HomeMy WebLinkAbout2003-01-09 Info Packet CITY COUNCIL INFORMATION PACKET
CITY OF IOWA CITY January 9, 2003
www.icgov.or9
I ,SCE'' NEOUS I
IP1 Tentative Meeting Schedule and Work Session Agendas
IP2 Memorandum from City Manager: State Legislature
IP3 Memorandum from City Manager: Upcoming for 2003
IP4 Memorandum from City Manager: Economic Development Strategy - Revisited
IP5 Letter from Hillary Sale to City Manager: Support that CDBG Funding be
Allocated for Housing Inspection/Code Enforcement Purposes
IP6 Letter to Waste Haulers from City Manager: Dumpsters
IP7 Memorandum from Police Chief to City Manager: 28E Agreement - University
Heights Public Safety Dispatch - Update
IP8 Memorandum from JCCOG Human Services Coordinator and Planner Long to
City Manager: HUD's Homeless Continuum of Care Funding Decision
IP9 Email to City Manager, Planning and Community Development Assistant Director,
and Neighborhood Services Coordinator from Jean Walker: Melrose/Grand
Avenue Traffic Study [staff response included]
IP10 Memorandum to Library Board of Trustees and Library Director from Assistant
City Attorney Matthews: Library Board Authority re: Lease of Real Estate
IP11 Building Permit Information - December 2002
IP12 Memorandum from Customer Service Manager: Utility Discount Program
Statistics - FY02 and FY03
J PRELIMINARY/DRAFT MINUTES I
IP13 Housing and Community Development Commission: December 19
IP14 Iowa City Human Rights Commission: December 17
CORRESPONDENCE TO BE ACCEPTED ON JANUARY 21 CONSENT CALENDAR
IP15 Patti Santangelo: January 11 Soup Supper
City Council Meeting Schedule and January9.2003
C~TY OF IOW^ C~T¥Work Session Agendas
www.icgov.org
TENTATIVE FUTURE MEETINGS AND AGENDAS
· MONDAY, JANUARY 13 Emma J. Ha/vat Hall
6:30p Special Council Work Session
· Budget
· WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 15 Emma J. Ha/vat Hall
8:00a - 12:00p Special Council Work Session
· Budget
· MONDAY, JANUARY20
Martin Luther King, Jr. Day Holiday - City Offices Closed
· TUESDAY, JANUARY 21 Emma J. Ha/vat Hall
TBA Special Council Work Session
6:30p City Conference Board
7:00p Regular Council Formal Meeting
· WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 22 County Administration Building
4:00p Special Council Work Session
· Joint Meeting: Cities of Coralville and North Liberty, Iowa City School District,
Johnson County Board of Supervisors
· MONDAY, JANUARY 27 Emma J. Ha/vat Hall
6:30p Special Council Work Session
- Budget- Boards, Commissions, Committees and Program/Event Organizers
· TUESDAY, JANUARY 28 Emma J. Harvat Hall
6:30p Special Council Work Session
· Budget
Meeting dates/times/topics subject to change
FUTURE WORK SESSION ITEMS
Regulation of Downtown Dumpsters Downtown Historic Preservation
Council Meeting Schedule
City of Iowa City
MEMORANDUM
Date: January 6, 2003
To: City Council
From: City Manager
Re: State Legislature
You may have occasion to be in Des Moines during the legislative session. Attached are
some "pointers" Jf you choose to visit at the State Capitol.
cc: Depadment Directors
mgdmem/legislature.doc
Steve Atkins
From: Susan Judkins [SusanJudkins@iowareague.org]
Sent: Monday, January 06, 2003 10:36 AM
To: CityVoices
Subject: RE: Tips for Capitol Visits/2-12-03 Legislative Day Registration
Ted Tedesco's comment that all legislative meetings are open to the public is correct.
Cities are especially affected by Ways & Means and Local Government committee meetings,
but many times there are specific issues affecting us that are addressed in other
committees such as Appropriations, Judiciary, State Government, Commerce, Economic Growth
or Transportation.
Here are a few pointers that can be helpful to know when at the capitol:
*visitor parking is available in various lots to the east and south of the capitol, or
along the street where specially marked. A parking garage west of the capitol on Grand
Avenue is still under construction, and I don't know if it will be ready for use during
this session. Parking can be tight; plan to arrive early when you can.
*You must use one of the public entrances on the ground floor of the capitol and will be
required to go through a security check similar to what is experienced at the airport.
It's relatively painless.
*There is a kiosk in the east hall of the ground floor of the capitol that sits just
outside the Legislative Information Office. Typically there are daily calendars for the
House and Senate printed on yellow paper that can be found in this kiosk. This lets you
know the planned time and location of various meetings if you haven't already seen that
information on the web.
*Public coat racks are available outside of Room 19 or at the west end of the second
floor.
*T!/pical meeting rooms include:
- Room 19 (the Reagan Room) on the ground floor, east hall
Room 116 or 118 on the first floor, east hall
- other rooms behind the House and Senate chambers
*Rooms behind the House and Senate chambers can be reached by walking through the chamber
(but only around the sides, not down the central aisle) if the legislators are not in
session; otherwise, these rooms can be accessed only by stairway on the north (House) or
south (Senate) ends of the first floor.
*City officials representing their cities' views typically do not need to register as a
lobbyist to visit with legislators at the capitol. Ask us if you have questions about
this.
*You should not stop to visit with a legislator in the House or Senate chamber beyond a
brief "hello"; more lengthy discussions should occur in the rotunda (the open area on the
second floor between the chambers) or other places outside the chamber. Forms are
available on tables in the rotunda or in the lobbyist lounges on the second floor to send
a note in to your legislator.
*In committee or subcommittee meetings, legislators sit at the table; visitors sit or
stand around the sides of the meeting room. In a subcommittee meeting, sometimes visitors
will be invited to sit at the table but wait for an invitation.
*Visitors may speak only when specifically invited by a committee member. Subcommittee
meetings are less formal and there can be more conversational interchange.
*"Suitable attire" is required of visitors. Men and women are safe in a suit; either
dresses, skirts or pants are all right for women.
*Cell phones should be turned off or placed on silent or vibrate ring only when in a
committee meeting or watching debate.
Konni and I look forward to seeing city representatives at the capitol this year. Let us
know when you are planning to come when you can, and we can have information available
that will help you to best help us on specific issues. Not only do we watch for key
committee meetings, but sometimes SUBCOMMITTEE meetings are where important work happens
and we can help you know when and where those are occurring.
We welcome your participation throughout the year, but especially on LEGISLATIVE DAY which
is 2/12/03. Another registration form will be included in the 1/10/03 Legislative Bulletin
if you've not already registered.
1
City of Iowa City
MEMORANDUM
Date: January 7, 2003
To: City Council
From: City Manager
Re: Upcoming for 2003
1. Revisit alcohol ordinances - March 2003
2. Homeland security - likely to have significant City involvement in fulfilling new
federal regulations.
3. Storm water management - file permits/applications with Federal EPA by end of
the year.
4. Downtown Historic Preservation Study - review
5 Public Power initiative/study
6. Collective Bargaining agreements
7. Annexation Plan - area in/around Airport
8. Water Plant - tour and community open house: into production
9. Airport - come to agreement on the long-term financing and management
10. Wastewater Plant - tour and community open house
11. Development Code review
mgdmem/u pcoming03.do¢
City of Iowa City
MEMORANDUM
Date: January 7, 2003
To: City Council
From: City Manager
Re: Economic Development Strategy - Revisited
In December 1999, the City adopted an Economic Development Strategy that outlined
policy and actions for a stronger economic development role for the City with the overall
objective of growing the tax base. The following information prepared by our
Planning/Economic Development staff identifies the areas within economic development
targeted by City Council and briefly highlights some of the accomplishments that have
occurred since 1999.
1. Business Friendly Community
· The Council has taken proactive steps to encourage business through the
adoption of five new Tax Increment Financing (TIF) districts and creation of three
economic development funds.
· The City's development code is under review. Staff is working to make the code
more user-friendly and reduce barriers to development wherever possible.
Completion of the code review is scheduled for 2003.
· The Council Economic Development Committee is making approximately 100
business visits. These visits are designed to provide the Council with a first-hand
view of the business climate.
2. Retention and Expansion
· Redevelopments of commercial areas within the community include the Iowa
Avenue Streetscape, downtown pedestrian plaza, Northside Marketplace, and
Sycamore Mall.
· Examples of expansions of existing businesses include Seabury & Smith, Procter
& Gamble, ACT, Steindler Orthopedic Clinic, Chezik Sayers Auto, and Hawkeye
Welding.
· Capital improvements (infrastructure) within the community have suppoded the
retention and expansion of local businesses and/or will provide for economic
opportunities (e.g., First Avenue, Scott Boulevard extension, water and sewer
treatment facilities).
3. Business Attraction
· Partnerships have been developed or strengthened with Iowa City Area
Development (ICAD), the Chamber of Commerce, the University of Iowa and other
organizations to promote and market Iowa City. Some examples of new
businesses in Iowa City include Alpla, Owens-Illinois, Gerdin Scott/Six
Warehousing, and Farmers & Merchants Bank.
January 7,2003
Page 2
· Iowa City is actively working with Cedar Rapids and other communities to promote
within the Technology Corridor to attract businesses.
Due, in part, to the City's initiatives building permits for non-residential commercial and
industrial investments in the community (January 2000 - December 2002) have totaled
$111,227,945. The following is a breakdown of these investments by type:
· $64,542,139 new industrial and commercial buildings
· $31,466,484 additions to commercial and industrial buildings
· $15,219,322 alterations to commercial and industrial buildings
cc: Karin Franklin, Director of Planning and Community Development
Joe Raso, ICAD
Mark Seckman, Priority-One - Cedar Rapids
mgdmem/CC-ecodev doc
Hillary A. Sale
1016 East College Street
Iowa City, Iowa 52240
./~
January 6, 2003
Steve Atkins
City Manager
City of Iowa City
Civic Center
Iowa City, Iowa 52240
Dear Steve:
As the Chair of the former Neighborhood Housing Relations Task Force, I write to
indicate my support for your recent proposal that the Housing and Community
Development Commission recommend to City Council that CDBG funding be allocated
for housing inspection/code enforcement purposes.
The members of the Task Force agreed that the City needs to allocate resources to
housing inspection. The CDBG guidelines specifically support the use of funds for code
enforcement. Moreover, housing inspectors provide a direct benefit to low and moderate
income people in our community. Housing inspectors work to ensure the safety,
sanitation, and decency of rental housing in our community. In addition, when they work
with landlords to determine occupancy limits, the inspectors play a vital role in
decreasing overoccupancy. During my time as Task Force Chair, I was persuaded that
the overoccupancy of rental units allows for surplus profits on the units. Thus, as
overoccupancy increases, the potential use of the property for something like affordable
housing decreases. Housing inspectors play an important role in making sure that
occupancy limits are respected and adhered to.
In sum, I support your attempts to find funding for additional housing inspection staff. If
I can provide you with any other information, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Very truly yours,
,
Hillary A~./Sale
Cc: City Council
Doug Boothroy
Karin Franklin
Marcia Klingaman
Steve Nasby
of
January 8, 2003 ~'~, C~'
Re: Litter around dumpsters
Waste Haulers:
In recent months, the City has received many complaints regarding overflowing garbage
dumpsters and the litter problems created by these dumpsters. The problem seems to result
from the lack of cleanup around the dumpsters, which then causes the blowing litter problem.
The City feels that this problem is not only the responsibility of the property owner but also the
garbage hauler. Property owners are continually asked to clean up the litter created around their
dumpsters, but they also need the help and cooperation of their refuse hauler to clean up any
mess that is created during refuse collection.
We all recognize the time constraints involved in garbage collection, but taking a few minutes to
clean up around the dumpsters would be appreciated. Increasing the frequency of collection for
some of these dumpsters should also be considered in order to help reduce this litter problem.
Given the level and frequency of complaints by downtown businesses as well as downtown
patrons, this is a problem that we cannot let get out of hand. More drastic measures such as
issuing citations in order to keep Iowa City clean would appear to be our next alternative,
notably if the complaints persist. Your cooperation is greatly appreciated. Thank you.
Sincerely,
City Manager
cc: City Council
Chuck Schmadeke
Doug Boothroy
Rodney Wails
Bud Stockman
Bob Shaver
mgr/Itrs/haulerltr doc
410 EAST WASHINGTON STREET · IOWA CITY, IOWA 52240- 1826 · (3191 356-5000 · FAX (319) 356 5009
IOWA CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT
410 EAST WASHINGTON STREET, IOWA CITY, IA 52240
(319) 356-5275 FAX # (319) 356-5449
"An Accredited Police Department"
DATE: January 8, 2003
TO: City Manager
FROM: Chief of Police ~
RE: 28E Agreement - University Heights Public Safety Dispatch - Update
In the later part of 2002 the Iowa City Police Department was contacted by Brian
Shimon, the Chief of the University Heights Police Department, to explore the possibility
of providing their department with emergency dispatch services.
Captain Widmer reviewed the requirements necessary to complete the tasks involved,
as well as determining a cost for providing the services. A 28E Agreement is needed to
provide the service. The City Attorney's Office is reviewing the proposed 28E.
The City Council of University Heights is in favor of the 28E and is awaiting acopy for
their review and approval. After the City Council of University Heights has reviewed the
28E our City Council can consider this proposal.
The service requested is a service that the Iowa City Emergency Communication
Center is able to provide. The cost Captain Widmer quoted to University Heights will
cover the cost of the service to be provided and a yearly review.
TO: Steve Atkin. s, City Manager
FR: Lind .ay~n, JCCOG Human Services Coordinator
Stev~(~ng, Community Development ~,/
RE: HUD's Homeless Continuum of Care Funding Decision
The state of Iowa (with the exception of Des Moines, Council Bluffs, and Sioux
City) applies for Balance of State Continuum of Care funding for housing and
support services programs that serve people who are homeless. At the local
level, we complete the Continuum of Care document for our area along with
grant applications for programs. These are sent to the state (Iowa Dept. of
Economic Development [IDED] and the Iowa Coalition for Housing and
Homelessness) that then combine all the local Continuums of Care into one
document. This document and grant applications are then sent to the HUD field
office in Omaha for our region and the federal HUD office in Washington DC for
consideration of funding.
On December 18th, the state was notified that Iowa was not allocated any funds
for Federal FY 03 (Iowa's share was approximately $4.4 million dollars that funds
12 continuing programs and 3 new programs) from this process because the
state Continuum of Care document was incomplete and was not scored high
enough to be considered for funding. The state contends that complete
applications were sent to Omaha and Washington DC. The Omaha office did
receive two complete copies. The application received at the HUD office in
Washington was missing pages.
On December 20th, the Iowa Depar-[ment of Economic Development faxed (and
mailed) a letter to Ray Bernardi, Assistant Secretary for Community Planning and
Development at HUD indicating that Iowa intended to appeal the recent HUD
decision. Also, on December 20th, staff from Congressman Leach and Senator
Harkin's offices met with HUD staff. A letter from Senators Grassley and Harkin
was sent on December 24th to Mel Martinez, Secretary of HUD. The state has
been investigating what happened and a draft formal letter of appeal has been
reviewed by legal staff at IDED, the Attorney General's office and congressional
staff and forwarded to the Governor's office. It was sent yesterday.
The Local Homeless Coordinating Board (LHCB) and City staff are keeping
updated on the situation and will report any new information to you.
Attached you will find examples of letters sent.
Citymanagermemore:CofCfunding 1.7.03
December 20, 2002
Mr. Roy A. Bernardi, Assistant Secretary
Community Planning and Development
Department of Housing and Urban Development
451 7th Street, SW
Washington, DC 20410
Dear Assistant Secretary Bemardi:
I am writing to express our deep concern about HUD's recent decision not to fund any
portion of the "State of Iowa - Balance of State Continuum of Care" application
submitted by the Iowa Department of Economic Development (IDED).
As illustrated by the "Continuum of Care: Project Priorities" chart found in our
application, much is at stake. Based on HUD's estimated pro rata share of $3.9 million
in funding for the area covered by our application, plus an additional $500,000 for
ranking a new permancmt housing program as the number one priority, twelve programs
currently funded by HUD would not have their funding renewed and three new programs
serving victims of domestic violence and youth would not be funded under HUD's
current decision.
We understand that the likely reason for HUD's decision was the reported absence of
critical material which had been prepared for our application. We are actively reviewing
the cimumstances regarding this issue, and expect to file an 'appeal as soon as we are able
to discern and document the facts related to our case.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
Mary Lawyer
Interim Director
cc: Honorable Governor Thomas Vilsack
John Garrity, Office of Special Needs Assistance Programs
Patricia Carlile, Deputy Assistant Secretary for Special Needs
/~ Patricia McCauley, Nebraska State Office
/ William H. McNamey, Des Moines Field Office
/ Senator Tom Harkin
Senator Charles Grassley
Representative Jim Leach
Representative Tom Latham
Represent.ative Jim Nussle
Michael Blouin
Page 1 of 2
· Linda Severson
From: Candace Peters [cpeters@meccaia.com]
Sent: Tuesday, December 24, 2002 11:36 AM
To: jclhcb@meccaia.com; Star Advisory Group
Subject: Richard Bender, Harkin-Grassley letter sent
....Original Message
From: Bender, Richard (HaM
To: ~Rndace p~ters
Sent: Tuesday, December 24, 2002 10:58 AM
Subject: RE: Johnson County Local Homeless Coordinating Board
Below is a copy of the text of a Harkin-Grassley letter sent
December 24, 2002
Hon. Mel Martinez
Secretary
Department of Housing and Rural Development
451 Seventh Street, S.W.
Washington, DC 20410
Dear Secretary Martinez:
For a number of years, Iowa, like many states, submits a combined grant application covering most of
the state for Homeless Continuum of Care funds. Under HUD's estimation of the area's pro rata share
of funds and extra funding for a first ranked permanent housing program, the portion of Iowa covered
might expect to receive was around $4.4 million for twelve continuing homeless programs and four new
proposals. This sum represents a very large share of the governmental funds available to assist homeless
individuals and families in the portion of Iowa covered. I need not tell you how crucial these funds are
for the most needy, the homeless.
Unfortunately, HUD recently decided to provide no funds under the Iowa Department of Economic
Development request because the material reviewed lacked a critical portion of the application. That
material was available in HUD's Nebraska field office but historically only the material in Washington
is formally considered. Fault is not the issue. Meeting the needs of Iowa's homeless is crucial.
We expect the State of Iowa to soon formally appeal the decision to not fund the application. We urge
that you take a personal interest in this matter and do all that you can to restore needed homeless funding
to Iowa.
We appreciate your consideration of this crucial matter.
Sincerely,
12/27/2002
Page 2 of 2
Tom Harkin Charles Grassley
U.S. Senator U.S. Senator
..... Original Message .....
From: Candace Peters [mailto:cpeters@meccaia.com]
Sent: Friday, December 20, 2002 8:5! PM
To: Bender, Richard (Harkin)
Subject: Johnson County Local Homeless Coordinating Board
Dear Mr. Bender,
Please review the attached memo with concerns relative to this weeks HUD announcement of the 2002
continuum of care awards. Your immediate attention is requested to the matter of the balance of state
application submitted by the Iowa Department of Economic Development (IDED) not listed as being
funded for the 2003-2004 year.
Candace Peters
Chairperson
Johnson County Local Homeless Coordinating Board
12/27/2002
Marian Karr IP9
From: Jeff Davidson
Sent: Wednesday, January 08, 2003 2:06 PM
To: 'Jean Walker'
Cc: Steve Atkins; Marcia Klingaman; *City Council
Subject: RE: Melrose/Grand Avenue Traffic Study
Jean, it has taken longer than we expected to get the budget and scope of work hammered out with the consultant, Earth
Tech. We are working on it currently and I expect to have it ready in the next couple of weeks. The 6 month timeframe
will begin when the committee commences its activities; we will endeavor to get done sooner than 6 months if we can.
You will receive all committee materials as a member of the committee; there have been no committee activities or
materials circulated at this time. The University's representatives are Larry Wilson, David Ricketts, George Hollins, Hugh
Barry, Ken Davenport (UIHC), and Barbara Eckstein.
Let me know if you have any questions.
..... Original Message .....
From: Jean Walker [mailto:walkersic@yahoo.com]
Sent: Wednesday, January 08, 2003 1:46 PM
To: Steve Atkins; Jeff Davidson; Marcia Klingaman
Cc: cou ncil@iowa-city.org
Subject: Melrose/Grand Avenue Traffic Study
Dear Steve, Marcia, Jeff:
I am wondering when the Melrose Avenue-Grand Avenue
Area Traffic Study by the UI and the City (including
myself as Neighborhood Representative), requested by
the City Council, will commence? On November 1, 2002
I received a note from Jeff to say that he was waiting
to hear from the UI.
I understand that Jeff, Karin Franklin, Rick Fosse,
and Brian Boelk will participate from the City staff.
I am wondering if the UI has communicated yet who will
participate from their staff and whether a consultant
been chosen to assist in the study?
I am presuming the six-month study will start at the
time of the first meeting of the City and UI
personnel, the consultant, and myself and I would very
much appreciate if I could be sent copies of any
relevant materials shared between the parties prior to
that meeting.
Thank you,
Jean Walker
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail Plus - Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now.
http://mailplus.yahoo.com
City of Iowa City
MEMORANDUM
Date: January 7, 2003
To: Board of Trustees of the Iowa City Public Library
Susan Craig, Library Director
From: Andrew Matthews, Assistant City Attorney
Re: Library Board Authority Re: Lease of Real Estate
This memo is provided in an effort to clarify the Board of Trustee's contractual authority with
respect to leasing of space at the new library building. Our office concludes that the City
Council must review and approve any leases entered into for rental space in the premises.
In 2002 the Iowa Court of Appeals issued a decision in Nolte v. Brown Memorial Library and
City of Dumont, ruling that a contract made by a city library board to buy real estate is not
enforceable unless it was approved by the city council. This Court of Appeals decision is not
a published opinion but can serve as a guide on the issue.
Iowa Code {}392.3 states in pertinent part that unless otherwise stated in the ordinance
establishing the agency, contracts and agreements entered into by administrative agencies
are subject to review and approval by the council. In its decision, the Appeals Court first
looked at the board's authority to contract as set out in the town's applicable ordinance. The
powers and duties of the town's library board are substantially similar to those set out in City
Code Title 11. The Appeals Court determined that the Dumont ordinance did not expressly
authorize the board to contract for the purchase of real estate without Council approval.
Given the similarities in the subject ordinances, the lack of specific authority for the library
board to sell or encumber real estate, and the fact that we are dealing with lease terms for
real estate, consistent with the Court of Appeals decision, our office concludes that the City
Council should review and approve any lease for space in the library.
Let me know if you have any questions or wish to discuss the matter further.
cc: Eleanor Dilkes, City Attorney
City council
Stephen Atkins, City Manager
Dale Helling, Assistant City Manager
Marian Karr, City Clerk
IPll
/
BUILDING PERMIT INFORMATION
December 2002
KEY FOR ABBREVIATIONS
· Type of Improvement:
ADD - Addition
ALT- Alteration
REP- Repair
FND - Foundation Only
NEW- New
OTH - Other type of construction
Type of Use:
RSF - Residential Single Family
RDF - Residential Duplex
RMF - Three or more residential
RAC - Residential Accessory Building
MIX- Mixed
NON- Non-residential
OTH- Other
Page: 2 City of Iowa City
Date: 1/2/2003 Extraction of Building Permit Data for
To: 12/1/2002
Census
Bureau
From: 12/31/2002 xx'elatu'~'
Type Type
Permit Number Name Address Impr U~ Stories Units Valuation
BLD02-00843 GENERAL MILLS OPERATIC 2309 HE1NZ RD ADD NON 2 1 $240,000
STEEL PLATFORMS FOR HVAC SYSTEMS
BLD02-00842 TOWNCREST PLAZA L L C 2302 1/2 MUSCAT1NE ADD NON 2 1 $1,000
DORMER ADDITION SIGN SUPPORT
I Total ADD/NON permits: 2 Total Valuation: $241,000 i
BLD02-00772 DAVID M FINLEY 881 PARK PL ADD RSF 1 10 $20,000
GARAGE ADDITION TO SFD
BLD02-00793 BARBARA A BENNETT 2123 PLAEN VIEW DR ADD RSF 1 0 $13,873
7.5' X 13' UNHEATED SU2qROOM
BLD02-00803 DONALD & CAROL LEIGH 15 BRUNSWICK CT ADD RSF 2 1 $13,299
3 SEASON PORCH ADDITION TO SFD
BLD02-00738 VALENTINO, RUSSELL S 1106 YEWELL ST ADD RSF 1 0 $12,900
12' X 12' THREE SEASON ROOM
BLD02-00808 WADE S & MELISSA P SHRI~ 8 WELLESLEY WY ADD RSF 1 0 $12,000
12'X 18' SCREEN PORCH
BLD02-00811 LOREN W & JOANNE L LEAl 1665 RIDGE RD ADD RSF 1 0 $11,800
20' X 26' ROOM ADDITION
BLD02~00804 GALBRETH, JANET L 722 BARRINGTON RD ADD RSF 2 1 $10,000
3 SEASON PORCH ADDITION TO SFD
BLD02-00722 TIMOTHY L HOLMAN & ME 420 FAIRCHILD ST ADD RSF 1 2 $9,500
ADDITION TO SFD
BLD02-00846 JOHN ERICKSON 3228 SHAMROCK DR ADD RSF 2 1 $1,600
FRONT DECK ADDITION TO SFD
I Total ADD/RSF permits: 9 Total Valuation: $104,972 i
BLD02-00800 ENGLERT CIVIC THEATRE I 217 -21 WASHINGTON ST ALT NON 3 0 $309,000
ENGLERT THEATRE LOBBY REMODEL
BLD02-00797 STEVE, KATHLEEN A 320 E BENTON ST ALT NON 2 0 $90,000
RESTAURANT
BLD02-00830 MARNET PROPERTIES %BE~ 218 WASHINGTON ST ALT NON 2 1 $45,000
INTERIOR TENANT SPACE SHELL OF 1 ST FLOOR
BLD02-00787 JASON CAYLOR 522 S GILBERT ST ALT NON 2 10 $35,000
PICK UP & DELIVERY PIZZA PREP KITCHEN
BLD02-00496 CHUNG SUN YU 415 S GILBERT ST ALT NON I 2 $25,000
ALTERATION OF RETAIL SPACE TO RESTAURANT
BLD02-00826 ZAREI, ZAVASH 320 -22 E BURLINGTON S~I ALT NON 1 0 $2,500
REMODEL INTERIOR OF RESTAURANT
BLD02-00831 CHERYL SOBASKI LLC 101 ESCORT LN ALT NON I I $2,500
CANOPY ON COMMERCIAL BUILDING
TotalALT/NON permits :7 TotaIValuaflon: $509,000
Page: 3 City of Iowa City
Date: la/2oo3 Extraction of Building Permit Data for
To: 12/1/2002 Census Bureau r p L*'e-o
From: 12/31/2002
Type Type
Permit Number Name Address Impr U_~ Stories Units Valuation
BLD02-00779 MCLEAN STREET LLC 321 MCLEAN ST ALT RDF 2 10 $65,706
DUPLEX CONDO CONVERSION
BLD02-00742 GREG ALLEN 619 E BURLINGTON ST ALT RDF 2 2 $20,000
CONVERT FOUR UNITS TO A DUPLEX
I TotalALT/RDF permits: 2 Total Valuation: $85,706 i
BLD02-00822 THOMPSON, JEANNE 916 S SUMMIT ST ALT RSF 2 1 $35,695
CONVERT DUPLEX TO SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING REMODEL 1 ST FLOOR
BLD02-00819 WILLIAM G & BARBARA M 718 S SUMMIT ST ALT RSF 1 0 $29,250
KITCHEN REMODEL AND ENCLOSE PORCH
BLD02-00836 WADE S & MELISSA P SHRI~ 8 WELLESLEY WY ALT RSF 2 1 $17,000
BASEMENT FINISH OF SFD
BLD02-00834 BRIAN & CYNTHIA MEYER 1632 TOFTING AVE ALT RSF 2 1 $10,345
BASEMENT F1NISI4
BLD02-00622 DANIEL LEICK 2211 NEVADA AVE ALT RSF 1 2 $1,938
WINDOW REPLACEMENT IN SFD
BLD02-00794 NEWMAN & KRISTI ABUISS 1428 BU1LESH AVE ALT RSF 1 0 $1,000
ADD THREE NEW WINDOWS. TWO 1N FAMILY ROOM AND ONE 1N THE BATHROOM
Total ALT/RSF permits: 6 Total Valuation: $95,228
BLD02-00827 TERRY L STAMPER HOLDIN 1075 FOSTER RD FND 1LAC 1 0 $0
FOUNDATION FOR DETACHED GARAGE
Total FND/RAC permits: 1 Total Valuation: $0
BLD02-00810 ARLINGTON DEVELOPMEN' 10 NOTTING HILL LN FND RDF 1 0 $0
FOUNDATION FOR DUPLEX(BUILDING F)
LOT 263(10-12)
Total FND/RDF permits: 1 Total Valuation: SO
BLD02-00761 LOPAREX INC 2000 INDUSTRIAL PARK R NEW NON 1 2 $52,900
DETACHED CHEMICAL STORAGE BUILDING
TotaINEW/NON permits: 1 Total Valuation: $52,900
BLD02-00809 GREG ALLEN 820 IOWA AVE NEW RDF 3 2 $339,753
DUPLEX WITH TWO CAR GARAGES
BLD02-00857 ARLINGTON DEVELOPMEN' 201-03 MANCHESTER LAN NEW RDF 1 2 $241,908
DUPLEX WITH ATTACHED 2 CAR GARAGES
BLD02-00814 ARLINGTON DEVELOPMEN' 11 NOTTING HILL LN NEW RDF 1 2 $241,253
DUPLEX WITH TWO CAR GARAGES
11-13 NOTTING HILL LANE
BLD02-00813 ARLINGTON DEVELOPMEN' 10 NoTTING HILL LN NEW RDF 1 2 $220,000
DUPLEX WITH TWO CAR GARAGES
10-12 NOTTING HILL LANE
Page: 4 City of Iowa City
Date: 1/2/2003 Extraction of Building Permit Data for
To: 2/m002 Census Bureau t,
From: 12/31/2002
Type Type
Permit Number Name Address Impr U_~ Stories Units Valuation
BLD02-00815 ARLINGTON DEVELOPMEN' 24 NOTTING HILL LN NEW RDF 1 2 $209,305
DUPLEX WITH TWO CAR GARAGES
24-26 NOTTING HILL LANE
Total NEW/RDF permits: 5 Total Valuation: $1,252,219 i
BLD02-00767 APEHOUSE L C 330 RIDGELAND AVE NEW RMF 2 10 $1,003,720
10 PLEX APARTMENT BUILDING WITH UNDERGROUND PARKING
330-32-34-36-38-40-42-44-46-48 RIDGELAND AVE
TotalNEW/RMF permits: 1 TotalValuafion: $1,003,720~
BLD02-00833 ARTISAN CUSTOM HOMES 84 CRABAPPLE CT NEW RSF 2 I $450,000
SFD WITH ATTACHED 3 CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00806 JASON LEE 1237 WILD PRAIRIE DR NEW RSF 2 1 $239,190
SFD WITH ATTACHED 2 CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00828 PLUM GROVE ACRES INC 2847 HICKORY TRL NEW RSF 1 1 $215,298
SFD WITH ATTACHED 3 CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00821 GLENN WEIMER CONSTRU( 4645 DRYDEN CT NEW RSF 1 1 $200,000
S.F.D. WITH THREE CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00856 ARLINGTON DEVELOPMEN' 4685 DRYDEN CT NEW RSF 1 1 $193,098
SFD WITH ATTACHED 2 CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00832 KEVIN KIDWELL 1308 PRAIRIE GRASS LN NEW RSF 1 1 $182,553
SFD WITH ATTACHED 3 CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00802 SOUTHGATE DEVELOPMEN 34 LINDEMANN DR NEW RSF 2 1 $168,404
SFD WITH ATTACHED 2 CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00823 ARLINGTON DEVELOPMEN' 15 ASHFORD PL NEW RSF l 1 $164,228
S.F..D. W/TWO CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00840 STEVE KOHLI CONSTRUCT1 1449 LANGENBERG AVE NEW RSF 2 1 $163,277
SFD WITH ATTACHED 2 CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00820 STEVE KOHLI CONSTRUCTI 1457 LANGENBERG AVE NEW RSF 2 1 $139,165
SFD WITH ATTACHED 2 CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00838 THIRD STREET PARTNERS I 1611 WETHERBY DR NEW RSF 1 1 $135,000
SFD WITH ATTACHED 2 CAR GARAGE
BLD02-00805 NEW DIMENSION HOMES O 319 PADDOCK CIR NEW RSF 1 1 $90,000
SFD WITH ATTACHED 2 CAR GARAGE
Total NEW/RSF permits: 12 Total Valuation: $2,340,213
BLD02-00656 B&L PROPERTIES 1233 -35 ESTHER CT REP RDF 1 2 $6,500
WINDOW REPLACEMENT IN RDF
Total REP/RDF permits: 1 Total Valuation: $6,500 i
BLD02-00807 DAXDANIEL LLC 715 IOWA AVE REP RMF 2 0 $5,490
REPLACE ROOF WITH SHINGLE ROOF
P~ge: 5 City of Iowa City
Date:1/2/2003 Extraction of Building Permit Data for
To: 12/1/2002 Census Bureau ~xpt~'e-o-~
From: 12/31/2002
Type Type
Permit Number Name Address Impr Use Stories Units Valuation
I Total REP/RMF permits: l Total Valuation: $5,490 ]
BLD02-00824 JAMES E & KIMBERLY A H't 3224 WASHINGTON ST REP RSF 1 0 $7,269
ATTIC FIRE REPAIR
Total REP/RSF permits: 1 Total Valuation: $7,269
GRAND TOTALS: PERMITS: 50 VALUATION: $5,704,217
Date: 2-Jan-03
To: City Manager and City Council ~,,~.,,..~ ~
From: Dianna Furman, Customer Servici~ Mar~ger
Subj: Utility Discount Program Statistics - Fiscal Year FY 02 and FY03
All Water Total
Services Sewer Discount Water Tax Sewer Refuse Recycling Total
Month Discount Discount Accounts Discount Discount Discount Discount Discount Discounts
FY 02
Jul 116 84 200 835.52 41.99 760.56 658.05 224.70 2520.82
Aug 127 94 221 896.00 44.90 857.69 701.10 239.40 2739.09
Sept 128 93 221 1023.68 51.25 980.49 808.71 276.15 3140.28
136 107 243 1043.84 52.35 999.90 827.17 282.45 3205.71
Nov 136 113 249 1106.56 55.47 1060.23 836.38 285.60 3344.24
Dec 142 117 259 1151.36 57.77 1103.34 867.14 296.10 3475.71
Jan 147 122 269 1164.80 58.20 1116.29 879.45 300.30 3519.04
Feb 146 124 270 1216.32 61.09 1165.83 913.26 311.85 3668.35
Mar 148 122 270 1184.96 59.39 1135.68 879.45 300.30 3559.78
Apr 153 118 271 1205.12 60.32 1155.07 925.57 316.05 3662.13
May 154 126 280 1207.36 60.37 1157.23 943.72 322.55 3691.23
Jun 156 132 288 1254.82 62.91 1202.48 1049.62 360.77 3930.60
FY02
Totals 1689 1352 3241 $13,290.34 $666.01 $12,694.79 $10,289.62 $3,516.22 $40,456.98
FY 03
Jul 112 113 225 932.26 46.57 892.16 695.24 238.99 2,805.22
Aug 118 115 233 1,006.18 50.07 963.26 769.48 264.52 3,053.51
Sept 123 121 244 1,042.02 52.03 997.76 783.00 269.12 3,143.93
Oct 129 122 251 1,068.90 53.45 1,023.62 803.25 276.08 3,225.30
Nov 122 127 249 1,129.38 56.57 1,081.80 907.87 312.09 3,487.71
Dec 126 128 254 1,133.86 56.68 1,086.11 816.75 280.72 3,374.12
Jan 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00
Feb 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00
Mar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00
Apr 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00
May 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00
Jun 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00
FY03
Totals 730 726 1656 $6,312.60 $315.37 $6,044.71 $4,775.59 $1,641.52 $19,089.79
cc: Kevin O'Mally
Mari/Utili~/NewDiscountMonthlyFY03.xls
MINUTES PRELIMINARY/DRAFT
HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ~
THURSDAY, DECEMBER 19, 2002 -6:30 PM
I IP13 I
CIVIC CENTER-LOBBY CONFERENCE ROOM
Members Present: Jerry Anthony, Lori Bears, Amy Correia, Mark Edwards,
Matthew Hayek, Rick House, Jayne Sandier
Members Absent: Morgan Hoosman, John Deeth
City Council Members Present: None
Staff Present: Tracy Hightshoe, Stephen Long
Others Present: Jesse Burns
Call to Order
Amy Correia called meeting to order at 6:30 PM.
Approval Of The November 21, 2002 Minutes
Motion: Bears moved that the minutes of November 21, 2002 be approved as submitted.
Hayek seconded the motion. All in favor, motion passed 6-0. (Sandier not yet present)
Public/Member Discussion of Items Not on the Agenda
None
Monitoring Reports
Hannah's Blessing - Daycare Expansion (Hoosman) - Hoosman not present. Staff reported that
the project is scheduled to open February 1, 2003. There is a minor shortage of funds. The
bank will secure a loan for the needed $10,000 of remaining repairs when a business plan is
completed. All that is left to do is interior carpet installation and construction of a backyard
fence. Neighbors got together and built a retaining wall. A director has been hired and they are
maintaining a waiting list for the daycare.
EHP- Shelter Coordinator (Deeth) - Deeth not present. Staff reported that funds were used for
the Shelter Coordinator position to provide case management, intake and referral for homeless
and near homeless persons and families. EHP has been spending the award in equal monthly
installments. EHP will change their name effective January 1, 2003 to the Iowa City Shelter
House. AI~ committee members will also be on the mailing list for their biannual newsletter.
City of Iowa City-Housing Rehabilitation (Edwards) - No information on housing rehab but is
reporting information on the Neighborhood Center at Broadway. The landscaping project is
done; it looks great and corrected an erosion issue. They also removed a fence that had been a
safety concern with neighbors and police. A new chain link fence will be constructed and new
playground equipment will be installed.
Garden Prairie LP-Affordable Rental Units (Correia) - Correia reported they have closed on
enough lots for14 units, and all but $20,000 to $ 25,000 has been spent. There is an application
in for State Home Funds and Low Income Housing Tax credits; there will be more information in
March.
Greater Iowa City Housing Fellowship- Affordable Rental Units (Anthony) - Anthony was unable
to get specific information regarding this FY02 project, but received information about the rehab
and acquisition project. Commission members had questions regarding GICHF's current
2
projects. Requested an update on all funds unexpended. Members requested information on
Longfellow Manor and the use of FY02 and FY04 funds and how that affects prior awards.
Correia handed out a memo concerning Housing Criteria for CDBG/HOME funded Projects from
Steve Nasby and also a memo from City Manager for information regarding staff's intention to
apply for CDBG Funding for code enforcement for FY04. A memo by Council Member Kanner
concerning code enforcement was also handed out.
Sandier Arrives.
OLD BUSINESS
Recaptured Funds Policy
Correia opened informal discussion of the draft policy. There was discussion among all
committee members concerning several variables. Commission members did not want to single
out LIHTC applicants from other projects who rely on outside sources of funding to make their
projects viable. Members recommended that all projects that rely on other required sources of
funding be treated equally under this new policy.
As CDBG funds must be spent on a timely basis (less than a year for many projects), but HOME
allows a five year period before funds must be spent, the commission recommended having two
separate requirements. This would recognize the complexities involved in housing construction.
The commission also discussed how many times an applicant can apply for required, other
sources of funds before the recapture of local funds. The Commission decided that they did not
want to automatically recapture funds if the first round of outside funding failed. Will discuss this
matter at the next meeting. Commission members wanted the flexibility of evaluating the project
and determining if the project's success would be greater in the next subsequent funding round
before automatic recapture.
Correia asked Hightshoe to take the committee's thoughts and comments and bring a revised
policy back in January for review.
Correia had a question about the City Manager's memo. The 10% increase in the number of
rental units from 1990 to 2000, is there a breakdown of what the rental units rent for? I.e.: what
is the percentage of those that rent for fair market rate? Hightshoe didn't believe the City had
this information.
Hayek questioned the proposed $4.00 inspection fee; what is the current fee and how large is
the Housing Inspection Office currently? 4 employees currently staff the office. He noted the
amount doesn't seem that large except when it is applied to large property owners and thus can
become a burden and cost will be passed down to renters.
ADJOURNMENT
MOTION: House moved to adjourn meeting. Edwards seconded motion. Motion passed 7-0.
Meeting adjourned at 7:45PM.
Shared\pcdLm/nutesLhcdc\ 12-19-02.doc
MINUTES ~
IOWA CITY HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION DRAFT/PRELIMINARY
EMMA HARVAT HALL
(City Council Chambers)
410 E. Washington St.
December 17, 2002
MEMBERS PRESENT: Lisa Beckmann, Paul Retish, Lucia Page, Jan Warren, Charles Major, Nick
Klenske, Keri Neblett, Bob Peffer, Rick Spooner
MEMBERS ABSENT: None
STAFF MEMBERS: Heather Shank
1. CALL TO ORDER: Meeting called to order at 7:00 p.m.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Beckmann asked for approval of or any changes in the minutes from the
November 26th meeting. Changes will be on the second page, first paragraph. Peffer should be
changed to Page with regard to a comment on display setups. Under New Commissioners the name
Billy should read Billie. Motion to approve amended minutes by Warren and seconded by Neblett.
Motion: Minutes unanimously approved.
3. RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL: None
**Billie Townsend introduced herself to Commission members. Townsend works at the University of
Iowa, College of Liberal Arts and Sciences in the office of the Dean. Commissioners also introduced
themselves to her.
4. Consider a Motion to Adjourn to Closed Session based on §21.5(1)(a) of the Code of Iowa to
review or discuss records which are require or authorized by state or federal law to be kept
confidential and pursuant to Chapter 216 of the Code of Iowa and §2-2-4 of the Iowa City
Municipal Code which requires that complaints of discrimination, reports of investigation,
statements and other documents or records obtained in the investigations, shall be closed
records unless the Human Rights Ordinance specifically permits disclosure. Motion made by
Warren and seconded by Page. Motion passed unanimously by role call.
5. Consider a motion to take no further action in case #14-14-0106 and close the file: Motion made
by Neblett to reluctantly take no fudher action in this case. Seconded by Page. Motion passed 7-2
vote. Peffer and Retish opposed.
6. NEW BUSINESS:
Awards and Certificates for persons leaving the Commission: A certificate was given to Page and
plaques were given to Major and Warren recognizing their effort on the Commission. Beckmann
expressed thanks for all their hard work.
Co-sponsorship of Arabian Human Rights Day: Information regarding this event is in the packet.
Shank was contacted by AsmaTaha regarding this event. She asked whether the Commission was
interested in co-sponsoring this annual event celebrating the life of her father who was killed by the
Sudanese government for his more liberal views of Islam. The Arabian Human Rights Day will take
place on January 18th in the Wayne Ritchey Ball Room. Motion to co-sponsor this event made by
Retish, seconded by Neblett. Motion passed unanimously.
Annual MLK Service-January 19th at 7:00 p.m. at Zion Lutheran Church: Shank spoke highly of
past services and she wanted the Commission to be aware of this great event that was in previous
years was held at Old Brick.
Cultural Diversity Festival-February 23rd: Beckmann asked what role we are to play in the festival.
Shank stated that the Commission usually provides information. While Shank called the organizers and
asked for a booth she has not heard back from them as of today. Beckmann would like to wait till the
January meeting before asking for volunteers to staff the booth for this event. There was a brief
discussion about possible means of attracting people to the Human Rights table.
MLK Celebration: Shank stated that she had talked with Jessie Villalobos and the National Conference
for Community & Justice (NCC J) will have a Martin Luther King celebration in Iowa City this year.
Villalobos would like to have the entire Iowa City community involved, including the Commission.
Shank asked whether the Commission wanted to co-sponsor this event. Tim Wise is the keynote
speaker. The affirmative action office is putting together the reception that will be held at the Union.
This does not necessarily require work other than attending. Motion made by Peffer to co-sponsor the
MLK Celebration and seconded by ??. Motion passed unanimously.
Latino/a Conference: Shank informed the Commission of the upcoming conference and announced
that there will be a planning meeting on January 27~h if anyone would like to attend. Beckmann stated
that she felt Commissioners might want to attend planning meetings closer to the event. Her opinion
was based on her understanding that not much was accomplished in the early planning meetings last
year. Warren suggested a sub-committee be involved in the early planning to save Shank some time.
Retish indicated that he did not know what the Commission's role would be in this and that maybe
we're being pretentious and should wait and see if their needs fit our skills. Neblett stated that the
Commission was asked to attend the planning meeting though. Warren indicated that she was getting
the impression that the Commission was trying to distance itself until it is specifically told of the plans
for the event. Beckmann stated that Warren misinterpreted her statement and at no time was there a
suggestion that the Commission not be involved in this event or wanted to distance itself. Beckmann
agreed with Warren that the Commission should be involved in reaching out to the Latino population.
Warren continued that she felt it would be a good idea if someone attended the early planning meeting.
Warren also acknowledged that she will be off the Commission but she thought another Commissioner
might be able to go. Beckmann asked whether someone would be interested in attending the planning
meeting. There were no volunteers. Since there was no response Shank will follow-up with more
information and send out an email to Beckmann & Retish later. Beckmann stated that the Commission
should be sponsoring this. Peffer said that he would know more about his schedule closer to the
meeting.
Comments on Case Readings: Retish asked for a meeting with the lawyers in Shank's office to
discuss the process the Human Rights Office goes through in its decision making, recommendations,
case law and authority it follows. Retish indicated that 99 times out of 100 he agrees with the lawyer's
recommendation, although he may not like it. He is frustrated at times and Shank indicated that she is
as well. He thought it might be helpful if the Commission had a chance to say if they're dissatisfied and
be able to ask what the Commissions options might be as Commission members. Shank stated the
Commission could educate. Shank agreed that she too is frustrated over cases. As she has
mentioned many times over the last few months disability law especially as it relates to employment is
discouraging because it is becoming more and more difficult under the law to prove that a person has a
disability. In addition, the Supreme Court is narrowing the effect of the federal statutes. Shank
stressed that this did not mean she was giving up. She is doing a great deal of education to encourage
people to see how important it is to treat every person with respect. Page asked what happens if two
out of three Commissioners read a case and decide one way and the third Commissioner disagrees.
Shank stated that the majority decision would stand. She further stated that if the two disagree with the
attorney's probable cause determination, then the Commission's decision without the backing of the
City Attorney. However, Shank emphasized that the Commissioners can disagree with the attorneys
and tell them this, but that will not necessarily change the opinion of the City Attorney's office. Warren
asked if the Commission's comments, concerns or disagreements are noted anywhere in the case
records so that the complainant knows that the Commission did not agree with the outcome of the
decision.. Beckmann stated that there is a difference between the City Attorney's opinion and how it
matches up with case law. Warren understood this but she wanted to know whether the complainant
and respondent would be made aware of the Commission's disagreement with the
opinions/recommendations of the attorneys. Shank responded that this type of situation had never
arisen. Retish asked whether a public hearing could take place if the Commission agreed that it should
even though the City Attorneys and the Human Rights office did not think the case was litigation
worthy? He believes that the sense of having a public hearing, the sharing of the information in the
public domain, is an outcome unto itself. Retish further stated the public hearing would be pursued
even though it would lose. Shank explained that pursuing a case, knowing it could not be supported
under the law as it currently stands could result in litigation against the City. Retish responded that the
Commission could lose the case and win the war. Page inquired as to what would happen if all three
Commissioners on a team found one way and the attorneys disagreed? Shank said she would discuss
it with the city attorney's office to see how it would work out. Shank reiterated that that situation has
never occurred. Beckmann asked if it isn't just "bad law" that two or three lay people can make a
decision that counters what trained educated professionals are hired to do. She thinks it's just "bad
law." Shank stated that when civil rights law were initially passed, the legislature envisioned lay people
conducting mediations of disagreements or small investigations. It was the hope of the lawmakers that
discrimination could be resolved through conversations. There was no real enforcement of the law
and/or damages until Richard Nixon signed the law that allowed for court intervention. Nixon's efforts
took place in 1973 and that is when the concept of employment law and the involvement of lawyers. It
was not the intent of the original drafters of the law to involve lawyers. Spooner said that he feels he
gets conflicting information from the lawyers regarding the cases. He asked exactly what the
Commission was suppose to be doing when it made a decision in a case. Shank asked what
inconsistencies he believed had been communicated. Spooner asked if the Commission was trying to
determine a possibility of probable cause or is it the idea of a probability of probable cause. He stated
that he has used different standards and he wants to be consistent when he looks at a case, or what is
it that I'm exactly trying to find. Shank stated that the Commission needed to look at the elements and
the facts of the case and ask whether it is more likely than not that discrimination occurred. Shank
indicated that she would ask the City Attorney to attend the next meeting to help explain the issues.
Shank is anxious to have all of the Commissioners' questions answered. Retish concluded that it was
apparent that there was a recent disagreement of opinion on a case. He believes there is a problem
between the lawyers and the Commission. He suggested that we ALL get together and have the
Human Rights office explain to the Commission exactly how the process works and how our jobs are
intertwined. He further stated that he wants to be able to help the complainant even if the law or
decision goes against them, but he's not sure how to go about it. Shank reminded Retish that
complainants that do not prevail in the administrative process have the option to take their case to
court. Retish added that a lot of people would not go that route, as they don't have faith in the legal
system. Retish said that the bottom line is that they (the complainants) came here for satisfaction.
Shank stated that the HR office does not represent either party to a case, as the staff employees are
neutral investigators. She further added that not every case involves discrimination. Spooner stated
that he feels frustrated but he understands that although it may seem unfair at times, he is glad that the
law is in place. Beckmann suggested that maybe a special meeting should be scheduled with the
attorneys. Retish asked about a suggestion Shank raised at an earlier meeting regarding skits
depicting discriminatory and nondiscriminatory scenarios to assist in the training of the Commission.
Shank indicated that Pittman has resigned to spend more time at home so the off~ce is very busy right
now. Retish stated that he would wait to meet with the Human Rights office staff.
7. OLD BUSINESS:
Job Fair Progress- Retish talked about a meeting he attended at the Workforce Development Center
representing the Education Committee. The Committee decided to break up into three sub-
committees: (1) Employer Group, (2) Grant Opportunities, (3) Job Skills. Shank attended the job skills
meeting. It is the intent of this group to put together tables at the Eastdale Mall with volunteers to assist
interested people in filling out applications, draft resumes, how to interview, write a cover letter etc. In
addition, the group wants to educate employers and employees on how cultural differences may fit into
the interview process. The final date for the Job Fair has not yet been determined, but on the 14th of
January there will be a meeting between the employer group and the skills group to update each other
on their progress. Retish said that the Job Force has started a program where they will have luncheon
meetings for employers and offer some training. He hopes that we can eventually work with both sides,
but we have started with employers. Shank urged Commission members to get involved since the
Commission is a co-sponsor and it would be terrific if the Commission members worked with
community members on projects like these. Beckmann asked Shank to put this issue on the agenda
next month and she would ask for volunteers to work at that time.
Sexual Orientation: Beckmann informed the Commission that she drafted the letter that was
discussed at the last meeting encouraging other Commissions to add sexual orientation to their
ordinances. The letter will be sent out December 18~h and there is a February 1s* deadline for
responses.
Shop with a Cop: Shank reported that she met with Matt Johnson and he told her that the Police
Department uses the word holiday as opposed to Christmas in the advertisements. He further stated
that the people that signed up for the program were from different religions and cultures. Shank said
that the State Police Association organized the Shop with a Cop program. Retish suggested the actual
shopping day be changed to a time other than Christmas. Beckmann asked if anyone would like to
assist Retish in working on this issue. Retish said that he would speak with a community relation's
police officer and report back.
Breakfast surveys: Warren talked about the survey data and indicated that Major's term was up and
he was unable to finish the project. Warren asked whether the survey was going to be modified before
Diversity Day and if so, who is going to do it? Major admitted that he did not finish the analysis but he
would give the materials to Beckmann. Beckmann created a spreadsheet to enter the data and she
asked for assistance in entering the date. Retish mentioned a person at ACT that could possibly be of
help.
HR Breakfast: Memo from Phil Jones. Beckmann would like this item tabled until the next meeting.
Warren noted that the memo isn't really from Phil Jones. Jones, Warren noted, just sent the memo to
Retish.
8. REPORTS OF COMMISSIONERS:
Neblett spoke of a magazine that she has called "Diversity Ink. Com" and she is leaving it with Shank if
anyone is interested in looking at it.
Major said that he has enjoyed being on the Commission for the past five years. He is disappointed
that more ordinance changes weren't made, but perhaps in the future. He also stated that he was
disappointed that Senator Grassley did not speak up publicly and make his position clear regarding
how he stood on Trent Lott's comments.
Warren stated that she too has enjoyed her time on the Commission and the many opportunities it has
given her and the Commission does important work in the community.
Page stated that she has enjoyed her time on the Commission and feels that she gained a lot more that
she has put in.
Retish no report
Beckmann no report
Klenske no repod
Spooner no report
Peffer no report
9. STATUS OF CASES:
Shank reports that there are cases down in legal, and several cases are almost finished. Warren asked
if anything would happen with the case she just finished reading between now and the end of her term.
Shank stated that she should know something soon. Shank also stated that Pittman's last day is
January 29 and Shank wilt miss her.
'10. ADJOURNMENT:
Motion made by Peffer to adjourn, seconded by Klenske. Meeting adjourned at 8:53 p.m.
Marian Karr r~
From: Patti Santangelo [psantang@hotmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, January 08, 2003 10:08 PM
To: council@iowa-city,org; nbeuter@ci,coralville.ia.us; vsa@icccvb,org; jclhcb@meccaia.com;
carolt@inav, net; adrian@isc-unlimited,com; brian-loring@ncjc.org; cher-weaver@uiowa,edu;
cdeprosse@earthlink.net
Cc: sstutsma@co.johnson.ia.us; rbignellic@iowacity.gannett.com; newsroom@press-citizen.com;
joe@joebolkcom.org; Ernie_Lehman@iowa-city.org; dlundell@ci.coralville.ia.us;
cindy.chapman@gazettecommunications.com; psantang@hotmail.com
Subject: Good Food - Good Music
Good Food - Good Music
A Soup Supper followed by a Gospel Music Concert will be held at First
Christian Church (900 Lincolnshire Place, Coralville, IA) this Saturday,
Jan. 11. Homemade chili, vegetable beef and vegetarian vegetable soups will
be served from 4:30 p.m. until 7:00 p.m. followed by a concert of familiar
gospel music which will be presented jointly by the UIHC "Heartbeats" chorus
and the FCC "Disciple Strings" at 7:30 p.m. Ail are invited to enjoy an
evening of family entertainment.
Soup plus drinks and dessert will be served in the lower level Community
Room. Prices are $6 for adults, $2.50 for children aged 6-10, and children
5 and under are free. A nursery will be provided during the concert.
This is the first concert to be presented in the new building! I have
tickets if you are interested.
They will also be available at the door.
Patti Santangelo
338-5550
621-0289 (cell)
Donate to charity for free
http://www.quickdonations.com/
Help support a favorite cause at
http://http://www.iGive.com/html/refer.cfm?memberid=6671&causeid=836
Patti Santangelo
psantang@hotmail.com