Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2008-10-21 Ordinance10-Z1-08 City of Iowa City 7a MEMORANDUM Date: October 15, 2008 To: City Council From: Karen Howard, Associate Planner RE: Sign code amendments proposed for residential zones At your last meeting, the Council requested clarification on two issues related to the proposed amendments to the sign code. Residential Leasing Company Signs A question was raised at the meeting about how staff and the Planning and Zoning Commission settled on eight apartments as the threshold for allowing "residential leasing company signs." Eight units was determined to be the minimum necessary to distinguish large buildings that could accommodate these types of signs versus smaller buildings where these commercial signs may detract from the buildings' intended purpose as residential dwellings. Residential leasing company signs are not currently allowed in any residential zone. Staff felt and the Planning and Zoning Commission concurred that there was some merit in creating a sign category for this type of sign and allowing them in multi-family zones on buildings that were clearly constructed as multi-family buildings with enough dwelling units to warrant a permanent sign. There is a higher probability at any point in time that a building with a larger number of apartments would have a vacancy than a building with fewer units. Eight units was determined to be a reasonable threshold that could easily be enforced. Another reason that staff and the Commission are recommending that permanent leasing signs be allowed only on larger buildings is that even in the high density multi-family zones there tends to be a mix of housing types and sizes -larger apartment buildings, older homes split into apartments or rooming houses, duplexes, and single family homes. While larger multi-family buildings have larger facades that can easily accommodate a small leasing company sign without detracting from the residential character of the building, smaller buildings, particularly those originally built as single family homes, do not. One final point of clarification: commercial signage is expected and allowed in commercial zones. Mixed-use buildings (ground floor commercial with any number of apartments above) located in commercial zones are allowed any type of commercial signage as specified in the sign code, including residential leasing company signs. Residential leasing company signs affixed to the building would be considered a facia sign for which there would be a certain allowance based on the size of the building facade. Signs for home occupations A question arose during your discussion about what signage is allowed for home occupations. A home occupation is an accessory use of residential property where the primary resident or residents of a dwelling use the dwelling as a place of work. A number of restrictions apply to ensure that the residential character of the home is not compromised. Home occupations are allowed one non- illuminated facia sign (a sign affixed to the building), not to exceed one square foot in size. Cc: Michael Lombardo, City Manager Jeff Davidson, Director of Planning and Community Development Doug Boothroy, Director of Housing and Inspection Services Jann Ream, Code Enforcement Assistant -- Prepared by: Karen Howard, Associate Planner, 410 E Washington St, Iowa City, IA 52240 ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE AMENDING ARTICLE 14-56, SIGN REGULATIONS, ARTICLE 14-9C, SIGN DEFINITIONS, SECTION 14-46-1, MINOR MODIFICATIONS, AND ARTICLE 14-3C DESIGN REVIEW, TO ALLOW LIMITED USE OF FREESTANDING SIGNS IN THE CENTRALBUSINESS SERVICE (CB-2) ZONE, ADD A DEFINITION AND STANDARDS FOR ENTRANCEWAY SIGNS, AND CLARIFY REGULATIONS REGARDING SIGNS ON RENTAL PROPERTIES WHEREAS, the Central Business Service (CB-2) Zone is intended for the orderly expansion of the Central Business District, to serve as a transition between the intense land uses located in downtown Iowa City and adjoining areas and to enhance the pedestrian orientation of the central area of the city ;and WHEREAS, freestanding signs are typically not suitable for pedestrian-oriented urban commercial areas, but there are limited circumstances in the CB-2 Zone where the existing configuration of a site and location of the building or buildings on a site might make it practically difficult to install a monument sign and that other types of allowed signage would not be readily visible from the street due to the location of building(s) or other unique site characteristics; and WHEREAS, archways that delineate the entrance to a parking lot or grounds may be appropriate locations for directional and/or identification signage; and WHEREAS, commercial sign clutter detracts from the residential character of single family neighborhoods; and WHEREAS, signs advertising real estate for sale or lease should be temporary in nature and not permanent features on a building; and WHEREAS, small signs identifying the leasing company are appropriate on larger multi-family buildings in multi-family zones where due to the number of apartments turnover rates are higher. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, IOWA: SECTION I. The Code of Ordinances of the City of Iowa City, Iowa is hereby amended as follows: A. By repealing Article 14-56, "Sign Regulations," and substituting in lieu thereof "Article 14-56, Sign Regulations," attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference;. and B. Amending Article 14-9C, "Sign Definitions," by adding definitions of "entranceway sign" and "residential leasing company sign," as follows: ENTRANCEWAY SIGN - Anon-building sign incorporated into or mounted on the face of, or affixed above or below an entranceway arch that extends over a walkway or driveway. Said sign type is intended to identify and direct traffic to a place, grounds, or parking lot. The sign may include the name of only one entity or place and an associated logo, crest, or insignia that identifies the place, grounds or entity to which the parking or grounds belong. The sign may also include the words, "parking," "entrance," and/or directional arrows, but may not contain any advertising message. RESIDENTIAL LEASING COMPANY SIGN: A building sign displaying the name, address, phone number, website, crest, insignia, and/or trademark of the leasing company for the multi-family building upon which it is located. C. Amending Article 14-9C, "Sign Definitions," by deleting the definitions of "real estate sign" and temporary sign," and substituting in lieu thereof, new definitions for these sign types as follows: REAL ESTATE SIGN: A temporary sign which advertises the sale, rental or lease of the premises or part of the premises on which the sign is located, including open house directional signs. TEMPORARY SIGN: A yard sale sign, temporary identification sign, real estate sign, or political sign constructed of temporary materials, such as cardboard, wallboard or plywood, with or without a structural frame, intended for a temporary period of display, but excluding banners. D. Amending Section 14-4B-1, "Minor Modifications," by adding a paragraph 20, under subsection A, "Applicability," as follows: Ordinance No. Page 2 20. Freestanding sign in the CB-2 Zone, according to the approval criteria and specifications as stated in Table 56-4 in Article 14-56, Sign Regulations. E. Amending Section 14-3C-2, "Applicability," by adding a paragraph 8, under subsection A, "Designated areas, buildings, and structures," as follows: 8. Entranceway Signs Requests for an alternative design for an entranceway sign as provided for in Article 14- 56, Sign Regulations. F. Amending paragraph 14-3C-3A-1, "Level I Review," by adding asub-subparagraph (8) under subparagraph a, as follows: (8) Requests for an alternative design for an entranceway sign as provided for in Article 14- 56, Sign Regulations. SECTION III. REPEALER. All ordinances and parts of ordinances in conflict with the provisions of this Ordinance are hereby repealed. SECTION IV. SEVERABILITY. If any section, provision or part of the Ordinance shall be adjudged to be invalid or unconstitutional, such adjudication shall not affect the validity of the Ordinance as a whole or any section, provision or part thereof not adjudged invalid or unconstitutional. SECTION V. EFFECTIVE DATE. This Ordinance shall be in effect after its final passage, approval and publication. Passed and approved this day of , 20 MAYOR Approved by ATTEST: ~~~`~ CITY CLERK - ity Attorney's Office ~ /~S/~~ Ordinance No. Page It was moved by and seconded by that the Ordinance as read be adopted, and upon roll call there were: AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: Bailey Champion Correia Hayek O'Donnell Wilburn Wright First Consideration l0 / 6 / oos Vote for passage: AYES: Wilburn, Wright, Bailey, Champion, Correia. NAYS: Hayek, O'Donnell. ABSENT: None. Second Consideration ~ o / 2 ~ / Moog Vote for passage: AYES: Correia, O'Donnell, Wilburn, Wright, Bailey, Champion.' NAYS: Hayek. ABSENT: None. Date published PAGE 56-1 14-SB Sign Regulations Article B. Sign Regulations . .. The purpose for this Article is to enhance and protect the physical appearance and safety of the community, to protect property values and to preserve Iowa City's areas of natural, historic and scenic beauty. These regulations are also intended to reduce distractions and obstructions contributing to traffic accidents, reduce hazards caused by signs projecting over the public right of way, provide a reasonable opportunity for all sign users to display signs without interference from other signage, to provide fair and equitable treatment for all sign users and to establish a reasonable period of time for the elimination of nonconforming signs. • ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ A. Applicability All signs on private property must be installed, maintained, and/or removed according to the provisions of this Article. B. Permit Required 1. No sign requiring a permit in accordance with the requirements of this Article shall be installed, altered, moved, improved or converted without first obtaining a sign permit from the Building Official or designee according to the procedures specified in Chapter 8 of this Title, Review and Approval Procedures. A permit is not required for incidental repairs or routine maintenance. 2. Certain types of signs are allowed without a permit and such exemption from the sign permit requirements is clearly specified in the tables included in Sections 8 and 9, below. A permit is required for any sign that is not specifically exempted from the permit requirements. C. Sign Installer's License Required 1. Except for those signs not requiring a permit, as listed in Sections 8 and 9 of this Article, it shall be unlawful for any person to install, alter, move, improve, remove or convert any sign without having a sign installer's license in good standing issued by the City. Aone-time sign installer's license shall be available to a tenant or owner of a building to permit the tenant's or owner's own sign to be installed. 2. The license to install, alter, move, improve, remove or convert any sign as required herein shall be known as a sign installer's license and shall be issued by the City to the person desiring to perform the work indicated above. No such license shall be issued to any person until such person shall have paid to the City a license fee as established by resolution of City Council and shall have filed with the Department of Housing and Inspection Services a copy or a certificate of a contractor's public liability insurance policy with coverage limits as set out in Title 3, Chapter 4 of the City Code. The City shall be designated as an additional insured, and the policy shall provide that the City is to be notified 30 days in advance of the terrnination of the policy. The license shall indemnify and save harmless the City from any and all damage, PAGE 5B-2 14-SB Sign Regulations judgment, cost or expense which the City may incur or suffer by reason of said license issuance. 3. All sign installer's licenses shall expire on December 31 of each year. Renewal fees and reinstatement fees shall be as established by resolution of the City Council. Any license that has expired may be reinstated within 60 calendar days after the expiration date upon payment of an additional reinstatement fee. 4. A one-time sign installer's license shall be valid for 30 days from the date of issuance. 5. The Building Official or designee is responsible for enforcement of these provisions and is empowered to suspend or revoke a sign installer's license for a violation of the sign regulations or if the license was obtained by fraud or if the license allows any person not employed by the sign installer without a valid installer's license to do or cause to be done any work requiring a license. 6. A person aggrieved by the revocation, suspension or denial of a license may appeal said action to the Board of Adjustment. 7. If a license is revoked for any reason, another installer's license shall not be issued to such person for 12 months after revocation. D. Application of State Law In any case in which the Code of Iowa, as amended, contains more restrictive requirements than the regulations contained herein, the Code of Iowa, as amended, will govern. 14-5B-3 General Location Standards A. Location Standards For All Zones 1. No sign shall be located in violation of the Intersection Visibility Standards set forth in Article 14-5D. 2. All non-building signs, and all parts thereof, must be set back at least 5 feet from any property line, with the following exception. Signs may be located closer than 5 feet to a property line at 10 feet or more above grade, provided no part of the sign or sign support overhangs any property lines. In addition, freestanding wide-base signs must not be located closer than 10 feet to any right-of-way or closer than 30 feet to any street curb. 3. Building signs must comply with the building setback requirements of the base zone. No part of a building sign or sign support may overhang a property line, unless specifically allowed in this Article. 4. For any sign that is allowed to project over the public right-of-way according to the provisions of this Article, a Use of Public Right-of-Way Agreement must be signed by the property owner as a part of the permitting process. 5. No sign shall obstruct ingress to or egress from any door, window or fire escape. No sign shall be attached to a standpipe or fire escape. PAGE 56-3 14-SB Sign Regulations B. Signs Adjacent To Residential Zones 1. Any sign located in aNon-Residential zone, but within 100 feet of a Residential Zone is subject to the standards and limitations of Subsection 8C, Sign Standards in the CO-1, CN-1 and MU Zones. 2. Electronic changeable copy signs are not allowed within 100 feet of a Residential Zone, except for allowed Time and Temperature Signs, as defined in Article 14-9C, Sign Definitions. 3. In Non-residential Zones, except for facia signs, no sign shall be located in the required front building setback area within 50 feet of a Residential Zone. 4. Facia signs located in Non-residential Zones and within 50 feet of a Residential Zone on the same side of the street shall not be placed on the wall of the building facing the Residential Zone. 14-5B-4 Construction and Maintenance Requirements A. Construction All signs, except for temporary signs, shall be designed and constructed to withstand a wind pressure of not less than 30 pounds per square foot of area and loads as required by the Building Code. B. Minimum Clearance Height The minimum clearance height is measured from grade to the lowest point on the sign. The minimum clearance height for freestanding, banner, and time and temperature signs is 10 feet. For storefront projecting signs allowed in the CB-2, CB-5 and CB-10 Zones, the minimum clearance height is 8 feet. C. Maintenance All signs shall be maintained in such a manner as to avoid becoming a hazardous sign. D. Changeable Copy 1. Copy that is changed manually Any sign may contain copy that is changed manually, unless precluded by definition or specifically prohibited herein. 2. Copy that is changed electronically Signs where the copy is changed by electronic means are only allowed as specified below. a. The sign must be located in a Commercial Zone or in a Public Zone. However, electronic changeable copy signs are not allowed within 100 feet of a Residential Zone, except for allowed Time and Temperature Signs, as defined in Article 14- 9C, Sign Definitions. On properties zoned Public, electronic changeable copy signs are not allowed where said sign would be visible from any adjacent Residential Zone. b. Electronic changeable copy is allowed on only one sign per lot. In the CH-1, CI- 1, CC-2, CB-2, and CB-5 Zones, a Time and Temperature Sign, as defined in Article 14-9C, Sign Definitions shall not count toward the one sign limit. PAGE 5B-4 14-SB Sign Regulations c. The changeable copy may not be animated (See definition of ANIMATED SIGN in Article 14-9C, Sign Definitions). The copy may be changed no more than once per hour, except for designation of the time and temperature, which may be changed more frequently. d. The sign may not contain images or be of a brightness that will interfere with, obstruct the view of, or confuse traffic. The sign may not contain images that may be confused with any authorized traffic sign, signal or device. The sign may not make use of the words, "stop," "go slow," "caution," "drive in," "danger," or any other word, phrase, symbol or character in such a way as to interfere with, mislead or confuse traffic. e. The sign must comply with the illumination standards as specified in the following subsection. f. In the MU, CO-1, CN-1, and CB-10 Zones, electronic changeable copy is only allowed on a time and temperature sign (See definition of TIME AND TEMPERATURE SIGN in Article 14-9C). The electronic changeable copy portion of the sign is limited to the display of the time and/or temperature and may not exceed 40 percent of the area of the sign face. g. In Public Zones and in CH-1, CI-1, and CC-2 Zones, electronic changeable copy is only allowed on time and temperature signs, freestanding signs, freestanding wide-base signs, and monument signs. On time and temperature signs, the electronic changeable copy portion of the sign is limited to the display of the time and/or temperature and may not exceed 40 percent of the area of the sign face. On freestanding and freestanding wide-base signs the electronic changeable copy portion of the sign may not exceed 40 percent of the area of the sign face. For monument signs the electronic changeable copy portion of the sign may not exceed 50 percent of the area of the sign face. h. In the CB-2 and CB-5 Zones, electronic changeable copy is only allowed on time and temperature signs and monument signs. On time and temperature signs, the electronic changeable copy portion of the sign is limited to the display of the time and/or temperature and may not exceed 40 percent of the area of the sign face. On monument signs the electronic changeable copy portion of the sign may not exceed 75 percent of the area of the sign face. E. Illumination Requirements Illuminated signs must conform to the following requirements: 1. Except for signs in the ID and Residential Zones and special event signs, all permitted signs may be internally or externally illuminated. All signs permitted in the ID and Residential Zones and special event signs may only be externally illuminated with white light. 2. Illumination through the use of exposed lamps or inert gas tubes is allowed, provided the exposed lamp does not exceed 11 watts or that an inert gas tube does not draw more than 60 milliamps. When inside frosted lamps or exposed lamps with a diffusing screen are used, no lamp shall exceed 25 watts. 3. Illumination through the use of LEDs is allowed only as specified for electronic changeable copy. All signs using LEDs must have installed ambient light monitors PAGE 5B-5 14-SB Sign Regulations and must at all times allow such monitors to automatically adjust the brightness level of the electronic sign based on ambient light conditions. At no time shall the sign be operated at a brightness level greater than the manufacturer's recommended levels. The electronic changeable copy must be monochromatic. It must utilize a dark background with only the message or image lit in a single color. 4. Artificial external light sources used to illuminate a sign face must be located and shielded such that the bulb is not directly visible from any adjacent residentially- zoned property or public right-of-way and must use a narrow cone of light that does not extend beyond the illuminated sign face. 5. Illumination on a property, including illumination from signs, must not exceed 0.5 initial horizontal footcandles and 2.0 initial maximum footcandles as measured at any point along a property boundary that is adjacent to or across the street from properties that are zoned Residential, CN-1, or CO-1. 6. All illuminated signs are subject to the provisions of the Electrical Code, including any permit fees. 7. Permit applications for electronic changeable copy signs must include a copy of the manufacturer's operating manual, including any recommended standards for brightness and other display operations. 8. For electronic changeable copy signs, whether the sign is programmed from the site or from a remote location, the computer interface that programs the sign shall be made available to City staff for inspection upon request. If the computer interface is not immediately available, the sign shall cease operation until such- program can be provided. 14-5B-5 Nonconformin Situations A. Nonconforming Signs All legally nonconforming signs must comply with the provisions specified for nonconforming signs in Article 14-4E, Nonconforming Situations. Signs deemed "historic" may be eligible for a special exception according to the provisions specified in Article 14- 4E, Nonconforming Situations. B. Signs for Nonconforming Uses A nonconforming use is permitted to have the same amount and type of signage as would be allowed for such use in the most restrictive zone in which such use is allowed, except that residential leasing company signs are not allowed on multi-family buildings in the RR- 1, RS-5, RS-8, RS-12, and RNS-12 Zones regardless of the nonconforming status of the building. 14-5B-6 Prohibited Signs A. Regulations are Exclusionary These regulations are intended to be exclusionary. Any type of sign not specifically listed in this Article is prohibited. In addition, the following signs are specifically prohibited in all zones: PAGE 5B-6 14-SB Sign Regulations Animated signs, except for barber poles as expressly permitted by this Article; 2. Hazardous signs; 3. Obsolete signs; 4. Painted wall signs; 5. Portable signs, including signs on wheels, trailers, and truck beds, but excepting those portable signs expressly permitted by this Article; 6. Roof signs; 7. Searchlights; 8. Spinners, balloons, pennants, or other similar devices; 9. Swinging signs. 10. No vehicle, including trailers, shall be parked so that it functions primarily as a sign. A vehicle will be considered in violation of this provision if questions a. through c., below, can be answered in the affirmative and there is no compelling answer to question d. to justify the parking location as opposed to some less conspicuous location. a. Is the vehicle parked at a prominent location? b. Can people driving by the sign easily read the sign? c. Is the vehicle in the same or similar locations for several hours during the same day or for several days during the same week? d. Are there any stated or apparent reasons, other than for signage purposes, that justify the vehicle being at that location? B. Removal of Prohibited or Illegal Signs In accordance with the following procedure, the Building Official or designee is authorized to require the removal of any illegal or prohibited sign: 1. Before taking action to require the removal of any illegal or prohibited sign, the Building Official or designee will provide written notice to the owner or operator of the business to which the sign relates. 2. The notice will specify that the illegal or prohibited sign must be removed or brought into compliance with this Article within a' reasonable time of such notice. 3. If the sign is not removed or repaired, as the case may be, within the time allowed, the Building Official or designee is hereby authorized to have the sign removed to be used as evidence and assess the costs of removal against the property for collection in the same manner as a property tax. 14-5B-7 Measurement Standards A. Maximum Sign Area 1. Where the size of a sign is regulated by the area of a wall, an awning or a canopy, the maximum sign area is calculated as a percentage of the total area of the wall, the awning, or the canopy on which the sign is affixed. PAGE 5B-7 14-SB Sign Regulations 2. For entranceway signs located on the front elevation of the subject archway, the maximum sign area is calculated as a percentage of the total area delineated by the archway. For entranceway signs located on the side of the archway, the maximum sign area is calculated as a percentage of the surface area of the side of the archway support on which the sign is located. Figure 56.1 illustrates how to measure the total area delineated by the archway and the surface area of the side of the archway support. The total area delineated by the archway in Figure 5B.1 = x(y). The surface area of the side of the archway support in Figure 5B.1 = a(b). Figure 5B.1 _T-- ~_ -,-- - , -, ~.~ - ,, 3. The total building signage on a wall, canopy, or awning shall not exceed the maximum sign allowance for that wall, canopy, or awning, regardless of the number of uses or occupants in the building. For example, if the maximum sign area for facia signs is 15 percent, then no more than 15 percent of any single wall of the building may be covered by facia signs, regardless of how many businesses are located in the building. B. Measuring Sign Area The area of each sign, regardless of shape, shall be computed by determining the area of a triangle, rectangle or circle that completely encloses the outer perimeter of the sign face. In the case of a sign composed of characters or words that are attached directly to a building, an appurtenance to a building, or a masonry wall, the area of the sign will be computed by determining the area of a triangle, rectangle, or circle that completely encloses the whole group of characters or words. C. Measuring Sign Height The maximum height of a sign shall be the measurement from grade to the highest point on the sign. In the case where a minimum height is established, the minimum height shall be measured from grade to the lowest point on the sign. PAGE 56-8 14-SB Sign Regulations i 14-5B-8 Signs Permitted by Zone ~' A. Sign Standards for the ID and OPD Zones 1. Permitted Signs: a. Single Family Uses and Two Family Uses are not allowed to install permanent signs, except for one small identification building sign and one integral sign and public flags, as specified in Table 5B-1, below. b. Signage for non-residential uses in the ID-RS and ID-RM Zones, are permitted one identification sign. The identification sign may be one of the following types: facia, awning or monument sign. For Institutional Uses, the sign may also include copy announcing its services or activities. c. Signage for non-residential uses in the ID-C, ID-I, and ID-RP Zones must comply with the sign regulations contained in Subsection 8C, Sign Standards in the CO-1, CN-1 and MU Zones. d. Residential uses in any OPD zone are permitted signage in accordance with the requirements of the underlying Residential Zone. Non-residential uses approved as part of a planned development are permitted signage in accordance with the sign regulations contained in Subsection 8C, Sign Standards in the CO-1, CN-1 and MU Zones. 2. Sign Specifications and Provisions a. All signs for residential uses in the ID Zones and OPD Zones are subject to the standards specified in Table 5B-1. b. All signs in the ID-RS and ID-RM Zones are subject to the standards specified in Table 5B-1. c. All signs for non-residential uses in the ID-C, ID-I, and ID-RP Zones are subject to the standards specified in Table 5B-2. d. In the OPD Zone, all signs for non-residential uses approved as part of a planned development are subject to the standards specified in Table 5B-2. B. Sign Standards for all Residential Zones 1. Permitted Signs: a. Principal uses, other than Single-Family Uses and Two Family Uses, are permitted one identification sign. The identification sign may be one of the following types: facia, awning, or monument sign. For Institutional Uses, the sign may also include copy announcing its services or activities. b. Parks and Open Space Uses are permitted entranceway signs as specified in Table 5B-1. c. In Multi-Family Zones, multi-family buildings with 8 or more dwelling units are allowed Residential Leasing Company Signs as specified in Table 5B-1, below. d. Single Family Uses and Two Family Uses are not allowed to install permanent signs, except for one small identification building sign and one integral sign and public flags, as specified in Table 5B-1, below. PAGE 56-9 14-SB Sign Regulations 2. Sign Specifications and Provisions All signs in Residential Zones are. subject to the standards specified in Table 5B-1. Table 5B-1 :..Sign Specifications and Provisions in Residential Zones and the ID and OPDZones Permitted Signs Zone Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height 8~ Special Provisions Max. Height: Top of first ID-RS, RR-1, RS-5, RS-8, RS-12, RNS-12 4 sq. ft. story. ti if on ica Limited to ident only, except as allowed for Facia Signs ID-RM, RM-12, RM-20, RNS-20, RM-44, 12 sq. ft. Institutional Uses. PRM Not allowed for Single Family and Two Family Uses. Max. Height: 5 ft Limited to identification 12 sq. ft. per sign face. only, except as allowed for ID-RS, RR-1, RS-5, RS-8, RS-12, RNS-12 May be double-faced fora Institutional Uses. total area of 24 sq.ft. Not allowed for Single Family and Two Family Uses. s Monument Sign Max. Height: 5 ft Limited to identification 24 sq. ft. per sign face. only, except as allowed for ID-RM, RM-12, RM-20, RNS-20, RM-44, -May be double-faced fora Institutional Uses. PRM total area of 48 sq.ft. Not allowed for Single Family and Two Family Uses. Max. Height: Top of first story Limited to identification ID-RS, RR-1, RS-5, RS-8, RS-12, RNS-12, 12 sq. ft. or 25% of awning only, except as'allowed for Awning Signs ID-RM, RM-12, RM-20, RNS-20, RM-44, surface, whichever is less Institutional Uses. PRM Not allowed for Single Family and Two Family Uses. PAGE 56-10 14-SB Sign Regulations :Table 5B-1: Sign Specifications and Provisions in Residential Zones and the ID and OPD Zones Permitted Si ns Zone Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height 8 9 Special Provision .Entranceway Sign Allowed for Parks and Open Space Uses in any Residential Zone, ID Zone, or OPD Zone For signs located above or across the top of the subject archway, the area of the sign may not exceed 25% of the area delineated by the subject archway. For a sign located on the side of the archway, the area of the sign may not exceed 33% of the surface area of the side of the archway support on which the sign is located. (See 14-56-7 Measurement Standards) s Maximum Height: 20 ft. Up to one sign per facade of the subject archway. The sign may not contain changeable copy. Sign copy may not extend beyond the edges of the entranceway structure. If an applicant finds that this standard is too restrictive, they may request a Level I review from the Design Review Committee for an altemative design. The Design Review Committee will approve, approve with conditions, or deny an application based on whether the proposed altemative design is appropriate to and integrated into the overall design of the entranceway. The Committee will consider such factors as color, materials, size, and proportionality. Minimum clearance height is 10 feet for entranceway signs across driveways and 8 feet for entranceway signs across walkways. Entranceway signs are not allowed if the subject lot or tract already has a monument sign located at the subject entrance. Residential Leasing Company Sign RM-12, RM-20, RNS-20, RM-44, PRM 3 sq. ft. The sign must be a building sign. Only allowed on multi-family buildings that contain 8 or more dwelling units. Up to one of these signs is allowed per building. Must be located no more than 10 feet above grade. PAGE 56-11 14-SB Sign Regulations Table 56-1 :':Sign Specifications and Provisions in Residential Zones and the ID and OPD Zones Maximum Height 8~ Permitted Signs Zone Maximum Sign Area Special Provisions The sign must be a building sign. Up to one of these signs is Small ID-RS, RR-1, RS-5, RS-8, RS-12, RNS-12, allowed per building. identification sign M ~ RM-12, RM-20, RNS-20, RM-44, P 2 sq. ft. No permit is required. i2 Not allowed if the building has a residential leasing company sign. ID-RS, RR-1, RS-5, RS-8, RS-12, RNS-12, 2 sq. ft. per face Directional signs ID-RM, RM-12, RM-20, RNS-20, RM-44, May be double-faced for PRM total area of 4 sq. ft. ID-RS, RR-1, RS-5, RS-8, RS-12, RNS-12, Up to one of these signs is Integral sign ID-RM, RM-12, RM-20, RNS-20, RM-44, 2 sq. ft. allowed per building. PRM No permit is required. ID-RS, RR-1, RS-5, RS-8, RS-12, RNS-12, Public Flags ID-RM, RM-12, RM-20, RNS-20, RM-44, - No permit is required. PRM ~ Only one sign is permitted; one facia sign, one awning sign, or one monument sign (See 14-5B-SA-1.b.,above) C. Sign Standards in the CO-1, CN-1 and MU Zones 1. All signs in the CO-1, CN-1, and MU Zones are subject to the standards specified in Table 5B-2. 2. Except for identification banners, monument signs, and entranceway signs, any number of signs may be installed, provided the maximum sign area for each type of sign is not exceeded. The number of identification banners, monument signs, and entranceway signs is limited according to the provisions specified in Table 5B-2. 3. Signage for residential uses must comply with the requirements for residential uses in the RM zones as stated in Table 5B-1. Table 56-2: Sign Specifications and Provisions in the CO-1, CN-1, and MU Zones permitted signs Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height Provisions Top of first Facia Signs 15% allowance per story, except as allowed Parapet signs are allowed, but only on one-story buildings. sign wall for parapet signs Canopy Signs 8 sq. ft. per sign Top of first story _ PAGE 5B-12 14-SB Sign Regulations Table 5B-2: Sign Specifications and Provisions in the CO-1, CN-1, and MU Zones Permitted signs Maximum Sign .Area Maximum Height Provisions Up to two identification banner signs may be affixed to each parking area light pole, provided that the following conditions are met: • The parking area must contain at least 200 parking spaces and be shared by multiple commercial uses. The light poles on which banners are affixed must be spaced at least 80 feet apart. .Identification 18 sq. ft. per 20 ft Each banner can be no more than 3 ft wide and 6 ft in height. Banners banner . The banner must be mounted or affixed so that the bottom edge of the sign is at least 10 feet above grade and the top edge of the sign is nb higher than 20 feet above grade. • The banner signs must be consistent in appearance and size. The permit for the banner sign shall be valid for no more than one (1) year. However, the permit will be renewable if the banner signs are in good condition or are replaced with new banner signs. Two or more uses on a single lot may share a common monument sign. The number of monument signs on a lot or tract is limited as follows: For lots or tracts with less than 160 feet of frontage on a single street, Up to 2 sq. ft of only one monument sign is permitted along that frontage. sign area per lineal • For lots or tracts with 160 to 300 feet of frontage along a single street, foot of lot frontage, up to 2 monument signs are permitted. The monument signs must be not to exceed 50 at least 150 feet apart as measured along the frontage. Monument signs sq. ft. per sign face. 5 ft. For lots or tracts with frontage in excess of 300 ft along a single street, May be double- up to 3 monuments signs are permitted, provided the signs are at least faced for a total 150 ft apart as measured along the frontage. area of 100 sq. ft. For lots or tracts with frontage along more than one street, each per sign. frontage is allowed signs based on the formulas stated above up to a maximum of 5 signs. Any sign that is located within 25 feet of a corner (at the point where property lines intersect) will count as two signs; one toward the sign allowance for each frontage. For signs located above or across the Up to one sign per facade of the subject archway. top of the subject The sign may not contain changeable copy. archway, the area Sign copy may not extend beyond the edges of the entranceway structure. If of the sign may not an applicant finds that this standard is too restrictive, they may request a exceed 25% of the Level I review from the Design Review Committee for an alternative design. area delineated by The Design Review Committee will approve, approve with conditions, or the subject deny an application based on whether the proposed alternative design is archway. appropriate to and integrated into the overall design of the entranceway. Entranceway For a sign located The Committee will consider such factors as color, materials, size, and Sign on the side of the 20 ft. proportionality. archway, the area of the sign may not Minimum clearance height is 10 feet for entranceway signs across exceed 33% of the driveways and 8 feet for entranceway signs across walkways. surface area of the side of the archway Entranceway signage as specified herein will count as one sign toward the support on which total limit for monument signs on a lot or tract. Entranceway signs are not the sign is located. allowed if the subject lot or tract already has a monument sign located at the (See 14-5B-7 subject entrance. Measurement Standards) Awning signs 25% of awning Top of first _ surface story Window signs I 25% of window I .. I _ area PACE 56-13 14-SB Sign Regulations Table 56-2: Sign Specifications and Provisions in the C0-1, CN-1, and MU Zones Permitted signs Maximum Sign Area' Maximum Height Provisions 25 sq. ft. per sign Time & face Temperature May be double- - Shall not project more than 6 ft. into public right of way. Signs faced for a total of 50 sq. ft. Maximum diameter: 9 inches Barber Poles - - Maximum length: 3 ft 3 sq. ft, per sign Directional signs face _ _ May be double- faced for total area of 6 sq. ft. Identification & Up to one of these signs is allowed per building. Integral signs 2 sq. ft. No permit is required. One private flag may be displayed in conjunction with public flags. Flags - No permit is required. Quick Vehicle _ Allowed for Quick Vehicle Servicing Uses. Servicing Signs No permit is required. D. Sign Standards in the CH-1, CC-2 and CI-1 Zones 1. All signs in the CH-1, CC-2, and CI-1 Zones are subject to the standards specified in Table 5B-3. 2. The total number of freestanding signs, freestanding wide-base signs and monument signs on a lot or tract is limited as follows. Any combination of these three types of signs is allowed within the stated limits. a. For lots or tracts with less than 160 feet of frontage on a single street, only one such sign is permitted along that frontage. Freestanding wide-based signs are not permitted on lots or tracts with less than 160 feet of frontage. b. For lots or tracts with 160 to 300 feet of frontage along a single street, up to 2 such signs are permitted, provided the signs are at least 150 feet apart as measured along the frontage. c. For lots or tracts with 301 to 600 feet of frontage along a single street, up to 3 such signs are permitted, provided the signs are at least 150 feet apart as measured along the frontage. d. For lots or tracts with frontage in excess of 600 feet along a single street, up to 3 such signs are permitted, provided the signs are at least 150 feet apart as measured along the frontage. One additional monument sign is allowed, provided the sign is at least 150 feet from any other monument, freestanding, or freestanding wide-base sign. e. For lots or tracts with frontage along more than one street, each frontage is allowed signs based on the formulas stated in subparagraphs a. through d., above. However, a maximum of 5 such signs are allowed on any one lot or PAGE 56-14 14-SB Sign Regulations tract. Any sign that is located within 25 feet of a corner (the point where property lines intersect) will count as two signs; one toward the sign allowance for each frontage. 3. Other than for entranceway signs and the types of signs listed in paragraph 2, above, any number of signs may be installed, provided the maximum sign area for each type of sign is not exceeded and the provisions specified in Table 5B-3 are met. 4. Signage for residential uses must comply with the requirements for residential uses in the RM zones as stated in Table 5B-1. Table 5B-3: Sign`Specifications and Provisions in the CH-1, CG2, and CI-1 Zones Permitted, Signs Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height `Provisions Facia signs 15% allowance per sign wall - - Canopysigns 12 sq. ft. per sign Top of first story - Up to 2 sq. ft. per lineal foot of lot frontage, not to exceed 25 feet, 125 sq. ft. per sign face. May however, in the be double-faced for a total CH-1 District, area of 250 square feet. property within When 2 or more uses are located on a lot, a common Additional sign area is 1,000 feet of an freestanding or monument sign may be installed. The maximum allowed in the CH-1 Zone as interstate area of the common sign may be 50 /o larger than the area of Freestanding follows. For property within highway right of the maximum individual sign allowed. signs 1,000 feet of an interstate way may have 1 The number of signs is limited according to paragraph D.2., highway right-of-way, one of freestanding above. the property's allotted sign with a freestanding signs is allowed maximum height up to 250 sq. ft per sign face, not to exceed 65 which may be double-faced feet. for a total area of 500 sq. ft. Maximum width: 10 ft. When 2 or more uses are located on a lot, a common sign may nstalled. The maximum area of the common sign may be be Up to 2 sq. ft. per lineal foot o 50 /° larger than the area of the maximum individual sign Freestanding, of lot frontage, not to exceed 125 sq. ft. per sign face. 26 ft. allowed. Wide Base signs May be double-faced fora The number of signs is limited according to paragraph D.2., above. However, a freestanding, wide-based sign is only total of 250 sq. ft. allowed if the lot frontage is at least 160 feet, and the City Engineer determines that the location of the sign will not obstruct the visibility of vehicles entering or exiting the property. When 2 or more uses are located on a lot, a common Up to 2 sq. ft. per lineal foot monument or freestanding sign may be installed. The maximum of lot frontage, not to exceed area of the common sign may be 50% larger than the area of Monument signs 50 sq. ft. per sign face. May 5 ft the maximum individual sign allowed. be double-faced for a total The number of signs is limited according to paragraph D.2., area of 100 sq. ft. above. Up to 1 sq. ft. per lineal foot of lot frontage, not to exceed 1 ft. less than Masonry Wall 50 sq. ft. per sign. the height of the One masonry wall sign is allowed, in lieu of a monument, Sin g In addition, the sign may not masonry wall, freestanding, or freestanding wide-base sign. exceed 15% of the total area not to exceed 12 of the face of the masonry feet wall. PAGE 5B-15 14-SB Sign Regulations Table 5B-3: Sign Specifications and Provisions in the CH-1, CC-2, and Cl-1 Zones Permitted Signs Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height Provisions Up to one sign per facade of the entranceway arch. The sign may not contain changeable copy. Sign copy may not extend beyond the edges of the entranceway structure. If an applicant finds that this standard is For signs located above or too restrictive, they may request a Level I review from the across the top of the subject Design Review Committee for an alternative design. The archway, the area of the sign Design Review Committee will approve, approve with may not exceed 25% of the conditions, or deny an application based on whether the area delineated by the proposed altemative design is appropriate to and integrated into subject archway. the overall design of the entranceway. The Committee will For a sign located on the consider such factors as color, materials, size, and Entranceway side of the archway, the area 20 ft. proportionality. Sign of the sign may not exceed 33% of the surface area of Minimum clearance height is 10 feet for entranceway signs the side of the archway across driveways and 8 feet for entranceway signs across support on which the sign is walkways. located. Entranceway signage as specified herein will count as one sign (See 14-5B-7 Measurement toward the total limit for freestanding, freestanding wide-base Standards) signs and monument signs on a lot or tract. Entranceway signs are not allowed if the subject lot or tract already has a • monument sign, freestanding sign, freestanding wide-based sign, or masonry wall sign located at the subject entrance, For shopping centers, up to two identification banner signs may be affixed to each parking area light pole, provided that the following conditions are met: The parking area must contain at least 200 parking spaces and be shared by multiple commercial uses. The light poles on which banners are affixed must be spaced at least 80 feet apart. Each banner can be no more than 3 ft wide and 6 ft in height. Identification 18 sq. ft. per banner 20 ft . The banner must be mounted or affixed so that the bottom Banners edge of the sign is at least 10 feet above grade and the top edge of the sign is no higher than 20 feet above grade. The banner signs must be consistent in appearance and size. The permit for the banner sign shall be valid for no more than one (1) year. However, the permit will be renewable if the banner signs are in good condition or are replaced with new banner signs. Awning signs 25% of awning surface Top of first story - Windowsigns 25% of window area -- - 3 sq. ft. per sign face Directional signs May be double-faced for total -- - area of 6 sq. ft. Drive-Through Only allowed in Zones where drive-through facilities are allowed Restaurant Menu Area: 10 sq. ft. -- for restaurants. Signs Time & 25 sq. ft per sign face. Permitted only in the CC-2 zone. Temperature May be double-faced for a - Signs must not project more than 6 ft. into the public right-of- Signs total area of 50 sq. ft. waY• PAGE 56-16 14-SB Sign Regulations Table 56-3: Sign Specifications and Provisions in the CH-1, CC-2, and Cl-1 Zones Permitted Signs 'Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height Provisions Maximum diameter: 9 inches Barber Poles - ~ Maximum length: 3 ft Identification & Up to one of these signs is allowed per building. Integral signs 2 sq ft - No permit is required. One private flag may be displayed in conjunction with public Flags - -- flags. No permit is required. Quick Vehicle _ _ Allowed for Quick Vehicle Servicing Uses. Servicing Signs No permit is required. E. Sign Standards in the CB-2, CB-5 and CB-10 Zones 1. All signs in the CB-2, CB-5 and CB-10 Zones are subject to the standards specified in Table 5B-4. 2. The maximum sign area for each type of sign, special provisions, and any restrictions on the number of signs allowed are specified in Table 5B-4. Unless specifically limited in Table 5B-4, any number of signs may be installed. 3. Signage for residential uses must comply with the requirements for residential uses in the RM zones as stated in Table 5B-1. Table 56-4: Sign Specifications and Provisions in the CB-2, CB-5 and CB-10 Zones Permitted Signs Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height Provisions Facia signs 15% of sign wall area - - Canopy signs 12 sq. ft per sign Top of first story - Up tonne canopy roof sign is allowed per storefront. The bottom edge of the sign must be located no more than 4 inches above the canopy. Storefronts up to 39 ft. in For storefronts up to 39 ft. in length: length: l5 sq. ft. • Maximum height of copy: 13" Storefronts between 40 . Maximum thickness: 6" Canopy roof signs and 59 ft in length: 25 Top of first story For storefronts between 40 and 59 ft in length: sq. ft. • Maximum height of copy: 20" Storefronts >60 ft in Maximum thickness: 8" length: 35 sq. ft. For storefronts >60 ft in length: • Maximum height of copy: 30" • Maximum thickness:10" Only one monument sign is allowed per lot or tract. When 2 or more uses are located on a lot, a common 24 sq.ft. per sign face. monument sign may be installed. A common monument Monument sign May be double-faced fora 5 ft. sign may identify up to 4 uses per sign face. total area of 48 sq. ft. A monument sign is not allowed if the property has a freestanding sign, an entranceway sign, or a masonry wall sign. PAGE 56-17 14-SB Sign Regulations Table 5B-4: Sign Specifications and Provisions'in the C6-2, C6-5 and CB-10 Zones` Permitted Signs Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height ' Provisions Awning signs are only allowed if the business does not Awning signs 25% of awning surface Top of first story have a projecting sign. Up to one sign per facade of the entranceway arch. The sign may not contain changeable copy. For signs located above or Sign copy may not extend beyond the edges of the across the top of the entranceway structure. If an applicant finds that this subject archway, the area standard is too restrictive, they may request a Level I of the sign may not review from the Design Review Committee for an exceed 25% of the area alternative design. The Design Review Committee will delineated by the subject approve, approve with conditions, or deny an application archway. based on whether the proposed alternative design is Entranceway Sign For a sign located on the 20 ft appropriate to and integrated into the overall design of side of the archway, the the entranceway. The Committee will consider such area of the sign may not factors as color, materials, size, and proportionality. exceed 33% of the surface area of the side of the Minimum clearance height is 10 feet for entranceway archway support on which signs across driveways and 8 feet for entranceway signs the sign is located. across walkways. (See 14-58-7 Measurement Standards) An entranceway sign is not allowed if the property has a masonry wall sigp, monument sign, or freestanding sign. Allowed only in the CB-2 Zone. Only one freestanding sign is allowed per lot. Allowed only through approval of a minor modification. Applicant must provide convincing evidence that the Two (2) square feet per existing configuration of the site and location of the Freestanding Sign lineal foot of lot frontage, not to exceed 40 square 20 ft building or buildings on the site make it practically difficult to install a monument sign and that other types of feet per sign face allowed signage would not be readily visible from the street due to the location of building(s) or other unique site characteristics. A freestanding sign is not allowed if the property has a monument sign, entranceway sign, or masonry wall sign. 1 sq. ft. per lineal foot of lot frontage, not to exceed 50 sq. ft. 1 ft. less than the Only one masonry wall sign is allowed per lot. Masonry Wall Sign height of the masonry not to exceed 12 wall A masonry wall sign is not allowed if the property has a In addition, the sign may , feet monument sign, entranceway sign or freestanding sign. not exceed 15% of the total area of the face of the masonry wall. Window signs 25% of window area - - PAGE 56-18 14-SB Sign Regulations Table'56-4: Sign Specifications and Provisions in the CB-2, CB-5 and CB-10'Zones Permitted Signs Maximum Sign Area 'Maximum Height Provisions Up to one projecting sign is allowed per storefront. Projecting signs are not permitted if the business has an awning sign, canopy sign or canopy roof sign. The sign may not project more than 5 ft. from the building wall. The sign may not be illuminated. Storefront projecting 6 sq. ft. May be double-faced fora 12 ft. The sign must be affixed to the building wall or to a pole i sign total area of 12 sq ft. s that is mounted on the building, so that the sign . perpendicular to the building wall. The sign may not swing or be easily moved by wind. A business wishing to install a projecting sign must show proof of liability insurance. Sign permits are be subject to Design Review according to the procedures specified in Chapter 8 of this Title. Up to one non-illuminated portable sign is allowed per storefront. The sign must be placed on private property or within a designated sidewalk cafe area. 6 sq. ft. per sign face. The sign may not block access to any doorway, Portable sign May be double-faced fora 6 ft The sign must be moved inside the business when the total area of 12 sq ft. business is closed. The sign must be weighted at the base to provide stability as approved by the Building Official or designee. A maximum of 2 sign faces are allowed per sign. Time & 25 sq. ft. per sign face. Signs must not project more than 6 ft. into the public Temperature signs May be double-faced for a - right-of-way total area of 50 sq. ft. Maximum diameter: 9 inches Barber Poles - - Maximum length: 3 ft 3 sq. ft. per sign face Directional signs May be double-faced for - -- total area of 6 sq. ft. Identification & 2 sq. ft. Up to one of these signs is allowed per building. Integral signs No permit is required. One private flag may be displayed in conjunction with Flags - - public flags. No permit is required. Quick Vehicle Allowed for Quick Vehicle Servicing Uses. Servicing Signs _ No permit is required. F. Sign Standards in the Industrial and Research Park Zones 1. All signs in the I-1, I-2, RDP, and ORP Zones are subject to the standards specified in Table 5B-5. 2. The total number of freestanding signs and monument signs on a lot or tract is limited as follows. Any combination of these types of signs is allowed within the stated limits. a. For lots or tracts with less than 160 feet of frontage on a single street, only one such sign is permitted along that frontage. PAGE 5B-19 14-SB Sign Regulations b. For lots or tracts with frontage in excess of 160 feet of frontage along a single street, up to 2 such signs are permitted, provided the signs are located at least 150 feet apart as measured along the frontage. c. For lots or tracts with frontage along more than one street, each frontage is allowed signs based on the formulas stated in subparagraphs a. and b., above. 3. Masonry wall signs and entranceway signs are limited according to the provisions specified in Table 5B-5. 4. Other than for the types of signs listed in paragraphs 2 and 3, above, any number of signs may be installed, provided the maximum sign area for each type of sign is not exceeded and the provisions specified in Table 56-5 are met. Table'5B-5: Sign S pecifications and Provisions'n the;lndustrial and Research Park Zones' Permitted Signs Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height. Provisions Must not exceed 25% of awning Height: Top of Awning signs surface or 12 sq. ft. per sign, first story _ whichever is less. Canopy Signs 12 sq. ft. per sign Height: Top of first story _ Facia signs 15% of sign wall area - - When 2 or more uses are located on a lot, a common sign may be installed. The maximum area of the 1 sq. ft. per lineal foot of lot frontage, common sign may be 50% larger than the area of the Freestanding signs not to exceed 50 sq. ft. Height: 25 ft. maximum individual sign allowed. May be double-faced for a total of 100 The number of signs is limited according to paragraph sq. ft. G.2., above. Freestanding signs are limited to identification only. Up to 2 sq. ft. per lineal foot of lot When 2 or more uses are located on a lot, a common frontage, not to exceed-~9 75 sq. ft. 5 ft• sign may be installed. The maximum area of the Monument signs per sign face. common sign may be 50% larger than the area of the May be double-faced for a total area of maximum individual sign allowed. 150 sq. ft. Monument signs are limited to identification only. Up to 2 sq. ft. per lineal foot of lot At each entranceway, up to 2 masonry wall signs may be frontage, not to exceed 75 sq. ft. per established, if no freestanding, entranceway, monument sign face. 1 ft. less than or other non-building signs are located at that May be double-faced for a total area of the height of entranceway. Masonry Wall Signs 150 sq. ft. the masonry In the ORP zone, masonry wall signs up to twelve (12) In addition, the sign may not exceed wall feet in height may be established in the required front 15% of the total area of the face of the setback provided the signs are located a minimum of masonry wall. twenty (20) feet back from street right-of-way lines. PAGE 56-20 14-SB Sign Regulations Table 56-5: Sign S pecifications and Provisions in the Industrial and-Research Park Zones Permitted. Signs `Maximum Sign Area Maximum ..:Height Provisions Up to one sign per fapade of the entranceway arch. The sign may not contain changeable copy. Sign copy may not extend beyond the edges of the entranceway structure. If an applicant finds that this For signs located above or across the standard is too restrictive, they may request a Level I top of the subject archway, the area of review from the Design Review Committee for an the sign may not exceed 25% of the alternative design. The Design Review Committee will area delineated by the subject approve, approve with conditions, or deny an application archway. based on whether the proposed alternative design is Entranceway Sign For a sign located on the side of the 20 ft appropriate to and integrated into the overall design of archway, the area of the sign may not the entranceway. The Committee will consider such exceed 33% of the surface area of the factors as color, materials, size, and proportionality. side of the archway support on which the sign is located. Minimum clearance height is 10 feet for entranceway (See 14-56-7 Measurement signs across driveways and 8 feet for entranceway signs Standards) across walkways. An entranceway sign is not allowed if the property has a masonry wall sign. Window signs 25% of window area - - 3 sq. ft. per sign face Directional signs May be double-faced for total area of 6 - - sq.ft. Identification & 2 sq. ft. Up to one of these signs is allowed per building. Integral signs No permit is required. One private flag may be displayed in conjunction. with Flags - - public flags. No permit is required. 14-5B-9 Non-Permanent, Off-Premise, and Other Special Signs A. In addition to the signage permitted in each zone, as described in Section 8, above, the following signs may be installed in any zone according to the specifications and provisions contained in Table 5B-6. These signs shall not be applied toward the maximum sign area specified in Section 8, except as otherwise indicated in the Table 56-6. B. Banners are not permitted, except as allowed for Special Event Signs and Going Out of Business Signs, as specified in Table 5B-6. Table 56-6: Sign Specifications and Provisions for Non-Permanent, Off-Premise, and Other'Special Signs Permitted Signs Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height Provisions. No permit required. In Residential Zones: Must not be illuminated. Area: 32 sq. ft. per face 5 ft Must be removed prior to issuance of the certificate of Construction signs May be double faced fora In Non-Residential occupancy. total of 64 sq. ft. Zones: 10 ft. Can be located closer than 5 ft to a property line if located on the wall of a building, fence or protective barricade surrounding the construction. PAGE 56-21 14-SB Sign Regulations Table 56-6: Sign Specifications and Provisions for Non-Permanent, vtt-premise, ana vtner apeciai signs Permitted Signs Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height Provisions. No permit is required. One non-illuminated monument sign per development of 2 Real Estate 32 sq. ft. per face 10 ft acres or more Shall be removed upon sale or lease of 50% of lots or units Development May be double faced fora in the development. signs total of 64 sq. ft. These signs shall not be considered off-premises signs, provided they are located on land that is part of the subject subdivision or development. No permit is required. One non-illuminated sign is permitted per principal building that is for sale, rent, or lease. In Residential Zones: 4 sq. ft.; Only allowed as a temporary sign located in the yard or in May be double-faced fora In Residential Zones: the window. Sign cannot be affixed to buildings, fences, flag Real Estate signs total area of 8 sq. ft. 5 ft poles or other permanent structures. In Non-residential Zones: 32 In Non-Residential Must be removed within 48 hours after the propertyl sq. ft.; May be double-faced Zones:10 ft. building, or unit within a building for which the sign is for a total area of 64 sq. ft. intended is sold, rented, leased or withdrawn from the market. For residential rental properties, real estate signs may be displayed no more than 4 months prior to the commencement of the leasing period. No permit is required. Signs in windows - - Posters and other non-permanent signs in windows are allowed. One non-illuminated sign per lot is allowed. Special events sign restricted to 4 times in 12 month period Special Events 100 sq. ft. - and single duration of 30 days May include banners, but not any sign prohibited by Section 6 of this Article, Prohibited Signs. Must not be illuminated. May be displayed for up to 60 days;. Going-Out-of- 100 sq. ft. - Restricted to once in a 12-month period for single business. Business signs May include banners, but not any sign prohibited by Section 6 of this Article, Prohibited Signs. Temporary signs 12 sq. ft. per face. No permit is required. (other than real May be double-faced for total Height: l0 ft One non-illuminated sign per lot is allowed. estate signs) of 24 sq. ft. Signs shall not be displayed for more than 60 days. In ID and Residential Zones: In ID and Residential 32 sq. ft. per sign face; May be Zones: 5 ft In ID and in Residential Zones, one monument sign is double-faced for a total of 64 In all other Zones: allowed at each street entrance to a subdivision or housing Development sq. ft. Not to exceed the development. signs In all other Zones: Not to maximum height for In all other Zones, one freestanding or monument sign is exceed the maximum sign the subject sign type allowed at each street entrance to a subdivision or housing area for the subject sign type as specified in the development. as specified in the applicable applicable zone. zone. PAGE 56-22 14-SB Sign Regulations Table 5B-6: Sign Specifications and'Provisions for Non-Permanent, Off-Premise,'and Other Special Signs .Permitted Signs Maximum Sign Area Maximum Height Provisions Off-Premises signs are not permitted in Residential, CO-1, CN-1, CB-5, CB-10, ORP and RDP Zones. May take the form of any type of sign allowed in the zone in Not to exceed the maximum which the sign is located and must comply with all other sign area for the subject sign provisions specified for the subject zone. type as specified in the Not to exceed the Only one off-premises sign is allowed per lot or tract. applicable zone and will be maximum sign height Two or more uses may install a common off-premises Billboards and deducted from the maximum for the subject sign directional sign. Other Off- sign allowance for the subject type as specified in Nooff-premises sign shall be located within 300 ft. of Premises Signs property. the applicable zone. another off-premises sign. Nooff-premises sign shall be located within 120 ft. of a Billboards: 72 sq. ft. May be Billboards: 25 ft Residential Zone, Parks and Open Space Use, Educational double-faced for a total area of Facility, ReligiouslPrivate Group Assembly Use, public 144 sq. ft. museum or government administrative or judicial office. Billboard signs shall not apply toward maximum sign allowance for the lot or tract. 14-5B-10 Privately-Owned Signs in Public Places A. Purpose In order to promote the health, safety and general welfare of the population, no privately- owned signs shall be placed on or over a public place, as defined in Article 14-9C, except as permitted by the City Code. B. Removal Existing privately-owned signs currently located on or over a public place that are not in compliance with the City Code shall be eliminated and removed. If the sign owner fails to remove the sign after so ordered by the City, the City may remove the sign and assess the costs against the sign owner. C. Special Provisions 1. Signs associated with parades, marches, public entertainment, public demonstrations, or the commercial use of sidewalks that are located on or over a public place are subject to the provisions of Title 10, Chapters 1, 2, and 3 of the City Code. Any signs located on or over the City Plaza are subject to the provisions of Title 10, Chapter 5 of the City Code. 2. The City Manager or designee may approve and execute applications on the City's behalf for the placement of privately-owned signs on or over a public place upon finding that the signs: a. Provide information and guidance to locations of general public interest; and b. Will not create a hazard to movement along or within a public place, restrict access to a public place, or interfere with the convenience and tranquility of the area adjacent to a public place. HOLLAND & ANDERSON LLP 123 N. Linn St., Suite 300 P.O. Box 2820 Iowa City, IA 52244-2820 Phone: (319) 354-0331 Fax: (319) 354-0559 October 17, 2008 City Council, Iowa City Dear Council Members: C. Joseph Holland jholland@icialaw.com Lars G. Anderson lnderson@ic ialaw.com Tarek A. Khowassah tkhowassah@ic ialaw. com I am writing regarding the proposed Amendment to the City's Sign Regulations. I was not aware of all of the provisions of this proposed Amendment until after the Council vote on October 6r''. I apologize for not addressing the issue sooner with both the Planning and Zoning Commission and the Council. However, I think there are some concerns which should be better addressed before these changes are adopted. The impetus for this proposed Amendment appears to be complaints from the Northside Neighborhood Association and residents in that area. Their concerns appear to be both the proliferation of signs advertising properties for rent and the length of time which signs remain on the property. Both of those are legitimate concerns, however, the proposed amendments to the Sign Regulations cast too wide a net to address the issues. The proposed amendments fail to make any distinction between the various residential zones, which range from RS- 5, which is the lowest density of residential, all the way to PRM which is the highest density multi-family residential zone in the City. The proposed Amendments also do not mesh with the rental cycle in much of the core of Iowa City. I represent a number of landlords who own properties in that area and have some understanding of that rental cycle. Most apartment rents in Iowa City commence August 1St. The ordinance proposes a four month window for signs to be 'on the properties in advance of the availability of units for rent. This effectively means that signs could not be erected until Apri11. It is well known that many rental units in the City core are occupied by undergraduate students who typically leave town in early May, following final examinations at the University. If signs cannot be placed on the property until April 1, this effectively limits that rental period to a matter of few weeks in April and the earliest part of May. During that period students are often focused upon completing their semester's work and final examinations. -~ ~6 For that reason many properties throughout the Iowa City and Coralville area are put on the market for August rental in January of the year. Students want to make their plans and have their living arrangements for the next academic year locked in early in the year. As a practical matter most of those students have made their fall living arrangements by May 1St One aspect of the signage issues which has received little attention is the value to consumers of the signs. They may suggest to a consumer that a property they hadn't considered is available, and provide contact information. This needs to be that window when students are actively considering their housing choices to be of value to them. Building signs may be preferable to yard signs. They are far less subject to vandalism. They are also less visually intrusive than a proliferation of yard signs. That is the reason many owners affix the signs to their building rather than regularly replacing damaged or missing yard signs. A major issue is the zones in which the amended Regulations apply. As I said, my understanding is they apply to all residential zones, including the high density multi-family zones. That includes a number of areas which are clustered around the downtown area, but do not intrude into the neighborhoods from which complaints have come which the amendments are designed to address. I would suggest as a compromise that these sign regulations not apply to properties in the more high density multi-residential zones PRMand RM-44. This would allow reasonable advertising of apartments available, while addressing the concerns raised by the Northside Neighborhood Association. . If you look at the Iowa City zoning map, it is easy to see that there is virtually no high density multi-family in the Northside Neighborhood, nor for that matter east of the downtown core. Excepting out the higher density multi-family zone is a reasonable compromise. Laws and rules and regulations should be narrowly tailored to accomplish their purpose, and revising the proposed Amendment in this fashion would achieve that goal. I recognize that the proposed Amendment has already had a public hearing, its first reading, and first vote. However, it is not too late to suggest amendments which best accommodate the interests of all of Iowa City's citizens. Very truly yours, i C. Jose h Holland CJHaes ~ L Prepared by: Christina Kuecker, Associate Planner, 410 E. Washington Street, Iowa City, IA 52240; 319-356-5230 ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE CONDITIONALLY REZONING APPROXIMATLEY 3.87 ACRES OF PROPERTY LOCATED SOUTH OF DODGE STREET AND WEST OF SCOTT BOULEVARD, FROM RESEARCH DEVELOPMENT PARK (RDP) TO COMMERCIAL OFFICE (CO-1 ). (REZ08-00008) WHEREAS, the applicant, the University of Iowa Community Credit Union, has requested a rezoning of property located south of Dodge Street and west of Scott Boulevard from Research Development Park (RDP) to Commercial Office (CO-1); and WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission has reviewed the proposed rezoning and determined that it complies with the Comprehensive Plan; and WHEREAS, the Comprehensive Plan indicates that this parcel is appropriate for uses consistent with the CO-1 zone; and WHEREAS, Iowa Code §414.5 (2007) provides that the City of Iowa City may impose reasonable conditions on granting an applicant's rezoning request, over and above existing regulations, in order to satisfy public needs caused by the requested change; and WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission has reviewed the proposed rezoning and determined that it complies with the Comprehensive Plan provided that it meets conditions. -- __ -- addressing the need for an attractive Dodge Street entranceway, neighborhood compatibility, and traffic safety; and WHEREAS, the applicant has agreed that the property shall be developed in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Conditional Zoning Agreement attached hereto to ensure appropriate development in this area of the city. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, IOWA: SECTION I APPROVAL. Subject to the Conditional Zoning Agreement attached hereto and incorporated herein, property described below is hereby reclassified from its current zoning designation of Research Development Park (RDP) to Commercial Office (CO-1): Lot 2, Press Citizen Addition, Iowa City, Iowa, according to the plat thereof recorded in Book 43, Page 311, Plat Records of Johnson County, Iowa, subject to easements, covenants and restrictions of record. SECTION II. ZONING MAP. The building official is hereby authorized and directed to change the zoning map of the City of Iowa City, Iowa, to conform to this amendment upon the final passage, approval and publication of the ordinance as approved by law. SECTION III. CONDITIONAL ZONING AGREEMENT. The Mayor is hereby authorized and directed to sign, and the City Clerk attest, the Conditional Zoning Agreement between the property owner and the City, following passage and approval of this Ordinance. Ordinance No. Page 2 SECTION IV. CERTIFICATION AND RECORDING. Upon passage and approval of the Ordinance, the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to certify a copy of this ordinance, and record the same in the Office of the County Recorder, Johnson County, Iowa, at the Owner's expense, upon the final passage, approval and publication of this ordinance, as provided by law. SECTION V. REPEALER. All ordinances and parts of ordinances in conflict with the provisions of this Ordinance are hereby repealed. SECTION VI. SEVERABILITY. If any section, provision or part of the Ordinance shall be adjudged to be invalid or unconstitutional, such adjudication shall not affect the validity of the Ordinance as a whole or any section, provision or part thereof not adjudged invalid or unconstitutional. SECTION VII. EFFECTIVE DATE. This Ordinance shall be in effect after its final passage, approval and publication, as provided by law. Passed and approved this day of , 20 MAYOR ATTEST: CITY CLERK Ap oved by GG .~'I~~~7~T~ ~~~~ City Attorney's Office q~y~v ~ Ordinance No. Page It was moved by and seconded by as read be adopted, and upon roll call there were: AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: that the Ordinance Bailey Champion Correia Hayek O'Donnell Wilburn Wright First Consideration 10/6/2008 Vote for passage: Ayes; Hayek, O'Donnell, Nays: None. Absent: None. Second Consideration 10 / 21 / 2008 Vote for passage: AYES: Hayek, O'Donnell, NAYS: None. ABSENT: None. Wilburn, Wright, Bailey, Champion, Correia. Wilburn, Wright, Bailey, Champion,Correia. Date published Prepared by: Christina Kuecker, PCD, 410 E. Washington, Iowa City, IA 52240 (319) 356-5243 (REZ08-00008) CONDITIONAL ZONING AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT is made between the City of Iowa City, Iowa, a municipal corporation (hereinafter "City"), and The University of Iowa Community Credit Union (hereinafter "Owner"); WHEREAS, Owner is the legal title holder of approximately 3.87 acres of property located south of Dodge Street and west of Scott Boulevard; and WHEREAS, the Owner has requested the rezoning of said property from Research Development Park (RDP) to Commercial Office (CO-1); and WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission has recommended approval of said rezoning subject to conditions related to ensuring that the property develops in a manner that enhances the aesthetics of the Dodge Street entranceway into Iowa City, is compatible with the nearby residential neighborhoods, and addresses traffic circulation issues; and WHEREAS, Iowa Code §414.5 (2007) provides that the City of Iowa City may impose reasonable conditions on granting an applicant's rezoning request, over and above existing regulations, in order to satisfy public needs caused by the requested change; and WHEREAS, the Owner acknowledge that certain conditions and restrictions are reasonable to ensure the development of the property is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and the need for an attractive Dodge Street entranceway, neighborhood compatibility, and traffic safety; and WHEREAS, the Owner agrees to develop this property in accordance with the terms and conditions of this Conditional Zoning Agreement. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual promises contained herein, the parties agree as follows: 1. Owner is the legal title holder of the property legally described as follows: Lot 2, Press Citizen Addition, Iowa City, Iowa, according to the plat thereof recorded in Book 43, Page 311, Plat Records of Johnson County, Iowa, subject to easements, covenants and restrictions of record. 2. The parties acknowledge that Iowa Code §414.5 (2007) provides that the City of Iowa City may impose reasonable conditions on granting an applicant's rezoning request, over and above the existing regulations, in order to satisfy public needs caused by the requested rezoning. 3. In consideration of the City's rezoning the subject property, the Owner agrees that development of the subject property will conform to all other requirements of the zoning chapter, as well as the following conditions: a. Substantial compliance with the Concept Plan dated July 21, 2008, attached and incorporated herein, with regard to the location of the building and parking lot. Any substantial deviation from the Concept Plan regarding building and parking placement shall require approval by the Planning and Zoning Commission. All other changes shall be approved by City Staff.' b. The vehicular access point shall be located as shown on the attached Concept Plan. c. Owner shall install and maintain landscaping to the S2 Standard, as described in Iowa City Code of Ordinances 14-5F-6, as amended, along -the length of the Dodge Street frontage: d. The Dodge Street building elevations shall demonstrate appropriate articulation and fenestration suitable for this important entranceway into Iowa City, which shall include the use of a brick veneer with limestone base, sills, and banding to break up the facade and windows on at least 30% of the facade. 4. The Owner and City acknowledge that the conditions contained herein are reasonable conditions to impose on the land under Iowa Code §414.5 (2007), and that said conditions satisfy public needs that are caused by the requested zoning change. 5. The Owner and City acknowledge that in the event the subject property is transferred, sold, redeveloped, or subdivided, all redevelopment will conform with the terms of this Conditional Zoning Agreement. 6. The parties acknowledge that this Conditional Zoning Agreement shall be deemed to be a covenant running with the land and with title to the land, and shall remain in full force and effect as a covenant with title to the land, unless or until released of record by the City of Iowa City. The parties further acknowledge that this agreement shall inure to the benefit of and bind all successors, representatives, and assigns of the parties. 7. The Owner acknowledges that nothing in this Conditional Zoning Agreement shall be construed to relieve the Owner or Applicant from complying with all other applicable local, state, and federal regulations. 8. The parties agree that this Conditional Zoning Agreement shall be incorporated by reference into the ordinance rezoning the subject property, and that upon adoption and publication of the ordinance, this agreement shall be recorded in the Johnson County Recorder's Office at the Applicant's expense. Dated this `~ day of ~ wiz , 20 ®~ OWNER UNIVERSITY OF IOWA COMMUNITY CREDIT UNION ~4~~~ /~o ichard J. oble Senior Vice-President CITY OF IOWA CITY By 2 Regenia D. Bailey, Mayor By Marian K. Karr, City Clerk OWNER'S ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Approved by: kl.cc City Attorney's Office 9/s/dg~ State of ---~u'~'~- ,County of ~~h~So~' ss: This instrument was acknowledged before me on the `~'`~ day of ~ ~~~-~~~', 2008 by Richard J. Noble, as Senior Vice-President of University of Iowa Community Credit Union. Notary Public in and for the State of Iowa My commission expires: `~C,~ ~~ ~~~L~~ << -rurr~E ~a,,,. ~;s~.~.! i'umber 221819 ~~ ~' l^- '~O^l(' f^ cX0iP25 CITY OF IOWA CITY ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: ~:l '~ ~~~ -~-y---~- State of Iowa, County of Johnson, ss: On this day of 2008, before me, the undersigned, a notary public for the state of Iowa, personally appeared Regenia D. Bailey and Marian ~K. Karr, to me personally known, who, being by me duly sworn, did say that they are the Mayor and City Clerk, respectively, of the City of Iowa City, Iowa, executing the within and foregoing instrument; that the seal attached thereto is the seal of said corporation by authority of its City Council; and that the said Mayor and City Clerk acknowledged the execution of said instrument to be the voluntary act and deed of said corporation, by it and by them voluntarily executed. Notary Public in and for the State of Iowa My commission expires: 3 / ' T .0 ~L,.__ y ~o ~~~~ C ' lL/'/ _ .. ~Y o ~ ~~ . '. ~ , ~ ' ' ,~~ 1 \-~ ~ 'Y?` ~ . o' \ ~ .-i5 1 ~ 1'• ` ~ . _~ ~ . ~ i 1 i 1 1 1~ 1 1 O . t' 1 1 " 1 \ 1 L.L 1 1 1 1 -- 1 1 1 \ 1 M .r' ' 1 1 1 1 1 1 ~ 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 v 1 1 1 1 1 \ 1 1 1 1 1 11 l 1\ 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 , 1 \ 1 1 1 1 1 1 \ 1 \ \ l 1 \ \ 1 \ 1 t 1 \ 1 6 1 11 1\ 1 1 1 'SS\ m 1 1 1 1 I..L 1 1 1 1 11 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ~ sO\ \ 1 1 1 1 1 11 \ 1 1 1 1 v <;, 1 1 \ 1 1 1 1 1 1 ~ 1 JI Irv ',o \ 1 1 1 1 1 1 II _ 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 11 11 1 1 z 1 1 1 j > 1 1 ~ 1 1 1 1 p ~? ~ 1 1 p 1 N ¢ p~ II Z 1 LL 1 \ ~ ~ 11 11 11 LL LL M~LLv o BT~~ 11 11 1\ ~ ~ ~ ~O ' oLL Cn w U ~ a ~ O ' A !~ \~~; ~ \• ~ ~ \\. \\ \ 1 \ ~~~ 1 \ \\ \ \ 1 \ ¢ \, 1 '~ 1 o V 1 • ~ P U Z m WZ ~ 1 1 !~ ~~ F WW}J ~QF- 11 1 LLLLLLJJ7 ¢ \ W a 1 1 1 1 l O ¢ a 1 1 1 1 I_ 11 11 _ _~. 11 11 :111 1 i 11 U ' a 1 ~ . ~., Z $ \ N . \ ~',~ \~~ \`~~ `~_. . \ ~ m ' ^-- 0 u J 1~ ,~~ 0 11 ~ 1 o ~ Z W I Q ~ 1i U $ >~ U • Iwo ~ ~ a 1 T ~ ~ ~~ '.~` cO CnJ~ ~ l.L. N ~ ` O ~~ln p.)`- ~ T f-- ~ II II II U n Z 1 111 11 11 ~ 1 1 ~ / // O __-' SI' 3 a' ~~ NCn tO Z C wz ' ' '~ ~~ ooln~dln N ~ (n ~ ~ wa 3 ~ (n Q ~ O w O= 1 1 ;. 11 11 11 / ; ;, N 1 1 1. N II p jj~O pYU` W / 1 ~ ' ~ ln NW~~+M Cn WQYUU Qa / ~ w , ~ li }1 W~UQC7J UaQ ~ ~ ~ w<n~UZLL ~ c~i~oa~~=~~ z ac i~~ ~~oc7z ; / ~ ¢ v -rye--. }~ 11 U = . Y ' ,' .'~ , ro N l F ¢ ~ J LL ¢ j ~ / i Nli 11 _ O ^ /.' ... ~ y~ ~i 1 d M /a 61 ti~ to _---_ - y~ o ~1 ~i ~ O (~ ~% / ,q0,. ~ ,~~11 1 ~ ~ 1 / 1 / 121" - ~ _ - Q , `~1~ 11 /~ / ~ ~ ~/ 11~~11111 / ~ J' ~1 1 / i' ,1 1 ~ ~`,~ ii _10-06.08... 8 Prepared by: Susan Dulek, Asst. City Attorney, 410 E. Washington Street, Iowa City, IA 52240; 319-356-5030 ORDINANCE NO. 08-4318 ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 6, ENTITLED "PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY," CHAPTER 10, ENTITLED, "SMOKEFREE PLACES," TO CORRECT THE DIAGRAM THAT ILLUSTRATES WHERE SMOKING IS PROHIBITED IN CITY PLAZA. WHEREAS, in Ordinance No. 08-4314, the City declared places to be non-smoking in addition to those set forth in HF 2212, the Iowa Smokefree Air Act ("the Act"); WHEREAS, one such place is city plaza in the area to the east of the southeast corner of 125 S. Dubuque Street (a/k/a Plaza Centre One), which is illustrated in a diagram; WHEREAS, the southern boundary of the diagram includes a small section of property that is not part of the city plaza; WHEREAS, it is in the best interest of the City to adopt a corrected diagram that illustrates where smoking is prohibited in city plaza. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CITY, IOWA: SECTION I. AMENDMENTS. Title 6, entitled "Public Health and Safety," chapter 10, entitled "Smokefree Places," is hereby amended by deleting the diagram of city plaza and inserting in lieu thereof the attached diagram. SECTION II. REPEALER. All ordinances and parts of ordinances in conflict with the provision of this Ordinance are hereby repealed. SECTION III. SEVERABILITY. If any section, provision or part of the Ordinance shall be adjudged to be invalid or unconstitutional, such adjudication shall not affect the validity of the Ordinance as a whole or any section, provision or part thereof not adjudged invalid or unconstitutional. SECTION IV. EFFECTIVE DATE. This Ordinance shall be in effect after its final passage, approval and publication, as provided by law. Passed and approved this 2lstday of October , 2008. A ST: CITY CLE Approved b ~` . 3 0 ._o F City Attorney's Office Ordinance No. 08-4318 Page 2 It was moved by Wilburn and seconded by 0' Donnell that the Ordinance as read be adopted, and upon roll call there were: AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: x Bailey x Champion x Correia g Hayek x O'Donnell ~ Wilburn _ g Wright First Consideration 10/6/2008 Vote for passage: AYES: O'Donnell, Wilburn, Wright, Bailey, Champion, Correia, Hayek. NAYS: None. ABSENT: None. Second Consideration ----------------- Vote for passage: Date published 10/29/2008 Moved by Wilburn, seconded by Champion, that the rule requiring ordinances to be considered and voted on for passage at two Council meetings prior to the meeting at which it is to be finally passed be suspended, the second consideration and emote be waived and the ordinance be voted upon for final passage at this time. AYES: O'Donnell, Wilburn, Wright, Bailey, Champion, Correia, Hayek. NAYS: None. ABSENT: None. ~n °~ ~' o rt ~~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ I--+ O M~+ n ~ ~^ ^~ ^ 0 Linn Street G Clinton Street -~^ ~o o ~ ~~ o®o