loulh of Iho downtown prevanll Iha
uponllon of Iho downlown,
Franklin uplolnod thai tho dock for tho Chouncoy Swan parking 10111 Ichodulod for
conltrucllon In tho Iprlng of 1992. Sho nOlOd lhol on Soplomber 30, 1991, tho Clly
Ccuncll will dllcUlllho downlown parking poliCY with tho public hoorlng 10 bl hold
on OClober 1, 1991, Sho ItrOllod Iholtho goal ollho CB.S lono II 10 havo I
pOdoltrlon Irlondly ItroollCOpO with oround 1I00r oCllvlly, albson IndlcolOd thai ho
would ovonluolly IIko 10 havo Inlormollon on 0 merkollludy 10 10011 relall ond olflca
UIOI Oil vloblo In Ihll aroo, Franklin nOlod IhOlln 1988. Ilollracommondad thai a
merkol.tudy ovoluolo Ihll eroo, Sho lold 01 Ihot limo Iholl was no IUPPOII from Iho
City Council 10 .1011 proeoodod with III planl bllOd on ulltlng knowlodgo. Sho laid
tho Council foltthol 0 morkollludy would nOI provldo any dollnlllvo onlworl,
albion laid Hleronymul ho. rollod doubll In hll mind rogordlng Iho oconomlcs 01
dovolopmonlln Ihll oroo. Holndlcotod thai 0 markollludy might provldo onlwars 10
.omo 01 Ihl. quolllonl. Franklin oxplolnod lhollho would nOI oxpacllhore 10 ba rapid
chang 01 In Iha or.. II Iho CB,S lono WOl odoplOd. In rOlponso 10 0 quesllon from
Dlerkl, Franklin Indlcatod thaI II II nOlloo 1010 10 IIquosl 0 morkollludy from Council.
Sha lold tholtho Commllslon noodllo olk II thoy con moko 0 doclllon bOlod on Iha
Informollon thalthoy olroody hovo and II tho dolay 01 0 morkollludy would bo worth
whllo, In rOlponlo to 0 quolllon 'rom albson, Franklin IIOIOd lhot If thoro II not
lulflclonl domond for olflco or 111011 UIO In tho oroo, Ihan Iho resldonl/al usal would
bo driving dovolopmonl, Sho laid thll could rasullln Iho ground floor of building I
1(,73
n I I .1 '-I
,\
PloMlng & Zonlng Commission
Soplomber 19, 1991
pago 5
baIng voconl, Sho Itrossod Ihol nOI noodfng 10 provldo parking lor rolofl or olfico USOl
will nol bo on Inconllvo thai would nagato 0 poor merkll, Sho suggOltod lhol grOllOl
IncontlvOl for commorclal davolopmonl mlghl bo noodod,
Dlarkl oxprollOd 0 concorn thai 3/4 parking Ipom par dwolllng unlit doll nOllound
lufflclonl for rol/donllol usosln lowo Clly, Franklin 11I00.od thallho Commllalon
noodl 10 conlldor Iho proxlmllY of thll oroo 10 tho downlown. She Slid Iho
Commllllon noodllo olk II parking II roolly nocOllory In tho downlown rosldonllol
OIeu, DIerks Indlcotod thai moybo Iddlllonol public parking should bo provldod boforo
davolopmonlll ollowod 10 occur with only 3/4 plrklng Ipom per unll. Fronklln IIOIOd
Ihal thoro II 0 quolllon of wholher or nOllho downlown .roe should provldo parking
for overyono In oil 01 Iho placOl wharo Ihoy mlghl wont parking, such 01 whoro Ihoy
work, whoro Ihoy shop, and whore thoy IIvo. Sho IIkod II Ihlsll tho chorocIOlINI
pooplo wanl for Iho downlown of lowo Clly, Sho IllOlIad Ihotll thoro WOl prlvololy
provldod parking In tho downlown aroo,lhon thoro would bo 1011 Inlonlo dovolopmanl
In Iho downlown, Sho Ilatod Ihollt'l pOlllblo Ihalthoro will bo 0 commllmonl by Iho
City 10 provldo parking In thll aroo or onother opllon would bo 10 10111 gal congOllod
10 10IVO 01 0 dlllncanllvo lor poopla bringing carllnlo tho downlown, In rolponlo 10
o qUOlllon from Scou, Chtlll/onlon IndlcolOd lholthoro II nOlo holghl rOltrlclJon In
tho CB.10 lono bUllhOlO 'I 0 floor 0100 rOllo IImll of lan, Miklo oxplolnod tNllho
CB.5 lono would ollow for 0 maximum holghl of 8lS 1101101, Glblon olkod whol
would bo tho rllk. 01 ollowlng rolldanllol dovolopmonl on Iho around f10cr In tho CB.5
lono. Frenklln relpondod thai rolldonllol dovolopmont on Iho ground floor would nOI
oncourogo offlco and IOlall USOI In Ihll 0100, Sho ItrOlSod Iholll'O Impononl 10
rolOlVo Ipaco for fUluro offlco and rololl dovolopmonl, Mlklo omphoalzod Ihot hovlng
rosldonllal dovolopmonlodloconl10 commerclol dovolopmont on Iho ground 1I00r may
not bo dOlllOblo,
Jaon GiI.oJn. 301 T.All SDftodm, nOlod thOltho Old Copllol parking romp II gonorolly
90% full and Iho Dubuquo SlIoOI 'amp II gonorolly 60.70% full, Sho ItrOllOd thai
wholhOl or nOllhoro II 0 parking problom In Iho downtown 0100, III. porcalvod 01
luch by many downtown cuSIOmO,.. Sho expressod 0 concern If parking boglnllo bo
percolvod 01 ovon 0 groalor problom Ihon I1II now, thon Iou pooplo will como 10 Iho
downlown 0100 10 Ihop, Sho nOlod thOlthl1 would do'ool tho InlOnl of tho proposal,
Scoulndlcalod Ihollllllmpllod In Iho Noer Soulh.Sldo Davolopmont Plan lhollho City
will ovonluolly provldo parking In Ihll oroo, Gilpin oxprouod tho concorn thOlIl Iho
parking roqulromontl 010 roducod boforo additional po/king II prov/dod, thll would
croalo mora of 0 problom In tho OIoa, In rOlponlO 10 0 qUOSllon from Rold, FlOnklln
Ilalod thai tho Chouncoy Swan and Rocroallon Building lOll would roduco lomo of tho
pOI king probloml, but sho ItroSlod thollho would forOlOo a now parking IOmp baing
conltruclod loulh 01 Burllnglon Strool, In rOlponso 100 quasI Ion from Scou, FlOnklln
1I0lOd thallho onllclpollon of tho 1011 01 par kino IPOCOI odjaconllo tho HolldoV Inn
ond Iho old IIblOry 101 did provldo on Inconllvo 10 tho construcllon 01 dockl on tho
Chouncoy Swon ond nocroollon Building 1011, SCClI oxprossod lho concern IhOlthoro
110 nood 10 lolvo long'lorm par kino probloml lor lho downtown eroo,
1~73
n I I .1 EI
PlIMlng " Zoning Commllllon
Soptomber 19, 1991
Pogo 8
Hloronymul IUossod thallho doll nOlllnd fGull wllh Iho proponJ, bUI would Ilko 10
havo II oxpondad, Sho Iuossod INtlho would prolor nOllo hlvo IImlll on Iho holghl
01 building I and fooll thai Iho propml doos nOI go far onough, Sho omphoalzod tNI
allowing rolldontlll dovolopmantlo occur on 011110011 would IImlllho oxponllon of Iho
downlown, HoncNn Indlcolod ho foolltNI parking litho mGjor Issuo In Ihll 0100.
Ho Iuollad INI ho would pro lor 10 NVO plOvlllonl mldo fOl plrklng boforo radlcll
ChongOI % mldo In Iho oroa, Ho aald tNI mlybo tho concopl of whll dovolopmonl
will occur In Ihll 0/0111 wrong, Ha laid II mlghl be plolorablo 10 conconuolo Iho
downtown oreo 10 0 Unlvorllly of lowo markll,
~hn 6ummGlhGrl. 20UdGLIGn SIIGOI, Illd ho fooll tNI opllonl fOl downlown
commorclalond rollll oxponalon Ihould nOI bo closod and tho ground 11001 0100 Ihould
bo /Olorvad for lhasa UI... Ho Iuouod lhol hlghor donllly roaldontlal dovolopmonl
will holp 10 IUPPOrllho IOlollond commorclll usos on tho glound lIoor, Halndlcolod
Ihll ho foolllhol pooplo who IIvo In tho downtown 0100 do nOI NVO lho nood for tho
dally uso of 0 cor. RummolhOlllold thollowo City II bocomlno 0 moro fmlblo allo
for lorga'lcalo dovolopmonlluch 0110.15 1I00r condomlnluml, Ho Itrollod IhGllho
high COSI of lond In tho downlown 0100 fOlcos davolopOlllo consUuCI /Oaldonllal usos
obovo tho oround floor,
LorlY Selllll11lGl, MMS CQnsulWlu, IlOlOd ho foolllhallloll noodllo rallo IllIIOhl1
fa, Ihll oroo of lowo Clly, Ho nOlod Iho/O II 0 pOlonllol for oxpanalvo olllco
davolopmonlln lowo Clly ond Ihaltho UIO of Inconllvol could oncourago thlllypo of
davolopmonl, Ho laid 11II plOforabla 10 provldo IlUdOnl housing In Iho oroo louth 01
tho downlown bocouso of Iho hlllorlcol Ilgnlflconco of Iho north lido,
Public d1lculalon wos clOlOd 01 9:21 p.m,
5coII clOllflod thollho prosonl zoning 10Ulh of Burllnglon 51roOlll CB.2 whlch roqulros
one parking Ipaco per dwolllng unll, Ho nOlod INltho porklno roqulromontl for
commOlclol USOI VOIles undortho pruonl zono dopondlng on tho use ond undortho
p,oposod CB.5 zono tho parking ,oqulromonll lor III commOlclal uses would be ZOlO,
Halndlcolod Ihal whon tho Councllaanlthllluuo 10 Iho Commlulon and 11011, Ihoro
was 0 fooling thai commorclal UIOS Ihould provldo parking whllo rOlldonllol UIOl
Ihould nOI bo roqulrod 10 provldo parking. FlOnklln oxplalnad Ihal origInally 11011 hod
rocommondad lhal thoro bo no parking roqullOmonll In Iho 0100 ond Iho Council
oxprOlsod tho concorn thai Ihoro bo lomo provlslon 01 parking for rolldanllol
davolopmonl. In IOlponlO 10 0 quoltlon from 5cOll, Franklin laid Iho roloxollon 01 Iho
parking roqul/Omonllllnlondod to lorvo 01 on Incontlvo 10 dovolopmonl, 5ho luollOd
Ihal1IIIImporlOnl10 conlldor urban do sign IssuOl and Iho Ikyllno of tho downlown
whon lOlling halghl ,oqulromonll, Glblon notod thai 0 numbor of 2.3 Ilory housIng
davolopmonll havo boon buill In Iho aro which runl again II tho OIgumonllhaltho/O
II a nood 10 havo higher holghlllmlll bocauso of tho high COil of land In thll OlOa,
Franklin IlrOllod thotlholO would bo 0 minimum holghl ollwo IlorlOlln lho proposed
Ca'5 zona. Glblon nOlod thai tho downlown orOl 1111I hallho pOlanllol for vOrllcol
dovolopmonl ond IhOl1f lho downlown II ollowod 10 oxpond horlzonlolly Ihll would
dlscourogo mora Inlonslvo downlown dovolopmanl,
/~71
nil ,I q
Planning & Zoning Commission
Saplomber \9, \99\
P,go 7
,I
,
Dlerka movod 10 dolor dllculllon 01 0 CI1Y4n1dalod Imondmonl 01 Iho Zoning
Ordlnanco 10 ollablllh I Conllal Sualnon Support (C8.5/,on. to October 3, 1991.
sovlllerg locondld. Th. modon carrl.d 5.0.
4. Publlo dllcusslon 01 0 roquosllubmlllod by Soulhgalo Dovolopmanl Company, Inc. 10
omond tho CommunllY Commorclal (CC.21 Zono 10 IlIow mlnl.warohouSOl II 0
plovlllonDl usa In thai zono.
Publlo dllculalon wal oplnod al 9:27 p.m.
Thoro WIS nono.
Publlo dllculI'on WII c1olOd al 9:27 p,m.
Rlld movld 10 roquOIlllall Olllalancolo /Oady Imlndmanlllo Ihl Zoning OrdlnancI
10 aUow mlnI.warahoul.. II I provisional UIO In Iho CC.2 zonl. Dlorkl locondod.
Dlerka Indlcalod lhal mlnl,wlrohoul.. II I usa Ihllll nol conalslonl wllh Iho CC.2
zono 10 aho IOOS no rOlSon 10 hlvo 11011 r..oarch Iho Issuo. SCali 1IIIOd lhal
roglldl... 01 Ilall'a ovonlual pOll lion, ho would ba unlikoly 10 VOla 10 allow mini.
Wlrohousos In Iho CC.2 zono boclusa hi laols II II 0 USI Ipproprlllo only In Iho
IndusII'l1 zonos. Gibson Ind Rold oxprmod Iholr Igroomonllhallho proposod usa Is
not applopllllo for tho CC.2 zono.
Tho modon fDllad on I O.S volO.
DIerks movad to dsny mlnl.walOhoulOI IS a provisional UIO In tho CC.2 zono. Rold
secondod. .
Dierks slllad thll consldorlng Iho OlhOl uSGS Ihll oro IlIowod In Iho CC.2 lono, sho
foolsthlt mlnl.worohousas would bo In InlPproprlllo usa.
Thl modon carrlod S.().
pTHER BUSINESS:
\.
Pllnnlng Ind Zoning Commission Inlormallon.
In ruponso 10 0 quosllon from SCali. Mlklo Indlcolod Ihallho Council danlod Iho
oxtonslon for Iho LSRD 01 Clpllal Vlow Apartmanls by I 5.2 VOIO.
Chrlslllnson Indica lad Ihlt ho would bo unoblo 10 Ollond Iho spacial work IOIslon on
SOPlombor 23. \99\, rogardlng Iho Ca.5 lona. Ho roportod Ihal ho waslnvolvod In
Iho dllfllng of Iho ca.s lono and will Iddrm quosllons 01 Iho no xl rogul.,
Commllllon moollng. Ho Indlcalod Ihal ho would prolor 10 hlvo dlrocllon Irom Iho
Commission boloro conllnulng work on tho Issuo 01 tranllollablo dovolopmont rlghls.
,
I
I
I
I
i
I
I
!
1~73
nil e CI
Planning & Zoning Commlulon
SoplombOll9,1991
Pogo 8
II
Raid nOlad lhaltho fodOlal manual/Ogardlng wOllands odd/OlIOsregulatlons regarding
placIng fI/I on wOII,nd. bul dOl. nOI .ddlOlI woll.nd. bolng dug. Sho .I"md lhal
this goos ,galnst Iho plosaN.llon 01 wOII,nds. Sho IIkod IIlho wotl,nds In thl
Whllporlng Moldows Subdivision Ire going to bo modo doopor. ChrllllDnlon
rospondod lhal tho wOllandslhat I/O In Whllporlng Moadows will bo modi lomowhat
daopor Ind that Iho Itudy conduclod by Lon Drlko concludod lhallhls wllllmplov,
this partlculer wall end. Scott nOlod IhlllomO would erguo Ihll meklng wOllendl
dooper Is 0 chango In tho wOllends ond Is not tho dasllucllon 01 tho wollands,
ADJOURNMENt;
Rold movod to Idjown tho moo ling It 9:S4 p.m. DIOIka locondod. Tho motion celllad S.().
Solly Dlorks, Sacrelery
M1nulII submltlod by Mary Jo Noll.
"'11.11
/(, ?J