Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-04-21 TranscriptionPage 1 ITEM 2. STUDENT LEADERSHIP AWARDS — Grant Wood Elementary Hayek: Would the students from Grant Wood please come forward! Karr: Right up here! Hayek: Hi, guys! How are you doing tonight? (all three respond) Good! Well we're glad to have you here! This is City Hall, which is where the City Council meets and I'm Mayor Hayek and this is the City Council right behind you and ... this is the group that makes the decisions about how many police cars to have and fire trucks to buy and ... what to do with our parks and how to fix the roads and things like that. It's a real honor for us to have you with us, and one of the things we do throughout the school year is invite the student leaders from the elementary schools in Iowa City down to our meetings, and each meeting one school is represented and ... two or three students from each school come each time and we get to hear a little bit about you and show you off to the community a little bit, and I also have an award for you! So I see that you each brought your piece of paper. That's the first step! That's good! And I think what I'll do is just hand the microphone to you and you can read your piece to us! You ready? (both talking off mic) Do you want to hold this or do you want me to hold it? (response off mic) All right! Put it up by your mouth! Etuma: Okay! (Read in French) Hayek: Do you want to read it in English too? Etuma: Sure! (laughter) Hayek: This is a first! Reading in ... in two languages for us! Throgmorton: Maybe you can hold it closer to his... Hayek: Yeah, a little bit closer to your mouth. Etuma: Okay. Hello, I'm Gabriel Etuma. I'm a student at Grant Wood Elementary School. I'm an athlete. For example, I played soccer in Iowa City Kickers for three years. In Mrs. Brock's class I was a team leader. I was responsible for giving directions to my classmate (mumbled) classroom money ... and doing jobs in the classroom. I believe Mrs. Brock chose me for this award because I have a positive attitu ... attitude and because I'm a good student. I don't usually get in trouble and I follow directions. I thank Mrs. Brock for nominating me for this award and thank you all for this award. (applause) Sekafetz: I'm Jordan. I'm in Miss Grigsby's class. First of all I want to give a huge thanks to Iowa City City Council for this award. It is such an honor to receive this. What being a leader means to me is showing respect and kindness to the people This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 2 around me. Also it means to always do the right thing and turn in all your work on time. Some of the things I've done in my early years of school are student council, second through sixth grade; (mumbled) star student, K through third; and power word. Here are some activities I have done this year at school: leadership group, a kindergarten mentor, safety patrol, art club, choir, knitting club, Jump Rope for Heart, and I became a certified babysitter. I participate in these activities outside of school: gymnastics for six and a half years, softball for seven years, and volunteer at Iowa City Moose Family Center. During Christmas, I find families in need and I get them presents and help them out. The activity I am most proud of is the leadership group. Our name is Girl Bosses. We're working on a project called the Hidden Book RG. It is a reading garden for the community. On Thursday, April 23, 2015, we are going to Cedar Rapids to try to persuade entrepreneurs to visit ... to ... to invest in our garden. We think this garden is a fun way to read and learn. I want to thank everyone in my family for supporting me. My coaches for always pushing me to do my best and never give up. My parents for always being there and supporting me. I can't thank them enough. All of my elementary teachers for pushing me to do more. Also a special thanks to Miss Grigsby for helping me finish my last year at Grant Wood. Once again, thanks to the Iowa City City Council. (applause) Cookes: Hi, my name is Amari. I'm a sixth grader in Mr. Kuntz class at Grant Wood Elementary School. I would like to thank Mr. Glenn for nominating me for this award. At school I have jobs such as safety patrol where I take little kids to the bus. Operation Backpack where I takes bag ... where I take bag of...bags of food to classes, and I'm a bank officer. I'm currently in the top math and reading class at school. I'm also in advanced band and orchestra. I have to practice 20 to 30 minutes a day, five days a week. They ma ... the band meets every Wednesday for an hour. Orchestra meets on Tuesdays for an hour. That means I have to be very careful in my free time and homework. Finally, I would like to thank the Iowa City City Council and Mr. Glenn for this award. (applause) Hayek: Well those are wonderful. You know I did safety patrol back in the day, a lot of it! I also did Iowa City Kickers and I was terrible (laughter) but I did a lot of those things and ... and I ... and it's so great to see you, the three of you doing things, as well, and it's clear that you're leaders in your school. We know that because your teachers have ... have nominated you and you're the ones who were sent by Grant Wood down here. You know I think our last Mayor, uh, Mayor Bailey was a Grant Wood graduate and did Terry Dickens, did he have a Grant Wood ... anyway! So there's.... some of the ... some of the Grant Wood ... some of the students who were at Grant Wood a long time ago have served on the City Council and maybe you will some day as well! So we're very proud of you. I do want to recognize your parents and your teachers and the other people who are here, w ho have played a big role in your lives. Uh, they're... they're important and we want to recognize them, but mostly we just want to show you off to the community and we're very proud of you. We have an award, one for each of you, and it reads as follows. It's called a Student Leadership Award and it reads: for This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 3 his or her outstanding qualities of leadership with Grant Wood Elementary, as well as the community, and for his or her sense of responsibility and helpfulness to others, we recognize you as an Outstanding Student Leader. Your community is proud of you. Presented by the Iowa City City Council. Gabriel, I'm going to give you yours. Jordan, here's yours! And Amari, here's yours. Let me shake your hands, as well, to congratulate you! We're proud of you. Good job! You can stick around and watch us, or go home and do some more homework. Your call! (laughter) (applause) Thanks so much! This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 4 ITEM 3. PROCLAMATIONS ITEM 3a Bicycle Month — April Hayek: (reads proclamation) Karr: Here to accept the proclamation representing Think Bicycles of Johnson County, Larry Fitzpatrick (applause) Fitzpatrick: I, um ... I just wanted to share with you a personal, uh, story about Bicycle to Work Week. I remember, um, about eight years ago, we were having, uh... uh, a commuter breakfast over here across the street. Had, uh, on College Street, and uh, there was three ladies there. They were riding for the first time to work over at the University, and um, I could tell, you know, they hadn't done it before and their tires were a little flat and their chain needed oiled, so I worked on their bikes and visited with `em, and mostly they were just asking me questions about how to get through the traffic and the easiest way to get over there, and then I never seen `em again the rest of the summer and we continued to do a commuter breakfast every Friday morning ... or every first Friday morning at the Bicycle Library and um ... I recognized their bikes when I was helping one, um, in September and I look around and there's these three ladies. I wouldn't even of recognized `em, you know. They told me they'd ridden the whole summer, and uh, they just shared with me, you know, how much better their health was and uh, how much they enjoyed the commute back and forth to the University, uh, instead of hatin' driving over there and uh, that's all happened because of you, you know. If, uh, we didn't promote bicycling and uh, have Bike to Work Week and the staff and uh, the Council, uh, support us, um, those ladies probably would have never would of rode. Thank you! Hayek: Thank you for that story! (applause) This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 5 ITEM 3. PROCLAMATIONS Item 3c National Crime Victims' Right Week — April 19-25, 2015 Hayek: (reads proclamation) Karr: Here to accept the proclamation is Police Lt. Mike Brotherton. (applause) Brotherton: Uh, yes I am Lt. Mike Brotherton with the Iowa City Police Department. Um, if you haven't seen the, uh, a public awareness campaign we've initiated for the last, uh, six or eight weeks, National Crime Victims' Rights Week with a special event tomorrow night, uh, at the Rec Center. Urn ... here's the, uh, poster that's been kind of publicized on City buses, on the side of buses. Also have a really big billboard on, um, Muscatine by, uh, Walgreens. Has anybody seen it? Payne: I have! Brotherton: So I would like to invite Mayor... Mr. Mayor, like to invite you and the rest of Council, and everyone here, and everyone that's watching, to the special event tomorrow night at the Rec Center. Um... it's going to be a great, uh, program. We've got, uh, all of the agencies and, uh ... organizations in town that are contributed to victim services. Uh, a lot of the, uh, prof... professional services, people are going to be there, and uh, we're going to have two guest speakers, uh, Dan Gable. I think everybody's familiar with him, and Linda Sorenson who is the, uh, retired victim witness coordinator for the Sixth Judicial District, and both of them, I don't know if you're aware or not, but have had, uh, their, uh, homicide, uh, family survivors. Both of them had their, uh, Dan had his sister murdered and, uh, Linda had her daughter, uh, murdered when she was 17 -years - old. That was 26 years ago. So they're going to share their stories, uh, the struggles, the grief, the ... the ordeals, uh, things that, uh, probably most of us have never felt and I think it'll be very, uh, encouraging and empowering for them, and for us, to hear their stories. Uh, this event began as a ... a collaboration, a partnership, between the Iowa City Police Department, uh, Johnson County Attorney, Rape Victim Advocacy Program, Johnson County Sexual Assault Response Team, and uh, the Division ... or Department of Correctional Services. Uh, a member from each of those agencies participate on a committee and they actually helped write the grant that we received for this project. Most of the money — pretty much all the money — went for the public awareness campaign. So, uh... I would encourage you to come. It's going to be a great event. I think it's going to be very meaningful. It shows .... it brings the community together. The theme for this year is Engaging Communities and Empowering Victims. I think it'll be very powerful to hear the stories and then we can all talk, and hopefully, uh, contribute, uh, to victim services in Iowa City. So thank you very much! Hayek: Thank you! This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 6 Throgmorton: Mike, could you please repeat where and when the event will take place. Brotherton: Yes! It's going to be at the Iowa City Rec Center tomorrow, beginning about 5:00, and it'll go to about 7:30. Uh, there'll be some tables and booths set up, like I said, uh, with a lot of agencies and uh, victim services provider. Uh, then the actual program will get underway about 5:45 and uh, we'll have some opening remarks. Linda Sorenson and then Dan Gable will speak, so it should get over about quarter to 7:00. Throgmorton: Thanks! Brotherton: Thank you very much. Hayek: Thanks, Lieutenant. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 7 ITEM 4. CONSIDER ADOPTION OF THE CONSENT CALENDAR AS PRESENTED OR AMENDED. Hayek: Item 4 is consider adoption of the Consent Calendar as presented or amended, with deletion of Item 4d(3) and uh, removal of Item 4d(7) for separate consideration. Mims: So moved. Payne: Second. Hayek: Moved by Mims, seconded by Payne. Discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 6-0. ITEM 4d(7) FIRST AVE. GRADE SEPARATION PROJECT - IOWA INTERSTATE AGREEMENT AND UTILITY RELOCATION REIMBURSEMENT - RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER, OR DESIGNEE, TO APPROVE REIMBURSEMENT FOR UTILITY RELOCATIONS IN THE FIRST AVENUE GRADE SEPARATION PROJECT. Payne: And, Mayor, I will need to recuse myself from this item because part of that, uh, utility reimbursements are to my employer. Hayek: Okay. Mims: Move the resolution. Botchway: Second. Hayek: Moved by Mims, seconded by Botchway. Discussion? Dilkes: And ... and let me just note, and you specifically worked on these utility relocations, there's gas relocations (mumbled) Okay. Hayek: Further discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 5-0, Payne recusing. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 8 ITEM 5. COMMUNITY COMMENT (ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA) Hayek: Okay, this brings us to Item 5, Community Comment. This is the opportunity at each City Council meeting for members of the public to address the Council, uh, regarding items that are not on the agenda. So if there's something that is not on tonight's agenda that you would like to bring to our attention, we invite you to come forward. Uh, our usual practice is to ask you to sign in, also verbally give us your name, and to keep your comments to five minutes or less! Knight: Hi, my name is Roger Knight. I've been here a couple times. Just trying to... echo the same things again and again, and uh, I wasn't here for a particular meeting, but um. ... Mr. Mayor, you seemed to be very much on the side of Mr. Moen, which I don't know what's going on there, but ... anything Moen has got going that he thinks is good ... is pushing people like me out of this city. Everyone who has low-income, which is really weird when this City Council pushes for equality. Equality for everyone! Except for if you're poor — get out! Which is not right! How can a city... do that so quickly? Let's go for Moen! Hey, Moen's got a great idea! He can spend our money! He can hurt the individuals of this city who are low-income. Hey! Great idea! Then they can't cry or whatever problems you guys have. Well (clears throat) I've said it before and I'm not going to say exactly how much I get, just over... seven and a half, 750, a month. I can't buy a ... I can't get a one -bedroom apartment with that! Screw food! Electricity! Anything else I need. But ... he's got two great buildings downtown. There's no way I'm going to live in either one of `em, and you want to give him another building! Well the... shadow, what's been deemed `the shadow,' I guarantee ya I ain't gonna live in there, cause I won't be able to afford it, or the other ... the next building... that you seem to ... think is a great idea. When's this city going to fight for everyone in this city, not just Moen? There are people who are struggling, with everything! The cable company not being very good. Prices of electricity. Food. Now ... I know you can't do much for food ... but electricity and cable, they're legal monopolies to the City. You guys could fight for the citizens! And stop doing the secret deals with Moen. That seems to hurt us. We ... this city needs about 10,000 ... 10,000 more apartments! Not luxury apartments! Good apartments for anyone to live in. Seems to be lately it's luxury apartments that get built, only luxury! I don't know if it's because that's where the money is. I'm assuming that's what it is. But we're hurting. I'm glad to see that the sidewalks finally got fixed on the potholes. What about the other things that have been brought up? You know, like ... not shut down the Senior Center? Boy, you guys got real big onto that one! Let's shut it down! You know, that's not good! We're having ol... you know, senior citizens in this city, and this county, comin' here, spending money. Not good. Uh huh! And one thing ... is, um, you said ... to Jim ... that, um, we don't need to get anything for personal belongings for unfortunately the homeless downtown. They can put it into... well, the Rec Center. When ... when was the last time you walked around the city, Mr. Mayor, or anyone on the City Council? Because you can't do that! They empty the locked... lockers and the ... at least men's locker room, and ... the Rec This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 9 Center. When are you going to fight for this city? The actual citizens who live here. Just a question! Just a few things I've brought up before, and I'm gettin' tired of having to bring up again and again, because it's like you guys don't hear it! You don't hear the cries of this city, what this city says about you! It's like you guys don't even care about us, and I can tell ya... with the things that come up, you don't! I don't know if I need to get a partition to go ... start going, to have most of you kicked off the City Council. But at least I'm fightin' for the city! How `bout you? Thank you! Hayek: Thank you for your comments. Madden: My name's Henry Madden, 1018 Marcy Street. Uh, I don't know whether I'm in the right order or not in speaking. I could hardly understand you when you said, uh, it's time to talk about things that won't come up tonight. Well I ... I was told by the Press -Citizen ... that the, your vote on rezoning 20,000 square feet on the corner of, uh, Gilbert and College was going to come up tonight, and if this is not the time to speak on it, maybe I should, uh... uh, hold my ... but I ... I wanted to say, and I agree with this young fella who was just talking here. (clears throat) It appears to citizens that the Council is `downtown oriented.' Well, we all want an active, viable, attractive downtown. Everybody in the city wants that, but uh... and you had a request for proposal put out ... about three years ago ... for that section of ... that 20,000 square feet. And, uh, in the ... in the request for proposal, it said it favored affordable housing. Just exactly what this ... this man was ... was recommending. Affordable housing. George Sherman, one of the nine that submitted his proposal had 153 units of affordable housing. 153! Marc Moen had 13! I guess you didn't want affordable housing! You ... you ignored the people that put in for that. The RFP, the request for proposal, had no limit on height, which I think meant the people should assume higher is better. You didn't say that, but you ... you said there's no limit! Well, the ... the present zoning limited it. Several of the nine designed five story, eight story, and 15 story buildings. One stated that it was designed to be net -zero energy. That wasn't important I guess! It would have probably been the first apartment building in America that was net -zero. Iowa City probably would have been on the map for that. The past Council ... only one of you has changed... ignored several constituent groups. Roughly a thousand people at the Episcopal Trinity Church were ignored. The 22,000 people that are members of New Pioneer Co -Op were ignored, and roughly the 10,000 in the... in the, uh, College Green Park area in the north side were ignored. Generally speaking, these people were all ... against this 20 -story building that you approved. Both the City Council request for this 10 - block zoning change and the specific one I think you're going to vote on tonight, for 20,000 square feet, when it was rejected for 10 -blocks and the people that rejected it didn't want ... didn't want a 20 or 15 -story building right next to College Green Park, right next to the ... the, uh, residential areas. But the Zoning commission voted ... would not approve either one of `em! It appears that you're ignoring that also. It appears also that Planning and Zoning wanted to continue with the City plan that was already in existence. In the January 9 ... 2013 City This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 10 Council meeting, I was here! I saw it; I heard it! Even though discussing... even before discussing the finances — TIF, cost, etc. — Councilman Mims' first ... was the first to speak and she stood up and said ... I see no further ... no reason for any further discussion. I was for the Chauncey in the very beginning. You mean you asked for nine ... you got nine RFP re ... replies? And you were for that in the beginning? Why did you ask for ... requests for proposals if you were for it in the beginning? Hayek: Mr. Madden, your time is up. If you could complete your comments please! Madden: The, uh... Senator ... or the Councilwoman Champion ... I don't think it's been five minutes! Hayek: It's been five minutes and 12 (both talking) Madden: Councilwoman Champion stood up and said, yes, I agree! Let's not get into any numbers game. Isn't that why we have a city council? To look at the numbers? Hayek: Sir, I'm going to ask you to finish your comments. We're consistent with community comment and anything else. Madden: Well ... I ... I have other things to say and I ... I don't like being cut off. Five minutes is a ... is a, uh... uh... Hayek: Sir ... we treat you like we do anybody else. (both talking) Madden: It would appear that this Council (both talking) I will close! I will close with this comment: it would appear that this Council should erase the problem set up to date on this piece of property and start all over again while listening to the citizens and to follow the City zoning plan. I wonder whether this Council has the moral courage and intestinal fortitude to weigh these factors and to reevaluate and start over. Hayek: Mr. Madden, I invite you to come back on the evening when we actually take up this item, which will be at a future date. Madden: Why wasn't it brought up tonight? Hayek: It's not on (both talking) Madden: It was on ... it was in the paper that you're bringing it up tonight! Hayek: You're now over six minutes, so I would ask you to sit down so that others can address (both talking) This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 11 Madden: I'm wondering why it wasn't brought up tonight. Why are the City ... why was the City, uh, Press -Citizen saying it was brought up tonight? Hayek: I don't know, sir. If you have questions about how our agendas are (both talking) Madden: You're not going to bring it up tonight, is that correct? Hayek: It is not on tonight's agenda. Madden: Oh, thank you! Hayek: Thank you very much for your comments! Dieterle: I'm Caroline Dieterle, and I ... my remarks will be much shorter. I wish I'd had a chance to accede some of my time to Hank, because I agree with a lot of what he was saying. However, the reason that I am speaking tonight is to express my extreme disgust at reading in the paper that, uh, people on the Council, at least some of you, uh, think about the Planning and Zoning Commission as being `dysfunctional.' Um, presumably because they did not bring in the verdict that you were hoping for. And, I think that that is a very bad attitude to have, because I think that the Planning and Zoning Commission... was actually funch... functioning the way a commission is supposed to! They were listening to what citizens had to say, and weighing what they were reasoning them with, and came up with a verdict that was an independent verdict that really, you know, mirrored what public comment was and public opinion. That's what a commission should do! And when you get a version of...of the ... well, you get a, um, a verdict from your commission and you don't like it, you know it is really... really, really annoying to hear that they think that this is a dysfunctional commission. It's doing its job and the people who aren't doing their job is the Council! If anybody isn't doing the ... doing their job. You know the more that I look at this situation here with City government, and I've been watching it... for a long time now, you know, with this ... mirage of expanding the tax base that never seems to do anything for anybody's taxes. They've gone up consistently every year since 1968. Uh, despite the huge growth that the city has had. You know it becomes clearer and clearer that basically the government here is existing for the sake of the developers who are making money off the rest of us, and that the Council runs the City as elite for the elite and they want it to be kept for the elite, and if you don't get the version of things that you want from your commission, then you have the temerity to say that they're dysfunctional, when actually they are trying to do the democratic thing and I wish that you would reexamine your consciences on this and change your attitude about the Planning and Zoning Commission. They did the right thing! Thank you. Hayek: Thank you for the comments. Anyone else during community comment? Okay! Move on to Item 6, Planning and Zoning Matters. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 12 ITEM 6. PLANNING AND ZONING MATTERS.. (In accordance with the City Attorney's memo of 2/28/07 entitled "Rezonings, Due Process and Ex parte communications" Council will discuss # 6a, 6b at formal meeting) ITEM 6a REZONING NE CORNER DUBUQUE RD AND N DODGE ST — REZONING 4.26 ACRES OF PROPERTY FROM LOW DENSITY SINGLE FAMILY (RS -5) ZONE TO MIXED USE (MU) ZONE LOCATED AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF DUBUQUE RD AND NORTH DODGE STREET. (REZ15-00002) 1. PUBLIC HEARING Hayek: This is a public hearing. The hearing is open. (bangs gavel) Any ex parte communications to disclose? Mr. Miklo! Miklo: Bob Miklo, Senior Planner, uh, with the Neighborhood and Development Services Department. Uh, this, uh... um, proposal has two aspects to it. The first of, uh, of it is a, uh, or aspect is a rezoning of the, uh, property on the, uh, east side of Dubuque Road, uh, north of Dodge Street. (clears throat) At a later date when you have third consideration you will also consider the subdivision of this, uh, of this property into two lots. Uh, aerial photographs shows the, uh, the location of the property, just as a landmark the existing Hy -Vee is just to the west on the west side of Dubuque Road. Uh, the proposal is to, uh, rezone, um ... lot #1, the proposed lot #1, to MU, which is our mixed use zone. It allows, uh, office uses and light commercial uses, as well as ... as residential. Um, the second aspect of the ... of the application, the subdivision, would create a lot #2 as well, which is existing RS -5, or single family, uh, zoning. That zoning would stay in place, which would allow a single family, uh, lot to be built on this ... on this property. The, uh... uh, proposed rezoning would allow a ... a medical office, uh, to be built on this property. In the future it could also be other, uh, light commercial or office uses allowed in the ... in the MU zone. Uh, the Planning and Zoning Commission considered this application at two meetings, um, and the, uh, at first there were some concerns about the, uh, size of the parking lot and the relationship to the single family home, uh, across the, uh... uh, Dubuque Street to the west. Uh, after some discussion and negotiations with the, uh... uh, applicant, the, um ... uh, Planning and Zoning Commission unanimously recommended approval of the rezoning. Uh, the concerns about the size of the parking lot have, uh, been addressed by a conditional zoning, uh, agreement, which would set aside, uh, a portion of the parking lot for later development, only if it's shown, uh, to the satisfaction of the City, uh, that it's necessary to serve the ... the needs of the development. Uh, the other concern was addressed to the satisfaction of the Planning and Zoning Commission by the addition of landscaping, uh, along Dubuque Road, um, and the removal of parking in, uh, this area. The, uh, your packet includes some additional information and a concept plan, uh, showing, uh, what the, uh, the, uh, proposed office building may look like on ... on this property. Uh, the mixed use zone does have a number of design standards that This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 13 have to be met at the time of ... of site plan approval. I'd be happy to try to answer any questions about this application. Payne: So the, um, the screening that'll be along Dubuque Road, that's going to be S3 screening? Miklo: Yes. Uh... Payne: And then ... that other lot can be built as single family, is that S3 there where you're pointing to or is it 2? Miklo: I believe it's S3 as well. Payne: Okay. Miklo: Be a ... a hedge, um ... uh, 50% evergreen, as well as a mixture of deciduous trees, over -story trees. Dobyns: What is S2 and S3? Miklo: Um, it's, um, requires a, um, basically a dense, uh, row of...of landscaping that you can't see through. Um, and it ... in this case they're also proposing a berm, which will help shield, uh, headlights or block headlights. Dobyns: S3 being the most opaque? Miklo: Um ... we also have a S4, which is a solid wall, uh, which we usually reserve that for industrial -type areas. Payne: So S...the higher the number, the denser... Miklo: Right, right, right! Throgmorton: So there are 232 stalls, right, 166 would be paved and the other 66 would be in phase 2, maybe ... maybe paved later on, is that correct? Miklo: Yeah, I believe it's ... it's less than that in this ... this iteration (both talking) Throgmorton: So 166 and 66. Miklo: Think that might have been in the original staff report, um, the urn ... the applicant could address, uh, address that. Throgmorton: Well the ... the map we have in our packet says 166 plus 66. Miklo: (both talking) It's what shown on this plan (both talking) This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 14 Throgmorton: What I ... first thing I was wondering is, uh, that I understand that the ... at least the total number exceeds, uh, the number that the City would require, the number of parking stalls the City would require for a project of this kind? Miklo: That's true. Throgmorton: Uh, so ... but I don't know. How many parking stalls would the City require? What's the ... minimum that it requires? Miklo: I don't know that. I can calculate that and report back. I... Throgmorton: Okay, so ... set that question aside for a second. Uh, I was then wondering why the developer thinks this number of stalls is required, rather than ... the min ... the minimum mandated by the City? Miklo: And I ... I believe the developer's, uh, representative can address that. That was discussed at the Planning and Zoning Commission and ... and, uh, one thing that was pointed out, that there is no on-stri ... on -street parking in this, uh, this area of...being that it's Highway 1/Dodge Street, there's no on -street parking allowed here. Uh, their concern was if they did not provide sufficient parking, it would spill over onto Dubuque Stre... uh, Dubuque Road and into the residential, uh, neighborhood. Payne: I did read that too in their meeting minutes, Jim, and my thought was ... and ... I had the same concerns — why are we putting in more than ... than what is needed. But ... wh... I guess what my thought was was ... the building is a ... there'll be ap ...appointments so it'll be a medical clinic and there'll be appointments. Well, if you have an appointment at 10:00 and I have one at 10:30, I'm probably going to get there before you leave. So ... there has to be more parking spaces than it seems like would be needed because appoint... people overlap, you know? So I can kind of understand where they're coming from... with... with that respect. Mims: Yeah, and my take on it was, it's more than the City requires, which ... I would agree, I mean, I don't want to have any more paved land than we absolutely have to have, but I also ... have absolutely no knowledge of how many parking spaces it takes at a medical clinic ... how many offices they're going to have, how many doctors, how many physician assistants or whatever. I ... I guess I would somewhat defer to them to have a better understanding of what their flow (both talking) Yeah, what the flow of people are and the needs, and I... I guess I looked at it and thought this was at least a reasonable compromise, that they're not paving all of it at once and then they're going to have to basically prove to the City the need for the additional lots before that can be paved. Hayek: So let's make sure we're asking questions and gathering information (several talking) This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 15 Throgmorton: ... let me follow up on the point you just made, Susan, about, uh... what ... a ... about the developer having to prove that the other 66 units are ... or ... or parking stalls are required. So the language in the text that I saw was `evidence of need.' So what I'm wondering is, how would the staff measure... evidence of need with regard to whether or not the other 66 parking stalls need to be paved? Miklo: We've had other situations and agreements, uh, where we've had such stipulations. And what was required, um ... um, to allow additional paving was to show that there were ... there was spillover parking, that there was parking on the street or that there were complaints from the neighborhood of, uh, excess parking. Uh, I believe there might have been only one case where we ended up allowing additional parking because they were able to ... to show that. Throgmorton: Uh huh. That sounds pretty reasonable. Uh, could ... if I could, one last question? Hayek: Sure! Throgmorton: Uh, with regard to the ... paving, uh... I note that storm water run-off from the parking lot would go through storm water pipes on north Dodge Street. So it makes me wonder why not use permeable pavers so that the water will filter ... would filter down into the soil rather than run off into the river. Miklo: Um, that would be a question for the ... for the applicant. Um, this (both talking) is in the, um ... um, watershed that's, um, handled by the, uh, regional storm water basin in, uh, in Hickory Hill Park, and other subdivisions in this area, um, are... are permitted to use that facility as well. Throgmorton: 0 ... okay. So I ... I guess maybe if the developer is present, maybe....couple, at least a couple of the questions I asked could be addressed... but maybe other people have questions for Bob. Hayek: No, Jim, go ahead and ask! Are there other questions for Bob at this time? Thanks! Don't go far! Sir, could you come forward? Yeah. Jim, do you have questions for the ... for the representative? Throgmorton: Yeah, I ... I guess I have two specific questions. Um ... hi! Hayek: Hi! Harder: I'm Jason Harder with, uh, Focus Commercial. We're the applicant, uh, also build -to -suit. Um ... the paving in the parking, this has gone through many iterations and you bring up a lot of good points. The ... the parking is ... is a double-edged sword. We don't want to put any more in than we ... we need, as Bob pointed out. We also don't want to be short, and so the ... the two -phased idea was, uh, I guess implemented. Um ... we based it on our client's estimation This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 16 of parking needs. You bring up excellent points — there's always overlap. It's hard to out -guess, but ... but if we fail on the wrong side of this and we're short on parking, I feel like it's going to cause a ... a real problem as there's no immediate parking available, adjacent to our property. So, uh, this started ... at one ... one time we had 300 parking spaces. And then we've constantly squeezed it down and squeezed it down, and tried to accommodate everything that ... that the P&Z, staff, the neighbors have asked us to do, and I think we've done a great job of it. Um ... there is a lot of parking. It's a fairly sizeable building. It's a two-story structure. Um, there could be at different times of the season there could be different, um, peaks and valleys in the number of, uh, clients that come and use this facility. So, uh... this is the rendition we came up with, uh, so to answer question #1, there's been a lot of thought and guesswork trying to go into this. We ... we don't want to spend money just to spend money. We don't want to have a sea of parking lot that sits empty ... any more than you do! Um ... I don't know if that addresses it to your satisfaction, but that ... that's how we (both talking) Throgmorton: No, thanks.... that.... that's helpful. I appreciate you describing that (both talking) Maybe could you touch on the permeable paver part of this too? Harder: Um ... sure! Uh... permeable paving is something that, uh... we've looked at on other projects. Um, it's not desirable by a lot of people. A lot of clients .... uh, for ... for different reasons. Uh, I'm not suggesting that it's not a good ... a good way to infiltrate water into the ground. Um ... this project was not elected to go with that, from our client's standpoint, a budgetary standpoint, the fact that this has already been accommodated by the City in a ... in a regional storm water retention basin. So it was planned for this area to already be accommodated somewhere else. So ... um ... we are sticking with a traditional paving versus coming up with a permeable paver, um ... that ... that was our decision, our client's decision (both talking) Throgmorton: Okay! Thanks! Harder: Sure! And I'm happy to answer any questions. If you want me to sit down, let other people come up and talk, I'm happy to do that. I'm... Hayek: Any questions for the representative at this time? Okay. Thank you. This is a public hearing. Anyone from the audience is welcome to provide input. Okay, I don't see any interest. Uh... before I close the public hearing let me take the temperature of Council. Are we inclined to go with the recommendation? Okay. Looks like we are. So I will close the public hearing at this time. (bangs gavel) 2. CONSIDER AN ORDINANCE (FIRST CONSIDERATION) Mims: Move first consideration. Payne: Second. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 17 Hayek: Moved by Mims, seconded by Payne. Discussion? Throgmorton: So I see merit in rezoning the property to MU, especially given its consistency with the Comp Plan, uh, and I think a medical clinic would be an appropriate use of the property. So I'll vote for the rezoning. Uh, but I do have a ... a couple concerns, or maybe one, I don't know. We'll see how this works out. Uh, that I would like to articulate. I note that 60% of the property currently is woodland, but only 10% is required to be preserved by our sensitive natural areas ordinance. Basically three to four acres of woodland would be cut down to make space for a 232 -stall parking lot. The ... this disturbs me. To my mind it once again raises questions about our sensitive natural areas ordinance, and maybe even the depth of our commitment to sustainability. But I know that topic is not what's at hand. I ... I just want to sort of flag it, uh... uh, for that future work session we're going to have a... about the sensitive natural areas ordinance. I... it just concerns me that, you know, what in fact is happening to woodland that ... has its own value. So ... I'll vote for the rezoning though. Mims: Yeah, I think it's a good use of this corner lot right on Highway 1. Um ... get some more development out there and commercial. Uh, I would just quickly comment on the trees, Jim. This is right in my neighborhood and um, I guess I would say that ... I think there's an awful lot on the slopes that are not going to be taken out, and an awful lot of what is there is really scrub. It ... it's not good quality woods... woodland that you would... really, really work hard to preserve. That's... there's an awful lot of scrub stuff in there. ... sol ...I love the woods. I've got a lot of it myself, and I like to keep it, but I don't think this is as detrimental as it might seem on the surface. Hayek: Further discussion? Roll call, please. First consideration passes 6-0. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 18 ITEM 6c SILVER SLOPE — PARTS ONE AND TWO — RESOLUTION APPROVING PRELIMINARY AND FINAL PLATS (SUB14-0008 & SUB15-0005) Hayek: Can we get this on the floor? Payne: Move the resolution. Botchway: Second. Hayek: Moved by Payne, seconded by Botchway. Discussion? Bob! Miklo: Um (clears throat) this, uh, application is associated with the rezoning that you just approved. Uh, it includes two parts, uh, part one, um, is, um ... uh, the Hieronymus property, um, located on Muscatine Avenue. Part two includes 19 single family lots and one multi -family lot. The rezoning just affected this sliver along the west and north sides of lot #20, which is the multi -family lot. And here's an image of the subdivision showing the new street, which would intersect with, uh, Scott Boulevard. Uh, and it would have, as I said, 19 single family lots and one multi -family lot, which would have access to the new street, um... the uh, part one includes the existing Hieronymus, uh, property or home, as well as outlot A. Outlot A is being set aside as permanent open space. It contains a grove of trees which would be permanently preserved as part of this, uh, of this subdivision. The, uh, Planning and Zoning Commission, um, recommended approval of the, uh, subdivision at their February 19U' meeting. It was a unan... unanimous vote with one, uh, member absent. Um, staff has found that it, uh, complies with our subdivision regulations and, uh, recommends approval. Be happy to try to answer any questions. Mims: Bob, part of this ... change in renegot ... renegotiation that's gone through here, establishing that outlot ... outlot A, basically prevents development along... Muscatine Avenue that would necessitate another cul-de-sac, is that (both talking) correct? Miklo: ...that's correct. There is the potential, uh, that these, uh, lots might be subdivided in the future, uh, for ... for, uh, with access to Muscatine, um, Avenue, but there would be no, um, possibility of a cul-de-sac, uh, resulting in outlot A being subdivided. Mims: Okay. Thank you! Payne: Even if they came and asked to change the ... plat? Miklo: Right. The, uh, final plat designates this and the legal papers, as well, as permanent open space. For woodland, or for preservation of this grove. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 19 Payne: How ... what's the distance between the intersection of Scott Boulevard and Muscatine to this new intersection? Miklo: I am not sure but I believe it's well over 200 feet. Payne: Not very far! Miklo: Um... Payne: And halfway down a hill! Miklo: Our transportation planners did look at this, as well as our engineers, and were satisfied with this, uh, intersection location. You may recall there was a previous subdivision on this property that had a, uh, street, uh, that intersected with Muscatine Avenue, even closer to the intersection (both talking) Payne: Uh huh! Miklo: ...and this was found to be actually preferable. Payne: So be in the middle of a hill on probably a place that backs up all the way down to the bottom of the hill, all the way to the crosswalk. Mims: But when we get the roundabout in it won't. Payne: (laughs) Yeah, exactly! (laughs) Miklo: Site distance was ... was looked at closely by our, uh, traffic, uh, planners, and they found that it was this ... this was not seen as being problematic. Payne: Okay. Hayek: Any other questions for Bob? Thanks! Any discussion from the audience? Coun ...Council discussion? Payne: I do have concerns about how close that is to the intersection. And I'm not in favor of the roundabout anyway! (laughs) Hayek: For the record there's no roundabout (both talking) Payne: Yet! (laughs) Hayek: ...as part of this (both talking) Payne: ... discussion! This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 20 Mims: ...just had to throw it in. Sorry! Hayek: Further discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 6-0. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 21 ITEM 7. LOT 7 NORTH AIRPORT DEVELOPMENT SUBDIVISION - RESOLUTION APPROVING A PURCHASE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF IOWA CITY AND RONALD WADE TRUST FOR LOT 7 OF THE NORTH AIRPORT DEVELOPMENT SUBDIVISION, AUTHORIZING CONVEYANCE IN ACCORDANCE THEREWITH, AND RESCINDING RESOLUTION NO. 14-325 a. PUBLIC HEARING Hayek: This is a public hearing. The hearing is open. (bangs gavel) For the public's information, the, uh, sale price for lot #7 is $185,000 and was recommended by the Airport Commission. Anyone from the audience? Public hearing is closed. (bangs gavel) b. CONSIDER A RESOLUTION Payne: Move the resolution. Dobyns: Second. Botchway: Second. Hayek: Moved by Payne, seconded by ... Dobyns. Discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 6-0. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 22 ITEM 8. 2015 LANDFILL CHEMICAL STORAGE BUILDING REPLACEMENT — APPROVING PLANS, SPECIFICATIONS, FORM OF CONTRACT, AND ESTIMATE OF COST FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE 2015 LANDFILL CHEMICAL STORAGE BUILDING REPLACEMENT PROJECT, ESTABLISHING AMOUNT OF BID SECURITY TO ACCOMPANY EACH BID, DIRECTING CITY CLERK TO PUBLISH NOTICE TO BIDDERS, AND FIXING TIME AND PLACE FOR RECEIPT OF BIDS a. PUBLIC HEARING Hayek: This is a public hearing. The hearing is open. (bangs gavel) The estimated construction cost on this is $100,000 and will be funded with Landfill revenues. Public hearing is closed. (bangs gavel) b. CONSIDER A RESOLUTION Dobyns: Move the resolution. Botchway: Second. Hayek: Moved by Dobyns, seconded by Botchway. Discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 6-0. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 23 ITEM 9. EAST HARRISON STREET RECONSTRUCTION — APPROVING PLANS, SPECIFICATIONS, FORM OF CONTRACT, AND ESTIMATE OF COST FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE EAST HARRISON STREET RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT, ESTABLISHING AMOUNT OF BID SECURITY TO ACCOMPANY EACH BID, DIRECTING CITY CLERK TO PUBLISH NOTICE TO BIDDERS, AND FIXING TIME AND PLACE FOR RECEIPT OF BIDS a. PUBLIC HEARING Hayek: This is a public hearing. The hearing is open. (bangs gavel) Estimated construction cost is $450,000 and will be funded with general obligation bond proceeds. Anyone from the audience? Hearing is closed. (bangs gavel) b. CONSIDER A RESOLUTION Mims: Move the resolution. Dobyns: Second. Hayek: Moved by Mims, seconded by Dobyns. Discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 6- 0. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 24 ITEM 10. $6,500,000 GENERAL OBLIGATION BONDS — RESOLUTION INSTITUTING PROCEEDINGS TO TAKE ADDITIONAL ACTION FOR THE ISSUANCE OF NOT TO EXCEED $6,500,000 GENERAL OBLIGATION BONDS a. PUBLIC HEARING Hayek: This is a public hearing. The hearing is open. (bangs gavel) Hello, Dennis! Bockenstedt: Good evening, I'm Dennis Bockenstedt, the Finance Director for the City. Tonight I'm going to address Items, uh, 10 through 15, which all relate to the 2015 GO bond sale. Um, there've been a series of five public hearings and six resolutions, which are, uh, the legal process for the issuance of the general obligation bonds. Uh, the sale date will be May 5`". Uh, the dollar amount that is currently proposed is $7,785,000 and there is a project list included in your packet, which, uh, was generated from this year's, uh, five-year capital improvement program. Uh, those projects, uh, really are primarily street and park projects. Uh, the largest project on that list relates to the First Avenue railroad underpass, of about $3,050,000. And I'll answer any questions if you have any. Hayek: Questions for Dennis? That list is very helpful, by the way. Mims: Yes! Hayek: Public hearing if anyone would like to address the Council on these items. Please do so! Public hearing is closed. (bangs gavel) b. CONSIDER A RESOLUTION Payne: Move the resolution. Botchway: Second. Hayek: Moved by Payne, seconded by Botchway. Discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 6-0. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 25 ITEM 15. DIRECTING BOND SALE - RESOLUTION DIRECTING THE ADVERTISEMENT FOR SALE OF $7,785,000 (DOLLAR AMOUNT SUBJECT TO CHANGE) GENERAL OBLIGATION BONDS, SERIES 2015, AND APPROVING ELECTRONIC BIDDING PROCEDURES Mims: Move the resolution. Botchway: Second. Hayek: Moved by Mims, seconded by Botchway. Discussion? Mims: I would just like to say thank you to our Finance Department and Dennis for all the hard work they do. I know we've got great bond counsel, but you guys do all the ... the foot work to get the stuff ready, so ... thank you very much! Hayek: Yeah, and this goes toward, uh... so many projects that we've identified as priorities, whether it's the railroad, uh, grade separation or park upgrades, uh... uh, elementary school partnerships, the like. Long list! Further discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 6-0. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 26 ITEM 18. FOOD TRUCK VENDING - ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 9, ENTITLED "MOTOR VEHICLES AND TRAFFIC," CHAPTER 4, ENTITLED "PARKING REGULATIONS," TO ESTABLISH PROVISIONS FOR FOOD TRUCK VENDING ON CITY STREETS. (Pass and adopt) Mims: Move adoption. Payne: Second. Hayek: Moved by Mims, seconded by Payne. Discussion? Browne: Good evening, Council. Um ... based on the last two votes on this, uh.... Hayek: Could you give us your name, sir, just for the record? Browne: Anthony Browne. Hayek: Thank you! Browne: Um ... based on the last two votes on this, it doesn't seem, uh, this is going to be controversial, even though apparently, uh, food truck vending is a controversial business model. Um, I want to thank Geoff from the City Manager's office. He helped us, uh, we all worked together to kind of, um, get this ordinance together. We, you know, listened to the concerns of the downtown district and the, uh, brick and mortar restaurants around town, and that's how this all came about. Um, I'm sure Kyle will have something to say about this also. He's the owner of Loco Burrito and also works at the, um, Farmers Market. So I encourage, uh, all six of you tonight to vote for it. Uh, again it looks like you will pass this and so hopefully this is not a controversial vote, but if it is, I encourage you to vote for it. Thank you! Hayek: Thank you for your comments! Would anyone else like to address the Council on this item? Council discussion? Are ... do you want to address us, Mr. Knight, on Item 18? Knight: (unable to hear away from mic) Hayek: Yes, sir, 18! Knight: Hi, I'm Roger Knight. Long time no see! Um, you know I just wanted to add one little, uh, note to this. This says food truck vending, but I don't know if there's some kind of loophole for party buses at night, but um ... maybe it's not. You guys lookin' at me like I'm an idiot (laughs) so I will shut up and back away then! (laughs) Unless there is some kind of loophole because I've noticed tho... all I was going to say is since this came up about food trucks, there's been a lot more This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 27 party buses at night. Um, I don't know if they come in from ... uh, Davenport or whatever, but ... the like traveling bars or whatever they're called. Um, I don't know if, like I said, it's some kind of loophole but they seem to be getting more and more, um... Hayek: I think that's unrelated to this. Knight: Okay! I'll back away and ... I'll stop lookin' like an idiot! Thanks! Hayek: Anyone else on Item 18? Council discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 6-0. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 28 ITEM 20. CHARTER AMENDMENTS - ORDINANCE AMENDING THE IOWA CITY CHARTER PREAMBLE, AND ARTICLE II (CITY COUNCIL) SECTION 2.06 (MAYOR), ARTICLE III (NOMINATION, PRIMARY ELECTION AND REGULAR ELECTION) SECTION 3.01 (NOMINATION), ARTICLE IV (CITY MANAGER) SECTION 4.02 (ACCOUNTABILITY; REMOVAL), ARTICLE V (BOARDS, COMMISSIONS AND COMMITTEES), SECTION 5.01 (ESTABLISHMENT) AND SECTION 5.02 (APPOINTMENT; REMOVAL), ARTICLE VI (CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTIONS AND EXPENDITURES) SECTION 6.03 (DEFINITION) AND ARTICLE VII (INITIATIVE AND REFERENDUM) AS RECOMMENDED BY THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMISSION. (FIRST CONSIDERATION) Payne: Move first consideration. Mims: Second. Hayek: Moved by Payne, seconded by Mims. Discussion? Is there anyone from the audience who would like to address the Council on Item 20? Council discussion? Payne: I guess I was just going to say that the Charter Review Commission put a lot of time and effort into this, and um ... I think that this is ... the appropriate thing to do is pass these at this point in time. Mims: Yeah, I'd just like to add a big thank you. I think maybe we did at our work session when Andy Chappell presented, but ... um, a number of people put in a lot of time at a lot of meetings, um, not only the Commission Members but uh, getting the input from the public. Um, I think ... you know, there's a lot of different opinions, um, some ... you know, very good I think discussion on some of the issues where there was not, uh, unanimous agreement. Um, but people came to consensus on these and, um ... got some changes and we move forward and we'll do it again in 10 years! Hayek: I thought it was very deliberate and thoughtful process, um, it was interesting to see not only the community input, but the engagement within the Commission, um ... which I thought was very healthy, urn ... so I'm supportive of passing this as well. Throgmorton: I'd like to make a couple observations. One is, I don't know if people in the audience or on ... watching on TV know this, but ... in a ... a previous work session — I don't know, was it two weeks ago, we talked about this briefly and we scheduled ... we ind... we indicated that we would be discussing other possible changes to the ... to the Charter, in a work session, and then depending on how that discussion goes, maybe move them along in accord with the legal processes for amending the Charter. So, that has nothing directly to do with adoption of this particular set of amendments, but ... there is this other process that... possibly This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 29 underway because we're going to talk about it in a work session. So I just want people to know that, and there are various topics I know that, uh, Kingsley had in mind, there are a couple or whatever that I had in mind, maybe y'all had some in mind as well. So the other thing I wanted to mention though has to do with the... the particular Char ... Charter, um, that we will be adopting tonight, so I want to draw attention to the new Preamble. It states, we the people of Iowa City, Iowa, pursuant to the Constitution and Statutes of the State of Iowa, and the principle of self-determination proclaim that the government of Iowa City belongs to all its residents... and all share the responsibility for it. So ... uh, I ... completely support that new language. Uh, it rightly emphasizes that "the government of Iowa City belongs to all its residents." But unless I'm mistaken, I also note that the Charter does not explicitly account for the role of non-resident property owners and businesses. And we all know that non-resident property owners and businesses exercise considerable influence over City decisions. Perhaps more than residents do. And the fact that non-resident businesses and property owners have a stake in City decisions, I think could easily be acknowledged in the Charter. I mean I'm not saying they don't have a .... um, a stake (laughs) in what we're doing. I'm just saying that the Preamble makes it sound as if it's residents only and ... my personal feeling is that residents are the people that count ... but the fact on the ground is that non-resident businesses and property owners exert a lot of influence. Dobyns: You want that in the Preamble, Jim? Throgmorton: No, in the body probably. I'm just trying to draw this ... draw attention to the gap between the language of the Preamble about who this City government belongs to, and who actually exerts a considerable amount of influence over City decisions. Dobyns: In your opinion. Throgmorton: Pay attention! Hayek: Any further discussion? Roll call, please. Passes 6-0. This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015. Page 30 ITEM 23. CITY COUNCIL INFORMATION Hayek: We'll start down with you... Kingsley! Botchway: Um ... nothing! I ... I just want ... is somebody else going to bring up the Victim Empowerment Program, because I don't have the ... I was trying to pull up my calendar. I think it's 5:30 to 7:00 tomorrow at the Iowa City, uh, Recreation Center. Okay! Sorry! That's what I wanted to bring up! Hayek: Jim? Throgmorton: Nothing! Mims: Nothing! Payne: I just want to make mention that tomorrow is Earth Day, and the City has several events, uh, going on for Earth Day. Uh, if you go to icgov.org, uh, there's a calendar of events and you can find those on that col... calendar of events. Hayek: Um, so we had the, uh... NCAA swimming and diving championships in Iowa City. Um, and we got a ... a nice message back from the athletic staff, uh, there had been a survey of coaches, NCAA, uh, staff and committee and officials, um, and the overwhelming feedback was that the experience, uh, at the NCAA championships here in Iowa City was a very positive one, and there was one comment in particular that was brought to my attention that I want to, uh, pass along, that somebody who participated in the event, uh, provided, and it ... and it is this, "My favorite memory had to have been walking around Iowa City and feeling like I was famous. The entire city was involved and that really contributed to a unique atmosphere. The people were extremely nice and made me feel like I was a big deal for simply being part of the championship." Um, and so this is coming from probably an athlete, uh, who was here competing, and I think that's a nice feather in our cap (coughing, difficult to hear speaker) commend U of I and, uh, CVB and ... and the City and ... and the others who were involved in putting on, uh, a remarkable event, uh, that we can all be proud of! So... This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council regular formal meeting of April 21, 2015.