The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About1992-04-14 Bd Comm minutes ,~'Q~) nn-'Y3 - - UBRARY BOARD MIN\1I'FJ SPIlCIAL BOARD MI!Il11NO Of MARCIl 31, 1992 01:00 PM IN 2ND FLOOR AD~UNI5TRAllvn CONFllJUlNCn ROOM BOARD MEMBERS PRliSIiNI': Tom Oclnwl, Slephen O~, Anno IlMar:lvc, Jerl lIolwt, PhIlip Ilubblnl, Ouy LundqulJt, K1l11y Moyen, Anno SpellCCt, Kent Snlm STAFF PRliSIiNI': SUWl Cn/" Lolly Eaen, M~~ !.ulworr, Debblo S1Ies Dwl CoultJlOy, ~IJ)'Or o( Iowa Chy, M1rJO Ounock, Pms CllIozea, 1I~lher Woodin, Ccd.u R.splds OUellO MI!Il11NO WAS CAWlD TO ORDI!R AT 01:10 PM 0TI1IlRS PRliSIiNI': 1110 only hem on lho IIClW ns I'C$Umptlon o( dlJcuulon o( lho FY93Johnson CoulllY conlrxt (or Ubruy 1C/V1cca. Swaim reviewed (or lho Boudtho cvenu slncll our IulBoud mect1n, on Mmh 19, 1992. Followln,h, upon rccommencbllon o( tho 'l'Nllccs, 11eu<< ns dtaIIed and ICIlllO Clwlcs Duffy, CJWrpcnon o( tho Boud o( Su~lJon, Mmh 23, 1992. Swaim 1wI, by lhIJ meedn" received I rcsponso ~led Mmh 30, 1992, 1110 leucr IlAled lhU IIncc lho CounlY IwI an I,RCmCnIIn pbee willi tho CIIY, dultho County Boud was u~bJo 10 reJpOnd (omWIy to tho IlRCJIIClll o( Mmb 2, 1992 lhU tho Ubruy Ikwd proposed. Duffy IUUCSled I&llho Chy Anomoy and County 1.llomoYI meet to work oullho Icplltlcs o( lho IlfCCIIIcnl culmltly In pbee. 1110 Boud dlJcusscd IhIJ response and rell ccnaln 1~ISIncc lho IlIomoYI ~\'O dl~,rccd a1rt.1dy l~llhoy would be u~blo 10 Rnd I solution and 1~llCncJOlbllon would be ncccssary . l'oulblUtlcs welO dlscusscd IUch u cxplorin, our Icpl options whh lho City Allomoy Includln,scckln,I declaralory Jud,emcnl under an anllclplled bracb o( conlllCl. 1110 Ikwd would aIJo Uko 10 know W~I our position should be on July I I( 1M conlllCl prico II ROC mel. 1110 Boud ns ulWl1moulln lu position WI cxccpl ror recelvln, MilO" tho only IcccplAblo proposal 10 (u litho 0110 In which lbo Boud asked ror S208,526In FY93 tied 10 l!lnulO yw plymck and dull new or mlJcd conlllCt mllJl be ncaot1aled bcrOlO IC/Vlco 10 Nrall'CJldcnu can be orreRd (or FY94, An)'lhln,leu JCOfWlII.zcs tho Boud'I ob\lplloRJ 10 10wI Chy I'CJldcnu who VOIcd ovcrwhclmln.ly 10 IUpport lho \lbrary levy Wi (1\1. 1110 Ikwd II anxIOUllO RIOlvo IhlllllAller Ilnco 10WI Chy and Johnson CounlY Nrulllbruy UlClIllO cxpectln'l'CJloRd IC/Vlccs July I and prcpmlloRJ need 10 be proceedln,. 77f i I i ; I , I i i ! , _..,n_ , . , ' 1 ~. , I i , ! ~...,..:.~,"..,...,>. rl n -, '-I LI ' - - A mocJon wu nwlo and approved did' Swaim 10 dnI\ . Icn" 10 lbo ~ta)'Or sulllllWlzln.lbo Nck.round IIld ICdon or our IIoW up lhls polllt. Tbo leucr would Ibo IUIO our RqIICSIlO lbo CouncU ror wlswlco In explorlll. other Iq1I mnNlcs willi lbo City AlIorncy Includln.lbo possIbUlty or nIln.lmmcdblcly ror . decbnlory Judacmcm OCIlbo curmll conlnCt. a~/Lundqullt Tho IIoW Is w10us lO ruolvo lhls nuller IIncc Iowa City and JoIuuolI county Nl11/1bl1lY WCfj ifO QpcaIit. feitijffiJ iefiW July I iiii1 pr.pmtloiu r.mJ lO be fillXo.:dl.... McctIn. was adJoumcd at 5:20 pm. Il.vJnvcJa~ ManN Lubarorr ~ ~ \ ) , "--T"'-'"" .. l 77e ~'Q~J CI [I -, LJ 5 MINUTES . IOWA CITY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT MARCH 11. 1992 . 4:30 P.~l CIVIC CENTER COUNCIL CHAMBERS - ... .. '."1 ~ f.. . ,. ,,. f J 51'" " """', ~., ''w. .. .1......... MEMBERS PRESENT: Jo~ Borlll. Ernlo Olllor, Cathorlno Johnson, John Ponon MEMBERS ABSENT: Candaco Andorson . STAFF PRESENT: M410dy Rockwon, Brillll Mulch, Ollila Chrlsdllllson, Mat)' Jo Noll OTHERS PRESENT: Mlchaol OODly, Oono Brawn, Tom WordOrilsch, UncIa Bondorf, Cl4JI Konor, ChariOl Rupporl. Dick HOVOL Clauda HovIck. Paula Brandl Jan Dun, Bob Mlchaol, R1chord Paltschull ~: Chlllrporson POllon C4nod tho mooting 10 ordor al 4:38 p.m, ld2ll2n: Barto moved 10 approvo Iho m'nutOI ollho February 12, 1892, moo ling. Johnson lOCondod. Tho mol/on carrrod 3.0. I. ~,Publlc holltfng on a roquoslsubmlUod by 00110 Chl Fralornlty lor Q slJl.month exlonslon on tho Soplombor II, 1991, spoclal oxcoptlon approval by tho Boord of Ad/uslmonl lor proporty 10C4lod In tho RM.12 Zone 01314 Church Slrool. Rockwoll roportod thai 00110 Chi Fralornlty had roquostod B six month ox Ions/on 01 tho SoplOmbor II, 1091, spoclal oxcoptlon approval by tho Board lor proporty 10C410d In tho RM.12 zone 01314 Church Strool. Slllll concurrod with tho appllclIIIllhalthoro had boon s10nlftC4l1I pregross on the prolocllIIId nOlod thai a goooraphlcDlly dlsporsod. volunloor govornlng body, by lis naluro, makoslhe procm tlmo consuming. Slalt rocommondod thai tho slx.month oxlonslon 10 Soplombor 11, 1902, bo approvod. ~: f.1lko GoarY. Dolin ((b' Frnlornl~ slalod Ihal as tho oxplratlon dOlO 01 tho spocllll o.coptlon approachod. Oolto Chllound IIsllll noodOd to como 10 a consonsus with tho govornlng boDld regarding tho des~n allho addition. Ho nolod th/s procm waslDklng longor than expoctod. Thoroforo, Della Chi roquoslod Iho six month oxtonslon. ~: Barta nOlod thallho process may bo laking longor than antlc/palod. bulslrOllod Ihallho applicant had romalnod conslslonl with tho original plllllS, Pellon Indlcalod Ihala d1sporsod govornlno board would causo additional dolays. Johnson oxprossod Iho bollol Ihal this was a roasonablo roquosl. 77~ I I , ;.---- ---.-;-..- 1 [I [I -/ '-I b BOllld 01 ~ultmonl Mnrch 11. 1002 PlIOO 2 l&IlQti: Johnlon moved 10 opprovo 0 Ilx month oxtonslon 01 0 Soplombor 11, 1881, Ipoclol oxcopllon approVAl by Iho Board 01 Adlullmonllor proporly locatod In tho RI.l.12 zono al 314 Church Slroollo Soplomber 11, 1992. Borlo locondod. ll10 mollon carrl211. 2. EXC92-()00~. Public hontlng on !I !9qtJ911I!lbmllL"<l by Zlon W.Ilemn Ch::lch ler ;pedal oxcopllonllo pormll Oxpat\llon 01 0 rollglouslnstitullon and modificallon 01 pnrklng aroo Icroonlng roqultomonts lor proporly Iocalod In tho RM.12 zono 01617, 619, ond 621 E. DovonporL Rockwon rovlowod tho Board 01 Adjustmonl doell/on datod Septombor 11, 1001, ond tho ltoll ropert datod M.1rch ", 1902. 51011 rocommondod \hit ~ 0 roquoslsubmlllod by ZIon Luthoran Church lor Ipoclol oxcopllons 10 pormll oxpanslon 01 a roliglous InslMon and modirlCllllon 01 parklng aroo sCloonlng roqulromonls 10 onoblo OItoblishmonl ola SO'lpaCO pnrklng lItoa en PloponJoslocatod a1817. 619 and 621 E. Davonport bo donlod. litho Bolltd donlod ~XC92.0003, stoll rocommondod Ihat tho roquOSl lor modiflod parklng oroo ICloonlng roqulromonls along thO Davonport SIrOol Irontogo lor tho oxlsting pnrklng lItOO locatod 01617 E. Oavonport SlIoot bo lIPPlovod, litho Board opprovod ~XC92.0oo~, sloll rocommondod \hI1 tho opprcvol be subjoct 10 tho pnrklng pIon bolng Implomontod In accordanco with tho slto pion lubmlltod on Janullly 12, 1092, and thai 011 plantings bo complotod by Octobor I, 1992. Rockwon notod thai 0 IOltor opposing thO appUcotion hod boon tocolvod from Doryn McClIIthy. Johnson oskod litho Boord would vOlo on this as ono Itom. Pollon rospondod thot tho Board would VOIO on II os ono 110m, bul nOlod thallhoro woro tNo Issuoslo bo consldorod by tho Boord. Ho Indlcalod \hIlltorrs mojor polnl was that tho loquoslod spocfol oxcoption would nol bo CCmpolJblo with \hO surroundlng rosldontiol nolghborhood, Ho notod IloII's viow Ihot tho roquost proporly Islocolod In 0 .c1onrly rOlldontlol nolghborhood,. POllon rolorrod 10 0 loltor Irom Chrisly Forguson, Includod with thO application mOloriols lubmlltod by ZIon LUlhoron Church, which tolortod 10 thO roquOSI aroo as 0 .mlxod.uso nolghborhood,. Polton chollongod ltorrs Intorprotollon 01 thO lItoa as bolng .cloarly rosldontiol," Rockwoll rospondod thot tho noarby ccmmorclol usos, IUch as Morcy Hospitol, litO nol port 011110 stroolSCllPo of this block. Sho Sllouod thai urban rosldontJol nolghborhoods hovo mlxod usos, and tond 10 bo moro podostrlon orionlod than luburban rOlldontlal nolghberhoods, Rockwoll omphaslzod thallhls plllticular block was moro tOlldontlolln naturo prior 10 Iho romovol 01 two housos by ZIon Luthoran Church, POlton Indicotod thalwhllo ho rospoclod stOl/'l opinion, ho dlsaorood with II. Johnson askod whoro tho now rosldontlol units roforrod 10 by Ilall would como Irom. Rockwoll rospondod thallhll would bo an option 01 thO proporly ownor In this plll1lculllt zono. Johnson nOlod thai thoro Is no guaranlOO thai tosldontlol unlls would bo dovolopod. Barto sold thai whllo thoro 010 2,300 parking IpaCes avolloblo In tho nolghborhood, ho strossod that most 01 lho80 woro probably 1II0und Morcy Hospital within lho throo block porimolor nround tho church. ~: ~rnwn, Zion lUlhornn Churc~, oxprossod his opproclatlon for lho opportunity to como back boloro thO BODld 01 Adjuslmonl. Ho notod thai tho loundlng 01 Zion gaOl back 140 yoars: Ihal tho church was In Iho community boloro thoro was 0 nolghborhood In this oroo, Ho oxplalnod thalwhon Zion pul on tho addition lovoral yoars ago, tho church dlscussod moving to tho Iring os 779 n rt -, '-I ,-, - - Ooard 01 ~stmonl ~blch 11, 1992 PDg03 " ollowll City. bul doddod 10 silly 01 tho CI/Uonlloc4llon. ZIon conaldorod tho church 10 be suppol1Jvo 0111I0 nolghbolhood. Ho rolonod to 0 ltudy thollllowod Ihalschoollllnd chutchos bring slAbl1ty to 0 community ond 11I011111 benondDlto rol4ln thou umln tho downtown DlOD. Orown rolorred to tho glowth In ZIon'l momberahlp, which II now juSlshort 012,000 mombers. He :!Ie-.:ed 1M! tho r~s1 b lOt II \C~~!t!ng c150 ~~~e5 e.'ld noted tIW 29 ~ c!to:dy o.IIL Thoro DlO ovanlng octMlJos thol DID chutchoOrlontad 10 tho church II olso locod Yflth palldng ptoblom.1n tho ovonlng, Brown amphaslzed !haltho 200 IpOCOS ot Morcy Hosplllll DID only lampotory ond lhAllulufo OJpDIlslon by Morcy HOlpUDI mUll be consJdarod. Ho noled thol ZIon II cIvtc mlndod ond open. III doors 10 groups such OS tho Gill ScouII, AlcohoGcs Anonymous, Youth Homos ond Hllndlulo. (GAlar Dlrtvod 015:05 p.m.) Brownln<<k4lod ho h4d not hoord any mombers 01 tho congragation volca dissotilfaction Yflth tha ptopol4l. Ho o.pI4lned lhDI 0 mamber ollila Proporly Beard canvasled tho Dlaa ond lound no oppollllon lrom nolghbollng ptoperly ownars. Ho nOlod !hal whllo this parking wos IlIIOoly Intandod lor ilia ZIon congrogaUon. ZIon hlld Insblulod 0 shDlod p.1IkIng Dlrongemonl with SL Wancolloul. Ho cmphulled 1/141 tho church hlld no IntonUon to genarolo Incomo Irom J)3rklng Ipacol. BrllWn loll tho roquostliltho chDloclOr 01 tho nolghborhood. - I" . Bar14 sAklthoro It 0 concorn with ptOlOrvlng low Incomo housing In Iowa City and noled IhOI opproval ollho IpoclDI o.copllon could solo procedenllor Iho domoUlion 01 oldor allUcluros. Bar14 osJo.od DboullululO o.ponslon plan.. Brown know 01 no luluro oxpanslon plans Ollhls time lor ZIon Luthoran Chutch. Brown lold thai tho church boughtlhO proporly luSIIO Iho north 011110 chutch boc4uso II nooded Iho ground 1I00r level 01 tho rosldenco lor youlh oroup spoco. Ho aold IhOltho uppor lovel 011/141 allUCluro Is ronled 10 HACAP lor S I por yoar. Tho church Is DIsc 0 momber 011110 Groalor Iowa City Housing FoUowshlp. Ho oxpl4lnod lhallho provlcus ownors 01 Iho tNO ItrucluroslhDl woro domeUlhod know Ihal domoUlion wos plonnod lor tho two buildings. Ho sold lI1altho church oflored 1110 two housos 10 Iho City and one hlld on osbOSIO. problom. Ho allossod lhDltho City clid aolvDgO approllmololy 40 110m. from tho two housos lor tho Housing Rohabdillllion Program. yom WmdJ!ilsch. mambo, ofJho 2Ion PrODartv Commill22.IIOlod his agroomonl will! Pollon lI1at tho roquosl proporly II located In 0 IIIlxod uso nolghborhOod and Is nol alllcUy rol/donlial. Ho 1110110<1 thai 0 nolghborhood Involvod mero than hall a 111001. Ho omphosllod tho allong congrooallonalluppor! ond oskod for a show 01 hands from 1I10so mombors 01 tho congrooalion prosonl althls moolino. Ho notod thai tho tNO housos thlll woro torn down worD ronlDl units, but slrollod thatthoy woro notlnvolvod In any lodorDllow ronl proorllma. Ho IIIId this WDl olso nol tho caso 011110 houso thol hod a ronllll unilloosod 10 HACAP. Ho aald tho church hlld IIctuolly added anD not unllto tho low Incomo houllng markol. Wordoritsch notod that tho RM.12 lono parmlts moro lI1an jusl rOlldenllal dovolopmont. Ho alalod thlllllthoso lols worD nol dovolopod lor parklno, thon thoy might bo lold for othot typos 01 dovolopmonl. In rooard to nolso and congosUon, ho Indlcatod thai thoro mlghl bo moro Irafflc on this block, butlho church wou/d anompllo lImit and rostrlcltho use to thoso moslln nood. Wordoritsch oxplalnod that nolghborhOod palllno look placo and showod a mop to tho Boord nollno thOIO Indlvlduoll who worD contoctod and ox prossed IUppar! for tho parklno oroa projoct. 1 77' [I [I -, Y 8 Bollld 01 Adjultmonl M.1tch II, 1892 Paoo4 As a polnl 01 cla/lfiC4llon. RockwoD Iltouod thai III 01 Iho usos pormillad In tho RM.12 lone by rlghlllnd liS provisional uses 11I0 rOlldonUaI. Othor UIOlIIIO pormillad In Iho R"'.12 zone only by spocl4l oxcopllon. . If Indlc4lad lh41 ZIon hlld wilneuod 1nct000b1o grOWlh which Included a number 01 IlI/lIlIlOS with Inlllllll lInd IIl1lII chlldron. Sho O_prOlled concern willi tho ~ plAced en l:.or.lE:2 :.'Xl ::!d :I:~ w:: r;,o;lj atIa 10 r.oo illjlVlln lhi lW'Nilg lot Slio omphllSlzod 1110 mUll ollon patk lovorlll bIockJ flNIIY kom ZIon. Sho Inde4lod 1110 WlIS also Ipoaklng on bohllll 01 o!hor IlI/lIllIol who h4va youngor childton. Sho IlrOSSod lh4ltho Bollld nood4d 10 b4ll111co compollng concorns lInd lIddrOIS tho !sIUO olllllory. She netad lh41 ZIon hlId boon a rosponsiblo nolghbor lIIld would continuo Ie bo a IOlponsJbtO nolghbor. Ink n . 114lod Iho hlld boGn a mombor 01 ZlM lor lour YOllrl and h4d throo chlldron. Sho no lad hor salory coneorM with wlllklng lOVoral blocks In Inclomonl woathor wI!h hor chlldron, Olpcdally al nJohL I 4 , nOlod thllltho clllond:ar p:arhlng Iyslom cull down on tho l\I1lounl 01 aV4IllIbIo p:arklng In tho 111011 lIS do tho ono.way IlroolS lh41 M through tho nolghborhood. Ho IlIId thoro Is a dorillllo nood lor this church patklng lIIId nOlod thai thoro 11I0 pooplo Irom nOllrby buslnouos Md Inlblutionlthll11I0 compollng lor thO IlImo plllklng spocos. plcl! HovoL1427 Onkcroll, Ilalod lh41 ho hod boon a mombor 01 ZIon lor approxlmotoly 35 YOllls. Ho lold IIlOI whon ZIon docldod 10 pulllll lIddIUon on tho church, tho congrogotlon doclded 10 101llll1n In tho nOIll north lido 11I011 ollowo City 10 holp MOp II v1l1b1o. Ho alIId lIS II rolJrod olomonllllY Ichool prlnclpal with !ho Wllchool ho 10rvcd 01 bolng Horoco MlIIln, ho Is IlI/lIdlor with tho porhlng problom. In lhls 1II0D. Ho alMd tho Bollld 10 conaldor tho IlI10ry Issuo. and tho no ods 01 tho oldorly. C1nud1n HOvlck, 1411 Onklnnd AVf/nuo. SllIlad !hallho WllS 11I.0 spoaklng on bohllll 01 hor huSblllld Paul. Sho concurrod With tho Church whon II docldod 10 construct an lIdcUon lIIld SillY In tho noM ond. Sho Illtod lhlIltho church 11I10 lupportod tho PlouCll School 01 Music In lis provlslon 01 Plllklng spacos In tho 1II0a. Sho nOlod thai ZIon lIUOWS lor !ho usa oltholr historic olglln lor proClico lInd rocilllls by non.church mombors. ~ slOlod thOlsho lools ZIon Lulhorlln Church Is II grool nolohbor lIIld doos lIU th011l good nolghbor could be o_pectod 10 do. Sho WlIS Improssod with !ho orowth 01 Iho church. Sho WlIS olad Ihoro woro churchos, II hosplllll, Md IIsloro In tho nolghborhood lIIld strossod tholthoso l\I1lonWos hOlp 10 mllko tho nolghborhood rosldonUalln noluro. Brondlthl\l1kod ZIon lor tho much ImproYOd pion ovor whol WlIS orlglnony lubmlllod. Sho loll thoro WlIS II oroal doni moro consldorllllon glvon 10 !ho ollocl on tho nolghborhood. Brondlsold whlll sho found unconsclonllbto wos thlllthls church boughltwo housos, look !hom 011 !ho lllX rolls, Md Ihon domolishad Iho housos boloro coming 10 this BOllld 10 roquoslopprovlII10 provldo parking 52 days oul ollho YOIII. Sho nOlod !hili Glollo Dol Luthorlln Church, lor on IIsloults lIIld fllIWS, lIllooSI hod tho doconcy 10 wolllor BOllrd 01 Adjustmonl approvlll boloro domollshlno II houlo. Sho WOI nOlluro II Zlon's ocllons woro tho rosull 01 II mlsundorsllIIldlng or woro II conscious oUorL Brllndllfalod Ihalllthls appllCtlticn woro opprovod. Iho hoped ZIon would rocoonlzo thOlthoso spacos 11I0 nol suUlclonl lor lis noods, lIIld would provldo "doslo thoso mombors 01 lis conorogllllon WhO woro 11111 In nood of lronsportollon, 77' [I [I -/ Y q Board 01 Adjusltnonl M.1rch II, 1992 PlIOo 5 Polton nolod thai Brand~ liko 11411, loll thai this WllS 0 rosldonll4l neighborhood, Orondl rospendod lI1allho WllS Irom 0 Imalllown. JUSlllS Iho could walk OVGrywhoro In tho IIll4I community. sho's 4blo 10 walk ovorywhoro 1110 noods 10 on tho noM 1kIo, Sho lAId IhIs II ono 01 tho rOllSons Iho Ilvos thoro. bocauso Ills liko olmaR !own wilh/n Olcwn. Silo IIIOllod 11II1 tho dMgor Is looking al rosldonll4l as only being Uko subwbs with row 4fler row 01 houses. SIlo ilffljlhMilod lli41lhcl noM sido is pM oi tho Origillllllowo Cny ond nOlod 11II1 chwchos ond buslnossOl woro oltabrllllod doso 10 whoro tho peoplo Ilvod. Sho IncflCOlod thai tho I4McoSIlO provldod to tho rosldonts who Ovo on tho nenh sldo, ond In tho example 01 tho church 10 OthOll os won, Sho o_prossod tho concorn thai os moro IIoUSOSIIO 10m down, tho 10.. rOlldonll4l1h1s oroll will bocomo. ~ sllllod IIIIllho Ilvosln 0 commorcl41 zono, bullho also consldoll IIor nolghborhood 10 bo losldontilll. Sho laid 11 was compabblo h4vlng IIll4I buslnoasos on tho north lido Md still consldorlng tho nolghborhood 10 be rosldonll4l. Sho Ian tho add,1lon 01 0 low O_IrO plUklng IpllCes would occur altho o_ponso 01 tho nolghborl who lIclumlly lIvo In tho 1100. Sho laid momboll 01 tho congrooaUon who 4/0 prOlonl h4VG concorns r~4/cSno IhlI soIoty 101 tho mombors 01 tho church, Dun IndIClllod 1110 would lake 10 soo tho "mo concorn lI10wn lor 1110 nolghbors. Sho nolod thai tho moro pooplo who coma Inlo tho nolghborhood, tho groalor 1110 risk Is, nOI only lor tho chlldron 01 tho mombors 01 tho congrooallon. but also lor tho chIldton 01 tho pooplo who IIVG In tho nolghborhood. OuR laid thai lor horloll, Iho doOl not consldor 0 throo block wlllk 10 be unrollSonablo and thlllII Ihculd nol bo unrollSonablo lor moSllndlvlduals. BlUlallSkod litho Itoros Md 10rvlcos In tho 4/00 4/0 nOI onuUod 10 0 placo lor tholr PlIllonslo plUk. Dun IlIossod thai this 4100 Is zonod rosldontial and 11II1 thoro Is p:uklng In tho nolghborhood. Sho Ilrossod thai 20 0_110 p4/klng sPlIcos win nol rosolvo tho nonhsldo parking ploblom, bul win hllvo 0 slgnlllcanl olloCI on tho charllClor 01 this block and tho nolghborhood In gonoral. DOARO QISCUSSION: GlIlor askod II Myono who was pro son I In 11Ivor 01 this potiUon actually Ilvod In tho nolghborhood. Two Individuals rlllsod Iholr hands. Johnson nOlod thai ono of tho housos thai was romovod hod an asbellos problom, so would havo ovontulllly boon log ally unlnhabllablo. Johnson slalod thai tho othor SltUcluro WllS nol vory saUslactory, Sho laid thai In hor opinion, tho City know whal WIIS happonlng with thoso slructuros whon thoy accoptod plocos 01 tho IlIucluro lor tho City's Houslno Rohabllilallon Program. Johnson sold sho favors public IIMSII and gonorally doosn'l approvo 01 on'lltool plUklng bocauso Ills In tho public rlghl.ol.way. Sho nOlod thai no bum run on Sunday. Sho sold tho car was horo 10 114'1 Md Il'l limo l/1al 1'10 rocoonlzod 1/111. Johnson nolod Ihallho church was localod all/1ls 1110 boloro 1/10 Zoning OfdlnMCO WllS Wllnon 10 II had boon grllndlalhorod In wllhoul parking. Sho Il4lod thai tho church now law tho plUklnO liS bolno nocOlSary lInd musl accommodato lis noods, Sho Ilrossod thallho church would bo roqulrod 10 provldo parking 1111 woro 10 bo conslruclod loday. Johnson loll on.slrOOI parkinG was moro unsightly IhM a plUklng 101. Sho Indlcalod call would bo In Iho oroa and II was limply a mallor ollholr locallon. Sho prolorrod 10 ooll/1om oil 01 tho Itroot bocauso thll would bo tho moro atlracllvo allornatlvo, Johnlon foil l/1alll lomo 01 tho oldor houllno was domolishod and parklno was provldod, thon tho nolghborhood bonolillod, Sho IlIld 771 [I [I -,. S [I BoOld 01 Adjustmonl M.1Ich II, 1992 pogo 8 tho nolghborhood would be loss dos~lIb1o by lorclng on.sllool pl\lklnO In tho I\IOlL Sho noted Ihat whllo tho fnndscoplng proposed Is doslrablo, II could IIlllaclltllsh so tho church w1II noed 10 bo ClIrolul 01 tho typo IInd nmounl olll\ndscoplng thllt Is used. BW 11lIIod Ihllllho prlmllly quosUon Is 01 tho appropr1l1tonoss 01 this usa In this nolghborhood. Ho notod thllllls you Itnnd on tho property nnd look l\Iound, you 100 0 clrugstoro. church, Morcy HoapilJll, cnncor conlor, IInd modlClll building OCtOSS tho ItrooL Ho Itolod thoso ClIO be dosltoblo usos In 0 rosldonUlI1 community, Ho llIId tho BOl\ld musl consldor tho proposed uSllgo lIIId tho pubUc good lhlIt will como from IL Ho laid Boord mombers must wolgh tho public good 01 tho plllkfng lot IInd tho pubUc good 01 rosldonUaI housing potonUlIlIy bolng roconstructed. BW notod lhlIl ho lupported tho nrsl oppllcoUon ond ono rooson wos to prOIOCltho oxlsUng proporty ownors 10 tho oxlont that tho pl\lklng oroo could be rovlowed ond controllod lor bullorlng ond tho typo olllghtlng. BlII10 did not think Iho porklng 1\100 would bo II grool dolrlmonl to tho community or tho rosldonts who would havo 10 look ot IL Ho noted that othor possiblfiUos could bo loss doslrllblo. Ho thouOhlthls 101 would bo hoovUy usod by Zion nnd 10 0 cortaln oxlonl by St. Woncoslaus. Ho said this would provldo 0 benofit lor tho nolghborhood by IlIkIng COli 011 01 tho Itrool ond would rosult In 0 IlIlor slluIIUon. Galor slalod thai ho would hllvo 10 IIIko tho opposllo polnl of vlow, Ho Slrossed thai parking lots oro nol bailor thlln housing In regord 10 tho public welll\lo. Ho symplllhlzod with tho noeds 01 tho church olld stressod thai his poslllon Is not II quostlon 01 tho worth 01 tho church or Its noeds. Ho laid obviously II nood lor parklno oxlsts nnd thlll Zion Luthorlln Church Is 0 wor1hwhllo organlzllllon. Galor noted thol his concorn portalnod 10 tho WilY this 1\100 Is zoned ond that on oxcopllon wos roqu~ed In ordor lor tho church to provldo oddillonal pllrklng. Ho oxprossed concorn thai IIpprovol 01 tho lpoclal moptlon lor Zion would glvo luluro oronnlzollons 0 procodonlto lollow. Thai Is. II thoro Is undoslroblo housing nnd 0 nood lor plllklng, than tho housing con bo domollshed 10 pormit construction 01 0 plllklng 101. GaJor slllted Ihot ho saw 0 pllllom olld could nol go olong with IL GlIIer omphoslzod thOI zoning WIIS 101 up with II groot dolll 01 foroslghlllS to whlll wos curronlly locllted In tho 1\1011. whlll would bo allowod In tho zono, ond whlltlypos 01 usos should roqulro spocllll oxcoptlons 10 bo grnntod by tho BOllrd 01 Adjustmont. GII/or stlllod tholthero WIIS morit In dlscusslno this Issuo, beClluSO nn oxcoptlon could bo ornnlod to pormlltho pllrklng. Ho ItrolSod thot II WIIS his own porsonlll fooling thlll this typo 01 pllllorn could not bo allowed 10 begin, oxlsl, or be mlllntlllned. Pollon strOllod- Ihllltho BOl\ld 01 Adjustmonl hlld dlSllpprovod this oppllclltlon whon It WIIS provlously submlllod, Ho notod that tho BOllrd Is II quosl'judlcllIl body olld can only Intorprottho IlIw. Ho omphllslzod thllllho BOllrd Is nolliko Iho Clly Councilor tho Plllnnlng nnd Zonlno Commission thllt oro ablo 10 mllko policy, bul rlllhor tho Boord musl sllln judgmonl bllsed on tho locts, ovldonco, IIIld IlIw. Ho Indlclltod thllt BOllrd doclslons 1\10 nol bllsod on tho numbor 01 peoplo who show up to spook In 'IIvor or In opposition to 0 potlllon. Ho oxplalnod thot BOllld doclslons 1\10 only IIppOOlllblo to tho Clslrlcl Courlllnd nollo tho City Council, Pollon stlltod thlll tho BOllrd approcllltos ovoryono'l Inpul, but must base lis doclslon on tho IlIcts IInd tostlmony prosontod, 17' n n -, s . , - - BolId 01 ~uslmonl M4tch II, 1092 PlIQ07 Pollon loll 11I41 tho curronl opplIC<lUon was a major ItOp lorward by Zlon. Ho had votod agaml ZIon'. /'fbllon In S~tOmlMr 01 1991 and !houghl althal limo, tho proplllallon was poor. Pollon boDovod Olll1olllmo,thoro woro a subSl4nUlIl numbor 01 plllklng placos willi In two 10 II1roo blocks 01 tho church, Dnd Ihallho dosltUCIlon 01 houllng and 11001 did not jultily Iho potiUon. Ho nolod 11I41 Zlon had rodovolopod Iho plan, bul was ItiU going 10 dOSlloy a 40.1001 walnullloo. ThIs was ono majot roason why ho volod oolllnslll1o olllllor potiUon. Pollon nolod 11101 Zlon'l olllllor \'Iol4tJons 01 boundllllos, woonlng, and 1110 pavInQ 01 1110 grnvollql Mlp4d !!Ipport hl5 ~n 10 vola ogainsi ii10 OWt /'fllllon. POllon Indle4tod ho was now Improssed by Iho gOOd lallh 01l0tl1ll41 ZIon had mado 10 comply wllh Iho zoning Dnd ICtOOnlng requlroments lot Iho prOlonllOI and Iho proposod plan. Ho nolod 11I41 ZIon had 0 dilloronl alUludo 1114n was I4kon Iaslloll. Pollon Ilotod 11101 difforonl dollnlUons had boon olvon 01 II1Is nolghborhOOd as olthot rosldontllll or mlxOd uso. Ho bollovod 1110 nolghbolhood could SUD bo rosldonUlIl wllh 0 church plllklng 101 so ho chollongod Ilolrs poslUon. Ho IlIcslod 1114t II was door Ihollhoso plllklng spacos would nol bo rontod oul. POllon omphDSlzod 1I1011hlsls on oxpanslon 01 a roliglous usa and nol a commordal usa. POllon notod Ih4llho Opp/ic4n1 wos proposlng 10 usa downcaslllghtlng. Ho opprocl4tod Iho concom bolng shown lOt 1110 nolghbors who lIvo In 1110 oroo. Pollon Indlclltod ho was also ImprOlSod by tho slgnoturos ollho property ownorl In Iho 1II00, who opprovo or hovo no opposillon 10 II1Is prO/OCI. Tho oplnlon 011110 nolghbors ClItIios substantial wolghl boC<luSO 1I10y muSlllvo wltIIlho BOllid's doclslon. POllon notod IhOllho nOllnCtoaso 01 21spacos would nol IDko ClIIO 01 DlI cltllo church'l pOlklng noods, bul ho Iltossod Ihol Zlon hod changod Its Intornal policy 10 uy Ih4llhoso spocos would Only bo usod by Iholo truly In nood, ospodany tIIo oldorly ond hlIIldlcnppod. Pollon notod 1h411h11 chango In policy hod oddod lubstantlolly 10 his doclslon 10 support 1110 potiUon now. BOlli notod IhOIIl alluoUon oroso In Iho Pnslln which 0 church mlslod tIIo BOOld In rogOld 10 It' Intontlons witll a POlklng 101. Ho sold fortunotoly 11101 potitloner hod 10 como boforo tIIo Board agllln SO tho BOOld was ablo 10 lIddtm Iho situation, Ho Sltossod tIIaltlloro Is 0 nood lor low Incomo housing In Iowa City and 1110 Boord musl bo concornod with any procodonltII01Is SOl by II1Is oellon. Barto Indlcotod ho would nol bo ploosod II In 1110 Iuluro, quOJlty property was domollshod simply lor parking. Johnson nolod thai sofoly Is 0 spoclol con corn 01 nigh I lor tills oroa. ld2I1QU: DOria movod 10 approvo ~ sub/OCI 10 Iho parking plan bolng Implomontod In accordonco wllh Iho 1110 plan lubmlllod on January 12, 1892, Gnd 011 planUngl bolng complOlod by Oclobot 1,1092. Pollan locondod. ~ (04lor voUng In Iho nogaUvo). 3, ~. Public hoorlno on a requoslsubmlllod by Aoglno Cothollo Education Contor lor a spoclol oxcoptlon 10 po/mlt oxpanslon of 0 rollolous Institution for proporty locotod In Iho AS.S zono 01 2140 Aochostor Avonuo. Mulch rovlowod Iho sloll roport dotod M4rch 11, 1992. SlolI rocommondod approval 01 ~ subjocllO Iho rovlsod projOCI plan submlllod on March 9, 1992, bolno Implomonlod. In rosponso 10 0 quostlon from Johnson, Mulch Indlcolod Ihollho Irolllc Illand doos requlro 0 curb, but tho Inlill con bo 0 porvlous or Imporvlous surfoco, Ho stotod Ills Intondod 10 controllho lrolllc IIow and soparalo a drlvoway from tho parkino ar~o, 17f Cl [I -, S ,? B04Id 01 ~ultmonl Match 11, 1892 PIOO 8 ... ~: .Bob "'c/I3ol. Allornov ~lho ooobn~ InlloducOd Mall Kolfor.lIlo Dlchllocl,10 tho BoOld. Ho Inclic4lod 1/I411110y would both bo lVAllAblo 10 lIIlswor qIIOl!lonS. BD/14 lISkod 111110 ptOpOled lCtoon/no would DddtlSs 1110 polonll4llmpact on tho privacy cllho rosldontial Il00S. Mulch rosponded 11101 tho p4IlUng AtOa 10 tho ncl1h will bo 1Ct0aned from tho r~ 10 !he WI 'h"..h Alt:ct~..:: In ~'= ~ tl'.; C=. ~: Pohon nolod lI1alll1o oppIic4nl had Addrossed lIll olllAlrl concarns with tho rO~lad alia pl4n, Ho nolad thai 11I0 Pf%ct would nol nooollvaly ImpAClll10 adjacanl propor1fos and tho ganorDI II4tld3rds had boon DddtOllad. O4lor a'Pfolled approdallon lor 11I0 appllcMlrl wlIIingnoss 10 chllll90 lho ptoposallo maolSlAn's concorns. !:!2IIml: Oolor moved 10 opprove ~ a roquoll submlllod bV Roglnll Catholic Educlltlon Conlor lor II Ipoclol oxcopllon 10 pormll oxpllnslon 01 clmroom IlIcllltlos sublocllO Iho rovlsod proloCI pions submlllod on March 8, 1892, bolnD Implomonlod. Poll on ICcondOd. ~. ~. Public hODlIng on a roquosllubmilled by Rlch4ld POllschun, on bohllll 01 flIOIlOrty ownor Looll Borry, lor II apodal oxcOjltJon 10 pormll mocllftC4t1on 01 roqulrod Ironl Itld lido yOlds lor proporty 1oC4led In tho RNC.20 zono 01 817, 825 lInd 827 fowo Avonuo. . --.-1 \ I RockwoD rovlowod tho lion ropor! d.1ted Fobruary 12. 1992. Sho nOlod 11I01 a conforming hlllldC4ppod parking spaco would nead 10 bo provldod. A1lhough Ills nol curronUy Dhown on tho plan. SIAlI rocommondod 1/141 tho spodal oxcoptlon 10 roduco tho lido YDld roqulromonl Ircm sovon 100110 fiva 1001 for properly JoC4IOd 01 817 lowD Avanuo bo donled and Ih4ltho spoclAl oxcopllon 10 reduco 11I0 Ironl yard roqulromonl Irom 15 1001 10 IIx 1001 lor properly IoC4led 01825 lIIld 827 Iowa Avonuo bo donled. Rockwon IndiC4led 11I01 sho had rocolvod COIlslrom nolghbors lIIld noled that somo hod 10 loovo tho moollng boloro this Issuo was discussOd boclluso 01 othor COmmllmonls. Sho rood II commonllnlo tho rocord Irom Tom Oolman lor Agudl1 AchJm. Sho also rood Inlo tho rocord II IOllor Irom SlIoh lIIld Kan BAkor which WllS rocolved on Morch 1" 1992. Sho nolad 1/141 sho hod rocolvad II COIllrom Mis. M4hllllnll. 0 ptoporly ownor 10 tho OGI~ who loll thai tho orOIl was In nood ollmptovamon~ bullho plolorrod 10 hovo parking odjaconllo hor ptoper!y rothor Ihon 0 bulldlnO os tho Dppllclllll ploposod. BOllA O.prOISed concorn with this oppllcoUon bolnO boforo thO BODld 1111 was nolln compllllllco duo 10 parking probloml. Chrisllllllson rOlpondod 11I01 sian C4nnol closo 11I0 door 10 on oppllCllllI COIning boloro tho Boord, bul ClIIl polnl out \hili II \hIs spac/III oxcoptlon Is Dpptovod, this wculd nol bo onough lor tho pr%cllo procoed. BIlr!1I nolod \hili II Iho spodol oxcopllons aro IIpptovod, \hon \ho appllcllnl would nood 10 comobllck 10 roquosllI vorlllnco. Rockwoll sllid lhlll Slllll would pro lor 10 havo lhlsllom donlad or tho DppllC4nl roquosl 0 dolorrllllo IIl10w submillaJ 01 a pIon tholl.ln compllonco wllh Coda roqulromonl', 77' '-<.,'," .~', ., [/ 0 -, S . 3 Boord 01 Adjus!monl M4tch 11, 1992 PagoO In 10lponso 10 0 quOltion kom Pollon, RIchard PIlllchuU, 11I0 appllc4nl. Il4lod Ihol ho WOllin Dlchlloct and a would,bo devoloper. Ho sl4lod his cSlllcully with this ptC/oct YiIlS boaIuso 01 10 many vDtlAblOl, which mlIdo II hDId to lubmll 0 roqu011 wllhou1 hDVlng lemo typo ollOlponlo In odvonco. Ho IndIc4lod IhlII ho would roquell dolol/lIIlo DI10w lOt a now submlll4llo oddlon 10mo ollho othor IsIUOl. Pollon 11410<1 !hal ho would highly recommend Ihollho oppkonl doos roquoll 0 dolorral ond WOIk with 11411 10 como up wlth a moro applOpt!4lo pllIn. POllon slrOlSGd 1/141 ho could nol luppOtllho pion IlS R W~ plco..:nl:d. P:~ rcqu;::cd ; dolatral :0 ;:ow 11'18 t;qIialll4li01 wpdalGd. Hi! Itrollod !hatlho numbol 01 IIIUOSInvolvod compllc4led his roquosL ThoIO appoMOd 10 be a connlct botovoon 100000s ollho Zoning OrdnllnCO rOODldng weonlng. Pollon nolod !halll would be boll lor 11I0 oppll(onllo wolll dOloly wlth stall and Ilroned !hallllo Board gonorlllly 'iIoWl 11411 IlS o.ports on lholO mallors. Pellon moved Ihol conlldolOllon 01 ~ Ipeclal oxcopllonl 10 roduco Iho lido vard loqulromonllrom &OVon 100110 live 1001101 PIOPOrtV 10Ulod 01 G1710wa Avonuo ond 10 loduco tho Ironl yard IOqulromonllrom II1l0on 100110 Ihl 1001101 plopOrlV locotod 11825 ond 82710wI Avonuo bo dolonod 10 April 8, 1992, basod on Iho toquosl ollho pOllllonor. Galor locondod. ~. ~: Johnson moved 10 odjourn tho moellng al 7:03 p.m, G%r IOconded. Tho mollon wrlod 4.0. John C. Pollon, Chalrporlon ]'1"\ .J-I .a....-t'? . \.. . ...., 11 \ Molody RockwoU"BoDld SocrOllllV Minulas lubmllled by Mary Jo Noll lNII1'OOA3." mA 771 , .----.--'1..'.. t] [I -/ S 'i .., " . 150,,1'.1 J. ~3u~h.".tl"l~ REgulo.R.' -CettNe~ m€EtitJ~ t\rch " ~,30 1>, m. '?lto.s& Si9~ IN: ~ ~(t-1J.~~ 11. I (JJ~ a ,\1 1. A ...3- t I'-f ,r IJ-oe ,I e v J f \)'(Nt<<,",- ~U-J () q, l/G Cy.pM'it; tf, S l W~'c.o..~rO to\.. \.r. Avt"t. 0 l 6 }, 1. s.t&t ~~ I 'I,).. 7 tJ. i~H~ . t" 1'( I / Ne~:,,-,, (lc,~lI.i~ ----~---"-"C"_:_-'_:_"~ T--.---...,-"----.- ,-- ~ I. ..D\ ~u... G(~ J.~-Iyo.. 5m.v",,", 3, T~ lJJ;..J.~ r:4~ ~ul 4, - -v , . 'i i ~ oS: i i . '. '. l 13. . Iq. ~~ ~ J1. '1: 0 : I"":" '~.QD eo O"I/t", , oJ 3<11'1 1<'lAA'~N~'" 4ve. "''-''.'h _'. j" -r ,,''-', -"'"-..., ,-,; .,~... ,.,_,o"._,......c.... t' \ - "--'-'--"'-';--'--"---""--,'-'- l ! , . . 77f '1~~L) l~ t] t] -, S S MINUTES COMMITTEE ON COMMUNITY NEEDS MARCH 18, 1882 . 6:00 P.M. LEE RECREATION CENTER AMEtIOED & APPROVED 411m2 MEMBERS PRESENT: GIDCO Coopor, MaIy Ann Donnls, Und4 Murray, Usa Oxloy, Robin Paol%old, Roberta Paltfck. Anrit Ponzlnor, Kolth Rufl, Marls Snldo,. Goorga SIlUr, Jim SL John MEMBERS ABSENT: None STAFF PRESENT: BlltM5, Krl<<I, ~YI ~ NYg9!\t P9!!1!9Y, SdI0mh0tt1 OTHERS PRESENT: 500 Bttachod 1Is1. 1. Tho CCN ,ocommonds to tho City Coundl 10 continuo to IUpport tho cum rnmp Bccossilllity program as thoy havo In tho prOvloU11wo YOIVI 01 tho cullonl amount 01 $25,000. 2. Tho CCN rocommonds 10 tho City Coundl to lund tho lonowlng 1002 COBa ProlON In tho amounts bolow: (1) UnUod ACIlon lor Youth. Youth Con tor Acquisition (2) Community Montal Hoalth Conlo, . Acqullltlon (3) Iowa City Froo Modlcal CUnlc . L4bolDtory (4) Mayo(s Youth Employmonl Program. FoJrmoaclows POlk POlk Improvomonts (5) HOME P,%ct Coordination (6) Housing Rohabllltatlon (7) Eldorly Sorvlcos Agoncy . Small Ropal, Program (6) G,oalo, Iowa City Housing Fonowahlp . AcqulslUon (9) LIFE SkIDs. Housing Support Program (10) AId to Agonclos (11) Gonoral PI4nnIng and Program AdmlnlstraUon (12) Contlngoncy ~: $41,180 $71,180 $14,000 $11,050 $15,300 $260,000 $17,350 $45,000 $18,984 $81,400 $ 125,000 $30.718 Chaltpollon Sl John caJlod tho mooUng to ordo, 018:14 p,m. Tho lollowlng amondmonts woro nolod: St. John alkod 10' a chango In tho Fobruary 28, 1092, CCN mlnutos, pago 4, undo, hoadlng 01 Eldorly Servlcos Agoncy.Small Ropal, Program. Sovonth luU IIno Irom tho bollom, betwoon "palnUng pr%CIS. I and "Sho sltossod," the lollowlng sonlonco should be addod: 'SL John oxprOlSod rOlolVaUons ollnsUlullonoJlzlng low pay lomporary work. I Paoaold askod 10' a chango In tho Fobruary 25, 1002 CCN mlnutos, pogo 6, undo, heading 01 Wrup Up,lllhould road, 'tho Housing Commission rocommonds" ratho, than "would recommond. 710 \ I , 1 1 I , I r i I , , I I , I I I , i [I [I -, S b CommlllOO on Convnunlly NoodJ M.vch 18, 1992 pago 2 Run movod 10 approve rlo mIDI. SIlltT locondod. Tho mollon passod unl\lllmou./y. CIIIltpaI10ll Sl John Il4lod apptOVOI 01 rlo mlnutOI IlS amondod. PM!M!d !!!led h!t ~ =t too Wlli.;~::r~ 10 ;om m1h IIi! H~ Coiiliiiisiion's rocornmoncb~on boc4uso n noadod lIdluStmonL Tho Houllng Commllslon rocommondod rlo Houmg RohlbltAlIon Program bo fundod lOt Iho lull amounl 01 $280,000. SIm movod 11II1 CCN 10nd . rocornmonda~on 10 rlo Iowa ClIy CII)' Council 10 continuo 10 lupport curb ramp ICcculblllly U Ihoy have In tho posl two yoollll tho curronllmounl, which he bolllvol II $25,000. "lknw1 roquoslod III oxp/4nollon lOt now members 01 posl actions loading 10 Stan'1 racommorm~on. SlAtr o.p1o/nod rlIl unll ~ yolllllllo CCN rocommondod $3,000 10 $5,000 annuaDy 01 COBa Iwlds lor curb ramp construcllon. Slncc thon, tho ClIy hIlS fundod tho.o curb ramp 1n.loJl4tions lIvough Iltaol molnlononco 10 Iho IIlSI ~ yolltl CCN modo Iho rocommoncbUon to Council 10 conlWlUO thai procou. Run IIkIIIIII 80.70 ramps I yolll' havo boon constructad compared 10 12 provlously. . . SIm 114lod n hIS boon I very successful program. SL John o.p/4Inod 11II11110 Commllloo wanlltho CII)' 10 bo lIWlII'O oltholt concorn and wanls tho Clty 10 conl/nuo lis IUppOI1. SIm suggoslad this bo I rocommondation 10 tho Council by CCN. ChDlrpoflO/l Sl John onlonolned tho me~on by Slm and 10condGd by Ru", Tho moUon passod unanlmoully. SL John Inltoducad CCN now mombors, Bruno Pigott, Rusty MatlIn IIId Susan Foonoy, who will lIIumO tholr posll/ons Apnll, 1002. SL John 114lod ho wiD conUnuo 10 10rvo as Chll!lparson until AprU 1, 1092. Ho lays as a child growing up In Motk IV pubnc housing, hll oxperionces IS a bonollcfaty havo Innuoncod his aggrOlalYo IlanCO IS a plopononl 01 public housing. SL John roquoslod tho 'oDowing bo rocortfod In tho mlnutos, Ho Ilalod his btothO(1 glrilrlond wrolo 1110 poom, "11", by Rudyard KIpling on tho whlto wan oltholr Mark IV ApllltmOnL Thll poom hIS IUllolnad him Ihtough 1110 yolll'l, Tho poom was road llloud. Vlco Chalrporson M4ry Ann OOMIs prosonlod COr1ll1colOSlo mombors whoso lonnsllo oxplring. ChDlrporson Jim SI, John has sorvod Ilnce \900, aoorgo Slm has 10rvod slnco 1088 and 10rvod IS chalrporson lor ono lorm. Roborto Polt1ck has lorvod with nolii' cenUnuous 10lVlco Ilnco \877. 7ft) \ I , I [I t] -/ S ,-, CO/M'lln" on Convnunlly Noods M.1tch 18, 1992 pago 3 M.1ty Nugonl ppl4lnod 1I11111h1sls ~o limo lOt CCN mombora 10 Ilk quolllons 0111I0 oppIIcan!l In a~ond4nco and Iho thon rovlowod 11I0 ranking ptOCOlS. &ho monllonod ~o upcoming Clly CounCil Public Hollllng on CCN roconvnond4llons would IAJIo placo on AprIl 14, 1892. NugonllUOQOIlod loIowIno ~o ordor u on 11I0 woNhool MIkman noted UA V, nrsl on II~ Wl\I nol yol prosonl and suggoslod 10 movo on 10 Community MonlAl Holllll1 Conlor. Bob Jllckson appoared 10 wwor quolllons. In roaponso 10 . quoldon lrom SL John, Jllckson raportod lh411110 socond noor lonanrllouo o.plros on May 15, 1892 and 111111 tho lonanl on 1110 third IIoor hat no 101lJO though ho roquesll 10 occupy untJ Augul~ 1002. Tho blIsomonl olflcloncy hat no 101lS0. POMOY It4tod lh4tll1o roquOllod funds Irom tho Boartf 01 SupoMIOI1 woro appt0pr\4lod In 1110 FY02 budgOL In rosponlo 10 0 quolllon kom MIllman. Jackson Il4lod lh41 paIl/4lfundlng may rosuR In 1110 pro/oct bolng dol4yod or nocossllallng ncgodallng o loan. Ho further llalod lI1al docrollSlng funds wiD rOlullln IncrollSed difficulUos bulls nol DWaro 01411 oxact cutoll point whoro tho pr%ct could nol conUnuo. SL John oskod I1lI1ls propollll compUos w1111 FocIorllllncomo lovols. PMkm4n rOlpondod In 1110 a/lltmallvo bul fndlC4tod fuMor rocordkoop/ng would bo necossary. In rosponlO 10 0 quolUon Irom Do Mis, Milkman Il4lod conlllUcUon roqulros Davld.Bacon IlIbor sland4td1 whlch roqulro Incroaled admlnlllrollvo Ulno 10 monllor compllanco. In rosponlO to 0 quolUon Irom Paolzold rog4td1ng what amount oflunds woro raquOltod, MIlkman slatod $12,000 was requolted by 1110 CUnlcs. SI4II' quosdoned admJnlslrodon cosls on tho workshoOI: MIlkman slatod 0 corrocllOn was noodod on tho workshoot: tho amounl $1,250 should bo changod to tho corroct amount 01 $2,000. ~ SI. John sfatod 1110 $15,300 raquOlI may nol nood 10 bo 1II1ocotod II HOME lunds DlO not rocolvod, although 111010 funds soom 1ISlurod. ~ Pam Bamos appoared 10 answor quosUons. 7'10 [I t] -, S 13 Commlttoo on Community Noods M.1rch 18, 1992 pago .. S/atr '1Blod Ih4I $5,000 lor Iho HII/orfc ProlalVllllon propolll IWlIch WAS VIlIl1cfthn Irom 110 Frfonds 01 Hlstorfc PrOSOMlllon Is nollncludod In tho $280,000. MIkman oxplDlnod thal Friend, 01 Hlstorlo ProsoMllon had VIllhdtllWlllholt IuncSng rGqUOIllOt tho $5.000 bul wlshod 10 IGmaIn Involved In an approprfato projod by provldng IOmO 1dlS~0NI lundng. In IGSPOIllO 10 Sl John, Barnos llalod thai tho hcuso on Bowory wlII bo laid 10 .lltsl'~mo buytt 01 low Incomo. \ Joan M4nn lIppOarod 10 IIIIWGr quolllons. Thoro woro no quoldon.. ,MaYOr's Vout/1SmoIovrnonlPrOClrntn lliWlPolrllfl!ll_PrOClrDmI Peg FlDlor lIppOarod 10 IIIIWGr quOIUOns. Thoro woro no quolllons. Regor Modskor oppoarod 10 answor quosllons. Milkman Sl4ted thai tho Sl4lo h4s HOME funds but lIor DrO grarllod through I compotillvo appWcaUon prOCOII. Sho furthor 'laled 11101 an lIpp/lcadon 110m any local prlvato organlz4llon musl bo opptovod by tho City as woll. Ruff askod IItholo funds would OIsls1 I da4blod parson In obl4lnlng housing. Modskor IIBIOd yos, thaI WOlI consldoration. "wasltrOllod thai tho goal Is 10 provldo low Incomo housing and nol handlcappod accosslblllty OIslllanco. Ruff Ilaled Ihaltho dlsllblod oro ollon low Incomo. Milkman oxplDlnod accoaslblUty WOl one 011110 roqu~omonlllo bo looked 01 whon rocolvlng COSO lunds, - - .------1'- i I Rober! SumsllppOared 10 anawor quosdons. Mllkmanltalod thai thoro VIlli be a $600,000 cap lor HOME lundl, Tho Slato probably gavo 1011 consldoraUon 10 tho COil 01 now consltuelJon, becaulO Iowa City II tho only clty ollglblo lor now consltuelJon. Sums rosponded 10 0 quosUon by PaoLzold regarding tho broakdown 01 tho cOil por unlland rohabllllaUon ol!ho Prols.Clllzon building, Ho Ilalod 1110 par unll cOil II skowed becaUIO II dooln'lloko Inlo accounlthal commorclal olflco spaco II croalod. Houslng unll COlllhould bo aboul $50,000. Ho lurthor statod !hall 0% ollho unlls would bo handlcappad accosslblo and 1110 romalnlng 90% would be handlcappad adaptablo. ., 7'10 rl n -/ s q - - Commllloo on Community Noeds Match 18, 1002 Poo05 ~onlor Cantor Aeeosslt!!!IV Imorovomonl1 No one WlIS prosonl to answor quosUons. Snldor Inltoducod a brloI discussion and SL John added comments rooatdlno advIWllIIly 01 power dcot openers. J12Mson Coun~lor AccosslblllIV Immovomonl1 No one WlIS prosonllo answor quosUons. No quollfons. \ PaolZold asked II thoro had boon any rosoluUon 01 whal was 10 hoppon with 11I0 prosonllacllity or 111\ WlIS a closed subloct. Ziolkowski roplled thai tho lubjOct was IIlIl open. Allor dlscusslon 01 tho proJoct hod dose1 and later In tho mooting, Durgor and Zlolkowlkl oddod Ihllltho slall 100 01 $35 por hcur on thO appncallon was 100 h~h and $20 por hour was corroct. -r-n. I No one was prosonllo answor quosUons. No quosUons. . n k P~ Frasor appolllod 10 answor quosUons. Frasor slaled aho hod brought a copy 01 tho Falrmoodowa backup proloct. Sho slaled Ihlllln roladon to tho nadona/ ObjOClfVOI, 51% 01 omployoos roforl 10.low and modoralo Incomo 100nllQOrl, Sho oxpla/nod thaI 01 tho six omployoosln this pr%ct, 5 aro 100nllQOrs and lis an adult, though all 11I0 01 low or medoralo Incomo. Milkman datlfiod thai slall's nol rocommondlng lundlng was a mallor 01 prlorldos. Tho Nod Ashton proJoct was lor p8/k and lralllmprovomollts, and thai was noltho Inlonl 01 CODa lundlng. . Frasor slaled Ihallhls Is tho main pr%ct for tho Youth Consorvadon Corps. I\'s approval win gonoralo malchlng slllta funds, Slarr askod whalamounl was roqulrod 10 rocolvo tho matching lunds 01 $22,000. Frasor rospondod with $11,565, wlthoulln.klnd support. Milkman addod tho backup proJocl was In 0 low.lncomo nolghborhood and may bailor moollho Inlonl 01 tho CODa program. 7fO i I I I I \ I I [I [I -, h n - - ConvnlllOO on Community Noeds Match 18, 1092 PlIOO G m. Soll.EmoIovmontjnvostmonljlomonstB No ono Will prosonl \0 wwar questions. No queltlons. W S~. lr.e. .Jleu"..!I\a S!J!!09rt.PlOlImm SIIn ukod In rogDrd \0 110 program'llIo \0 GICHF'I proposAl, II GICHF Is nolluccossluI. wID lho LIFE SkIIII program bo vtabIo. Jo" Lauer responded \hal yos, LIFE SkIJII would bo vIablo. Nuoonl ukod Modskor II GICHF dooan' rocolvo HOME lundng II thoro Is sWI a commltmonl 01 $2.000 lor tho LIFE SkIIII program. Ho rosponded In lhO alflllnallvo. QIlDan Fo. added R Is budgoled separatoly. SL John lllkod how LIFE SkIJII cHonts aro soloetod. Fo. answored Ihalsoclalsorv!co agondos IUch III DHS and Nolghborllood Conlors mako rolorrals. Sho added thoro Is no problom In IUrlllg lho lmil 01 30. No ono WIll prosonllG answor qvosUons. Jim Swaim arrived IalOr. Murray askod II parIIaI lundng hod boon dlscussad wllh UAY. Mi1kmall answorad \hal aho had dlsculSod Ihroo opllons wllh thom: 1) Conltllct purchaso, II ownor would agroo; 2) PIII1IAI funding 1540;000) lor \his )'Oar, with a commltmonllor an Dddillonal amounl o.g., $80,000 noxl yoar, 3) Section 108 Loan Program. Al \his polnl, Swaim antvad. Murray rophrasod hor quosdon, addIng win tho $40,000 be onouoh1 Swaim slalad tholr board had mixed roac1lons and hod nol como 10 a dodslon. Tho obovo throo opllons woro rovlowod, Swaim slalod thaltholr sponsoring organlzaUon. Youth Sorvlcos FoundaUon, hod rolsod aboul $20,000 annually In tho pll5l. and Is moving loward $50,000 par yoar, Ho addod, 1110 I(rosoo FoundaUon may be a malor nrsl ClIIldldalo lor !hIs lundlng Incroaso, !houoh ho has nol yol approachod !hom lor tho 50% challongo granl. Swaim slatad In rospanso 10 SL John'S quos lion !haltho prosonllonanrs loaso oxplros May I, 1992. Swaim sugoostad 10 his board thai duo to !holr shortago olspaco, !hal!hoy pursuo tho 101150 boolnnlng May " 1992, rooardlOls ol!ho outcomo ol!ho prolocl. Tho board has nol yol doclded. 7g0 I I I .---...-....-..--.;.--... \ I [I [I -, b -I Comminoo on Cornr'OOnlty Noads MAlcIlI8, 1992 PlI007 ,\ , R4lpOndlng /0 OeM", 8m .lalod tho doling dlro hod boan lal for July f, though lack 01 lunds IIIIY dol4y Ihls dAlo. SwaIm corroctad . momo lonl out l14l1ng I 75% Incrouo 01 clonts over . yoAl was Idudy over . ~.yolU perlod. lIsl YO"'I rovbad llguro II I 34% lneroDlO. Cooper ISkod N 110 0WII0tI do nolloDVO Iowa CIty, VlilIthoy ltiIIloa 10 UAY. SwAIm ropllod!hal thoy wollld. Oxley ukod N tho ownor II Inltrollad In lallng on conlnld. SwAIm 114lod !hal yos, ho II very lupporIlvo. TNI may roquIto an odcIllorl4llon. , i , I SL John ClllIod lOt any quoldOlll lor 111II. Cooper ukod II Ddmlnlsltllllon 100 comos oul 01 granl menoy or II pI/1 01 tho projod. Milkman 11410d 111111I0 odmInllltllllon costs lOt I pr%ct do nol como out 01. gonorDI Ddmlnlsltlldvo fund. IlIIlII pAIl 01 1110 pro/ad. DOMIt liked 111110 rocommondod conllngancy llII10IInlll comparadvoly high or low. MiIkm4n IlIkI 1110 lools II II 1110 'r1ghl"l/llOUnl (5%). HlllOrlc4lly II was 10% bull14J boon ~cod. Ponllnor ukod II 'CHAS compllllrlCO" on WOtkshool1l roDlly CHAS rolovlIrIco. Milkmllrl oxplalnod . 'No" mallrl."Nol ~." SL John onlar1alnad . medon 10 dOlO tho quasllonlng period. SlMr mevod and Coopor 10condod. Mollo.., PUlad uIllIIlImcUlly. ) 1. Community Monl4l HoDlth Contor . Acqulllllon Polnll AwDrdod: 51 RankIng: 2 (do' 2. lowll:lly Free ModcaJ CUnIc . lDbonllory ImprovomonlJ PolnlJ AwDrdod: 53 R4n1dng: 1 3. HOME Pr%ct Coordlnlllon Polnll AwDrdod: 50 Rlnldng: 5 4. Housing RohabUlI4Uon I Polnll AwDrdod: 51 Ranking: 2 (do, I I I 5, Eldorly Sorvlco. Agoncy . SmDll Roplllr ProgrlllTl PolnlJ AwDrdod: 45 Ranldng: 7 8. MaYO(1 Youth Employmonl Program. Houso PDlnUng Program Polnll AwDrdod: 33 RankIng: 11 7. arollor lowI City Housing Followshlp . AcqulslUon Polnll AwDrdod: 48 Ranking: 8 8. lowl City Pross.CIUzon Bulldlno . Acqulsldon PolnlJ AwDrdod: 24 Ranklng: 15 730 .. . ...~-. -.----_..--._.---.-.-. .-.-.-.-----.--_. --.. < i ~-, .. .. n n ,-, b r? - - Commllloo on Community NoodJ Match 18, -'092 PDg08 " 9. 80nlor Conlor ACC4lllbaltt Improvomonll Points AwDtdod: 27 R4nk1ng: 13 10. JohnlO/1 County HolIhh pontor AccGulbIIlly hlptovomonts Points AwDtdod: 32 R4nk1ng: 12 i I. SyslOnlS UnDmllo\f Now Nolson Conlor AccoIdllDIy ~ovomonlS Points AwDtdod: 35 R4nk1ng: 9 12. Horoco MAnn PTO . Pla)'vround AecossallIity ~ovomonlS Points AwDtdod: 25 R4nk1ng: 14 13. M4yot'l Youth Employment Program. Alhlon Troll Hold Pro/OCt Points AwDtdod: 17 R4nk1ng: 16 14. IS ED . Soll,El1ljlIoymonllnvoalmonl DomonsltDdon Points AwDtdod: 14 R4nk1ng: 17 15. LIFE SklIII. Houtlng Support Program Points AwDtdod: 41 Ranking: 6 16. UAY. AcqulslUon Points AwDtdod: 51 I ----r--- RAnkIng: 2(do) SL John romlndod CCN 11I41 rocommondallons Iogolhar willi Il4lI'l rocommondllllonl go 10 CIIy Council who thon IlIlIko tho lInallundlng doclsJon. PlIClzold roquoslod limo 10 rovlow MYEP'I altomatlvo FlIIrmoadowl PlIIk proposal. SL John movod lInd Murray locondod 10 IlIklI Q brollll. Mellon passod ul14lllmously. SI. John C4IIod moollng to ordor. Ponzlnor roquOSlod procedural dllllnC4llon on approprlAtono.. 01 consldorlng MYEP'I bIIclwp proposal. Paltlck alalod Iho would havo prolorrod thoy had mado tNo Sopatllto prosonlllllons. Murray slalod allhough Falrmoadowa had nOI boon prosonlod, " was roquOIlod altho 2125 mooUng 10 bo consldorod II Nod Ashlon was nol approved. SI4rr lIddod,tho FlIIrmoadowa POlk proposal was clslrlbulOd boforo 1110 ranking proceduro lInd tho ItaII rocommondallon also. PaolZold statod thai thls a1tomatlvo proposal should nol havo boon aUcwod originally. Milkman addod thai changing tho funding mld-cyclo Is ono oltha lactors aoating IhiI problom. Slarr romlndod tho commllloo thalli had provloully boon rocommondod, socondod lInd approvod thai thoso bo consldorod loparatoly, Ahor ruMor dscussion, FlIIrmoadows PlIIk Improvomonts ProJocl rocolvod a ranklng. Points awDtdod: 34 Ranking: 10 Murray movod 10 ollmlnato proposals wllh awardod points undor 30. Thoso aro: Iowa City Pross. CIUzon Bulldlng AcqulslUon, Sonlor Contor Accosslblllty Improvomonls, Horaco Mann Accolliblo Playground, MYEP.Nod Ashlon lInd IS ED Soll-EmploymontlnvoSImOnl DomonSlraUon. This was socondod by Paolzold. MoUon passod unanimously, 7g0 rl n -/ b 3 - - Commlltoo on Communlty Noods Match 18, 1992 Pso09 S/arr movod /0 tully fund Froo ModIc4I CIitlIo ($f4,oool: Houllng RohAbllitaUon ($280.0001: IIld HOME Projoct Coordlnnllon (SI5,300I. Socondod by DOMIs. Mollon pwod fOol, SL John dlssonting. S/arr movod 10 tund EIdorly SoMcoS Agoncy (SI7,3SOI. Socondod by P.Unry. DOMb liaiod glvon lIlO conskforaUon 01 olhor prO/octs porhaps olhor Iunds could bo oblUlod. Palrlck ltalod 11I0 dilllculty In loeallng olhor lundng. Ponnoy addod 11I0 roquOl1od amounlls noltho onUra cosl 0111I0 program. SL John boDovolll1o work 01 tho program noodalo bo dona bul has phIlolophlcol quolUofll about tho numbor 01 poop/a 10rvod by 1110 dollAlllponL Palllck ltatod 1110 coslllllo qulto low. Joan Mann addod lasl yoar S7,000 was spant on 20 ptO/octI. Ru" 11410d ho consldorad It oconomlcal. SL John rolpondod by ltallng wo havo a Housing Rohllbl&tallon Program. BAlnOlltatod that ESA has nnod a gap. Thoy (ESAI roDovo a burdon 10( tho RohAb' program. Schornhorll addad lI1altho Rohab program Is oporating al mlllllmum and Irankly tho ltall dooan'l havo tho limo 10 do thOIO amllll pr%cta. Paotzold o.proslad coneorn that tho commJnoo may nOI bo consldorlng rank, by spondng manoy on lomo Imlall projoell boloro lomo 011110 llIIgo, Mollon passod lOot, 51. John dlssonllng. Donnls movod and Murray loeondod thai Johnson County Hoalth Conlor AeeOlslblnty and SYltoml Unllmltod Nolson Contor projoet bo oOmlna/od fram lundlng conlldorallon. Ru" ltatod whon Johnson County Hoalll1 Contor was roeondy ronova/od with CDBa lundJ.lhIa Improvomonllhould havo boon dono. DOMls Itatod tho WIC program wal a valuDblo lorvleo though lundlng 01 thll aeeoulbIDty Improvomonl wal nol 01 hlgholt priority. SI, John added lupport 01 tho WIC program bul roeommondod not lundlng this prOPOlal roquolL Paotzold Itrossod tho valuo 01 tho WIC program whllo nol roeommondlng lundlng tho pro/oct. St. John addod Ihalllko tho WIC proJocL ho doosn'l wanllo 100 an Ineorroct mOllago IOnllo SYltoms Unllmltod by nOllundlng proloet. Mollon PlISsod. 9 to 2, Coopor and Patrick dlssonting, 780 \ I I t 1 I rl n -/ b 'i - - CommJUoo on Communlty Noods Match 18, 1992 Pogo fO OllCllsslon 01 USO 01 conllnQoncy lunds lor cosl ovorruns by Milkman, Poo/zold. St John. Ruff and Ponzlnor 10Uowod. Mollo(llor 5% conUngoncy In 1110 amounl 01 $38.921 by Oxloy. Socondod by SllIIr. MoUon passod fOot, SL John dluonUng, St Jolin molioilod liiid Murruy locondod 10 fund lilo CommUnity MonlDf HOalth Conlor AcqulslUon 10( S71,ISO. Paotzold romlndod commJnoo mombors 11101 Mr. Jackson laid 1I10y would bo Dblo 10 work will1 $66,150. Sho llllProuod hor coneorn olltrotchlng 1110 monoy and 1110 Imporlanco 01 nolloltlng up agone/ol agalnsl oach othor In compoUllon lor lunds. PaIIlck 11410d bolng dlslurbod whon It IIllIld thaI agondOI rnako /rodo 0111. Ponnoy addod 111011110 commlnoo ClIII go back and roassou. Mollon passod 803, Murray, SllIIr, and Paotzold dlssonUng. SllIIT movod 10 fund alCHF $45.000, locondod by Donnls. Ponzlnor askod II HOME lundlng dopondod on CDBa lundlng and Is this truo lor lIII oppllcallons 01 HOME lundlng? Milkman o.pl4lnod no, appllcllUons 11I0 /udgod on points and IoCDllundlng apoclncaUons, howovor ovIdonco ollolal community lupport Is ImportanL MoUon passod lOot, Palrlck dlssonUng. Paotzold movod 10 lund LIFE Sldns, Inc. $16,984. Socondod by Storr. SL John and Pootzold o.p'ollod suppoll 01 nood and valuo 01 program. MoUon paslod 9.2. Coopor and Patrick d1ssonUng, Palrlck movod 10 lund UA Y for $41,150. Socondod by Starr. StlllT oskod II II Is approprfato 10 ask Frasor litho pall 01 tho romalnlng amounl would bo usoful for 1110 Fafrrnoadows PAlk Proloct ($8,000 VI. $1 f,OOO). Fruor rospcndod by o.plalnlng II would addrosl pall 01 tho matching IUndl, bulthoro II a Umo rostralnllho would nood to 10cal0 furthor lunds Pootzold romlndod tho Commlltoo thai thoro ora two othor MYEP projocts. SI. John lug90stod using tho balanco for tho Falrmoodows Park program using somo conUngoncy lunds. Ho lomlndod tho eommlnoo tho 5% II a rocommondaUon and Is arbitrary. StlllT romlndod commlttoo tho moUon on noor Is lor lundlng UAY $41,150. II passod balanco would bo $57,045. Ho Ilolod Ihal consldorlng a projoct of $1 f,950 would roqulro tho conUngoncy bo roducod by S8.205100vlng $30,716 In ConUngoncy Funds, 711) \ I I ! .. .... T . I j n n -/ b 'S - - Convnlnoo on Community Noods Match 18, f992 Paoo II ~Iollon ClIIrIod unanimously. St John movod 10 fund MYEP FAltmoodows PAlk projoet SI1,95O with dilloronco coming from Conllngoncy Fund. Socondod by DOMIs. . Ponzlnar askod Fruor a1nco tho ranks lor t.vo 01 MYEP's (Houso PalnUno and Falnnoodows PAlkl projoctl 110 almllII dld aha havo . ptOloronco. Frosor ropllod tho Isauo lor 1110 Faltmoodows Park PrO/oct Is matching lunds. Mallon passod 803, Au", Pootzold and Ponzlnor dssonUng, St John movod 10 rocommond 10 City Counclllo lund abovo prolOdS. Socondod by Paotzold. Mallon passod unanlmoualy. A luggosllon 10 Swam roqulrod that UA V look Into Soetlon 1081und1ng. II will bo dlscussod 01 no_I mooting. Nugonl romlndod CCN 011110 no_I mooting ~ I, 1992, at 5:00 p.m. litho Sonlor Conlor. SL John movod 10 DdiOUm. PoolZold locondod. Motion passod unanimously. MooUno adjoumod 1110:00 p,m. Mnulollubm/nod by Monica Krlso. \ .-~ ,- 'i~------'-' --T--~" \ . " ....".. 1'60 . .\~ f)~ Cl Cl -/ b b MINUTES IOWA CITY HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MARCH 10, 1092.7:::10 P.M. SENIOR CENTER MEZZANINE CONFERENCE ROOM MEMOERS PRESENT: Joyco OAlrolt. Suo UchL Doug RussoD. Joy Somol MEMBERS ABSENT: K4'I1!! ~ !lo!!y !<oily, ~r Stoolo STAFF PRESENT: "kIo, Noff OTHERS PRESENT: Claronco Havorkomp ~: Chalrporaon Ruuol CDIlod 1110 mooUng 10 ordor al 7:::18 p.m. Thoro was 110110. Uchl nolod thai Nowyaz was mlsspollod on paoo 2. Somol movod 10 DpprOVO tho mlnulos 01 tho Fobnlaty II, 1092. moollng as arnondod. BarTOn 10condod. Tho moUon canIod 4.0. !dklo roportod 11101 Somal and RuuoD anondod 1110 M41ch 5, 1992. Planning & Zoning Commlulon mooUng 10 hoM tho diICIlsllon rogMdng tho Haddock ColtDgo. MlkIo roportod lI1al tho Planning & ZOnlng Commission volod 5.210 DPPIOVO tho rozonlng applIcallon Iub/oct 10 tho appIIcanl paying $5,000 lowardt tho roloCDtIon 01 tho houlo and thoro bolng I one yoar graco portod boloro tho hoUlO II movod. Ho Iltossod t-NO Cornrnlsllonoll, Dlorks and Gibson, loll ItrOngly lI1attho conaoo should romaln on silo and 1I1011l10ro should bo moro offort on 1110 port 011110 dovolopor to prosorvo tho hoUlO. Ho said 1110 otho, Cornrnlss/onOIl bosod tholr opinion on a IogDl oplnlon 'rorn tho City Anotnoy'1 Ofllco 11101 was roloosod alll10 mooUng, Millo lnclcalod thai tho logDl oplnlon lald thai aovlng tho conaoo would bo In compllaneo will1 1110 Comprohonalvo PIon and II would bo In 1110 publlo Inloroll to lavo 1110 coll4go. Howovor, 1110 opinion concludod thai any COnditlonl on tho rozOnlng mUll be roasonablo and IInCO tho dovolopor WIIS nolln agroomonl with laving tho coltDgo on 1110, thon II would nol bo roosonablo 10 lorco him 10 prosorvo II on alto. Ho 114lod thai tho IogI11 oplnlon IndICDlod thalli would bo roosonablo 10 roqu~o manoy and limo from tho dovolopor 10 anow OthOIl 10 movo 1110 conogo. !dido Ilalod lhal GIbson and Dlolkl volod aoolnllll1o opp/ICDUcn and Gibson Indlcotod ho foil lhall/II was In tho publlo Intoroltlo prOIOrvO tho houlo by moving II. 1I10n tho dovolopor could o.p/oro oll1or opllonslo koop 1110 houlo on 1110. Millo laid albion also hod a concorn Ihalll10y woro only baing glvon t-NO opUcnl with rogAld 10 1110 COllooO, Somolllolod thai thoro WIIS also omphosll plocod on 1110 IImlloUon thai tho dovolopo(1 plannod, Ho notod lI1altho plan did nollncludo prolorvollon 01 tho houlo and thoy only rovlowod tho , , \ I I 781 [[ CI -/ b ~f MINUTES HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MARCH 10, 1992 PAGE 2 prepoiallhal WiD in Ironl 01 VIi) ~illillliilon. ~ i)ipIi1iiIid lhi1lllli Ivw. ~ Powi i condillonal rozonlng " thoro Is s mutual sgroomonl with Iho dovoIopor. Ho notOO II1Dl 110 dovolopor IndlCDlod that ho was not wl1&ng 10 plosorvo tho corraoo on Illo. Ho IndICDIOO Iha1 Jan Nash hod aDId allho Planning & Zoning ConvnIulon mooUng thallhll alllludo on tho poll 01 110 dovolopor could rOlullln this u bolng an IsIUO 01 olthor a YOlO to a111nn or dony tho oppIICDllon. Somol oxprouod concom rogordlng Iho omp/lullthot was pIAcod on tho houlO aJono rathor than In tho contoxl 01 Iowa City hlslory. Ho nolod 1I10ro was ovon a luggosllon 10 moYO lIlo houso 10 Wost Branch and he ItrossOO II1DlIl1Is would bo a Ion 10 Iowa CIty's horitago. Ho aDId 1110 concom on tho pari 011110 Commlsslon 100mod 10 bo 1101 wo'ro going 10 oJow 1110 dovolopor to doltroy tho 10ltlng which will doCtoaso 1110 hlslOllc valuo 011Nl houso 10 h mull bo movod. At RussoWI roquosL Miklo rovlowOO 1110 City AnOmo(IIlndIngS. Runol roquollod II copy ollhls Iogol opinion. LIcht notOO that thoro 10omod to bo a concontraUon on 1110 houso rathor than 1110 IOlUng. DorrOIl luggostOO 10IWlIIdng a rocommondallon 10 Counclllhot rolloralos Iho Hlstorlo PresorvaUon Commllslon'l pollUon, Sho omphaslzOO Ihal 110 hoUlO In lis conloxlls 011110 gtoalolt valuo. LIcht ItrOIlOO lI1altho voJuo would bo dmIn1ahOO litho houso Is movod, Sorno/llatOO thai h could bo comparod 10 tho Hoovor blrll1p14co. MikIo nolod that moving 1110 houso would aIJo dostroy III chanco to bo placed 'on tho NoUon4I Roglllor 01 Hlllorlo Placel. Somolluggollod moklng an argumont In ragAld 10 Iho hlstorlcal conlOkl 01 Iowa City and nol jusl thai Iho houlO rDprosonll1l Ilgnlllcant typo 01 archllocluto. Somol and Runol IIgroOO 10 drolls momorandlm to 1110 City Councll. Miklo ropollod that tho Planning and Zoning Commission 0110 dllcuuod amondmont 10 1110 Zoning Ordlnanco roquostOO by Gloria Dol Lull1orlll1 Church that would pormlltho louJng 0111 church parklng lot In tho downtown 11I01. Ho Itrossod II would bo ImItOO 10 only oxlsUng PAtf\kIg 101110 1I10ro would bo no InconUvo 10 domollsh homollo Ctoalo oddUonol parking, Ho ltalod IhIsllmondmont would only opply 10 Gloria Dol and St Palrlck'l. Ho InclcalOO thai conakforaUon 01 this 110m would bo on tho Match 31, 1002, Council aoonda, Mlldo 114100 thai Planning and Zoning Commllslon also cllCUISOO a propolod 1110 p/an ro'tiow procOllll1al would dool with 1110 urban dOllgn IslUOl, Ho 110100 that tho Planning & Zoning Commission would conUnuo 1110 publlo hoaring 10 Match 19, 1002. Ho ropollod thai Frtondl 01 Hlltorio ProlorvoUon and tho NOlll1 SIdo Nolghbolhood Aslod4Uon hod roprolonlAlIvolllltho lOll Commlsllon mooUng 10 dllCllslthls 110m. Ho lald ho would koOp 1110 Hlllorlc ProlorvaUon Commission Inlorrnod 01 any changos, Russo I notod 1110111111 would roqufro Hlslorlo ProlorvoUon Commission rovlow 01 Itructuros that oro ollgiblo lor tho Hlstorlo Raglltor and notlult tholO 11101 aro curronUy In Hlsloric DIIlrlcls. Mlldo Itolod thai ho had rocolvod commonts rooordlng Soturdo(1 moollng and concoml woro oxproslOO ragA/ding 1110 longth of tho prolontallon which rOOucod tho amount 01 limo for publlo Input. Ruaaoll notOO thallomo Impollanl poop/a In ollondanco loll prior to tho publlo Inpul. Mlklo 7g/.' [[ [I -/ b /3 MINUTES HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MARCH 10. 1992 PAGE 3 IDId ho would ~o Iikod !o hAYO hAdlh9 pte!!llta!!on h!gh!!ght lho I::uc: ~ wMI i11tvd UIV gonoral pubnc, and .uggoslod lhal a loIlowup IoUor 10 MDltya Svondson might bo In order asking 10( a chango In luturo proson14Uons. Somol sold mo)bo " would bo approprlato lor tho CommJulon 10 asslll Svondson In making prosontaUonsto tho public. I.Wo rOlpondod thOlthoro wiD bo pubnc holltlng. on tho /Inal documonl and II would bo approprtato al 11101 polnl 10 havo elo CommJ.slon mombors pro.onl Idoas 10 tho public. Barron .uggO'IOO .ondng fonors 10 1110 poop/a who hod loft tho moolJng oDlty 10 loIlcllll1o~ InpuL Llchl OlplalnOO 11101 aho loft elo olocullvo .ummary ahould havo boon clslribulOO 011001110 tho CornmJallonors In advanco 011110 moollng, Thoro WIIS a consonsuslo IOnd 0 Iottor 10 ovoryono who was on tho InvtIoUon 11I1 roquosUng lollov.w Input Pdklo ropollOO thai Dick Gibson hod sold 11101 ho Ion that tho plan was 100 spoclllc lor a p/annlng documont Ho aaJd thai ho porsonoDy loolslharo ahould bo moro concontrotJon on a IimlIod numbor 01 goals. Thoro was 0 conson.UlIo 10nd a Iollor 10 Svondson with a draft lottor 10 bo IOnl 10 tho altondoollndcaUng rospofllOl ahould bo lonlto Svondson. Barron l14tod thai 1110 largol dotOI may bo unroallsUo and lhal 1I10ro may bo an allompt 10 aecompllsh 100 much, 100 loon. MJkJo rOlpondOO thai KDIIn Franklin, DlrOClor 01 Planning and Community DovoloprnonL hod luggo.too a nvo.ton yoar span rathor than a II1roo.lJvo yoar span. Ruuol III0aaod thai 1110 plan noodalo bo workoblo wilhcul doloatlng 111011 by not eonlldorlng Itoflllmo roqultomonls. Licht omphaslzod thaltha p/an canl roqufto 10 much as 10 roqulro that a now 110/1 porion bo addOO ImmOOlaloly. Miklo laid Ir. Importanl to havo tho publlo olpron tho nood 10( lmp/omontaUon and lhIa Is whal would lu.tlly additional ltall Urno, RUlloO IndiCDlOO thai ho hod spakon with Paulo Orandl 01 Frlonds 01 Hlslortc ProlorvaUon, wIlo IndcotOO thai Frlonds would nko 10 co'lpofllor tho ovonL Ho o.p/alnOO lhal ho would also con14cl Laurlo Roblfllon 01 tho Johnson County Hlstorlo PrOlorvallon Commlsalon. Ho roportod thai CDlol Polorl, AdmlnlstraUvo Asslltanl 01 tho JOhnlon County Board 01 Suporvllors, Is onthusJOltlc rogordlng tho UIO of 1110 courtroom lor tho colobraUon and 10011 thai approval would bo Ilkoly. Barron laid .ho would chock with A1chllocll allowa Slato lor potonllaJ jurors 10( tho DWAlds. Somolluggollod thai for nOli yoar consldoratlon Ihould bo glvon 10 IdonUIyIng 1110 ,pookor who would attracI a crowd whoso Inloro.lls much broodor than limply hlstorto prolorvaUon. Ho IndlcatOO granls ahould bo avalloblo 10 pay for tho lpoakor. RUlsoII askod Commlsslonors 10 rovlow tho wk 1111 and contact him with whal thoy would bo willing 10 do, Ho laid ho would Uko an op.OO ploco 10 bo wrltton 10 hlghllghltho Issuo.thal hovo occurrod In tho pasl yoar,luch as church p4lklng and BlulfwoOO. In rosponso 10 0 quoltlon Irom Somol, Miklo laid ho would lond tho juror guldollnolln 1110 nOlt Commission packol. In rogard 10 posslblo nominations, RUlloII montlonod Jim LAlow'1 low olllco, and Somol montlonod John Van Glldo(. houso and tho Blair houlo on Unn and Fairchild 1110011. Mlldo notOO thai SI. Woncoslous' now rool was InslallOO with Ihlngloathat glvo tho appoaranco of IJotO. 7fl [[ Cl -/ b ,~. , , MINUTES HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MARCH fO, 1092 PAGE 4 Ho roporiOO ihai Svandson hasluggosiOO giving IIWOIds 10( amoilor pr%cil IUch as polnUno and gonOfll molnlonanco. Thoro wu no Inloroll o.prouod II thllllmo In changing tho mooUng Umo and doto. tdklo ropollod 111011110 Dodgo and Bowory houso hlld boon donatOO 10 thO City and 11101 ono yoar wu glvon Irom 1110 original domollUon doto 10 movo 1110 Itructuro. Ho nclod thaI this ono yoar dodno O.pltol on ~ I, 1992, and lhallho movlng dalo Is Ichodulod lor Match 24,1992,10 movo tho Iltuctuto 10 Rundol StrooL Ho nclOO 1I10llho now IocaUon II In tho Ilood plan 10 a buomonl will nol bo pormlUOO. Ho oxpl4lnod thai Frtonds 01 Hlstotlo ProsorvaUOn has Ioanod tho CIty $32,000 and thO City wlIlthon rohab 1110 houso 10 IOU 10 Ilow,mOOoralo Incomo 141nl1y. Ruuol ropollod 11101 Hanlck and Somol had boon rooppolntod 10 throo.yoar lorms, Ho nolod thaI Barrolt and Ruuorllorms will o.plro In Match 01 f904, and thaI Llchl and KoUo(llorms wID o.pro In Match 01 1093. Ruuoll ropollOO thaI an appllcaUon wu rocolvod Irom 1110 National TMI HonO( Awardlln tho ovonl DnyOno has I bullclng 10 nomlnolo fO( lhIa honor. . tdklo ropollOO 11111 an HRDP workshop will bo hold ragDrdlng tho applIcaUon lorm. Ho laid lhoro wu I granl fPllllcallon dolldllno 10( Juno I, 1092. Ho luggostoo thai thO Commission mlghl wanllo conlldor HRDP gronlllO( IoUow.up and Implomonlatlon 01 thO prolorvoUon p/an. CIAlonco HDVOrClllllP llalod 11101 thoro was conluslon 011110 Saturday mooUng ragA/ling 1110 presorvallon plan and how thO goals and objoctlvos woro 10 bo prlor\UzOO. RussoD luggollod II would bo Iou conluslng II In 1110 10Uow,up Ioltor poop/o woro only askod 10 rOlpond 10 lIlo lop Ion IuUOI. Llchl nolod lI1altho goals woro gonoraUy lramod In IUch a way thalllll 01 tho IIslod objOctlvOI would bo roqu~od 10 roach I goal. ~ Somol movOO 10 lIdIoum thO mooUng a19:10 p,m. Barron locondod. Tho moUOn carrlod 4.0. M1nulollubmlnoo by Maty Jo Noll ~II... 7el Ii ~~} J ,. rl n -/ .-/ [I - - Drift MINUTES BROADBAND TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION WEDNESDAY, MARCH 18. 1992.5:15 PM COUNCIL CHAMBERS . MEMBERS PRESENT: Troy SlOvonl. Paul Cutllo, Rooor Chrllllon. Cordoll JoPPltn, Tim Finor MEMBERS ABSENT: STAFF PRESENT: OTHERS PRESENT: Nono ShollOl, Brou. Holling Doug Allaire, Corol Spaziani \ RECOMMHJDATlON TO COUNCIL Nono. LIST OF MA'tlJRS PENDINO COMMISSIONIC:OUNCIL DISPOSITIO~ Trlonnlol revlow and coblo TV rofronchlslng/ronowol nogollollonl. Propolod Rleol yoor 1893 BTS budgOl. SUMMARV OF DI!lCUSSIQH. ShollOl repollod nino complolnll ond nOlod Ihal comp/olnll ConcOlnlng 0 pOO( Olllludo on Ih. Plrt 01 HOIII.go omP/oym .re on lho ,110. In .nolhOl compl.lnl, . nolic. wu hung on . lublerlbor'l dOOf cl.lmlng . slgMIloak hod boon doroclOd.lnIOllorocc... required .nd 101Vlc. would bo 100mlMlod II no ruponlO WOI glvon by . cOlloln dOlO, Whon Iho IOchnlcl.nl relurnod, no loak could bo dOIOClOd, OleOpl . ono.lool oroa OIOUnd Iho cOMocllon 10 lho houI.. Tho lochnlclon lhon Inlormod Iho lubscrlbor'l 100vlco would b. lormlnarod .nyw.y IIlnlOlMI.cml wu don/ad. Chrlsllon recounlod . Ilmll.r oxperlonc., bul wu glvon no PliO( nOllco 10 hll IIlVIco bolng 100mlnalod. Whllo lho comp.ny'l mOllvollon II unknown, II WDl .grood thoy I.ck proper conlldor.tlon ollho CUllomor. Sh.llor, olong whh 0.10 Holling 0( SUI.n Horowhz, hoo mOl wllh olllcloll 01 Roglna High School, Corolvlllo Chy M.nager Kolly H.YWO/th, .nd Johnlon County Dllllror SONlcu Coordlnalor Jim McGlnly to dllcu.. tho relllnchlslng proe... .nd 10 .dvllO Ihom ollho forthcoming noodl ......mont. Moollngl with tho low. Clly School Bo.rd, PATV. tho Public Llbr.ry .nd Iho Un/vorllly allow. .re pI'MOd. Doug AII.lro repO/rod PA TV II dovolopino . lurvoy 10 bo Ion I to curronl .nd Pili .CCOll UIOlI to 0..... tholr noodl.nd dovolop Iholr requol1lln rogord 10 rolr.nehlllno. Corol SpOlI.nI repO/rod tho librory hol dovolopod . policy 10 ouure mOllor 10POl don't lo.vo Iho building, A IOrlOl 0112 prooromllo bolng odllod from loollgo Ihot.t 0 Frlondo 01 tho Llbrory IYOnt, .Supper In Iho Slockl,. In which 11 wrllorl from Iho Unlvorlhy 01 low. Wrllorl' Workahop rood Irom tholr workl. Sh.llor ropollod tho Itcond dr.ft of tho Rico. WIIII.ml rolronehlllng noodl OUOllmonl h.1 boon IOnllO 0 numbor 01 pooplo In Iho communllY 10 onluro III IOlov.nl l..uOI 010 covorod .nd Iho quolllons .re undorllDndoblo, Tochnlcol Inlormollon hom HOIII.go hOI boon lonl 10 Rico, WiIIloml ond Iho rochnlcol oudll will bo conducrod In April, CALL TO ORDE6 Tho mooting wu collod 10 order 01 5:20 p,m, i \ I 78'- rl n -/ ,-, . , - - llIoadbtnd T.I.communlc.llonl Commlulon March la. 1882 P.g. 2 . bPPROVAl OF THE BYC t.1INUT~S The ,.bnllty 19. 1992. mIll WII. cOlllcl.d IIglld''''O Iht new policy on Rot.lld rllm.. R'IIl.d r.tml.1I plohIbllld on fiblllY Chl1Vlt120, bul nOI 110m being vI.w.d In Iht low. Clly Public UbI.ty. II wllmovsd by CIIIII. .nd ..cond.d by Clvlld.n 10 'Pplov. Iht cOlllclld ,.blu.ty 19. 1992. BTC mIll, Unenlmoualy.pplovtd. SHORT euOllC ANNOUtiCEMENTS None. ANNOU~CEMENTS OF COM"'ISSIONERS TIm Flnel Inqullld .bout lhe ulu.1 dm.II.m. llqullld 101 l.rvIe. 10 bo .1lIb1llhad In new .ubdlvlJlonl. ShllIlI IIpolI.d Ihll .1 . rllllll 01 pall plobl.ml, . plOC... hid bo.n .11.b1llhad In which d.yolopell .11 10 conl.Cllho c.b1. comp.ny II III In .dy.nco II polalblo on lho pI.MOd d.yolopmonl 10 Ihlllhe company c.n pI.n lholl budgoll .ccOldingly .nd Iht c.b1. c.n bo burlod wllh olhol uIIGIIII. TNI plOCOl1 hll WOIk.d w.lI. ShllIOI will chick II lhe plOC... hll boon lolIowod In lho CIII bloughllo Flner'l .1I.nUon. BTS RE~6t ShllIOIllpOllod olghl people conod In compl.InII,lwo .boull.l. 1001, one .boullnlOlloronco on lho Atu . (nloll.IMlonl chlMeI. IWO .boul 11101, one .bouIIIOllng,' one .boullhe lOll ollht Qu.d Clly chlMell, one .boul (ncOl., .nd one .boul . Sclonlology plogllm pl.yIng on PATV. In IIglld 10 lhe 1.10 1001, ShllIOIllpon.d Alallllnl CllY AIIOInoy AMo Burnsldo docldod lhe c.b1. company con lIb1ulllly docldo nOllo chlrgo 1.10 foo.. The Sclonlology plogI.m on PA TV gonorllod . dllCuIJlon conlolld on lho dllllncllon bolwoon. ploRI.m.k1ng OIg.Nzollon uliIIllng PATV Ind .dyolllalng on PATV. PATV Boald ChilI Doug An.11I nolld Ihll ploRI.m.klng OIg.nlullOIII 110 nollOlblddon. bul .dyolllalng II. Cuell. IIId Ihlllho I.pel bloughllO PA TV by locol clllunl, bul plOOucod by oulaldl OIg.NUllonl, orion IlIgo 1nallluIIOIlI, Chlngllhe IOnO( 01 loc.'lcc.... ShlIIII nolod Ihll .1 one polnllhe PA TV guld.llnellnclud.d . IOImul. which lot.aldl. c.rt.ln pelclnllg. 01 11m. 10( loc.lly pioducod plogllm.. AII.III uld he bollovod IhlIIOImul.l. no longlllnclud.d In the guldollnol boC.UI. of lho .cIvIc. 01 lhell .1I00noy. Shellll nOI.d 10g.1 opinion. dlllOl on lhe m,"01. Shellol nOlOd Ihll lher. hevt bo.n conalllonl compl.lnll .bout Iht .lIllud. 01 c.b1o company omployoo. .nd 1.1.ly lhey hevt Incluaod. MOil complalnl' w.ro .boulll.ld wOIkoll, bul 10m. .1.0 .boul olllc. pellOMtI. In .nolhel compl.lnl, . nOlle. wu hung on . lublCrlbol" dOOl llOllng ',Jlgnall,ok hid boon dOIOCI.d, Ilqu111ng .nu.nco Inald. .nd Illhe .ublCllbor did nOI conllcllhe comp.ny by . glyon d.lo. aolYlc. would bo 100mlllllod. Wh.n lhe company rO\Ulnod the n.xl d.y. Ih. lublCllbtr ukod 101 plool 01 the I.ok. None wulound excopl . one.lool .11. llound Ih. COMtcllon oullld. lho houI.. Tho lochnlcl.n. lhen 1.ld Ih.y WII' going 10 dl.cOMtcl nrvlco anyw.y IIlhoy w.ro nolIOIIn. SNIIII hi. conl.clod Ih. Logal Dap.rtmanl ond wllllalk 10 Bill Blough. SNIIII quolllonod lhe lacllc. u.od 10 g.ln anlllnco. Chrllll.n IIcounlad . Ilmllll expellanc., H. IIIU1nod homa 10 Ilnd hi. ..lYlco 10rmln'lod wllhoul pliO( nOllllc.Uon.nd. nOllc. on hi. dOOllllllng .100k Nd boon dOIOCIOd. Whon Iho lochnlcl.n. rOlurnod .nd conduclod IUlllnlldo, lhe rOlull1 woro norm.l. SoyoIII COMOCIOII woro IIpl.cod, Whon ChrlIU.n Inquilod II 10 Ih. 1I.lon lorlholl ,cllonl, lhe lochnlcl.n expl.lnod Ihal. pOlllbllllY 01 c.blo TV InlOlforonc. wllh air 1I.llle Ilgnall.xlllod. Cmll. nOlod Iho IlIgo IInOI c.blo comp.nlol I.co lor Ilgnalloakog.. BOlh ChrllUan and 78" [I [I -/ ,-, ,? Btoadblnd T.I.communlc.lionl Commlulon March 18. 1992 PIg. 3 CalOlla commanlad IhlllhI companY'1 IpprOAch I.ckl coneldarlllon lOt IhllublCriberl, JapplOn volcad concarnl 01 how unlcrupulOUI Indivldu.11 could employ elmU" prlll",e I.Cllcl 10 gain .nu.nca 10 lomaona'l homo. JapplOn raquoltad InlOtmlllon on lho proc.dural ulOd lOt nOllfylng cUllomarl Ind lOid I IYlllm of prlOt nOllca Ind duo prOCIII Ihould be employad. Chrllll.n luggOltad IhI company m.y be 10 wOtrl.d lbout tho Cilllliqliil1l:iI 01 nilllilJlilllillng 101NI' tJ'JlII 01 ptotl.ml, INIINIl COIlll.oilfr rNthill procaduru lullar. Jappl.n lugguled Ihll I naad 10 gon.rlta Illlllllcll evldance 01 cOtrocllng ptobllml m.y ba mOllvlllng Harltlga'l ICllonl. Shllllr IOld H.rlllgl may ba looking fOt mulllpla tal.vlllonl/Ocalvlng urvlc. wlthoul paying lOt mulllpla oullatl. Clvllllln Ind Cmlla rlquOltad Ihlt H.rttaga ptovlda InlOtm'llon on how many Incld.nll 01 s/onalluk. Ihly hlva dllcovarod and Ihllmounl 01 11.11 lima davolad 10 tho ptoblam. Shllllr /OpolI.d Ihlllh. FCC hll lot MW lachnlcll Illndlrd., loma 01 which I/O lalt 10 Ihlloc.1 Irlnchlur to anlOtca, Copla. ollha tachnlcal Ilondlrdl Ira baing IOnl /rom tho FCC. Shlllar,llong with Dlla Hailing or SUlln HOtowllZ, hll mal with olllcl.11 01 Raglna High School. COtllvllla Clly Mln.gar Kally HIYWOtlh,.nd Johnlon Counly DllOllar Sarvlm CoOtdlnalOt Jim McGlnly 10 dllcuulha r'''lnchlllng procm and 10 Idvlulham O'lh,'orlhcomlng nOldllllmm.nl. MOIllngl 110 1110 p1.M.d with Ih. 10wI Clly School BOlld. PATV. lho 10wI Clly Public Ubrlry and Iha Un/v.rllly of Iowa, Sl.vonllnqul/Od II Kirkwood would ba conllCtad. Shlllar laid lh.y could ba and m.nllon.d Ihll Illho limo tho /ronchllo wu filii gr.nlod, Kirkwood W'I conelda/Od a C.dar Rapldllnllilution and bacom.lnvolvad In th.lowl City IYltam by operallng Educlllon Ch.MOI 27 lor Ih. ECC. Thllluu. g.MIOI.d 1101 01 dllCuulon by lho BTC at Ihllllmo. Cu.lla Inqulrad IIlh. IlOnchll. roqulrll . raprmnlOllv. of lho clbla company 10 ba pral.nl .1 tho BTC m.ollngl. Shallar rllpond.d lhal lho comp.ny'l IUlnd.nc. II nOlraqulr.d .nd Ih.t Blough .lw'YI contaCII him II h. II unabl. 10 IU.nd, Shllllr wlllraqu'll Blough und .nolhor IOptmnllllv. II ho II unabl. 10 IU.nd. Cmlll volc.d Iruluallon Ihllllnca lh.lowa Clly lyllOm hu baan acqulrod by TCI, and whon Blough II UMbI. 10 Inand. Iharo h.1 baan an IMblllty 10 ptovld. lho InlOtmallon roquoll.d by lho BTC, \ t:lERITAGE REPORT Blough wal oul 01 lown. Shallar roporlad Blough had provld.d .11 Ih.l.chnlcallnfOtmallon roquIIlad by Ih. conlullanll. which hal boon IOnllo Rlc.. Wllllaml Auoclalal, ECC RE~ORT Shallar IIld ho h.d lalkad with Joanno Van Daus.n who rapollad Ihal ChlMal 27 hid baan running Imoolhly and Ihal Ih. hu baan working wilh lh. taacharl and admln/lllOlOtI proplrlng Iham for rolranchlllng, LEGAL REPORT No ropoll, PATV REPORT Doug Allllro rapollad Ih. PA TV Board Is conllnulng Ih.lr ouuaach prooram 10 IOrvlco orglnlzallons. A porlonnol policy Is baing dovalopod 10 claarly III oul procoduru ragarding dllclpllno Ind grlovancol. John Hm prosonlod a lhroa.yoar oqulpmonl purchuo plan 10 buy Supar VHS c.mcordars, A lurvoy 01 curranl and pall accoss usorlls plannod 10 gOlhor InpuI 7~ . t] t] -/ '-I 3 Bto.dblnd T.I.communlc.tlonl Commlulon Milch 18, 1892 P.g. 4 to m/It the PA TV Bu.ld ItI th," ,,'"nchlalno "qUill. Thf plo/fclld t/m.lllm. 10( compl.tlon I. OctObel 1992, Cmll. .ald h. hid t.lk.d 10 John HUI .boul the paperl Unlv,"l1y Inllln. .1 PA TV ." required to wIlli lOt tholr InaIlUCIOt.. PA TV hi. nol be.n receiving copies 01 thlll papore.nd Cmlla.uogllt.d Ih.I.IlOtU be m.dOIO Ilqu1l1 cOp/es II they m.y be ben.ncl.IIO the oparetlon. 01 PA TV. liiiiiAilV iiEfS)ilf Clio! Spall.nI dl.lIlbulld COP/II 01 the AV IImlndll clld. .nd the new AV btochw., Quld.lInt. govllnlng the c.tnCOtdll In Ih. plol.ctlon boolh In MOlting Room A wOllllc.ndy dllwn up. Thf c.mcOtdll will bo mil.blo 10 PATV, ChlMOI 29 .nd the IIbt.ry, but nol mll.blo 10 the public. IndlvldUlI. m.y btlng their own clmcOtdll. .nd the libt.ry will C.bI.Cllllh.llpe 1I.lallr d.1I11 wlsh.d. GlOUP' who w.nllO hive lhelt m..llng Ot .venl c.bI.call .hould cOO/dlnat. pI.yback times with Cmy Aahe. BtClulI 01 .n Incldontltl which I mlltllt.pe WII borlow.d boloro I cllculltlng copy could bl mid.. I policy hu boon dovoloped to .nlur. mlltllllpal don'tlOlvo th. building, Tho 1Ib1I1Y will mike. copy on lOqullt,1I poulblo, 01 I Pltlon con bring In tholl own tlpt II they wlnttholr own copy. Tho fllondl olthalowa City Public L1brllY hoslod In avont callod 'SUppel In the SlIck,"'n which f I mombell olth. Unlvllsity 01 Iowa Wrlllll' Workshop rud "om thell WOtk.. Tho ovont WII llped .nd II baing .dilld Inlo 12 plOll"ml, CABLE 1)1 REFRANCHISINQ , \ , I , . Shallerllport.d that Sua BUlkellquOIlod IlIn~oy IXtonllon to Milch 30 10( hllllpolt duo to the IlIgo numbol 01 loturned qUIIl/annal,.s. Tho 10cond drift ola neodl Ullllm.ntllom R/ca, William, has boon IOntto . numbll 01 peoplo In tho community to m.ko IUI. .11 the . rolov.nt quolllon h.vo beon eskod ond th. qUlltlon, .,. ltldOllland.bla. ROIponl.. "' duo . ApllI 3. SI.von, comm.nlld lhat moro na"allv./opon,ondod quoltlonl may bouer .1I0w INtltullonslO IXplUllholl neadl, All roquestod HOlllagotrCllochnlcallnlormallon hll boon IOnllo Rlc., Williams. Don William, and/ol an anglnool wiU coma 10 Iowa CIIY ItI ApllI to . condUCllh. IIchnlca' audll. Rica, Williams lugaa.lld tho comp.ny conduct I IWOOP trlC' belor. .nd ,'llIth. IlUnk IIn. II cut to onabl. I houso 10 be mov.d and tho rosullllo bo mada avallabl. to th.m. Shallll ha, Idontill.d 405 lub.cribell who have IXperloncod ploblaml who "' willing to SOIV' II tOlt sites, pjLpLlC DISCUSSION Nona. 7S;;' n rl -/ '-I 'i - - ~". B/oadblnd Tlllcommunlclllon. Commllllon Malch II. 1992 Plgl 5 6Q)OURNMENT II WII movod by CIIIIII, ..candid by Chlllllln. 10 Idloutn. Unanimously IpP/ovld. Adjoullvnlnllll: 12 p,m. Rllpoctlully lubmlllld, WilUam ClIW Shill., lItoadblnd Tlllcommllllclllon. Specllllll _lUll... ,- ~ ..: . . 7f~ i..::~,"'..,,"'., . I' I I \ :--r~--f- - , rl rl -/ ,-, 5 - - 'O~'\ ~ MIIlVfII IOII~ C In 110II.1110 COHIl UIIOII '.I~UAAr 11, 1"2 MII~T ~ LI. COIOIUIIln UcaJATIOII cam~ - MOIl ~ IWII1U ,ulm. ~l\j&al!l J ImP.!, !e!llll '.ur~CV'r.iliillC, .1.... L IlAAAU, .1ltrr.y I roWWl, ~.r.1 UILLr (arrlv.d ,.011, .1ack IIClWlOII IWII.U AI.m. 'alii lOLl nAr' ,win. Ron H.nd.non, IIIrhnn. MUkun, OoIIV Ioothroy, ..or.tary Vlrvlnla 'trOlld ClWIOII/AlWllIWfT' TO MIIlVfI. O. 'UVIOU. 1II1f111O. Won. UCOIOIIllD~TIOII' TO COUIlCILI Hon. UCOIOIIllD~TIOlII TO CClI ro~ PUWOIHO nQU.1TI ro~ CIllO PUNDI. - That HOIIal"9 ~.habllltatlon be rundld ror "21,000. - That pr.r.r.nc. be vI'.n to thol' pro"Ctl that ...t the voall or the ClC.U phn. 1II1f11lO TO O~IR. ,.00 All b)' Chllrpenon Moor. . MIIlVfII. Kotlon to ~ppro'. Mlnut'l or .1anuary 14, 1"2, wal ..d. b)' Moor., I.oonded b)' Harrll, oarrled '-0. CClI Uro~T - 'AlfIOLD-DU~UHI~IC CClI .I.ctld nev orrlclr. and dllculald C~nlt)' D.,.lopaant W'lk ~prll 20, lt12. CIllO IIOUlllIO u'o~n . HILIUWl Hllkun dllCUlled the HIIO that wal dlltrlbut.d with pack.tl. Ih. Itltld CClI will be h.arlnv rtqUlltl ror Pl" rundlnV on 'Ibruary 21 and 26, 1"2. .ntltllllnt rundlnv or '701,000 plul appro.l..t.l)' '10,000 InCOll, payback rrOl loanl, II ..pect.d. Hllkun Itat.d thlt non. or the '11,000 ror Hou.lnv Dovnplr-ent ~'lllt.ne. wa. .pent. Thl. WI' a pilot pro'.ot but noon. hll Uled It. Hllklen Itlted Ih. would be Itt.ndlnv I thr..-dlY HOKI rundl trllnlnv In alnll. Clt)'. Th. City .ult COlpet. ror Itlt. rund.. ah. .xpect. the City to r,c.I,. betwe.n '700,000-'100,000. Th. Ipplloltlon ror th.l. rund. will be .ublltt.d lat.r. Itlrr will be brlnvlnv r.coe.tndatlon. Ind pro,.ct. to Houllnv Com.ll.lon o,.r the n.xt two IOnth. ror Ippro'll. Hllkun Itat.d Itlrr I. Itlll trylnv to vlt I 'll'IV' bulldln9 built. ~I.o, .tlrr I. workln9 with 'rl.ndl or Hlltorlo 'r'l.r'ltlon on 1O,lnv I hoUI. loclt.d on the corn.r or aowery , Dodv, to I property ownld by the City on ~und.11 .trl.t. Hotlon that /lou.ln9 Com.l..lon r.cOllllnd to CCH that 1I0ullnv ~Ihlbllltatlon b. rund.d ror "2',000, wa. .Id. by Hoor., ..eond.d by HeHlhon, olrrl.d 6-0. ~',,' I 1 "-.-'''-'-'''',---' . , 7f3 o [I -/ ,-, b .AGI 2 HIIIUTI. IOWA CITY NOU.INO COKKIIII~ 'I'~UAAY 11, 1112 Motlon that Kou.lnq co..l..lon r.co.Itnd to CCW that pr.r.r.nc. be 91.en tD tbo.e pro'ect. that ..et th. GOal. or the CHAI pl.n, wa. aad. by .or...n, ..~ondtd by ~.llly, carrltd-.-O. NOU.1NO AImlO~ITY UPO~T - HIIIDIUOII - I.ctlon . I Public Kou.lnq Update H.nd.r.on r.,llVld the Monthly .tatl.tlc. ~'port and .tated a ntW line hu be.n addtd to .how the nllllblr or 11I\I landlord. .nrolltd ror the IIOnth puttclpatlnq In the pf09rult H. nottd aha that Ltk.lld. l. a~~.ptlnq new partlclpant. a9.ln. A t.n.nt 9roup h.. be.n .tarttd at Ihaarock 'l.~. and 9rouP' at Hu.catln. A,.nu. and Wa.hlnqton Itr..t will be .tartlnq .oon. A NO'A viii be publl.htd ror C.rtlrl~at.. and Vou~h.r.. Kou.lnq co..l..lon ..-bIr. a9r.td that .t.rf .hauld put toq.ther .n appll~atlon packa9', - Update on Publlo Kou.lnq A~qul.ltlon .roJ.ct III hau... haw. be.n oUertd to dat.. Hary.... ollon vlll be looklnq at the unlU and Irflnqlnq vlth IlIID to do the appfll..l. ~apalfl n.tdtd lU.t be 1... than 10' of the pur~h... prl~. and the pur~ha.. prl~. 1. the appral.al prl~.. Th. ofr.r prl~. ..t. the parAllt.r. and unlt. lU.t ha,. be.n bullt before KIrch, 1111, the d.t. of the NO'A. Thlrty-four pack.t. ha,. be.n requ..ttd to d.t.. Th. d..dlln. ror .ubll..lon l. Har~h 16, 1112. , - Offl~. ~.ntal lpa~. Hou.lnq Authority .taff 1. belnq lncr...td vlth the addltlon or. Hou.ln9 'ptcl.ll.t. Th. curr.nt offl~. .pa~' of l'Oo.q ft 1. too .aall. H.nd.r.on .tated n..d 1. ror .bout Zooo.q ft. ~.loo.tlnq In the Cl,lo C.nt.r 1. not an optlon. Itarf va. looklnq at the Ooodvlll bulldln9 downtown but City Councll dot. not vant the ofrl~. to r.looat. In the downtown .r.a. It.ff l. .tlll looklnq for option.. DrlCU.lrON - Non. ADJOUIUIIllHT - Motion to adjourn at II" All VII aad. by Hoor., ..~ondtd by ~.llly, carrl.d 1-0. APPROVlO IY I " I 7f3 o CI '-I -] ;-f i~\pl ~r,l~J !~}J'JA~Y . . L.... tel r; i' SuL:::: ia XP~(OV3' MINUTES IOWA CITY PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION APRIL 2, 1992. 7:30 P.M. CIVIC CENTER COUNCIL CHAMBERS MEMBERS PRESENT: AM Bovblorg, Casey Cook. Pele Cooper, Sally Dlork., Richard Gibson MEMBERS ABSENT: STAFF PRESENT: Nancy Reid, Tom SCOII Miklo. Mulch. Chrlsllan.en, Nell \ CALL TO OROE6: Vice Chairperson Cook called the moellng to ordor .i 7:40 p,m. RECOMMEr-jOATIONS TO CITY COU~: I. Recommend approval by a 4.1 VOle (Diork. voting In the nogallvol 0' REZ92.0005 and SUB92.0006. an amendment to Iho Ihe plolimlnary and 1/1141 OPDH plan 01 Lot 98, 0 rosubdivl.lon 0' LOI 90. 01 Ty'n Cae Subdivlllon, Port II, to allow lor. a1nola".mlly rOlldentl.,lot on tho nOllhoolt cornor 01 Cambria Court and Coe Drlvo, .ub/ectto a slngle.lamily houso baing buill on lhis 101 that tho dwelling unll.hould 'aco Cao Drlvo and Ihatlhe drlvoway onlor Irom Cambria COUll. 1 2. Rocommend approval by . 4.0.1 VOle IGibson ab.talnlngl 01 REZU.0006, rozonJno Irom RM.145 and CI.lto P lor PIOPOrly localed along tho wo.t.'do 0' tho 800 block 01 Capllol Slroot. ~UBLlC DISCUSSION OF ANY ITEM NOT ON THE AGENQA: Thero was Mne. DE'lELOPMENT ITEM: I. S.91 U. Public discussion 0' an applicalion submlllod by Hodge ConslIuclion Company lor prolimlnory pial apPloval 0' Willow Crook Subdivision. a 8.15 acro. 20'/01 rosldonllallubdlvlslon localod allhe 10Ulhoost cornor of Iho InlorlOCllon 01 Mormon Trok Boulovard and Wast Bonton Slroot. 145.day Iimirallon porlOd: April 7, 19921 Miklo ropOrlod Ihattho rovlsod pIal had rOlolvod all ollho romalnlng dol/clonclo. and dlscropanclOl excoPtlor 0 nOlo logording tho roplacomont 01 tho .Idowalk on Mormon Trok Boulovard, Slall roquoslod Ihat 0 nOlO bo addod Ihallho dovolopor will romovo Iho o~lstlng four. foot sldowolk and loplaco It wllh on olghHootlldowalk. Miklo nOlod Ihallho Clly Would pay for Iho COSI 01 lour loot 01 Iho .Idowalk, Ho ropollod Ihotlho Public Worka Doportmont rovlowod Iho .lrOOI cross IOcllon and fOltlhatlhoy woro odoquoto butlhotlho Inclino might prosonl probloms In Inclomont woolhor. SloII rocommondod Ihallho dovolopor Involllgllo a plannod dovolopmont bocauso ollho 7ttf , t] [I -, '-I 13 P1annlno & Zon/no Commission Aplil2, 1992 Paga 2 10POQlaphy 01 Iho .110, bUI Miklo nOlod Ihal Iho dovolopOl cho.o 10 propo.o convonllonal dovolopmonl, Dlorks oxplOllod concorn. with Iho plopolOd InlO/locllon bolno .0 clo.o 10 Iho InIOl- mllon olllenlon SlIeol and MOImon Trak Boulevard. In Il!Sponu 10 a q<Jesllon frem Cook. Miklo Indlcalod lhallho Cily ISlOsponslblo 101 any OVOllllOd CO.I. ol.ldowalks on MOlmon TlOk Boulovlld. Ho oxplalnod lhallho Clly EnglnOllloolSlhallho oxllllno .Idowalk .hould bo romovod 10 ollow 101 Iho con.llucllon 01 a lovol sldowolk. In rosponso 10 0 quosllon 110m Cook. Miklo .Iolod IhalllOII and Iho opplicanl havo nOI dl.cussod WhOlhol or nOllho Clly .hould pay 101lOmoval ollho axl'llno .Idowalk. Bovblorg Indicolod Iho has concornslhal.uch a .IOOp grade bo nOlllhl.lnlorlOcllon. Miklo .ald IhalII Iho Commllllon has concorns IOgardlng Iho glOdo. Ihoy could dolor Ihl.llom and IOquosllhllllOII from Iho Public Works Dopartmonlanond Iho noxl moollng, Ho nOlod Ihls would roquilO 0 walvor 01 lho 45.day Iimllallon porlod. Publlo dI.cu.slon was oponod al 7:50 p.m. kl1ll~ SrlDhan. MMS ConsultanlS. usod Iho ovorhood PIOIOCIOIIO Ihow Ihallho II1s1 40.50 1001 Ollho plopolOd road has a Iwo porconl downwlld glodo. Ho Indlcalod Ihal Iho mlddlo IOCllon 01 Iho road slopu upward II a nino pOlconl and Ihon I. IOducod 10 allx pOlconl glOdo. Ho oxplalnod Ihallho IwO porconl Grado allho bon om ollho loadway Islntondod 10 provonl.lormwalor from IhlslUbdlvlslon 110m runnlng Oul onlO Bonlon 511001. Ho Indlcalod Ihallho vortlcal CUIVU holp 10 mlnlmlzo Iho ollocI' ollho glOdo, Slollon .Iolod lhallho CIly EnglneOl had concern. bmuso Ihl. Is nOla pllolllY 10ulO lor snow lomovaland mOlllbil/lY could bo a problom ba.od on Iho grade during Iho wlnlOl. Cook askod If Iho Public Works Dopartmonl haupprovod Iho 111001 gradu. Miklo IOspondod Ihallho glOdos moollho SlIndlldl 101 localsllOOII bocauso Iho grodo muSI bo undOl 12%, Glbsoll Indlcalod Ihal ho would havo 10 VOIO ogolnsllhlsllOm If a VOIO woro lakon al Ihls moo ling bocluso ho cannol undOrallnd Iho grade bosod on 0 vorbol doscllpllon, Ho .ald ho would plOllllo havo Ihlsltom dolorlOd 10 havo Iho Clly Enolnolrlng Ilall dlscUlllho grodo wllh Iho Commission. DIOIks IndlcalOd sho has concOIns with Ihls Ilopo bolng locolod so closo 10 Iho InlorsoCllon, Cook Indlcllod Ihal ho lools Ihls Is o complex IlIuo Ihalls dllllculllO addlOss In Ihls mannOlallh/s moollng. Public dl.cusslon wo. clolOd al 6:02 p,m. Cook oxplalnod Ihlllho quosllcn ollho SlOOp OlOdo musl bo addrouod mOlo clollly ond said Ihallho noxllnfc/mol moollno would bo Iho apploprlalo limo. Cook askod If Iho appliconl would bo willlno 10 OlOnlan oXlonslon ollho 4B.day IImllOllon. Bovbjorg movod 10 dolor 5.912310 April 18, 1992. Glblon .oconded. Tho mOllon cal/lod B.O, \ t I 7~~ - rl r, -/ '-I q - - Pl.Mlng & Zoning Commlulon AJlI~ 2, 1902 P.g. 3 In fG.potIlt to , qut.tlon 110m Mlklo. Hodg. gavo vO/ba' app/ova' to an aXlonllon 01 lho 4Sod.y Iimlllllon porlod. Cook Imod lholal lhol 11m. Ihoy could 0110 dilcuu tho luut 01 .xponl' rooording IIdowolk lomovol .nd loconluucllon. ZOtllNG MID DEVELOPMENT 'TEt.J1~: I, REZ92.ooo3 and SUB92.000!l. Public dllcuulon of an oppllcaUon lublnlllod by VIIl.g. P.nno/l 101 . IIZoning Itom RS.S 10 OPOH.S and 101 p/olimllllry OPOH and LSRO pI.n .nd JlIonmllllry Iubdivlllon plalapprovollor Villaoo G/oon Pan XII. a IS.15 .cro, 42.unll IIl1donll.J dovolopmonl, loealod wOSI 01 SCOll BoulovOId and aoulh 01 Musclllno Ayanuo on Vlllogo Road, 14S.day IimllOllon porlod: Ap/ill2, 19921 Cook IIPOIIOd INllhoro would bo al 111I1 IWO 100mal moollngl 10 allow lor public dlscuulon OllNllIOm bocoula IIII . lozonlno, Ha Iuouod Ihal no VOlO would ba lakon II IIliI moollng. Mlklo lIv1owod lho 110" IIPOlI dllod April 2. 1992. Ha lold 110" II anllclpOIlng Ihol lho IImolnlng dollclonelll and dilc/opanelos will bo 1010lvod bolo/o Iho nUllo/mol moo ling. S"II IIcommondod app/oval Ollholo Iloml upon losolullon ollho lomalnino dollclonclOl and discllponelol. In rosponlo 10 a quOlllon Itom Bovblo/o. Mlklo oxplalnod IhOllho uPOrodo ollho .owor Uno will bo II lho COil 01 Iho dovoloporl and nOllho Clly. Ho sold Iho IIno Iholll noodod 10 lorv. INs dovolopmonl will also IOrvo Iho Vlllogo Groon oroa IMl/omalnl 10 d.volop wNch II undor Ih. lomo ownorahlp, Cook rolorrod 10 a 101l0r Irom Robort WacMJ 1000lding Ih. 1110'1 high wOlor lablo. Ho said ho would IIko Iho Rlvorfronl & N.IUt.J A/III Commiaslon WOII.ndl Commllloo 10 moo I prior 10 Iho noxl Plonnlng & Zonlng Commlulon Inlorm.1 moollno In ordor 10 moko. rocommondOllon rogording Ihll 1110. \ I Publlo dllculllon WII oponod 01 B: 13 p.m. f,1ikll Catnev. 42 Wahlield Coull. Il000d IhOI ho II In lavor 01 melnlolnlno Iho Villogo Groon concoPI which II Ihal 01 opon Ipeco surroundod by housos, Ho said Ihls JlIovldol lor a grOOl doll 01 opon IPOCO. IIduCII 1I0"lc and Incroo... sololY In Iho lonso 01 communily. Ho IndicOlod ho dOli nOllool you can gOllhl1 with a condo. mlnlum Illulllon, Ho roforrod 10 a 101l0r rogardlng Villogo Groon IhOllndlcalod IhOllho opon 01111, gllon IPOCOSOnd wOlkwaysaro conslslonl wllh Iho proyamno philosophy 01 urban plannino, Tho 101l0r nOlod thaI lhoso amonlllu Incrouo Iho valuo 01 P/oportlOlln lho Villaoo Groon aroo. COlnoy nOlod lhallho qualilY ollho aroa Is ollon allmpononllo 0 buyol II II Iho qualllY ollhe houso lholls bolno pU/chasod, In roo Old 10 1I0rmwalor drolnaoo, COInoy sold Ihol curronUy slormwolor drolnslrom Iho p/opolOd dovolopmonllllo 10 Iho soulh lowards oxlsUnO dovolopmonl. Ho polnlod oUI Iho locollon ollho IIOrm sowor Inlellhal drains lho aroo and nOlod Ihollho drolnago onlllneoll ulually blockod, Ho uprouod Iho concorn lholl/lho dovalopmanl SilO has on lnerooso In olovallon Iho Impocl Ollho SlormwOlor 10 Iho proportlos 10 Iho soulh will bo Inlonllllod, COlnoy oxproued concorn 100ordinO lho chango In grodo lor lho 71'/ [I [I -/ 8 [I Plonnlno & Zon/no Commlulon ApllI 2. 1992 Pogo 4 , ~ ' 1110 IV.lom and lhollhl. would roduco il..flOCI/yon.... H. notod tho I It ,pllf.ra thol Iho orOl ahown on Ih. coneopl p1.n 10( MUI. phaau 01 d.yolopmonllo lho nollh 01 Iho plopo.od .100mw010l dOlanllon linin hot 0 hlohtr danlllv than AS.S. Ho nOlod thai thI. cou.u uolllc ploblam., C.lnoV laid INIII lhoro I. 0 /Oronlng, II would bo plalo"oblo 10 ju'I/Orono lho orll plopoltd 10/ condomlnlum. ond nol Iho,o 101. p'QPQ~d 01 alnglo.lomlly doYOloomanl. pory Non!.. 18 Worw~k Clrela. uplolnod lhol ho I. ploaldonl 01 lho VlIlogo Groon Homoownor. Auoclollon. Ho nOlod INI ho hal had ltyorallonglhV diaculalOlU with lho daYOIOllfr ond Itld ho II .xcllOd 10 .001ho Vinogo Groon coneopl bolno complOlad. NoOlo .xplolnod Ihlllhoro oro 171 homo. CUllonllv conllluclod In Villog. Groon ond Indlcolod lhal POll XI win odd ,pploxlmol.lv onolhor 40 homu. H. .u....d lhal ho lool'lhov haYO ulobllah.d o II and old 01 homo In lho V.nogo Groon oroo whlch ruulll In .om. coneorns/Ooordlno Ihl. dOYGlopmonl. Noglo ..p/olnod INI ono coneOln Illho .010lv 01 lho loko ond nOlOd lhol tbpponl ond lnopplopllolo romoru woro modo rogordino lho lone1no ollh. lok. Ollho Commlnlon'llnlO/mol mool1no. H. /OpoIlod Ihol Iho" I. 0 hlOh numbor 01 ctllld/On In lho Vlllogo Gro.n oroo .0 Iho lake I. · algnlllconl coneorn lor ruldonl', Noglo uplolnod lhal momboll 01 Iho Homoownor. Anoclollon mOl wllh Ih. dovolOllfr ond como up wllh Ih.ldoo 01 lonclng bolwoon lho condomlnlum.. Ho luonod lhallho condomlnlum. win bo m4rkOIOd 10 llfoplo who mov nOI hovo childron ond INllho condominium. con IOIYO o. . bullor bolwoon Iho alnglo.lomllv dovolopmonl.nd Iho loko. Ho 'I/Onod INI no lool.INllho Commllalon ahould ju'l /Orono Iho orOlIhOII. plopolOd 10/ condominium. ond IlIvo Iho oroo plopo.od 10/ a1nglo.lomilv dovolopmonlll AS'S, Noglo nOlod INI ho IOU voluo Ollho loko 110 vlsuol onhoneomonllO/ Iho dovolopmonl ond Ihov 010 nOI loquullno INI 0 10.1001 high loneo bo consuuclod. Ho omph4a1rod IhOllhov almplv wonl plOIOcllon bocouso IhoV 010 coneornod IOgolding 1M ..lolV ollho oroo 10/ childron. Ho nOlOd Ihol donso vogolollon could 0110 IOrvo IhillVPO 01 bullorlng Il\lIposo. Noglo oddr...od Iho Inuo 01 011'11I001 parking and soid In Villogo GlOon Ihov try 10 koop call Irom bolno porkod on Iho SUOOI.. Ho o.p1olnod INllhI. I. ono ollho 1I0ndolds Ihov hovo triad 10 ollobli.h and Ih.y would Iiko 10 .00 conllnullv IhroughouI Villogo Groon, Noglo .Iolod INI ho 1001. Iho dovolopor. .hould 0110 dovolop Iho omonlllo.ln Ihls dovolopmonl and lhl. would Includo Iho OlOon .pom. Ho .uoasod IhOllllhould nOI bo Iho Homoownorl Anoclollon IOIPon.illdilV 10 lond.copo Iho oroon .poco. Ho IOponod Ihol cu"onllv Ihov molnloin Iho glOon .pam ond roploco bushos and lroO. whon nOCOSlOrv. Noglo nOlod IhOllho cul'do"oc loIlow. Iho Villa go Groon coneopl, bUI dou nOI Includo 0 oroon spoco Ollho middlo ollho circlo. Ho nOlod Ihol Iho groon .pocu Ollho mlddlo 01 cuf'do,lOc, 010 ulOd bv ruldonll and Ihoro loom. 10 bo on obondonmonl ollho concopl plan lOt luluro dovolopmonl. Noglo .trmod Ihol Villogo GlOon POlIsl.X hovo 0 .orlo. ol.idowolk.ond IhI. plan do.. nOI.oom 10 allow lor sldowolk.. Ho .old ho would liko 10 100 IhI. 'nuo oddroasod 1I0couII Iho Hornoownors AlloclOllon .hould nOI bo lO.ponsiblo lor adding .Idowolks 01 0 10101 dOlO. Noglo roponod IhOllho mO'IOl plan dono by Noglo & McClOady showod 0 conuslly locolod pork lor Villogo G"on, Ho laid ho loolllhol complollon 010 pork would bo -------r---- \ I j 78~ n n -/ 8 ' I - - Planning & Zoning Commission April 2. 1992 Paga 5 banallclal. Ha lAid lho only ploposad grean Ipaco II nOI conllOlly locolod IOf Iho Villoga Groon orlland II simply I "'"0W Ipaco bahlnd I houlo. Naglo Slid ho II glad 10 100 growlh ollho V11lago Groon Ilea Ind wlnlllllo ba conslllonl whh Panl I.X. Miklo nOlod lhal Iho City roqulr.. IwO 011'111001 Il'.klng IpaC.. 10( s/nolo"amUy da..llopmant. ~lavlI Qulglav. 1 t Wakallald COUll. oXplosaod COllCOIn whh Iho omounl olllllllc on Woyne Avonuo. Ho OlplollOd cOllCorn Ihlt I1II bacorn.. mOfI hoavily lIavonod wllh on'IIIOOI parking Ihon II will bacomo I mOfO dangOloul situation. olpaclaUy 10( chlldron. Ho notod lhallho Villago Groon HornoowNrs Alloclallon wOIlnlluonllal1n gOlllng lavoralllop Ilgnlln lho ar.. 111I lOO\mor. \ Oall Keller. !II Wakelleld COUll. Indicllod lhal thoro 110 35 childran llIldorlho slxlh gllda on Wakallold COUll, Sha Slid lhal on Iho~ way to Ichool.lhoy will pall by lho proposod lako Ind mony will be 11IIoctod to Iho lako, 1C01l0r oxplolnod lhallho 10011 thara will ba a drowning In tho lako lilt II not bullorod Of 101 back lanhOl "om lho rood. Sho slIouad thallhoy boughllholr homo becouso lhoy llIldOlatood Ihla would bo a alnglo.lamlly dovolopmonl. Sho omplles/lod Ihot IIlhay had wanlod 10 Ilvo Nil Ilako. Ihoy would havo boughl plopany Ihol waalocllod Ilfllalako. ~Q~lI. !l0 WekellDld COUll, llkod who would hmllabilily IOf ony occldonll thai would occur ot tho loko. Ho nOlod lhallh, HomoownOlI Alloclatlon cOlllos /Ioblllly Insural1Co lor Iho opon apms. Ho IIld IIlh, HomoownOla Allocllllon would bo /Iablo lor accldonll at Iho lako. Ihon ho would nOI bo In lavO( 01 Iho ViI/ago Graon HomoownOlI AlSocllllon occopling Ihla 1I001nl0 mombarlhlp. 1 Cook raponod Ihlllho Cily would nOI hovo any IlabllilY and lho Immodlalo /IabilllY would bo on Iho ownlls 01 Iho condominium I. Ho auggoslod Ihoy could ahoro lIabililY with I!lo oxisllng Vlllogo Gloon HomoownOlI AIIOClollon ltuough nogollollons. Julie Cbrl!llan!Dn. 34 Wakellold COUll, nOlOd Ihol hOl propllly obulllho proposod dovolopmonl, Sho Olplolnod thol olomonla.y Iludonta 110m Iho Slorllng 1101 CUI Ihrough 10ls on Wokollold Coun 10 gOllo achoollo IhllO would bo 0 high numbOl 01 chlldron Ihal would ba oxposod 10 Iho loko. Sho oxprollod conCllna oboullho omount 01 wOIII In tho 0100. Sho roponod lhal Iho film flold In Iho 1100 haa 011 on boon unplonlOd bocouso olllondlng WOIII. Sho oskod IIlho cUllonlrosldonlS would bo ouould lor Iho COSI 01 upgrading Iho 10wor, Cook rOlpondod Ihollho dovolopor would bo lololy rOlponsiblo, bUI could POllINI oxponlo on 10 now ownorlln Iho orao. Ho sllomd Ihollhllo would ba no bono III 10 tho CUllonl ownars ao thay would nOI ba aisOIIad. Penov Ooorno. 19 Wakelleld COUll. IIOlod hlr moln concarn Illha IAfOly 01 chlldran In IIgOld 10 Iha loka. Sha lAid sho Is nOI opposad 10 Iho condominium dovolopmanl. bUllold Iho 10011 only tho 0111 proposod lor condominium I Ihould bo IIl0nod. 1Sl/ D [I -/ 8 ,? PlaMlng & Zoning Commission ApllI 2. 1992 Pago 8 David Mallnl. 38 Wakel/ald COUll. Ilalod Ihal thoro ara 10rlOUI walolllloblomlln lho nolghbOlhood, Ho Indlcatod ho hos 0 concOln thalff lholo II any InCIOUo In olovotlon thll would Inclom tho omount of IlOlmwalOllunoll 101 oMlltlng dovolopmont. Ho said ho doos not 1001 thattlllng would holp with tho ploblom 01 tho ImmodlOlO lunoll. Ho notod that tho oxlsllng dlaln In lho araa Illnadoqualo. Molino notod lhot PodOllllon ond bicyclo 1I0fllc oliO como "om lho Slorllng araa In ordolto rooch Villago Avonuo. In IIsponlo to . quos lion "om Bovb)org. Molino Ita lad lh411~1. " MI A buemenl In hiS houso and that ho knows 01 no housos within tho alOo lhot hovo bolomontl. Dick Back. 28 Wakal/ald Courl. Italod that wotOlln lho 0100 1I0wsllom tho north to tho aoulh. Ho notod thotln tho pUlIOVOIol YOOlllhoro hovo boon 10voro 1lI0bloml with Ilondlng wOlolln tho 0100. Ho nOlod lhol hll nolghbOI hod IOlIlood tl.. thot WOIt lunk Into tho ground that hod bogun to 1I0at 01101 hoovy lain. Ho II/ouod thottho wotOl doos not dlaln odoquololy 10 ho II concolnod thot any Incltuo In olovallon would causo addlllonol stolmwator plobloml, Ho oxplalnod thai ho Is Ikoptlcol U to how olloctlvo lho Wing Iystom will boo GalY Naglo askod what parts ollhll addillon would bocomo tho losponllbility 01 tho Villago GlOon HomoownOlS Assoclallon, Lal/v Schnl11lal. MMS Consullanls. slalod lhatlho cUl/ont plan only IIzonos Loti 23 and 24 to OPOH and thosa ala tho lOll whoro tho condominiums alO Ploposod. Ho lold tho only lOason tho othor 1011 woro Includod on tho In/llal application In lho IOzonlng II bocauso ono applicallon was filod 101 bOlh lho IOzon/ng and lho lubdlvlslon. SchnilllOlll/ossod that tho cUl/onlly dovolopod portion 01 Villogo GlOon II not onllllly conllstonl with tho ollglnal conCOPl plan 101 Vlllogo GlOon. Ho nOlod lhot 101 uomplo. tho ollglnal plan did not Includo lho locond colloCIOl Slloot. SchniltjOl omphoslzod lhat lho ollglnal dovolopOl Is no longol Involvod In lho Plojoct and tho now dovolopor's dOlllos 010 nOl COmplololy conslslonl Wilh tho ollglnal plan, Ho notod thai Wakoflold COUlt doos not havo groon spaco In lho COntOl 01 Iho cul.do.sac. In IOgald to bmmonls. Schnllt)ol lopoltod Ihat Chuck Schmadoko said that tholO could bo no bosomonlS In lho alOo thai 010 low or Ihon lho cUlb olovollon. Ho said bosomont' con bo pormlltod If Ihoro Is 0 liling ,yslom 01 an oUllot lor lump pumps. SChnllt)OI IOportod Ihal thOlo II no way 10 ovoid having 0 1I0rmwOIOl dOlonllon bosln In thl, alOa bocouso It Is nocoSSDIY and loquilod, Ho said Iho dovolopolloltlt would bo bost to doslgn lho basin as on amonllY, In ruponso 100 quollion Irom Cook. SChnlltjolllld It would bo possiblo 10 doslgn lho SlormwalOI dOlonllon basin nOl to bo 0 wot bolt om basin. In losponso to 0 quolllon 110m Diorka, SchnlltlOI Itolod Ihot If Iho alOa Ploposod 101 condominiums woro doslgnod 101 singlo.family lots, lho bosln would not bo much dlflolont as It Is cUl/onlly Ploposod, Cook olkod If tho lillng syllom could handlo lha surlaco 1I0w. SChnllljal ralpondod lhat In lural sltuallons thalo ora ollan Ilsallthat Inlolcopt somo of Iho sur'aco walOI. Cook nOlod lhat tho PUIPOSO 01 tho 1I0rmwalOl ordlnanco Is to plovont now dovalopmont 110m having a nagollvo Impact on oMlsllng dovolopmont. Ho olkod If this plan could bonofll oMlsllng dovolopmonlln lho aloa, SchnllljOllolpondod Ihat ho fools tho tilo IYllam would ImplOvo lho ulsllng Iltuallon, In luponso to a quosllon 110m COOPOI, Schnlll)ol said lhatlho tllo IY'lam w~uld ba lho losponsiblllly 01 a HomoownOlS Aasoclallon, and It could ba tho ontllO 71~ i j i , j I I I I rl r, -/ 8 3 - - Planning & Zoning Commlulon Aptll 2. 1992 Pago 7 Villago Groon Homoownor. Assoclallon, alubsocllon 01 Iho Villogo GrOIn Homoown. .r. Alloc/al/on. or an ontlroly .0paral0 Homoownor. Assoclallon. Ervin Glovlg askod WNI would Nppon 1I1ho Villago Greon Homoownor. Alloclallan dOli nOI .CCOpl Iho opon .roll ond Iho now rosldonl' do nOl wonl 10 'orm 0 homoownor. lIIoclollon. Chtl.llonson rospondod INllho Cily will nOI molnloln Iho .roo .0 tho dovolopor will nood 10 provo INllhero I. 0 mochonJ.m 10 OUW, !h411h4 .roa wiD be malnlalned Ihtough porpolullY. Ha no lad INI. homeownerlllloclallon I. alyplcol woy 10 achlevo lhl. gool. pill Franrr. aDDU. .lalOd INI ho hll.lwoYllnlondod Ihola laporalo homoowner. lIIoclat/on would bo lor mod lor Iho condominium ownors ond Ihoy would occopllull 1I0bllilY 101 Iho loko. Ho uld INlln OIdor for Iho oxl'llng lubdlvlslon 10 hovo Ihe 011. .11001 parklno IpacOl. Ihls would raQulro lhallhoro bo IwO slall goragos with lout .paco. In Iho drlvoway. Franlz Indlcalod Ihal 0 parking Ipaco mUSI bo 18 1001 In longlh 10 Ihll would tOQulro 38.1001 drlvoways, Ha nOlod lhal ho did n0110l many. drlvoway. In Iho exlsllng Vlllago GrOIn dovelopmonlS lhol hovo 36.fool drlvowoy.. In rogold 10 lho conlrolly locOIOd rocroollon oroo. Frontz nOlod Ihol Ollho limo Iho original plan wlllormod Ihoro woro nOlllormwalor basin rOQulromonll. Ho Slid lhll arOll1 now noodod lor allormwalor dOlonllon basin undor lho rogulallons. Publlo d1,cuu/on WII clolOd al 9:28 p,m. \ I , Dlorkl exprOlSod concorn rogording acelll lor omorgoncy vohlclos II a lonco Is conSlrUClod bOlwoon lho condomlnluml. Sho sold lhls could bo a problom. ospaclolly IIlhoro II donso vogalallva landscaping and a lonca, Miklo nOlod Ihal Iho plan curronlly dOOln'l show 0 lonco, bUllndlcalod lhallho F1ro Dopallmlnl would rovlow lho plan agoln lIalonco II shown. GlbsOll slalod lhallha Slormwalor ord/nanco In a son so oneouragOl condomlmum dovolopmonl bocauso Iho bosln con lorvo as opon sPoco: Ho said ho accapll Goil Kollor'. commonll rogordlng II you wonllO livo by 0 body 01 wOlor Ihon you would bo likoly 10 occopt lomo 01 Iho rosponslbililY for your childron. Ho lold Ihol ho undormndl lhalll Is 0 dlllorontllluallon whon 0 loko Is proposod lor your backyard. Ho .1I0uod Ihal accoplanco 01 lIabililY moy nOI bo Iho only r..ponso 10 lholo concorns. Ho uprossod eoncorn Ihal SIlOOIS loom to only bo addrauod whon a dovolopmonlll proposod and nOlod lhal a grool doal 01 Ira file I, bolng placod on lho IwO roads that como out 01 Villogo Oroon. Ho nOlod lhoro Is no point In pun/ng In a wolkwoy Iyslom 01 lhls polnl, Ilnco dovolopmonl hal alroldy occurrod lhrough much 01 lho dovolopmonl, Ho slalod Ihll I. 0 prlco lholll pold lor Incromonlol dovolopmont, Gibson Slid Iho dovolopmonl 01 Iho groon spoco and liabllllY lor Iho pond b~lh nood to bo addro...d, Cook IIOlOd Ihol ho would aecopl r..ponslbillly for Iho fIIppont commonlthll wos modo ollholnformol mOIling, Ho SlId ho shoros concorns rogordlng hovlng tho basin IDIVO bOlh Iho purposo 01 Slormwolor dOlonllon ond 01 0 Pllllvo rocroollonollpocO. I I " . 78' , I, ! r I 1 i' , , . , ---.t , I t'':<'''''' t] CI -, 8 'i PlIMlng & Zoning Commllllon AIl/U 2, 1882 Plge 8 He old ho do.. nOI 1001 a lance II lho ani war, bul would conlldar having. non,wel bonom balln In Ihll Ir'... Glblon ull/...od cOllCorn whh !ne"llIng Iho pavomonl by having 10 much o"'II"el parking In 1M drlvowlY. Ho luggOllod narroworll"OII mlghl bo noc....ry lOt Ihll lyP4 !I! M!g!\M!h!l9d, Bovbltrg ..kod 10( Inlormlllon on how lho lile IYllom would bo m.lnl.lned. Schnllllor rolpondad lhallho only mllnlonance ho lor..... II ucav.llon Ind rop.lr IIlhoro II b1ocklgo. DIerks moved 10 dolor R1Z02000031nd SUB820000S 10 AprU 16, 1892. Bovb/arG lecond.d. FranlZ .grOld 10 0 wllvor ollho 4Sod.y Iimllallon parlod. The modon carrl.d S'O. 2. ~ Public dllcuulon 01 .n applic.llon lubmlllod by Jim Cilugow . Conauucllon 10( I rozoning Irom RS.8 10 OPDH.8 .nd prollmln.ry OPDH and LSRD pI.n IpP/ov.IIOt Wlthlnglon Squ.rl Condomlnluml. I 2.04 .cro, 16.unll rosldonllol dovolopmonl, locI lad lllho norlhwlIl cornor 01 tho InlOflocllon 01 Scon Boulovard and Wlahlngton Slrool..14Soday Iimllollon parlod: April 13. 1092.1 Miklo rovlawod tho 110" roporl dOlod APlil 2. 1092. 510" rocommandad approvol upon rOlolullon 01 Iho dollclanclOl ond dlscroponclos. Public cllculllon wu oponod II 9:48 p.m. ... '--r~'~r' I ' i Thoro wu nono. Public cllculllon wu clolOd 01 9:48 p,m. Coopar movod 10 dolar REZ02.000410 April 16, 1992. Ciibson IOcondod. Tho mOllon c."'ld 5.0. Glugow Igroad 10 . w.lvar ollho 4S'd.y IImllOllon porlod. 3. ~iOO!llnd SUa~.OQQQ,. Public dllcuulon 01 an Oppllc.llon submlllad by Ty'n C.o Condomlnlum Allocl.llon 10 amond tho prollmlnory ond IInal OPDH pion 01 LOl98, I rolubdl,vlllon 01 LOI 80. Ty'n Coo Subdlvlllon, Pili 2, 10 allow lor a l/nglo.I.mlly rolldonllollol on Iho nOllhOllI cornar 01 Com brio COUll ond Coo Orlvo. 14S.doy Ilmhallon parlod: April 12, 1002.1 Mulch ropollod lhol ha hod IOvlawod Iho Clly Council mlnulOl, public Inpul allhOlD mOIling I. and lonars IOcolvod .nd lound no dlscuulon 01 . roqulromanllholthls 101 ". "i,.;"~~~'''''' ,,,,,,,,,~,.,,~--,,,,,'" ~'"....'__;..... :....,._"";...._"i.". .. 7''/ . t] Cl -/ 8 5 Plann/no & Zonlno Commlulon Aptll 2, 1992 Pago 9 bo lotalnod 101 common open .paco. Ho nOlod that 011 dol/clonclo. and dllclOpanclOl hid beon IOloIvod by tho opplicant. Publlo lI.cuu/on WII opened at 9:51) p.m. Nell Mock. 2~41 Cell D(bj. .lItod that 11'010 hat beon conlllucllon In tho 1101 101 Ipptoxlmltoly tlvoo YOII.. Sho Indicotod aha I. not.Ufptl.od thllo WIIO no 101111. Irom nolghboll 0( public Input whon tho OIlgllIIl.ubdivlllon took placo bocau.o lho 1101 WII not dovoloped It lhattlmo. Sho nOlod IhlllhalO I. I .chool bU.IIOP Ind . clly bu. IIOP on thll COlnol. Sho .llOuod lhat aho dOt. nOI 1001 lhat II will bo In .1lllCllvo p1oco to build Of In Imonlty 100Iho nolghbolhood. Sho notod that a. In open Ipaco. thl. lot Plovldol ,oliol Irom tho mulll.lamlly dovolopmont In tho nalghbolhood. Mock .talod aho hal pellOlllny pllnlod olghtllOOI on tho lot and lhat lhay hlvo beon mowod down. Sho IIld aha would be wlll1no to continuo to allompt to mllnllln Ind ImPIOVO Iho lot II II WIIO 10 IOmlln undovolopod. .11m Buck. 2353 Cell D(~,.tllod lhal ovon Ihough lhllO I. no ovldonco In Iho Council mlnuto. Ihlt lNllot WII dodicltod a. open .paco, Ed Thoml., who lold Nm N.lot, .ald tN. lot had to bo lOt Illdo 101 open Ipaco 10( Ihl condomlnlum., Ho I.kod that Iho Commlulon wlitlOl OOOlgo NIglo to IOlurn to 10wI City 10 vOllly INlluuo. Buck '11d hi bought N. lotlollholr homo boCIUIO lhoy likod having tho opon Ipaco In lho 1101, HI.ald .toll .hould a.k lho ollglnal dlvoloporalOllholllmplmlonslltho tlml Iho 1101 WII I/llt dovolopod. Buck IOld ho would 11.0 Iiko to havo any housoto bo bullt on tNs/otto bo obllgod by I covonantlhatl. .Imillr 10 Iho covonantlhlt runl wllh N. property. Ho nOlod Ihal whilo addino INI houlo mlY bo Ippropllato whon ono conlldll. tho donllty 01 tho ontllO Ty'n CII 1101, ho 1IIOIIOd thlllhl. particular alO. hll Ngh donlity. Ho nOlod lhal ho foolllh.t carlon CII Olivo .nd Camblla COUlt will h.vo diUlcully .oolng ono anolhllll 0 houlo I. conllluctad on this cor nil lot. &m4 , plos/danl 01 lha Ty'n CII Homoownll. Auocl.lIon, Slid thay bagan tho plocm 01 soiling thll ploparty bacaula 01 on amplY lot II COltl Ihom opproxlmaloly 12,000 oMuolly 101 upkaap and tml. Ha lold ho IhoughtlholO would ba no objacllonlll only 0 Ilngla.lamily homo WOIO plopolOd. Ha Slid thoy hova on ollllth.t would IOlultln tho conlllucllon 01 0 14,000 .qualO 1001 ronch houso In Iho '200,000 prlco longa. Rolmll Slid ho wal.urprl.ad lhlla wlla oblacllonl ond nOlad thot thlla loam. 10 bo no woy to coma to on oglOaoblo complomlla, Ha 1IIOIIad Ihatlho lOlls not davolopod 01 0 pork ond "opOlloward. tho condominium.. Ha Slid ha wa. awalO that 1100. hod boon planlod on Iha lot. but Ihoughtlhat kldl hod plonlad Ihom. Ha naiad lhatthay did lIy to IOloln Iho 11001. bul oxplOlIOd 'ulprlsa to find out who hod aClually planlOd lhasa 11001 on thall Ploporty. Ralmar .lImod lhot ho doa. not 1001 0 .lngla,lomily hou.o would dlmlnl.h Iha valuo of axis ling homo. In lha 0101 and ho I'" no ploblom wllh vl.lon for drlvOlI atlho cornaro Ha nOlOd that salbackllOqullOd bv Iha City Codo .hould plOvanllho houlO "om baing on ObSllucllon to drlvlI', Don ZlIvele. 1154 Climb/III COlin, Ty'n Coo Homoownora Auocl'llon mom bar. oxplollOd hll aglOamonl wllh Roimar. Ho nOlod Ihal whila IhOIO hOl boon Pill 78f t] [I -/ 8 b Planning & Zoning Commlulon Aptll 2. 111112 Paga 10 conllrucllon In tho arOl. this was 101 multl.lamllv conlllucllon. Ho IOld lhIt conl,rUCllon 01. Ilngl..I.milv homo would havo a much 1011 algnllicantlmpoct on Iho nolghbOlhood, Ho sllouod lhal ho laols POll conllluctlon bV olholl ahould nOI havt . boarlng on this doclllon. Ho sllOllod lhatthov 110 not rOlponslblo 101 plomIlUthat wo,. mado bV thCl Pllt plOpolly ownor and dovoloparl, Ho sllOllod that tll/I lot II oxponaivo lor Iho ownolllO maintain and thatth. Inlolloctlon ahould not bo ovt.'y dangorous. Ha said that this Ilructur. would allo lltovldo 0 bullor betwoon ~ oxlStlng mull/.familv dovolopmontand lho ainglo.lamllv dovolopmont. Ho IOId ho laols It would be unlalr to havo tho homoownors ouoclallon maintain this lot 101 tho onjoymant ollho nalghbOls. Public dllcusaion w.. dOlod al f 0: 1 0 p.m. Bovbferg moved 10 opprovo REZ02.0005 ond SUB02.0000, on oppllcatlon 10 omlnd Iho plOnmlllJry ond "nil OPOH plan 01 Lot 98, a IOllIbdlvlaion 01 LOI 00 01 Ty'n CII Subdlvlllon, Pin 2. 10 anow lor a slnglo.lamllv lOaidonl/a1 lot In Iho nollhollt corner 01 Clmbrll COUll and Cao Orlvo IIIb/octtO IlIngll.llmUv hoU11 bo/ng bullt on thlllot that tho dwolllng lIn1tlhould Ilco C.o Orlva.nd lhattho drlvaw.v antll "om C.mbrl. COIlIl. Olblon locondad. In rOlponso to a qUOlllon "om Glblon, Mulch Indica lad th.tlha Tr.lIlc Englnoor IIId rovlowod tho Ilto and lOW no llfoblomsll conlllucllon woro to occur on thll lot. Ho . notod thatlOtblcka would applv Iult as thay do with olhor COlnOr lOti In low. City. Bovblorg alkod II thoro would bo Ilmlll on vogolatlon that could be pl.ntld on thll silO. Mulch stalod IlIIlthl, luuo II addromd bV lho Clly OrdlllJnc:o. Olorkl oxpromd coneornl bocaulo ollho dltliculllnlorloctlon adl.conllO Iho 101. Sho laid II would be proforablo 10 IIIvo InlOlmallon from lho OIlglll4l dlvoloper to know wlllt his undorlllndlng ollho lilllalion WII. Mulch 1lI00IOd llllt documonls woro rovlowod and Ihoro WII no monlion olth/s 101 being inlondod al opon spoco. Ho nOlod tllll Ed Thom.. had slgnod a numbll ollholo documonrs. In rOlponso 10 0 quOltlon Irom Dlorka, Mulch 1I.lod Ihollho original dovolopor could hovo had Iwlco as much donsllv II WII consuUClod In tho dovolopmonl. Ho nOlod IlIIt anothor subdivision 01 this U'CI would roqulro ollmilar rOlonlng roquOII. Giblon notod lhallh/lllan unfOllunllo Illuollon, bUI IUOIIod lhalthoro Is no quolllon IlIItlhlsls an approprlalo UIO lor Ihls 101. Cook said lhol II tho condominium ownOIl hovo cloor lilIo 10 this proporty. thon thoro II no logol mOlnl 10 provon! Ihls rOlonlng, Ho IlrOllod thol ha faols Ihoro Is abundant opon IPOCO In Iho oroo and a lulIlclonllox bOlO II noodod 10 SUp POll OUt parks, Olorks alkod IIlhoro would bo logol rOllonllO donv lh/I rOlonlng. Chtlltlonlon rospondod that Ih/I II a rOlonlng and not a Iubdivlllon. Ho laid Ihol wllh a Iubd/vlllon. IIlho roglllotlonl aro mOllhon go nor ally Iho propolal must bo approvod. Ho Indlcotod lhot wllh a rOlOnlng, Ihoro Is moro 01 an luuo 01 why you con dony a rozonlng with Ihoro bolng a hlghor thrOlhold boloro a Clly aC11 IlIogolly. ChtlltlonlOn saId ho 1001 no com polling logo I rOlson on ollhor lido 01 Ihll Inuo and would rocommond Ihotlho Com minion conco",ralo on Iho planning InuOl, Ho nOlod thai ovon IIlhlslot hod boon Ihown .. opon IPOCO on tho plot. tho plot cOllld bo omondod. Olorkl oxprouod concorn wllh rOlllbdlvldlng lOll In nolghborhoods that havo olroodv boon dovolopod, 7fr i I ! ! , I I ! I Cl [I -, 8 ~f Plonn/no & Zonlng Commlsslon April 2, 1992 Pogo II Tho mol/on cortlad on a 4.1 VOla. IClarh vOI/ng In Iha nagollva,l 4. REZ920000B, Public dllCuulon 01. Clly.lnlllalod Itzonlno Irom RM.145.nd CI.lto P lor propOIlY loco led .Iono the wtllllde 01 Iho 600 block 01 S. COP/lol SlIeot. Glb'Q!\ '~cy"d hlmsell IIem lho Ccmmlulon balad ilill~omplilibiliiy 01 oliico on IIIe neXllNeo Items. Mulch rev/ewod tho 11011 repoll dOled April 2, 1992. 51011 recommendad .pprovol 01 REZ92.o006. \ Publlo dllculllon W'I opanad '110:25 p.m. Thara WDl nona. Public dllculI/on WDl clOIId a110:25 p,m. Bovbfarg movad 10 .pprovo REZ02.0000 Ih. razonlng 110m RM.14510 CI.f 10 P lor propany locolad along Iha wall IIda ollha 800 block 01 S, C.pllol Strlll. Coopar lacondad. Tha mOllon corrlad 4,0.1. IOlbson obslo/nlngl 5. BEZ~2.00071 Public discussion 01. Clly.lnitloled rezoning Irom RM.145to PRM lOt propOIlY located gonorolly belwoen Clinlon and Dubuque Slroel and DovenpOIl and Jollorson SlIeels Including Ihe properly loco led 01 tho soulhom cornor 01 tho Intellecllon 01 Clinton ond Jollellon SlIeets. \ I 8. REZ92.0Q.Ql. Public discussion 01 0 Chy.lnlllOlod rOlonlng Irom RM.145 10 PRM lor propellY loco led gonerolly belween NeWlon Rood, U.S. Highway 8 and Wool! Avenuo. Miklo revlewod the 11011 reporl dOled April 2. 1992. Public dlsculI/cn was opened el1 0:31 p,m, Clndv Pmons. 1131 E. WIsh/nnlon SlIaar, sloled lholsho ownl Iho proporty Ihot would bo olloclod by lhls rolonlng. Sho sold Ihoro Is 0 problem wllh congosllon and parking In tho hlgh.donlflY area on lho nOllh sldo, bUI sold Ihot sho lools 0 rolonlng Is not whol WOuld holp Ihls slluollon, Sho nOlOd Ihollho dormllorlos so om to gonOlolo Iho call In tho oroo. POllonl sold sho ownl olght units on Iho nOllh lido ond ollon tlmostononls do nOI hovo call. Sho suggoslod lhollho problom with Iho RM.145 lono might bo thai It doos nOI roqulro onough parking, Sho saId Iho 10011 Ihll Is on oqullY Issuo bocouso mlny hova Invaalod bocauso 01 tho dovolopmant pOlanllol avolloblo In Iho RM.145 zono, Sho laid 0 rolonlng would bo punishing pooplo who modo lhlllypo ollnvoslmonl, Sho notod IhollhOlO was also shOll nOllco glvan which ollowod 1I1l10 limo lor proparollon lor lhls hoorlng. POllonslOld Iho lools tho Issuos oddlmod In Iho PRM lono 010 Incongruous with lho dovolopmonl Ihol oxlsllln Iho 0'00, Sho IndlCOlod thai sho bolloyos OS long as do,mlto,'os and soro,ltlos 0'0 located 7''1 r r -/ FI 8 )) -- P10Mlng & Zoning Commllllon Apld 2, 1992 Pogo 12 In lho "00, lho plob!oml will conllnuo 10 OXIII. 5ho uld IOqulrlng molO porklng lOt dovolopmonlln lho RM.145 rono looml mOlo oquhoblo ond lonllblo, "ftrv MIJlIer. 13 LindO! Vollev Circle. uld ho dlloglOOI wllh Iho propolOd IOron/ng on Iho WOlllldo. Ho laid ho II olio concornod whh Iho Ihollnm 01 limo In IOgard 10 nOllco ollhl. ploposod ZOllO chango. Ho lold Iho 10llor 10 proporly ownall was wtIncn en p,l.4lch 25. 1992. HI !uUHd l~1 !hI, I, ~ I.dlcol chango ond thot many pooplo hlVO purchalOd plOpolly In lho RM.145 zona with Iho Inlonllon 01 racouplng lholl InvDltmonllNough dovolopmonl. Ho lold ho II nOllUla Ihallho RM.145 II baing mllulod on tho wOlllldo. Ha Ilrollod Ihal mony ollholr lananll do nOI hava . cal' and INII. why thoy dacldod 10 IIvo It lhillocollon In OIdor 10 wllk 10 and 110m wOlk. Ho plDlonlad lallor. Irom Purl Lallo ond Bob & Joon Powor. who also oXpllllOd Iholr oppollllon 10 Ihll rono chango. EblIlllI..IJlnson. 18 61doowood Lone,llDIod lhal ha has ownod prop ally al918 NOWlon Road linea 1975 and lhal hll mothor CUllontly IIvOl allhls locallon, Ha uld ho hal wOlkad allho CoIlago 01 Donllllly Ilneo 1973 and hal SDOn Iha changOllhol hava occurrod In Iho aru. Ha IOvlowod Iho boundarlOl ollho RM.145 rono ond nOlod Ihal Ihoro II only ono oIdar homo localod In Iha wOllarn pOlllon ollhis rono allho cornor 01 Nawlon and Valloy. Ho Indica lad Ihalln Iho mlddlo IOCllon ollha zona Ihoro 010 \ lour aparlmonllond Ion homll and IhattNDO 01 lhasa aparlmonls woro buill slneo Iho I RM.145 zono wOllmplomonlod. Ho nOlod Ihatlho oallorn loction hDlllx apallmonll ond INOO hOUIDl, Ho laid Ihoro ora 28 opallmonl bulldlngl and 16 h.omllln Iha onllro RM.145 zono. Ho laid lhallho Chy would bo alklng Ihallho bur don ollho rona chango ba call1od by Iho ownorl ollha homll who havo nOI YOllully dovolopod tholr prOPolly. Ho sold ho 10011 Iho parking probloml In Iho araa alO IOlalod 10 Iho Un/vorlllY 01 Iowa and nOllo Iho IOlldonll, Ho nOlOd that a majorilY ollho pooplo who IIvo In Iho aru walk 10 work. .I!a1.Glnoow. Ilalod ho II oppolod 10 Ihll IOronlng. Ho naiad Ihallho now zono would rDlullln 1011 parking bocaulo ollho IOlback roqulromonll, Fronk Woonor,llalod Ihat ho hlll ownod 325 NOllh Dubuquo 511001 lor approxlmatoly 20 yoall, Ho lOal no problom Wllh Iho oxilllng zoning, bUllhallhoro Is a problom with Iho planning Ihalll occulllng. Ho laid Ihal mosl ollho 1011 In Ihll arOD alO 40 1001 1011 Ihal con no longor ba buill on. Wag nor sold plannorllDOm 10 wOllY mora aboul callihan apallmonll, Ho nOlOd lhallho UnlvorsllY 01 Iowa doos nOI wOllY oboul carlond dooln'llDOm 10 hovo 0 porklng problom. Ho laid tho Clly Ihould wOllY Iou oboul parking In Iha downlown alOa. Ho Indlcalod Ihallho mOllsuccoulul apallmanl unil ha managol hlll no parking availoblo and hlll a IWo,yoOl long wailIng 1111. Wagnor sold lhoro aro a 101 01 oducalOd pooplo In Iowa City who would IIka 10 hava mlhollcl, bUI alOn'llulO how 10 go aboulll. Ha laid ho would lupporl dOllgn IOvlow 10 holp OIIura Ihal now prolocllln thll arOD aro alllacllvo. Ho Indlcalod Ihoro Illomolhlng aboullho now zono Ihal dOli nOI hold walOl. JIm Muller. 1125 SevmQur. Ilalod Ihal on IOvoral occallons ho haslnvllod momboll Ollho Commission 10 look al Lincoln Halghtlond nobody hOI o~prollod on InlolOll 71'/ Cl [I -/ 8 g PloMing & Zonlng Commllllon Apld 2. 1992 P.go 13 oXCOpl 10( Cook. Ho uld 1110 pol king "" ond 1110 ploblom 010 1010 lad 10 1110 Unlvelsily 01 low. omployeOl. Multoluld 111I1 coplo. 011110 PAM lonO Ihould hove bftn ..nlIO .n .II.cl.d plOPfIlV own".. Mull" JlJd 110 I.alllho plopoud lonO fl Ildlculou.. Ho .nd.d hi. comm.nll by uylng poopl. who wOIk Illho ho.pllal ollon wlnllO five noli 1110 hOIp/III. ,Igbo Aummalhnll oxplOlud hi. ogloomonl wllh lho 01110, .poako". Ho uld ho II poltlculllly concornod wllh 1110 11011I oroo Ind hol beln wOlklng wllh Jim OIOlgow 10 dlvelop . waft ihouvht out ~h.riii in tliii iiii. Hi iild hi ililVl nallli why IMII who w.llld 10 dovelop Ihoutd hove lho dovolopmonl opllon Ilk on OWIV I,om Ihom. Ho lumod lhol 110 10011 hlgh"I.o dlvolopmonl can be . wln.wln 1l1lk1llon. Aummolholluld lhol lomO 011110 dlvolopmonll hovo nOI beon Iho mo. I IPpolllng dovolopmonll. bul 1.ld lhollhll doo. nOI mOln lhol pOlonllol dovolopmonl would nOI /llln. Ho uld 1110111111010 II .ny orOI In Iowa Clly wholO hlgh.,llo dovolopmonll. ,PplOplIIIO. Ihon 11II 1110 AM. 1 015 "00 on lho wO'llldo. Ho IUOI.od 1110101. high podOlui.n uallic In Ihll "01, Hould 110 hod .glood wllh Iho downlonlng In lho noa, IOUlhlldl Ind I.kld 11111010 IIId beln Iny plopo.111 PUllorlh uncIor Ihl PAM zona 101 lholllll. Miklo rupondld 111I1 Ihorl WOIO no IppllclUonl locolvod lor Iho noor lOUlhlldl oroo. bul IUI...d 111I1 Iho 1011O WII 1u.1 odoplod ono monlh ogo. AummolhollllolOd lhol 110 fool I Ihl'O mlghl be modillcallonl modo 10 1110 PAM lonO In lho IUIUlo. Ho IUOgo.lod loting willi IIIppon. wllh lho noor loulhsldo Ind Ihon mOking Iny odluSlmonl1 In Iho ,ona I' noodod bofOlo IPplying 1110 olho, oroas. I tianev Menan rOld 0 '0110' /rom 110, mOlho,. Aulh McOIMUI. which o.prollOd t opposilion 10 1110 lO,onIng bOlOd on 1110 Iil\lnclal ,omlllcalions. Sho IIlmod lhol hor I mOlho, hoSlokon 10 1101111110 CilV'1 ConeO",1 IOgo,dlng parking and I. planning an all,oclivo building lhol Ihould allraCI lho IVpo of young Plolullonall Ihal would ! ploboblV wOlk In lho 1101. a! Wonder. 841 NOlmandy Dl~, Ulgod 1110 Commllllon 10 IUPPOlllho downlonlng. Ho Iumod Ihlllho,O II 0 10VO'0 pa,klng ploblom In Iho oral ond lhal ho hOl 30.35 ca,alyoor lowod Irom 1Il1101. Ho .1II0d 111010 corl belong 10 ruldonll of Iho oroo and nOI Un/vollIIY ollowo omplovGOl. Ho nOlod lhallhoro II 0 g,ool dOli of car Ilo,ago IhollOku ploco In Iho 0100 and Ihallho.o oppo.od 10 Ihll ro,onIng 010 only Inlolulod In moklng 0 g'OII doal 01 monov, . SllIod 111I1 ho 'UPPo'lIll1l. 1010nlng ollhough ho dou 100 lomo p,obloml wllh Iho now ,ono. Ho omphOlllOd Ihlllhoro II 0 dollnllO parking ploblom In Iho wOlllldo 0100. Ho laid lhol mo. I Ollho mulllplo dwolllng unlll lhol woro OIlgll\llly buill In Iho 0'01 WOIO olllmilOl Iypo ond Icalo. Ho laid Iho AM. 145 ,ono c/OIlod probloml bocau.o of Iho low parking IOqullOmanl ond lack 01 IOlback roqullOmonll. Ho said ho '0011 Ihoro 0'0 sa'olY ploblom. wllh Iho now bulldlnQl on Uncoln Avonuo bocaulO pooplo In Iho .ummor will como oul ollho undor. Iho.buildlng parking 0'00 Inlo Iho .un ond lhl. could ondangor POdOlullnl. Ho said IImlllng Iho availabilllV 01 on'IUoOl parking would Incro... pa,klng probloml, Ho said ho hOl ownod 1Il1 CUl/onl mullfolamlly dwolling unllllnco 1083 and hiS had only IwO lononl.ln Ihal porlod 01 limo Ihal do nOI own call. Ho Ilrouod Ihal whilo 'OIldanl. 78r nn-/yo - - , " P10nnlng & Zoning Commllalon AptU 2, 1802 Pogo 14 I i I I ! I I I I I In tho 01.. moy wolk to wOlk 0( cllll. Illty go".roUy wont to IIIv. I clr In OIdor to go plml on tilt wookond. M8roorDt Lq!nJ.gQ IIOIOd aha OPPOIOI tllll roronlng, Silt IIkld 101 mOlolnfOlmlllon on tho donslty thot would bo pormlllod undor tilt PRM rOllO. ....klo ,olpondod thot SO I)IlIw.~, wOYld MtgowM with ullto IPllIC.lWI:ly 100 l:r.l1:!:etO ~ ~fd with bonu.... ....klo Hid InlOtonlllon II bolng ovolullod rogording how mlny &nlllro locllod In tilt Ir... Lllnlon Hid thotlt would Ippol'thotlllll II procoodlng without Informltlon on tilt numbe, 01 unltlln tilt Ir... ....klo rOlpondod thottllllnlOlmltfon 11I1 boon gl'horod, but I. not yotlvlDlbloln wrlllon 101m. Publlo c1lculalon WII c1olOd ot I I If4 p,m. 80vbjorg movod to dolo, REZ02.0007to April la, 1002. D1orko locondld, In 'Olpenl. to I qUlltlon Irom D1orkl. Clvlltllnlon Ilalod thot Ilt would ptolor tNt Glblon not rOlpand to tho IlIuo 01 Unlvoraity 01 Iowa pa,klng dltoclly, but would ptolor to havo 11I11 chock Into tllllllluo. Tho modon clrrlld 4.0.1. (Qlblon Ibllllnlngl CII,kl movld to dllor nEZ02.00a to AptU I a, 1002. 80vbjorg locondod. Tho mollon clrrlod 4.0.1. (albion Ibltolnlngl . -'--'--'-'r--'- \ I , Glblon ro/alnod Iho Commllllon. COMP.B.E~ENSIVE PlA~ AMENOME~I~: f. Conlldor lOlling 0 publiC h..ring 101 April IS, 1092, on I propo.olto omond lilt low. City Comprohonlivo Pion by Incorporaling tho JCCOa Anorial 51'oot P1.n 101 10wI City Urb.nlrod Ar... Clorkl movod to lOt. public h..rlng 10' AprU 1 a, 1002. on I propololto omond tho low I City Comprohonalvo Plan by Incorporating tho JCCOa Artorlal Stroot Plan lo'tho 10wI City Urb.n1rad A'... CooporlOCondod. Tho mOllon c.rrlod 5,0. ~O~SIDERATION OF THE MI~UIES OF ~~fi~H 19. 1002. MEeTI~Q: Bovbjorg movld to .pprovo tho mlnulOI 01 tho Mlrch 19. 1802. m,ollng .1 clrculalod. Coopor locondod. Tho mOllon corrlod 3,0.2 IDlork. .nd albion .bll.lnlngl. P]]ER BUSJ.NES~: f. Rnooll on Mft~bJ I. 1 Q02. CIIV eoune,1 mnnliDa. Tho,. WII no dl.culllon. 2. PJnnnln" & ZOOI"" Commlulon Inl"rmftll.all, Dlorkl roportod Ihot 0 lolnt moollng with tho Johnlon CounlY Plonnlng to Zoning Commllllon will bo hold on Ap,i1 20, 1992. 7Sf '''''''',.,., --~-r---------- I j , . ! ' q L l < , I ,c ,;".;,...." "..,,' ~.'" n rt -, q , , - - ,,~"" . Ptlnnlno & Zonlno Commllllon Ap11I2. 1992 Plgo f 5 ~pJOUBNME~T: Coop., movod 10 odJourn Iho moollno 0111: \9 p,m, Bovbjoro locondod. Tho mOllon ca"lod D.o. AM Bovblolg, SOCIOIIIY MinulOllubmlllld by MirY Jo Noll "'~I... 7111 ,." , ! f\ I I i 1 , '-"~'-'----""--'--'------'-',"'- -.....----.; I I I 1 i , , , o 0 -/ q ,? I , I ! . . i I I , I , i ! .~ I I I \ i i REgu.lo.R. CouNcil meEHtJ~ '1'130 'P. m. '?lto.s& SiS~ IN: ~ M.N\S- CON~t~':"~~ )"'c:...:.... l{'2. ((.'I"J;~' ("(".,:1 ((7"' , uJ,,,, ,oj "tL c.U. -.J~ \ St I~ .31 If:.+fI CJ.. Iq~ N 1 r ~Lf.Jt 'f-o , .~~ tlJ~ a.,... . lli1 ~. C, Lt'ne't" dll,IG Z It 1 ,\\a.v:P ~~h ...., i') . .. . 10, I, '''0'''' 13. .., .. n;--? L. =' 'N. C Iq. j~s"j ~ \J)u~ ;,'.-' I. \ I 1 I 1 I , . o CI -/ q j . . REgu.lo.R. COlLNcil meEt',t.J~ '(130 'P. m. '?lt0.5& Si9t.\ !~J: ". I 13. Iq, , ~ 1'1 , . i~----------..r \ ' I . [I [I -/ q l{ ~~.) 1) MINUTES RIVERFRONT AND NAT\JRAL AREAS COMMISSION MARCH 18.1992.5::10 PM SENIOR CENTER CLASSROOM MEMBERS PRESENT: RogOI Bl\lIIor, Don 011o, AI RobAl, Nancy SHlotting. Doan SultM l.Iny W~son , MEMllERS ABSENT: Lotan HOtlOn. Jill Hubo~ Robart WAChA!, RAndy WIllmIl1. Vlcancy STAFF PRESENT: MIlch, No" P~EL1~l1N.~frV SL~J'CIIo ~~~r;v~1 OTHERS PRESENT: C4thorlno ODOI, pog McEItoy.Fruor, JoG llalkcom ~: Vlco ChaItpor1on Brunor C4lIGd lho mooUng 10 OIdor 115:38 p.m. Brunor and RobAI notod thDllholt nlllnol should bo Dddod 10 1110 III 01 mamboll who woro lIbSonUrom thO Fobruary 10, 1002 mooting, W~son luggOltod d4litylng lho goallllnd oblOCllvoI 011110 WalorwDya, WOllandl, Woodands and Troil Accoll CommiflOo. ,WiIIOn movod 10 approvo tho mlnulos 01 tho Fobru4Iy 10, 1092, mHUng IS lIInondod. Soibor1lng 10condod. Tho mollon CDtI10d 6.0. Mulch rovlowod thO allo pl4n with tho CommIuJon. Ho nolod thalli loction 01 tho Old Bonlon Stroel Brldgo will bo Incorporlltod In tho polk with II hlstorICDI plAquo. Ho e~plaJnod thllltho /roU Ioadl 10 tho NOli undor 1110 brldgo and thalli boDlltNaIk would bo conltructod 10 IitIk trDlls on elthor aldo 01 thO brldgo. Ho Indlcalod II1l1l Frasor Is lOOking Iunds 10( MaYO(1 Youth Employmonl Program 10 conltruet 1110 boDlltNoJk. Frasor o~pl4lnod thaI 11111 projoct hAI boon prosontocl 10 tho Comminoo lor Community Nooda In an lInompl 10 rocolvo Community Dovolopmonl Block Qranllunds, Sho o~plaJnod thai thO 1101I rocommoncl4tion modo by tho Community Dovolopmonlllllll Is 10 nollund tho boardwalk pr%ct. Frasor Indlcatod thallho has lDfkod with Marlanno Milkman, Community Dovolopmonl Coord'iI1l1l0r, and 01 he/luggoltlon hu proposod a backup projoet lor thO construcUon of a &hollor al FoIrmoadowt PAlk. Frasor 114lod Iho would anond thO publlo hooting thaI win bo hold by thO commJnoo on Community Noods. Frasor ItrOSlod thaI donlaJ 01 this proloCI would croOlO IIIOVOrO ImpOCI on hor program boCDuso II would bo 1110 ntll timo Iho would bo fllcod with rovortJng 11410 lunds and docroaslng 1110 numbor 01 youth 10rvod. Sho ItrOllod Iholtho Commlnoo on Community Noodl doOI nollltNaya affirm thO 11011 rocommondatlon and nOlod thai tho City Councll mDkOlthO nllAllundng dodslonl. Sho lald Iho may bo bock boforo thO CommluJon for lurlIlor ondollomonll or lupport Frasor laid thollho has rocolvod II contribullon of 510 6 dump truck Ioadl 01 brlckilor Ihls projoeL Sho thonkod tho Commission for tholr ondorlomonl. Sho notod lhD112,000 carsldoy travol on Bonton StroOI so Ihlslypo 01 projoet would provldo o.pcsuro lor hor loonogo omploymonl program. In rosponso to 0 quoltlon lrom Robol. Mulch 110100 thaI Prololllonal Munlor usos City proporly lor porldng 01 10mHrucks and this lasuo could bo usod In nogotlatlons In trying to oblaln porrnlsalon 10 havo 0 mural plocod on tho lido 01 tho Profolslonal Mufllor building, In rosponso 785 [I [I -/ q 5 RlverflOnl & Natural Aroas Commlsslon Match 18, 1992 Pogo 2 10 a quolllon &om Rogal, Mulch llalod thalli mlghl bo poulllo 10 nlll 110m tho proposod obsorvaUon dock. but ho nolod 111011110 dock would bo oppro.lmlloly 20 1001 Dbovo 110 walOf IovaL Ho notod thallho omp/luls will bo on podoslrlan UIO 01 lho ~lIlf. Ho lAId tho ownOf 01 McDonaldslllnlorOllod In COMoctfng 10 tho troll 110m his proporty. 0110 Ind Wilaon l~ongIy luggOSlod vorllylng thollllo donalod bricks 110 In loct PlYIng bricks or 11111 mollturo ponoltlUon woill bo i problom. Mulch ropollod tholtho I.lbnIIy dsplay apaco will nol bo avalloblo bocaulO 01 LIltllly IIaH roduetlons. Ho Indlcalod ho would chock to 100 II a apaco would bo ovaIobIo ~ 1110 ColMllulon 1015 up the display 111011. SuQlvan roporlod thai EmlIy Rubrighl 01 PrO/oet GREEN IndlCDlod thlll/unding 10( tho prIm 01 thO photo contosl will probably not bo II problorn. Brunor IndlCDlod ho would proparo a rnomorondum 10 Intorastod OrolllllZlIllonl aakJng 10( nomlnallons for thO apoclol rocognlUon llWOId. Brunor ropollod thai thoro would bo a bus lour along tho lowll RIvor, and 1110 Commission dlscussod roulo opUons. Brunor laid II had also boon luggostod 10 havo I Rlverfronl and Natural Aroas CommJulon information labIo noM 1110 regls/roUon lAbIo. Thoro was a COfllOfllUSto lollow Ihtough on 11111 rocommondaUon willi mambors 10 holp 101 up thO 1lIblo. II was aorood 11101 matorlals would bo provtdod altho no. I CommJulon moollng In ordor 10( mombors 10 docldo whal Ihould bo usod for the Inlormollon Ioblo. SuUlvan luggOllod including onlrlollor thO pholo conlosl. Mulch 110100 11101 momborl should 101 him know I1lI1oy wanllho City 10 covar thO cosl 01 tholr roglstrallon 100 10 onond Rlvor City V. ono dlstrlbulod tho troo rogulaUons for commordal dovolopmonl and luggOSlod changoSlo mako thoso rogulatlons opply 10 rosldontlal dovolopmont. Ho nolod thallho goalaro 10 plan 10 prOIOrve oxlstlng troos and nolod thaI tho oxlsUng roguloUofll l4ko Inlo accounltho idolS thai 1110 CommJsslon would lIke 10 100 Includod In an ordlnanco. Ho luggOSlod II mlghl bo bosllo modify thO o.IsUng regulations. Ho laid tho WoodlondJ Commlnoo II ItJlllooklng 10( opproprlolo Ianguogo for somo Idoas thoy wanllo Incorporalo. Ho IndIclItod thaI Nolan Bog04ld 01 tho Housing Inspoel/on Sorvleos Doportrnonl hod concoml rogordlng Incrooslng thO COlli 01 housos by roqulrlng largor alzo trOOl. one ropollod thallhls rosultod In a modlllCDUon 10 docrooso the minimum Ilzo Irom ~'Io f'lor lA/go dodduous ~oos and Irom I~ 10 W lor amlIIIor doeiduous troos. Ho Itrossod thOlthoy would nol rocommond changing tho numbor 01 trOOI roqu~od. Ho Indlcalod that In rogard 10 prOIOCUng o.'stlng Ilgnlflcanl troos, ho lpoko with Jim Maynard rogordlng donning a slgnlncanl troo, MaynOld laid thol transp/anllng I troo any largor than 8.8 Inchos would bo almosllmposslblo 10 this Is whatthoy will bo donninG as IIllgnlflcanl troe. 0110 Ilrossod thalthoy don'l wonl 10 provonl romoval altogolhor, bUllul1 wilhod 10 roqulro a loglllmalo roason and auggoslod Ihalll pormlllhould bo roqullod from thO City Forollor boloro I algnlncanl troo Is romovod. Ho laid thoy could also add 0 loel/on thOI roplocomonl 01 IlgnlllcanlItOOI mUll bo by oqulvalonl dlamolor Inchos. ?is ~ t, i, f f . ! I r I I i ,.-. , OO-/gb Rlvarlronl & Natural Aroas Commllslon , March fS, 1992 Pogo 3 WIlson o.prossod concams rogatdng tho minimum p/antlng mo. Ho IDId ho would prolor 10 havo f' dlamotor lor ImlII/ dodduoul troos and I~' dlomotor lor llIIgo dodduoUl ~oo.. Ho Indlcatod ho Ilkostho Idoa 01 using 1110 oxlsUng rogulotlons bocauao II would bo loll 01 a Ihroll 101110 dovoloprnonl community. Solborllng luggoslod InCOlpOrBUng Informallon on ~oo proloctlon will1ln 1110 rogulotlofll. SuUlvon luggoslod havlr.g two loll 01 ~oo rogul4Uon., ono ~!!~ lor commercbJ :net ro-eklGnUaJ. Hi! nolad lhi; would avoid cilanglng Iho roqulromonls fO( commorclal dovolopmont Wilson notod thalll1ls would addross his concams rogllldlng lho minimum p/lnllng prlco. Brunor nolod II1Is Itom should bo rovlOWod 01 tho nu.l COmmlaslon mooUng and ukod 11141 commonts bo lorwotdod 10 Otto prior 10 thai mooUng. Mulch ropollod thai ho and WIlson mot wlll1 Mlchaol Jackson 01 tho Iowa Dopart/nonl 01 Transportation. Ho IDId 1I10ro will bo nogoUaUcns rogotdlng thO I)l)O ollonco and .141od thal1l10Y profor a posl willi lhroo C4bIos bocauso 1I10ro would bo loss visual obstruction ollho Iowa RIval. Ho IDId with a 4~ loollonco thoro noods to bo 8 rub rail a13~ fOOL Ho IDId IIthay mUll Incorporato this Into tho lonco, thoy would do 10 In tho 100SI obtruslvo monnor. Wilson Itrossod thallochnlCDlIy IhIs would nol bo a blkowoy bocauso thoro Is only IIx fool 01 hoadway undor 1110 brldgo. Ho sold thai II II Is nol a blkowoy, thon thoro Is 10chnlcalJy nol a nOod lor a rub roJ Olpodally Ilthoy movo tho lop CDblo 10 tho odgo 01 tho post 10 lIIIow for oddiUonaJ protoctlon. Thoro was nono. ~: I. W410rwnvs Commlnu: Thoro was nono. 2. WOIIRQd. Commlll22: Thoro was no no. 3. Woodlands CommllJ22: Thoro was no no. 4. ]rnlls and AccoSl Commll122:, Wilson ropollod Iholltom I undor goals and obJoctlvos was comp/otod on Fobrullly 10, 1992. Ho ropollod Ihol Solborilng and tho Planning studonls walkod along tho Iowa Rlvor with Ockonlols on his proporly. Wilson 11lIIod thai tho A100 north 01 Bonton Stroolll a problom bocauso 01 Iho railroad tracks on thai litO. Ho notod Iholll ono /rock could bo romovod with 0 lonco conslructod to soporoto tho opon oroo Irom tho romaln'ng trocL thon a trail mlghl bo posslblo. Ho lald that thoro oro somo poaalbUlllos wllh tho aroo 10Ulh 01 Bonlon Stroot. Solbor/lnO notod thoro woro Q numbor 01 probloms with this arOQ and sold thai Iho CommIssion should probably concontrato on trail dovoloprnonl on thO WOSI sldo 01 tho Iowa Rlvor, Wlllon luggOllod thai a troll could follow Rolston Crook or 785 n n -/ q '-I - - ! RIYorlront & Natural NODI Commission Match 16, 1002 Paoo.. CopIlol SlroollO( II1Is logmonl 01 a lroll on lho Eastaldo ollowll Rlvor. Wilson roportod thallho CommJUoo wllI mool rogllldlng 1110 slldo show and thai tho Proposod brochuro wIU bo comp/Gtod by lho p/oMlng ltudonts by April 20, 1002. Soilorlng 11410d thalaomo lncIvIcNaIs 11I0 working with HoarUand Inn In CorolvUlo rogardng improving tho~ IandsaIplng on 1110 rtvoraldo olll1olr proporly along tho Coralvlllo COMoctlon. Sho 1ndC4lod aomo 011110 land adlolnlng Pizza Hut mlghl bo donolod and 1110 CoralvlDo City Englnoor lollll1at doanlng tho silo could bo an Eoglo Scout proJoct. RobolluggOl1od pulllng publlo clacuulon alll10 boglnnlng 01 tho agonda 10 avoid having mombors 011110 public who wtah 10 lpook l14y throughoultho mooUng. ~: Wilson llalod thai altho lasl mooUng mombors dlscussod 1110 Unlvoralty 01 Iowa Il4tus rogonflng whol wu DIong Cloar Crook. Ho IlIkI thai thoy 11I0 avoiding II1Is 11I00 and nolod thai CoraMI/o II doing a loA ltudy. In rogAld 10 thO Iowa Memorial Unlcn and brIdgo 10 Iowa Avonuo trail logmonL ho ropollod 11101 F.I,R.S.T.1s pursuing tho onglnoortng problom with thO railroad. Ho notod thallho Unlvoralty 01 Iowa Foundation has boon opproochod rogatdlng lundlng. \--,- I ~: Thoro was nono. ~: one movod 10 oc/loum Iho mooUng al7:04 p,m. Robolaoeondod. Tho motion carrtod 8.0. Idnuloslubmlnod by Maty Jo Noll PIldJdmiIMWIMc:I.11 785