Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout6-6-24 PAAC Agenda PacketPublic Art Advisory Committee Thursday, June 6, 2024 3:30 PM Emma Harvat Hall City Hall, 410 E. Washington AGENDA 1. Call to order 2. Public discussion of any items not on the agenda 3. Consider minutes of the April 4, 2024 PAAC Meeting 4. South District Bus Stop Bench Project Update & Contract Discussion 5. Sculptor’s Showcase Selections for 2024-2026 6. Discuss FY2025 Budget Priorities 7. Staff updates a. Arts Stakeholder Meeting – New Date TBD b. July Meeting Date (falls on July 4th holiday) 8. Old or New Business 9. Adjournment If you will need disability-related accommodations in order to participate in this program/event, please contact Rachel Kilburg Varley, Public Art Coordinator at 319-356-5014 or rkilburg@iowa-city.org. Early requests are strongly encouraged to allow sufficient time to meet your access needs. Draft, p.1 Public Art Advisory Committee Mtg, 4/4/2024 Minutes Public Art Advisory Committee April 4, 2024 Emma Harvat Hall Public Art Advisory Committee Members Present: Ben Clark, Steve Miller, Andrea Truitt, Jeremy Endsley, Rachel Kinker, Leslie Finer, Nate Sullivan Members Absent: Anita Jung, Juli Seydell Johnson Staff present: Rachel Kilburg Varley Public Present: None Call to Order Miller called the meeting to order at 3:36 p.m. Public Discussion of Any Item Not on the Agenda None. Introduction of new members: Leslie Finer and Rachel Kinker Committee members introduced themselves and welcomed new members, Kinker and Finer. Officer elections: Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson Per the PAAC by-laws, officers must be elected annually in February or the first possible meeting thereafter. Sullivan nominated Miller for the role of Chairperson, Clark seconded. Miller nominated Truitt for the role of Vice-Chairperson, Endsley seconded. Miller made motion to approve these nominations, motion passed (7-0). Consider minutes of the February 1, 2024 PAAC meeting. Truitt moved and Endsley seconded that the minutes from the February 1, 2024, meeting be approved. Motion passed (7-0). Determine Awards for the 2024 Public Art Matching Grant Program Committee members individually scored 2024 Public Art Matching Grant applications using a scoring rubric prior to the April PAAC meeting. Kilburg projected the compiled scores and anonymous comments for Committee review and discussion. Kilburg shared that $15,500 was available to award and approximately $46,505 in funding was requested. She noted that a few applicants (Open Air Media Festival, Public Space One, Family Folk Machine) were previous recipients of Public Art Matching Grant funds, though that does not disqualify them from being funded again. Kilburg also mentioned that after several Committee members had commented that two applicants’ proposed project budgets were incomplete, she reached out to those applicants to seek Draft, p.2 Public Art Advisory Committee Mtg, 4/4/2024 clarification. Kilburg provided budget clarification received back on one of those grant proposals. Finer asked whether other Committee members felt the Open Air Media Festival submission was different enough from the past to warrant funding. Miller mentioned it is an annual event and that they are continuing to grow and invite new artists each year, but suggested the Committee consider allocating less than the amount requested. Finer asked whether there was a minimum funding requirement the Committee had to follow and Kilburg said the Committee has the discretion to make an award at any amount they desire. Sullivan noted that Open Air Media Festival, Quicker than a Ray of Light, Summer Groove Dance, This Too Shall Pass, Refocus Film Festival, Illuminating Excellence, and the Writing Garden proposals received the highest scores and suggested the Committee decide whether and how much to fund each of these top proposals. Miller suggested maxing out grant awards at $3,000 in order to fund all of these proposals. Committee members deliberated briefly. Several Committee members mentioned they liked the Englert’s grant application and were disappointed it fell just outside of the top scores. Kilburg pointed out that, if funded, Open Air Media Festival will have been a top scoring application and funded for five years in a row. She suggested that, in the future, the Committee could consider funding that annual event as a sponsorship, rather than continuing to put it through the grant program, which would make more funding available for other projects. The Committee decided to discuss that possibility in the future before the next grant cycle. Sullivan made a motion to approve the following Public Art Matching Grant allocations, Finer seconded: • Open Air Media Festival - $3,000 • Quicker Than Ray of Light Then Gone - $1,725 • Summer Groove Dance – $555 • This Too Shall Pass – $3,000 • Refocus Film Festival – $3,000 • Illuminating Excellence - $3,000 • Writing Garden - $1,500 Motion passed (7-0). Discuss Sculptor’s Showcase Program for 2024-2026 Kilburg Varley reviewed that the Sculptor’s Showcase has been being offered annually, in which the Committee issues a Call for Artists to submit sculptures for consideration Draft, p.3 Public Art Advisory Committee Mtg, 4/4/2024 and selection for placement on one of 8 pads throughout the community. For the next round, staff recommended the following changes: • Transitioning from a one-year to two-year display period, which would lessen burden on both artists and City staff and open up additional budget flexibility in the “off” years; • Increasing the artist honorarium due to a longer display period; and • Streamlining the application form and imposing a maximum limit of 3 artwork submissions per artist. Committee members agreed with the proposed two-year cycle and discussed the amount of the honorarium and directed Kilburg to research stipends paid to artists in similar programs in other communities and establish a competitive rate based on that. Sullivan made a motion to accept the memorandum and increase the honorarium rate to no more than $2,500 for two years, Finer seconded. Motion passed (7-0). Discuss Lucas Farms Neighborhood & Meskwaki/Sauk History Project Kilburg shared that, after the Call for Qualifications for this project was unsuccessful, she contacted faculty at the Meskwaki Settlement School to discuss a possible partnership on a public art installation that involved students through art and trades curriculum. The students would have the opportunity to develop a design based on neighborhood input, fabricate the installation through their coursework, and install the project under the leadership of the faculty. Kilburg shared a proposal letter the faculty drafted which included a couple of concept ideas to demonstrate how they would approach the project. She clarified that the Committee was not selecting one of these concepts but should indicate whether they wish to move forward with this process. A concept would still be developed by the school faculty and students in partnership with the neighborhood, with final concept approval by the Committee. Discuss South District Bus Stop Bench Project Kilburg reminded the Committee that, after several delays due to budget issues, the Committee increased the project budget in September 2023 and has been waiting for an updated timeline and budget from the artist and artist mentor in order to amend the initial agreements. They artists submitted an updated budget just prior to the April 4, 2024 PAAC meeting, which was below the established $24,000 maximum budget (just under $20,000). Miller asked about the responsiveness and timeliness of the artist/mentor on previous milestones. Kilburg shared that she had established monthly check-in meetings with the artist/mentor and there had been some difficulty with seeing progress be made over the last few months. Committee members discussed setting specific and firm project milestone deadlines to ensure the project stays on track. Kilburg suggested signing a first amendment to their agreements which would deliver the 4:1 scale metal model by May 15th. If that deliverable was met, then the Committee could consider signing a second amendment with the artist/mentor to complete the project in full, with those firm and specific milestone deadlines included. Truitt Draft, p.4 Public Art Advisory Committee Mtg, 4/4/2024 suggested the Committee invites the artist/mentor to provide more frequent progress updates at PAAC meetings, and not just with staff. She also asked whether making smaller, more incremental payments to the artist/mentor is possible to ensure the deliverables are being met. Miller asked Kilburg to work with the City Attorney’s Office to determine the right contract language that accomplishes the Committee’s interest in firm deadlines and fiscal responsibility. Kinker made a motion to authorize an agreement amendment with both the artist and mentor for the completion of the 4:1 scale metal model, Sullivan seconded. Motion passed (7-0). Outreach & Engagement Subcommittee Updates Miller mentioned a draft agenda for the Arts Stakeholder Meeting was included in the agenda packet and asked for any comments or feedback. The Committee members discussed possible dates and Truitt and Finer encouraged staff to consider a guest speaker who would be a fresh voice for attendees. Miller also suggested lengthening the period for discussion and that the agenda timeline overall felt a little rushed. Kilburg agreed to incorporate these suggestions and continue planning the event. Staff Updates Kilburg shared that the Downtown Iowa City Cultural & Entertainment District launched a new marketing campaign, “X Marks the Arts,” and encouraged Committee members to subscribe to the newsletter. Kilburg Varley also shared that she is unable to attend the May PAAC meeting and will have another staff member lead the meeting in her absence. Miller and Truitt shared their experiences and thoughts on the Regional Arts Summit which they attended in March. Adjournment Clark moved to adjourn at 4:39 pm. Sullivan seconded. Motion passed (7-0). Draft, p.5 Public Art Advisory Committee Mtg, 4/4/2024 Public Art Advisory Committee Attendance Record 2023-2024 Name Term Expires 2/2/23 4/6/22 5/4/22 6/8/23 7/6/23 8/3/23 9/7/23 11/2/23 12/7/23 1/4/24 2/1/24 Ron Knoche X X* X X X X X* X X X* X Juli Seydell- Johnson X X X X X X X O/E X* X X Steve Miller 12/31/23 X O/E X X X X X X X X X Eddie Boyken 12/31/24 O/E X O/E O/E O/E O/E O -- -- -- -- Andrea Truitt 12/31/25 X X X X X X X X X O/E X Anita Jung 6/30/23 X X X X O/E O/E X X X X X Jenny Gringer 12/31/23 X O/E O/E X X X O/E O/E X -- -- Jeremy Endsley 12/31/25 O/E O/E X X O/E X O X X X X Nate Sullivan 6/30/26 --- --- --- --- X X X X X O/E O/E Key: X = Present X* = Delegate attended O = Absent O/E = Absent/Excused --- = Not a member South District Bus Stop Bench – Revised Budget Subtotal Parts/Labor Paid Out Remaining Phase 1: Concept Design $1,300 Mentor Labor $1,300 -- $2,000 Artist Labor $2,000 -- $3,300 Phase 1 Subtotal $3,300 $0 Phase 2: Fabrica�on of 4:1-Scale Metal Model $1,191.58 Materials (qty x price): • 2in .120 EW Steel tubes lnr ft (113 x $4.64) • 14G Steel - 4ft x 10ft sheets (2 x 283.63) • Bolts & hardware (1 x $100) $1,191.58 -- $700 Artist Labor -- $700 $1,891.58 Phase 2 Subtotal $1,191.58 $700 Phase 3: Fabrica�on & Installa�on of Final Project $2,805 Artist Labor $2,805 $700 Mentor Labor $700 $7,684.29 Materials (qty x price): • 2in .120 EW Steel tubes lnr ft (450 x $4.64) • 14G Steel - 4ft x 10ft sheets (10 x $283.63) • Finishes - primer, paint, etc ( 4 x $150) • Floor Mounted Jib Crane (1 x $2,606.06) $8,130.36 $1,150.00 Equipment rental (telehandler - 1 week) $1,150.00 $2,500.00 Cement Footing/Foundation $2,500.00 $5,000.00 Structural Engineer (30 hours x $100/hr) $5,000.00 + 700 Credit: unspent funds for materials from Phase 2 +$700.00 $19,585.36 Phase 3 Subtotal $0 $19,585.36 $24,776.94* Project Total $4,491.58 $20,285.36** *Budget not to exceed: $24,000 **At least $776.94 needs to be reduced from amount remaining to be paid out. Amendment #2 to Agreement for The South District Bus Stop Bench Art Project by and between the City and Ethan Wyatt Whereas, on March 8, 2023, the City of Iowa City, hereinafter referred to as the CITY and Ethan Wyatt, hereinafter referred to as ARTIST, entered in the Agreement for the South District Bus Stop Bench Project by and between the City and Ethan Wyatt, hereinafter referred to as the Agreement; and Whereas, the Agreement requires ARTIST to complete certain phases of the public art project, hereinafter PROJECT, by certain dates; and Whereas, on April 16, 2024, the City and ARTIST amended the Agreement to provide additional time for the ARTIST to complete the fabrication of a 4:1 scale metal model and the City agreed to increase the overall project budget to no more than $24,000; and Whereas, the City has paid ARTIST $3,191.58 for labor and cost of materials for metal model; and Whereas, although ARTIST has not completed all remaining phases as required under the Agreement, the City and ARTIST desire to allow ARTIST additional time to complete the full scope of the PROJECT. NOW THEREFORE, it is agreed by and between the City and ARTIST to further amend the amended Agreement as set forth herein. Article 1, entitled Scope of Services, is amended by deleting Paragraph 1.1b in its entirety and the following new Paragraph 1.1b is substituted in lieu thereof: b. ARTIST shall work with the Project Mentor and CITY’S REPRESENTATIVE to produce and install the PROJECT by September 30, 2024, according to the following schedule: Deadline Payment Milestone June 30, 2024 ARTIST will identify the materials to be purchased along with the cost of the materials by this date. The City will promptly make a payment to ARTIST for the cost of the materials upon City review and approval of the materials to be purchased. After purchasing the materials, ARTIST must provide receipts from the materials to the City, and any unspent funds will be subtracted from future payments or reimbursement requests owed. Aug. 30, 2024 Artist Payment #1 ($1,403)* Fabricate sculpture & installation of concrete pad and footings Sept. 30, 2024 Artist Payment #2 ($1,403)* Install jib crane & sculpture ARTIST shall also submit invoices for any equipment rental, concrete pad and footings, and structural engineer services by this date. The City will promptly make a payment to the vendor upon City review and approval.* The City shall not make any payments in excess of the maximum project budget or for any ineligible expenses. It is the responsibility of the ARTIST to obtain pre-approval from the City for such expenses to avoid incurring ineligible expenses. *less any unspent funds from the payment for materials • ARTIST agrees and acknowledges the PROJECT is incomplete. • If ARTIST fails to meet any of the milestones by the deadline, the City may terminate this Agreement as provided for herein, and if terminated, the City shall not be obligated to pay ARTIST any remaining scheduled payments, and ARTIST shall immediately reimburse the City for the funds the City paid to ARTIST to purchase the materials. • City payments shall not exceed $24,000, less all expenses already paid out to this Agreement ($3,191.58) and under the separate Mentor Agreement dated January 4, 2023 ($1,300). All other provisions of the Agreement and Amendment #1 to the Agreement, not inconsistent with this amendment, remain in full force and effect. ARTIST _________________________________________________________ Ethan Wyatt Date Artist CITY _________________________________________________________ Geoff Fruin Date City Manager Approved: ______________ City Attorney’s Office PUBLIC ART SPECIFICATIONS AND MAINTENANCE REPORT ARTIST: TITLE OF WORK: PROJECT ADDRESS PART I - FABRICATION AND INSTALLATION INFORMATION MATERIALS 1. Material(s) used (be specific; include also source or manufacturer, life expectancy of material according to manufacturer; attach manufacturer's technical data sheets, if available): 2. Material finish (e.g., natural, paint color and type, glaze, patina, sealer, fire retardant, etc.; be specific; include also brand or manufacturer): 3. Materials used in the presentation of the artwork (e.g., composition of base or backing, framing, type of hanging fixtures, etc.): FABRICATION 1. Fabricator Name: Address: Phone Number: 2. Fabrication technique or method (attach diagrams or drawings, if necessary): INSTALLATION 1. Installation executed by: Name: Address: Phone Number: 2. Installation method (attach plans showing footing and/or key installation details): EXTERNAL FACTORS 1. Describe physical positioning of the artwork (e.g., measured distances from relative objects or points in the environment): 2. Describe existing environmental factors which may affect the condition of the artwork and any precautionary measures (e.g., direct sunlight, extremes of annual rain, temperature, air moisture or dryness, acidity of rainfall, flooding, wind, erosion, vibrations, air pollutants, vehicular and/or pedestrian traffic; animal interaction--bird droppings, potential for nesting, burrowing; human interaction with artwork--touching, sitting, climbing, vandalism): DESIRED APPEARANCE 1. Describe the desired appearance in specific terms including the physical qualities such as matte rather than glossy luster; color of patina etc., for which the agency should strive in order to maintain the artist's intent. Describe what may be acceptable alterations in form surface, texture and coloration as related to natural aging of materials. Include drawings or photographs which show the condition of the artwork upon installation: 2. If the work is site-specific, describe in detail the particular relationship of the work to its site, including any significant physical aspects of the site, which, if altered, would significantly alter the artist's intended meaning and/or appearance for the work (attach drawings as appropriate): PACKING AND SHIPPING INSTRUCTIONS 1. Please explain how the art should be packed and shipped should the artwork ever need to be transported (be specific, attach diagrams if necessary): PART II - CONSERVATION INSTRUCTIONS The Artist should provide detailed instructions regarding the methods and frequency of maintenance for the artwork as follows (attach additional information as appropriate): 1. Routine maintenance (e.g., removal of dust, dirt; maintenance of protective surfaces; tightening, adjusting, oiling; trimming of plant materials, etc.): 2. Cyclic maintenance (less frequent and more extensive preventive measures, e.g., disassembly and inspection; reapplication of protective sealers; repainting; cleaning of textiles, etc.): 3. Who should be considered competent to perform cyclic maintenance? Describe any special training, materials, tools, or procedures required. 4. Who should be considered competent to perform significant repairs? 5. Describe any special training, materials, tools, or procedures required for refitting, replacing, or reconstructing portions of the artwork damaged by vandalism, accidents, disasters, or weathering. AMENDMENT #2 TO AGREEMENT Whereas, on January 4, 2023, the City of Iowa City, a municipal corporation, hereinafter referred to as the City, and Ray Michels of Iowa City, Iowa, hereinafter referred to as the Consultant, entered into the Agreement (hereinafter referred to as the Agreement) for the mentorship of an emerging artist; and Whereas, on April 17, 2024, the City and Consultant amended the Agreement to provide additional time for the Consultant to complete mentorship services through on the fabrication of a 4:1 scale metal model; and Whereas, although the full scope of mentorship services have not been completed, the City and Consultant desire to further amend the Agreement to allow Consultant additional time to complete the mentorship services for the completed and installed project. NOW THEREFORE, it is agreed by and between the City and Consultant to further amend the Agreement as set forth herein. Part II of the amended Agreement, entitled Time of Completion, is amended by adding the following: • Consultant agrees and acknowledges the bench has not been installed. • Consultant shall provide mentorship guidance to the Emerging Artist through the completion of the project by September 30, 2024. • Consultant acknowledges he may be invited to attend the Public Art Advisory Committee meeting no more than monthly to provide an update and answer questions. • If Consultant fails to provide the mentorship services to the Emerging Artist through September 30, 2024, the City may terminate this Agreement as provided for herein, and if terminated, the City shall not be obligated to pay Consultant $700 for installation of the bench. All other provisions of the Agreement, not inconsistent with this amendment, remain in full force and effect. For the City For the Consultant By: By: Geoff Fruin, City Manager Ray Michels Date: , 2024 Date: , 2024 Approved by: City Attorney's Office Date 6 S R i v e r s i d e D r Highway1 W Mesquakie Park S M a d ison S t Fr ie ndship S t Ke ok u k St D e a r b o r n S t Fr i en dl y A v e W a l n u t St S C a p i t o l S t B r ad ford D r Defo r es t Ave SS u m m i t S t Sh erid an A v e Ginter Ave 3 r d A v e G S t 2 n d A v e S C l i n t o n S t B o y r um St Southgate Ave Way n e A v eS Gil be r t C t S D u b u q u e S t K irkwo od Ave M u s c a t i n e A v e S G i l b e r t St S D o d ge S t L o w e r M u s c a ti n e R d S Governor S t S 1 s t A v e Lakeside Dr S y c a m o r e S t R us s e ll D r H o llyw o o d B lv d T a y lo r D r McC o llister B l vd Whisp e r i ng M e a d o w D r Dicken son Ln Hi g h w a y 6 E Sand Prairie D o v e r S t W e lli ngton Dr E r o b i L n M us ca t i n e A v e S S c o t t B l v d S S c o t t Blvd Court Hill Park H e i n z R d Hi g h w a y 6 S E Sc o t t B l v d S E County of Johnson, IA, Iowa DNR, Esri, HERE, Garmin, SafeGraph, GeoTechnologies, Inc, METI/NASA, USGS, EPA, NPS, US Census Bureau, USDA, Maxar MFCol l i s t e r 1 7 City of Iowa City 2 3  City of Iowa City 66 6 City of Iowa City % a k e r %radIord 5 City of Iowa City 9i s t a P a r k SF o t t  City of Iowa City Riverfront Crossings Park (1001 S. Clinton Street) Iowa River Trail, South of Riverfront Crossings Park (1001 S. Clinton Street) Iowa River Trail & Terry Trueblood Recreation Area (579 McCollister Blvd.) Mercer Park (1317 Dover St.) Scott Park (640 S. Scott Blvd.) Iowa City Sculpture Pad Locations 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 10.13 Miles .e[KiEit$ 4/22/24, 1:44 PM PAAC Budget Survey https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1s0gpjjJeNSbqPPonRjVjqnZV9FEB0WkHT-oLBSCn_VM/viewanalytics 1/3 Please select your top budgetary priorities for FY25, based on existing PAAC programs, activities, and goals. (Select no more than 3). 5 responses Considering budget limitations, please identify any projects or programs you would like to offer annually versus every other year. PAAC Budget Survey 5 responses Publish analytics Copy 0 1 2 3 Sculptor's Showcase Grant Programs Large Neighborhood Art I… Large Public (City-owned… Maintenance of Existing… Public Art Inventory & Ma… Outreach & engagement… Artist support programs 2 (40%)2 (40%)2 (40%) 3 (60%)3 (60%)3 (60%) 1 (20%)1 (20%)1 (20%) 2 (40%)2 (40%)2 (40%) 3 (60%)3 (60%)3 (60%) 1 (20%)1 (20%)1 (20%) 0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%) 0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%) Copy Sculptor's Showcase Grants Neighborhood Public Art installations Public Property Art installations Maintenance of existing installations 0 2 4 6 AnnuallyAnnuallyAnnually Every Other YearEvery Other YearEvery Other Year 4/22/24, 1:44 PM PAAC Budget Survey https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1s0gpjjJeNSbqPPonRjVjqnZV9FEB0WkHT-oLBSCn_VM/viewanalytics 2/3 Considering limited staff capacity, please select the top 3 ways you would like staff time to be prioritized in FY25: 5 responses Please share any other thoughts, questions, or concerns you have regarding the Public Ar t budget & priorities: 2 responses Getting an intern would be helpful due to the time commitment required for an updated Public Ar t Strategic Plan. Based on what staff priorities end up being and what staff capacity is, I'm wondering then if PAAC members can help with certain other activities a bit more. As in: "Here are the staff priorities we've laid out, here's where staff needs help/members can help. This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy Copy 0 1 2 3 4 5 Planning: Public Art Strategic Plan & Art Main… Implementation of Large Public Art Projects Outreach & Engagement with artists & arts Comm… Maintain & improve existing programs (Sculptor's Sho… Administer grant programs, including the Matching G… 4 (80%)4 (80%)4 (80%) 2 (40%)2 (40%)2 (40%) 2 (40%)2 (40%)2 (40%) 2 (40%)2 (40%)2 (40%) 5 (100%)5 (100%)5 (100%)  Forms 4/22/24, 1:44 PM PAAC Budget Survey https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1s0gpjjJeNSbqPPonRjVjqnZV9FEB0WkHT-oLBSCn_VM/viewanalytics 3/3 FY2025 Public Art Budget Tentative FY24 Carry-Over Request Expense Line Amount Notes Sculptor’s Showcase (2024-2026) $18,000 Selections made June 2024. Paid out in August. South District Bench Project $18,810 $24k total budget. $5,191.58 paid out to-date. Lucas Farms Neighborhood Project $17,137 Plan to resume in Fall semester Dave Dennis – Maintenance Contract $6,526 “Birds in Flight” remaining completion Total $53,947 FY25 Budget - $55,500 (additional $5k over prior year) Expense Line Amount Notes Maintenance $15,000 Inventory Condition Assessment & public art maintenance projects Public Art Matching Grant Program $15,000 Opportunity Fund $23,500 Other grant programs or priorities Misc. $2,000 Longfellow tunnel, updated strategic plan, misc. plaques or supplies Total $55,500