HomeMy WebLinkAbout1992-03-17 Bd Comm minutes
\\)
/,'J)v
.J
. '
- -
. .
- -
MINUTES
BOARD OF EXAMINERS OF PLUMBERS
FEBRUARY 19, 1992
ROBERT A. LEE RECREATION CENTER
MEETING ROOM A
DRAFT
MEMBERS PRESENT: Mlko D,ockmon, F,onk Kllpotrlck, Jono Hogodorn, Rick
Bocholdo,
STAFF PRESENT: Bo,nlo Olvald, Gary Yodor
OTHERS PRESENT: Ginny Bioi" RUIlOI Boll, Jamol Mullo,
~
Tho mooting wos callod to o,dor by tho Chal,pOllon, Fronk Kilpatrick, 01 7:02 pm,
II wos movod by D,ockman, locondod by Haoodorn, to app,ovo tho mlnutol ollho
Octobor 2, 1991 mooting 81 lubmlllOd. Tho motion corrlod unonlmously.
Jamos Mullor broughl up lhat lomothlng mUlt bo dona to provontlho City 01 Iowa
City f,om doing plumbing work In Iowa City wltt,out IIrlt oblalnlng a plumbing pormlt
and without having a IIconlod plumbar, Tho Issuo WOI dllcussod ot lomo longth
whon Kilpatrick laid that ho would talk to tho City Council concornlng this mallor.
Kilpatrick notod sovo,alltomsln tho coda thot ho was concornod about and thoughl
noodod clo,IIIcatlon: Socllon 104 (I) CONTAMINATION, su,loco and g,oundwotor
,should bo addod to lho list 01 contamlnanls, Soctlon 603, plastic DWV should hovo
IImltl on horlzontallongth and Ihould bo IImltod 10 combustlblo conltructlon rathor
than to lho numbor of Ito,lolln tho building, Soctlon 1002, soltonod WOlor should
not bo usod 01 d,lnklng wotor. Soctlon 10031sl, connocllonlto co,bonoto, Irom Iho
bockllow dovlco should nOI bo coppor, Soctlonl 1307, 1309, 1310, 13171cl Flgu,o
11 ond Appondlx C a,o dupllcalod In Iho UMC ond uec ond Kllpotrlck thought Ihoy
could bo ollmlnotod 10 ovoid conlllctl ond dupllcotlon. Gory Yodor polntod out thot
pooplo In one trodo roroly hovo lho books ollho otho, trodolto UIO 01 cross ,olo,onco
and thus tho duplication II nocolso,y, Kllpotrlck wos olso concornod obout Iho
Instollollon 01 p,lvoto sopllc IYltomsln Iowa City In tho o'oos not so,vod by tho city
sowor systom, Espoclolly 01 concorn was tho possibility 01 on opo,tmont complox
bolng built with 0 p,lvoto sowo, systom. II was polntod outlhotlhls posslbllllY Is
,omoto bocouso tho Planning ond CommunllY Dovolopmont Doportmont plus tho
Johnson County Hoolth Doportmont would both bo Involvod,
1
D3~
,
I
I
I
\
,
I
I
i
J
i
\
,
,
t.
,.
i
~
t'
.
- -
pogo 2
Bornlo Olvold p,olonlod Inlormollon "om lha lowo Public Haollh Doportmont obout
p,opolod chongol In Iha lowo codo oulllnlng 0 ,oqul,ad p,ogrom 10' BockllOw
provontlon wllh conlolnmont bolng onoclad by January " 1996 ond Iha UPC
laqullomontllhot 0 cartlllod bockllow DIIombly tOltlng p,og,om bo 101 up by Jonuo'y
" 1993, Mullolllotod that tho City 01 Iowa CItY Ihould loko conuol 01 tho p,og,om,
10glltOl tho dovlcOl, to It all 01 tho dovlcOI at InltDllollon and tho yoo,ly ,oqulrod
tOltlng, Ho laid tho lIoblllly Illkl 101luch 0 plog,om would high. Ba,nlo Olvold
Ilotod thot would loqul,o ono or maro oddltlonol pO'lonl to odmlnlllor ond to It In
luch 8 prog,om ond tho city would p,obobly bo roluctont to hllo oddlllonol pOrlonnol
to to It dovlcOI, Mullor lold thot wo could uso tho mon I,om tho lowor plant thot
WOIO doing tho plumbing wolk bocousO thoy ovldontly didn't hovo much oliO 10 do,
Tho boo,d og,ood thot mo,o ,osoo,ch mUlt bo dono 10 wolk out tho dOIOll1 ollho
tOltlng plogrom bolo,o ono II lnltltutod.
Kllpoulck notod tho nOllt 110m on tho ogondo WOI dllculllon about 0 molnlononco
lovol plumbing IIconlo ond alkod whot thll lovol olllconlo would moon. Olvold
,olotod thot plumborl holding thll lovol olllconlo would bo ollowod to ropolr ond
roplaco plumbing nllturOS and WOlor hootOrl, A dllculllon b,ought up Iho p,oblom 01
unllconsod pooplo doing plumbing wo,k without pormlll 0' Inspoctlonl: tho probloms
01 lOgulotlno onotho' lovol 01 IIconso and tho addod wolk load to tho building
dopartmont which would ,Glull. A luggesllon Will modo by Mullor Ihat on add In Iho
popor bo lakon out by tha city to notlly tho public thot any plumbIng wo,k baIng dOIlG
In Iowa City mUlt bo do no by IIconsad pooplo and that po,mltl mUlt bo lokon out lor
ony romadoll. Ho rolalod that tho CIIY 01 Codor Ropldl runl luch 0 add In tho Coda'
Ropldl papor and IIluch on add woro In tho papor a couplo tlmol 0 month It would
probably moko 0 dllloronco. Kllpoulck modo 0 luggostlon that tho City ollowo City
hlro onolhor pOrion lor Building Inspoctlon Sorvlcos ond thOll1 bo lundod by 0 hlghor
100 Ichodulo lor pormlts, It WOl docldod that tho molnlonanco lovolllconlo bo lablad
lor now,
;
f
,
Tho nOlll 110m on lho agonda lor discussion wos IImlllng gOl pip 0 InSlallotlon to
IIconlod plumborl, II WOl docldod ollar soma discussion to conllnuo to ollow Iho
hoollng conuoclOrllO Inltoll gal piping, II was luggoslod that Olvold do 0 prossu,o
tost Inspocllon on tho gOI pIpIng In addlllon to Iho prOlSu,O tOil thallho gos company
do~s boloro maIo' Inltollotlon,
Bocholdor broughl up Iho locI thot tho dOllgnollon DWV should bo oddod lollowlng
ABS ond PVC In Iho mond IIno 01 Socllon 401101 ollho lowo CItY Amondmonlllo
tho Unllo,m Plumbing Coda. II WOI oorood Ihot It bo oddod bolo,o thO now
omondmontl 0'0 opp,ovod by Iho plumblno boo,d.
HoOodorn movod ond D,ockmon locondod 0 mOllon thot Dlock ond AlsoclolOI bo
opp,ovod 01 Iho 1011lno oooncy 10' lulU'O Journoymon ond MosIO' Plumbo'1101ll.
Tho motion wos possod unonlmously,
1
53'
, .
- .
- ,-
, -- I
- -
I
I
pogo 3
Hogodorn movod to ollmlnolo Iho P'OCllcol pOlllon ollho lournoyman plumbors oxom,
Bocholdor locondod Iho mallon, Tho mollon pOllod 3 10 1 wllh Drockmon vOllno
ooolnlt tho mOOluro,
~
Drockman movod for adlournmont and Iho mooting wos adjou,nod ot 9:06 p.m,
Mlnulos lubmlllod by Bo,nlo Olvold, Soc,olary, Boo,d 01 Exomlno'l 01 Plumbors,
Approvod by:
Chal,man Frank KllpDUlck
I
,
1
I
i
5~~
. .
.
\' -
- -
j, \1l.?~
~
l'
UBRARY BOARD MINUTES
BOARD MEETING OF FEBRUARY 27, 1992
, '
4:00 PM IN 2ND FLOOR ADMINISTRATIVE CONFERENCE ROOM
....',- ,.
BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Tom GollNn, Stophon O,oonlool, Anno Ho,g,ovo,
Jo,1 Hobort, Phil Hubbo,d, Gory Lundquist, Anno
Sponcor, Kont Swolm
BOARD MEMBERS ABSENT: Kothy Moyor.
STAFF PRESENT:
SUlon Crolg, Marmo Lubo,oll, Hol Ponlck, Co,ol
Spozlanl
,
,
I
I
OTHERS PRESENT:
MEETING WAS CALLED TO ORDER AT 4:07. PM
~:
A corrocdon In tho mlnulo, of tho rogulor moodng of Jonuory 23 1992 WDl modo.
'Tho mlnutos woro opprovod as corroctod, Moyor.lHobort.. This corrocdon wos
notod ond tho mlnutos woro opp,ovod as co,roclod, HobortlG,oonloof
~:
~.
Dllbursomonts for Jonuary woro rovlowod and opp,ovod, Hubba,d/Sponcor.
Visa Card Expondltu,os for January, 1992 wo'o rovlowod.
~:
.L Slntul otComDuto, ~
Crolg roporlod on tho bids rocolvod from CLSI ond Soquonl, Soquont wos
Ilgnlflcandy hlghor on tho sYltom and molntonanco Ihon CLSI, Crolg rolloratod
ho, rocommondotJon thot wo stoy with CLSllor lovo,al roasons: Ono company
10 sorvlco both ho,dwo,o and soltwa,o moans thOI p,obloms will bo add,ossod
olflclontly and quickly: loss stall limo roqul,od to Implomont It: good history
with this library, 'Tho syslom as II alands now Is ,unnlng at Ita maximum and
1
.
.
537
I .
- - ...-
, -
-
,
2
2.
oxponllon II nocOllory. Thll IYllom will ollow UI to g'ow ond to pion ohood
lor lovorol yoorl wo,th 01 g,owth. Tho 11011 hal glvon thll compulor upg,odo
tho high 011 p,lo,lty 01 any automaOon proloclS Ichodulod lor tho noxt two
yoo,l.
At tho Morch mooOng thll mollo' 01 bUllnol1 rt!JI"oppoo, on tho agonda fa,
ocOon. II app,ovod, InllOlloOon will loko placo In Moy. Boord mombor
Lundqullt ukad for and will bo glvon a copy 01 tho IpoclncoOonl on tho
propolod IYltom.
Crolg rovlawod tho Agandoltom thot ronoclod ou, ,ocord cl,culotlon In January
01 t 992,
3.
Sho Inlormod tha Board 01 tho ALA Conlo,anco bolng hold In Son F,onclsco
Juno 28 to July t. Somo IIb,ary Itoff will bo allondlng. Boa,d mombo'l 0'0
ancou,ogod 10 Ollond,
Although unabla to ollond Loglllotlvo Ooy, Crolg roportod on tho ItOIUI 01 tho
Regional Ubrary sy.tgm, Ona thl,d 01 tha monay lor Roglonal Ub,o,lol wos cut
ond tha balanco pUllnto tho budgot for tho Stato I1b,ary, Tho jUb'CllmmlllOG
movad tho budgot IIno bock to tho Roglonalllbro,lol, but only tho roducod
omounl. 1\11 not oxpaolod that tho Govarnor will approva thll mDDlU'O. In thll
rogard, coplol 01 poOOonlln lavor 01 Roglonalllbrary IYltom will bo lont 10 our
10callaglllato'l with a covor lallo, to bo wrlllon by Boa,d p,OIldont Swolm. A
moOon WOI moda ond approvod autho,lzlng Swolm to Convoy tha pOlltlon 01
tho ICPL Board In IUpPOrt 01 tho Roglonolllb,ary IYllom. Graonloal/Golman
Oobb G,oon, Chlld,on'l IIb,arlan, will pa,Oclpato In 0 'Young W'llo"a...
Wo,klhop' which will bo hold at Iowa City City High School thll coming
wookond. .
4.
6.
8.
Tho CO,Rom notwork In Iho raforonco 0'00 will bo up and running thll month,
An opon hOlllO will bo plonnod ot thot tlmo.
~:
Swaim OIkod Golmon to 'oport on hll followup to 0 phono call1rom 0 pOllan ,oga,dlng
whot wulolt to bo on obloctlonablo film Ihown on Ch. 20. Tho film II Iho only R
ratod tltlo on tho IIbrory'llIlt of tholo ovalloblo lor cablocaltlng, No R ,otod films will
bo shown on Chonnol 20 pondlng tho rogulor policy ,ovlow Ichodulod 10' Ap,lI.
Swolm ,opo,tod on tho IIOIUS ollho nogollollons wllh tho Johnlon Co. Boo,d 01
Suporvllors ro County'l sho,o olllb,ory'S budgot. Golmon w,oto 0 p,oposod controct
wllh Input I,om Swolm, Eggo,s ond C,alg ond rovlow by City Auornoy and Monogo,.
.
1
637
I
I
I
I
I
I
!
I
!
,
,
f
.,
~
.
--
-
-.
.' I
';.. -
3
Swolm thonkod Golmon lor hll 0110'11 In w,ltlng tho p,opolol. No doclllon WOI modo
ot tho Suporvllors Fobruory 26, 1992 moodng ollondod by Swolm, Golmon, Sponcor
ond Crolg olthough 0 luggesdon WOl modo bV Suporvllor Moyo'l 10 IUPPOrl 0 lassor
omounl for ono yoor only. Tho now propollll ollowlng lor phollng In 01 tho County'l
portion WOI sho,od with tho Suporvllorl. II WOI ,ocommondod by tho Boord thol
Pruldonl Swolm wrlto 0 lonor to tho Boo,d of Suporvlwl I\odng thot IIII tho ICPL
Boord'l pOlldon thol unlOll tho ConltOCI II ronogodolod, tho Boo,d oxpocu lull
compllonco with tho curronl conllocl. Tho Boo,d will nOllupport pordol poymont lor
FV93 unloult 'I 0 p,ovlllon of 0 now conllOCI which IdpulolOI full povmonl 01 0 1010r
dOlO. A copy of tho p,opolod conllOCI will bo Includod with tho 101l0r. Tho lonor will
olfor to provldo onv oddltlonallnformotlon noodod bV tho Suporvllo'l 10 onllblo thom
10 como 10 0 doclllon Coplol 01 tho lonor Ihould bo Ion I 10 City Manogor, Mavor ond
CIty Anornov. A modon wal modo and opp,ovod 10 dl,oCI Prolldonl Swolm 10 w,llo
thlllonor convoying 10 tho Suporvllora tho Boo,d'lldool and wllholln thll mollor;
tholr IlIong doslro 10 10ttlO tho mOllor In on oqulloblo falhlon ond tholr Itond In
IUPPOrt 01 thll p,opolOl. GroonlooflHo,grovo.
Tho Boo,d docldod tholol thll tlmo no Ilgnl will bo plocod In tho IIb,ory rooo,dlno thll
dllooroomonl. Howllvor, publlo lorvlco 01011 will bo dlroclod 10 rolor quoldonl or
concornl from tho publlo 10 tholr propor county ,0prolontotlvol. Slolf WOl dlroctod
10 updolo tho quoltlon ond onlwor IhoOI. Furthor olforu 10 Inlo,m Johnlon County
rurollibrarY ulora Including writing 0 101l0r, pOltlng Ilgnlond handing oUllnfo,motlon
.
In tho IIb,ary wo'o nOI rulod OUI. .
~:
~
,
,
Crolg roportod on bohall 01 Dobblo Solos Ihol10 dalo $2B,ooo of $43,000 of lho
IUllolnlng fund has boon rolsad. A 1010thon WOI hold Mondov night with Iwo mo,o
schodulod. ThoV rocondv rocolvod 0 plodgo for 0 bouldor on Iho Donor Rocognlllon
Troo. All tho loam havo boon fillod ond pions 0'0 undorwov for on oddltlonal b,onch,
Tho volunloor rocognltlon loa II Ichodulod lor Ap,1I 6. Suppor In tho Slockl, plonnod
for Sundov, Mo,ch 1, wosluccosllullV moo ling III goal oso momborlhlp d,lvo,
~:
A,
In Iho Inloroll 01 limo II WOI docldod 10 pOllpono this buslnass untJllho noxt
moodng,
8,
637
.
f I ' I ::-'
4
Tho Boa,d vOlod unanlmoualy In favor 01 kooplno tho IIb,ary opon ,ogular houri
on minor hollday.IVoloran'. Day, Day ollor thanksgiving, Martin Luthor King
Day, Prosldonl's Day), oponlng Sunday. In Soplombor, bog InnIng with tho
Sundoy ollor labor Day and bolng opon July 3, 1992 ICltY holiday lor
Indopondonco Day). G,oonloallHobart
....". . ...
~
Prior 10 adJournmont tho Boord WDI romlndod thot noxt month'. moo~ng will bo on
March 19, 1992. Moo~ng was odlournod. SponcorlHobart
Tho moo~ng waa adJournod at 6: 16 pm. GolmanlHoro,ovo
,
i Mortho Luborolf,
I
,
,.
I
I
...' .~
"'.""~'".,".,..,,, ," ,.-..'
~
I
,\
i
.
.
537
.
[,." ~.
V'"
,,'j1I....
. )
~~'~" I!~ "~:-R ~J\P
'.." , " ,L",/I'
~'~f~1 :.j,i:~,.,,1 uJ
......jllt.,.".",' ,,,
MINUTES
IOWA CITY HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
FEBRUARY I I, 1092.7:30 P.M.
MEZZANINE CONFERENCE ROOM. SENIOR CENTER
Joyco ll4nol~ Kovln Honlck. BOily Kolly, Suo Uchl. OOug RUISOD,
Jay S4mol
MEMBERS PRESENT:
j
l
,
I MEMBERS ABSENT:
i
I
i
! STAFF PRESENT:
I
I OTHERS PRESENT:
I ~:
:
ElollllOr SloGIG
"'kia, Non
M4ItyI Svondson
ChDltporson Ruslon C4IIGd 1110 mooUng 10 ordo, a17:35 p,m.
f
I
Hnnlck IllItGd lI1al ho Is on tho BoIIId 01 UnJtGd ActJon 10' Youlll whJch ownl 410 Iowa Avonuo.
Ho IlIld UnJtGd AcIfon lor Youlll II roqUOIUng COBG lundlln orcfo, to ocqu~o 422lowl Avenuo
lIIld would IIko 11I0 ondorsomont 01 tho Commlsslon 10' this proposnl. Hnnlck rovlowod a 10110'
110m Swaim 10 tho Commission lIIld ,oad a proposod Iollo, 01 ondorsomonllo tho CommlOoo on
CommunJly Noods. RussoD IlIld tho quostions 1110 Commission noods 10 uk Is II 11'1 approprlato
10 ondorso a 1pG(l1lo projoct lor COBG'luOOs lIIld ilia ~ IIIIs proloct nppr0pri4lo, Maklo 114IGd
thai part 01 tho goal 01 tho COBa program Is 10 oncou,ago historic p/osorvatJon and this could
be lpoclnod In tho 101l0r 01 aupport. Ho laid tho Commission could IUpulalo thai n11o,aUonl 10
iho linlctu,O would como unclor tho Commlsslon ,ovIow 0' 10Dow SocrollllY ollnlorlor guldonnos,
. Ho iopor1od lIIat F,londs 01 Hlslorlc Prosorvation Is maldng a propolallo match $5.000 01 coea
funds 10' houllng rohabllllatJon.
Bor,oll movod 10 oOOo/so tho 1000r 01 suppor1 10' tho Unltod Action lor Youlll coea proposnl and
10 aulllomo Russolllo algn tho 101l0,. Kolly socondod. Tho motion cantod 8'0.
(Hnnlck 101l817;~ p,m,)
I
I
i
I
!
~
I
i
f
Tho,o was nono. '
,
Kolly ukod thai Innguago bo addod 10 1110 discusalon 01 410 N, Lucas 51'001 10 nOlO lIIal grading
could holp rosolvo 1110 walo, problom In tho buomonl. Bor,oll asked lhal on pago 3 altor tho
discussion 01 tho Haddock propor1y, a hoadlng bo addod thai ,oads 'OTHER OISCUSSION FOR
REMAINING ITEMS,'
Kolly movod 10 app,ovo Iho mlnutos as amondod, Somolaocondod. Tho moRon cor,lod 5,0,
,
,
~~
i
I
I
I
!
i
!
.
,.
I
,
,
F
"
"
r
'i
[
t
,
"
.
!
,
,
- .
- -
1
. '
- -
Hlltorlc P'OlOrvOUon Commllalon
FobnJlIIY I I. 1002
Poo02
~ . t.Wo ,oporlad \hollundl 010 baing roquollad lor '001 'oplIlI, plIlnllng
and Intorlc' ,0novoUon, Ho I4kl numo,OUI DIIornllonl havo 1II,0lldy boon mlIdo 10 \hit ItructurO
10 01 mOil II would bo a contnbutlnO IlIueturo In a potontl4l Nollonlll ROOlsto, 01 Historic Olltrlcl
Ho laid \hol \holtructurO could ovonlulllly bo rOltOlad, KoDy luggOllad \hol I commonl bo mado
'oollldlng tho IIdIng \hol was Inal4llad In 1001.
,
Uchl movod lhAllho Com million o.prlll III concorn rogordlng 1M provloul work,
Including vlnyllldlng which WOI nolln oeeordonco with tho SocrolAry ollnlorlor llAndordl
ond rocommondl lhAl any rool ropalrs be dono In oceordoneo wllh Soerolary ollnlorlor
llAndardl and Iho conllguratlon 01 1M rool bo mlllnlAlnod. Somollocondad. Tho motion
canled 5.0.
Russon Ilotad 1IID1 P'OlOrvallon Wook will bo tho IOCOnd wook 01 May and molorlllll will bo lont
by tho Nollonol TrulL Ho Indc4lad IhlII thO Commlsalon trDdillonlll\y halll an ovonl during
Hlslorlc Prelorvollon Wook with 0W0Id. \0 ploporly owno'llor 'OItorollon In tho provloUI YOOl,
Ho IlIId \ho ovontls co.hollad with Frlond. 01 Hlltorlc PrOloMllon and Iasl YOOl JOhnlon County
H!m!!o PIO$orvollon Commlsllon Will 0110 Involvad In tho ovonL Tho Commission rovlowod pasl
Iocallons whoro tho eo,emony has boen hold IInd thoro Will I coolOnsullo rosorvo 11\0 JoIiiiion
County CourthoulO.
In 'OOOld 10 lpollkors, Somolluogollad coolldorlng lpollkors who mlghllltltacl an lIud1onco thlll
would nol othorwlso allond. Ho IlIId IOWI HumanlUol BoOld lund. DlO lomOUmOI avoJllllllo lor
, lpollkors. Ho IIIId thO,o \I I dllcroUOIIlIIY lund 10( up 10 $200 and omllll granll 010 ovallllblo lor
up to S1500, Kolly luggOllad asking SvondlOn 101 luggosUOnl 10' alpollko, and UchlllalOd
thallomoono mlghl bo avllll4b1o I,om tho ,oglonlll olneo 'rom tho NlIuonlll TrusL
BOIrollsullOostod Judy McClu,o and POllOY WltNorlh IIslu,ors, Russoll IUOgostod Prolosso, Willi
01 Q1lnnoll. thO Commission 11I50 d1scussod nomlnoo. IInd tho Ma,gll,ol Novlsch AWllrd. In
rosponso 10 a quosllon I,om Somol, Russollsllltad thllla guosl oditorllll will bo lubmlllod 10 tho
loclll madla. RuslOII sllld thlllln provloUl YOOlIII d1splllY was 101 up In tho publlo IibIlIIY. bul ho
lndlcatod \hili Old Cllpllot Mall mlghlllllow '0' mo,o oxposu,o lor a display, Somollllld tho
Commission noads 10 look al waytto holghton III plOfilO Ind sllld IhlII tho BoOld 01 Roaltors
nowslollo, could Includo a historic plOsorvllllon column. Russon IIIId tho Commission could makQ
boliO' uso 01 ClIblo TV. Svondson sUllOostod thai tho Commission could oxpand tho ,oclplonts
01 Awa,ds OilY Hllto,lc P'OIOMtlon Wook to Includo doslgnorl and conllaclors. Sho sUOgostod
tho,o could IIlso bo IIwa,ds 10' oducallon, communication, govornmontactlon and buildings that
hllvo boon consorvod ovo, IIn oxtondod porlod whllo ,otolnlng tho original uso,
Svondson dlst,lbutod coplos 01 tho plan. Sho ,ovlowod tho ,ovlslons thot hod boon modo to tho
ovorvlow which will bo oroonlzod ch,onoloolcally, Sho Indlcalod tho ,ovlslonslncludo oXpllnslon
01 discussion on tho northsldo Issuos and said addlUonnJ ,osonrch Is noodod 10' tho porlod
638
.
. . -
- -
1
. -.
-
Hlltorkl P'OlOrvOUon Commission
FoblUary \1, 1992
pogo 3
bolWOon January 011988 ond July 011088. Sho o.pl4lnod 11141 tho ovoluollon sadlon uso.
InlOllnoUOn I,om tho InI0MOWS, IUrvoyl ond plonnlng 10lSlon and II orgonlzod by thomo.
Svondson lold lho neodl Commlsllon Inpul In roollld 10 tho gooll and obloctlvOI whlch will
Includo llmoUnOllo, ,ocommondod octlons. Sho IOId 0 londmoIk OIl1nonco will bo high on 1110
..~ bul tho CommllSlon noods to ,ovIow 1110 opproprlolO ordo, 10' tho goal.lInd objOctJvOI. Sho
luggostod 11141 tho plOlorvoUon phllOlOphy could bo IncotpOrDlod In tho Nolghborhood SOrvlcol
OInco ond tho COBa plOO,om, Svondlon askod 11141 tho CommIlSlonOll moko tholr commonts
10 ho, within tho noxllow wooks. II WOI og,ood lIloltho,o would bo 0 apodal Commission
mooUng to d1lcul.tho plon on FoblUary 21, 1902.
Miklo notod \holll1o Fr10nds 01 HIsIOllo P,olorvollon plopGsalll bolng plopotod by Poula BrondL
RUlSon IOId ho would con14c1 B,andlto 101 ho, know thOI tho Commission con plovtdo 0 10110'
ollupport " on oppIle4l1on IIlubmllIod,
I.
n .
I
I
I
I
tdklo rovlowod 1110 plan 10' Rochollo, HilIl Condomlnlumlllnd polnlod oul1l1011l10 plon
ahoWIlM @~Iting hO!!JO loeatad 01 1110 odgo olaltrooL Moklo Indlclllod \holll tho cui,
dO'loo wo. rolocalod~ tho houso could bo lOVod ond IncotpOrDtod as I unit In 11I0
dovolopmonL Ho o.plaJnod \hol I now pllII1 hod boon ,ocolvod on IhlI dolo lIlollhows
ono unlllocalod litho silo 01 tho GXlstlng houlo. Ho l14tod thol tho PIonnIng & Zoning
Commission IIlnlo,ollod In whallogaJ outhority oxlllS 10 roqulro tho plolorvation 011110
structuro as I condition 01 tho rozonlng, Ho IOId tho quostion Is whothor rololnlng 1110
houso wID lulllQ a publlo nood tholII lnIt1olod by tho ,ozonlng, Miklo IlIlod lIlal Jon NOlh
has Indications "om tho SllIlo Hlltorlcol SocIoty lInd II oppoOtltho houso might bo 01
noUonolslgnll1conco. Ho ItroslOd thol moving thllstruclu,o wID doC/ouo Its hlsto,1cllI
Ilgnlncanco. Uchl omphulzod \hol willi 1hI. pO/\lculor Itruclu,o, tho allo Is C/IUcoI. Miklo
lndlcatod 11101 In tho pul, tho City hos ,oqulrod onvl,onmonlally sonsldvo 0'001, luch u
wotllll1ds, to bo dodlcalod 10 tho City. Svondson ,ololod 0 almllor slluollon thol occurrod
opp,oxlmololy olghl YOO/s ogo In oovonport \hol ,olullod In 0 historic struclu,o bolng
tronslo"od 10 tho City 01 oovonport. Somol suggoSlod having P,ofolSor Soy,o'l
commonts lorwordod 10 tho nowspupo"
,
,
I
i
I
,
2.
Tho,o WIIS 0 consonsus 10 continuo to moot on tho socond Tuosday 01 tho month. with
fuluro consldo,otlon 10 be glvon to mooting 0111110' In tho ovonlng,
3.~:
Mlklo ,oportod Ihol F,londs 01 Hlslo,lc ProsorvOUon will contrlbuto $32,000 10 movo tho
atruclUrO localod 01 tho corno, 01 Bowory and oodOo SlIoolS 10 a Clty.ownod ploporty.
538
,
Hlslone P,olOlVation Commission
FobllllUY II, 1992
PDQO 4
Ho olpllllnlld l/lllllho ClIy wlI11/l0n UIO CODa lunds 10 ,ohl!b tho Itructu,O and lOa 1110
1\ pltvlllo Indlvldultl,
4. p'osolVn~on lnw UodaIt,
Tho,o wo,o no commonls.
5. lldwlllnnnlllO ~Ion WOIV,oarnm.
Miklo oxpllllnod Ihlll this 110m Is 101 Counclllnlormltllon and IncludOI histone plosorvallon
mollo,..
8. .QlbW1mDl.
M1klo rolorrlld 10 1\ patition 110m rosldon\s In tho Coaago Gtoon PltIk 11I01\ ,oquosllng 1/10
OIll1b1lshmonl 011\ hlslOlIc dlslrlct In tholr nolghbofhood. Ho luggOll1ld thl\ll\ lo11or 10
thom would bo approprlltlo. RUlSoa 00'000 10 ,ospond 10 tho patillon and IlIId 1/10'0 II
1\ nood 10 IIllrt tho nolghbofl on rolOllrch and IUrvoy WOIk. Svondson Illllod lIlalln 19B5
tho,o WlIS 1\ plollmlllltlY appIIC4llon 10' tho Collago HID DlOO 101 tho Nollonlll Raglltor 01
Hlllone Plocos. Sha oorood 10 contacl Jim Jacobson 101 tholO molorlall.
Miklo ,olorrod \0 on artIclo I,om tho FobIuory 11, 1992, CodDl Rapids GlUollo ,agDlcfing
\ho NODI Sou\hsklo rodovolOpmiiil pWi, Hi itatOO lIlV iII1fcIG ~c: lllc H~tctIc
ProlOlVl\tion Commlsllon'l rocommond4tionllo, thla DlOO.
RUIIOa ropor\OCl thai Councllmombor Nooml Novick lISkod lor tho Hlslorkl ProsolVollon
Commlsllon mombo,.' opinions ragordlng tho P'OIS CItl10n bulldng, Mildo Iltld thol ho
bonOVOS this roquOIl1a In rosponso 10 a plopolltl \0 ,omovo tho bulking and conltruct 1\
houllng projOCI almIlDllo EcumonlcoJ TowoII. Uchllold It would bo proloroblo 10 IlIVO
tho onll,o building, bullllOlSod 1Il0 Impot\ltnCO 01 OIly oIlo,odons bolng mado In a CltIolul
and lonsltlvo mOllnor. BDlrOllluggoslod lomo typo 01 adaptivo rousa Is nolldod lor \his
building and IIlIs would Imply Ihlll tho,a will bo lomo 1011 olltruclu,1\1 0I10roUonS. MikIo
laid thalli CIl'( Iunds DlO roquoltad, thon tho,o mlghl bo lomo conllol ovor tho 0110'1\'
lions. Svondson loId It would bo boll II tho Qonnoll Corpo'Dllon 'Ololnlld ownorahlp ltIld
thon thoy could lllko advOlllllgo ollDlC Incontlvol mo,o 10 thlln 1\ now ownor would.
Russoll ltallld thai ho win rOlpond 10' tho Commission Ihlll tho building a/lould bo
p,osolVod with only IImllod oIlo,otions.
~:
Kolly movod 10 adjourn tho moollng 0110:10 p,m. Uchlsocondod, Tho motion C4,rlod 5,0.
Mlnulos lubmlttod by Mary Jo Noll,
"'."....
1
Sg
I)~I
!
~
,
~
.
I
:1
I
I
.
,
1
Drift
MINUTES
BROADBAND TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 19. 1992.5:15 PM
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
MEMBERS PRESENT:
MEMBERS ABSENT:
STAFF PRESENT:
OTHERS PRESENT:
TIOY Slovons. Paul ClSolla, Rooor Chllsuan
COldOIl Joppson, Tim Finor
ShAlIOI, Blau, Holllno, Burnsldo
Cosey Ash., Doug Allallo, aary Slland
BECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL
Non.,
~IST OF MATTERS PENDING COMMISSIONICOUNCll DISPOSITION
Tllonnlal rovlow Ind cabl. TV I.franchislng/llnawal nogollalions.
Ploposod liscal yUI 1993 BTS budgol.
SUMMA"Y OF DISCUS-Slot:!.
Doug Allalll IIportod Ihallho PA TV Board hn lormod a Commllloo 10 cOOldlnalo Iholllnpul
10lllfranchislng. Tho Ploposod vldoo wOlkshop policy 101 PATV hu boon IIvlsod 1001101
Ihe allornallvo 01 volunloll limo Inslud 01 0 '5 01 110 100 01 workshop partlclpanls. A
doposills also bolng consldolod 10 roduco no.showl. Cosey Asho ropollod Ih. Liblaly Is
wOlklng 10 o~pand pIoorammlng. AV Lab policy has boon changod 10 roduco no.shows, A
now lulo plohlblll 'R' lalod lilmlllom bolng shown In ICPL. GalY SIIand, IIPolllng 101 Iho
ECC, nOlod Kllkwood'l 0110111 with 1010coursOI. TolocouI" logllllalion II up and Iholl all
planllol malol uponslon In Iho nUl 11'10 10 Ihroo yurs. Anno Burnsldo loportod on Iho logal
qUllllonl now bololl hOl, Sho IIqulllod clorilicalion 01 whOI wn munl by ownorship In
Iho qUllllon OVII conllol ond docislon.moklng rogordino oducollonal OCCOll chonnol 27. A
now ECC conllOCI wn provldod ond Iho ISluo will bo purluod. Burnsldo olso roportod Ihol
Iho coblo TV consullanl'l RFP IlIponsos Oil public documonls ond Ihus moy bo made
avoilablo 10 anyono roqullling Ihom. In rogords 10 roquiling HllilOgo 10 rolmburso Encolo
subscliborslol poymonlS whllo tho 10Sl 01 subscribors woro sull gOlllng Encoro froo, Burnsldo
,0Pollod Ihollholo 1'101 no blloch 01 conllacl, mlloly 0 Windfall lor non.subSCllbors ond lhus
no logal rOCourso ovoilablo, Burnsldo roquollod CIOlllicollon Ollho agllomonls wilh Horilago
10 dOlormino Iho Inuo 01 poniblo addlllonol spm 101 PA TV. Shollll roportod 26 complalnll
from 17 pooplo. Ono complainllnvolvod tho shorllimo hamo pormlllod bololl lalo toos Oil
chorgod. ShallOt quostionod il HOIllago 1'1011 wilhln tho logalllmo homo. Burnsldo will
pursuo Ihi~ mOIlIl. Tho Cily will bo moving 0 la,go house which willlnvolvo InlOrrupting
sorvlco 10 12,000 pooplo 101 up 10 12 hours. A campaign by lho CllY 10 Inlorm cllizens 01
IIcycling policlos Is boing inllialod. Horllago hal ollorod SPOIS on Iho UlollilO channols tor
lhol campaign. In rog~rds 10 rohonchlSlng, 137 complolod quoslionnalroslrom lho Busko
workshops hovo boon sonl 10 BuskO and Iho lln.lloport IS expoclod In 2.01 wooks. A
lochnical quosuonnallo hom RiCO. Williams Anoclalos lor Horllago ond Shallor 1'1111 bo lonl
soon In plIPorouon lor a lechnlcal oudlllO bo conduclod In March. Shallor nOlod lhallho
Sonalo IIconlly pOlSod cablo TV ro"ogulauon loglslallon and tho HousO 1'1111 consldol lho Inuo
S3~
, ..
Blo.db.nd Tolocommurncll1ons CommissIon
'eblUlIY 19, 1992
PIgo 2
In March. Tho CilY will send commonls 10 Iho FCC IOQardino Iholl Ploposod ,ulo.m.kinQ
Involving lolophono company onllY InlO vidoo .nd cablo TV sllvicos.
~Ll TO ORDER
Tha moollno WIS cIII.d to OIdol .1 5:20 p.m.
~PP~OVAl OF THE BTC MINUTES
111'111 movod by ClSolIl ond socondod by Clulsllon, 10 IPPIOVO lha Jonu.'y 15, 1992, BTC
mlnull1, Unanlmouslv IPprovod.
5tiWJUBlIC ANNOU~CEMENTS
Nono,
a~NOUNCEMENT OF COMMISSIONERS
,
!
I Nono,
I fAN REPORt
Doug Alllir. lOPOlIOd Ihlllh. PAN Soald fo/miil i eilfflmillGO 10 cooldinala PATV', Input
Inlo Iho lOlllnchislno PICCOlI, Tho wOlkshop policV hos boon lovlsed, In oddilion 10 Iho
doll" chorgolOl wOlkshop pooplo will bo ollll.d Iho Illlln.llvo 10 volunloll ono houI 01 limo
100Iho PII,ploductlon Ind Quldolinol wOlkshop Ind 11'10 hOUllloI olch ploducllon workshop,
A .5 Ind .,0 ChllQO II In ollornalivo II pooplo choose nOllO volunloll. II nollhol II posslblo,
o"lnoomonll will be wOlkod oul wllh Iho PATV 11011. John HOII will pllplro I hondoullO
bo glvon pooplo whon Ih.y sign up 101 0 workshop OJCplolnlno Iho policies, Tho policV will bo
llviowod In six monlhs, Tho WOlklhops hovo hod 0 ploblom with no.shows. A doposills
baing consldllad 10 IImody lhil ploblom, BonlllOcordkooplng 01 workshop Inondonls olso
pl.nnod,
LjBRARY REpORt
I
I
j
,
I
\
t
.
f
Asho IIpollod Ihll ho II workino 10 exPlnd Llbllrv Chonnol 20'1 plogllmming. A,ho II
looking 10 o~pand odull pIoorammlng wllhoUI 0 dOlollorotlon 01 childlln'l programming, Ono
pOSSlbdllY Is Narrltivo TV, I "00 Ploorom on Iho NOllOIglo Channol, 0 '01011I10 chonnol nOI
carrlod bV Hllllago. Ellon Buch.non is consldlling wOlklng wilh Doanno WOllmon 10 dovolop
I urles 01 plograms 101 childlln. Sho II olso dovoloplng 0 now sllles wllh 0 working t1t10 IbA
~oleelel o(Jowe City. Toll Me YOUI SIOIY lonolhol 01 Buchanon', sarlosl hes Ihloo mOil
Plooroms plonnod, Thllo Is a ploblom with Iho comoll In Moollng Room A, bul by rouling
ludlo SOPOlOlolV II hos boon corroclod. Bocouse 01 no.shows In Iho AV Lob, wolk.ln limos will
bo upandod. POllons will bo IImilod 10 threo blocks 01 limo 19, 12 hoursllllhollhan 12 hours
pOI monlh and romindOl cords will bo mailod 01 hondod oul whon limo is schodulod. A
complaint was rocolvod oboul . film IhOl contains somo nudilY. An intu,hn rulo has boon
modo banning 'R' rOlod tilms bOlng shown In Iho lCPL.
1
63~
I
I
I
I
I
I
j
I
I
j
j
.
.
-
1
Blood bond TolocommurnCOllons Commllllon
FobtullY 19. 1992
Pogo 3
ECC REPORT
Gary Slland 10POlIOd on Klrkwood'l 1010COUllOl and commonlOd Ih41 lomO IludonlS hOvo
IUOgulod Kirkwood 14ko 4 luonoor 1010 In 101'14 CiIY, SU4nd SOld Kilkwood'l posillon 1.10
holp Iho ECC lUllhol Iho 101'10 Clly Communily School o.11I1C1'1 goal ond plovldo Ihom
o~porliso II nocomry. Tol.cOUIIU 110 c4b1.cUlln Iowa Cily bul all ovorrlddon when Iho
ECC has a Plooram. SIIond sold Ih.llhO ,olllnchlsino wOIklhops didn'lllllnlO Iholl Ichodulo
10 Ihoy could nOl411ond, bul Kirkwood has boon In ConllCI wilh JOIn Vln D.uson, Slovonl
Inquilod Illholo 1'1010 ploblom. wilh 1010COUI.OS whon 101'11 CilY ovorrldOl. SIIond Inpondod
lhal by schodullno 11'10 Op4SodIlIWO limn e doy livo dlY' I wook Ihoy havo OV"ComO mOil
Ich.dulino ploblom,. Thoro 010 ~O peoplo 10glSlOrod II coblo.only Iludonllln 101'11 City,
which II up 20% 110m 199 I Ind 175 roglstorod 101 Iho op.n loolnlno lob. SomolimOl
.ludonl. IIgislOllol on onoClmpul COUtSO lhen dlscovolilll on lOpe In lh. opon loolnlno lib
01 loorn II Is clb/oCOSI IS 1'1011 Ind "011 dOino 1111 homo 10lhol lhan Illondlng closs. Tholo
Is I molol o~ponsion In lol.coursos anllcipllod In Iho nUl 2.3 YOllt. Currontly lhoro 110 12
coursos. 25,30 are plonnod In IholulUIO. Tho '5,00010110.000 COSI POI Plooram I. one
ploblom. In 10Qllds 10 Klrkwood'llnpullnlO Iho 101llnchlSing PICCOlI, Shall" monuon.d
Ihollho Busko .ducollonol workshop WUlho lirll OPpOllunl\y 101 Kirkwood'llnpullnd lhal
Iho noods 1U000monllulvoy, which will prob.lbly bo complolld Ind diSlllbulod In lho 1111 01
'92, will plovido onothOI oPpollunily 10 gOlhOl Kllkwood'llnpul.
LEOAL REPORT
Anno Burnsido rlSpondod 10 0 momo oUll1nino Iho issuOl curr.ntly bololl Iho logol
CopOllmonl. In IIglldl 10 ownlllhlp 01 oduellionll Channol 27. Burnsido IIquulod Clorill,
cOli on ollho munlng 01 ownership. Shollor lospondod Ihol ownOlthlp should bo viowod In
10lms ollllnchise nogollollons and Iho 10dOlOlllw 01 pOlmlllino Cl\lts 10 IIqulre fronchlso
hold liS plovldo 10cililllS, oqulpmonlond ChOMOI IPOCO 101 Public, Educolion, Qovolnmonl
(PEQ'accm. ShollOl explainod IhOllho ECC WIS lo/mod 10 gOI odueolional chonnol 27 011
Iho glound ond lhallho oldlnonco loovu how lho channoll. OPIIOlod up 10 local OnlllilS.
SovolallulUlos aro inlorosllng in who docldOl how lho ChOMOlls run. Go,y Suond plovidod
I copy 01 on oporallons agllOmonlllgnod In March of 1990 bOlwoon Kirkwood ond Iho ECC.
Burnsldo will PUISUO Ihls qUUlIon. In rogord. 10 Iho propllOly SIOlu. 01 coblo TV consullonl
RFP rosponsos. Burnsldo repollod lhol Lindo Qonlly bollovOl Ihol on opinion had boon
plovldod Ind lhol, In monco, lho proposoll Ire public dccumon". Tho Cily moy copy Iho
proposals Ind cholQo Ihoso who dUllo copios. In logo,d. 10 IIqulllng HII11000 10 lIimburso
Encoro subscllbers 101 chalgu whllo 011 Olhll SUbSCllbols Slilllocolvod EnCOIO frIO, BUlnsldo
IIPOllod on opInion 1'1111 shortly bo lorthcomlng SIOllng IhOlO IS no 10gOl rocoulto os lhero wos
no brooch 01 COnlIOCl. moroly a wlndlolllor non'subSCllbors. SlOvons nOlod lhollho SOUICO
ollho siluOllon WOl 0 10Chnlcol problom. Th" II ovidonco 01 Herllogo's IOchnlc.1 obllillOllO
bo conslderod dUllno rehonchlslng. Shollol notod thltlho wholo Encore ondoovOI rolloclS on
HOIllogo's doclslon.moklng prOCOII. In ,ogoldslo ocquillng more t,cllily spoco 101 PATV.
Burnsldo 10qUOslOd clorllicollon 01 ogloomonlS Wllh Horilogo. Shollol SOld lhoro wore 11'10
ogreomonls of posslblo ImpOII - 0 19801 CilY/HolllogO og,oomonl ond HowkoYO'1 orlglnol
fronchlsa proposol. In rogords 10 P.ving Clly bills Ihlough InlOlICllvO coblo sorvlCOS. BurnSldo
Inquired Illho mOllOI hod boon dlscussod wllh lho bonks. Shollor said II hod boon discussod
wilh lho bonk 10plQlOnlallvos 101 lho Cl\Y WhO ",d l\ had nOl boon InllI.lOd boc.uso II wos
bollovod Ihallhoro would nOl bo onough volurno. BurnSldo SOld lho logo/ pllnClplos should bo
. lho samo os 10wa.lllinOIS Gos t. EloCIlIC'S oulomOllC poyrnonl systom and IhorolOlO II should
bo no problom.
53~
j
I
1
I
I
!
I
I
I
i
,
,
~
I
}
i
I
.
1
Blo.dbond TolocommurnClllons CommiSSIon
'Oblullv 19, 1992
P.go .
HERITAGE REPORl
No lOPOII.
BTS REPOIU
Shollol lOPOIled 2& complolnll 110m 17 Ptoplo: 11'10 oboul oUlagu, 10uI oboul spllllling
IIlu.lOUt oboullho Iou ollhe Ouod Cillo. ChOMOI., Iivo ObOUllolo loos. one IboUI billing
prlOlIO the SOMCO, one obOUllo/lure 10 COllY mOle ChOMOI. with .10100 ,ound, ono Ibouc
InlorlolOnco on ESPN, ono .boullho ICllmbllng IYSIOm mok1no lOP/no one channol.nd
wotching onolhol dillicull, one obOUllnobdllY 10 gOI SOIvlco. ono oboul movlno I subscllbo,'s
SOMCO. on. ObOUllho dOIOllOlaUon 01 0 slgnol, Ind 10uI eboul EncOlo. In losponso 10 .n
Inqulty bV SI'vons, Shallol gov. d.lalls rogllding Iho complain! aboullho InobililY 10001
sorvlco, A losllullnlln Iho Old CoP/loI ConlOl wlnlod sOIvlco. bUI Herilago said lhoy hod no
mOIl. Wh.n Ihe ConlOl 1'101 burlllhllO was no conduil plovidod 101 cablo. ShallolllpollOd
lhal 01101 ho conllclod Ih. phono compony, lowo.lllinol. aas & EloClllc. lho Old Capl101
ConlOI. ond B,ll Blough, ills boing wOlked OUI. Tho 10SlOulanl ond Iivo OlhOl buslnOIl"
should bo golllng IOrvico. ShallolllPOllod on onOlhOI complolnlllgOldino Iho billing limo
lromo. ACCOldino 10 0 plovlous lagol opinion Iho com pony moy bo pOlmlllod 0 10.dlY billing
pOllcd, In IhI. c..., Horlllge oppears 10 bo sonding Ih.i, bill so Ihal II alllvlS 10 Iho
SUblClibol on tho 27!h tnd 1M" IIIbKlibtl! have unlillh4 fifth 10 pay. Ilurnsldi will follOw
up on Ihls, Shollol lOPOIIOd lhal Ih. Cily plonl on moving 0 houso 01 somo hlllorlcol
slgnillc.nco 10 bo usod 10110w.lncom. houslno. In Iho piCCOlI 01 moving, 12,000 cablo
subscllbors will be wlthoullOMCO lOt up 10 12 hours. Bill.Blough has boon vOlY holplul on
lhil mOIlOl. Tho CilV will bo undOllaklno 0 compaign 10 lnlolm Iho public oboullICyclinO.
Blough h.. ollolld 10 plovldo IPOIS on Iho 111011110 chonnols.
CABLE TV ~EFRANCHISINa
Shollol lOPOIlId Ihol 137 quOSltonnolros 110m lho coblo TV lollonchlllng wOlkshops hod boon
lint 10 Suo Busko. AbouI 150 peoplo ollonded Iho workshops. Busko's llnollopOllll
o~poclod In 2.4 wook.. Tho lochnlcol oudil by Rico. Willlom. Assoclalos hu boon movod to
MOICh, A quO.lloMII,O 1'111I bo s.nllO HOIilogo and ShlllOl. Rico, Williams 10 collocUon .omo
Inlllol dOlO ond lalOl Joan Rico ond on .nginoll will olllvo 10 do IOSUno. Ploblom 0I0as alO
b"ng IIlOlIChod In plOPIIOUon 101 IhI. lochnlcolaudil. BocoulI 0 IIunk Iino will bo CUI whon
lho houlO 1'111I bo movod Ind Iho Inlogllty ollho slgnol Is no VII os good 0110111 hu been
spliced, Casolll ond Slovon.romolkod Iho oudil should CCCUI oltollho house hos boon moved.
ClvlsUon Inqulrod IIlho company had mOnlloned using hbol opllcs os 0 soluUon. Shollol said
Ollhough Blough hod monllonod Ihol I libOl bock bono would bo burll, no dOlO has boon
plovldod ond Iho company plobobly would nOI commlllO II unlillhoy wero SUI 0 Iho ',onchl.o
would bo IInowod. ShollOlloPOIlOd Ihol coblo TV lI.rogulollon logislollon 5,12 plSSod ond
HR.3560 1'1111 como 10 lho 11001 In oOlly MOlch. II possod, Iho 10glsloUon will hovo dillel
ImpoCI on 1I110nchlsing 01l01lS. Tho Cily hos a 10110110 go 10 lho FCC commenllno on Iho
Plopolod lulomaklng IIgaldlng IOlophono compony OnllY InlO plovldlno cobia TV sorvlCll.
Cuollo Inqulrod litho lochnlcol oudil Will dOlormino II Iowa Cily qualiflos 101 rolO 100ulollon
undOllho FCC's olloClivo compolilion rulos logoldlng lho numbOI 01 slgnols locoivod. JOIn
Rico ond lho onOlnoOl wllI,dolormlno II/owo CllV 10COIVOS Iho ollOllod numbor 01 slgnols.
537
,
i
1
j
I
!
BIOIdb,nd Tolocommurnc,uons CommllSlon
FObluolY 19. 1992
Pogo 5
,\
.
PUBLIC DISCUSSIOtj
Nono.
ADJOURN~ENI
II was movod by CosolI" IIcondod by Cluisllon, 10 odjourn. UnonlmOUlly oPplovod,
Adjoulnmonlll 6:20 p,m.
RospoClfully lubmlnod,
i
I
I
..
,I, '--/\ C I~"'"
I", ..... .. .
. I~' .' ,.'
William Drow Shollol
BIOldbond T"ocommunlcollons Spoclolill
...
'-"".11...
,
I
I
I
!
l
I
I
53~
.
. \I'J\
, A\~<.1
')
Kayor'l Youth z.ployaent proqraa
Kinutll
BOlrd ot Dirlotor'l Keetinq
January 22, 1"2
Doard Klablr. pre.ent. Dave Jacoby, Loren Forbel, Bob Lohnertz,
A.K. Traw, Jacque KcClun, Jean KcCarty, and carrie IIorton
statf Prllentl Peg HcElroy Fralor and Pam Klooao
I Call to ordlr. Dob Lohnortz callld the moetinq to ordor at 4108
( P.H.
~:
\
I
I
I
I
\
I. IDtroduotioDI and 'llcOle. Bob Lohnortz wolcomod all in
attondanco. Board IlIbora introducod thoJlllolvoa to now
board mOJllbor Davo Jacoby. Welcomo, Davel
n. Approval ot Hbut... Hinutol trom tho IIovolllbor 20th
mootinq wore approvod by conlonlUI.
III. Approvll ot rinlncill Roport. Financial roportl tor tho
lonthl ot Octobor - DacoJllbor 1991 woro approvod by
conlonlua.
XV.' Additional Aqenda Itea! , corrllPQD41ngl RIOlivldl
1. Donationl wore roco1vod by the Karnilki tully and
Goldon K Kiwanil. . Thank you lettera wore lont accordinqly.
2. Indopondont Living lont a card to HYEP .tatt thankinq
tho I tor thoir ottortl in preparing tho VISTA propolal.
3. pog roportod on an article which diacullod a national
lurvay that concludod that toona who wora amployod bocalo
1011 intoraatod in Ichool. It haa boon tho axparianco ot
HYEP that tho oppolito ia truo.
4. HYEP il tho rocipient ot a grant troJll the Iowa
communiti CUltural Attairl dopartJllont to ba uaod in
conjunct on with tho Iowa Conaervation Corpa Toon
Componant. Work will ba dona on the Youth Centar with an
educational emphalia on the aiJllilaritioa betwoon tho Youth
Canter and Hartin Luther King'a birthplace.
V. Now DUlinoal1
1. Tho peraonnel committee roported that it will bo tri-
chaired, Illoot ovory othor month, and will be daaigning a
handbook tor tuture comJllitteo JIlaJllbora. They will bogin
roviowing the exocutivo evaluation procodure 1n Harch.
2. The quarterly report waa paaDed out and will be
diacUlaed at the Fobruary meoting.
I
5~O
.
1
I
1
!
II
VI. Old DUliDe111
1. Proqral roportl v.r. r.colv.d by all 1n the loll. Th.
Ind.pondont Llv1nq proqra. ....ad to .xp.rl.nc.
dlttlcultt.. durinq a.cllblr. Att.r dllculllon vlth Linda,
poq foal. the probll.' ara cOlpoundad durlnq the holiday..
Jl4n HcCarty upr....d concarn ovar tha pOlllbUity ot
10.inq vork.ito. b.cau.. of thil. Dava Jocoby addad that
JTPA oxpariancad tha I4Ia I1tuationl vith cUont. that
conth.
2. Tha Youth s.rvic.I Foundation il dovolopinq Itratoqiol
to incr.uo itl board .h. and al.o d.liqninq upcolinq
fundrai.ar.. Activiti.. vill includa tvo Iprinq .ailinql
ond a dinnar to ba hald in Jun..
3. poq att.ndod a NASCC boord .aatlnq in aarly January.
Ilopofully in the nlllr tutura v. vUl b. apprll.d ot tha
fund1nq pOll1bUitlal availablo trol tha National and
COlllllunlty S.rv1c. Act. P.q 1I1'0t. concopt papan L'lqardinq
10va'l involv...nt and val alkad to rapraaant tha a.cond
raqion ot the country at tha national t.chnical alliatanca
.aotinq to bo h.ld in lat. January.
4. Bob Lehnortz praiaad the haarinq cOllitt.a for doinq
a qroat job and tor b.inq vory dadicat.d. Carrio Norton
.harod 1010 conc.rna vhlch voro .xproa.ad follovinq KYEP'I
prolOntat1on and board lalbon brainatol"lllod on vaya to
oddroal thai. It Val luqqaltad that in the tutura HYEP,
Youth 110..1, and Unitad Aotion tor Ycuth practica thdr
prllontat1ona tor th.ir boardl to recdvQ 1nitial f..dback.
Tho board a100 alCprell.d conc.rn that it lay not bo
aupportiv. .nouqh to the Itaft. Whon board recruit..nt
baqinl in the Iprinq, loalural.nt and atatiatica .xp.rt.
vill bo approachod r.qard1nq thoir int.raat 1n aaliatinq
vith lonq1tud1nal atudioa.
VII. A4jourDI Carrio Norton lov.d and A.K. Trav a.condod that
tho 100tinq bo adjourn.d. Hotion carri.d. HSC. Tho lo.tinq
val adjourn.d at 5115 P.H.
Tho noxt .o.t1nq vill bo hold Wodnoaday, Fobruary 26, 1992,
at 4100 P.H. at 410 Iova Avonu..
!
f
ROlpoctfully aubl1ttod,
...-...
'.J "
;, .1atll- CLI.~.K-
Pal Klooao
Adllnlatratlvo Coordlnator
Joan HcCnrty
socrotary/Tron.urar
A3HYHII92 ,JAIl
640
,~~~1
I
!
I
l
!
.
!
I
;
,
- - .
MINUTES
PLANNING' ZONING COMMISSION
MARCH 5, 1992 . 7:30 P.M.
CIVIC CENTER COUNCIL CHAMBERS
r.... ro, .
, 'ro' . '. ~'t " . '"
i' . . '"
n , ,
'I .
- ---
MEMBERS PRESENT:
AM Bovbltrg, Cmy Cook. Solly DIOIkl, Richard Gibson, Noncy
Rold. Tom ScOIl
MEMBERS ABSENT:
STAFF PRESENT:
POlO COOpol
MkJo. Mulch. Clvlllllnson. Noll
CALL TO ORDER:
Vleo Chalrporson Cook coll.d lho moollng 10 OIdll 01 7:38 p,m.
8ECOMMmDA TIONS TO CITY COUNCIL:
I, Rocommond opptovoI by. 8.0 vOlO 01 SUB92.0004. lho plollmlnolY plol 01 NOWPOlI
Woodl, 0 6.101. oPplO~lmllo 37.8 OCIO lubdivllion locolod nOIlh oliOi'll Clly, OOIt 01
Prohlo du Chlon Rood. olono lha Will lido 01 NowpOll Rood In NowPOlI Township.
2. Rocommondod opplovll by 0 4.2 vOlolGlbson Ind Dlorkl vOllno In lho nog'llve) 01 z.
9\10 ond S.9128,lho IIzonIng 012800 ROChall1l Avonuo Itom ID,RS 10 OPDH'5 ond
tho plolimlnoryLlIgo Scol, Rii1diiillillOtnlGpmOllt ond Pl4/lMd Development Hoo~
plinllor Rochallor Hilll,' 32.unIllOlidonll.1 dovolopmont on In oPPlo~lmolo 27 OCII
olio locOIOd on lha nOllh oIdo 01 RochIllor Avonuo USI 01 51, Thomos Courl, lubloCI
10 I condillonolllzonIno Igroomonl pllOI 10 Councilldlournlng lho publiC hoollng ond
pld condlllons II lottOi'll: Tho Commllllon find I lhot Iho loqulllno lha plOpolly
own" 10 plOSONO lha houso by lomov.1 to onolhor 0110 ond/Ol to lolroln 110m
domolltlon 01 tho houso 101 0110011 ono YOOI Itom Iho doto olllnol OPDH Ind LSRD
Ipplovol by Iho City Council II olOOIonoblo condillon 10 Impost on tho ownorln OIdor
10 lotlsly lha publiC nood 01 hlllOllc plOIlIyotlon dllOclly cousod by tho OWnol'l
ploposod IIzonIno, II II furlhOl condlllonod on Iho dovolopol IglOolno 10 01111 tho
Hoddock House 10 tho Clly ond contributlno 15,000 towordl lho movlno ond rolocollon
cOltl of lold houlo. FUlthor, lho mOllon 10 IppIOYO II lubjoct to: 111 I HistOllo
Amlllcon Bulldlnol SUNOY IHABSI documonlotlon 01 lho litO 10 be mUluolly ogrood to
by Jon Nosh Ind lho dovoloporsos 10 tho tlmo whon 1III to OCCUI, Iho pl.n Idonlllylno
Iho mlluro holdwoodl nOllh ond nOllhwolt 01 lho house, ond tho nolO on lho pion
should lIod plolocllon 1'1111 be Ilqu1l1d during construcllon, Clly FOIOSIII ond Iho
Ptonnlno ond Communlly Dov.lopmonl DIIOCIOI oPPlovol 01 mOlhodl 01 prosoN.lIon
01 doslroblo mOIUII 1110S Idontlllod 101 pllSOlYallon on tho pion ond IImovol 01 ony
tr~os on tho SilO, lito diSlonco It Lorch Lono Ind RochoslOl Avonuo bolng IOsolvod
with tho Publio Works DeportmOnl, grading pOIml1 bolng Issuod prlol 10 Councllllnal
consldllollon, 100.yoOl f1oodploln bolng covorod by 0 consoNollon OOIomonl,
provlllon 101 0 ton.lool oosomonl ond olghHool wolkwoy bolno provldod wlthln lho
consOlvotlon oosomonl ond lold walkwoy 10 bo Inslollod Ind conllluclOd 01101 Iho
IdonUllcoUon ollho wollonds ond opprovol by Iho City ond Iho malorlollol construc.
lion should bo oilhol grovol or IImoslono SCloonlngs, thollho 101'101 oosomonl bo
1
5~1
,
1
PloMlng & ZonIno Commission
Milch 5. 1992
Plge 2
i
I
i
I
,
I
!
I
i
l
I
i
t
1
{
~
,
i.
!
~
f
r
Ulablished prlOl to Council conJ/d,"l1on ollhl "Ill' OPOH Ind LsnD pion. lhal on
addillonol wllkway "om IN aldowolk lhal onds OliN WOSI hall ollho culodo'SlC be
provld.d 101 and Ilod Inlo IN walkwoy proposed In lha consolVollon OOIomont ond
Slid wolkwoy be Inslallod no 10101 lhon eno yeal 01101 Ilsuanc. ollho buildinG polmll
101 Iho lilt dwolling unll ond lhot 1M Fill Mlrwl's opprovol 101 numbers ond
locOllonl 011111 hydllnll be IOcurod. Cook "condod.
3. Rocommond opplovol by a 6.0 vOIO olon omondmonl to 1M Zoning Ordlnonco, Soct!on
36.151c1l4110 pormll I....d pa/klng by 10llglOUllnslllUllonslocotod In RM.145 Ot PRM
zenos,
fjJBLlC DISCUSSION OF ANY ITEM tlOT ON THE AGENDA:
Th"o 1'111 nono.
CPNSIDER OF THE MINUTES OF THE FEB6UARY 20. 1992.,WETING:
Rold movod 10 opprovo tho mlnulos ollha F.b/uoIY 20, 1992, moollno. Oovblorg IOcondod.
Tho moUon carried 5.0,
f
DEVELOPMENT ITEM~:
2, SUB 92.0003, Public dlscusslon 01 on oppllcaUon submlltOd by Will Sido Company
1000PPlovol 010 plllimlnory ond Iinol pilI 101 Iho IIsubdivislon 01 WOIl Sldo Pllk, LOI.
25.32, I 64.lot, lIaldontlll subdivision, localod 0111 01 Wllllldo Drlvo and nOllh 01
EOII Rood, (45.doy IImlloUon porlod: Milch 15. 1992,1
Miklo Indlcotod thlt now pI.ns had boon dlsllibulod 10 lha Commllllon prlOl to tho
moollng. Ho nOlod lhal lh11 II 0 IIsubdlvl.,on 01 on 0100 OIlglnally doslgnod 101
commelclol dovolopmonl and becouso ollhl., Iho .ubdivislon design Incluclos long
101'1' of lol/Iy norrow 1011, Ho Indlcolod Ihot 110111. coneOlnod lhat IN doslgn 1'1111
losullln a greal amount 01 poving 101 drlvowlYs ond I long lun 01 curb CUi'. Ho Slid
IhI. wos 01 plrtlculol conelln 101 lho 01011 ollho lubdivislon IhAt hovo onouoh lot
Ilea to occommodolo 11'10 dwolllno units pol lot, Ha lold thai 10 oddrtllthll coneorn,
lho dovolopOl hos ogreod to llipulolo lhot only ono dwolllno unll 1'111I be bullIon each
lot, Miklo explolnod lhlt thll would doclllSO Iho omounl 01 pavlno lOt drlvowoy, In
Iho subdivision, Miklo IIOlOd lhal 11011 oskod tho dovolopol 10 consldor on ommont
II Iho 1101 ollho 1011 to 01101'1 vohiculol OCCOlS In 0 m.MllllmUor to on olloy, Miklo
sold tho oppllconl ploloro not to hovo OCCOlO 10 Iho reol 01 tho 10111lvough an olloy
os wos .uggostod by sloll. Ho Indlcalod Ihol tho Public WOlks Dopartmont hAI
IIvlowod Iho .tormwolOl bosln ond hoslndlcolod Ihat Ills odoqualo 10 hondlo oil ollho
IlolmwalOlllom Ihl. lubdlvision and Iho lurroundlno mulll.lomlly dovolopmonl, Ho
IIportod thollho appllconl hos ogreod thai no building pormlt. should bo Issuod 101
LOll 19064 unlll aocondary oCCOIa hos boon provldod 101 Ihll dovolopmonl, Miklo
slalod Ihol dollcloncios ond discroponclos 10 and" 4, which portaln 10 Iho lobellno
01 0 dlolnogo oosomonl, havo nOI yOI boon losolvod and Ihat opproval ollho pl.11
should bo subloCllO tho corrOCllon ollhoso Iloml, Ho roportod Ihol a grading ond
j
I
\
541
.
-
-
1
Pllnnlng & Zon/no CommISSIon
MIlch 5, 1992
PIgo 3
"o'/on conr,eI pI.n had boon .ubmlllod, bul had nol VOl boon lIv1owod bV lho Pub/Ic
WOIkl Doparlmonl. Srlll locommondod IPp/ov.' 01 SUB 92,0003, lub/oCI ro Ih.
lI,oIutlon ollho dol/c/onellS Ind discIOpanelOl II dOlcllbod Ind IPP/OVII ollho
glldino Ind Oloslon conllol pion. Ind conJlructlon dllW1nol PIlOt 10 COINlCiJ
conS/d"Otlon, Mlklo rolollld 10 I mOmOllndum 110m tho Clly FOIISI" thor glvOl
IUOgOlllon. 101 mltlgltlng Inv damlgo thot ha. OCCutlld 10 11001 on lho Wosl.rn
botNlclOlV 01 WOIt Sid. Pllk. In lOlponso ro I quostlon 110m Bovb/org, Mlklo Olllod
thollho cOndillDnlI lOlon/no IgloOmont did IddllSS lho P/OSOlVltlon 011'001 It lho
POIlmolol 01 Iho Wo.t Sldo Park Subdivision.
Publlo cI.cu.slon 1'111 OpOnod II 7:45 p.m,
;
~
.,
C/atxll. Lolnll. 2088 L1ll1o Crook LonQ, Illrod lhol OPPlo~lm.lolv louI wookl Igo II
WIS btoughl ro hor ollontlon Ihallho O~C.Vltlon, I.kino p1oco In Iho Plo.'mllv ollho
buff oak 1110 IOCOIOd on Ond noollhoil 1111 prOPOlly lino, moV be domaolno 10 IhollOO.
Sho o.p1olnod lhollho conlOClod TOllv ROb/ruon,tho Clly FOIollor,lhollOmo day Ind
11111 0 phono convOlslllon wllh him, lolllholllom Iho lono Ond Iho fnlOlmallon lhal
ho Suppllod, ho was POssibly nOI a dl,/nIOl.SIOd lhlld Pllty wllh looold 10 IhI. 1100,
Sho o~p1olnod Ih.1 Iho lhon ConlaClod Loon LVVOII, I locII mllUIO 1100 O~POII. Ind
ukod him 10 ISSOSllho POlcont 01 domlgo lhol had loken p1aco 10 dalo Ind Ilso
ISllm.lo Iho porconl 01 domago that would OCCut with MOIOI~M'! !lIggOStiiS 16f1iacfy
ollrulolllno 0 1I1/11M11 II. IClolnlfli/ Win Wilhin Iho dllplino Ollho 1100, Sho IOPOIlod
Ihol LVVoro- was olkod 10 provido I wIlli on "'Usmonl ollho CUffonlllluol/on Ilong
wllh proposod IImodlOl Ind Iho Osllmolod COSI 01 .old IImod1as, Lolnll ..Id sho
'.POCII 10 IIcolvo thll Wllllon IOPOII by tho ond Ollho wook. Sho nOlod lhat Iho
vOlballlPolt Iho has IOcolvod 110m LVVOl. I. vuUy dll/OIonl 110m Iho IOPOIlllom
Robinson 1I0aldlnO lho pOlconr 01 dam. go. Sho o~plalnod lhal tho V consldOl
thomsolvOl alowolds 01 Iho 1100 ond loko Ihol, lI.ponslbllily 10' IOIIOlOlIon Ollho
damogo VOly SOIIously, Sho sold sho would IPpr.cI.IO ony commun/collon 1I0aldlng
tho 1110 ond Ills hor Undolllandlno IhallOPoJrs musllOko ploco bolOlo lho 1110 ComlS
out 01 dOlmoncV, Sho S1l1ssod Ihat limo Is ollho o..onco.
faro Laao. 2048 L11110 Crook LalJJ, .Ialod lhol ho was not nolll/od whon lhl.IIOCI was
1I10nod, Ovon lhough ho hos P'OPOIIV abUll/no this tlocl, Ho notod lhal Iho CllY
OIdlntnco nVs Ihol glodlng pions 010 IIqulrod undOl COItaln condillons ond ho lolt thai
thov.hould bo IIqUllOd 101 IhI'llOCI bocouse ollho s/opo. Ho Ind/cotod lhol ho Wont
10 lh. HouslnO 'nspoclIon SOlVlcOI Dopoltmont to '00 lho orod/ng pIon. and 1'101 told
thai nono 1'1010 IIqullod bocouse lho olghl'p'o~OI WOIO bolno buill on Indlvidual/ol',
Ho "Id ho Ihon lo/llholtholl would bo 0 LOIgo Seolo Rosldonllol Dovolopmont PIon
bocauso ollho Icalo Ollho dovolopmonl. Ho said II was O~p/a'nod 10 him that lhll
was notlOqullod bocauso tho bulld/ngl WOlO on Individual lOll. Ho laid ho did "nd Iho
documanlloOlldlno Iho IOlonllon Ollho O~lsllng vogolatlon olono tho POIlmolOl ollho
llOCI, Ho Slolad Iho Cllv old/nonco 101010 10 1100 PloSolvollon ond .Ols locommonda.
lions IOglldlno octlvltv lhot Con OCCUI wllhln tho dllpllno 0111001 ond lho IIlooualds
Ihat should bo Instllulod dUllno conslluctlon, Ho nOlod Ihol no 1010lnlng woll was
conSlluCIOd, ovon rhough porklng lOIS WOII constlucrod odjaconl 10 monv malUlo
IIoos. Ho 10POIlod rhOI a 1100 loco rod on his prOPOlly had a blonch lomovod bocauso
51/1
.
. -
- -
PI.Mlno & Zonlno Commllslon
Mtlch &, 1992
Pag. 4
It ..IIMod OVOllhll tlOCt, Logo 1lI0md thot Iho (1001 octod IS . bfckdlop IOIlhol1
neighborhood ond oddod volu. 10 Iholl ptoperlY, Ho nOI.d lhal il now OPPOIlI lhol
mony 01 lhaSO 11001 will be losl. Ho Itld lhel MOIolond hal Indlcolod lhot Iho
nelghbOl. 110 W'lhIppy with tho dovolopmonl boCOUIO Illncludos 10woI,p,lcod units.
Ho .lIouod IhallOl him Iho ptoblom II wllh IhaUOcuUon ollha unll.. Ho uplalnod
lhat Iho dovolopm.nl lOqu!IOS 15.201001011111 which Obull his property. Ho sllomd
thollt doOl nol fit In wilh tho odlaconl nolghbOlhood bocouSllho olghl'pluos ,rollnod
up In 0 101'1,
Cook Inlormod lho public lhollho Commlsslon II lIv1owlno tho IIsubdlvlllon 01 Ih.
ptopelly odloc.nt 10 lho '"I lhat Iho nelghbOlI 110 concornod .bout, bul ho
oncoulIgod lhelt commonll. Ho nOlod lhal thaSO could Inlluonco Iho Commission',
consldorollon ollutUlo dovolopmonl by Ihls dovolopel In 111m. 01 tho Qu.lily ollho
dovolopmonl 10klno placo.
.lQbn 'rllol. 2040 Lillie Cllok lone, SIIlod that ho lharos Iho concerns lhol h.vo
boon uplIlSftd by his nolghbOll, Ho sold ho has 0 concern with Iho noluro ollho
Inlluslon to lho 1I00lint, Holndlcolod lhat If Iholl Ilroqullomonllo ovold Iho dllpllno
01 llOU, thon he II Ihockod by Iho lock 01 concern 101 Iho drlpllno Ihol hu boon
Ihown by IhI. dovolopel, Ho nOlod lhallhe grodino In mony cosos wonl up 10 Iho
trunkl 01 lho llOU, with 3-4 1001 ollill bulylno Iho l1unkl ollho 11101 In mony cuos,
In '@elld lQ @I~M, FlOW told \Ills IlIuo 1'1111 probably bo 1I101vod. bul It Is 111II ,
concern 101 him, Ho nOlod thallho lill comos Ilghl up 10 tho plopolly IIno. FIOSOI
exprllsod conclln logllding h.vlng porklno 1011 wllhoul ony bOlllors. Ho lold lho
pilklno 1011 010 ononllolly In Iho bock yards 01 tho homos In Iho nolghbolhood ond
hudllghll 1'1111 bo Ihlnlng Into bodloom window.. Ho sllmod 1III hl.lnlonllon to IIvo
In lh1. homo lor I numbol 01 yUI. Ind lold m.ny ollho nolghboll hovo lold 10lgol
plopolllo. In OIdol 10 roUro on L11110 Creok Lono, FrlSlI omphlSlzod Ihol ho II not
domandlng thai tho dovolopol h.vo 0 nOlUII PIISOIYO In tho alU, bUI ho Itld ho Ihould
be obla to plOCllco common COUIlISY 10 Iho nolghbors so os nOI to dllluPt Iho
IlfostyllS lhallhay expectod whon Ihoy movod Inlo Iholl homo.. FIIIOI o~pllmd
concOln IIgoldlng oullldo IIghllno 01 night on Iho gllogos ond lold thll could bo 0
molol disrupting lactOl. Ho ItrolSod thollhOlo noods 10 be, borrlOl ond laid ho Is not
lurO II ho con walt unllllho nowly pl.ntod tillS lIach lho opploplloto moturlly lovol,
~otolftnd, S&M ProDftIIlu. lIotod Ihal whon Iho IIzonlng occurrod, ho did not
try to hldo tho lac I 110m anyono 01 whol ho 1'111 pl.nnlng, In logard 10 notlllcollon,
MOIolond said ho had lomoono olso 1111 oul Iho oppllcoUon, bUl ho Ilko, lull
IIsponslblllty II onyono wos nol noUflod. HowovlI. ho notod Ih.1 0 Ilgn 1'101 poslod
on MOlmon Tllk Boulovlld ond 0 notlco .ppoored In lho nowsp,pOI, Ho explolnod lhol
two nolghbol. callod during Iho lozonlng plocm 10 ho II SUIO th'l somo nolghbors
1'101001'1110 ollho IIzonlng, MOlol.nd lold Ihat 01111 ho gOI his building pOlmlls, ho
Ihought Ihalll 10110 os Iho IiII 1'111 koplaw.y !rom Iho trunk I 01 Iho troll, lholl
would nOI bo plobloml, ho said Obviously ho wos wrong. MOlolond o~plolnod thol
onco ho locolvod tho 101101 110m tho Clly Mon.gor rogardlng lho 11001 ond Iho gliding
thot h.d occullod, ho h.d Iho Clly FOIOSIOI como OullO mako suggolllonl. Ho said
ho hosromovod tho dirl ond Is working with lho Lolntu logolding tho rotolnlng 1'1011,
1
5~/
.
- - . ~
, I
- -
PloMlng . Zonlno CommlSllon
MIlch 5, 1992 .
Page 5
Ho ..Id lha Clly FOIIIIOIlndlcolod 10 Illm that thall 1'1" d,mlgo to lho 11001 on lho
nolghbOll lido ot lhallvino whon lho IOvino 1'111 cut 10 01101'1 101 wolkoul bosomonl..
Ho .~plllnod lhot Robinson o~plolnod 10 him Ihal onc'lho lotolnlng 1'101111 consllUCI'
od, IholO moy be 0 10% diobock In tho crown ollho 11001. Ho lopollod Ihal Juno
Mlynold sold lhal wllh loloctod plunlng, lhoro mlY be no domogo. MOIolond Slid lhal
In lho lulUlO. Ills dovolopmonl will occUlln . mOlo oducOlOd maMOI.
MOIolond sold lhol wllh tho ploposod dovolopmonl, hols wOlklno wllh tho o~lltlng plol
doslgn 101 lho IIIC1, Ho sold lhal wllh Iho .loII'SloPplng down lha hln, lholonoth 01
tho IlIoot .hould nol be e ploblom, Ho sold ho pie 1011 10 havOlho gllOgOl to 1M llonl
ollho homos ,nd Iuouod lhat 1III nOI dOllllblo 10 hovo on alloy behind 10lS becauso
peoplo wonllunctlonol back Vords, Ho Slid he would liko 10 hlvo Ihllllom vOlod on
Ollhll moollno,
I
I
1
~
1
I
i
,
In lOIPonso 10 a quOSllon from Oillk., Miklo sold lhallho grading plons had boon
IIc.lvod on lhi. doy, Ho lold Iho profimlnary plal.hould .how lho 10Poorophy ollho
traCl. Rold "kod II MOIolond would be willing 10 consuucl 0 bOlll1l along wllh Iho
1I10lnlno 1'1011 behind Iho olghl.plo~ units, MOllland rospondod lhal ho would be
willing to put up 0 wood lonco. bul ha plonll on plonllno .1~.loOI arbOl vilOO, Ho
nOlod lhot 0 mOlonry lonco would IOqulrolOOllng.lhol could c.uso oddillonal domago
10 lha loot IVllom 01 11001. Doug BOOlhloy, OlllCtOl 01 lho Hou.lno ond Inspoctlon
SoiVlcii Dip;rtmcnt, notod thAt t/I@ CllY Codo IIqulrol. arbOt v1100 be usod 101
IClOOnlno ond not a lonco. MOlllond sold thol ho has buill 0 calch basin ot Ilia aml
ollho lirst perklno 101 ond 1'111I do tho somo 100lho IOCOnd park1no 101. Ho .old thai
tho II00m 1'10111 1'1111 thon be plped to lho ClOok. Ho notod lhat lholO 1'101 OIoslon on
lho .110 pllOIIO Iho dovolopmonllo Ifill Iho dovolopmont hos boon complolod, Iho
OIoslon ploblom should be doclOosod. In ruponso 10 a qUOlllon from Rold, MOlllond
laid ho Intonds 10 build curbs on lho par kino lot ollOllho 1I10lnlno 1'10111. complolOd.
In IISPonse to a qUOlllon from Bovblarg. MOIolond .Iotod Ihot 0 silllonco 1'101 put up
Iho doy .1111 ho mot wilh Rick FolIO ond T,"y Robln.on. BovblOlg OIkod II ho would
bo uslno sllllonculn olhor 01000 unlillho IOtoinlng 1'1011 Is buill. MOlllond IIspondod
IhAt lho rolainlno wall. 011 now bolng construclOd, Ho lold ho did uSO 11101'1 on lho
hill bohlnd tho Fro SOl ond MOpo plOPlltlOl, Oovbl"g oskod how lhll Iypo 01
constlUCllon Is monJtolld by Iho Clly, 0001NOY IIspondad lhat tho Dopollmonl 01
Houslno ond Inspection SorvlcOllakOl complolnt.from the public, but gonOlolly 111011
drolnogo complolnt. to EnoinoOllno roga,dlng IUologlOllo controllho ploblom, In
IIlponso 10 a quostlon from Rold, Moroland clorlllod tho locollon ollho silllonco,
Olorkl OIkod IIlho placomonl ollill on tho lito would causo on Incrooso In cllok loval.
MOlllond IIOIOd Ihol Ihls .hould nol hoppon bocouse Iho crook luns Inlo Iho
ItolmwollI bosln. Ho .Irouod Ihal tho bosln II now ovorslzod bocause II was
dOllgnod 101 commOlclol dovolopmonl, bul 10sldonUal dovolopmonl I. occurring
Insload.
Gibson sold ho laols II'S doplolablo lhallhls sllUDtlon o~ISIS, Ha nOlod thai Morolond
has boon 0 dovolopOI In Ihls community 101 0 lono tlmo ond ho doo. nol undO/'lond
why mil ond Iho nolghbors hovo 10 loll him whOllO do In lhls slluoUon, Morolond
said lho .110 roqulrod cui Ind WI and on Iho 11'11101 ho dldn'l fool 0 rOlalnlng wall
1
SLIt
.
-
- -
flIjMInQ . Zoning Commission
Mlrch 5,1992
P'ge 8
,
i
i
l
I
I
I
1
I
i
I
would be noodod II he s1opod lha hill ond kePt lhe ,,11 IWlY from Iho lIOOks 0111...,
H. sold he IlwIVI pllMOd on usJng I lOlllnlno 1'1011 101 lho second 101, MOIollnd sold
the lOlolnlng wons win be 15 1001 oWly from IN 101 Uno Ind hall IIOlllno 10 InSlln
thom now. MOIOllnd IlIossod lNl he wu nol e 1110 o~port Ind didn't know tho
omount olliU lhat would harm lho 1I0U. Ho omphosllOd thai 11011 010 what soli his
units, In IIIPonst 10 e quosllon from Gibson. r.lorollnd sold thaI tho glld1no WII
bolod on pllns, Gibson liked Illhe pllns conod 101 gliding 10 like pllCO up 10 Iholol
line, MOIollnd lospond.d lhal hall nOI lurO II lhel Is whit lho pllns clnod lOt.
POlO Llgo sold lhal 11'10 unllS hevo boon ConlllUClod bohlnd his prOPO'ly Ind 1.ld tNI
nOl In 01 lhe Conclllt 100lho porklng 101 has boon pour.d V'I, Ho sold ho would uk
thll lh11 conclllo not be Inslollod. In lOSponSO 10 I quosllon 110m Dlolks, Boollvoy
uplllnod INt I proporty OWnol CIMollllm e 1100 INIII nol on hll 01 hol propolly,
H. sold lhall 010 no IIgul.llons In lho Cily Codorogordino IIlndalds 100lho prolOcllon
01 11001 ucoplln Iho gliding Ind OIoslon conllol OIdlnonco,
&mILMAJla. 2034111110 Creek ~.!lt, uked how lho 1'11101 110m Iho hlghol porklno lot
wlllllach IhalowOI pork1no 101 Ind Ih.n how will It rooch Iho slOlmwIIOl bosJn.
MOIolond o~pl.lnod lhat It 1'111I go from 0 COlch basin Ilvough I lubo 10 lho cllok Ind
lhon 10 thaSIOlmw.11I basin,
Publlo c1lculllon wu closed II 8:28 p.m,
,
Cook oxplolnod lhal lhOlO 1'101 I wish on Iho POlt ollha Commllllon 10 dolOllhllltom
10 tho nul 100m.1 moo ling 01 March 19, 1992, Mrklo said thll would IIqul;o wllvOI
01 tha 45.doy limllotlon porlod by Iho Ipplicont. In rosponse 10 I qUOlllon 110m
MOIollnd, Cook said lho CommlSllon would Ilko 10 SOl lomollluOI clOllod.up belOlo
moklno I finol doclslon, In IllponSO to 0 question from MOIOlond, Miklo lold lh1t he
would not bo Iblo 10 wlthdlow e WIIVOl 01 lho Iimll'llon pollod belOlo tho no~t
mOIling onco lhal WIIVOI hAI boon modo, In IISponse 10 I qUilt Ion 110m Miklo.
MOIolond lold lhal ha would glonl I w.lvoI ollho 45.day Ilmll.tlon pOllod,
Dlllks movod 10 dolol SUO 92.0003 10 Milch 19, 1992, Bovbjolg locondod, The
modon clrrfod 5.0.
1, Public hOlllno on I proposed OIdinonco Imond1no Iho silO plon IOvlow procoss 101
mullHomily, commOlclal ond InduSlllol dovolopmonls,
Doug Bootlvoy o~plaln.d lhallhll ploposollll rovislon ollho o~lltlng 1110 pion lOvlow
plOCOSS. Ho said cUllonlly, I procossIs lollowod lhal .nlalls tho dovolopoI bllnglng
In 0 dllwlng 01 tho 101 which Ihows Iho conligulollon ollho building, porklng, .nd
compllonco wllh 1Cl00nlng IIqul,omonls, Ho Slid Iho plans 010 Inlondod 10 Ihow wh'l
Iho lot would look liko whon tho building II In p/aco. Ho lold Iho IOvlslon 10 Ihls
plocosslakOl Iho procoss 10 0 dlllOlonllovol .nd has Iddltlon.1 gooll. Ho Slid ho
would hlghllghllhroo ollhoso go.ls.
1
51/
,
-
-
1
PloMlno & Zon/no CommlSllon
Milch 5, 1992
Pogo 7
I
I
I
.1
I
!
Boollvoy Indlcl1.d thollho IIrsl goolll to Chlngolha lOviow ptOCUl Itom ologllloUvo
prOCUl 10 In odmlnlstlOUvo ptocm. H. uplolnod lhat CUllonlly IlIldonUol
dovolopm.nll on two OCIOS 01 mOlO go Ilv000h 0 8.8 wook ptOCUl 01 Commllslon
Ind CouncillOviow. Ho Slid Ihty samo typo olllvlow lokll ploc. 101 non'lIs1donUol
d.v.lopmonl on ono 01 mOl. OCIII. Ho notod lhallha curront ptOCUl hollow dll'gn
IIqullomontl ond Iho llvislonl onow 100lho ptOCUlIO bo slIOImlinod whilo ollowlno
Iho Commllslon ond Council mOlO limo to oddlUl policy quoSUonl.
Boolhtoy Indlcotod thot e IOcond goolll to loduco tho llvoshold lhot tllggOIl tho silO
plon lOvlow PlOCUl. Ho laid concern. have boon o~ptmod that lho OCIOlgO .nd
donllty loqulromont. 010 too high. Ho laid II OppolI. INt dovolopoII oveld lho
ItOlmwltOl monagomonl ond silO pI.n lOvlow ptocm by ke.p/no dovelopm.nl. lull
UndOl Iho doslgnolod oCI.ago. Ho nOlod lhal undOllho ptoposod ptoc.... only slnolo.
llmily ond duplu dov.lopmonl WOUld bo mmpllrom tha ptOCUl.
Boollvoy up/olnod lhal 0 Ihlld goal Is lha OIlobllshmonl oloddiUonol do sign stondlld.
IUCh IS onsullng compotibilily with Iho nolghbOlhood, InlrOllluctulo ond Iho
communlly In gonOtOl. Ho rovl.wod o~amp/II 01 lho doslgn SlondOld. lhal 011
Int.ndod to oddll.. lpeclllc ptoblom.. In IIgald 10 dlolnogo ond OIoslon. ho said thot
cUlllnlly Ihoso IssuII oro IIgul.IOd only Ihtough lho stolmWI101 monagomonl
OId/nonco which only oppllosII Iho dovolopoI Is roqullld 10 havo 0 p1.t or QO t1vOUOh
Ill! LSRO proem. Ha lilil iroi!Oii IOqulromonts aro lncludod IS POlt 01 lho
IIOlmWOIOl manogomonl OId/nonco, Ifo nOlod lhatll 0 dovoloPOl hal 0 IlIldonllol
dovolopmont locOIOd on 1.90 ICIOI. Ihon no dlOlnogo 01 erosion conllol moosulos
would opply, Ho upl.lnod thai dtOlnago 110m now dovolopmonll hal boon 0 problom
In 101'10 Clly Ind tho 1Iv1llonl would oddll.. thl. ptoblom.
I
I
,
i
I
i
I
I
I
.
In IIgOld to IIghtlno. Ooollvoy laid hls dop"lmonl IICO/vOl lllquonl complalnll
IIgoldlno IIghllno 110m POI kino lots ond commOlclol OliOS obulllno lIs1d.ntlol USI..
Ho lold Ihlt undOllho CUllonl slondOlds, 0 dovolopoI can bo In complionco with Iho
IIgulotlon. bulsllll bo Intluslvo on nolghbollno.propoltlos. Boollvoy oold lhat CUlllnlly
lhOlo WOII no sotbock roqulromonl' 101 dumpslOlI .nd lhat ICIOOn/ng or moving 01
dumpslers cannOI bo IIqulrod. Ho lold lho lovislon 1lI0poSOl 0 10.100t solbock 110m
lho lot IIno ond Icroon/ng 01 dumpslOlI, Ho laid Ihll would holp 10 contloltho b1owlno
01 doblll. Ho .old tho 1Iv1I/on. olso would IIqulll Iho ICIIOn/no 01 mOChanlcII
oqulpmonlluch OS mOlolO, Bootlvoy .old tho llvislonl would pormlt tho IOviow 01 lho
domolltlon OllllUClulO. ollglblo 100lho Notlonol RoglstOl 01 HlstOllc Ploces which gool
boyond tho cUllont IIgulatlons which oro IImllod 10 IlIuctulI. locotod In HillOllo
DlstllclS,
IScolI onterod tho Council ChambOlS 01 8:45 p.m,1
Boo!hloy sold tholanolhOllssuo 10 bo oddllssod by Iho IIvlslon. Is tho compoliblllly
01 do sign Wllh tho nolghbolhood. Ho Slid thollho .tandaldl nood 10 bo mOIO Ipociflo
Ihon Is cUllonUy Ploposod, Ho .ummalllld lhallho proposal would 01101'1 Iho Clly 10
loko I mOil oggresslvo 1010 In IIvlowlng Iho compatibilily olltlucluros and design,
dlolnogo, lighting, ond OlhOllssuOI. Ho sold Iho quostion 101lho public Is Ihould lho
.
5'11
.
. -
- -
I
. .
i
- -
PloMlno . Zoning Commission
Milch 5,1992
Pogo 8
CommlSllon chango "om Iho loglslollvo 10viow prOCOllIO on .dmlnllllotlvo roviow
prOCOll. Ho IIIusod Ihallho pulpOSO oliN lovillonllslo lmprovo IN chollCIO' ond
IIvobility ollho communllY Ilvough botlol dOllgn. Ho nOlod lhol on Bloomlnolon
St'lOlO dovolopel 1'111 proposlno I bulldlno Ind tho pions WOII not conslllont wllh the
stlUCIUlOS In IN nolghborhood. Ho Slid thol ollor discusllon with stoll, tha dovolopel
volunlorlly oglood 10 chonoOSlhat mad. Iho IIIUCluIO III Into Iho chlrOClor ollho
IUlloundino 1100. Ho Ihowod In lIIusllotlon ollho proposod building Ind 1IIIOd Ihll
INs Ills In IXImplo 01 I now bulldlno being compoliblo wllh lis nolghbOlhood,
Dlolks olkod 1111111 would be Iblo 10 comploto lha "viow procoslln 0 tlmoly loshlon.
Boollvoy lospondod lhat INs Is 0 promolulo qu.ltlon becouso It would dopend on how
Iho OIdlnlnco Is ovonluolly odoptod. Ho notod thollomo slondllds would loqullo 0
dlllolonl opproach In Iho lIv10w ond may IIqulrollvi.w by lho PlOMno Doportmonl
ond Iho Public WOlks Doportmonl. Ho IlIlIIOd thaI havino dlolnogo ond OIoslon
conllol be 0 prlvoto motlll bOlwoon odjaconl propelly owners Is nOlO SlllsloCIOlY
InSWOI 100lho public. Ho sold Iho goal has olwoys bo.n 101 I lOVon.doy IUlnolound
101 building pelmlls ond Ihls should nOI Chanoo. Cook o~plossod lha coneorn Ihll
compatlbillly could bo usod II In mlullonolY lochnlquo In somo nolghbOlhoodl
becouso ollho subloctlvllY Involvod. Boollvoy luouod lhallhlsls nOltholnlonlond
Iho Commlsslon ond Council could guarontoo lhallho IlIndllds ore nOI voguo.
Tho public hoorlng 1'111 opon.d 01 8:53 p.m,
.
f4u11 BlInd\, 824 NClflh Gllboll, stOlod Iho wo~ IIprosonl1no Fllondl 01 HIIIOIlc
PIISOIVOllon, whlch oncoulogos tho roslolollon, rohlbililollon. odoptlvo IIUSO Ind
molnlOnonco 01 oldor buildings In 101'10 Clly, Sho sold Ihly Oil lh1nklul to Iho Clly 101
provld1no lund1no 101 tha Doslgn Guldollnos book which ollors guldollnos ond
sUOgosllonslol wOlk on oldOl SllUClulI1 ond now conslluctlon In oIdol nolghborhoods,
Sha Slid somo 01 lho Issuosln Ihls book Ire Iho somo thlt 011 oddllssod In Iho slto
pion lIv10w procoss ond o~pressod Iho hope lhal lh1s pICCOlI would plovldo
dovoloPOlI wllh IIslslonco In Cllollng bulld1noslhal 1'10 011 con IIvo with. She IlIossod
lh1t dovolopmonlloovos on Impression on vlsIIOlI to 101'10 Cily, bulltressod Ihol mOlo
Imporlontly dovolopmonl ollocls how Ihose 01 us who IIvo In 101'11 City 1001 bOlh
nogollvoly Ind posltlvoly Ibout OUI nolghbOlhood ond communllY. Sho Slid lhll con
Influonco Iho doclslons that 1'10 moko, luch II wholhor 10 IImoln In 0 nolghbolhood
or movo OIlnvolllno In OUI plopOlly.
Brandlshowod IlIdos to Iho Commission 10 domonsllllo tho IUUOSlhollho hOPOSlho
oldlnlnco will oddlo". Sho nOlod IhollporlmonlS In slnolO'lomlly nolghbolhoods 011
olton Incompollblo with tho o~lstlng IIIuclurOI, Sho sold lhallowo Clly 1'101 ollglnolly
deslgnod wllh Iho olloysl~londod 101llolllc ond porklng 10 Iho 1101 OlltruclUles, Sho
sold oportmonlS now hovo perking vislblo hom Iho llrooll ond Ilso o~posod lho
ectlvllY lhel occullln Iho IlIoy 10 lho public on Iha strOOI, Sho sold sho would IIko 10
hovo Iho ordlnanco oddross SIIOOIICOPO, Sho notod Ihel epollmonl bulldlngl ollon
eppoOllo bo 100 10100 ond nOlod Ihelln somo ClSOS goblod loolllnos would docrellO
lho vlsuel impecl Ollho scelo ollho eperlmonl buildinos, Sho nOlod Ihel pllvocy ond
ool01Y oro olso Issuos 01 conco,", Sho showod IlIdos 01 buildings Ihel did nOl oddress
5'1'
.
.
- --
1
. '
- -
PloMlno . Zonlng Commission
MilCh 5, 1992
Pogo 9
lhase concornl. Sho showod oxomples 01 good doslgn lhol 110 podOSlllon frlondly.
hovo numlloul wlndowlond IIChllOCIUlOI dOtlll, ond ullli,. quolilY mllOlloll, Shalold
lho ICIOOnlng 01 molors would olio be dosllod.
hI:dIJz1W Slid \Nt lho WOII Sldo Com pony oppllcollon prosonlod Iho Commllslon
wllh mony 01 thaluUOI lhol Boollvoy 11I1 d.scllbod. Shasold she IlIongly IUPPO/II
lho lovlslonl In Iho sllO pion rovlow process.
PII Eckhardt. 814 NOIlh LInn. Slid tho would OIlCOUIOgolho conlinuod dovolopm.nt
01 lha lovlalonl to lho ailo plln lOviow procoss because II 1'111I halp lha Clly molnloln
Ilsoll,
61oxandOl KOln. 1639 Bldgo Road, sold lhatlho limo has como to begin to consldOl
tho luilobilily 01 SIlUCIUl.S within on 0100. Ho sold Iho 1010 concorn should nol bo Iho
bonom Iino. Ho sold bonol doslgn alound 101'10 Clly could mako Ihlnol bonol Ihon
lhoy 110 bocomlng.
i
i
i
I
1
,
LallY SchnlIlIOl. MMS ConSI~IAnll. lold his conc.rn Illhol mony ollhaSO Issues 011
olllody oddlOSlod In lho ronlno OIdinanco 01 could be Includod on Iholl own. Ho sold
lho dovolopmonl communlly II uncomlOlloblo wllh pullino lhoso IssuOl undOl
admlnlsualivo lOvlow. Ho sold mosl 01 lho dovolopmonl shown by Bllndl on Iho
slid.. 110 tho luuit 01 tho imoo lliat Wii In plica In lNl area, Ha IIOlod that we
now IIIvo HlstOllc Dislllcll 10 holp conllollhll ploblom, Ho sold ho bollovos tho
glldlno ond 1I0slon conllol OIdinonco can be IIlggorod on III own ond lhallho building
olliclol con Impose II on ony pion, Ho sold lhallhore 011 many limos wh.n IhllO
ItIndlldl don't Mod to opply ond dovolopell con use Iholl own Ikin Illhol IlIIn hillno
In onglnool, IIchiloct, 01 landscape OIchlloct. In response 10 . qUlltlon Itom
BovblllD, SchnlnlOluld lomo ollho' Ilondordl Oil lIasonoblo, Ho Itlomd thlt
doalgn IlondOldl olroady o~ISl In lho Zonlno Oldlnonco tllll COVII mony ollhoso
ISSUOl, Bovblorg askod II SchnlnlOl has 0 problom wllh oxlOnding Iho Ilondlldl 10
slluollono whall Ihoy CUlllnlly don'l opply, SchnlnlOluid ho has 0 ploblom wllh tho
compollblllly IIOndO/d. IEdilOl'1 NOlO: Dloinago ond oroslon II only revlowod ond
conllollod by Iho Clly In IImllod Illulllonl,1 Ho aold lho Ilatod Inlonl ollho Oldlnonco
1110 docllo" lho Imount 01 limo lhAl lho lIv10w PIOCOllIOkOl, but ho notod IhAl no
limo llomo 11I1 boon oltlbllshod In Iho OIdinonco, Ho o~promd lho concorn IlIIt II
won'l doclIOlO lhallmo ollho llviow procoss and could loke olmoS! II long II Iho
CUlllnt prOCOlS. Ho lold ho has no ploblom with Iho IIqullomonlllol 10lgo ploloCIS,
pion Sldors. Soulhllalo DovoloJllI1lQ1, slolod Ihol ho hll plobloms wllh various POliS
01 till Oldlnonco. Ho lold lho blggOlI ploblom Is wllh Iho omounl 01 dlsClllion 101
11011. Ho nOlod Ihoro ore nOI mony guldollnOl glvon 10 dovolopoIsln odvonco. Ho sold
ho would nOI bo opposod 10 Iho compalibilily Ilandald Ilthore Oil guldollnes ond
IIgulatlons Ihol 01111 guldanco 10 dovoloporl. Ho quesllonod Illho proposal would
upodilo Iho pIOCOlS, Ho Indlcalod Ihol ho 10011 0 mOil apploprlalo oCllon would bo
10 omond lho ronlno Oldinonco 10 addrossspocllio concorns. Ho sold ho would pllloI
10 "0 problom 01111 dovolopod In Iho zoning ordlnanco ond 10m Iho rovlow plOCOSS
011\ cUllonlly ullll.
T
,
51/1
.
.
-
-
1
- .
. .
-
Plonn/ng & Zonlno Commllslon
MIlch 5, 1992
Plgo 10
D4l1.MOOlO. Pat MOOIO Consl/ucllQ1], sold INllhls proposal II putUno lho dovolopel'l
Ilv'lihood In lho hondl 01 tho dlloctOt olth. Houslno InspecUon Sorvlc.. Dopartmont.
Ho nOlod lhoro Is no Ilmolramo In tho OIdlnonco 101 comploUon ollho lOvlow procm
ond ho has coneolns wllh how costs would bo Incroosod unci" Ihll proposal, MOOIo
10YI ho hal no probl.ml IIlIondllds opply 10 ItlUCIUlOS wllh 12 01 mOlo dwollino
unlll, He sold lhat II . lWO'OCIO IIv.shold IIqulllmOnll1 nOl odoqualo, lhon ho
luggollod to 101'101 Iho Illndaldl. Ho II/mod lhallha build"l do not conllollhe
locotlon oltllnslOlmorl, bullllhol lho ul/lily com pony doos. Ho notod lhal lho \t.nd
Is to build In harmony Wllh lho ulsUng nolghbOlhood ond e~prollod cone.rn with
glvlno too much conllol to lha Clly, Ho IIImod lhallho COSI 01 lond In lowo City II
phonomonol so II Is difficult to lacllnco oddillonol lond to seloon dumps 1011. Ho
sllOls.d Ihls propou' would Incl...Olho COSI 01 houslno ond luggollod lhallho Clly
Ihould wOlk with Iho Homobuild"l AllocloUon In Iddloulno those probloml.
,:,
.
,
,
::
r
r
}
!
i
~.
l
I
i
,
,lJm ~ullal. I I 25 SavmOUI. slotod lhal his blggoS! cone"n II wllh IhllnlrostluclUlo
01 lho Clly In mok1no II compoUblo to dovolopmonl. Ho IlIossod Ihlllholl Is 0 nood
101 d.volopmonlln 101'10 Clly Ind laid INI mony 01 Iho bui1dlnol lhal havo boon
domollshod woro nOlln good condillon, Ho said ho 101S 0 purposo to Iho nOllh ond,
but IllIuod thai dovolopmont II noodod In Ihll communlly. Ho IlIld thol holools tho
OIdlnanco os proposed could hall almost oil prOjocllln low. Clly,
~,~kc HodnCl, HGdoil CoosllIlClliiQ. fiiiOiliid INl tho Homobulidlll Alloclollon IOImod
I commltlOO to lOvlow tho proposal. Ho sold lhal mombOIl Ollhls commllloo mot wllh
BOOlhloy ond Stovo Aikins, tho Clly Menagor, Ind sold lhot lhoy 1'1010 told Ihot Iho
pulpOse 01 tho Old/nonce' wos to o~pedllO lho lOvlow procoss, Ho lold Ihls gool
IPPOIII to bo lost bocluse ollho oddillonolllqulllmonls. Ho uprOlsad coneorn with
loovlno so much up to lho dlscllllon 01 on Individual slallperson and lold lhat Iho
cUllont procm WOlke. Hodgo said II sa.ms to him thot tho proposolls llyino 10 CUfO
mony Ills Ind sllluod lhot lomO III oJllldy oddllssod In Iho Zonlno O,dlnonco, Ho
sold ho hiS buill SIlUCIUIIS IholllO compatiblo wllh uslslonco 110m tho nolghbol'
hoods ond said ho would Iiko Ihls volunloly prOCOSlIO conllnuo.
RaJah Slaullal. Landmark rl)glnaarfDg. said lhal mony ollhose IIqullomonts would bo
vory o~penslvo, ospeclolly whon 0 mojOl sllO plan would be IIqullOd,
POlO Lago Illd thot this proposollils In Wllh lho dovolopmonllhol hos boon occurring
odjocont 10 Iholl nolghbOlhood. Ho said Iho Illck soomslo be pulling up smollor unlls
on Individual 1010 10 ovoid Iho IIvlow PlOCOlS. Logo sold ho lools thlsloopholo should
bo lIxod.
Mike Furman aold thai ho Igrm thollomo ollho loopholos should bo closod, bUllhol
this should bo dono wilh Ihe Zoning OldlnollCO, Ho sold lholthis plOCOSS Ihould nOI
bo ot Iho dlscllllon 01 I non.oloctod 01 non.appolnlOd olllclol,
Mika Hodollsoid Iho bulldors 010 ploud ollholl buildings, Ho Slid In Iho oorly 1980'1
thoro was on ollompllO mOOllho domond 101 housing wilhoul COIO 101 doslgn, bUI
Ihot bulldols all now moving away 110m lhls lIond.
5~1
. .
- - - -
1
PIonnInQ . ZonIno CommJlslon
Milch 5. 1892
pog,"
~ Hid ho would 1nvi10 poojll. to lOUt LIncoln H.lQhlS 10 100 lho quality 01
consllucllon. Ho III0000d lholo Is 0 noed to moo I tho noeds lhol o~ISl In lho 1100.
~ Itid lhallom. 01 tho IIIUCI~OIlhol Olt nol compatlblo wllh nolQhbOl'
hoods 110 fount 10 not on WId.1I have chang.d tholl woyt. Sho Itld Itvl.w lOt
smonof dovelopmonl. would be ospoclony holpllA noOl lho downlown 1100.
Tho public hooting 1'1" doud " 9:38 p.m.
Rold moyod 10 condnut tho public hoorlno 10 M.,ch 1 D. 1992, Cook .ocondtd. Tho
modon cOlrlod 8.0.
3. &UB9~.OOO~, Public dlsculslon olon opjlllcotlon lubmln.d by LucII Von Oldon 101
proUmlnoly jllot opprovol 01 NowpoIl Woodl. 0 8,101. oppro~lmol' 37.8 ICIO
lubdlvlslon locOIOd norlh 01101'11 Cily. out 01 Pro~lo du ChI.n Ro.d. 01011O lho WOSl
sldo 01 NowpoIl Ro.d In Nowpolt Township. (45'doy Ilmllollon porlod: Mlrch 15,
1882.1
Mulch IOpoIlod lhal.n ollho dollcl.ncloo ond disclopanclos had beon losolvod by lha
oppllclnt,
Publio IIlculs/on 1'111 opon,d lit 9;50 ji,iii.
Tholl wos none,
Public cllcuulon 1'111 cloud .1 8:50 p,m.
Cook movod 10 opprovo 8UB92.o004. lho proamlnoty plol 01 Nowpolt Woodl. I 8~ot.
opproalmoto 37,8 IClt lubclvlalon IocOlod north 01101'10 CIIY. 1111 01 PloIrle du Chlon
Rood. olono lho 1'1011 side 01 Nowpolt Rood In Nowpolt Townlhlp, Glblon I.cond.d,
The modon colrlod 8.0,
JONING ITEMS:
1. z,g 11 0 .nd 9,9128. Public discussion 01 In oppllcollon submillcd by Dill Happol to
IIlone 2800 Rochellll Avenue Itom ID'RS (Inlollm Oovolopmonll 10 OPDH.5IPlonnod
Oovolopmonl Houllnglond to opprovo prollmlnolY LlIgo Scolo Rosld.nllol Oovolopmont
ond Plonnod Oovolopmonl Houllng plans 101 Rochoslll HiUI. 0 32,unIt IIsldonllol
dovolopmont on on oppro~lmolo 27 OCIO sllo locllOd on tha nOllh sldo 01 Rochellll
Avonuo 0111 01 SI, Thomol COUll. (45'doy IImllollon pollod: Milch 5, 1092.1
Miklo llviowod Iho mOil IIconl plot Ind nOlod lhal Iho dovolopmonl Ivold. tho
woUonds to Iho nonh. Ho Indlcolod lhal on Inlornol wolkway II .hown llvough tho
dovolopmont ond nOlod Ihot tho now plot Ihowl Iho ollminotlon 01 tho Hoddock
Conogo, Ho lold lho City AllOlnoY'1 Olflco would plOIOnl on opinion obOUl Iho City'.
obillly to IIqulro Pllservollon ollho cOllogo, In IIgald 10 Iha plOSllvollon ollha 11101,
Miklo "Id lholo could bo 0 condillon on Iho 100onIno Ihol 0 pIon 101 Iho plosllvotlon
S~I
f
. ~
. -
-
1
Pflnnlno & Zoning Commlsslon
Milch 5, 1992
Plgo 12
I
!
j
I
i
I
!
j
j
,
,
f
f
i
,
J
ollho 11001 bo submlnod 10 rho CilY llId Ihll 'omOvol 0/ .ny 11001 doslgnatod 101
PllSONOtlon would loquilO oPplovol by Ih. Clly FOIOSlOI .1Id Iho Clly ManogOl. Ho
uplolnad Ihlllho Public WOIkl Doporlmont IIquo.lod odditionollnlOlmotlon loglldino
tho .Ighl dlSlanco at Iho Inter.octlon 01 Lorch L.no ond Rocha'lOI Avonue. Mklo I.'d
thtt Iho Public Works Doponmont has loviowod Iho gl.dino plan, Ihtl ChtngOS 010
noodod be fOil It cln be .pprovod, Ho .ald Iho Public WOIks Dopl/tmont hts roQUOltod
IddltlonollnlOlmotlon on oloslon conllol oncl thoro moy neod 10 be I cOndillon on
IPprovolllquillng Public WOIk. opprovol 01 Iho orollon conllol mOlSulII ptlOl to
Council consldolltlon, MkJo IlItod lhol Sloll would proposo lhot tho consoNollon
oosomonl COVOI Iho ontllO 100 YOI/ nOodpllln 10 Iho nOllh ond ollhl. proPOlty ond
th.llholO be e plovl.lon 10' I podoslllon WOlkwoy OISom.nl wlthln Ihl. ConSONOtion
oosomont, Ho o.ld "011 hal concorns rogold1no Iho mon.wollbllllY 100lholOSl two
PI/king .pocos 101 Iho Un/tl locllod In Iho mosl nOllhoostllly POltlon 01 tho
dovolopmont, MikJo IOld Iho CUllont pion Ihowltho ,0wOllinos on Iho 00110'" pOlllon
ollho plop.rly ond Closslno R.lston Cllok. Ho .tlollOd llllho .ppllconl" rosponslblll.
Iy 10 obtaIn Iho nOc....,y OOIomonlS 100lho IOWOI.nd 10 moko oll.noomonlS 100lho
lOwer'. conslluctlon. Miklo ..,d IhOllhl. dovolopmonl os proposed would .lImlnoto
one ollho low ollernallvo locotlons 101 ollvaugh 111101 nOllh 0/ RochlllOI Avonuo 10
11011 would IIcommond Ihol tho opplicollon be glv.n consldOlotlon only II tho
Commission Is .otlsllod thai tho SIIOOI nOlwOIk In Iho nOllhoostOln ponlon 01 low.
Clly c.n bo .ccompllshod 10 lho OOSI 01 this 1110. Miklo Slid Ih.11l tho CommissIon
1001. thol Iho 111001 nOlwolk con bo odoqUOloly complol~d, Illtn !!all would
(ecommend apPfoval only if tho 'SlUOS dl.cussod con be IIsolvod,
In IIsponso to . question 110m Gibson, Miklo uplolnod lhal. .omo ollho luuoo ho
lolsod all lolOlod to oddltionol Inlolm.tlon Ihot I. noodod by Iho Public WOIkl
Dopl/tmont, Ho SlId tho oppllclntl.ln ogroomonlthtt lho conservollon OOIomont wll/
covOllho onllll 100 VOOI floodploln. Ho .tatod Iholl will nood 10 be . cOnditIonal
IIl0nlng IgroomOnllhl1 1'1111 spoclly lho dovoloper'. ond Iho City'. lospon.lbil/lIoo.
Chl/sllonson sllossod Ihotlhls Iypo 01 agllomonl would lun wllh tho land, Rold notod
lhat 10 Iho nOllh 01 tho o~lstlno IlIUClulI thero I/O louI 10lgo IplUCO tllOS Ind ono
lalgo doclduous tlOO thol '" nOI .hown ont tho pIon, Sho .tlluod Ihol ovon Illho
dov%poI plans to lomovo thoso IIOOS, lhallhoy .hould be Idonllllod on tho plan,
SCOtl .old IhOI O. chall ho Would lIod I momolondum 110m Iho City AlIOInoy
IIgoldlng Iho CommissIon'. Ibil/ty 10 condltlonolly rolonO tho IIICl 10 Includo
prosoNotlon ollho SlluCtulI, II10rrod 10 as Iho Hoddock Houso, Ho notod Iholtho
memo Indlcotes that Ills plobobly nOI wllhln Iho powor ollho Commission to roquill
pro,oNotlon ollho 1I1UClUIO on tho "10, Ho lovlowod lonouogo IIcommondod by tho
Clly Atlo,"oV 10/ usa In 0 conditlonolllquOSI ond thollonouogo roods os 101101'1': 'Tho
Commission IInds tholloqulr/ng tho PIOpOlly cwnOl 10 proSOlvO tho hou.o by romovol
10 onOlhol .110 ond/ol to rolloln 110m domolltlon ollho hcuso 101 lllooSl lomo pOllod
01 tlmo Is 0 loosonoblo condition In oldol 10 .otlsly tho public noods 01 hlstOllo
PlIsolvotlon dllocUy cousod by tho ownol'. Ploposod lozon/ng.' SCOII lOPOflod Ihot
lho dovolopoI has OOlood 10 tho tlmo llomo 01 ono YOOI hom lho dOlO 01 Council
oPPlovol 01 Iho IInol OPDH plan. Ho sold oPPlcvol would bo lunhol conditlonod on tho
dovolopoI olfollng tho Haddock Houso 10 tho Clly ond lho dovolopoI conlllbullng
.
r
j
5'11
.
__ 1. _
-
-
1
PloMlng . Zonlng Commlsslon
Milch 5, 1992
P.go 13
n,ooo 10 lho IOloc.lion ollho house, Ho uld lha dovoloptl IS In ogroomonl with
thG.. condillons. In IUPonSO 10 0 qutsUon 110m Mrklo. SCOII uld Iho condiUonal
rolon/no would only 11101 10 Iho houlo ond lho Olhol condilionl, Including Iho
roqullom.nt 10 prtsOlVO 1M lilts Ind lho consolVollon momonl, would bo pa/l ollho
OPOH plon.
Publlo cllcusslon WOI optnod 0110:10 p.m,
Jln Nllh, sold the CilY'1 Comprohonllvo PIon d.fllltl lho olomonlO whlch hovo boon
lOUlCl 10 bo Importont to lho 1'1.1111. 01 lhll City ond whlch '" to bo prOI.Clod .nd
pmolVod, Sho IlIlOd dovolopmonll Includo buildings ond ICOniC villlS, Nuh
ollplolnod lhat lho Comprohanllvo Plan SOVI thoro 110 IIIUCIUlIS In 101'11 CllY which
ptovldo 10011 lor 1M lolldonll ond porptlualo 0 logocy 01 hlllOIlc IIchilOClulI1 ond
CullUlol Ichlov.monlS 101 111 momboll ollho communllY, Sho sold 1IIIIho policy 01
lho Clly 10 plOlOlVO ond prOlOCllho unlquo OluibulOS 01101'1' CilY'1 public ond prlvolo
nolghbOlhoodl uldonllRod by Iho Clly 100Iho gonolol 1'1011.11 ollho communlly .1
IlIgo. Sho IUOgoslod lhol Ihll lonouago OllOblllho1 0 cloll dUly on tho parI 01 tho
Commllllon, ,cllng uncIOI lhaOUlhOllly ollho Cily Council 10 olnlmoUvolv oddlOlllho
h111011c Ilgnlliconco 01 Blullwood ond 1lllondlCopo. Sho 1I111S.d lhallho IIgnlllconco
01 tho 1110 II beyond quosllon. Sho IlP01lOd lholll halO wrlllon lullno 110m Iho vOlY
Iyslom 101 up 10 dOlormlno hlslOIlc IIgnlllconco, In Iddillon 10 bolno ollglblo 101 lho
NOllonol Roglllor 01 HIIIOIlc PI.cos IIgnlllc.nco, sho ompholllOd Iho 1110 olso hal tho
pelOtll!:1 01 N"llon:l LondlNrk Slgnlllconco. Silo lndleOlod IMllhl: Is 1110 umo SlAtu;
glvon 10 Iho SI11UO 01 L1borty, lho WhlIO Houso, ond Old Clpllolln 101'10 Clly,
Nosh sold It II hor undOlllondlno lhallho cholc.s 110 10 oilhOl Illilm 01 dony tho
roQUOllod lone Chanoo, Sho IOld I thlld ollornollvo IppollllO bo pOlSlblo boCIUSO
lho Commlsllon dool hove Iho IUlhOllty 10 Ilsuo . condlUonal IIlon1no, Sho
oncoUlogod lho Commlsllon to Issuo 0 condillonallllonlno to pllSOlVO lho house on
lho lite 101 tho benoflt ollho community ollllgo, Sho lu.ssod lhat moving Iho houso
would dosUoy 1lllIgnlllclnco. Sho nOlod lhollho Commission should hovo coplos 01
tho 101101 she sonl 10 Hoppol .nd ukod lhal Ihoy plmo IIrud lh11 101ler. Sho
omphullOd Ihlt lhllls e litO whoro Iho houso ond 10ndICopo 011 oquolly ImPOlllnl,
Sho oxplllnod lhol 10 IOplIOIO lho house ond silO "om one onolher would dostroy Iho
hlllOIlo Ilgnlllc.nco,
.
Nlsh Indlcolod lhot II thero I, 0 doodllno IUnnlno out 101 CommlSllon oCllon on IhI.
110m, Ihon Iho would IUOgtsllhollho only cholco 1110 dony lho Ippllcollon 01 101 Iho
IIko 01 0 doodlino lho ComplOhonslvo Plon would bo Ignolld. Nash said Iho II
conlldonl thaI Happol would ogloo to on o~lonllon 01 Umo IIlho ollOlnoUva II donlal
01 Ihls oppllcatlon, Sho laid Iho would hOIO 10100 Iho plOCOSl conllnuo Ilnco lho main
olfoct ollho tlmo log Is 10 1'1001 down Iho pooplo who wonllO soo Iho house ond 1110
plOsOlvod. Sho llIollod thollho public has no pOlonllollol PIOIII 10 hop Ihom
mOllvalod IhloUOh Ihoso monlhl, only Iho wollore Ollhll communllY ond Iho oppolllng
lhoughl 01 losing such a cullul.lauol ollhls cily.
51/1
.
- -
-
.-
, ' ,
-
1
D
P1oM/no . Zon/no Commission
M"ch 5. 1992
Pogo 14
;
,
I
,
I
,
,
!
,
t,
Nosh uPlouod Iho concern IIlaI wllh sPt1no O.covollon ond gild/no mlghl bo SllIlod
bolOlo 0 lintl dOlermlnallon 01 lh. Ion/no oPp/lcllIon has bo.n mado. Sho Slllssod
IIlaI tho hal nOI YII locolvod 'Pptovol"om lho dovolopoI fOllho HlIlOllc Amerlcon
Buildinos Survoy IHABSlloom 10 do Ihol, wOIk on Iho silo. ShaomphosJlOd Illallhll
lurvoy would COSI Iho d.volopel nOlhlng ond would bo complolod by gl.duoIO
lIud.ntl. sChollll, ond ptolossJonoll In IN liold who would bo donollno Iholl limo.
Sho lIol.d II tho 10ndscopo II d/SIUlbod, lhon dOlo would bo lost. Sho SIIossodlhot
tho IlndSCOpo OJ II o~/SII In 199211 OJ clitlcollO Iho HABS documontollon oils IN
SIIUClutO 111011. Nuh urgod lho Commllslon 10 oncourogo lho dovolopoI to nOI
ptomlluloly .1101 Ihls silO. Nosh o~plolnod lhat Ihll Is not 0 lug 01 1'111 botwo.n two
oppos'no pllllu .nd tho would halO 10 SOl II 101 up OJ . prOSllVollon/.t VOIIUI
dovolopoI Icontrlo, Sho slIouod Ihlllho prOSOlVOllon/ll 110 lIv1no 10 bonolltlho
communlly OJ I whol..
In IOJPonS. 100 quosllon Itom SCOII. Mlklo Indicolod thll 0 glodino perm/I had boon
oppllod 101 by Iho oppllconl, bul lhal II curronlly dOli nOI comply wllh Iho Codo.
SCOI\ uld that Council oPPtovol would bo noodod ptlOl 10 0 grad/no pelmll bolno
Issuod to Iho oppllconl, Nuh uld IhalOI 0 minimum lho would Ilko to havo Iho HABS
toom on Iho lilO bolOlo Iho 10ndscopo II o/lOlOd, SCOII ouutod Nuh Ihll tholl would
bo no gliding, '~covollon, 01 ollerlllon ollho onllll Ildgo unliloller tho CQY!IClI aCI!
on ~ ~l!l!I~atlon. He .IIoma Ihit ii gloding pelmlt would nOI bo ISluod unlil .1101
Council oPPlovol, In IIsponso 10 0 quOS lion 110m MkJo, Noth sold II pOlliblo Iho
would Ilko to hlvo 0 cOndillon 01 opploval bo Ihlt tho HABS loam I. ol/owod 10 do Iholl
wOlk In OIdlllO documonllho 1110, AI Scoll's IIquUI, Nash lIv1owod Iho HABS
proglom. Sho uplolnod thol II Is 0 progllm by which hlstOllc sllll 011 documontod
.nd thot Iho dOlO II modo ovailoblo 101 lUlulI sCholor/y IlS011Ch, In IIlponso to 0
qUOlllon 110m Gibson, Nosh Ololod Ihol sho IIquOSlod pelmlsslon 110m Iho dovolopel
Ipplo~/mlloly Ilvoo to louI wooks ogo 10 01/01'1 Iho HABS loom 10 documonllho 1110
ond hIS not YOlllcolvod . Illpenso, In IISponsO 10 0 qUOlllon 110m SCOll, Nosh sold
Ihot lho documonlollon would Includo IIno dlowlnos ollho sllo,lncludlno lho SIIUClulo
ond Iho 10ndlClPO, Sho sold planllnos would bo Idonllllod ond locolOd ond
photoglophl would bo lokon. Sho Indlcolod tho IIsullS ollho Sludy would bo Itolod
Ollho Llbroly 01 Congross ond would bo Ivolloblo 10 Iho gonerol public 1001l1OOIch.
f1oul. DI.ndl. 8~4 N. (lUbe" Sllenl, .lOlod lhal would liko on uplonlllon IS 10 Why
thOlo dovoloPolI COMOI SOl lhot Iho house ond 10ndscope would bo on mot 10 Iho
dovolopmonl, Sho notod Ihol Mike Hodgo usod Iho lonco 01 SummllIKllkwood 01 on
0110110 his dovolopmonl on Ihallllo. Sho sold thai In this slluollon Iho dovolopolI
011 u,'ng Iho hlslOl/c noturo ollho "10 IS I lOOIon Ihol WOuld plovonl pooplo 110m
buying InlO this dovolopmonl. Sho luggoslod lhot tho o~lllIng SIIUClulo could bo usod
II 0 homo 101 lomoono who likos 10 gOldon, 0 community building, 0 cOlolakOl'1
cOllogo, 0' 0 gUOII houlo. Sho nOlod Ihol whon lhoy pUlchosod Iholl homo on Iho
nOllh lido 110m Blank & McCuno, lho 1I0ltOll u.ad tho hlslOllcol conto~t 01 0
nolghborhood II 0 lolling polnl. Sho IndlcolOd thol now Ihoso limo 110/1011 011 laying
lhot tho hlsloric conlo~t Is bod 10' lhll porllculor dovolopmont, Sho said Iho WOuld like
10 know why lho dovoloporl Oil pulling tho bUldon on othol pooplo 10 movo this
buildino whon romoval Itom lho 1110 would only moko lho dovolopors 1001 lass ouillY,
,
{
59/
.
- -
-
1
, I
- -
PtonnlnQ . ZonIno Commission
MIlch 5. 1992
P.go 15
SCOll nOlod lhotl/lNs .ppllc.tlon I. donl.d. lhtlO wOllld be no gu."nl.o lho! Iht
house would 10m. In on tho silO. H. suomd thtl Ihll d.pondl on lho ownelahlp .nd
dovelopm.nl pllno. Ho Slid ho hot boon .dvlsod by lho Clly AIIOtnoy lhal donl.1
basod .nUloly on IOI.nUon 01 tho IIIUCII.WO nIN, silO would be dllllcult to dol.nd.
Ho up/.lnod Ih.l with lho condillonel lOloMQ. tho dovolopol must.gloo to In 01 the
condillonl prlOt 10 Council closing lho public holling, Ho sold lho dov,'opol hal OPlod
nol 10 hop lho ItNC1I.WO In III Cl.Wlonl plopoul. BI.ndl uld the II o~tromoly
dluppolnlod with tholo IOIIIOtI who hove luch e high IOpullllon In low. Cily. ScOll
uld tho City could do uBl.ndl wlsllollllOWI Clly hod 0 hili Otic Iondmolk Otdinonco.
~, IlIlfd Ihtllhls silO hal h1S1OtIc IIIOS 1M! WOIO slgnlllc.nl .t the
limo lho H.ddocks purchas.d lho prOPOlly, Sho IlImod thaI olomonll 01 lho
londsc.po c.n be prosolYod. Sho sold lho HASS 111m c.n Indlc'1010t tho benolit of
oil whal trOOI 010 on tho silO .nd Whal 11011 con bo plOIOlYod, Sha uld Ihll would
01101'1 .11 01 us 10 havo I port II nOI on ollho H.ddockl' d/o.m,
i
I
I
1
I
i
I
I
l
,
I
!
,
l
t
Roboll Sayrll. 4 I 8 Hutchllon SIIOOl. IlIlId lhalll lho Ipocl.1 colloctlon II lho
UnlvelSlly 01101'1' Llb/.,y. ho ,ovlowod MI. H.ddock'l wllllnol, Ho sold Ihtllho mOle
lhat ho I.ornod. lho mOl. Inulgulno ho lindl Hoddock to be, Ho nOlod lhal whllo
H.ddock 1'111 .n oplnlonelod mln, ho 1'101.110 ..nslllvo Ind Inlellltlno, SlylO Hid
that I opocl.llnlllell 10 hlm. II In OSIoy wIllIon In 1904 lhat 1'111 glvon II I
CN!!t!!lu gllt!e;! H.dd~k', f,lend. and IIIIIUy. Ho o~p1alnod wt tho omy gool b.ck
to April 10. 1856. to wh.n Hoddock lIrslo"lvod In 101'10 Cl,ly, Ho up/olned lhtt tho
....y tolkl obout Hoddock'l 1I11t ulp out on lho plIl/'O .nd II1I dllclibod u
.ccur.loly.1 Hoddock could havo doscllbod It, S'VlO llromd that H.ddock wII.n
Intollstlng mon ond Ihtt thOl011 mOlolhat c.n be lound oul .bout him. Ho suggoslod
Ih.t thaoxlstlng IUUClulI could be usod II on ...ot 101 1M IIIlghbOlhood 10 ke.p II
110m becomlno Iusllnothol condominium dovelopmonl, Soyll sold thaI ho hopos lhal
In lImo wo could wOIk out on ogllomonl with 011 01 tho pooP/o Inlerolled In Ihlllnue
10 Inow tho house ond oroundl to be plOSDlYed. Ho I.'d lhal mOlo con be loomed
ObOUl lho conlllbullon 01 tho Hoddockl 10 CUI clly ond our 11010,
II10mn Bol~lldoll. 306 MollO" Court. nOlOd lhat tho HomobulldOl" Alsoclotlon look
gllot polnl to Ilk tho Commlsalon to Uusllhem 10 do Iho Ilghl III/ng. Ho lold Ihll
lOOms to bo lha oPPOltunlly 101 0 dovelopor 10 do tho light lhino ond Iho Commlnlon
should 01101 thom tho OPPOIlunlty to do 10, Ho lUOgoslod Ihot . pion could be ovolvod
that prOSOIYOS Iho houso on Iho 1110 .nd Illmogin.tlvo .nd will prOSOIYO 0 pOlllon 01
lha hislOly Ihol moy havo beon oVOllookod by a 01101 mony 01 us.
Pat Ec~haldl. II I 4 N, linn SlIeot. IlOlod thaI basod on hel rosoo,ch, Haddock hos
bocomo a vOly 1101 pOISon 10 hOl, Sho Indicolod lhollholl II. ph01OQloph 01 him in
his olllco II Old Copltol. Sho luggoslod Ih.t devolopmonl 01 this p/OpOlly Ihould be
ollowod. bul wllh cOlloin consldOlatlons, Sho lold Iho 10011 Iho house Is vllY
Impollonl ond consldOlatlons ond IOloguo,ds mull be pUlln ploco.
Pubflo dllcuulon 1'111 clOlOd 01 10:40 p,m,
51/1
,
.
. - -
, .
- -
Plonnlng & Zonlno COf11mlsslon
Milch 5, 1992
Pogo 16
SCOtl load 0 momo d.lod Morch 5, 1992, "om tho Clly AIIOInoy to lho PloMlng ond
Zonlng Commlsslon,
Cook movod 10 OpplOVO Ihe flndlngl 01 publlo nood which wo~d lond oupportlO 1M
Clly ond ownor onllrlno Inlo e condltlonollonlng Igllomlnl, II plovldod by locllon
41405, Codo 01101'10, with lho CommissIon flnclng ""I lho ploposod OPDH pion hol
cloltod I publlo nood 10 Plllorvolhe Hoddock/Blullwood Lono II 0 hlllorlo I1111ClUIO,
which publlo nood hol bton clloctly coulod by 1M IOIonIng, MoolI IptclflcaJIy
commontod 1M Commllslon flndl:
1, Tho Hoddock/Blullwood Lono houso hoo slgnlnconllmmotorle/ hlllorlo volut 10
lho cltllOnl oliOi'll City, duo 10 III OlChllOC1UIII '1IlUlOlond II In oumple 01
IIchltoct Andlow Jockson Downoy'llondlcopo dOslgn ond II ono 01 1M low
luch IlIucluroo lhlt OXIIII Will ollho MllslSlJppl:
i
I
,
\
I
l
I
,
I
2. Tho plopolod OPDH.5 plln onllclpoloo .lthol domoGtlon 01 PIOlOrvotlon ollha
houso by lomovol 10 onolhol locI lion: ond
3, AI I d1loCl IlIull 01 lho plopolod OPDH lOlonlng, Iho Commllslon nndl lhot
pIOlOrvollon 01 lho hoUIO II 0 publlo nood, which his bton d1l1clly coulod by
Iho plopolod IIl0nlng:
4, BlIOd on locommondollonl "om lho Frlondl 01 Hlllorlc Plolorvollon, lho Clty'o
H1110rlc PIOIOrvollon Commllslon ond Iho Complohonslvo PIon, Ihl Commllslon
flndl lho City hal 0 volld publlo nood 10 pluorvo ond plOIOCl lho Dlullwood
House II on Int.glol part ollowI CllY'1 IIchllOCIUlII hlllory Ind lh1t ono
mOlhod 01 pIOlOrvlng Iho housoII IOmovol 10 onothol silO, PIOIOllbly 10 I rU1I1
01 counlry oOlllng:
5, Convolloly, lho CommIssion nnd. thaI Pluorvotlon ollho house by pormlltlno
d.molltlon 01 lho house 10 not In lho publlo IntOllll, ond lhol IOmove/lo,
lhlllloro,lho PlIlOIIOd mOlhod 01 pIOlOrvollon 10 SIllily Iho publlo'o nood to
plOIOCl 101'10 Clty'o OlchlloctulOl hlllory: ond,
6. Tho Commllslon Iullhol nndl lhol roqulrlng lho PIOPOrty ownol 10 plUOrvl Ihe
house by IImovlllo onolhll slto OndJOI 10 lolloln 110m do moll lion 01 lho hou"
101 II 10111 onl yoorllom Ihl do to 01 CouncO opprovaI 01 iho nnll OPDH plan
10 I IODlonoblo condltlon 10 Impolo on lho ownol In ordol 10 "IIlly Iho publlo
nood. 01 hlllollo PIOlOrvltlon d1roclly cou"d by Iho ownor'. plopolod
lelonlng.
Bovblllg IOcondod,
Cook o~plolnod thai whol ho IIkos about Iho dovolopmont Is Iho plosorvotlon 01
gloonbolls and IIalllysloms, Ho nOlod Ihala trail olong Ralslon Clook would Iiko
SCOII Boulovard to HlckolV Hill Park, Ho said ho would o~pocladdltlonal dovolopmonl
In lho aru 10 conUnuo lhls 11011 syslom, Cook Indicolod lholln his mind, Iho morlt.
1
5'11
.
. -
-
1
Plonnlng . Zoning Commission
MIlch 5, 1992
P.go 17
ollho "gumonl on plOIOIVOtion 01 Iho house aro irrOplOOChablo. Ho 1.ld IIII 0
queSllon 01 who plys 'nd how ond II Iho fufl burdon con bo pI.cod on tho dovelopoI.
Ho Hid It OPpollO II COMOI. H. Hid lhal IIlhoro II onough commllmonl In Iho
communlly, lhon POlhaps lha house cln be plOSOIV.d, but nOI on Ihll silO,
BovbjolO Indlcolad Ihls Is I silu.tion 01 volld compoling InlOIUl, Sho slid Iho
opploclolOl lho findinol ond hopos Ihoy will be opplovod. Sho eXplOIIod Iho hopo
lhot .omolhlno could be wOlkod oulln lho InlOllm 10 IIsolvo lhallluotion.
Gibson Indlcolod ho I. puul.d OliO why no IUPonSO Itom IN dovelopel 1'101 locolvod
by NOIh IIgllding NI lOquoSllO polmll HABS documonl.tion 01 lhlllllO. Hlppol
lospondod Ihlt ho wOllld be mOto Ihln happy 10 hlvo Ihom look .llha SilO, bul ho
10011 Ihlll. e 10P.rololssue 110m whot tho Commission Is consldOllno, H.ppol 10YI
lhal ho hal done nOlhlno 10 halm Iho sito.
Gibson o~pI.lnod Ih.1 ho c.n IOmombel 11111 soolno Ihls house Opplo~lm.loly 30 YOlII
.go, H. Hid ho hal olways mOlVol.d 0111 olthough N had only lOon II from e
dlslOnco, Ho uprossod hi. 10011110 IhAllholl II /uSI lomolhlno lholl wllh log old 10
Ihll houlO ond III peslllon on IN b1ull. Ho Indlcolod lhal somo 01 lh1. loollng will
Inosclpobly be lost ond Hid ho II I.d oboul thil .Ituotion, Gibson Slid tho II 011 nOI
mony lhlnol In 101'10 Clly like thll SllUCluro, Ho Indicllod lhol ho dool nOlloollho
house cln IUCCOlllully be movod becouse pall 01110 Ilgnificanco Is 0 comblnollon 01
whoro /1111. ond 11$ W/IQYl!!jlngt, ,Ho l!~J!/'!ll!d thll he does nOleecopllMllho 11'10
ollarnot/VOI 110 10 ollhOl 101llho houso down 01 to movo II, H. omphUlzod Ihlllhoro
I. 0 OIlOt dool 01 mlddlo ground botwoon Ihoso 11'10 IltOlnotivU, Ho notod Ihlt III. .
posslblo to modify IhalllO, but thai dool nOI moon Iho house noods 10 bo lomovod
110m lho silO, Gibson lnillc.tod th.1 ho hll I bulo ploblom with Ihls Issuo bocluse
ho Is not convlncod Ihlt oVOlythlng hIS beon dono wllhln IOlIon 10 IOVO tho house,
H. uplolnod lhat ho had ploviously .uggoslod 10 tho dovoloPII IOp.rollng 011 0
.0cUon ollho land wllh tho houso 110m Iho b.lonco ollhallack. Ho lold Iho IOcllon
wllh tho houso could lhon be loId 01 . 1I0sonlblo pllco ond Ihls would open tho
poSllblllly IhAllho homo could be pUlchosod ond IISl0l0d 101 somoono to Ilvo In. Ho
Indlcllod Ihls opllon his nOIIl.lly boon dlscUSlOd, Ho lold thai somo plollt mlghl be
lotogono by Iho d.volopel, bulltlossod Ih.llho InVOllmonl could bo IIgelnod,
Gibson Indlcllad thot ho hll not h.d .n oPPOllunlly 10 dlscuSl Iho logal opinion 000
hol nol YOI loon II In wrlllng, Ho Slid ho 11111 hOlld Iho logal opinion allhll moot/no
ond lold ho lools lh1. Is on un,ccoploblo 101 01 cllcumslancOlln which to moko 0
doclslon thlt could possibly be Iho most ImpOllonl docislon ho's boon liked to moko
Ilnco ho', boon on Iho Commission. Gibson IndlCOlod Ihol 11111. posslblo 10 nogot/.to
on orrlngomonl luch II hll oppllont/y .lloody boon nogoll.IOd wllh Iho dovolopOI,
Ihon II Ihould bo posslblo 10 nogot/.IO lomo Olhol kind 01 .rr.ngomonl. Ho 1.ld one
opllon mlghl bo to pUllho cOllogo 101 1010 01 0 pllco Ih.1 wouldn't loqullO en oul 01
pockolloss on Iho pili ollho dovolopoI to 100 II10moono would pUlchllO ond 1011010
Iho homo, Gibson sold II no one coosos Ihl. opporlunlly wllhln 0 101S0nablo porlod 01
t/mo,lhon Iho dovolopmonl Could plocood wllh aomo sodnoss on his pell, bUI wllh tho
convlCllon Ih.1 all h.d boon dono Ihol could 10 holp plOSOIVO this Plopolly. Gibson
5~1
.
-
1
- , I
- -
PlOMno & Zon/no CommlssJon
Milch 5, 1882
Pogo 18
i
I
I
j
I
,
I
,
~
j
o~plolnod lhal ho dool 1001 Ihls II 0 vOly losponalblo dovolopmonl ond would be on
...ot 10 tho commlMllly, HOWOVOl, Gibson Slid Ills nOI posalblo 101 him 10 oddlou thl.
Issuo wllhoul lho OPPGIlunity to cons/dOl tho logol opinion In mOlo dOloil. He II/mod
lhot ho 10011 It II 0 vory nll/OW opinion ond doos not lo.vo loom to conlldOl Othll
Optlonl lhot oxlst.
Olblon moyod 10 tob!o Z'1I1 10 ond 8.8218, D10rh oocondod. The motion llOod on
· 3.3 YOlO, ISCOII, Rold and Cook yotln8 In 1110 ntgotlvo,'
Ololh o~pt'ssod h%groomont wllh Glblon ond sold Ih"ooll nOl onough comptomls.
Ing hol liken pI.co. Sho I.'d silo would Ilko 10 .00 moro discussion 01 tho ISlUGs
belOlo silo could YOlO poslllvoly on Ihls 110m.
SCOl\ Indlcolod ho ogrolllhotlholl 011 mlddlo position., Ho nOlod lhot ollh. 'OSI
Commlls/on mooting Iho ChilI rovlowod opllonl 100lho dovolopo/to InvOltlgolO. Ho
o~p/oln.d Ihll Iho Issue comos down 10 lhoso options being occoplod by lho
doYOlopo/, SCOII IlIlOd Ih.tln lha PIli ho hll sold lhal 110 doos nOl 100111 Is
occoptoblo 10 locolvo wlltlon logol opinions on 1110 nlghl 010 mooting. HOWOVOl, SCOII
nOlod lholln Ihls COIOlho CllY AltOlnoy'1 ollie. hal o~tonslvoly discussod lh1slssuo
01 tho houso ond sold ho knows Ihll OlhOlI on lho CommIssion Oil nOI pIIVV 10 tho
lomo dlscuSllonl II tho ChilI Wllh lOglld 10 IhIIISWt, ~Olt /Opotlcd that tho City
Auomvy InlOtmod him vorboliy Ihlt hol olllco would hlvo dilllcully dolOndino 0 don/II
buod on II10ntlon 01 tho houlo 01111 prOlonllocollon.
SCOl\ lold ho won't Sly lhotlhoro OIon'l othOl ollOlnotlvII, bul ho would IImlnd lho
CommissIon thot whllo Ihoy hovo lho POWOl to IIcommond 0 COndltlonl1 roIOn/ng, II
Ihould 101101'1 tho Clly AtlOInoy's IIcommondollon tho I It dool /1111 with Iho Issuo 01
p/Olorvlno Iho house In o log Illy dolonslblo mlMOI, Ho Sllomd lhot tho motion to
IpprovO Ihls 110m would be lubloCllO 0 numbol 01 ISSUIS, luch OIlho PIlSOrvotlon 01
11101, site dlsrlnco II lho Inlllsoctlon, glodlng pormll oPprovol PIIOl 10 Council
consldorotlon ond consorvation oosomonl bolng OVlllho ontlll 100 YOlllloodplaln,
ptovlslon 101 I wllkwoy oosomonl wllhln Iho consorvltlon onomonl, Idditlonol
wolkwoYI 110m tho lubdivlllon to lho conlolvallon ouomont ond I 101'101 U.omont
belno IIsolvod ptlOlIO Council consldllOtlon, Ho Indlcllod thot Iho Commission could
olso discuss IOqulllng tho HABS documonlollon ollho silO. Scolt ItlOmd Ihllth/I
Itom hol boon bolOlo Iho CommllSlon I/nco Oocombol ond It would loom 10 him 11111
lho Ilsuo ollllho dovolopoI II willing to SlvO lho houso on silO hiS Illoody boon
onSWOlld numOlous tlmOI,
Rold oold Iho would IIko 10 hovo Iho mOlulI hOldwoodl 10 Iho nOllh ond nOllhoul 01
Iho o~lltlng houso bo shown on Iho glod/ng plan. Sho olso Indlcolod Iho would IIko
to hlvo Iho nolO on Iho plan lhol laYI PIOlocllon ollho o~lstlng tlalS moy bo IIqulrod
dUII~g conllluctlon chongod 10 rood lhol such PIOlocllon 1'111I bo IIqulrod dUllng
consllucllon. Sho sold that IIlho house connOI be lOVod, Ihan OlloOlllho londlcopod
could bo PIISllvod, In IOsponlO to I quostlon lrom Gibson, Rold ao/d lhollhls WOuld
show mOlo apoclllcolly what 110" will bo PlOsOlVod Ind Ihoso Ihol 010 10 bo romovod.
5~1
,
. .-
- -
P1.M1no & Zonlno Commlsslon
MarCh 5. 1992
Poge 19
Glblon IIquOIt.d thot SCOII rOIOld Iho flndinol. Dlolks o_ploSlOd hOl og,oomonl.
Scollllllod tho rtndingl.
Glblon Indlcolod that ha would 1111I ~ko to soo 0 dilcusslon ollho olhar opUons 110m
lho dovoloptl. Ho IlImod lNI he does nOl oquolo moving lho Hoddock houso wllh
prOlorv.tlon, Ho uplo!nod IhallOt 111I1 IUSon ho will be voUno ogolnsl tho flndinol
to 01101'1 tlm.'Ot lhe Commission ond dov.loptl to UplOl. olhol OpUonl. DIOIkl askod
Illho IlIuctUle could be lorn down loon In lho luIUI.. ClvlsUonsen Itspondod INI
lholt would be no W'Y to block I domolillon ptlmll " Ihll limo, D10lkl .~p1olnod INI
tho would halo to ... thll happen simply 10 ond lulUlO discussion 01 111I1 ISluo.
Gibson Indlcol.d ho 10011 Ihll would be 0 tlloody becou.. lhall NI nOI yot boon In
opPO/tunlly to do on HABS ollho silO, Ho IOld ho Is complololy UIIIblo 10 UOOOllllOO
111I1 poslllon by tho dovolopel, Ho o~prossod hll foollno INI tho dovolopOl has IIkon
on oxllOmoly hAld nogolloUng posillon bec.use ho doOl nOI wonllO do whOI 0 vlly
1010' I.gmonl ollho commlMlilY wonlS 10 havo dono with 111I1 IIIUCturO. Gibson
Indlcolod he 10.ls lhallhll Iypt 01 nogoUollno POllulI musl be dull wllh In I IIko
mOMOI.
BovblOlg laid lNllho findings dOli wilh bOlh lha CIIY'o oUlhO/lly 10 p1oco condillonl
on thll 1I1onlno 000 Iho woy to 1I0ch 0 conclullon to Ihls Issuo, Sha nOlod lhat tho
CM YOOl period ollol! !OIlIe lIexlbilily.
Cook sold, ho fools Iho one y'Ol period glvOllndlvldual. lomO loowoy 000 provon" 0
sltuollon wholl lho d'voloptl con got 0 domolillon ptlmlt In lho nool lUtUIO, 5coII
.xplolnod lNl tho Clly AIIOInoy'o Olllco look.d ollho OPDH.5 pion lNt II cUllonUy
bolOlo lho Commllslon Ind vlow.d lho two ollOln.tlvOl thot .10 posslb/o flom Iho
pion, Ho sold lho Clly AIlOlnoy'1 Olllco 0110 lookod ollho posslblllly 01 e condlllon
01 IOvino lhalllUCIUlO on tho silO, H. o~p1.lnod INl Iho Clly Allornoy vOlbolly
InlOlmod him thol hll olllco would h.vo dllllcully dolondlno Iho 101101 lypo 01
condillon. Ho I.id lhal unlOII lha dovolopel comOllolwold wllh onolhOl option, lhl.
,., problomollo sltuotlon, SCOIl Slid Ihot ho COMOI 10y lhat Illho Commission 1'10111
on thll Issuo, lha dovoloptl will Chanoo hll pOslllon, Ho stlOssod thot lho dovolopoI
II willing 10 IIvo with Iho flndlnos ond lhol 0 condltlonol lOZon/no ogroomont would
conllln bOlh Iho Ilmollomo Ind would be conclillonod on Iho d.volopOl ogroolng to
01101 tho houso to tho City, Ho said lh11 would bo IIqullOd bocouso no ono olse N'
como 10lwold 10 occopt lho prOPlltV. nollhOllho Frlonds 01 HI.IOIlc PlOsorvotlon nOl
Iho 101'11 City HlslOllc Pruorvatlon Commllllon, SCOIl nOlod lhallho dovolopOl hOl
oglood 10 donolo 15,000 towordl tho coli 01 relocotlon ollho hOUlO, Ho o~plolnod
Ihol III olhor IssuOl would bo condillonod on Iho oPPlovol ollho OPDH pion.
Gib.on sold ho Is lliIllnlOlOSlod In whOlhll 01 nOllhoro has boon 0 bono lido 011011 10
10vO Iho houlO on Iho 1110. Ho o~preSlod concOln with Iho lor mOl ollho logol opinion
01 1'101 IIcolvod by lho Commission ollhi. mooUng,
Tho mOllon 10 OpplOYO Iho IIndlngl pDl"d on 0 5.1 volo IQiblon voting In lho
nogotlvol,
1
5~1
.
-
-
, ~
1
P1'nnlng . Zon/ng CommllsJon
Milch 5, 1892
P.go 20
Ro/d movod 10 'PIltOVO z.&110.nd S.11128.111t lOIOn/ng 012800 Roch'lIer Avollllf
110m ID'RS 10 OPDH.!I.nd lilt Iltonmlnory lolgo Sct/o Roald.nllO/ D.yo/opm.nl .nd
P1.nn.d D.volopmonl Housing pI'/11 lor Roclltslor Hal., . 32'iln/l losld.nllo/ doyllop.
monl 011 on opptoalm'le 27 'CIt sll' loc.lod on tho nonh side 01 ROClltltOl Avollllf
001101 SI, Them.. Coun. lubfoCllO . conclllonal lOIOn/ng ogrOOmonl pt!0I10 Council
'40um/no tho publlo lIt.rlng .nd "/d cOndlllon. .. IoIIow.: The CommllslOllflnd.
Ihot lilt lO~rlng 1110 /lfoporty OWlllr to lltolOrvetho hoUIO by romovo/ 10 onothor III.
ond/o, 10 lolllln Irom d.mollllon 01 1110 hoUIO lor '110'" one VOl' 110m lilt dolo 01
final OPDH'nd LSRD 'P/lfovo/ by 1110 CIty COIIlClI I. e lOOIOnolllo cOnclllOll 10 lmpooo
on tho OWIIII In Old., 10 l.lllly Ihe publlo lII.d 01 hI.lorlo lltolOrv.llon IIIOClly C'Ultd
by Ihe oWnot'. /lfopoltd rOlon/ng. "'0 lurtlltl cOnclllonod on the dovo/opo, .gloo/no
10 Olio, lilt H.ddock Hou.. 10 Ihe Clly .nd conlrlbullng 11I,000 lOW lid. 1110 movlno
'nd ItloC.llon COil' 01 ol'd hoUIO, Furth." lilt mollon 10 'pptove I. IUlijocllo .
HA8S documonl.l/on 01 lho 1110 10 be mUluoIly .glood 10 by J'n NOIh .nd tho
dovolo/llll '1 10 lho 11m. wlltn II I. 10 occur, Iho pI.n IdonllfyJng lh. m.turo
ho,dwOOd. nonh .nd nonhwolI 01 Iho hou.o. .nd 1110 nolo on 1110 pI'n ohould ro.d
Plolocdon will be lOqullOd dutlng con.lruellon, Clly FOIOlIO, .nd Iho PI'nn/no 'nd
Commun/ly Dov,/opmonl O/roCl01 oPlltovo/ 01 mOlhodl 01 lltolOrvodon 01 doslltllle
m.lulo 11001 Idontlllod 10' Ilt'..rv.don on Ihe pI.n .nd lomovll 01 .ny 11000 on 1110
1110. silo 1I11.nce .1 Lorch lone .nd RochOlIO' Avonuo beIng IOIoIvod wI", Iht Pu!lIIG
WOlk, Dop.nmonl, gllcSnO /lI1m.l1 b!/n; lUl/filjitlot io touncD IIn.l consldolldon.
100'Viif lIoocfp/.ln be/no covolod by I con.orv.don O..omonl.IltOvlslon 10' 'lon,Iool
o..omonl.nd o'ghHool WllkwlV beIng Iltovldod wll"'n Iho conlOrv.don o..omont
.nd IOld wollw.y 10 be Inlld.d 'nd conSI'UCIOd "101 Iho Idondllc.don 01 the
w.d'ndl .nd 'Plltovo/ by tho Clly .nd Iho m.lorl., 10' conSlruedon ohould be .ltho,
Ollvol 0' UmOllono 'Cloon/ng., lhol tho "wor ...omont be OIl.b11lhod Iltlor 10 Council
consldOlltlon 01 lh. IInll OPDH .nd LpRD pI.n, lhol In .dlldono/ W"kw.y 110m lilt
IId.wl/klhot ond. '1lhe 1'1011 holf 011110 culodo.o.o be Iltovldod 10' 'nd dod InlO tho
w"kw.y Iltoposod In Iho consorv.llon o..omonl .nd oold WoIkw.y be Inll.D.d no
"Ier lhon on. voor "ler IOIUlnco Ollho blildlno /lIImll 101 Ihe "" dwomng Un/l 'nd
Ih'l lho RIO Morsh.,'. 'PP'ov., 10' number. .nd loc.I/ono 01 1110 hydllnll be O,culod,
Cook IOcondod,
DIOIkl o~plolnod lhol Iho Oonola"y liklllho dovolOpmonl, bul lools thollho IIIUO 01
lho house hos nOI boon lully oddlollod. Sho 1IIOII0d thol sho hol nOI had tho
OPPOIlunlly 10 /lIIOonllly IIv/OW Iho Clly AllOlnov'. 10001 oplnlon Ind told lho Would
IIlher nOI VOIo In loyOt 01 lh11 110m unlil sha hol hid lhol OPPOItunlly.
Glblon nOlod thollholl II on O~IIOOtdlnarily 'ono 1111 01 condlUonl Ond lhol ho will VOIO
ogalnll Ihllllom lor lho lOOlons Ihol hovo alllody boon Il0tod.
Rold 'old Iho would bo vol/no In IOyor ollhls Itom pllmarily 100lho IIDlon thollho
clnnOI onvlslon Iho hou" IOmalnlno whoro It II ond moinloln/no lho 10011110 Ond
o~lsl/ng oppoaranco ollho IUlloundlng landscapo In conjuncl/on wIth lho houlo whon
you hovo dovolopment OCCulllng to tho north, ODSI ond soulh. Sho Illossod Ihol
dovOlopmonl will ConUnuo 10 Iho nOllh on Ihls Il0ClluIlhol north ond lhls will dOSllOY
Iho vlsla tho I Haddocks mUSI hovo enjoyod, She omphaslzod lhallho selling will havo
51/1
.
. -
- -
1
PloMlng & Zoning CommiSllon
~Ich 5.1992
pege 21
boon ollmlnolod. Sha uld lhal whllo Iho .oluUon II nOlldOll, .ha .gllod lhat lha
hou,o Cln be movod ond pul in on oreo whall II con be IOIIOIOd. Sho nOlod lhal II'"
can olso be loplantod to lOplOCO Ihoso thai ore losl. Sho lumod thaI IhI. has nOl
boon on my doclslon.
Cook uld thai II lomOonO who hal lponllivo YOI/I 01 hi. 1110 buvlno .nd n~lng up
old hOUIOS, ho Illomill., with lha economic Issu.. 01 lO.IOIollon, Holndlcltod ho ha.
gllYO doubt. II thll houso con be 1I11010d. Ho noted thot It lullollllom .X1l1me
phVllcol ond lunctlonol oblolosconco ond doubll thaI loslOlOUon II posslblo.
HOWOYOI, ho uld this II . doclslon lhalthould be up 10 lho ml/kotpl.co, Ho sold tho
dovolopel ollorlno f5,OOO Is I Sl1l1 In Ihll dlrocllon ond one VOII to find 0 lolutlon 10
e lIos0n0blo comptomlso. Cook o~pI.inod lhal ho would bo vOllng In I,VOf 01 lh11
110m,
Bovblllg Indicalod lhat sho likes lho pion ond tho lik..lho houso. Sho "Id IhAllllho
pion Is apP/ovod, Iho house would no lonoor be localod whore Ilthould bo, Sho
uptmod tho hope lhal within tha nUl YOOI tharo 1'111I be 0 now 10lUno 100Iho houso
and Indlcalod Iho would bo voUng In lavOl ollho pion.
Rold lold tho Is confldont Ihollho 11001 thallho Hoddocks plontod will bo sovod Ind
moybe IholO would be loom In Iho dovolopel'o POCkOlbook 101 I commomOlallvo
placquo 10 IdonUly lho oroa.
Scott oskod Diorks Ind Gibson to 111101010 Iholl reasons 101 YOllno agolnsl lh1s 110m..
Dlorks o~plllnod that whilo Iho liklltho dovolopmont, tho 10011 tho Issuo ollho houso
II untosolvod, Sho sold tho Commission recolvod a gll01 dOli ollnlOlmotlon 110m both
tho publiC Ind Iho City AttOlnoV'1 Olllco lhat Iho would tiko 10 haYO mOlo tlmo to
olllmllolo tho InlOlm.Uon, Gibson sold ho ogllll wllh Dlllks Ind ho II also cOllCllnod
with Iho flndlnos ond lhallho Commission was unoblo to soo thom In wlltton 101m,
Ho notod thatlho Commission Ilso IIcolvod 0 glOol do.1 ollnpul from Iho publiC II
this mOIling Ind hOl boon unoblo 10 plOCOSS It, Ho stlOssod thai ho lools lhlt nOl
ovoly loosonoblo 011011 has boon modo to IOVO tho houso on tho 1110 Ind lOlonllon on
Iho .110 II 0 bottor ollornoUvo Ihon 10 movo 1110 onOlhal loco lion.
ScolI.,ld thaI ho would bo voUng In llvOl ollhls 110m. Ho sold thai ovon lhough thll
II 0 mOllon that oppoo,. to hAvo Iho lUPPOII 01 0 malOlilY 01 tho Commission, thoro
hovo boon common" modo concorn1no tho lock 01 accommodaUon 10 Ihoso who wonl
to savo Iho house by tho dovoloporl. Ho II/usod thai logoldloss 01 whOI Iho
Commission docldos, ho hos conslslonUy IOmlndod mombors ollho public Ihallhoy
1'111I nood to odd/us this Issuo at Iho Counclllovol.
Tho motion colllod 4.2 IDlllks ond Glblon yoUng In lho nogaUvol.
2, Public discussion 01 a ploposallo omond Zoning Oldlnanco Socllon 36. I 5lcIl4110
pormltloasod parking by rollglous InsUlUllons locolod In RM. I 4 5 01 PRM zones,
Tho 11I11 lOPOII dalod JanuolY 16, 1992, wos onlOlod Inlo lho locord.
Sill
,
I
(
I'
I
\
!
~
t
.
f
I 3,
~
I
~.'
,
"
I
1
~,:
p,
,
':,
i
?'
~~,
j;
f
. .
1
PloMlno . ZonIno Commllslon
Mlrch 5, 1992
P.go 22
Publlo cllcuulon 1'101 opened 01 11:53 p,m,
~ Monson slol.d 11101 haltols Ihls Is 0 good ogloomonllhal would benefit bolh
GIOII. Dol Luthoron Church ond Iowa City. Ho 1~p1olned IlIotlt oddllssos bolh lhe
unlque neodl 01 church porklno ond tho CIIY'I nood 101 downlown parklno, Ho sold
thla .IIollQOmlnl 1'1111 onow 101 p10m to be Ivoll.blo In 0 parklllQ lot durlno work1no
dOYI to the public becouso lho mO/OIlty ollhe polklno .pocos only 10qulll church use
on tho wookond'lnd ovonlllQl, HI told Ihll ogloomont would not roqulll the church
to ptovlde tho lpom 10 thaI In lho futurl lhey 1'111I be ovolloblo lor lha church If
nemsory. Monson told tllol he ogloos with the doclslon reached by Ita II In
dotolmlnlno lho numbol ol.pocos 10 be lo.olVod lor lha church.
Public d1lculslon 1'101 dOlOd II 11:55 p.m,
Cook movod 10 OppIOV. an omondmonllo lho Zonlng Oldlnonco 80c1lon 36.15101141
to pelmlt Imod pltklng by longlous In.1Ilu1lons IOC010d In Iho RM.1 45 01 PRM lonos,
Rlld oocondod,
Cook .old he couldn't be mOlo In 10vOI 01 sharod porklng, howovOI,ltla nOI .rollgloua
purpose to 10010 porklllQ ond thalli i commllclol uso, Iho plopony should be lub/.ct
10 ptopolly IIX,
The mo1lon cOlltld 5.1 ICook vOllng In Iho nogl1lvol,
Public discussion 01 lho .ummoly IIpon 101 Iho RochOlIOl Vlllogo Condomlnluml
PloMOd Dovolopmont Houslno jlIoposol, 0 1 5.unll, IOsldonllol dovolopmonl ploposed
on lho opplo~lmoto 3,4 OCII IIICl oll.nd localod In Iho loulhwost quodlont 01 tho
InlOllOCllon 01 Rochollll Avonuo Ind SCOII Boulovard,
Mulch rovlowod Iho slollropOIt dalod March 5, 1992,
Publlo dllcu.slon 1'101 oponod II 11:59 p,m.
ThOll 1'101 nono.
Public dllcusslon 1'111 do"d ot11 :59 p,m,
Glblon movod 10 OpplOVO lho.ummory IIport 101 lho Rocho'llI VlII.go Condomlnluml
PI.nnod Dovolopmont Housing PIOPOIOI, Rold lOCondod, Tho motion cOlrlod 6'(),
Q1HER BUSINESS:
1, Aooolnlmonl 01 P1annlnn and Zoning Commission ROOIOSBnlftllvo 10 tho Alloolt Zonloo
~,
SCOII oppolnlod Dlorkslo SOIVO In this copocilY.
5'1'
m I
\:.""
, .
~,
.
- - ,
1
PIJMlno . ZonIno Commission
~lCh 5. 111112
P.ge 23
Cook thlnkod lho CouncillOf N. 1I0ppo!nlmonll0 tho Commission,
6DJOU6t:lME~
Glblon moved to odjourn lilt moo ling ot 12:05 o,m, BovbjorO aocondod, Tho mOllon corrlod
8~ .
AM Bovbjolg, S.CIOIOry
M1nut.. lubmltlod by Mily Jo Noll
t&lu....
51/1