HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022-01-12 TranscriptionPage 1
Council Present:
Staff Present:
Alter, Bergus, Harmsen, Taylor, Teague, Thomas, Weiner
Fruin, Jones, Kilburg, Fruehling, Knoche, Havel, Sovers, Clark,
Davies, Fleagle, Hightshoe, Ralston, Grier, Liston, Seydell-
Johnson, Nagle-Gamm, Tharp, Carman, Morris, DeLoach
FY2022-2026 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM (CIP)
Teague: Uh, welcome everyone to the City of Iowa City work session, continuing our
budget discussion. And the first item is gonna be, uh, CIP. And I'm gonna
invite Jason Havel, who is our City Engineer, up to the mic to get us started
or, yeah, right there. Right.
Knoche: Uh, Mr. Mayor, Council, good afternoon. Uh, I'm Ron Knoche, your Public
Works Director.
Teague: Great.
Knoche: Uh, today we're happy to present the proposed 2023 to 2026 Iowa City
Capital Improvements Plan. Uh, we'll use the ESRI storybook platform for the
presentation. Uh, I'd like to thank the Engineering Division, in particular
Killian Laughead for producing the final presentation. Uh, the capital
improvements fund on can be found in the proposed budget document
starting on page 513. Uh, today we have five objectives. Uh, first Nicole
Davies will go over the plan development process and the fund summary. Uh,
second, staff will discuss the ongoing projects. Uh, there are 12 major
projects that are not included, uh, in the CIP, so these are projects that have
been previously funded, but don't currently show up in the program. Uh,
third, staff will discuss the 18 annual projects in the CIP, uh, then staff will
discuss 124 projects that are identified in the five-year program. Uh, to try to
save some time in the presentation, uh, we've attempted to condense
projects, uh, that are similar in nature or at the same facility. Uh, with this
being the case, the project will not necessarily follow the order that are in the
proposed budget document. Uh, the final objective staff will discuss is
projects considered to be on the radar. Uh, these are projects that are on the
unfunded list, uh, but staff believe Council should be aware of. Uh, we
appreciate the opportunity to present the proposed program, and with that,
I'll turn it over to Nicole.
Davies: All right. So, I'm Nicole Davies, the interim Finance Director, and current
Assistant Finance Director. So, I'm just gonna go over a brief overview. Um,
this first slide, just showing kind of the CIP calendar and how it all comes
together, um, you know, forms are sent out to the departments in early
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 2
September. This gives them a chance to one, um, update or amend any
projects that are already on the current CIP plan, and then two, to add or
request any new projects to be added. Um, so they have a few weeks to work
on those, turn them in to the Finance Department, um, then the Finance
Department produces a preliminary report, um, then we pull together a, a
committee review to go through the projects, um, any amendments, produce
that preliminary report. And then, uh, the Finance Department will go back,
make a few changes, and then the committee, uh, meets again in October, the
end of October to, uh, take another last look at that, make any final changes
that they want. Um, and then the Finance Department will put together that
final CIP report the end of November, which is about the time the operating
budget is also getting wrapped up. And then, um, obviously this came out to
you the same time that the operating budget did on, um, December 17th. The
next slide just kind of shows the breakdown, um, spending by division. So,
you can see Streets is, uh, where most of our CIP dollars is spent, which, I
can't read that number from there, but it's about $7- or about $80 million
that's on Streets. There's a few large projects in there. Uh, we have the Dodge
Street reconstruction, which is about $15.8 million, um, the Taft Avenue
reconstruction, which is another $11 million, and then just the annual
pavement rehab over those five years. CIP plan is about $10 and a half
million. Um, the next biggest is Wastewater, um, and that's about $32
million, $32.8 million, and more than a third of that is on the digester
complex rehab, that's about $13 million, and again, they'll be going into
greater detail on these projects, um, here in a little bit. Um, then the next one,
the Transit Facility, or the Transit, which is, um, a little over $20 million, but
$20 million of that is for the Transit Facility itself. Um, and then same thing
with the Equipment. It's about $12.8 and about $12 million of that is for an
Equipment Facility. So then going to the next slide, which is kind of where,
um, the sources that we use to fund the CIP program. Again, the biggest
portion of that is the, um, GO bonds, um, a little over $60 million, um, and
that's usually used primarily for Streets and Parks projects, is where most of
the GO bond funding goes. Um, we also have a large portion of revenue
bonds, which is about $17.7 million, um, and again, $13 million of that is for
the digester rehab for wastewater, um, and then we also have a lot of grant
funding, um, between the federal grants and the other state grants is almost
$40 million, um, and a big piece of that, is $15 million for the Transit Facility.
Um, the rest of the grants is usually again for Streets and the Airport. And
then the next slide just kind of breaks down the yearly expenditures across
the five years. Um, as you can see, we've got a lot of kind of big projects
coming up in the next couple years. They're ones that I've kind of already
briefly mentioned in '23, that's where you're gonna see the, um, $13 million
that's for the digester complex rehab. Um, '24, that's the $20 million for the
Transit Facility and $11 million for the Equipment Facility. And then in '25,
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 3
that's where the $15.8 million for the Dodge Street reconstruction is. And so
now I will turn it back over to Jason to start going through the projects.
Havel: All right, thanks, Nicole. Uh, so we'll start things off with the ongoing projects.
So as Ron mentioned, these are ones that don't show up in your current five-
year plan because they were funded previously. So, they are projects that are,
are currently underway. One thing I would note that is this is not a, a
complete list, so there are other projects that are still being completed, but
this is kind of a list of our, our larger ongoing projects. So, first thing, first, uh,
our 20 whoops, the 2021 asphalt resurfacing product, so this is the one that
we started last year. The remaining work here will be an overlay of Rohret
Road from Mormon Trek Boulevard to essentially the Highway 218 bridge,
um, also included in that will be overlay of a few City facility parking lots, the,
the Robert A. Lee Rec Center lot, as well as the Parks maintenance shop lot as
well, and then some other smaller sites would be included as well. The
Idyllwild Storm Water Drainage Diversion, so this will be a, a storm water
diversion up near the Idyllwild development, and what this does is, basically,
we'll divert, uh, runoff from upstream during larger events. This is one that
we're looking at starting construction this spring, uh, should hopefully have
construction completed this summer. The Riverside Drive pedestrian path,
uh, for those of you that have been around for a little while, probably
remember this is, was originally going to be a pedestrian tunnel that would
be going through the railroad embankment. Uh, we had gone through, uh, a
lot of the design of that project, um, late in that process, the railroad came
back and said that they had significant safety concerns and would not allow
for the, the tunnel to proceed. So, we've kind of regrouped a little bit, worked
with the DOT, and the current plan is to look at narrowing up Riverside
Drive, narrowing up travel lanes there a little bit, and we should be able to
get enough space in there to, uh, at least get a sidewalk connection on the
west side of Riverside Drive that would then provide for a continuous
sidewalk from Benton Street to Myrtle Avenue on the west side of Riverside
Drive. American Legion Road reconstruction, so this is one that started last
year, Phase 1 has been completed, so this will be, uh, Phase 2, and this will be
basically finishing the, the construction of the east end of the project. As a
reminder, this one took American Legion Road from a rural section to an
urban section, so curb and gutter, storm sewer, uh, includes bike lanes and,
uh, sidewalks as well. First Avenue/Scott Boulevard intersection
improvements, this is one that we actually just bid recently, so you should be
seeing, uh, an item on your next agenda to award this project. This will be
constructing a roundabout at the First Avenue and Scott Boulevard
intersection with construction planned to start this spring, and completion
this summer. Second Avenue bridge replacement, this is another one looking
at construction starting this spring, so this is a, a bridge on Second Avenue
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 4
over Ralston Creek, essentially replacing the existing bridge with a new
bridge.
Teague: I have a question.
Havel: Yeah.
Teague: The, the one previous, you said First Avenue and Scott Boulevard. I'm a little
confused with that.
Havel: Yep. So that is currently is a four-way stop, and so that will be converted to a
roundabout.
Teague: Okay.
Fruin: That's uh, most recognizable by the ACT entrance. Yep, there.
Teague: All right. I didn't make the conversion up.
Fruin: Yeah. The roads kind of twist and turn over there.
Teague: Okay. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you.
Havel: Melrose Avenue improvements, this project started last spring, um, they
were able to complete a lot of the, uh, drainage culverts, grading, the water
main was extended out to the Landfill, um, so this spring they'll begin the
paving improvements, with that being the majority of work remaining, it
would be the paving, and then the final grading. Benton Street rehabilitation,
this one will be a crack sealing project with an over, asphalt overlay, so
there'll be, uh, an overlaid street from Mormon Trek Boulevard to just west
of Greenwood. As part of that, well also narrow up the travel lanes and, and
re -stripe it to include, uh, actual bike lanes on that facility, also include some
water main work, ADA curb ramps, that kind of stuff as part of the product as
well. Orchard Street reconstruction, this is one that a lot of the work was
completed last fall. They have one section remaining, basically between
Douglas Street and Highway 1, so there will be a portion where, uh, our
timeframe where that one will be, that road will be closed, they'll be doing
some storm sewer work and finishing up the, the reconstruction of that
street. Foster Road elevation, so this is one where we're looking at a, a
functional design for elevating Foster Road, kind of looking at what it would
take to, to have a, a construction project to elevate Foster Road to be more
resilient when it comes to flooding, uh, the main goal here being secondary
access or, or more resilient access, to the, the Peninsula Neighborhood during
flood events. Dill Street water main replacement, this is, uh, over just west or
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 5
east of Rocky Shore Drive. This is a section where we've had, uh, a number of
main breaks, so looking at replacing water main in this section, we will also
be looking to include sidewalk basically between Black Spring Circle Park
and Teeters, um, as, uh, a section of sidewalk infill as well. Go ahead.
Seydell-Johnson: And I would just mention the one, uh, with Black Streams, Spring
Circle Park, that was one of the ADA improvements asked for by the Parks
Master Plan too. So that is kind of a double, does double duty there.
Pedestrian Mall playground replacement, the playground has been ordered,
uh, but due to pandemic -related delays, we're still waiting on it from the
manufacturer. Uh, we hope to have it by the end of May and have installation
early summer. The same is actually true for Glendale Park on both the shelter
and the smaller playground. There are different manufacturers, but all of
them are running behind, um, because of pandemic delays right now.
Havel: So, we'll move on to annual projects.
Seydell-Johnson: Okay, we'll start with City Hall projects, as you know, an aging
building that we've talked about, um, in a number of other conversations.
Coming up next would be the larger roof replacement on the building, um,
and then some renovations to the restrooms, employee fitness area in the
future years, we've held out on the rest, um, for some of the other facility
planning that's happening right now. Parks annual improvements, this is our
small projects fund throughout the parks. A lot of the park signage that has
been replaced recently, partner projects with organizations, um,
scoreboards, those kind of small things come out of this project. Nothing
specifically called out for the next year. We, uh, we wait until we hear from
our neighborhood groups and, and work on it as we go on that one. Park
annual ADA accessibility improvements, this follows the Park Master Plan of
2016, where we talk about increasing accessibility to the parks and the
features like playgrounds and shelters within the parks. Um, next up, Oak
Grove, I believe we also have Hunters Run and a few others that are not too
far down the line, um. Most of these are getting to be pretty small additions
as we have been, uh, making our way through all of the parks on major
renovations. Intracity bike trails is smaller trail segments or repairs and
maintenance that are needed to be done, um, on the trails each year. Annual
rec center improvements, this does call out some projects at Robert A. Lee.
We are currently on hold with this though, as we wait on the results of our
Recreation Facilities and Master Plan, um, to see if there's any other different
programming needs or different priorities that come out of the public input
on that plan. Um, and we will adjust this as needed after that point.
Alter: May I ask, um, are there two separate fund streams since, for this, and then
also the special project that with the, the, um, committee and looking for the
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 6
public input, because I'm assuming that may be more substantial in terms of
recommendations, and so.
Seydell-Johnson: So, the, the Rec Facility and Master Plan is looking at really long
term, um, lists of things. So, the funding stream would be through CIP, as
you'll see there's several different projects called out for both of the rec
centers and the aquatic facilities, um, and then I'm sure that the list that we'll
get from the Master Plan will be much larger than any of the funding streams
that are currently, currently available. So, we'll have that discussion when we
have that, that list. Climate Action Facility improvements. This is throughout
all the City facilities, but things like replacing windows, upgrading HVAC
systems, looking at possible solar installations, things that can help lower
greenhouse gas emissions and become more, um, efficient in our building
operations. Contracted tree improvement, so on Saturday, we talked about a
thousand trees planted this last year, um, we are really greening the skyline
of Iowa City right now. Last year, this paid for, um, the Mackinaw
neighborhood, which is north of Foster Road, and then a lot of trees along
Scott Boulevard, which many of them have been planted within the last three
or four weeks. So, a lot of trees from last year. Now, next year, we're looking
at trees along Kennedy Parkway on the very west side of Iowa City, we have
about 40 -plus trees planned to go there, 370 trees in the South District, along
the Langenberg neighborhood, and then a smaller project, about 87 trees
along Prairie du Chien on the north side, so we will continue that tree
planting, uh, with this project.
Havel: Continuing on with the Bicycle Master Plan implementation, so this is a fund
that has money available every year to continue implementing, uh, projects
that were included in the Bicycle Master Plan, this fund would be used for
those improvements that aren't already included as part of another project.
Annual storm water improvements, this is a fund that allows for annual
money to, uh, make improvements to the storm water infrastructure, that
could be addressing sinkholes similar to what's shown here in the picture, it
could be replacing or repairing damage intakes or, or pipe or whatever it
might be, uh, related to storm water. Annual traffic signal projects, this is a, a
fund that is used for, uh, a variety of things related to traffic signals, it could
be, uh, installing a new traffic signal at a location, it could be replacing, uh,
traffic signal or traffic signal components. Um, it is also used to install pan tilt,
zoom cameras at the various intersections. So, we've been working our way
through the existing signals and installing those cameras, um, at signals that
don't currently have them. Traffic calming, so this is the fund that would, uh,
basically be used for construction of speed humps or other traffic calming
measures that are approved through the neighborhood process, so if a
neighborhood goes through and, and completes the process and it's
approved, then this is the fund that would be used for construction. Curb
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 7
ramp and ADA, every year we go through and develop a project to, uh, install
new or, or updated curb ramps at various locations throughout the city,
typically we'll focus on areas where we receive complaints or requests, um,
with the highest priority being locations that currently don't have any ramps
at all, and then we kind of work our way through other ones that just are not
ADA -compliant. Annual pavement rehabilitation, uh, the big-ticket item here
a lot of years is the asphalt overlay program. Uh, it does also include other
maintenance types, it could be chip seal, it could be PCC patching, uh, crack
sealing, that kind of stuff, uh, anything to do with pavement management.
Underground electrical facilities, so this is an account that's used for, uh,
those locations where we have typically MidAmerican, uh, electrical utility
that would relocate their facilities from overhead to underground. In the
past, it's been a, a couple of different processes that we've used, um, there's
been times where we would pay essentially the upcharge from relocating to
another aerial location to relocating underground, so whatever that
difference in cost is we would cover that to have them move their lines
underground. Um, we've also had some instances recently where if we would
provide them with a dedicated route or an easement area, that they would
cover the cost of putting those underground. So, we use this account to take
care, take advantage of those opportunities. Annual bridge maintenance and
repair, the big-ticket item here is every other year we go through and inspect
all of our bridges, um, the maintenance recommendations that come out of
those are also funded from this account. Um, there are times where if need
be, this can also help fund the bridge replacements that, the bridge
replacement projects that we've been doing, but primarily it's more on the,
the smaller maintenance projects. Annual sewer main replacement, so this is
for replacing damaged, uh, sanitary sewer, so it typically is spot repairs of
either sanitary sewer pipe or manholes. It does also include our maintenance
projects, so it would be sanitary sewer lining, manhole lining, and other
related work. Parking Facility restoration and repair, again, this is an annual
project that we've worked with consultants to develop a, a multi-year plan
for recommended, uh, maintenance work at our parking facilities, and so this
is what is used to follow up on not only that design, but also construction of
those, repairs. The Transit Interchange and bus stop improvements, so this is
a, a newer annual project that was a result of the recent Transit study, looks
at funding improvements to not only the, the Transit Interchange downtown,
but also at, uh, bus stop facilities, uh, throughout the city. And with that, we
will move on to Airport projects. So, I'll turn it over to Mike.
Tharp: Oh, good afternoon. Again, I'm Mike Tharp, I'm the Airport Manager. Um, the
Airport CIP uh, program is actually funded from three different areas. We
have, uh, federal -level money from the, uh, Federal, Federal Aviation
Administration. Whenever they participate in a project, they, they cover 90%
of the share. We have the Iowa DOT, which, uh, at the state level also has
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 8
programs for both, uh, Airport improvement program work and vertical
infrastructure work. Their shares are anywhere from 70 to 85% of the
project, depending on the particular project. And then we also receive from
the General Fund a hundred thousand dollars, which we use for our grant
matching. With that our projects, um, 2022 is gonna be an active year, but
first up is our Airport parking lot expansion. With the increase of activity of
the Airport, uh, parking is occasionally an issue, um, uh, more often than not
whether we have people using our conference room, uh, just active charter,
uh, days where folks have been using the Airport, go out for business trips,
whatever, um, and then especially on game days where we get a lot of traffic.
Uh, Engineering is, is going to help us, uh, carve out some spots around our
Beacon Circle and add about 20, 22, uh, parking spots, and that'll help
alleviate some of those issues. Hangar A door replacement, um, we have one
building that was built in, uh, somewhere in the 1950s. Uh, this building
operates, their doors operate on a, a chain and counterweight pulley system,
um, system works great, but it's also extremely dangerous, uh, because it's a
gravity system. So, if anybody loses control of, of, uh, the door, that's hold, uh,
the chain that's holding that door, uh, that door will slam down. Uh, we have
state money to re uh, replace about half of the building doors at the moment,
and in a future project, we'll be looking to do the other half of the building.
Uh, Runway 7 environmental assessment, this is part of a, a whole list of
projects that are part of the 7/25 reclassification and a reconfiguration, uh,
program that we've been undertaking for the past few years. This one, uh,
looks at the Runway 7 end to add about 200 feet of pavement. Uh, the
objective there is to get the entire runway, um, uh, on that, uh, that line up to
5,000 feet of available takeoff and landing distance, and that's, uh, Runway,
uh, 7 extension, that's the physical work that would come after the
environmental assessment. Uh, this one is gonna be something that happens
this year. Uh, the 25 -threshold relocation. We have an 808 -foot displaced
threshold. So, what that means is where the pavement ends, the airplanes
have to land 800 foot, 800 feet further down their runway, and that becomes
the area that they can use for their, their landing calculations. This takes that
line and shifts it, uh, shifts it back towards Riverside Drive by about 700 feet.
Uh, similar situation occurs with the 12/30 threshold displacement and
relocation. Um, this actually came about also as part of our obstruction
mitigation project, so we didn't have to go quite as hard into the, uh,
northwest neighborhood for tree clearing, um, that was a project we've done
over the last couple of years, uh, to clean up our, uh, Airport approaches on
each of the runway ends. Apron expansion, uh, again, with the busy days,
increasing the traffic, we are finding we are running out of spots to put
airplanes, especially on game days, but, uh, that will add, um, additional
concrete for aircraft parking. Uh, 7/25 pavement repairs, much like the street
system, uh, runways need occasional tender maintenance. Uh, this is a crack
sealing and a light maintenance project to cover about half of the 7/25
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 9
runway and same thing with 12/30. Uh, just pacing down the line. South
Hangar development, this is something we're working with the state on, uh,
this is providing concrete infrastructure for future hangar development. Uh,
our goal here is to entice, uh, private hangar development, uh, um, with, uh,
individuals that can do that. And that's the Airport's program.
Havel: All right. If there's no questions, we'll move on to Fire.
Grier: Good afternoon. Fire Chief John Grier, uh, Fire Department, uh, programs.
First off, we have fire apparatus replacement program, just a little brief
overview. We do have a replacement program in place, which typically we,
have nine-year frontline, a seven-year reserve. Exceptions to that would be a
ladder truck or the, uh, Quint, which is, those have the 20- and 16 -year, uh,
timelines on those. So, coming up in 2024, we are planning to replace the
aerial Quint 2 that is based out of Fire Station #2, and the Scotty House,
which is the fire safety house that we have typically in the past used with
school children, as you might expect, that's kind of been on, on hold for a
little bit. And then in 2026, we have another fire pumper due for
replacement, and then 2027, just as a heads up, we have two other fire
pumpers, uh, due for replacement. Pro-, program number two is replacing
the, uh, slab reconstruction at Fire Station 1. We have a crack that has grown
over the years. We were able to patch it this year as a temporary fix, but we
will be working on that in 2020 and this year. Third up for us is replacing, uh,
carpet, tile and flooring at Fire Station 1 in 2024. I don't know the date that
we did this other carpet, but it's been a long time, as you can tell by the
pictures, it's coming up. So, look forward to that. And then our final one is, as
the City Manager talked about the other day, is design money for new Fire
Station #5 and relocation of Fire Station #3 in 2026. If you have any
questions about any of those things, I'd be happy to entertain 'ern.
Teague: Great. Awesome.
Grier: Thanks.
Havel: All right. We'll move on to Library next.
Carmen: Thanks. Um, I'm Ellsworth Carmen, Director of the Iowa City Public
Library. We've got two projects to talk briefly about, uh, today. The first is,
uh, a multiyear project to replace some of the carpeting and furnishings at
the Library, which would be original to the building, um, furniture and
carpet, uh, just, just time to get it done. Um, this project will not be new to
anyone in the room, it's, it's been in the works for, for a while. Um, and we've,
we've moved it around a little bit, I think, um, where we have it scheduled
now for '25 to '26, feels like a great, a great time to tackle it, um, and, and
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 10
make sure it gets done before we move into, um, into having to do sort of
piecemeal work to, to take care of the issues. Um, our second project is an
automatic material handler and sorter, um, this is a large piece of equipment
that automates some of the process work of incoming materials that are
being returned to the Library. The real, um, reason behind it is to increase
accuracy of materials coming back and get them back on the shelves faster
for a quicker turnaround, um, and less wait time for our patrons. Putting in
an AMH like this does not affect staffing levels one way or another. I think it's
important to make sure folks understand this won't be reducing our staffing
numbers. It's just a complement to our current model. Um, we are having
some issues with, uh, material supply as we talk to vendors for this project,
but I'll, I'll keep Geoff and the City abreast of, of how that's going as we move
forward. Any questions? Thank you.
Havel: Next up will be the Senior Center.
DeLoach: Good afternoon. I'm LaTasha DeLoach, Senior Center Coordinator. I'm just
gonna talk to you all briefly about our CIP um, for the Center. Um, so it's been
a little bit since we, um, uh, have done a full historical renovation on this
building, probably since it opened, and so this is exciting for us to be able to
have this opportunity to do some exterior and some interior work. Um, this,
um, one thing I was thinking is we need a dimmer for you all for, for the
screen, um, cause that could be really helpful. So, this is a, a major, large scale,
um, renovation on the exterior. We're working with consultants currently to
get a full, um, a closer look at some of the internal structure so that we can
really know the scope of that contract, um, just because one thing we've
learned at the Senior Center is once you open up the wall, there are
interesting things from a historical building, um, that, that are in there, and
so there are some things that we need to kind of figure out, so we know the
full scope of that so that we can get that going. We believe that'll probably be
a, probably a two-year process for us to get the exterior up to date. Um,
there's some immediate things that need to be fixed and then there's some
other things, um, later on that we'll get fixed, but we wanna make sure that
it's, um, kept up. It, it's probably a really powerful statement from one of our
consultants is one of the best ways to keep sustainability going in your
community is to renovate historical buildings versus tearing 'em down. And
so, we're definitely grateful for, uh, this building, even given during the
pandemic that we're able to use it in the way that we are. Um, looking at also
at the interior, the interior, we have a, uh, a really strong focus on some
sustainability efforts there, looking at our HVAC, how we can reduce our
carbon footprint as well as, uh, significantly changing our energy usage by
switching to LED lights, um, as you all know, we're still using kind of older
lights and we definitely wanna upgrade those, 'cause that will help us
significantly as we try to reduce, um, to reduce some of our, our, uh, imprint
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 11
here. Another is looking at, in our kitchen, our kitchen, it's pretty popular
discussion here in our building. Uh, one thing that also will help us on a, on a
sustainability effort is the ventilation hood that we have for cooking, uh,
needs to be replaced and, and, and moved, and so we hope to get that, uh,
addressed here in the interior, um, section when, when that comes up in a
couple years. Um, the hope with the kitchen is for it to be a certified kitchen
so that people who are doing food trucks or other catering can be able to rent
the space as well as if we have events here in this larger room, they'll be able
to use the, the kitchen for preparing meals for folks in here. But also, most
importantly to our senior center mission is to be able to provide educational
programs out of that space. Um, and we recognize how important that is to
the Downtown District and to the community in general. Um, and I think
that's about all I have. Anybody have any questions?
Fruin: Just a quick note to add, um, the Senior Center Master Plan will be coming
your way, uh, in a, in a month or two, probably, the, the Commission's gonna
be deliberating that later this month, and that'll be a, um, you know, a
significant decision for the Council to make. Uh, this budget totals, I think,
over $6 million worth of investment in this building, which as, uh, as Latasha
mentioned, uh, something that's probably long overdue for this building. Um,
and that level of investment hasn't really been put into this since the City
began operations here several decades ago. So just a lot of discussions on
that to come up, uh, later this winter and spring,
DeLoach: It also included, thank you, Geoff, for reminding me, I have a big old
highlight and forgot it. Um, also in that report, you'll see an ADA, an
accessibility report, um, which is really important. Of course, we're currently
ADA compliant, but we wanna always move as close to accessibility as
possible. So, you'll also see that as a part of that report.
Weiner: What, when you're looking at HVAC, do, did you, you, is the, you planning to
move away from gas?
DeLoach: Yeah. I mean, that's a hope is for us to reduce our emissions, right? So,
we're, we're looking at options. Um, the building actually has a couple
different systems and so we're trying to like certain sections of the building
have their own systems, and so we're trying to see what other options are
there. Do we go electric? Do we, you know, we're looking at what will us, the,
the, the best reduction, uh, to get as close to zero as possible. Some of them
are very, very, very, very pricey. I don't think that's something we're gonna
be able to accomplish right now, but, um, you all will get a chance when you
see that report of some of the options. And that'll be part of our discussion of
trying to make a decision about where we want to invest.
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 12
Havel: Okay. All right. Up next will be Parks and Recreation.
Seydell-Johnson: All right. Julie Seydell-Johnson, Director of Parks and Recreation.
We start out with a really important trail connection along Highway 6,
Broadway Street to Fairmeadows. This has been here a while, um, but we're
moving forward on that and excited to get that in here. City Park pool
replacement, and probably the number one question to me out on the streets
right now is what's gonna happen to City Park pool. We do not know the
answer yet. It has been a central question in the public input we're receiving
for the Recreation, um, Facilities and Program Master Plan. This is a
placeholder at this time. Um, we it'll probably, uh, be later this spring before
we have the input gathered and, and information about that. We did have an
assessment done of the pool shell. It is losing a lot of water. It, uh, there are a
number of ADA, um, issues in the pool house and different things like that.
So, we're moving forward with cataloging all those and using that as we come
to you with a decision on this project later. Okay. Splash pad improvements,
uh, the, I believe the equipment is just about ready to be ordered for this.
This is happening this summer, where we'll be replacing the aboveground
equipment at both Wetherby and Fairmeadows. Uh, not only will they give
both of those, a nice, fresh look with some new and, and cool play equipment,
but substantial water savings. So, the newer equipment, some of this
equipment is now over 20 years old, and the newer equipment uses much
less water coming through the nozzles and whatnot, so a big water savings
there as well.
Alter: May I ask when, um, would you actually, like, given, if the supply chain and
you don't have problems with delays, when would the work on those
happen?
Seydell-Johnson: So, in this particular project, it's actually just a purchase of the
aboveground equipment, which I don't wanna call it snap and play, but it's
pretty close. So, it would be, uh, the installation is, is fairly easy and it
wouldn't see any impact on operations maybe more than a few days closure
if it happened in the middle of the summer. Ideally, we'd have it done in time
for, to open this spring. So. Um, upgrading, uh, the BAS controls for the HVAC
systems through a number of the buildings, fire station, animal control, um,
these will make it more efficient and allow our staff to operate them remotely
and, and monitor them. It's been very important this week when it's been
below zero one day and then 35 degrees above zero the next day.
Weiner: So, what does BAS stand for?
Seydell-Johnson: Building automation system?
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 13
Weiner: Thank you.
Seydell-Johnson: Yep. Double check with Kumi. Uh, we have two park sites that we
are poised to get to, um, have dedicated from developers on the North,
Northside. Uh, one is Palisades, and we will be renaming that when it
becomes dedicated to us, there's a lot of confusion about whether that's the
state park or our smaller park Um, and then Stonebridge, which is kind of on
the Northeast side, uh, the Parks Commission has gone out and looked at
both those sites. We have some pretty good plans in place and ideas of what
we'd like to do, um, and as soon as the land is dedicated, we'll be able to
move forward on some of the purchases and get those rolling. Chadek Green
Park restrooms and shelter, uh, we've had our neighborhood meetings for
this, and we are almost at 90% plan development. This looks at the
community garden site, it will add some accessible parking features, some
accessible beds, new paths to the gardens, new, uh, gates on some of the
garden spaces, a small shelter, and a small play area. So, it'll make it into
more of a neighborhood park than only a, um, than only a community garden
site. Rec Center improvements, so once again, this is something that's on hold
right at the moment until we finish our Recreation Program and Facility
Master Plan to prioritize what the greatest needs are for these things.
Whispering Meadows is underway. The ecological improvements actually
have already taken place largely this past fall, uh, there's a lot of
improvements to the wetlands that, the trail system back in the wetlands
received some new aggregate, uh, there's some and bridge repairs back in
that area. Next spring well be bidding out a small playground, um, there is a,
a residential lot that we own off of indigo Court, and that will receive a
playground, possibly a small shelter, depending on, um, what the bidding
climate is when we are able to do that, and accessible paths into this park.
Lower City Park shelters and restroom replacement, this one has been in the
CIP for a number of years, it's moved around here and there. Um, the idea is
to consolidate some of the shelters, moving some of the, or removing some of
the older ones that are in the areas that still flood, or that have potential for
flooding. This particular item in your packet says that we would remove six
picnic shelters. That's not quite accurate any longer. This was, um, written a
few years ago in that the shelter by the, what was the carnival rides has
already been removed, and the shelter that is near the Parks maintenance
shop has been converted into a staff area to help us spread out our, our staff
during COVID. So, we're, we're down to about three of the shelters that we
would likely remove, which would be 5, 9 and 13. They're all kind of out in
the areas that tend to flood and then replacing, you know, I know these
numbers probably don't mean everything to everyone, but 7, 11 and 12, and
keeping 6 and 8. So there would be some changes. We, uh, have some, uh,
people concerned that there's a lot more use in the shelters, and we would
agree that has happened during the pandemic. So that'll be evaluated as we
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 14
get closer to the actual project for what we end up doing with those. Kiwanis
Park playground, everyone loves the natural play area, a lot of people love
the natural play area at Kiwanis, it is just seriously aging and being very
difficult to maintain. So, this will look at replacing that in 2023, so that means
this summer, uh, we will have neighborhood input meetings out at the park
to gather input about how people would like to see this playground, uh,
replaced. The project calls for the shelter replacement as well, that may or
may not be necessary, uh, that shelter's still in pretty good condition. We'll
evaluate, uh, when we get to that point. Napoleon Park softball fields, this is
regrading, redoing the drainage, just keep keeping them playable and at a
high level of playability for our teams that use them. Upper City Park, similar
to Lower City Park, this has been moved in the CIP so it coincides at the same
time that the City Park pool refurbishment or replacement would happen. So
essentially everything in the Upper City Park would happen, hopefully, in the
same construction season. The Upper City Park shelters are generally very,
getting very old, um, and are difficult to maintain, so we would definitely be
looking at shelter replacements and potentially something different with the
restrooms, whether it be actually combined into the pool building, if that was
a new building or something different done with the outdoor restrooms that
are in that area. Hickory Hill Park, Conklin Lane, the north entrance. This is
the last of these kind of classic looking shelter restroom facilities that we
have in the park system, um, and this is scheduled for replacement in 2025.
Court Hill Park, shelter playground replacement will happen this coming
summer. Once again, we've had the neighborhood meetings out there. Uh,
this one we failed to calculate when the sun would go down this fall, but I
would tell you that the neighbors came out in the dark with their own
flashlights, uh, to give their input on this, project in the shelter. It was really
cool. Um, and we have a playground, uh, chosen, and the playground and
shelter stay in essentially the same location. Um, just some improvements to
both. Robert A. Lee, uh, pool filter and HVAC, one thing we do know from our
study so far is that this, uh, facility infrastructure is quickly nearing the end of
its life. However, we still want to finish the Recreation Facility and Master
Plan before we prioritize this, um, with the other large ticket projects that are
in there. Happy Hollow is scheduled for 2024, this is a replacement only of
the playground. Uh, as you know, we've done the restroom and shelter and
some of the field renovations and different things in that park over the last
few years, um, so this would finish that park as far as the, um, renovation
schedule. Terrell Mill Skate Park, uh, one of our heavier used facilities,
believe or not, um, on Dubuque Street, we have applied for a federal grant to
help hopefully match the funding here so that we would be a $1.25 million
project that would, uh, be not only a skate park, but make it into more of a
roller park, so you could do, have a, um, a bicycle, BMX kind of bicycle area as
well, and, um, a lot of interest in that from both local residents and, uh, Think
Iowa City, as far as being able to host, um, events at a facility like that. So,
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 15
Mercer ballpark diamond improvements, um, going through all of them, the
facility out there with additional shade, additional work to the fields, um,
new fences, and then, uh, looking at the amenities. This will likely be in
partnership with City High, assuming that they stay there for their baseball
program. Hunter's Run on the west side is one of our older playgrounds
that's, that we haven't, have yet to replace in recent years, so this is 2023,
which means again, next summer, well be out in this park with
neighborhood meetings to talk about what the neighbors would like to see
for their playground and park shelters. Event facility improvements. This
covers our event facilities, which are the Lodge at Terry Trueblood, the Ned
Ashton House and the Riverside Shakespeare Theater Stage in City Park. The
first year, uh, or currently in this year, we have funding to do a restaining of
the park Lodge, which is in need of that. And then the next, uh, priority will
be some fairly substantial renovations to the Shakespeare stage. Uh, we've
met with Riverside Theater, have some ideas from additional grant writing
for that as well, but they're very committed to wanting to continue to use
that location in our parks, and it is going to need some fairly substantial
renovations to be able to be continued to use for that, use for that purpose.
Off-road bike trail development, this will take place near Terrell Mill Skate
Park, um, along the river bottoms, then up into some land that we, uh,
purchased from the Elks, um, golf club last year, uh, this will be largely, uh,
implemented by our Parks staff with some, uh, funding for the bridges and
wetland type things like that, so. Benton Hill playground replacement, um,
that's a picture of the shelter, which is not part of the replacement, but the,
uh, the playground would reach the age by this point that it in 2026, that it
would be on our list for evaluation and potential replacement at that time.
College Green Park, 2024, this is another one that is very, very much used by
a lot of different groups and a lot of people. It's a well -used park, um, and it is,
I believe, the second oldest playground that we have, equipment we have in
the system right now. Willow Creek trail replacement. Um, the trails through
Willow Creek Park, um, have had a number of tree roots and different things
come up, they aren't, um, they aren't smooth and level any longer. So, this
would replace them in '22, '23. ADA elevator improvements, this would be
City Hall and the Rec Centers. And I believe here, we're not here at the Senior
Center. We have a special helper in that picture, if you can see that, um, but
the ADA improvements are things like adding voice commands, adding, um,
braille, adding some other things that, um, that would make them, uh, more
accessible to a wider range of users. And then in 2026, replacing, uh, North
Market Square playground replacement, this would be, uh, done in
conjunction with the school as well since they use this playground quite a lot.
And obviously the neighborhoods. Um, it's in, it's in fairly good condition at
this point, but realize this is four years out and it's heavily used every day
during the school year. Reno Street, this is a good example, if you can see the
pictures of how a playground is in good condition, but maybe doesn't have
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 16
the highest accessibility. For a long time, our playgrounds were put in with
the timber beams around the, uh, landscaping beams around the edges. Um,
so this one is, doesn't have a direct path from the street. And also, once you
get to the playground, there's a number of obstacles just to get over, to get to
the actual equipment. So, this will look at, at providing that access both to the
playground and the shelter and the gardens there. Um, and then also
potentially replacing this if needed by 2026. Tennis court renovations, we get
a fair amount of use of tennis courts at City Park and at Mercer. Mercer was
redone a few or resurfaced a few years ago, along with the pickle ball project,
um, but even with that, because of the high number, high amount of use, we
have both of the tennis courts listed as needing future, hopefully, resurfacing,
possibly larger structural repairs as well. And then this is a holding spot for
some, um, park development. On the far west side is that development, um,
potentially takes place in future years, could be in con-, in conjunction with a
school or fire station, and, um, our Rec and Facility Master Plan is looking at
this as what are some potential recreation needs, uh, for the area as well.
Alter: Can I ask a quick question, um, as a new Councilor who really doesn't have
sort of the historical context I'm really struck, um, you guys are gonna be
busy, these are a lot of projects, and I'm wondering is part of this due to
delays because of the pandemic. And therefore, there's a certain amount of
catch up or is this kind of business as usual, where this is a constant rota of
having to do this kind of upkeep. Cause some of these things also don't look
to my mind, uh, or to my eye necessarily as like upkeep, but like actually
fairly substantial overhaul. So, Fm just wanting a little context.
Seydell-Johnson: Sure. So, we, we predict usually that a playground that's installed
the last between 20 to 25 years and with about 50 parks, you're always
gonna have a certain number rotating through for renovations. I would say
that the amount of projects you see here isn't necessarily because of the
pandemic. It actually predates when I came six years ago, um, there has just
been a substantial, um, investment in the parks since I've gotten here. And so,
we have been chugging along with five, four or five parks' projects, thanks to
our friends in Engineering, um, over the last few years. And we're, we're
nearing the end of that first round of renovations. We're at 15 or 20 parks left
with substantial needs in them. Um, so I think we've made a lot of progress,
but it's ongoing and we love that the parks are used as much as they're used,
but that, that requires some, uh, general upkeep, care, and maintenance
throughout too.
Alter: I mean, it's great to see that there's so many and that there's attention to
them, but yeah, just impressive amount of work
Seydell-Johnson: Thank you.
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 17
Thomas: I, I think there was a period of a period of time too, when, um, you know,
parks in the system were not being renovated, kind of in a timely fashion. So,
I think in the last, I would say since I've been here maybe 10 years there,
there's been an acknowledgement of that and an acceleration of doing the
renovations.
Alter: Thank you.
Taylor: That involved the ADA component too. So, I'm, I'm very happy to see that,
that it's more aware now of, of those issues.
Seydell-Johnson: Yeah. This, a lot of it follows the 2016 Park Master Plan. Um, we've
been very fortunate thanks to your support that we've been following
through with the promises and the priorities in that plan. So that's really
guided the ADA improvements and the park renovations state.
Alter: Right. Thanks.
Havel: All right. If there's no more questions, then we will move next to Police.
Liston: Good afternoon, Dustin Liston, Chief of Police. We just have two projects.
None of them are new, so for those of you that were here last year, it should
look familiar. The first one is the digital photo evidence management, and
that's an evidence management system that will enhance the efficiency and
accuracy of submitting, cataloging, retrieving, and distributing digital
evidence. Um, currently, evidence, uh, evidence, photographs and videos
must be cataloged on paper, transferred to DVD disc, and submitted to
Evidence for storage and upon request for viewing of copies by attorneys or
officers, those discs must be located, replicated, and distributed, which is a
very time consuming and antiquated process by today's standard. This new
system will allow upload directly into the system, create photo logs and
associated information and files, and a file, and be able to file it under proper
incident numbers for ease of retrieval while remaining, uh, maintaining high
security for the evidence. And the next one is the Animal Shelter standby
generator. And this provides a natural gas generator at the Animal Shelter,
which would be able to provide a safe and comfortable environment for the
animals during any kind of power outage, which is timely today 'cause my
wife called me and told me that we didn't have power on the west side of
town for a while. So currently the Animal Shelter, uh, the animal center loses
the ability to provide heat or cooling during any kind of power outage. The
center is built to be climate controlled, which does not allow them to have
any possibility to open any of the windows. Some rooms with animals do not
have the ability to have access to outside air. Extended periods of time,
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 18
exposed to extreme heat or cold, have the potential to cause distress for the
animals. That's it for me.
Havel: Thank you. All right. We'll move on to Public Works.
Havel: Starting out at the Landfill, a couple of projects there, one being the
Equipment Building replacement. So, this will replace two existing buildings
out at the Landfill. Currently we have some equipment that is, uh, too large to
be housed indoors and out of the elements. So, this will replace a couple of, of
storage buildings out there and allow for that, uh, that storage to occur, uh,
indoors and not having to be out exposed to the elements full time. The other
one being a bulk fill, a bulk water fill station. We have a couple of these
located in other locations, uh, within the city. This allows for vehicles such as
tanker trucks and that kind of thing to fill up with, uh, water more efficiently
with the new water main that's been extended to the Landfill. It provides a, a
few different benefits, one being, it helps to turn over the water that is in that
water main. It's good for, for water to be used and, and not to just sit in the
water main. So, this will help to help with that turnover, also can help with
Fire operations out at the Landfill should it be needed, also can help with
their daily cover, uh, operations as well out at the Landfill. Next are a couple
of products related to the composting out at the Landfill. The first being the
compost pad improvements, the current surface out there, um, is in definite
need of repair, there's large potholes and it's just not a great, uh, surface for
them to be working off of during their composting operations, so this will
help to fill that in, um, provide more of a hard surface for them to work off of
and, and certainly aid with their, their composting operations. The other
thing would be a piece of equipment and excavator for compost operations,
uh, again, helping to, help with that process. Next up is a couple of, um,
system improvements out at the Landfill, first one being the Landfill gas dual
extraction system, and then the ACM Landfill gas infrastructure expansion.
Both of those will look at expanding the, uh, gas and leachate collection
systems out at the Landfill. So, we have two existing systems there, um, and
looking at extending both of those into additional parts of the Landfill, the
final one being the leachate lagoons, there's currently two lagoons that are
out at the Landfill. One hasn't been used for a number of years, so we'll
decommission that one. Uh, the other one will be basically cleaned and, and
for, provide some repairs to it as well. Future Landfill cell design, so we are
currently operating in FY18 cell that is getting to the point where it will no
longer be able to be used here in the coming years, so we will begin the
process to, um, design and construct the next Landfill cell, which we are
calling FY23. Equipment Maintenance Facility replacement, so this will take
the facility that's at the, the corner of the south Highway 1/Highway 6
intersection and move that down to the Public Works site, so it'll be a new
facility that'll be constructed it down at the Public Works site near the, the
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 19
recently constructed Public Works Building. Moving on to storm water
projects, the first one here is the North Westminster storm sewer upgrades.
So, this is a section, uh, Westminster and Washington Street where we've had
complaints of localized flooding, and this project will look to upsize some of
the storm sewer out there to address that localized flooding, um, so that one
is in '22. The Rundell Street pump station vault modification, those, this will
have a couple components, the first being looking at, uh, modifications to the,
the vault and the hatch or the top of the, the vault to allow for ADA
accommodations. Right now, it does not meet, uh, ADA requirements, so we'll
address that. It'll also look to address or replace some of the equipment that's
actually housed in the vault. River Street storm sewer improvements, so
along River Street, we actually have a section of, uh, essentially a ditch that
often gets filled with debris and becomes somewhat problematic from a, a
maintenance standpoint, so what this will look at doing is installing new
storm sewer to address that issue. The non-public safety radio system
upgrade, so the existing non-public safety radio system is, has reached the
end of its useful life and is need of, uh, upgrade and replacement. The Market
and Jefferson Street two-way conversion, so this project would look to
convert both Market and Jefferson Street from one-way traffic to two-way
traffic. Um, this'll include signal, uh, upgrades and replacement as well as uh,
pavement markings, ADA improvements, and other associated work.
Kirkwood Avenue to Capitol Street connection, so this will extend both
Kirkwood Avenue and Capitol Street near Riverfront Crossings Park Um, this
will be for the design of the project at this point, um, it also will include some
water main work, as well as removing the existing railroad stub that crosses
Benton Street down in that area. The next few products will be street
reconstruction. So typically, street reconstruction's gonna include all new
street pavement, sidewalks, as well as utility improvement, sanitary sewer,
water main, that kind of stuff. Um, these are also opportunities where we'll
look for the undergrounding of utilities that we talked about earlier, so these
are good chances to work with utilities, to, to take care or take advantage of
those opportunities, the first one being Dubuque Street. So, this would be
reconstruction from Washington Street to Iowa Avenue. This would be
basically, came out of the Downtown Master Plan from a, a few years back.
Work would be similar to what we did with Washington Street, uh, a few
years ago. Court Street reconstruction, so this would be from Muscatine
Avenue to First Avenue. The Rochester Avenue reconstruction, this would
occur from essentially Ralston Creek to First Avenue. Fairchild Street, the
reconstruction will be from Clinton Street to Linn Street, in this case we'll
actually reinstall the brick surface, so it will remain a brick street after the
project's complete. Dodge Street reconstruction. This would occur from
Governor Street down to Burlington Street. This would be a joint project with
the DOT. North Gilbert Street reconstruction would be the section from
Brown Street ne-, north to Kimball Road. Park Road reconstruction would
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 20
occur from Rocky Shore Drive to basically the extent of the Gateway project,
so right near, uh, Riverside Drive. Taft Avenue reconstruction would be the
section from American Legion Road north to Lower West Branch Road, and
this one would include, uh, a conversion from, again, a rural section to an
urban section, so similar to what we're doing on American Legion Road. The
next one would be South Dubuque Street from Wright Street to Benton
Street. So, the next project would be a study of the, the southern Highway
1/Highway 6 intersection, so this is one, if you've driven through there
recently, you'd probably notice that there's sort of the kink in it in the east -
west section, so, um, we'd be looking at basically potential geometric
improvements and other roadway improvements, um, as well as pedestrian
improvements. So, there's no currently no sidewalk or curb ramps or
anything like that for pedestrians at this intersection, we'd be looking at, uh,
those improvements as well. Um, another piece of this that we would look at
would be, uh, potential coordination with the DOT project for, um, their
replacement of the Highway 6 bridge over the Iowa River, I believe they're
looking at undertaking or beginning that project in 2027, so there may be
opportunities in the future to, to coordinate with that as well. Next up would
be the Oakdale Boulevard Extension alignment study. So, we have an
alignment study that was completed a number of years ago, uh, recently
there has been some interest in potential redevelopment in this area, and one
of the main questions that comes up is what corridor do we need to, to
reserve for the future Oakdale Boulevard Extension. So, this would look at,
uh, sort of updating that, that study, make sure we're, we're still reserving
the correct corridor that makes the most sense for us, uh, given kind of
where we're at, uh, recently. Gilbert Street bridge replacement, so this would
be the Gilbert Street bridge over Ralston Creek, again, replacing the existing
structure with, uh, likely a similar structure.
Bergus: Jason, on that one, um, I think you can't see it on, on this, but I think in the
book it says that's a 2023 project. Is that right, this year?
Havel: Correct. Yep.
Bergus: Okay. Do we have any sense of like how soon it would be actually impacting
traffic on Gilbert Street?
Havel: As far as closure or when it would be reopened?
Bergus: Uh, closure. Like I, I'm assuming replacing the whole bridge means that at
times it's gonna be closed and I just, I'm just thinking this is like a major
impact one.
Havel: Yep.
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 21
Bergus: So, I'm just wondering if we know when.
Havel: Yes, it will be a major impact. It will be closed during construction. We
originally had looked at ways to potentially try and maintain traffic and it's
just, it's, it's a pretty tight area when we were replacing the bridge and it just
wasn't really feasible. Um, so I would anticipate, you're probably looking in
spring of '23 is when those impacts would begin.
Bergus: Okay, thank you.
Havel: Yep.
Weiner: And with respect to a couple of others that you talked about already, um,
Court, Rochester, and Park, those are all, you know, know, so big, big chunks
and major. What, what, can you remind me what the timing for those are
please?
Havel: Oh, I'd have to, so Rochester will begin in, um, '22, so that we're looking at,
uh, '22, '23 for that, I think Court was '24, '24-'25 for Court and then Park
Road was '25. Was it? Oops.
Weiner: I don't know. Park Road's in pretty bad shape.
Havel: Yeah. So, we'd be looking at construction starting in '25 for Park Road. So, did
that cover all of 'em?
Weiner: Yes. Thank you.
Havel: All right. So, the next one's a big one, so the Burlington Street Bridge
replacement project, um, so this would, the current plan includes some
design money. We actually have some money that was allocated last year to
kind of begin the study process for this project. So, this is, um, a situation
where there's currently two bridges that cross the Iowa River for Burlington
Street. One is actually owned by, the owned and maintained by the City, the
other one is owned and maintained by the DOT, um, so our bridge is, has
reached the, the end of its useful life, and, and we need to, to look at replacing
that, and so with this project, we are currently, um, working to, to see if there
might be an opportunity to replace two bridges with one bridge, um, also, as
part of this project would be looking at realigning or, or making
improvements to the Grand Avenue corridor to make a better connection
between Burlington Street and Melrose, um, obviously for, for bike facilities
and that kind of stuff, the, a more direct connection makes a lot of sense. Um,
we've had preliminary discussions with the University, and they seem
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 22
receptive to that, so, um, that would be part of this product as well. Also
looking at the potential for, um, what would be needs for utilities, not only
the City utilities, but also University utilities, as well as what opportunities
might be there to eliminate the dam. Iowa Avenue bridge rehabilitation
project, so this would be a pretty major rehabilitation project that came out
of actually our, our last round of bridge inspections, so we'd be looking at
some concrete rehabilitation as well as some other, um, improvements there
for that bridge. The Riverside Drive pedestrian bridge at Iowa Avenue, so this
is one where, uh, we've had a fair amount of spalling that has occurred, so
there's small pieces of, of concrete that have fallen over time. Uh, we actually
had a project earlier this year to go out and, and remove the pieces that we
could easily remove. Uh, the next phase would be to do a, a more extensive
rehabilitation project, uh, just as a reminder, this would be a joint project
with the DOT and the University. On to sanitary sewer projects. So, the first
one is the Benton Street trunk sewer improvements, so this is in the area of
Emerald Street and Benton Street. Uh, the current, uh, sanitary sewer in this
location is undersized, it's also not easily accessible. So, this project would
look at upsizing that, and, and moving it slightly into, uh, a location that's
more accessible for maintenance of the, the sanitary sewer main. The Rohret
south sewer, so this is the project that we'll look at upsizing and extending
sanitary sewer along Abbey Lane and under Highway 218 to serve the area
west of Highway 218 for future development. The next group will be, uh, lift
station improvements, so the first one being the, the Hawkeye lift station, um,
this would be essentially kind of a, a complete redo of that location. We'd
actually get rid of the, the existing building and, and upgrade the, the type of
lift station that's out there. Uh, the Napoleon lift station would be
rehabilitation of the equipment that's there, um, just a reminder, I mean, this
is equipment that's operating 24/7, 365 days a year, so it just gets to the
point where it needs to be rehabilitated or replaced. Um, similarly, the
Highlander lift station, we'd be looking at replacing and rehabilitating some
of the equipment there. And then finally out at the Peninsula, we would look
at replacing the control panel and adding a, a secondary pump to that
location as well. Next, we'll move down to the Wastewater treatment plant.
The first section or the first group of projects here would be in the aeration
basin, uh, section of the Wastewater plant, so the first project here would
replace some of the mixers down there, make them more efficient, uh, with
new equipment. The second project would basically move the existing
conduit and cabling that's currently on the, uh, the hand railing down there,
um, and expand it for, or allow for a future expansion. And then finally would
be replacing the remaining mixers that weren't done with the, the first
project, and then replacing some of the other equipment, um, in that area.
Next, we'll move over to the influent section of the Wastewater treatment
plant, kind of the headworks of the plant, so we'd be looking at replacing the
influent pumps, um, at the Wastewater treatment plant, and then the second
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 23
project there would be improving and, uh, making it, improving the influent
flow monitoring, helping make that more accurate and more efficient.
Wastewater treatment plant equipment, so this is a, a group of projects that's
really looking at, uh, replacing equipment that's reached the end of its useful
life or, or making minor modifications. The first one would be the biosolids
conveyor improvements, this would help with, uh, loading material into
trucks. Um, the second one would be replacement of the return -activated
sludge pump, um, yeah, replacement of those pumps. The next one would be
replacement of the grit classifiers, and then finally replacement of the
rotating drum thickeners. The digester complex rehabilitation project, this
will be a big one down at the Wastewater treatment plant. Um, there'll be a
couple different phases of this. A lot of this, uh, revolves around the struvite
issue that we have down there, which is essentially kind of a, a mineral
deposit that occurs, um, throughout kind of the, the treatment process, uh, so
the first one would be more on the op- or the, uh, system side of things, kind
of looking at the way we, our, uh, treatment process works and are the, how
we can remove phosphorus from, from the system that would help to
eliminate that struvite issue. Um, and then the second phase of that is gonna
be looking to replace equipment that's been damaged by the struvite, um,
and, ah, in, is in need of repair. Primary clarifier repairs, this is really just a,
um, replacement of equipment that's reached the end of its useful life. It's
been in full-time operations since 2002. The jetter truck replacement, uh,
originally was planned on a replacement schedule of 15 years. We're I
believe about 12 years in, and it's just getting to the point where there's a lot
more maintenance costs, and so this would essentially be money to buy out
the final three years to allow for, uh, replacement sooner. Treatment plant
paving improvements, this would be replacing essentially street pavement
down at the Wastewater treatment plant for kind of their main drive aisles
and other locations within the, the plant area. The Wastewater System
Master Plan, so this would look at kind of a 20 -year plan for wastewater
operations, not only at the plant, but as also at the lift stations and the
collection system as well. HVAC replacement, so again, down at the
Wastewater treatment plant, looking at HVAC replacement for a number of
their, their buildings there. Roof replacements, this would occur not only at
the wastewater plant, but also at the water plant. Again, there's a number of,
of locations and buildings there that just the, the roofing has reached the end
of its useful life. Moving up to the water plant and HVAC study, there's a, a, a
few locations within the water plant where there's been some ongoing issues
with HVAC equipment and operations. This would look at kind of taking a
closer look at those, figure out what's going on and provide, uh,
recommendations for improvements that could come in the future to address
those issues. The next group of projects will be water main replacement
projects. Um, the first one here is the Bradford Drive area, would include
water main replacements, not only on Bradford Drive, um, but also Louise
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 24
Street and Wayne Avenue, uh, for our water main replacement projects.
Typically, those will include essentially replacing existing water main that's
not in good shape, whether it has a history of breaks or whatever it might be,
um, with essentially in-kind, uh, water main. The next section of water main
replacement would be the, from, er, along Melrose Avenue from Camp
Cardinal Boulevard to Highway 218, as well as Highway 1 from Hawks Ridge
to Westport Plaza, and then finally out on Highway 6 from Fairmeadows to
Industrial Park Road. So again, all those would be water main replacement
projects. Up at the Water Treatment plant, a few, uh, improvement projects
there, the first one being, uh, would be replacing the variable frequency
drives, or the VFDs, for the high service pumps at the water plant, next would
be an upgrade to the chlorine feeder system, which is used as part of the, the
treatment operations up there at the water plant. Next product would be the
water or improvements to the, the meeting room at the water plant, this is
one that's often used for training or larger meetings, um, it's certainly has
some needs as far as upgrades there, you know, it has an old projector, really
isn't conducive to, um, larger meetings and, and having those be a, a good
presentation space, so looking at making some improvements there, also
we'll include some lighting. And then Collector Well #2, cleaning and
upgrading. So, this would look at cleaning and capping, uh, a couple of the
laterals, and then also looking at drilling new laterals to help with capacity
for Collector Well #2. Next up is a treatment technology study for the Water
Division, so this would be a study that would look at the, uh, treatment
methods that are used up at the water plant, be looking at nutrient removal,
um, as well as the, the future for potentially either staying with or moving
away from lime softening, um, and some other components. So, the, the first
phase would be the study phase, and then the second project would be, uh,
money to implement the findings that would come out of that study. And
then finally, water distribution asset inventory. So, the City is currently, um,
undertaking a process to develop an asset management, uh, software and,
and program. And so, what this would do is look at going out and collecting
asset information for the water distribution system. Give us good
information to go into that asset management program, um, for future
evaluation. That is it for Public Works. Lot to go through. So, all right.
Bergus: I had, I had a question for you, Jason.
Havel: Yeah.
Bergus: Um, going back to the annual, um, projects, there was $250,000 a year, I
think for Climate projects that Juli, I think mentioned, um, 'cause maybe,
maybe they're under Parks and Rec, I'm not sure, but it was government
buildings improvements that are climate related. Do those tie to things like
the roof replacement on water and wastewater? Like are we looking at, okay
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 25
now is the time we can add solar panels? Or is it, is it more divided as
between the departments?
Havel: I, I guess I would say that for the most part, we kind of consider those as part
of those projects. I don't know, as far as for of a funding standpoint that
they're yeah, they're directly interconnected, but that's definitely something
we consider as we look at those types of projects.
Seydell-Johnson: The, the earlier fund is more the General Funded building --
Bergus: Okay. Yeah.
Seydell-Johnson -- so it would be City Hall, the fire stations, Senior Center, Rec
Centers, um, not the enterprise funded necessarily.
Bergus: That makes sense. Thank you.
Havel: All right. Up next is Transportation.
Nagle-Gamm: Good afternoon. Darian Nagle-Gamm here to walk you through just a
few projects that we have in Transportation. Project number one is video
cameras for our parking facilities. We do have cameras at all of our existing
parking facilities today at our entrances and exits, but this project is really
going to expand, um, those security cameras to other parts of the facilities,
both to help us keep, uh, tabs on, on, on traffic, um, flow and demand, on
parking demand in the facilities and just, um, to help, um, improve security
and to improve our response to incidents when they occur. Second project,
uh, proposal is for, uh, to replace our current parking enforcement vehicle.
Um, this is a, this is a photo of our, our current vehicle, uh, well-worn and
loved. Um, it has license plate reader technology, which really helps us in our
ungated facilities. So that's Chauncey Swan and Harrison Street, you pay by
plate at those facilities, so there's no gates, which makes it really nice from a
user perspective. You can just go in, you pay at the pay station, you enter
your, your, your license plate. Um, these, or these vehicles help us, um, uh,
help us with enforcement and make sure that that folks who are using the
facilities have paid the user fees. The third project is parking ramp
automated equipment. So, our current equipment, so when you pull into one
of our gated facilities, you pull a ticket, um, pay when you leave, um, at the
exit or you pay at the, the pay -on -foot, um, uh, machines that we have near
the stairwells. Um, that was all installed in 2009, this equipment has about a
10 -year lifespan, so we've already pushed it past that. The pandemic may
have helped us out a little bit, 'cause there was some reduced demand, there
is one pandemic bright spot right there, um, but as things have picked back
up again downtown, we're definitely seeing, um, increase in demand and the
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 26
equipment failing at greater and greater rates. So, this project would, um,
seek, uh, a new, or put out an RFP or an RFQ to, to have all of our automated
equipment, um, replaced this year, which will really help, um, with the
efficiency that people are able to, um, access and enter our, and exit our
facilities. All right, number four is a replacement of LED fixtures in our
parking facilities, and this is one that we've, uh, started last year and will
continue. Um, we were pretty early adopters when it came to, to
transitioning to LED lighting, which saved, um, so much money over the last
10 years, uh, over their lifespan, but they are beginning to fail at, at an
increasing rate. Um, they're really efficient, but they don't last forever. So,
this project is to go, um, and improve and install kind of that second round of
LED lighting in all of our facilities. All right, project five is Tower Place
drainage modifications, and, and this one could probably be categorized as a
climate change project in that, um, the, the, the drainage that you see on
maybe a residential building, you'll see, you know, uh, drainage on the
outside of the building, well, this parking facility was built so that all the
water, um, and snow drains inward, um, and then it exits through a pipe at
the bottom. What we've found in recent years, uh, during extreme weather
events when there's a lot of rainfall really rapidly is that we experience
flooding in the very lower level. There's a, there's a parking condo, um, that
you enter off Gilbert Street, in the very lower level, there have been, um,
there have been flooding impacts, um, that have been substantial, and again,
these are extreme weather events, a lot of rainfall in a short period. So, this
project would help divert some of that storm water to the outside of the
building and, and reduce that pressure on, uh, the current storm water
system, um, in on the interior. All right, this is a new project. Um, you
probably don't think about roofs much when you think about, uh, parking
ramps, but, um, there is a roof over the stairwells and it, we did an inspection
this year, and we did find that the roofs, um, on Capitol Street Ramp and the
Dubuque Street Ramp's stairwells do need to be replaced. So, these are
projects to, to replace them in order to, um, prevent any future, um, issues
from occurring in those stairwells. All right, this is another new project. This
is a Tower Place office remodel. And, um, in short, we have more people, um,
working in this, out of this office, and an increasing number in the last year,
um, than we have space for, so really this is a project to, um, to reorganize the
space in such a way that we can fit more people, um, in here. This office is
shared by our customer service representatives, who, who answer, um, uh,
walk-in traffic, answer the phones and email requests for both
Transportation Services and for, for Refuse, um, the administrative staff for
Parking and, uh, myself and Mark Rummel. We also work out of this office as
well. So, it's really just, uh, it's we need to find a way so that we can all work
there simultaneously, and that's not something that we can do really easily
today. Um, last project here is the Transit Maintenance Facility relocation.
And I briefly, uh, talked about this on, on Saturday, um, at our, at the, the
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 27
budget work session then, but this is a project to, to replace the current
Transit Facility at a different location. Um, this is our, our Transit Facility is
just knocking on the door of 40 years, which is really about the life span of
such a facility. So, in addition to, you know, the wear and tear of a 40 -year-old
building at the end of its useful life, um, we have some site-specific
challenges, um, some, um, uh, soil subsidence issues at the current site. And
so, um, we have been actively pursuing federal funding and the good news is
there are federal funding sources for such a facility. I expect, um, we could
see approximately, if, if a grant is awarded, which again, we're actively, um,
applying for these grants, but we, probably 75% of that cost could be covered
federally to give you a sense of, of, um, what the remaining, um, obligation
would be. The, the new Transit, uh, Facility, uh, which will be shared with
Equipment is earmarked for the Public Works, uh, site that's located at
McCollister and Gilbert Street, um, there's already space allocated for it, um,
so it's a matter of, um, you know, finding those federal dollars to help us, to
help us kickstart this, uh, facility relocation. I'd be happy to answer any
questions.
Weiner: Is it, am I correct that the new, the new equipment you're putting into, um,
to charge the new electric buses is gonna be movable? Will that, that be, is
that --
Nagle-Gamm: That's correct, the chargers that we have just installed to power the
electric buses that will be on the road in the next few weeks, that equipment
will be able to be moved, and, and honestly, the equipment that we have right
now is loaner equipment. Um, they weren't, because of pandemic, uh,
pandemic, um, challenges with, with getting our own chargers, we have
chargers from another part of the country, so they can be moved, um, and
that was one of the benefits to us, um, from our perspective to go electric
now, um, in our current facility, because we can move those to the new
facility.
Harmsen: Are there any, uh, plans or any talk about using, uh, with a new facility
using something like solar to augment the recharging of the buses, uh, solar
panels and things like that?
Nagle-Gamm: Great question. Yeah, I think that will, that will definitely be something
we'll be evaluating throughout the process is, is, um, you know, what options
do we have to not only supplement the power, but also just make it an
overall, um, environmentally friendly building as we possibly can.
Havel: All right. The last section is On the Radar. So, these are the, the projects that
don't show up in the current plan or, or only a portion of them show up in the
current plan, as far as maybe it's a situation where there may be some design
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 28
money, but not construction money. Um, so these are kind of those major
products on the horizon that we'd wanna make sure you, you keep in mind as
we move forward.
Seydell-Johnson: So, the first one is the Lower City Park Master Plan improvements.
And this is, uh, was a plan completed about six years ago. We have chiseled
away at little parts of it with all the improvements that we've been making,
but this would overall, the larger part of it would be to raise the road through
the park to provide additional resilience to flooding in the park, um, along
with some additional, um, renovations to both the baseball fields and to the
Riverside Festival Stage. The next one is Eastside sports complex. We own
land, um, just south of the new Hoover Elementary School. Uh, we have
planted trees to start a buffer there, uh, but everything else is on hold. We've
done a planning process that, uh, fills it with baseball fields and soccer, uh,
also potentially a space for an indoor facility. This is being revisited as part of
the Recreation Facility and Master Plan to prioritize it along with other
projects. Um, and then the Recreation Master Plan, which I've mentioned
about 16 times today, um, this plan is in place, but this, or is in progress right
now and it will help us prioritize the needs of all of our aquatic facilities, the
rec centers, the outdoor athletic fields. Uh, we've got a lot of input from the
public about their priorities and their hopes and dreams for what recreation
can be in Iowa City. So, we look forward to sharing that information with you
and, and working through a prioritization process, um, and hopefully funding
streams for a lot of these larger projects.
Havel: The next project is the Taft Avenue reconstruction. So, we talked earlier
about the section from American Legion Road to Lower West Branch Road,
um, there are also, is two additional sections that would need reconstruction
in the future, the first one being on the north end from Lower West Branch
up to Herbert Hoover Highway, and then on the south end from American
Legion Road down to 420th Street. Similar situation with McCollister
Boulevard, we recently completed the section from Gilbert Street over to
Sycamore Street. There's, uh, long term plans to continue to extend that to
the east from Sycamore Street, uh, over to Scott Boulevard. Another one here
is Carson Lake, so this would be on the west side of Highway 218 between
Rohret Road and Highway 1. Uh, the thought here is that this would be, uh, a
regional detention basin that could also serve, uh, recreational uses. So, it'd
be a, a lake that could be used for, uh, recreational uses while also again,
serving as that regional detention basin for storm water use as well. Foster
Road elevation, so, as I had mentioned earlier, we have, uh, some initial
money in there for our functional design, um, should we choose to move
forward with that, then there would need to be construction money allocated
in a future year for, for that project. Same situation for Highway 1/Highway
6, again, we have money in there for a study to kind of take a look at things,
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 29
um, but there would be a need for future construction dollars. That is the
information that we have for you.
Teague: Okay. All right. Any questions for staff? That was a lot of information, but
really appreciate, um, to-, walking us through this. I did have some general
questions, I guess, um, when we're talking about sustainability, um, I, and
even, um, just, you know, decreasing carbon emissions. I'm, and I think
Councilor Bergus has kind of brought that up, um, is that something that you
all are always reassessing on some level throughout all the projects?
Havel: Yeah, I would say it's something that we're always considering on our
projects. You know, I think there's some, roofing is, is an example where, you
know, it's, it's not always as simple as just saying, adding solar panels. So, I
think it's something that we, we look at and, and we try to, to take advantage
of opportunities that we do have, um, but kind of work through that process.
And it, sometimes it works out and sometimes it, it doesn't for as far as
what's gonna be, um, workable for a project.
Teague: I know that carpet is often something that, you know, some of our buildings
have, but there is more and more moving towards, um, like natural concrete,
natural concrete is, ever, that reconsidered for some projects.
Seydell-Johnson: It, it has been, um, the trade-off with that is sound, and we're
already working in some spaces that are difficult because of the number of
people working in small close -in spaces. So, it's, it's not always the best
option for that reason, but it's something that we've, we've often considered.
Teague: And then I have, I think, um, just a couple of more questions. For the
crosswalks, I know that we have one project that, um, has a pilot program
where it's kind of heated if I understood it correctly. Is that, is the, that
correct?
Havel: On Muscatine Avenue, the conductive concrete.
Teague: Yes. Um, that hasn't been installed yet?
Havel: Correct. Yeah. And I guess just to clarify, so it would be the sidewalk on the
adjacent to the, uh, bus stop. So, it wouldn't be the actual crosswalk in the
street.
Teague: Okay. All right. It brings up a question just about like the ADA curb ramps.
Um, is, will there be an ADA curb ramp there that will be kind of, with the
heated option or, or no.
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 30
Havel: I don't recall if the actual ramp, I don't believe was conductive. I don't think
we did conducted on the ramp. I think it was just the sidewalk, the, uh, bus
shelter pad.
Teague: Okay. I just know that once, um, we have some experience with that, it
would be interesting just to see, um, how, uh, that new pavement is. Other
than that, I don't think I have anything else, but thank you all. Anyone else?
Taylor: I had a question, um, throughout there, there was, uh, comments about some
new traffic signals and that, of course, they're, they're all losing their life
expectancy. Also, uh, a friend of mine who's sight impaired, uh, commented
on the, uh, speaking ones that we have downtown, and he really, uh, liked
that and appreciated that. Are there plans for any of the ones that we're
going to be installing? Is does that add a large cost or is it possible that we
can add some more speaking signals?
Havel: It does add some cost. The, we've basically taken the, the stance that we
would install those at all future intersections as we make improvements to
the, the signals.
Taylor: Good. Thank you.
Thomas: Well, I, I have a number of, um, now that we've seen the, the, uh, the
budget, uh, and also the, the CIP portions and are, in a way going to be
moving into, um, discussions of the strategic plan. I prepared a kind of a
summary of my thoughts at this point, and I've sent it to Council and the City
Manager, to Geoff. Um, so I, perhaps this might be a good time to go over
those comments.
Teague: Sure. Just get closer to your microphone. Thank you.
Thomas: Um, I've tried to, in, in, so far as we're moving toward the strategic plan, I, I
wanted to try to place them within that context of, of the strategic plan. At
least the, the goals that we have, uh, at the, at the current time, they may be
going through revision when we meet again on that, um, but for me, I use
them as a reference, uh, for these considerations, uh, and the first would be
fostering, foster, healthy neighborhoods and affordable housing throughout
Iowa City. Uh, with, under that heading, promoting a range of housing
affordability and demographic diversity in the core neighborhoods through
revision of land use regulations and the creation of economic incentives, and
perhaps for the benefit of, of, uh, the new Councilors, I wanted to give a little
bit of background on that. Um, the core neighborhoods, uh, are in many ways,
a treasure to Iowa City, uh, from a tax revenue standpoint, uh, there's
significant amount of high density, high family, multi -family redevelopment
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 31
has generated on a per -acre basis, considerable wealth for decades. Uh, that's
a dimension, I think, I think is kind of interesting to think about as we talked
about revenue streams and generation of tax revenue, um, that may not be
understood in terms of looking at the core neighborhoods, um, but in fact,
because of their density, uh, they do generate considerable wealth on that
per -acre basis. Uh, the market forces that fuel these higher densities and
increased property taxes have else, have also had significant negative
impacts threatening the stability of the core neighborhoods since the state
legislature preempted the City's land use policies attempting to address some
of these impacts, there appears to be a trend toward a greater number and
size of investment -owned, densely occupied rental properties, whether in
older houses or in proposed infill development. Concerned neighborhood,
neighbors feel a sense of urgency and are in the process of developing a
multifaceted strategy to address this threat constructively. There are, there
are three actions, uh, by this group that have been identified by which the
City Council can help advance this strategy and achieve its strategic plan goal
of providing affordable housing throughout the city, as well as reduce climate
emissions by improving energy efficiency. The first of those is the, the City
property on Ronalds Street, at 724 Ronalds. Uh, that was purchased about
five years ago, uh, by the City to serve as a site where we could consider, uh,
how to develop missing -middle, um, in an infill manner rather than a
greenfield manner. So it was, it was a condemned property, as I recall. And,
um, we pretty much just paid for the value of the land. The improvements, if
you've been by there, um, I think were-- I looked at the assessment to, I think
there are around $12,000 in improvements on the value of the property, but
the, the true value of it is, is the property itself, so that, that is something that
I think we need to move on. It's become a bit of a nuisance, um, you know, it's
a vacant property. And, um, that coupled with the fact that, that we are
feeling this, this urgency regarding future development, this, this would be an
opportunity for us to model what it is we want, uh, whenever an infill
opportunity should arise. Uh, the second element would be the form -based
Code for portions of the core neighborhoods, uh, which could be coupled
with affordable housing incentives. Again, in terms of background, there
were, there was preliminary work done on the form -based Code for this area,
uh, but it never, it never was taken to the final stage where the Code was
actually developed as was done for the South District. Um, if we are to
promote, and I think the idea here is, is to support and promote infill housing
in the core neighborhoods, it has to be done well, and the only way we can
ensure that will be done well would be to do the form -based Code. Uh, you
know, we have seen some examples, uh, over the last few years and, um, it
just reinforces the concern that we have in terms of making sure that any
infill development is, is done, you know, in a manner where it's compatible
with the, the context in terms of scale and architectural form and so forth.
The third item would be the creation of an urban revitalization area, uh, in
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 32
other words, a, a residential tax abatement program for certain building
improvement. So that that's a strategy that we've seen, uh, used in
commercial, of some of our commercial zones, but because of some of the
conditions of the, uh, the residential housing stock in the core
neighborhoods, it, it puts any kind of attempt to, um, improve them at a, at a
kind of a disadvantage because of their existing condition. I was talking about
this with the Mayor the other day, and, um, he toured a-- the building to the
north of the, um, Haunted Bookshop and was along with the former Mayor,
appalled at, you know, the existing condition on the inside. So, so that's sort
of a, a built-in disadvantage to try to advancing, um, you know, a rebalancing
of the, of the core neighborhoods. So those are the three items that, um, as I
noted, you know, depending on staff load and availability and, you know,
costing out what, what these, these items might, uh, might cost in terms of a
project, um, you know, that those are the, the three on, on the healthy
neighborhoods. Uh, the second --
Teague: Uh, I just, I, I did just wanna, um, maybe just chime in for a minute because I
wanna make sure that some of your items get the attention that it needs.
Because I think that, um, as we're talking about the, um, the fostering, uh,
healthy neighborhoods, that is a part of our, uh, plan that we're gonna be
talking about. And I wanna make sure that maybe if you can highlight some of
the things that will be, be more pertinent to this budget cycle, um, because I
know that affordable housing, in big picture it is, but I think we'll, um, be able
to zone in and have a more fruitful conversation with Council, maybe at an
affordable housing opportunity. Um, so if you can just maybe zone in on some
of the, uh, budgeting items that we can consider for now.
Thomas: Well, that's, that's, um, as I was noting, you know, there's, with the Ronalds
affordable housing pilot project, um, that may become a budget item. Um --
Teague: We have affordable housing funds that we can, you know, tap into, right.
Thomas: So there, you, you know, as, as Geoff said, um, at our last meeting, I'm
trying to identify, um, concerns and projects, the actual way in which they're
financed, I think is another question, and it kind of depends in part on, uh,
who does the work, is it done by staff, is it done by a consultant, and then if
there is any kind of capital cost associated with them, how is that going to be
handled? Um, so it, you know, that pilot project could be something that, uh,
the, the City finances, uh, or it could be something that we develop the, um,
you know, request for proposals for a private developer to do the work. So, it,
it has a number of different potential directions it might go. Um, so in my
mind, at least from my standpoint, perhaps Geoff has another thought on this,
is, is trying to see to what degree Council supports the initiative, uh, and then
looking at how the project moves forward.
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 33
Teague: So, I hear you saying, uh, there could be multiple funding streams, at least
for this project. I get it.
Thomas: Um, the second item is, is again, more of a strategic plan, uh, issue, not, no
cost associated with it, as I see it. And that would be, um, promoting the
formation of neighborhood associations and also self-supporting
improvement districts like we are seeing, uh, in the South District with that
commercial zone. Um, so, so, and that's in fact, one of the things that this
working group in the Northside is looking at, um, my understanding is they
can be, um, considered for historic properties. So that may be a, um, another
strategy that would be part of this multifaceted strategy. Um, the second goal,
uh, would be enhancing community mobility, which I would add, and access
to opportunities for all residents, uh, and under that heading would be to
improve the two critical dimensions of freedom of movement and access to
opportunities throughout the year, emphasizing safety and comfort, with
special consideration for young children, youth, persons with disabilities and
the elderly. So, under that, um, heading would be some projects, uh, for you
to consider. One would be one that we have talked about, um, in the past
year, and that would be this question of snow removal at curb ramps, bus
stops, and along bike lanes. Um, and I attached in the, the email that I sent to
you, the, um, Cedar Rapids 2019 Pedestrian Master Plan, partly because I
know there are a lot of concerns at what is this project that we're talking
about, uh, what's the scope of it. Uh, and again, I think that's something, um,
that we as a Council will need to, to consider if we support the idea, uh, but
what the Cedar Rapids plan suggested was, which was, you know, just two
years ago, um, identifying priority areas for its application, first of all. Uh, you
know, there's a recognition that, that, um, depending on the scope, this can be
an expensive, um, an expensive item. And so, the, the Cedar Rapids plan did
identify a number of priority zones based on the level of activity of
pedestrian, uh, movement, uh, in Cedar Rapids. I think a similar thing could
be done for Iowa City. Uh, in fact, I suspect the pedestrian activity in certainly
the center of town, may be as high as anywhere in the state of Iowa. As you
know, I mentioned earlier, the, these higher densities, which the Court
neighborhoods have, the there's a real reliance on pedestrian infrastructure
by those residents. So that's, that's one item that could, could result in a
budget cost. Uh, I, you know, obviously at this point, uh, we're, we're not
gonna be, uh, able to apply this to the current season that we're in, but I
would hope we could have a plan in place for winter of next year, um, to
develop, you know, this, this approach. Uh, the second, the second item
would be, uh, the, uh, creating safe and enjoyable and comfortable streets for
all forms of mobility, uh, with an emphasis on the major thoroughfares. And I
think the key issue here that I see is that many of our, our major
thoroughfares are what might be called unsafe by design. Uh, what we could
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 34
do with redesigning those streets is to make sure they self -regulate, uh,
which essentially would be prioritizing public safety over vehicle speed. Uh,
streets in an urban context with more than one lane in any one direction,
tend to have the most negative impacts. Uh, if we were to be successful in
better self-regulating our streets that should reduce police -officer -initiated
traffic stops and City personnel responding to crashes, which, you know, we
heard about our, from our Fire Chief, the, the degree to which our Fire
Department responds to emergency responses. I'm sure they are often, if not
always involved in responding to crashes. Uh, this may result in less office
interaction with the public, thus freeing up more officer time and department
resources for priority activities. So, what, what are the projects that would
fall under that category? Um, we talked about the reversion of Market and
Jefferson to two-way traffic. Um, you know, I'm pleased to see it back in the
CIP. I would certainly, given that this was identified as a, a high priority,
priority in the, in the Streetscape Master Plan, uh, which was adopted in
2014, that we could move it up perhaps to, uh, 2023,'24. Uh, right now it's in
the '25,'26, um, fiscal year. Um, in addition to that, I would hope we could, I
would, I would basically like to have an update in terms of the, the, um,
schedule for Gilbert Street. It's kind of been, again, many of these projects
have been on our strategic plan or, you know, noted as, as things that we
should be moving forward on, and I, I really just want an update on that. Uh,
although I would say, and I will perhaps point to this as well is at this
moment is I, uh, I've mentioned my concern with the safety that we are
achieving on our current bike lane systems, uh, so I would suggest that we,
it's been five years since our Bicycle Master Plan has been adopted, and, um,
we did not, uh, receive that Gold status that we've been seeking since 2016,
um, and one of the reasons, I think, based on the, the comments of the
evaluation was that our system, our system is not sufficiently friendly to
people of all ages, and I've kind of shared that concern. Uh, so it seems to me
after five years, maybe it's time to, to revisit, uh, our, our Master Plan and see
if there are any changes to our, our, the work that we're doing to better
ensure that they are, um, truly accessible to persons of all ages. Um, another
project, uh, that, that I've certainly been posing to, to Council and staff would
be Burlington Street. Um, I was just looking at the, the Downtown Riverfront
Crossings Master Plan, which was done about 10 years ago. And, um, they did
a, a geographic mapping exercise as a part of that master plan. And among
the comments was Burlington Street is a barrier. Address it. Uh, the
suggestion, uh, that I've been posing would be, uh, flexibly using the curb
lanes. It's a five -lane thoroughfare, the curb lanes for parking during off-peak
tra-, off-peak traffic hours, uh, that that's a strategy that's often used in cities,
which see a, you know, kind of a variable volume of traffic. Um, and, and they,
and they wanna try to make sure that the, the roadways, uh, capacity is, is
kind of consistent with that volume of traffic and provide parking
opportunities when they're available. Um, yesterday the, the Downtown
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 35
District's, uh, legislative committee gave tentative support to that pilot
project, um, which, which is what I'm suggesting again is not to, as I, as I did,
uh, several years ago on Washington Street, with the signalization at Linn and
Dubuque is, is it's this, this provides an oppor-, there, and with Burlington, an
opportunity to test an idea, you know, without investing a large sums of, of
money, uh, to see if in fact, this concept of, you know, flexibly using the curb
lanes is viable or not. Uh, but thus far, the, the legislative committee did give
a tentative support, raising concerns to it, with it. Um, the last project that I
would mention is Dodge and Governor, we, we saw presented today, it's in
the 2025 CIP, uh, this is a $15 million major capital project. And I guess I
would say my concern is as with these other streets, how well is it working?
You know, we, uh, back in September received a letter from Barbara Epstein,
who lives on Ronalds between, uh, Dodge and Governor. And, uh, she, she
wrote an email to us saying that, um, you know, she was attempting to cross
Governor to get to the cemetery. She had a leg injury, she thought she saw a
gap in traffic, um, but in fact, some cars northbound, um, almost ran her over.
I mean, she was, rushed to try to get out of the way of traffic, fell and, and
literally had to, to crawl to the other side of Governor Street. Um, Governor is
a, is a tough street it's, um, you know, it's got very, very few signalized
intersections. It's, uh, the, if you're northbound on Governor, the last light is
on Market and you have basically a straight shot up the hill to, uh, the hillside
without any other signalization, and it's almost a mile from Market before
you hit the, the top of the hill there. Um, so there are all kinds of problems
that we've, you know, I certainly, as, as a member of Council have seen letters
to the Council expressing concerns about the fact that it's difficult to cross.
There are lots of destinations on either side of Dodge and Governor as you,
you travel the corridor, park, schools, the cemetery, and so forth. So, I, I really
wanted to ask, is this really the best design that we, if we're committing to
the next 40 years with the design of Dodge and Governor, is this really what
we want? Um, this is our opportunity if, if we really want to try to give it a
more of a, um, you know, what might be referred to as a contextually
sensitive approach, this is the time. Um, and, and, you know, it's the, in our
lifetimes, it's gonna -- our only time to achieve this. Um, I also have down
here, you know, and we talked about this during the, um, policing
restructuring, the Police Department, the use of automated traffic
enforcement, uh, on major arterials where self-regulating street design may
not be feasible in the short term, you know, and in considering, uh, and
preparing these, these, this summary, you know, my personal feeling at this
point is that I would really prefer us at this time to emphasize the idea of
redesigning the streets so that they better self -regulate. Um, as a, as a first
strategy, um, you know, after all we are, we're dealing with streets that are
incentivizing, um, in their design speeds that are essentially illegal. We're
giving our Police Department an almost impossible job of enforcing those
laws because the streets are telling drivers to drive at unsafe speeds. So, so
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 36
that would be my, my suggestion at this time is, and, you know, I was the one
to advocate for the automated traffic enforcement, uh, at this point, um, I
would really like us to try to focus on making sure our streets are safe by
design rather than unsafe. Um, some, some other smaller items, uh, again, for
consideration, probably during the, um, strategic plan would be accelerating
the use of transportation alternatives through an electric bike incentive pilot
program, um, and then there's a, a pending work session, uh, that we haven't,
we haven't addressed yet, and that is, uh, within the neighborhood plan for
equitable distribution of high-quality destination parks and public spaces
with an, an easy, enjoyable, and safer walking and biking distance for all
residents. So that, that's in our work session. I modified the language a little
bit. Um, that concern, I think, has just been amplified by COVID, you know,
we, when we shelter in place, uh, and this is particularly true for children and
elderly, they, they are more or less limited to their immediate surroundings.
So, I'm, I'm really hopeful we can take a, a look at how we can plan our city so
that we do bring these destinations into closer proximity to those who are
walking and bicycling, um, the, under demonstrating leadership and climate
action, a minor, but I, I have heard concerns. We did, we recently hear, hear a
concern from someone living at the, um, Prairie Hill cohousing, and that is,
uh, revising our backyard chicken ordinance. Um, right now there are some
language in there, um, which limits where you can have chickens, uh,
currently it's single family residential, uh, and then there's also a
requirement that you get the permission of your neighbors. Um --
Teague: Um, I will say, make sure we're keeping it to a budget item that's more
strategic, strategic planning, right.
Thomas: Right -- I, I'm just, I just wanted to, you know --
Teague: -- not notice to the public.
Thomas: Yeah. This has no cost, no cost associated with it, uh, um, but I, I, I just
wanted to put it out there, so you had some time to think about it. Um, so, so
that's basically the items that, that I have, um, I've identified, most of them
have a, a fairly long history to them. Um, you know, I'm keenly aware of the
fact that this will be, you know, the last, these next two years will be my last,
most likely on City Council. Um, many of these things have been, uh, you
know, on the, on the radar since I've been on Council. Uh, so I'm, I'm really
hopeful we can, um, you know, and, and when we developed them six years
ago, we hadn't gone through Black Lives Matter and COVID, and all these
other things, which I think have certainly, in my mind, accelerated the need
to, to consider these the, you know, the approaches I've been suggesting. Um,
so I, I, it is, I apologize for the kind of, uh, going beyond the budget and the,
the CIP. Um, I, I will say, you know, when I, when Pauline and I first started in
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 37
2016, we had a strategic plan disc--, that discussion took place in December
before we even took office. And I'm, I'm wondering if that may be, you know,
doing it in the, in front of the budget discussions rather than after our budget
discussions might make sense, because I, I think it's helpful to have that
overarching vision when, when thinking about, um, questions relating to the
budget and the CIP. I know, I know in that 2016, uh, strategic plan discussion,
it generated some items that then were incorporated into the budget and,
and resulted in some changes. So, um, again, thanks for giving me the
opportunity here. And, um, I'm very interested to know what your thoughts
are on these, these items.
Taylor: I'll just make a quick comment since he mentioned my name. Um, that
experience was amazing. Awesome and amazing as you would say, uh,
Mayor, uh, because it was not only the new incoming Council members, but
the current sitting members that were going to be outgoing. We all, as a
group, sat together in a room out at Ashton House and put this strategic plan
together with all of our thoughts. And so, it was really an amazing experience.
And I, I would suggest that we do that again, but I just had a few comments,
mostly relating to parks. I apologize, Julie, um, no real complaints or
concerns. Uh, it's just that one of the items, and John mentioned the length of
time we've been on the Council, and it seemed like it was when former Mayor
Pro Tem Salih came on board. So, it was over four years ago. Uh, we talked
about, and I think it's still on our potential work session agendas, the
possibility of the rubber surface at the parks and playgrounds, uh, but I see
that, um, I think it's the Market Square playground replacement, uh, is going
to be replaced with, um, wood fiber or something was, I think was, it was not
the rubberized. And so I had a concern about that, and, and, uh, we
mentioned at that time we might work together with the Iowa City
Community School District. And I know at that time with the Long, their
Longfellow playground, when they replaced it, they had three different, uh,
grounds. They, they did the rubberized and the wood fiber and, and a third
one to kind of study which one they thought would work best, um, lasted
longer, cost less, et cetera. So, I, I'm, I was just kind of discouraged to see that,
that the rubberized was going to be replaced and wondered, 'cause I think
it's still on our work session, possible discussions, uh, whether we could, uh,
go back to that, 'cause, uh, we talked about it being a safer surface, although it
was a little more expensive, but it lasted longer. So that was one of my
concerns. The other was the, uh, replacement of the, um, shelters at City Park.
Uh, I know we got a letter, but even before we got the letter that kind of, uh,
did red flags from you, 'cause, it, um, City Park and those shelters I've seen
over the years as, as a great venue for play -- people, for large gatherings, uh,
and, and I know it's been limited lately because of COVID, but it actually, with
those open air shelters is, is a better place for people to gather, uh, they felt
safer being in, in the outdoors with the open air. Um, so I, parks have always
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 38
been to me synonymous with picnics and it's, it's a lot nicer to have a picnic
inside a shelter if you've got a large group, but along with that, if, if we can't
do that, if we're thinking that there's not a need for that, uh, I would hope
that perhaps we're the planning to, um, add some picnic tables, something for
these people that see the park as a gathering place for picnics, uh, would have
some place to sit and eat and be comfortable, uh, particularly in a shady spot,
not out in the sun, direct sun, but with the new trees and et cetera. So, um,
those were just, uh, my concerns. That's all.
Fruin: Just to quickly respond and um, there's a Parks Commission meeting that
started at five, so that's why Juli had to leave, otherwise I'd be deferring to
her, but, um, uh, regarding the surfacing, that's certainly something your
Parks Commission has talked quite a bit about and you, um, should be seeing
a lot more of that rubber surfacing throughout our system, so they're taking
in that kind of geographic, uh, analysis approach to all these projects. Uh,
you've seen some rubberized surfacing, um, come up at City Park, um, at, uh,
Wetherby Park, Willow Creek Park, um, are some recent examples of projects
that we've done where we've just incorporated either all or a portion of that
playground, uh, with rubber surfacing. So just want you to know that your
Parks Commission is paying very close attention to that issue. And yes, we
are able to, to kind of learn from some of those early experiences from the
school district as well. And then the, the, the City Park, um, shelters, you
know, that's something we can certainly, um, revisit, uh, down the road. That
project is not a near-term project. That's a few years out, looks to me like it's
a, um, '24 project. And particularly as Juli mentioned with the Upper City
Park, that's gonna be, we're gonna hit that pretty hard with the master plan.
So, I think we'll be able to spend some time, we can kind of flag Council's
interest in analyzing shelter locations and number of shelters and that sort of
thing. But I wouldn't worry about spending too much time on that now since
that project's a few years down the road.
Taylor: Thank you.
Teague: Any other comments?
Harmsen: I had a quick question about the, uh, digester, um, uh, project. Um, you had
mentioned something about it, uh, replacement being needed because of a
mineral buildup that was in turn caused by, uh, phosphorus that was being
treated, um, and maybe something that's been talked about in earlier Council
sessions, so I'm new, so I'm catching me up to speed. Just curious if it's, uh, if
there's anything as, is this a repair that's being, uh, sped up or caused more
soon because of this phosphorous issue, um, any ideas on where this is
coming from? Is this something that we should be thinking about? Um, either
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 39
that, yeah, just kind of just some background on that, just to, just to know,
what's, what's sort of driving that.
Knoche: Yeah, so, uh, when we did our last plant upgrade, we changed the process
and, and how a little bit of the process and how our, how the wastewaters
treated. And, and so with that process, it actually precipitates out the
phosphorus, and so the, the, the nutrients that are there in the water
precipitates it out, and it actually comes out in the piping system, uh, as it
goes through the kind of the sludge processing, uh, piece of it, and so, um, it,
it's, this is a, a process change that, um, is, is, is one that is, is being done
across the country. Um, it was an unforeseen issue. Uh, and so now we're in
the process of figuring out how to address that. And I, I think with the
digestor upgrade, we'll be looking at a, at ways to, to basically try to
precipitate that out prior, you know, basically in a controlled manner versus
it in an uncontrolled manner, which is what we have now.
Harmsen: Okay, thank you.
Knoche: Yep.
Teague: I do wanna make a comment, just, uh, circling back to some of the things
that were brought up, um, by Councilor Thomas. Um, a lot of this, uh, stuff, as
I mentioned, we'll be able to really take up and give it some, uh, the time that
it's, it's needed to discuss. One thing I will say. Um, it least for me, when I
think about a lot of these, a lot of the things that he pointed out, revisiting the
Bike Master Plan, and as well as, um, some other initiatives when we were
talking about traffic enforcement and, and things of that nature, one thing,
um, I at least wanted to mention when it comes down to the budget that we
might consider, um, it wouldn't be now, but that we can give some thought to
is that Market Street/Jefferson, um, I, I think I heard him say that, um, in
2014 it was toward this, um, top of the list, um, and so that's something that I
think, um, we will be able to discuss here in the near future. Other than that,
I, um, do think, um, when I look of, when I look at the list, um, there is nothing
that strikes me that is more immediate, although we could have some, um,
direction given to staff for like our next budget cycle, which typically we, um,
do in August, uh, for the following year. And so we would want to have those
discussions between now and then, so that we can, amongst the Council, uh,
determine what of those have some init-, you know, have some speed, um,
and again, I think some of this will come out in our strategic planning
because I did like how, uh, you kind of went through and gave some of the
titles of how it falls, uh, with the Council, um, or past in, uh, Council's, uh,
priorities.
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 40
Weiner: Yeah. I just wanna touch on a Cou-, a few things that Councilor Thomas
mentioned, uh, basically the two, the, the one-way street conversion with,
with Market and Jefferson. Uh, I'm definitely interested in revisiting and I
appreciate your calling to our attention, um, uh, Dodge/Governor. I think that
is, that's definitely worthwhile taking a close look at, and finally having lived
various places where, um, there are projects such as he proposes for
Burlington, um, I, I think that's a, a potentially really, um, worthwhile project
to examine.
Teague: I'll also mention that I think it's really good to have a lot of the, uh, the, the
staff here that, um, facilitate a lot of those initial, uh, conversations kind of
heard some of this. I think that's beneficial as well.
Fruin: Just real quick, um, the Market/Jefferson, uh, as you have deliberations, if you
want to move that up, um, we really don't think there's any way to get that
project done, start to finish until '24. That would be the earliest that we could
do that. Um, if we ordered new traffic signals right now, we wouldn't get 'em
this coming construction season. Uh, there, there's that much of a delay in
receiving those, but with that project, we, we still need to do full design. And
that's a, that's one where you're gonna want a lot of public input. Um, uh, I
don't think that's gonna be as a popular of a project with everybody as, as we
might think. We know the Downtown District is supportive of that, but as you
get into more serious discussions, you should, you should expect some
controversy with that. It doesn't mean we shouldn't pursue it, but that adds
to the process, um, we just have to be a little bit more deliberate with, with,
how we go about public input. So, if you do wanna move that up, um, I'd
suggest '24, '25, um, but we're gonna have to do some gymnastics with other
projects because that's over $2 million in bond funds. And we couldn't just
layer that on top of whatever that year's bonding is, if we want to maintain
kind of that, um, uh, level bonding year to year and level debt service, um,
type of project. So, staff would have to give you some options on other
projects to, to delay or remove in order to move that up.
Teague: Since there, uh, will be the, well, we know that this will go out to the public
and will, people will weigh in on it, seems to me that it's gonna be very vital
for us to kind of start those deliberations since it's already been delayed. And,
um, it, it, it is had some on-off, off the CIP, um, so I would suggest that, um, I
did hear three Councilors, uh, give support for it. Um, I don't know if there's
any other Council that would give support to kind of move it up to the 2024,
so we can give direction to staff at this point.
Alter: I'm certainly interested. Um, I didn't know if this was like a session in which,
um, indicating that kind of interest actually does, is this just moving forward
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 41
in next steps of being able to look at this? Or is this the moment at which
we're saying, okay, now this is 20 --
Fruin: It's all budget, so you can, yes. Okay.
Alter: I mean, I'm, I, I know that this has been on the radar and it has something
desired for, um, several years, 10 years now. Um, so I'm also mindful that big
changes create big reactions, and so I think that it does make sense to, uh, get
public input and probably sooner rather than later, because this is just going
to potentially, keep getting down the road.
Teague: So, it does sound like we have a supportive four, so well, uh, direct staff to
do that. And I'm sure that University of Iowa will, will probably need to, we
would want to know what they're doing beyond Clinton, um, 'cause there
was some concern in the past that they may be cutting off that street.
Fruin: Can I just get some clarification? What, what is the direction are you asking
us to move the construction up to '24? That is, what design up, the design up
to '23 or you --
Teague: '24. I, I, I heard 23, 24 from, uh, Councilor Thomas, and with your concerns
about how, you know, fast as it can go, um, do we have direction for 2024...
Fruin: The design or construction?
Teague: I would assume construction.
Fruin: Okay. So, do you want us to start design? We would typically start design a
year earlier...are you saying you want that design to start in '22?
Teague: Correct. To get the ball moving because there's a lot of elements to it.
Fruin: Okay. So, we're gonna have to come back to you probably at Tuesday and,
and work through some gymnastics on other projects here, 'cause, like I said,
we're gonna, we're gonna have to move some things around, okay, to make
the bonding work. Unless -- you wanna bond more in that particular year.
And we'll just have to explain the implications there.
Teague: Okay.
Bergus: Yeah. I, I think we would just wanna be really careful about understanding
what that might mean. Like our deadline for increasing our debt service levy,
for example. I don't know if, Geoff, that's, if you're going that far, if that's
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 42
what you're saying that we would need to, um, have additional capacity that
we would be raising taxes for, to move it up that far.
Fruin: I -- I think that's what we need to look at if there's not a willingness to delay
something else or push something else back, um, then yes, we might, we
might have to have that conversation.
Alter: Well, what I was sort of clumsily saying is that I would like to know what,
without saying, yes, let's move. Uh, let me start over. I would like to know
what the potential things that would be removed would be so that we can
make a decision about the relative value of whether we move forward with
the two-way, of that jumping forward in, um, the, the plans and the execution
of them, um, in relation to what the other projects are that would be pushed
back or removed altogether. So that was actually where I, what I was
attempting to say, um, it was not that I was giving a, a thumbs up
unremittingly. I would like to know the context of like, if we're doing this,
what can we not do in, in its place? So, yeah.
Teague: And I think that's fair.
Alter: Thank you for allowing me to, to revisit that.
Teague: Yeah, I think that's fair. Um, at least for all of us, we need to know what
we're talking about in big picture. Um, and so at least, um, we're, we're
directing staff to kind of bring us some information back.
Alter: Yeah.
Teague: With the, you know, we have to state when we would like it, the 2024 and
then move forward from there. And, but we will have still that ability to get
some information, to make a final decision.
Alter: Okay.
Teague: Because it does have, uh, a domino effect on other, correct, on other
projects.
Alter: Thank you.
Bergus: Yeah. I'd be interested in, in talking about, you know, what we might trade
out for it. But I I'm hearing from our City Manager that we may not have the
capacity for something that would be as aggressive as construction in '24
without some much more serious implications. So, I'd, I'd urge us to look at
maybe, you know, right now it's on '26, could we absorb it in '25 without
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 43
trading out other things? I mean, that, that's kind of where my head is at. Just,
I don't, I don't feel like we have the time right now to get more information,
come back, consider how that affects our debt capacity. Right. If it's $2
million for, and also for our staff, if we're not currently under the, you know,
if we're not designing it now, I don't know how we can build it in '24.
Harmsen: Yeah. I, I think I, I, I, uh, that, that makes sense. I think I can agree that we
can look at, maybe it sounds like we're talking about two options moving it
up a year sooner or two years sooner. Right. And so, you know, from '26 to
'25 or from '26 to '24, so depending on which one of those is the most
feasible, I do agree this, this is something that, that, uh, does seem like a good
idea to pursue. Um, and it, you know, obviously we had been caught up on
some of the history behind it, so, um, but I think, uh, like I think, uh, Council
member Alter, and, uh, Bergus have said that it would be good to sort of see
what, which dominoes that affects, those two different sorts of options. So
yeah.
Fruin: So, what we'll do is we'll, we'll discuss it internally and try to get you
something it'll probably be in your late handouts for Tuesday. We'll, we'll, uh,
have some budget time or some, sorry, some work session, time reserved for
budget. And, uh, we'll just give you some preliminary scenarios, uh, on
Tuesday, uh, and, and, uh, let you know, kind of how we think that could
work to, to move it up a year or two.
Alter: Okay. Is there an appetite, there are a number of suggestions that don't
necessarily, some have a specific timeline, um, and others are suggestions
about, you know, what makes for a more livable city, um, and I'm, is there an
appetite to sort of bundle those into getting some public opinion well in
advance of whether this is now, on the table about deciding them, just so we
can start gathering input? So, for instance, I agree, I think it's a great idea to
talk about parking on Burlington during off peak hours. I'm one person, what
it would be great to get some input from people, ditto, the Mar-, um,
Governor and Dodge, right. And to find out how people feel about this, to see
whether that's even, you know, something that we want to pursue or in its, in
what kind of iteration. So, I'm thinking of like a survey or something. And I
know that right now is not the time to worry about that, um, given the
constraints of what staff has to, have, what staff has to be doing right now,
but I just put that out there as, you know, later in the year, if this is something
where we can start gathering information about the ways in which we would
like to get public input on changes, potential changes. Um, so I just, probably
not a new idea at all, but I just throw it out there.
Teague: It's important, I think, to always point out the public, um, appetite, uh, for
some of these, and I think, um, oftentimes we might be, um, talking a little too
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 44
aggressively here and not just putting it in the public's hand, um, at, you
know, early on.
Bergus: Well, I, I just wanna voice some support for things that Councilor Thomas
said in the, like the bigger picture and Mayor, as you said, having staff here
and my apologies, we're holding everybody, now, almost till 5:30, um, but,
but I do think from a strategic planning perspective, like being able to tie the
projects as they are in our budget book, every single one says, how does this
match the strategic plan objectives or priorities? Um, but I don't know that
we as a group and certainly as a new group really can say, okay, you know,
when we're talking about changes to it or things that we wanna see
prioritized, I don't, I don't feel like we're kind of anchoring those things
necessarily very, at least very openly or, you know, in our discussion. So, I
really just wanna reiterate and thank John for, for bringing that up and
saying, are we sort of frontloading those priorities? Um, we talk about how
much money we're spending on roads and street reconstruction and, uh, car -
centric mobility, and I really think that what, um, John, what you said about
making our communities, the, you know, as accessible and livable for
children, for disabled people, for the elderly, and kind of deemphasizing our
reliance on motor vehicles. If we agree on that as a goal, if that's something
that we're talking about that would really help our staff kind of understand, I
think, big picture priorities, but I don't, we haven't articulated something like
that yet.
Teague: And we'll be able to do that in our strategic plan a little more.
Bergus: I think so.
Fruin: Yeah, and I, I, I think you've already done that. I mean, past Councils have
done that and hopefully you're seeing that reflected in the built changes. We,
we just can't touch every road every year, right. I mean, it's a, it's a systematic
process, but as you look at the new roads that are being constructed, as you
look at how we've reconstructed roads, hopefully you're seeing those
priorities play out. Um, and if not, we need to, we need to hear it. But, um, you
know, that's, that has been a priority for, for Engineering, for, for our, for our
Public Works staff, for the consultants that we're working on, because that's
been the direction we've been given, past Councils. That's why you're seeing
25 mile per hour speed limits on, on some of our major arterials. That's why
you're seeing new bike lanes pop up. You're seeing grade -separated
pedestrian, um, crossings. Those types of things are as a direct result of that
exact direction that we've been given.
Teague: Right. Any other item for today?
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 45
Thomas: I did, I did want to, I haven't heard any response, uh, on the, uh, the core
neighborhood initiative, the three items there. Uh, I'm not sure what that,
that's, your lack of comment means, if it's that --
Teague: Uh, so are you talking about like Ronalds Street --
Thomas: Ronalds, the form -based Code and the, you know, the developing some
language for residential tax abatement, those, those were three items that,
you know, came out of this working group that, you know, is trying to
develop a strategy to, to, to deal with the threats that are felt there. Um, and I
haven't heard any response. I, I don't know Geoff, if you feel, I mean, we could
carry over this conversation, but I was just a little bit sensitive to the, this
matter of, to what degree because they're somewhat open ended in terms of
their financial implications, what kind of direction we needed to give now.
Fruin: Yeah. I, I could really quickly go through those. 724 Ronalds, um, our staff has
been working on putting together an RFP. We're gonna be asking, we're
gonna be, uh, moving forward with demolition of that property, but it's
gonna require a 30 -day period for Historic Preservation to weigh in, uh,
there, because it's in a, it's in a district. Um, our plan is to do an RFP and, and
extol the goals of affordable housing and energy efficiency and see what we
get, um, as we've done in the past with some of these projects, we'll share
that RFP with Council before we issue it and, and get your feedback. Um, we,
we certainly could look at using affordable housing funds, climate funds,
those types of things to enhance, uh, or to incentivize the development that
we're seeking. Um, the form -based Code for the, uh, core neighborhood, I
think that's a discussion that you probably need to have with the, uh, with the
broader context of planning initiatives. We've had that conversation. We
know we have a lot of district plans to upgrade. We know we have three or
four form -based codes kind of hanging out there in order to pursue. Um, I
think you just need that, that context of, here's how much NDS can handle in,
in a given year or two, what are your priorities? This can certainly be added
to that list. Um, but it, it, you know, that is a, a very, uh, small focus, uh, uh,
with just the core neighborhoods there. And then the urban revitalization
area. Um, we did, we just did something similar, uh, for commercial purposes
on Highway 1 and Highway 6 that took us over a year to put together, um,
that that was done, um, by Wendy Ford and the Economic Development
office with significant help from the Attorney's office and, and Public Works
with some surveying. So, we can certainly do that. That's another type of just
priority, um, uh, uh, issue. So I don't know that that has a huge, uh, budget
implication, other than we'd have to report to you, um, kind of what some of
the, um, you know, if, if, if taxes are being abated, obviously that could put
some strain on the budget, but, um, in terms of just the mechanics of pulling
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.
Page 46
it together, um, you're looking at probably a year plus of periodic staff work
to, to advance that.
Teague: Right. Anything else? No. All right. I think we are done for today and I wish
everybody an awesome and amazing day. Thanks for coming.
This represents only a reasonably accurate transcription of the Iowa City City Council
work session of January 12, 2022.