Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1997-11-18 Info Packet (1)CITY COUNCIL INFORMATION PACKET November 14, lgg? IP1 IP2 IP3 NOVEMBER 17 WORK SESSION Memorandum from City Manager. Teams Memorandum from Finance Director. Solid Waste/Recycling I Airport Commemlal Area/Project Development Discount Program for Water, Wastewater, and NOVEMBER 19 WORK SESSION IP8 IP9 IP10 IPll IP12 IP13 IP14 IP15 IP16 Memorandum from Planning & Community Development Director. Plan I 1997 Comprehensive MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS IP4 Letter from Mayor to Arlene Heck (TCl): Univision IP5 Memorandum from City Manager. Accessible Bus Training at Goodwill IP6 Memorandum from City Manager. Police Beat Configuration/Downtown Beat IP7 Memorandum from City Manager. Dubuque-Kimbell Sidewalk Memorandum from City Manager. First Avenue/Captain IHsh Parkway Letter from City Manager to Representative Dick Myers: Deer Management Memorandum from City Clerk: Meeting Schedule for Remainder of 1997 Memorandum from City Clerk: Proposed Budget Schedule Memorandum from City Clerk: October 23 Council Work Session Memorandum from City Clerk: Joint City Council/Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting, November 3, 1997 Memorandum from City Attorney: Attorney Assignments Letter from Assistant City Attomey Mitchell to Skateboarders: Skateboarding Letter from First Assistant City Attorney to Kirsten Frey: The Cliffs Apartments: Slope Stabilization Project November 14, 1997 Information Packet (continued) 2 IP17 IP18 IP19 IP20 IP21 IP22 IP23 IP24 IP25 IP26 IP27 IP28 IP29 Agenda for 11/18/97 Bd. Info regarding Oakland Memorandum from Planning & Community Development Director:. Buffer House - Update Memorandum from Planning & Community Development Director to City Manager. Hy-Vee Truck Traffic and Lighting Memorandum from Planning & Community Development Assistant Director to Business Owners/Residents of South Gilbert Street corridor. Traffic Problems on South Gilbert Street Letter from Traffic Engineering Planner Riplay to Rick Altrnan: Traffic at South Gilbert StmetJPrentiss Street/Bowery Street Memorandum from Associate Planner Yapp to Senior Planner Miklo: Alleys in New Subdivisions Memorandum from Joyce Carroll and Barb Coffey to City Manager. Final Report on City Employee Leaf Raking Project Letter from Tom Magnet to Mayor. City Employee Leaf Raking Project Letter from Kenneth Starck to Police Sgt. Steffen: Thank You Letter from Senior Housing Inspector Klinefalter to Rental Property Owners/Managers: Housing Inspections Memorandum from Transit Manager to City Manager. Art on the Bus October 1997 Building Permit Information Agendas: November 13 Johnson County Board of Supervisors Meetings Agenda: November 17 Johnso~ County Board of Supervisors Meetings Memo from City Mgr. regarding absence.. Copy of Annual Report of Boards & Commissions FY97. of Supervisors. Cemetery (distributed 11/17 Trueblood). FY99 Infor Copy Human Service Agency Funding Requests. regarding the Iowa League of Cities Legislative Day - 3/4/98. of South District Plan (revised, draft dated July 1997) qOll City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: November 13, 1997 To: City Council Airport Commission From: City Manager Re: Airport Commercial Area/Project Development Teams In order to continue the process of the development of the proposed North Commercial Area as well as the relocation of Public Works facilities, I would like to suggest the formation of two committees to assist in this process. The first would be a technical advisory committee made up of the following individuals. City Manager Airport Manager Director of Planning Director of Public Works City Attomey (Assistant assigned to Airport Commission work) This Committee would be responsible for identifying policy issues, technical review of any proposed plan and other matters which might have policy and/or financial implication concerning the success of the development of this airport property. They would have the latitude to seek whatever technical advice from other professionals as necessary. An operating budget will be developed. The second group would be a policy committee made up of two representatives from the City Council and two from the Airport Commission. Their purpose would be to receive the information from the technical advisory committee as well as generate information needs and any other concerns with respect to the project development. They will be asked to review the vadous staff reports of the technical committee. I would hope that this group would be able to develop the framework of a formal agreement between the City Council and the Airport Commission in order to have these vadous projects proceed. The issue of the involvement of the private sector can be addressed by this committee and if it is their desire to put forth a formal request for proposal that meets with the policy guidelines of the Council and Airport Commission, that too can proceed from this committee. These two working groups I believe can generate sufficient information in order to move the project forward. I will place this matter on an upcoming City Council work session agenda and I would request the Airport Manager would place this matter before the Commission. CC: Assistant City Manager Director of Planning & Community Development Director of Public Works Airport Manager City Attorney Director of Finance Im~n~'n~a 11-12.doc City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: November 14, 1997 To: From: Re: City Council and City Manager/;~ ~ Don Yucuis, Finance Director '~ Discount Program for Water, Wastewater, and Solid Waste/Recycling The current discount program will be affected by the change in the minimum bill from 200 cubic feet to 100 cubic feet. The curTent discount rates are as follows: Water 50% of minimum charge Wastewater 50% of minimum charge Solid Waste 75% of minimum charge Recycling 75% of minimum charge Below is a chart that shows the impact to a user that qualifies for the discount program based on the current user rates and discount percentages. It also shows the March 1, 1998 rate increase, the change from 200 cubic feet to 100 cubic feet and using various discount percentages. Existing rates Water-50% VVVVTD-50% Ref/Rec-75% Minimum Minimum 100Cu 200Cu Ft or Ft or 300 400 500 600 700 800 Less Less cuff cuff cu ft cuft cuff cu if. 13.91 19.06 24.21 29.36 34.51 39.66 44.81 March 1, 1998 rate increase Water-50% VWVTD-50% Ref/Rec-75% 9.10 14.89 20.69 26.49 32.29 38.09 43.88 49.68 All at 75% 6.15 11.94 17.74 23.54 29.34 35.14 40.93 46.73 Water-100% VWVTD-100% Ref/Rec-75% 3.20 8.99 14.79 20.59 26.39 32.19 37.98 43.78 City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 13, 1997 City Council Kmrin Franklin. Director, 1997 comprehensive Plan Rather than amend the text of the Plan at this point, I will be providing you a continuing memorandum that will outline the changes that have been discussed and resolved to date. As you review these changes, if there are any that you do not believe the council reached through consensus, please raise those issues at the next meeting. Upon completion of the work sessions and with agreement of the council, this memo may then be referenced pdor to your closing of the public hearing. I have not included editorial changes in this list. As soon as you close the public headng, we will make the amendments to the original text and reprint the plan. Amendments from the November 3, 1997 work session: · Page 13, #3 Delete last sentence of paragraph and insert: In the future, efforts will be made on the part of the City Council to use the Capital Improvements Program to guide more effectively the location and timing of growth in the community through an annual review and prioritization of the CIP prior to the budget process. · Page 23 Delete the last sentence of the first paragraph and insert the following: The area east of Scott Boulevard was annexed for industrial development in 1997; the area near the airport requires annexation at some point in the future. Strategies: · Page 29 Add to last paragraph: Each of the strategies will require investigation as to their feasibility and practicality. Some will require working with other jurisdictions and community organizations. An Action Plan will be developed annually to pursue the various strategies. As the feasibility and appropriateness of a strategy is evaluated, that strategy may be modified, deleted, or replaced with a strategy that more successfully achieves the goal. · Page 33- Arts, Culture, and Human Development Goal 1, Strategy 3: Work with the Iowa City Community School District to include public recreational facilities and meeting areas in new schools. Goals 2, Strategy 2: Allocate a minimum of $100,000 annually for public art. 1997 Comprehensive Plan November 13, 1997 Page 2 Goal 4, Strategy 1: Consider a funding strategyto provide financial assistance to local arts, culture, and human development activities sponsored by non-profit groups. · Page 37- Environment Protection Goal 2 add: Promote regional storm water management systems. Goal 7 add: Reevaluate performance standards for glare. · Page 41 - Land Use and Urban Pattern Goal 4, Strategy 2 Work with the business community on strategies to keep downtown commercially viable. · Page 49 - Transportation Goal 2, Strategy 4 Provide separate trails where appropriate; complete a network of trails including the Iowa River Corridor Trail. Goal 3, Strategy 2 Ensure adequate levels of transit service dudng a.m. and p.m. peak travel periods. Planning Districts · Page 80 - South Central Planning District--Add to Open Space paragraph: The Neighborhood Open Space Plan should be amended to consider open space for existing and future residential development in this area. · Pages 89 and 90 - Southeast Planning Distdct~Update text regarding annexation of Scott- Six Industrial Park. South Planning District · Page 7--Amend reference to accessible apartments above commercial uses. Provide accessible apartments in the neighborhood commercial centers. · Page 12--Add to the last sentence of the last paragraph: ...and along Highway 6. cc: Planning and Zoning Commission City Manager Jeff Davidson Bob Miklo November 14, 1997 Ms. Arlene Heck General Manager TCl of Eastem Iowa 6300 Council Street NE Cedar Rapids, IA 52402 CITY OF I0 WA CITY A number of citizens approached the City Council on November 11, 1997 with concerns about the partial loss of the Spanish language channel Univision from the Iowa City lineup. They have come to rely on this service for a variety of r~,cds ranging from information about their native country to a useful language study aid. 'rhe City has long regarded the foreign language channel services as valuable assets to the cable system and to our community. While it is not our prerogative to specify which services you provide, we urge you to seek a reasonable alternative to the partial removal of Univision. We understand you have to deal with the 'must carry' requirement as well. In the event you determine there is no acceptable alternative that would keep Univision a 24-hour service in the intedm, we would appreciate TCI's assurance to all our citizen subscribers that you will restore Univision as a 24-hour service as soon as the current upgrade allows for the channel capacity to do so. Thank you for your consideration of this request. Sincerely, Naomi J. Novid( Mayor cc: City Council Broadband Telecommunications Commission Jo..~ Abreu, Citizen EAST lVASIIINGTON STREET * I01~A CITY. IOWA ]J&-Jeee · FAX (319) City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 13, 1997 ¢~y Cour~l City Manager Accessible Bus Training at Goodwill On Thursday, November 6 Monk Leonard, one of our Transit Supervisors, conducted an accessible bus training session at Goodwill Industries for twelve of their consumers. Monk worked with Nancy Overstreet from Goodwill to organize the training session. Nancy indicated that the majority of the people attending the session will be able to transition to the fixed route system by spdng. We decided to pursue accessible bus training and plan on having another training session in the spdng at Goodwill as well as Systems Unlimited. City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 13, 1997 City Council City Manager Police Beat Configuration/Downtown Beat The Police Department is in the process of evaluating the addition of a downtown beat as part of the beat configuration for the community. The new downtown beat would cover the area from Capitol Street on the west, Jefferson on the north, Gilbert on the east, Burlington or Court on the south. The Police Department is planning to have an officer assigned to that beat 24 hours a day, 365 days of the year. The beat would be pdmadly a walking or a bicycle beat. Two officers would be assigned during the daytime (0700-1500), two on the evening shift (1500- 2300), and two on the late night shift (2300-0700). The fact that there are two officers assigned means that both officers would be on duty approximately three days a week, the other four days one of the two would be off duty. This should help address some of the concem in the downtown business area about having officers visible in the immediate area. At the present time the beat is quite a bit bigger and requires that the officer leave the immediate downtown to handle calls for service in other parts of the beat. The remaining areas of the city will be reevaluated for the workload and areas covered to determine the best. assignment of officers to make full utilization of available resources. We hope to have this in place by January 1, 1998. City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 13, 1997 City Council City Manager Dubuque-Kimball Sidewalk While we have concluded easements, it does not appear that we can get the new sidewalk installed this construction season (what is left of it). cc: Chuck Schmadeke City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 12, 1997 City Council City Manager' First Avenue/Captain Idsh Parkway The following represents the Council's policy as discussed at your Monday, November 10, 1997 work session. 1. Construct 12" waterline from Dodge Street along Captain Idsh Parkway to a point east of the proposed ACT driveway intersection. 2. Construct 24" waterline from Dodge Street along Captain Idsh Parkway to a point east of the proposed ACT driveway intersection. 3. Construct geometric changes and install signal Dodge and Parkway intersection. 4. Grade for streets from Dodge to a point east of the ACT driveway intersection necessary to provide sufficient fill dirt. 5. Construct Captain Idsh Parkway, east to a point just beyond proposed ACT driveway. 6. Conclude agreements with ACT concerning driveway access. 7. Initiate planning process in accordance with memorandum of November 6 by Planning Director. cc: Department Directors Planning and Zoning Commission November 6, 1997 The Honorable Representative Richard Myers 9 Woodland Heights Iowa City, IA 52240 CITY OF I0 WA CITY Re: Iowa City Deer Management Plan Dear Representative ~1'~: ~)' Thank you for your interest in Iowa City's proposed Deer Management Plan and the process for obtaining DNR approval. A copy of the Deer Management Plan is enclosed. It is my understanding that the State of Iowa has jurisdiction over deer pursuant to Section 481A.2, Code of Iowa (1997). The Natural Resource Commission is the body that has been delegated the power to establish policy and adopt rules for hunting and killing deer and other wildlife. IOWA CODE §§ 455A.5, 481A.38, 481A.39, 481A.48 (1997). The Department of Natural Resources (DNR) enforces the rules adopted by the Commission. The rules which the Commission has adopted for deer hunting are set out in the Iowa Administrative Code at 'l-rUe 571, Chapter 106. The Commission has established some Deer Population Management Areas around the State. These areas are described in the Iowa Administrative Code at Title 571, Chapter 105. Deer Population Management Areas have been established in the Cedar Falls/Waterloo area and the Cedar Rapids/Marion area. We have been told there are no written guidelines that the Commission follows when adopting a Deer Population Management Area. We have found nothing in the State Code which would prevent the Commission from allowing sharpshooting or trap and kill as part of an urban deer population management plan. To give you some background, the DNR recommended a citizen task force be convened to determine if there was an overpopulation of deer. If the numbers were too high, the Committee would review killing options. The DNR stressed the importance of devising a proposal that was acceptable to the community. To assure a wide array of opinions would be included, the City Council of Iowa City assembled people with the following backgrounds: an officer with the Iowa City Police Department who is also an avid bow and arrow hunter; residents living in an area heavily populated with deer; a resident living in an area not heavily populated with deer; a member actively involved in animal rights; individuals with science and biology backgrounds; a member of Project Green; and the supervisor of the Iowa City/Coralville Animal Shelter. The Committee and the DNR agreed that Iowa City has a deer overpopulation problem and that the number of deer need to be reduced in certain areas of Iowa City. The group studied the methods of 410 EAST WASHINGTON STREET · IOWA CITY, IOWA $2240-1126 · (319) 356-5000 · FAX (319) killing in painstaking detail and unanimously agreed to a plan. The Committee recommended that the number of deer be reduced initially by means of sharpshooting and trap and kill. The City Council recenfiy adopted these recommendations. Although lows City has not yet submitted its. application for reduction of deer through sharpshooting and trap and kill, senior staff members of the DNR and the chair of the Natural Resource Commission spperenfiy have indicated to newspaper reporters and City staff that they will likely reject the plan. The DNR's objection to Iowa City's plan seems to be that sharpshooting and trap and kill would take away an opportunity for recreational hunting within the City. However, the goal of the Deer Management Committee was not to come up with the best way to provide an opportunity for recreational deer hunting within Iowa City. The C0mmittee's goal was to come up with a solution that most quickly, humanely, efficiently, and safely reduces the deer population within Iowa City. As of October 22, there were reports of nineteen (19) motor vehicle accidents this year involving deer which resulted in an estimated $27,730 worth of damage. (See enclosed memo regarding car/deer accidents.) Each week, I receive additional reports of deer/vehicle collisions. Thankfully, none of these accidents have resulted in serious injury or death to any drivers or passengers. The DNR has also indicated they are concerned that if they allow Iowa City to reduce its deer population by use of a means other than bow and arrow hunting, it could be the beginning of the end of the sport statewide. I believe this is an over-reaction. Urban deer management is not recreational hunting. Separate rules and regulations for urban deer management and rural recreational hunting are needed to. afford municipalities the tools necessary to solve this problem. Sharpshooting and trap and kill methods have been used successfully for several years as part of urban deer management plans by communities in Illinois and Minnesota. We have heard of no adverse effects on bow and arrow hunting in those states. The Deer Management Plan adopted by the City Council is only for 1997-1998 winter. The Deer Management Committee will reconvene next spring to assess the effectiveness of the plan. I believe it is safe to say neither the Committee nor the City Council view sharpshooting and trap and kill as permanent, long-term solutions. The goal is to reduce the deer herd initially through the use of sharpshooting and trap and kill, and then to use other methods to maintain the herd. I would suspect bow and arrow hunting could be considered as a method of controlling the deer herd in the future. We hope to have our application for approval of our deer management plan submitted to the DNR within the next week to ten days. We are in the process of refining the plan and detailing the areas where sharpshooting and trap and kill would occur. Representatives of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) have indicated that sharpshooting is more effective at initially reducing the deer herd population than bow and arrow hunting. The agency has performed sharpshooting for deer management in other communities; furthermore, USDA staff have indicated they would be willing to 2 mist the City of Iowa City with our proposal. We have requested and will soon receive the Wildlife Control policies adopted by the Illinois Department of Natural Resources that do allow for sharpshoofing over bait for urban management purposes. The City of Iowa City has followed the recommendations of the DNR by establishing a committee to determine what was best for Iowa City. The Committee and Council agreed to a plan. They struggled with this most unpleasant decision and decided upon methods demonstrated to be effective and accepted by neighboring state DNR officials. The apparent rejection of this community's plan leads to questions regarding the entire process recommended by the DNR. If there is only one acceptable method, the DNR should not ask citizens to spend months deciding what is bast for their community. The DNR should simply mandate and remove the deer under their own initiative. I have included articles from our local newspapers regarding deer management. We would greatly appreciate any help or assistance you could provide the City during this process. If you have any questions, comments or concerns, please do not hesitate to give me a call at 356-5010. Thanks again for your help and assistance in this matter. Very truly yours, Stephen~J~. Arkins" City Manager Enclosures City Council Senators Neuhauser and Dvorsky Representatives Doderer, Masher, and Foege Eleanor Dilkes, City Attorney Dennis Mitchell, Assistant City Attorney Lisa Handsaker, Administrative Assistant 3 City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: November 14, 1997 To: From: Re: Mayor and City Coundl Madan K. Karr, City Clerk ~__..¥, Meeting Schedule for Remainder of 1997 REVISION #16 November Monday, November 17th, Work Session - 7:00 p.m. Tuesday, November 18th, Regular Formal - 7:00 p.m. Wednesday, November 19th. Special Work Session (Comp Plan/Joint Meeting with P&Z) - 5:00 - 7:30 p.m. December (Cancel regular scheduled meetings of December I and 2) Monday, December 1st, Special Work Session (Comp Plan, Sales Tax, or Solid Waste) - 7:00 p.m. Monday, December 8th, Special Work Session - 7:00 p.m. Tuesday, December 9th, Special Formal - 7:00 p.m. Monday, December 15th, Regular Work Session - 7:00 p.m. Tuesday, December 16th Regular Formal- 7:00 p.m. (Cancel regular scheduled meetings of December 29th and 30th) cc: Department Directors Cable TV Maintenance City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: November 14, 1997 To: 1998 City Council From: Marian K. Kar~, City Clerk~~'~ Re: Proposed Budget Schedule A number of you have requested a schedule for upcoming budget discussions. City Manager Atkins, Finance Director Yucuis and myself sat down and reviewed previous budget deliberations and combined those with Council absences and individual Members preferences and came up with the following suggested schedule: Monday, January 5, 1998 - 1:00-5:00 p.m. 5:00-6:00 p.m. 6:00-9:00 p.m. Organizational Meeting with budget overview to follow DINNER BREAK Board and Commission input and other budget issues Saturday, January 10, 1998 - 8:00-Noon Thursday, January 29, 1998 - 6:30-9:00 p.m. Monday, February 2, 1998 -. 6:30-9:00 p.m.' Tuesday, February 3, 1998 - 6:30-9:00 p.m.' Staff estimated approximately 12 hours of time for review of the budget. The above schedule would allow that time without the February 2 and 3 meetings. However, it's always easier to cancel the meetings if not needed then to try and find an open date. This schedule also takes into consideration Council absences, the regular meeting schedule, and the necessity to set public hearing on the budget at your regular meeting on February 10. Please let me know if any of you have a problem with the dates as proposed. Again this is merely a suggested schedule but we'd like to firm it up as soon as possible. Thanks for your assistance. * If needed CC: City Manager Finance Director cclerk~.Jdget.doc o01 City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: November 14, 1997 To: Mayor and City Council From: Marian K. Karr, City Clerk Re: Council Work Session, October 23, 1997- 7:00 PM- Council Chambers [Transcription of the Victor Dover lecture 'Iowa City's Future Neighborhoods' is available in the City Clerk's Office.] City Council Members present: Novick, Lehman, Norton, Thornberry, Vanderhoef. Staff present: Miklo, Franklin, Davidson, Head, Boothroy, Long, Winstead, Yapp, Kugler, Schoenfelder, Karr. Tape Recorded: 97-147, Both Sides; 97-148, Side 1. City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 14, 1997 Mayor and City Council Madan K. Karr, City Clerk Joint City Council/Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting, November 3, 1997 - 6:35 p.m. in Council Chambers Council Present: Novick, Kubby, Lehman, Norton, Thomberry, Vanderhoef. Absent: Baker. City Staff: Atkins, Helling, Karr, Dilkes, Holecek, Franklin, Davidson, Kugler, Miklo, Rockwell. Planning and Zoning Commission: Bovbjerg, Chait, Ehrhardt, Gibson, Shive, Starr, Supple. Tapes: Reel 97-148, Side 2; Reel 97-149, all; Reel 97-150, Side 1. IOWA CITY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 1997 DISCUSSION Reel 97-148, Side 2 Planning and Community Development Director Franklin guided an overview of the 1997 Iowa City Comprehensive Plan Draft, including discussion of Growth Policy, Neighborhood Concept, Goals and Strategies, Planning Districts and the South District Plan. Franklin emphasized that goals addressed in Iowa City's Beyond 2000 were the basis for the 1997 Iowa City Comprehensive Plan. Growth Policy. Franklin explained the Growth Policy addresses the issue of where growth will occur and the growth boundary is a line that delineates the city's sanitary sewer service area. Franklin said the three areas changed since the 1993 adoption of the Growth Policy are increased growth areas north of 1-80 in the North Corridor Planning District, west of Highway 965, and diminished growth area in the south. In response to Starr, Franklin said a lift station would be needed to serve the area west of 965. Kubby inquired about previous comprehensive plans designating when growth will be phased in. Franklin stated phased scheduling of capital improvement projects is not included. Franklin explained phasing was abandoned in the 1997 Comp Plan draft and planning for expenditure of sewer and water dollars and prioritization of those projects occur in the Capital Improvements Program (ClP) budget process. Franklin reminded council that if a developer wished to do a project in an area that is not included in the CIP, the developer pays his or her own way. Kubby stated that council should carefully consider the timing of CIP discussions. Franklin suggested inserting a statement in the Comprehensive Plan that refers to the timing of CIP process. Bovbjerg inquired about Iowa City's growth boundaries in relation to neighboring municipalities. Franklin pointed out the growth boundaries on a map and explained that Iowa City has an agreement with Coralville regarding annexation and subdivision review. Franklin stated that with adoption of the 1997 Comprehensive Plan, Iowa City would need to review that agreement with Coralville. Joint City Council/P&Z Commission Meeting November 3, 1997 Page 2 . Annexation Policy. Franklin explained that the Annexation Policy contains a provision advocating consideration of annexations when control of development is in the city's best interest. In response to Norton, Franklin stated land could be annexed, then zoned for intedm development. In response to Kubby, Franklin noted unimproved agriculture land within the city's corporate limited pay lower property taxes. Vanderhoef asked if there is a time limit when the city is obligated to provide service to annexed land. Franklin stated there needs to be some logic behind taking the property for annexation, and yes, the city needs to provide services within a reasonable period of time. In response to Vanderhoef, Franklin explained that an involuntary annexation is a long protracted process. The state law now allows for a city to annex a smaller piece of property if it is in the way of a larger annexation as long as the smaller piece is 20% or less of the larger piece. Thomberry referred to, When considering the merits of a proposed annexation or development, the impact of increased vehicular traffic on any street... will be studied. Thomberry asked if the Iowa City Board of Realtom use city maps of artedal and collector streets? Franklin stated that all of the information is available. Franklin said the provision, When considering the merits of a proposed annexation or development, the impact of increased vehicular traffic on any street...will be studied... was an addition made to the 1997 Comprehensive Plan because of input received from the Longfellow Neighborhood Association. Franklin explained that when there is an annexation, staff will do the traffic study in terms of predicting average daily tdps generated by that project, look at where that traffic might flow, and place a paragraph in the report regarding the vehicle trips expected from this development. In response to Norton, Franklin stated there would need to be enabling legislation in place to apply an impact fee. Franklin stated that one of the policies in the Plan is to preserve the integrity of existing neighborhoods. Gibson stated he is concerned about including the provision, When considering the merits of a proposed annexation or development, the impact of increased vehicular traffic on any street...will be studied... because the answer will always be subjective and it is very difficult to improve arterials. Franklin noted that the statement required consideration of traffic as a factor in development decisions but this was not the only factor. Kubby asked if the Comprehensive Plan gives priority to in-fill development. Franklin said priodtization of investment of infrastructure is in the Annexation section of the plan. Kubby inquired about Annexation Policy, page 12, #2 Development in the area proposed for annexation will fulfill an identified need without imposing an undue financial burden on the city. Kubby asked how does the city know when a new development is economically feasible? Franklin replied that looking at the costs of capital projects as a consequence of annexation is a guide and the policy is only a guide for making a decision about annexation. Kubby raised the concern about making reliable policy decisions without knowing the true long term impacts. Franklin said council can decide to have a fiscal impact analysis done. In response to Kubby, Franklin summarized that #2 is saying the financial consequences of annexation should be considered. Neighborhood Concept. Franklin stated Beyond 2000's Iowa City is a community of neighborhoods is considered when looking at both existing neighborhoods as well as new ones. Franklin summarized comments received from Victor Dover emphasizing regaining some kind of sense of community. Thomberry inquired by neighborhood commercial. Franklin stated the goal is to try to get those commercial uses within a neighborhood of a size that they will primarily pull from the neighborhood that is around them. Thornberry stated that he doesn't understand what size of business in a neighborhood commercial is okay in a neighborhood. Franklin said the idea is to serve the needs of the surrounding neighborhood without pulling in a lot of traffic from other parts of the city and that specifies as to size of businesses occurs through zoning. Joint City Council/P&Z Commission Meeting November 3, 1997 Page 3 Kubby inquired about compact neighborhood design and asked if a plat can be denied if it does not have compact design. Franklin stated the law still needs to be changed. The Comprehensive Plan is the desire of the community; the next step is drafting and adopting laws. Franklin stated pdoritization of ordinance amendments takes place in Planning's Annual Action Plan. Goals and Strategies. Franklin stated the goals and strategies as outlined came out of the Beyond 2000 task force. Kubby asked how changes or new goals and strategies should be handled. Franklin stated that council should give her any editorial changes and present new goals and strategies for council discussion and P&Z Commission review. South District Plan. Senior Planner Miklo reviewed the South Distdct Plan. Miklo stated initially staff prepared maps and reports about the South District; staff met with major property owners, potential developers, and neighborhood associations to advise them of the planning process; and received input from the School District, environmental groups, and the P&Z Commission. Miklo reported that the major element of the South District planning process was a sedes of neighborhood workshops that included presentation of background matedal and planning for the future of the specific neighborhoods. Miklo reviewed land use maps that illustrated the neighborhood design concepts, including neighborhood focal point or commercial center; a variety of housing types and styles; neighborhood commercial would be surrounded by medium to higher density housing; smaller multi-family developments at intersections of collectors and arterial streets; a variety of ways to get around the neighborhoods via a series of collector streets; smaller parks scattered throughout the neighborhoods; and a trail system. Miklo pointed out retail commercial development and potential for industrial development. Miklo stated the plan recognizes floodplain and wetland areas appropriate for a possible regional park. Ehrhardt suggested that parks be designated and the property be purchased eady in the planning process. Miklo said the Parks and Recreation Commission should designate where to expend parkland acquisition funds. Miklo said the South District Plan does identify land for a possible school site and suggests a neighborhood park be developed in association with that school. Council and P&Z commission members asked that updated maps be made available. Starr noted that the P&Z commission had a 7:30 p.m. P&Z Commission meeting scheduled. Franklin noted the 1997 comprehensive Plan Draft public hearing is continued to November 11. Council and P&Z Commission agreed to scheduled another discussion on November 17, 6:30 p.m. [P&Z Commission left 7:45 p.m.] Kubby asked how practical is the proposal for accessible apartments on the upper floors of commercial buildings. Franklin stated the proposal for apartments on the upper floors of commercial buildings was put in the plan because of the strong input during the neighborhood workshop. Vanderhoef raised the concern that putting 3 to 4 apartments above a small business may not be economically feasible. Norton suggested that language be changed to state "or wherever feasible." Council discussed ADA requirements. Novick suggested changing the wording to encourage accessible apartments. Kubby suggested "provide apartments above ground floor as outlined in the ADA." Franklin suggested allowing apartments right next to commercial as long as the apartment was an accessible unit. Norton asked that the Plan address enhancing Highway 6 area. Franklin reported that there is a $300,000 capital improvement project, over three years for Highway 6 drainage, sidewalks and entranceway. Thomberry suggested using ADS drainage pipe for that project. Joint City Council/P&Z Commission Meeting November 3, 1997 Page 4 Norton referred to the South Distdct Plan, Consideration should be given to incorporating landscape medians or green buffer strips along Gilbert Street, Sycamore Street and the east West Parkway. Norton recommended changing the wording to read "....Sycamore Street, East West Parkway and Highway 6 all along the north boundary of this district." Franklin stated staff would make that change. Thomberry recommended installing electrical conduit along Highway 6 for lighting. Norton asked council members if they were ready to support smaller lot sizes in RS-5? Vanderhoef requested that council discuss alleys and the use of front doors facing arterial streets. Franklin stated the placement of front doors facing arterials are not housing types that encourage outdoor play. Franklin emphasized that the concept allows for a mix of housing and not a single type of housing dominates. Norton suggested the use of frontage roads. Vanderhoef asked about economic impacts from allowing development of smaller frontages and smaller lots. Franklin explained the Peninsula design is an opportunity to develop a more compact development with a diversity of housing types. Kubby asked for information regarding the amount of land taken up by concrete/impervious surfaces in compact development design. Council discussed alleys. Franklin said the property owner typically pays for the rock put down in alleys. Kubby stated that she does not want to promote gas station convenience stores as the core of neighborhood commercial. Franklin said comer grocery stores, like Seaton's Grocery, are no longer practical or economically feasible. Norton asked how the city will limit development in the river corridor area to just the three parcels of land located near Napoleon Park. Franklin said zoning or purchase are two ways of control. Norton inquired about the sand and gravel area. Vanderhoef stated the purchase of that land was discussed when Napoleon Park property was purchased. Franklin stated the area would be looked at as a regional park. Vanderhoef referred to Victor Dover's concepts of neighborhood commercial and asked about the idea of adding a second floor use to the new First Avenue Hy-Vee. Franklin said that residential uses over commercial need a special exception from the Board of Adjustment and the scale of Hy-Vee would make a residential-commercial combination of uses difficult. Planning Districts. Franklin explained that the information in the Comprehensive Plan summarizes what is currenfiy in the district and what are the issues. Kubby referred to the South Central Plan, page 80, Open Space, Because there is not extensive residential development... Kubby stated that there are two mobile homes parks in the South Central area and they should be able to have open space. Franklin suggested adding language indicating that for the residential development that does exist, there should be consideration given to open space. Kubby said the residents living in the South Central Planning area should have the opportunity for input. Franklin stated those residents have been given opportunities for input but many haven't taken it. Norton emphasized that he has eight pages of comments regarding the 1997 Comprehensive Plan Draft. Norton referred to page 13, Fringe Area Agreement, and stated that it should be more strongly articulated that Iowa City has a visible edge. Franklin referred to page 41, Land Use and Urban Pattern, second strategy, Establish wherever possible green space at the edge of the urban growth boundary. Kubby said that strategy needs to be emphasized more. Kubby also recommended stating more prominently "encouraging continued investment in the downtown." Norton stated attention should be given the Iowa City's entranceways. Thornberry Joint City Council/P&Z Commission Meeting November 3, 1997 Page 5 asked about the strategy, Work with the business community on strategies to keep downtown competitive with outlying commercial areas. Franklin stated it is a matter of balance between a healthy downtown and growth in other commercial cores and it has always been a policy and direction of Iowa City to maintain downtown Iowa City as a vital part of the community. Lehman stated that he did not like the word "competitive" used in the strategy and suggested saying, "work with the business community to maintain the viability of the downtown." Franklin suggested, "maintain the economic viability of downtown." Norton suggested, "keep downtown commercially viable." Franklin agreed with that wording. Norton inquired about the attractiveness of entranceways. Franklin stated something could be put in the Environmental Protection section. Norton asked if plans are for a regional or area- wide storm water. Franklin explained there is a regional storm water in the northeast with the North Branch Detention Basin. In response to Norton, Franklin suggested inserting a regional storm water management strategy under the Environmental Protection Goal: Support acquisition and management of watersheds, floodplains, wetlands, and greenways. Kubby referred to Environmental Protection Goal: Protect scenic and historic vistas, control offensive noises, and promote unobtrusive lighting and signs. Kubby asked for review of lighting performance standards. Franklin stated it is on the pending list. Vanderhoef requested a strategy to complete a network of inner-city trails to connect neighborhood, parks, schools, commercial areas and adjoining neighborhoods. Franklin suggested placing that strategy in the Transportation section. Lehman stated "where feasible" should be added to that strategy. Franklin said it is assumed "where feasible" throughout the Comprehensive Plan. Norton inquired about the provision for wide curb lanes for bicycles. Council and staff discussed use of ~,'here appropriate" and "where feasible" in the Comprehensive Planning document. Lehman referred to Transportation, Strategy, Maximize the level of transit service during morning and aftemoon peak travel periods. Franklin said it means provide transit services necessary dudng those peak times. Davidson explained it means that those are the times of day when the potential for transit service is the greatest and rather than spending a lot of money dudng the times of day when it is not being used, focus on those peak times. Lehman suggested using, "focus level of transit service." Kubby disagreed saying focus means the city can cut daytime non-peak hours totally. Kubby objected changing "maximize" to "focus." Davidson suggested that the Comprehensive Plan include a disclaimer language statement in the front of the document. Franklin suggested adding a statement about the meaning and use of strategies on page 28. In response to Norton, Franklin stated a strategy should state something about protection of vistas. Norton stated he will prepare a strategy relating to protection of vistas. Thomberry referred to page 33, Arts, Culture & Human Development, Second Goal, Strategy: Set aside 1% if the budget for any public building .... Thomberry stated that council did not decide on the 1%. Kubby said that language needs to be updated. Norton stated there are several places where language updating is needed. Vanderhoef referred to Arts, Culture & Human Development, Fourth Goal, Strategy: Establish a fund to provide financial assistance to local, arts... Vanderhoef suggested using the word "foundation" rather than "fund." Lehman suggested the language, "encourage the community to establish a foundation." Kubby suggested, "establish a funding strategy." Franklin suggested either "establish or consider a funding strategy to provide financial assistance". Lehman referred to the Strategy: Expand the Joint City Council/P&Z Commission Meeting November 3, 1997 Page 6 public library consistent with the Iowa City Public Library Strategic Plan and asked if it was too specific. Franklin stated the council needs to meet with the Library Board if there are disagreements regarding their Strategic Plan. Lehman noted the Comprehensive Plan calls for public recreational facilities and meeting areas in new schools. Lehman stated that the school distdct should be contacted. Franklin suggested changing the wording to "work with the school district." Vanderhoef stated "include public art, culture or human development components in the redevelopment plans for parcel 64-1A" is too specific. Franklin replied that the Goal "Elected official will consider human development factors when making decisions" is critical. Kubby stated that council needs to start at the beginning to review the Comprehensive Plan Draft. Council tentatively scheduled November 19, 5:00 to 7:30 to continue Comprehensive Plan discussion. Meeting adjoumed: 9:10 p.m. City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 13, 1997 Department and Division Heads Eleanor M. Dilkes, City Attorney Attorney Assignments As most of you know by now, we have hired Andy Matthews as an Assistant City Attorney. Attached you will find a recent memo to the City Council which provides a brief history of Andy's experience. Andy will start work on Monday, November 17. Now that we have a full staff I have made assignments of major departments/subject matters to the various attorneys. In making these assignments I have been cognizant of the disruption to departments within the City that results from attorney turnover. Some change, however, was inevitable given my new responsibilities as City Attorney and our need to evenly distribute the workload between the attorneys. We will see how these assignments work and make adjustments as necessary. Please call me if you have questions or concerns. Eleanor Dilkes, City Attorney City Council City Manager/Assistant City Manager City Clerk Public Works and Engineering Finance Department Human Rights Commission/Coordinator Property acquisition and coordination of the same Litigation supervision Sarah Holecek, First Assistant City Attorney Planning & Zoning Commission/Planning Department (excluding Community Development and JCCOG Human Services) Board of Adjustment City Assessor/majority of tax assessment appeals Police Department Personnel/Civil Service/Pension Property acquisition as assigned II. IV. 2 Dennis Mitchell, Assistant City Attorney Housing & Inspection Services/code enforcement Public Housing Authority Airport Animal Control Magistrate's Court (½) Senior Center Property acquisition as assigned LitigatJon as assigned Andrew Matthews, Assistant City Attorney Community Development and JCCOG Human Services Cable and Cable Commission Library Fire Department Parking & Transit Parks & Recreation Cemetery Magistrate's Court (½) Litigation as assigned Attachment cc: City Council City Assessor Sarah Holecek Dennis Mitchell Andy Matthews November 13, 1997 CITY OF I0 WA CITY Mr. Heath Klahs 229 S. Johnson Iowa City, Iowa 52240 Mr. Mike Green P.O. Box 2294 Iowa City, Iowa 52244-2294 Mr. Eric Neubauer 2O9 E. Fairchild Iowa City, Iowa 52245 Mr. Brian Getting 209 E. Fairchild Iowa City, Iowa 52245 Mr. Isaac Bums 318 N. Gilbert Iowa City, Iowa 52245 Dear Gentlemen: As you probably know, someone moved all the ramps fi'om the Civic Center Parking Lot to the area under the College Street Bridge in the Chauncey Swan Parking Ramp. City crews have now removed the ramps to a storage facility. If you would like to pick up the ramps, please let me know. I should point out that we do.not have any space indoors to store the ramps during the winter. The City agreed to allow skateboarders to use a portion of the Civic Center Parking Lot for skateboarding during certain hou~o not the Chaxmcey Swan Parking Ramp. Our reasons for allowing skateboarding in the Civic Center Parking Lot rather than the lower level of the Chauncey Swan Park/ng Ramp were two-fold: first, Chatmcey Swan is much busier after 6:00 p.m. (unlike the Civic Center lot, anyone may purchase a parking permit for Chauncey Swan); and two, the City would have an easier time maintaining and policing the Civic Center lot if skateboarders failed to follow the rules we agreed upon. Unfortunately, the City's has had to spend a significant amount of time maintaining and policing the parking lot. As I noted in earlier letters, we have had problems with people skateboarding during the day when the parking lot is full; with people leaving the ramps at night, especially al~er it has rained; with people leaving trash and debris in the parking lot; and with people damaging the barricades. Based upon the coming inclement weather, as well as the skateboarders inability. to follow the rules we established, skateboarding in the Civic Center Parking Lot is being suspended for the winter. I would like to meet with some of you or other skateboarders before we allow skateboarding again next spring. EAST WASHINGTON STREET · IOWA CITY. IOWA $2240.1126 · (319) 3S6-$000 · FAX (]15) 3S6o500f~ t oo ' If you have any questions, please feel free to give me a call at 356-5030. Very truly yours, Dennis J. Mitchell Assistant City Attorney Steve Atldns, City Manager Marian Karr, City Clerk Terry Tmebloock Parks & Recreation Director Mike Moran, Recreation Supervisor Joe Fowler, Parking & Transit Director Bill Dollman, Parking Manager Jeff Vananer, Maintenance Department November 5, 1997 Ms. Kirsten Frey Barker, Cruise, Kennedy and Houghton P.O. Box 2000 Iowa City, Iowa 52244~2000 CITY OF I0 WA CITY Re: The Cliff Apartments: Slope Stabilization Project Dear Kirsten: As you know, the City Council agreed not to resist your request that the November 1, 1997 construction completion deadline be extended to December 15, 1997, and the City filed the appropriate document with the Court stating this position. As part of their decision not to resist your requested extension, however, the City Council asked that I clearly convey to you, in writing, their likely position on a request for another extension of the completion deadline. Without recounting the relative merits of the arguments on each side of such a request, I can unequivocally state that should another extension of the completion deadline be requested, the City Council will take the position that such a request should be zealously resisted, and the original municipal infraction. citations aggressively prosecuted to the fullest extent possible. As stated, the City Council requested that I communicate this information to you so that you may be advised of their position on the issue of future deadline extensions in this matter. Very truly yours, _S. arah. E' ..,~"ece_k. / . ~'~-.~rst~A~s i st ant City Attorney CC: Steve Arkins, City Manager Naomi Novick, Mayor Marian Karr, City Clerk Eleanor Dilkes, City Attorney Dennis Mitchell, Assistant City Attorney 410 EAST II,'ASHI~IGTO~ STREET · IOII~A CITY. lOUISA 52240-1126 · (319) 356-5000 · FAX (3]9) 3~6-~009 e/oo City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 10, 1997 City Manager and City Council Karin Franklin, Director, PC~~ Butler House - Update Last November, the (~ity Council authorized us to proceed with stabilization of the Butler House, located on the new water plant site. Since then, this project has been bogged down in our efforts to obtain a Memorandum of Agreement from the U.S. Corps of Engineers and the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO). The City is required, as part of the federal permitting process for the water plant, to undertake the water project subject to a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) between the Corps and SHPO. The agreement articulates the obligations of the City for this project as the project relates to historic resources. The Corps and SHPO have not been in agreement as to what should be included in the MOA regarding the Butler House. The house is a factor in the MOA because SHPO and the Corps have tied together the acquisition of the new water plant site and the acquisition of the Peninsula in their permitting process. In so doing, the federal flood hazard mitigation money which was used to purchase a portion of the Peninsula is used by SHPO and the Corps to link the permit required for the water plant to what is called a Section 106 review. This review includes extensive archaeological work and protection of any historic sites within the project limits. The staff does not necessarily agree with SHPO and the Corps as to the appropriateness of linking the acquisition of the lower Peninsula property with the Butler House site. However, in order to acquire the necessary permits, we have been attempting to work with both SHPO and the Corps on this issue. The debate or difference of opinion between the Corps and $HPO regarding the MOA is that the Corps is only interested in the visual impact the water plant project will have on the Butler House, whereas SHPO requires more extensive language regarding the demarcation of the historic site, the visual impact, and any stabilization plans the City may undertake. At this point, we are attempting to satisfy both agencies without unduly obligating the City to do anything with the Butler House. This does not mean we may not, as part of a local decision, proceed with utilizing this building, but we do not wish to have that decision dictated by the State. We have forwarded to $HPO archaeological surveys and stabilization plans for the Butler House. Upon receipt of their approval, we will proceed, as we intended to one year ago, to stabilize the house. We will then discuss with the Council, as well as appropriate City commissions, future plans for the Butler House. Our immediate goal is to satisfy the Corps and SHPO such that we can obtain the necessary permits to proceed with the water plant construction. We will keep you apprised of the status of this project. CC: Eleanor Dilkes Chuck Schmadeke Scott Kugler Historic Preservation Commission Parks & Recreation Commission Riverfront & Natural Areas Commission bc\memos\1-1 KF,doc City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 7, 1997 / Steve Atkins' City Manage_r_./,~~ ;./i,/.,,~ Kadn Franklin, Director, CDI~ Hy-Vee Truck Traffic and I.Jghti'ng' I have spoken with David Bailey, Real Estate Manager for Corporate Hy-Vee, and Terry Holcomb, Manager of the First Avenue Hy-Vee, regarding the issues of truck delivery schedules, truck traffic on First Avenue, and lighting within the First Avenue Hy-Vee parking lot. Mr. Holcomb has instructed all of the frequent vendors and those who would make eady moming deliveries to deliver only between the hours of 5:00 a.m. and 10:00 p.m., and to use Muscatine Avenue for deliveries from the east and west and First Avenue for deliveries from the south. These instructions were conveyed to the offices of the companies as well as the individual drivers. The lighting in the parking lot has been evaluated by Julie Tallman; the lights have been modified to diminish the footcandle power at the property line to one foot candle. Julie remeasured the lighting after modifications were made to the fixtures, and there were two fixtures which still exceeded the footcandles at the property line. She is working with the landscape architect for the project to bdng these two fixtures into compliance. cc: Mike Finley, Creekside Neighborhood Association Date: November 12, 1997 - CITY OF I0 WA CITY To: Business owner or resident, South Gilbert Street corridor From: Jeff Davidson, Asst. Director, Dept. of Planning & Community Development Re: Traffic problems on South Gilbert Street Over the past several years the City has noted a decline in traffic service along the South Gilbert Street Corridor. We are referring specifically to South Gilbert Street between Benton Street and Stevens Drive. What we mean by a decline in traffic service is: · Increased delay and congestion to get from one end of the corridor to the other. · Difficulty in getting in and out of driveways and intersecting streets. Increased intersection delay and congestion. · An increase in the traffic accident rate. · More difficult for pedestrians and bicyclists to travel in the area. We know that this deterioration in traffic service is more than just a perception. We are dealing with traffic volumes that in 1997 are much higher than we ever envisioned. For example, between 1994 and 1997, the number of vehicles through the intersection of Gilbert Street and Highway 6 each day increased 38%, from 37,250 to 51,471. Dudng this three-year pedod the population of Iowa City probably increased around 3%, so we are dealing with an increase in traffic that far exceeds the increase in population. We are trying to determine how best to deal with this situation, and what we can do to make sure Gilbert Street is a safe, functional arterial street. Our first step in this process is to ask you what you think. Do you think there is a problem? If. so, what are some ideas for improving the situation? Many of the possible solutions involve impacts to pdvate property along the corridor, such as adding a center tum lane on Gilbert Street or improving sidewalks. Organizing driveway entrances better, as has been done successfully in Coralville along Highway 6, will improve traffic safety but may be perceived as negatively affecting access to individual properties. Are there solutions that will reduce traffic volume on Gilbert Street so that the existing street works better, without impacting adjacent neighborhood streets? I would appreciate you responding using the enclosed, postage-paid mail back survey. Once we have an idea how those of you along the corridor feel, we will report to the City Council and see how they want to proceed. Thanks for helping us try to improve this difficult situation. Feel free to give me a call at 356-5252 if you have any questions. City Council City Manager 410 EAST I~ASHINGTON STREET · IOI~A CITY. IO!VA SZ240-1124, · (]19) 356-$000 · FAX (319) ]~&.$GII9 CITY OF I0 WA CITY South Gilbert Street Corridor Traffic Analysis Survey of Business Owners and Residents I i-'lease tatum no later than December 3, 199/ o Do you feel there is a problem with traffic on South Gilbert Street between Benton Street and Stevens Drive? [] Yes [] No If yes, which of the following better describes the problem: Check any which apply. [] Overall increased traffic and congestion [] Increased delay and congestion at intersections [] Problems getting in and out of driveways [] Traffic accidents ,~ Difficulties for pedestrians and bicyciists ~ Other 3. I think the following ideas should be considered to improve traffic conditions in the South Gilbert Street Comdor. Return to: Jeff Davidson, Department of Planning & Community Development City of Iowa City 410 E. Washington St. Iowa City, IA 52240 November 12, 1997 CITY OF I0 WA CITY Mr. Rick Altman 720 Clark Street Iowa City, IA 52240 Dear Mr. Altman: Thank you for your letter regarding traffic conditions at the intersection of south Gilbert Street, Prentiss Street. and Bowery Street. As you are aware, the layout of this intersection is less than desirable because of the offset between Bowery and Prentiss Streets. However, it has not been one of our top 15 accident locations in the last five years. Next spdng we will look at this intersection for possible improvements. Before making any signal timing changes, a traffic count will be completed to identify the amount of traffic on each approach of the intersection. Because these counts are weather sensitive, it may be late winter or early spdng before this can be completed. We will then look at making some timing changes to the signal if appropriate. Your suggestions will be evaluated as part of this process. Thanks again for your commentsl If you have any questions or would like additional information, please call me at 356-5254. Sincerely, Doug Ripley JCCOG Traffic Engineering Planner cc: City Council City Manager Jeff Davidson Longfellow Neighborhood Association EAST WASHINGTON STREET · IOWA CITY. IOWA $2240-112i · (3141) ~J&.$000 · FAX OIO City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: November 13, 1997 To: Robert Miklo, Senior Planner From: John Yapp, Associate Planner Re: Alleys in New Subdivisions The question of whether the introduction of alleys would increase the amount of paving in new subdivisions came up during the development of the Sensitive Areas Ordinance, and again with the draft Iowa City Comprehensive Plan, both of which encourage the use of alleys in compact neighborhoods. It is true that alleys in conventional single-family subdivisions with lot widths of 60 feet or more, would · increase the amount of pavement per lot. However, alleys in combination with narrower lots and slightly narrower streets will use less pavement per lot than a conventional design. If designed properly, alleys can be a valuable amenity to a neighborhood. Benefits of alleys include: · V~rrth garages off the alley there will be fewer curb cuts on the street, and none of the front yard would need to be paved. · W"~h local traffic using the alleys, the street will carry less traffic. · Alleys can serve as the location for utility services and service vehicle access. · In more dense neighborhoods with small houses, locating the garage to the rear helps improve the residential appearance of the street. The following table helps to illustrate how the use of alleys, in compact neighborhoods, results in less paved area par house when compared to conventional subdivisions. In general, the narrower the lot the less pavement per lot there will be, regardless of how deep the lots are. It should be noted that the most likely land uses in compact neighborhoods with narrower lots will be zero-lot line, townhouse, and small single-family dwellings. Street Width, Lot Size, and Pavement per Lot Street AJley Lot PavemenU W~!th W~lth W"~lth Lot 28' 0' 60' 1,680 ~f 25' 16' 40' 1,640 25' 16' 30' 1~0 25' 16' 25' 1,025 Conventional lot f :\sh m'ed\pcd\alley 2. City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Re: November 13, 1997 Steve Arkins, City Manager Joyce Carroll~nd Barb Coffey ~'/ Final Report on Leaf Raking Project On Saturday, November 8, 74 volunteer City employees set out in two shifts to rake the yards of senior citizen residents in Iowa City. Nearly the same number of family members, friends and Boy Scouts assisted the crew. At the end of the morning 36 lawns had been raked. Comments received from the senior citizens attest to how greatly they appreciate our efforts. We hope to continue to expand the program each year so we can reach greater numbers of seniors. A survey is being sent out to volunteers asking for their comments and suggestions to improve and expand the program. We are considering enlisting the efforts of service clubs and neighborhood associations to achieve this goal. Attached is a list of the City.employees who volunteered for this year's project, Special certificates of appreciation will be prepared to reward the efforts of specific departments who achieved superior participation in this project. Small Department Category: City Attomey's Office City Clerk's Office Both these departments achieved close to 100% participation this year. Large Department Category: Planning & Community Development The Planning Department is commended for their strong support of the leaf raking project both this year and last, as evidenced by their proportionally high level of participation. Leaf Raking Volunteers November, 1997 Administration: Steve Atkins, City Manager Dale Helling, Asst. City Manager Kevin Crawtey, Cable 'IV Ron O'Neil City Attorney's Office: Eleanor Dilkes Dennis Mitchell Annie Rowtey Sarah Holecek City Clerk's Office: Julie Vopadl Sue Walsh Sondrae Fort Finance: Don Yucuis, Admin Cyndi Sheets, Admin Kevin O'Malley, Admin Jim Gulland, Safety Leigh Lewis, Admin Debi Mejia, Acctg Barb Coffey, Doc Services Libby Musser, Doc Services Cathy Eisenhofer, Purchasing Jim Kerr, Purchasing Tony Winter, Purchasing Judy Mills, Purchasing Paula Griffin, Treasury Dianna Furman, Treasury Brenda Miller Housing & Inspection Services: Bernie Osvald, Bldg Ron Boose, Bldg Doug Boothroy, Admin Kathy Zuckweiler, Admin Julie Tallman, Bldg Tim Hennes, BIdg Stephanie Hubler, HIS Library: Sara Brown Larry Parks Parks & Recreation: Terry Trueblood, Admin Mike Moran, Rec Cindy Coffin, Rec Madlyn Bennett, Rec Joyce Can'oil, Rec Kate Mohr, Rec Jeff Vanatter, Govt. Bldg Steve Roberts, Govt. Bldg Laroi Dean, Govt. Bldg Terry Robinson, Forestry Judson Yetley, Forestry Planning: Kadn Franklin, Admin Kim Moetler, Admin Katina Lewis, Admin David Schoon, Eco Dev John Yapp, Urban Plan/JCCOG Scott Kugler, Urban Plan Steve Long, CD Steve Nasby, CD Liz Osborne, CD Jeff Davidson, JCCOG Linda Severson, JCCOG Doug Ripley, JCCOG Brad Neumann, JCCOG Public Works: Chuck Schmadeke, Admin Carol Sweating, Water David Nash, Water Tim Dingbaum, Water Gem Turecek, Water Kevin Slutts, Water Michael Sansen, Traffic Eng Police: R.J. Winkelhake, Chief Ron Fort, Lt. Beth Windsor, Records Sr. Center: Linda Kopping Michelle Buhman Craig Buhman Transit: Ron Logsden Alice Swenka November 10, 1997 NOV 1 7997 CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE Naomi Novick, Mayor Iowa City Civic Center 410 East Washington Street Iowa City, Iowa 52240 RE: Judd Yetley and Jim Gulland Dear Mayor: At this time I would like to express my appreciation on behalf of my parents and our entire family in regard to the above individuals. Since my parents are elderly and I live some distance from them, it is difficult to do all the necessary yard work. Much to my surprise, when I arrived at their house on November 8, 1997, the above individuals were just finishing raking the yard. From time to time, you do 'hear criticism of city employees and these two individuals would certainly contradict those negative remarks. Although I don't live in the community, I would thank you on behalf of all the other citizens in the community for these two individuals and other individuals who participated in volunteering to rake other elderly individual's yards. I would appreciate it if you could convey my appreciation to these other individuals and to Joyce Carroll and Barb Coffey who apparently helped organize the program. On behalf of our family and other families, thanks. Respectfully, Tom Magner 417 5th Street N.W. Independence, Iowa 50644 cc: Jim Gulland Judd Yetley THE UNIVERSITY OF IOWA November 6, 1997 Sgt. Jam~s Steffen Police Depattm~t Civic Ceat~ 410 E. Washington St. Iowa City, IA $22A0 Dear Sgt Steffen: Just a brief no~ to thank you v~y much for meeang with my beginrang rep6mng class yesterday. It was an informative session, and several students commented afterwards how useful it was in getting a better understanding of how police work and how journalists work Perhaps more importantly it showed how police and journalists have to work together. Again, thanks. I imow the meeting took time from other important work, but the students and I really appreciated it Sincerely yours, Kenne~ Starck Professor &"~: Chief R. J. Winkelhake School of Journalism a~d ~ Communication 205 Commumcatlons Ctt. iowa Ci~,lowa52242-1592 310/335-5821 FAX31O/B35-5210 E-mail:journ~ism-aamin~uiowa.eclu ¥olq November 7, 1997 Dear Rental Property Owner or Manager: CITY OF I0 WA CITY The Housing Quality Task Force which met several times in the fall of 1995 and into early 1996 recommended that more information and explanation be made available for technical issues related to housing inspections. HOUSING & INSPECTION SERVICES is planning a half day seminar for early 1998 end would like your input for topics to be addressed. The theme the City would like to use is common deficiencies and approved corrections. The seminar would be geared toward maintenance professionals and property owners who perform their own maintenance. The focus and scope will be maintenance which can be performed by persons without trade licenses. We are confident that we can supply knowledgeable people for the following areas: plumbing repair and maintenance electrical repair and maintenance exiting issues including: stair handrail/guardrail, corridors, fire doors, stairway enclosures fire resistive construction, .hazardous areas and occupancy separation Your suggestions for specifics in these areas or additional topics would be greatly appreciated. Please call, drop us a line, or FAX our office with your suggestions or comments. The seminar will be free but reservations may be necessary. Looking forward to hearing from you. Sincerely, Gary Klinefeller Sr. Housing Inspector 356-5133 FAX 356-5008 410 EAST WASHINGTON STREET · IOWA CITY. IOWA $2240-182b · (31~) 356-$000 · FAX 356-5009 City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: November 11, 1997 To: Steve Atkins, City Manager From: Ron Logsden, Transit Manager Re: Art On The Bus The an on the bus program is underway with art done by the first and second graders from Horn Elementary being displayed bus ~42 which we have running on the Westwinds Route. On Tuesday, November 11 ~ I took bus//42 to Horn School so the kids and a number of their parents could see their art displayed on the bus. The kids were very excited and the event was covered by the media and the Superintendent of The Iowa City School District, Barb Grohe. We will display art fxom the students at Lentme Elementary During the month of December. Steve Atkins CITY OF I0 WA CITY BUILDING PERMIT INFORMATION OCTOBER 1997 ) KEY FOR ABBREVIATIONS Type oflmprovement: ADD Addition ALT Alteration DEM Demolition GRD Grading/excavation/filling REP Repair MOV Moving FND Foundation only OTH Other type of improvement Type of Use: NON RAC RDF RMF RSF MIX OTH Nonresidential Residential- accessory building Residential - duplex Residential - three or more family Residential - single family Commercial & Residential Other type of use o1'7 Pa~e: ~c~: ~0/0~/~ ~..: CITY OF ZC~A CITY s,,t.~ACTZ~ OF BUILDING PEPJ~T DATA FOR C~SUS BUREAU P.~PC~T Permit ~licant ~ l~kirems Type Type Stories Un/ts Valuation No. l~pr Use BLD97-0774 l~tO~-~ & ~ 2200 104000 BLD97-0744 HY-V~E INC. 1720 ~0 ~ 28 C~N ~.ED~"IC~ ADDITIC~ ADO ~ 1 0 $ 45000 BLD97-0783 SII~i~t~R OIL 2153 AL"T CIR ADO N(~ i 0 $ 19450 27 x 7.S' A~ITI(~ TO C-~ENI~C~ STORE ADPl~l'mat8:3 S 168450 BLD97-06&l C~RISTL~N ~ 701 O~OL~ D~ ADD ~ 3 14 $ 1771140 S~iVIC~S 14-~IT APARTg~T BUILDi~G ~ T~O LEVEL PA~KING STRUt"~URE. ADD ~ l~tS: I 14 $ 1771140 BLD94-0704 ~ NI~]~ 415 5T~ AVE ADD I~SF 10'x 24' FZ~.~T FLOO~ ADDI~I~ - 22'X 2t" AT'Ii~HED ~ ADOITZ(H~ - 24'X 28' SECOND f-,~Y ADDITI(H~ TO ~LgTI~G S.F.D. BLD97-0690 ELIZIBET~ CLOTHIER 747 R~ ~T 18 X 22 KITC~{AI~D STUDY ADOIT~(~ 0 0 $ 80000 BL~97-0649 ~ & LYNN MO~O~.RZS 1724 E CO~T ST FAMILY RO(~ AND GARAGE ADDITI(~ ADD R~F 1 0 $ 31994 BLD97-0800 ~ SC~I'Z 725 N LI~N ET 16'6" X 12' SC~.E~N PORCH ~ A 10'3" X 9'4" ~DOP DECK ADD RSF 1 0 $ 20000 5L~97-0782 DORSEY PH~L~S 427 ~ AVE 26 x 10 KIT~{EN ADDITIO~ A~D ~SF 1 0 $ 18750 5L~97-0735 JAWIFS & NIN~ PET~AN 410 MAGG~AN AVE 8 X 14 TWO STORY ADDITION ADD RSF 2 0 $ 1500C 51297-0739 JAN FL~.~-~'~ 1714 DEFOREST AVE 17'-6" X 20' ATTACHED GARAGE ADD RSF 1 0 $ 1500C 5LS~7-0784 MEG & ROBERT 12 X 16 SCREEN PORCH 2526 MAYFIELD RD ADD RSF i C $ 14624 i:Li97-0670 ROBERT HARRIS 701 MANOR DR 12 x 12 TNREE SEASON PORCH ADD R~F i C S 13704 ADD RSF 1 0 $ 5OOO0 Page: 2 Date: 11/05/97 from: 10/01/97 To..: 10/31/97 Permit J~lic~nt name No. CITY OF XOMA CITY EXT~XO~ OF B~X,PING I~T ~k~TA FO~ Type Type Stories Units lmpr Use Valuation BLD97-0700 ~ & CATB~XI~ 30 DOg/4AM CT ADO RSF 1 0 $ 12000 BLD97-0758 SI~]J~iKAR M ~ 1025 D~XG~ ~ ADD RSF ~ EXXST~ PO~C~ TO FOUR SEAS(~ RO(]~ A~D ADD A 12 X 20 DEC]( 1 0 $ 8000 BL~97-0740 TIM S~OEDER 221 S LOMELL ST 14 X 29 ATTA~a~I~ ~ A~D 14 · 10 SC~.EEN PO~C~ ADD RSF 1 0 $ 7424 BLD97-0787 !!~ADF~D J. & 217 POST BAP~A~A K. ~ 12 X 24 ATTAOO~D Cu~RA~ ADP RSF 1 0 $ 5000 BL.D97-0697 ~ & ~ 14 X 20 SCI~E~N PO~CH 2734 Li~D~q RD ADP RSF I 0 $ 45OO BLD97-0762 FI~J~'IS M & ST~J~ A 1Sl1 CP.O~Y LN CLARK 16 · 24 C]Uti~D~T A~O ~SF 1 0 $ 4000 BLD97-0759 ~ R ~I~ 14 X 28 MOOD DECK 1314 CARROLL ST AD~ RSF 0 0 $ 3600 BLD97-0753 EADDLEBROOK L.C. 8 x 23 DECK 128 ARABLV~ CT ADD RSF 1 0 $ 2200 BLD97-0763 MARK A FL~'~ 15 · 12 DECK SO REGAL L!i ADD RSF 0 0 S 2200 BLD97-0741 ~ PAINE 823 RONA~PS ST 6 · 4 C~VERED PORCH ARD 18 X 4.5 DECK ADP X~SF 1 0 $ 2000 EL~97-0691 ~ & JEAN ~I~'E 2355 JE~SUP 12 X 34 WOOD DECK ADD RSF 0 0 $ 1800 BL~9~-0767 H.R. JORDAN 10 · 16 ~RT 1433 BUP~c.~R AVE ADD RSF 1 0 $ 1666 BL297-0768 DAVID HAMILTON 828 RIDER ST ADD I~SF 0 C $ 160C EAw~IOR LANDING AND STAIR~ ADD R.~F perf..Its: 22 $ 315062 ~Li}--0734 AERO RENTAL 227 KIRKWOOD AVE ALT NON REMODEL E]fT~IOR OF BUILDING TO INCLUDE A~ Ak'NING AROUND T}IE PERIMETER, INFILL F~ AND NOR/'H WINI~S WIT~ BRICK, REVISE N.E. CORNER TO INCLUDE A S $ 222939 Page: 3 Date: 11/05/97 :~o~: 10/01/97 To..: 10/31/97 CITY OF IO~A CITY ~w~CTIO~ OF BUILDING PERMIT DAT~ FOR CENSUS BUP.~AU Permt ;~plic~t mme Address Type 17pc Stories Units Valuation No. I~pr Use WINDOM. BLD97-059S k~s.~m~q AI]TO/PART~ W~RICA INTeR/OR 501 HOLLYMOOD BLVD ALT N(~ I 0 $ 146000 ELD97-0688 G~J~DVI~ C~K~tT 2346 ~ TREK BLVD PARTNERS 3500 S.P. INTeRIOr OFFICE FINISH ALT NO~ i 0 $ 76000 BL-D97-0766 ~ ~ TX~ 605 N !X~GE ST ALT NOtq REPLACE TICtEE ~At~lOR GL~.$S ~ WIT[{ ~OOD F~J~ING/tND NEI~#IE)0~S A~DA 0 0 $ 9000 ~LD97-0654 ~T~ 717 ~ TREK BLVD DEVELOPMENT C~MPANY 18 · 63'o6" IgA'~tlO~ FINISH FOR DRY CLEA~ING FACILITY ALT NO~ 1 0 S 6000 BLD97-0752 ~ASHXNG'IT~ PA~K 363 N 1ST AVE ALT N0~ 0 0 $ 5200 BLD97-0803 HY-~ FO~D ST~E 1720 MATERFRONT D~ INC. INSTALL NEW PARTTTIO~l FOR T~ T~%CCO AR~A ALT NC~ 0 0 $ 3800 BLD97-0747 SO'TIe. ATE 1907STEVenS DR'' ALT NO~ 1 0 $ 1000 D~LOPMI~q'T CGg(PANY INTERX O~ FINIS~ ALT ~ ~r~LLtS: 8 $ 467939 5LD97-0732 A~Y S~ 25 N lrAlq BUREN ST ALT RAC 2 0 $ 250C~ RID40DEL k'XISTING ACC~ORY BUILDING (GARAGE) TO ACCODATE H0~ OCCUPATIO ( S~I"UDI O) ALT RA~ permits: 1 S 2500S EL~97-~757 RIC~ ~]~0£ZE 925 BI/)0~I~-TON ~T CONVERT S.F.D. TO DUPLEX ;tit RDF 2 1 S 300C Ei.?97-0751 RICH WI~S'TI~ 708 ~ INSTALL BEDRO0~ E~S WINDO~ ;%LT RDF perm:ts: 2 Page: · Date: 11/05/97 rro~: 10/01/97 To..: 10/31/97 CITY OF IOIIA CITY ~'TRACT2C~I OF BUZLDING I:~E~T I~TA FOR CENSCIS BUREAU REPORT Permit A~licant ~ Address Typ~ Type Stories Units Valuation N:. lm[;r Use B~97-0381 CAM~ ~OPERTI~, S18 CAPITOL ALT PJ4F 0 0 $ 2500 BLD97-0743 KEYST~3~E Pi~OP~KTY 518 CAPITOL ST ALT ~ 0 0 S 1000 CONSTRUCT C'~a.R~DOR TO SEPARATE BEDRO(~ ~ ~T ~ ~its: 2 S 3500 BLD97-0736 TED RITTE3~fER 3621 E COURT ST ENCLOSE SCREEN ~ORC~ WITH PLASTIC STORM, #INDO~S ALT RSF 0 0 S 7000 BL.Q97-0698 D~ & (~ 2734 LINDEN RD ALT RSF RIB~L~ ENCLOSE EXISTING 14 Y 20 SC~ ~CH WIT~ PI~%STIC G~ S~ NIND(~S BLD97-0773 DEE ~T~ 920 GI~ AVE H~3~ODEL KITCHEN A~D REPIJ~:~ NIND0~ 0 0 S 6000 BLD97-0708 ~y & J~E JOSS 2600 IRV~ AVE · ~PROXIMATLY 700 S.F. OF BA~ID~ FINISH ALT RSF 0 0 $ 6000 =-L~97-0793 MOORE CG~ISTRUCTIO~ 1418 WIL~ PP, AIRIE DR BASID~ENT BATH, FAM/LY ROOM, A~D BEDROOM FINISH ALT RL'F 0 0 $ 5000 ALT RSF 0 0 S 5000 0 0 S 3000 EL29~-0737 LES BAf-I~A!4 520 HOLT AVE ALT RSF ENCLOSE EXISTI]~ 11'-6' X 16' S(~tE]~ lh3RC~ #ITH PLA$?IC ~ #INDO~S ALT R. SF 1 o S 2500 BL~97-0701 B[T~TY RIB~ 2 RITA LYN CT E~iCLO~E ~:XZSTING 9 X 12 SCR~ PORCH WITH I~IC WINDOWS ALT RSF 0 0 S 250C DAN SEIFE3~T 3428 SOOTH JAMIE L~ FINISH APPROXIMATLY 448 S.F. OF BASEMENT AR~A ALT ~SF 0 0 $ 150C 5L~9~-0712 JOl~ T GI~SELL 1614 DICI~SON L~ FINISH APPROXIMATLY 252 S.F. OF BAS]D~ENT AREA E'----97-0772 JAMES & ]~ECCA 1205 JE~'~'~.q~.gON ST ALT ~SF 0 C S 120C SIMPSON INr~IOR REMODEL: R~OVE W;tLL B~ LIVING ROOW AND DINING AREA, INSTALL NEW EA~£RIOR DOOR ALT RSF permits: 10 $ 3970~_ CITY OF IOWA CITY 1801 S RIVERSIDE DR 52 x 232 TEN UNIT AIRCRAFT. TEE HANGEK NEW NON i C S 3~5~.' Page: 5 D~te: 11/05/97 £rc~: 10/01/97 Is..: 10/31/97 CITY OF I0~A CITY ~Ai~ACTI01~ OF B~IILDING PERMIT DATA FOR ~z~u~ BURFd~U ~PORT Pernut ~licant ~--- A~dress T~ Ty~ Stories Units Valuation No. Impr Use BLD97-0B0& 360 CO~i~ICATI0~S 1825 D~ RD NEW 180' HIGH CO~ICATI(H~T~R#ITH 28 X 11'-6' UTILITY BU/LDXNG 1 0 $ 200000 BLD97-0676 J~R0~I~o I!~C. 2 ~C~ L~ ~ ~ 1 0 $ 120000 3500 S.F. ~ia~NI~NC~ STOR~ NEW NOiqper~lts: 3 S 695000 ~'-D97-0801 C~y MIC~ 847 R~)ELL ST NEW RAC 1 0 S 9000 28 X 34 DETA~]~DGAIt~G~ ~ RAC ~rmzts: 1 $ 9000 ~LD97-0657 ~ Vl~TUR~S, L.C. 2500 RUS~IO~ DR 12 PL~ L'~I~J~ME~#IT~ 12 (~ CAR GA~ ~ RMF 3 12 $ 450000 BLD97-06S3 i~I~ ~, L.C. 1432 ~ PL 4 U~IT C~X]~iFI]~M #ITN T~O CAR ~ HEW RMF 2 4 S 250000 BLD97-0655 ~X~ %r~, L.C. 1500 MC~ PL 4 ~IT CO~IX~INIM~#ITH TWO CAR GARAGES N~W RMF 2 4 $ 250000 ~LD97-0656 ~ VEN~, L.C. 1505 ~ PL NEW ~ 2 4 $ 235000 4 ~IT C~IM~#IT~ SIN~ S~'GAi~ l~ I~ p~r~i:s: 4 24 $ 1185000 ~1-~97-0755 MC C~Y-TAYLOR 4851 SC)~CHAS£ CT $.F.D. WIT]{ T~O CAR C~ 51297-0756 B & H BUILD!~ 1324 GOLD!~OD DR S.F.D. WIT~ TWO CAR C~ ~1297-0694 DAV-ED LIMITED 3440 K~ S.F.D. WIT~ T~O CAR C~ ~L29"-0802 ~DORE CONS~UCTIC~ 1214 GOLDENROD DR S.F.D. WITM T~O CAR GAR~ 5L13~-0714 JASON LEE 1432 WILD P~RIE DR S.F.D. WITH TWO CAR GARDE ~12:~-~769 JEFF MILLR':R 1251 SANTA FE DR CONSTRUCTION S.F.D. WIT}{ TWO CAR GAR~£ 219011 N~ R.SF 2 1 $ 181355 NEW RSF 2 1 S 159227 128837 N'~ RSF 2 i $ 122283 l~ RSF ! 1 $ 116222 Pa9e: To..: CITY OF IO~A CITY EXTRACTIO~I OF BUILDING PE~MrI' ~ FOR C~NS'GS BUREAU REPORT Permit ~licant name Address Ty~ Type Stories Units Valuation No, lmpr Use NEW RSF p~rmlts: 6 6 $ 926935 BLD97-0~10 ~ ZI~i 512 S D~mu~J~ ST REP MIX 0 0 $ 3000 ~ OFF 2 ~ C~ BACK- P.~ROOF #ITH CLASS 'A' I,M~TED S1iIla~mc PEP MIX per~s: 1 $ 3000 B~D97-0791 S~AT~ 901 HOLLYl~OOO ~LVD PEP N(~q DEV~LOI~4~T HA/L ARD #i~D DAM~. TEAR OFF 2' IS0 MODIFIED ROOFL~G SYST~ INSTALLED BLD97-0794 CITY OF IO~A CITY 410 MASHI]~'I~ ST ~ A~D REPLACE S~CTIONS 'A' B~D97-0715 ~ A~D NE~ZIL 119 ~(~T ST ~ AND ~ TILE ~tOOF. ~ BROKEN TILE 0 0 $ 84000 0 0 $ 62000 NON 0 0 $ S6000 BLD97-0790 ~ NIDISS 124 ~ ST ~P NOtt REROOF WITH ~ ~ 'C' R~F ~ B~97-0536 FI~ ~~ 2701 R~ A~ ~P ~ B~97-0721 ~ ~ & 605 ~ A~ ~P ~ Bi~D97-0789 TO~NCREST 1070 NILLLM~ ST R~P overlay with tarred ISO. high density hardboard ~nd fully adhered 0 0 $ 17992 BLD97-0764 ZI(]~ LUTI{ERAN ~JRCH 310 N JO~l~G~ ST REROOF WITH CLASS 'A' FIBERGLASS SHINGLES 0 0 $ 17600 BLDg"-0707 FIRST ASSEMBLY OF 1330 KEOKUK ST GOD REROOF WITH CLASS "A" SHINGLES 0 o $ 12825 5L/9~-0720 DEA~ THORRBERRY 1445 BOYRU~ ST REROOF WITH CLASS "A" SHIl~LF~ NON C C LLi9--0716 FAITH BA/~TIST CHURCH 1251 VILLAGE REROOF WITH MINIMUM ~ASS "C" ROOF CQVERING PEP NON £ C $ 3151 5L197-0781 DEAN THORRBERRY 519 HIGHLAND AVE REROOF WITH CLASS "A" SHINGLES PEP NON 0 0 $ 600C R~P NON 0 0 $ 600C 8160 9446 Pa9e: ? Dale: 11/05/9~ ~om: 10/01/9~ To..: ~0/3~/9~ CITY OF ~0~O. CITY ~t~w~'"TIOt~ OF BUILDING PERMIT !~TA FOR ~ BUREAU P. EPORT Pez~ait ~licant ~ A~fress ~ ~ Stories Units Valuation No. I~r Ome 219 N GIL~E~T ST PEP NON 0 0 $ 900 BLD97-0724 JE~RY C~EY 2500 ~[~CAT~]~ AV~ ~.~P ~(~ 0 0 $ 300 · EPAIR SHA~ P~OF F~{~ HAIL AND #IND DAMAGE ~P N(H~ pe~ts: 14 $ 289S06 ~..EP ~DF 0 0 $ 5157 BLD97-0683 CT~TXS ~ 416 S S~9~T ST REP RDF ~ A~HOXD~TLy 62' OF CL~Y ~]N~AT](~ AE) ~.~PLA(~ #17~ C(~C~-7 M~S~RY U~ITS. 0 0 $ 1600 BLD97-0689 D(~LD R I~-'T~.~ 517 $ ~ ~ ~EPL~C~ 0~ CO~ER ~T. O~E JOIST A~D S0~E DECKI~ BOA~D~ REP ~DF 0 0 $ 900 81.D97-0731 ~LL~AM VO~HI~S 1904 TAYLO~ ~ PEP RDF 0 0 $ 400 ~.~PL~ ~XIST~NG 8 X 8 D~CK ~ STAIRS ' ~P ~)F ~tR: 4 $ 8057 BLD97-0812 ~ P. EALTO~.S 922 COLL~E ST R~OVE A~D REPL~iE CLASS'A' SHINGL~ BLD97-0727 (~.AIG HAES~"f~R ~E~OOF 26975 S25 S JO~N~O~ ST PEP ~MF 0 0 S 20000 5''97-0709 DAVID FO~A~ 307 #XIJ.~O%~ND PL TEAROFF AND P. EROOF NIT~ CIAS~ 'A' SHINGLES 81S97-0705 GEORGE FRO%~IN 815 O~CRF. ST AVE )~OOF WITI( ~ 'A' $HINGI~ BL/97-0728 K~'YSTONE PRO~T~f 1116 OAKCREST AVE MANAGEMENT REROOF USING CLASS A ~{IN~$-~ BL297-0723 GLEN JACOBSEN 708 OAKCREST AVE R]~OOF USING (~.~S A $HINC~LE~ L_:97-C725 GLE~ JACOBSEN 718 OAKCRY. ST AVE REROOF USING CLASS A SHINGLES R~P RMF 0 0 $ 19800 REP RMY 0 0 $ 15300 REP R.MF 0 0 $ 13802 REP RMF 0 0 S 13393 REP P. MF C C $ 13393 Page: 8 Date: 11/05/97 £ro~: 10/01/97 To..: 10/31/97 CITY OF IONA CITY EX'T'RACTIliIEI OF BUILDING PERMIT DATA FOR c~q~us BUREAU REPORT Permit i~plicant na~e Addscoo Ty[~ ~ Stories Units Valuation No. I~pr Use BLD97-0811 ~ R~T~ 522 E BtlP.~Ize,.,z~..~l ~ R~P P,~ TEAROFF AHD P. KPT~%CE ~ 'A' FIBERGLA~ SHI!a~r,-~, REINSTALL 2X4 DOUBLE !~ SLPY~, 46' RIi~ 0 0 $ 10016 BLD97-0&92 ~-(]qECuA 804 IO~A AVE PEP J~qF RE~ KXIST~]~G ,~z.~AIOR DOOR AND REPL,A~:~ WEST ELEVATI(AN SIDII~G WIT]4 0 0 $ 10000 BLD97-0779 B~Y BY~ RKDECK AND P. EROOF 906 E B~ ST REP RJdIF 0 0 $ 8922 BLD97-0765 C~ CO. 631 S VAN B~ ST J~OOF ~ C~ =A' FIBERG~ SHI]~ R,~P RMF 0 0 $ 7628 BLD97-0719 GI~ PA~"T~ 720 N Dq~B~E ST REROOF N1"~4 CLASS 'A= SH17a~-q PEP 1~ 0 0 $ 7500 BLD97-0722 HOMARD EI~ 605 ~[DE ~ P. KROOF U~ING CLASS A SH17a'~J~q REP PJqF 0 0 $ 7300 BLD97-0718 MIKE HCEX~E 130 JE~q.q(Hq ST J~EP RMF STRUCTURAL STABILIZATZOI~ OF ~ B¶IILDI]~GAS PER KNGINEER'S REPORT 4 0 $ 5000 BLD97-0748 JALIL MOSTAFA3FI 219 H~S~ ST REROOF Wi~ C1~ "A" SHlJa~J~q REP PJ~F 0 6 $ 4600 BLD97-0713 GARY SLAGER FAJd~Ly 316 S D~DGE ST PARTNERSHIP REROOF WITJ4 CLASS =C' ASPH~.LT ~i~=~t~ P.~P ~ 0 0 S 3500 BLD97-0711 GARY S~ PAULY 330 S D~ ST PARTNEI~'HP REROOF #IT~ CLASS=A= FIBERGLASS PEP J~ 0 0 $ 3200 BLD97-0746 D~ MEIER 425 BOq~ERY ST REROOF WITH CLASS "A" SHIN~m-q REP RMF 0 0 $ 3000 ELD97-0717 R & J APARTI~qTS 902 NEWTO~ RD REROOF USING CI2%SS "C" SHINGLE REP RMF 0 C $ 2863 5LD97-0780 JULIE & JAMIE 723 J~M%'~ON ~T REP ~ 0 0 $ 1200 SCHWESER EXTERIOR WOOD LANDING AND STAIRS PEP RMF permats: 20 6 $ 197389 5129~-~750 MARY THROGMORTON 508 S SU~IT ST P. EROOF WIT~ CLASS "A' SHINGLES PEP RSF C [ S i026{ ~ro~: 10/01/~ To..: 10/31/97 CITY OF IO~A CITY ~m~-'~IO~ OF BUILDING PE~G~T DATA FO~ C~SUS B~REAU R~PC~T Per~it ~licant na~e A~ress Ty~e Type Storzes Units Valuatzon No. I~r Use BLD97-0738 ~ ~L~ 1510 C~C~T ~T ~I~NE~T FO~qDATIO~MALLA~DAD~ 5 X S WOOD FROIr~ 0 0 $ 10000 BLD97-0749 ~ ~ 219 MY~TL~ AV~ HEROOF #IT~ CLASS 'A' SHIIW~mc UP ~SF D 0 $ 8910 BLD97o0081 M~C~A~L ~ 816 J~II~R DR UPL~Z EXZSTII~ PATIO BL.D97-0696 ~¥ ~ 1232 M~;C~TINE AV~ R~OOF #IT~ CL~S~ "A' P~P R~F 1 0 $ 7568 R.~P P. SF 0 0 $ 6800 B~97-0481 FI~-qT ~ 213 NOOD~l~K~ AVE ~P ~SF 1 0 $ 3500 BL~97-078S GA~Y ~ 702 IO~A AVE ~EP ~SF 0 0 $ 1200 UPI,~CE R~l-i~ PO~CH JOIST COL~ ARD RAILINGS REP ~SF l:)ermits: 7 $ 48244 TOTALS 51 S 6156422 11/12/97 11:19 To:IOW~ CITY CLERK From:Jo Hogarty 319-3S4-4213 Page 1/11 Sally Slutsman, Clmirperson * :: Joe Bolkcom " .,o Jonathan Jordahl .._. -- S~hea P. Lacina November 13, 1997 ;-- ' '..' BOARD OF SUPERVISORS FORMAL MEETING 1. Call to order 5:30 p.m. Agenda 5:~0 p.m_ - Public Hearing adopting proposed plans and stx~ifications, proposed form of contract, fixing cost estimate and setting public hearing on remodeling of property at 417 South Clinton Streel~ Iowa City, Iowa to provide a courtroom and office space. a) Motion adopting proposed plans and specifications, proposed form of contract, fixing .cost estimate and setting public ~earing on remodeling of property at 417 South Clinton Street, Iowa Cay, Iowa to provide a courtroom and office space. 3. Action re: claims Action re: formal minutes of November 6th and the formal minutes for canvass of votes for city election of November 10th. 5. Action re: payroll aufimrizations 6. Business from the County Auditor a) Action re: permits b) Action re: reports c) Other 913 SOUTH DUBUQUE ST. P.O. BOXI350 IOWA CITY, IOWA 52244-1350 TEL: (319) 356-6000 11/12~J? 11:19 To:IO~ CITY CLERK Agenda 11-13-97 From:Jo Hogarty 319-354-4213 Business from the Zoning and Planning Zoning Admini.~trato~: Page Z/11 a) First and second consideration amending the legal description for Lot 3, Timberwood Estates, NE 1/4 of Section 18; Township 81 North; Range 7 West of the 5th P.M. m Johnson County, Iowa. Submitted by Art Hoefief (Z9653) b) Motion setting public hearing for various zonings and plattings. c) Other 6:00 p.m. - Public Hearing on Conditional Use Permit 9706 a) Discussion/action re: the following Conditional Use Permit: 1) Application CU9706 of Tom H. Williams, owner, signed by William L. Meardon, representing S & G Materials of Iowa City, requesting a .Conditional Use Permit to operate a sand and gravel excavation as allowed m Chapter 8:1.34 (H2) of the Johnson County Zoning Ordinance on property located in the SE 1/4 of the NW 1/4 and Application CU9706 of Tom H. Williams, owner, signed by William L. Meatdon, representing S & G Materials of Iowa City, requesting Government 2 and the West 1/2 of the South 19.10 acres of Government Lot 1, all in Section 34; Township 79 North; Range 6 West of the 5TH P.M. of John~n County, Iowa. This property is located south of the I?aak Walton Road SE and east of Oak Crest Hill Road SE in West Lucas Twp.) discussion/action 11/12/97 11:19 To:IOf~ CITY CLERK Agenda 11-13-97 From:Jo Hogartv 319-354-4213 Page 3 Page 3/11 7:00 p.m. - Public Hearing on Amendment, Zoning and Platting applications: a) Discussion/action re: the following Amendments: The Fringe Area Agreeanent between the City of Swishcr, Iowa and Johnson County, Iowa. An amendment to the Johnson County / Iowa City Fringe Area Agrccmcnt (Chaptcr 28E Code of Iowa). Dclctc thc word Plat and replace with the new words Concept Plan in "Fringe Area A Paragraph 1 and Fringe Arm C, paragraph 2 Subparagraph 2. b) First and Second consideration of the following Zoning applications: 1. Application Z9729 of Fobian Farms Inc., West Branch, signed by Carl Fobian, requesting rezoning of 2.5 acres fxom CH Highway Commercial to C2 Commercial of certain property described as bcing in the NE .1/4 of the NE 1/4 of Section 11; Township 79 North; Range 5 West of the 5th P.M_ in Johnson County, Iowa (This property is located in the southwest quadrant of Herbert Hoover Highway NE and Oasis Road NE in Scott Twp.). 2. Apphcation Z9742 of Richard Rossman, Rivcrside, requesting rczoning of 5.0 acres fi'om AI Rural to RS-5 'Suburban Residential of certain property described as being in theNE 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of Section 12; Township 77 North; Range 6 West of the 5th P.M. in Johnson County, Iowa (This property is located on the east side of River Junction Road SE, approximately 0.2 of a mile south of Otter Creek Road SE in Fremont Twp.). 11/12/97 11:19 To:IO~ CITY CLERK From:Jo HogartV 319-3§4-4213 Page 4/11 Agenda 11-13-97 Page 4 Application of Z9743 of Robert Rtmamelhart, Riverside, signed by Randy Knottnems, requesting rezoning of 3.5 acres (a 1.95 acre and 1.54 acre parcel) fi'om A1 Rural to RS Suburban Residential of certain property described as being Lot I of Rummelhart's 1st Subdivision located in the SW 1/4 of the NW 1/4 of Section 21; Township 78 North; Range 6 West of the 5th P.M. in Johnson County, Iowa (I'his property is located on the north side of the "Y" intexsection of Observatory Avenue SW and Ruppenkamps Road SW in Liberty Twp.). c) Discussion/action re: the following Platting application: I. Application S9768 of Robert Rummclhart requesting prel'uninary and final plat approval of Rummelhart's Second Subdivision (A Resubdivision of Lot 1 of Rummelhart'sIIST Subdivision) a sulxUvision described as being located in ~e SW 1/4 of the NW 1/4 of Section 21; Township 78 North; _R~g. ' e 6 West of the 5th P.M. in Johnson County, Iowa (This is a 2-19t, 7.9 acre, residential subdivision, located on the north side of th~ "Y" totersection of Observatory Avenue SW and Ruppenkamp~, Road SW in Liberty d) First and Second comideration of fiae following, Zoning application: 1. Application Z9744 of William MacKenzie, Iowa City, requesting rezoning of 1.99 acres from AI Rural to RS :Suburban Residential of certain property described as being in the Township 78 North; Range 6 West of the County, Iowa (This property is located in ~ of Dane Road SW and 480th Street SW in Lil NW 1/4 of Section 9; 5th P.M. in Johnson ~e southeast quadrant i1/12~J7 11:19 To:I0~ CITY CLERK Froa:Jo Hogartv 319-354-4213 Page §/11 Agenda 11-13-97 Page 5 e) Discussion/action re: ' the following Platting application: Application S9761 of William MacKenzie requesting preliminary and final plat approval of Mackenzie Manor, a subdivision described as being located m the NW 1/4 of Section 9; Township 78 North; Range 6 West of the 5th P.M. m Johnson County, Iowa (This is a 2-lot, 28.99 acre, one lot residential and one lot farmstead split, located m the SE quadrant of Dane Road and 480th Slxeet SW intersection in Liberty Twp.). f) First and Second consideration of the following,Zoning application: 1. Application Z9745 of Arlene Hotz, Iowa City, requesting rezoning of 5.0 acres from AI Rural to RS-5 Suburban property described as being in the NE 1/4 of 18; Township 78 North; Range 5 West of thl County, Iowa (T!xis property is located on Avenue SE, approximately' 1/4 of a mile n¢ with 520th Street SE in Pleasant Valley Twp. g) Discussion/action re: the following Platting ap Residential of certain the SE 1/4 of Section :5th P.M. in Johnson the west side of Taft rth of its intersection Application S9754 of Randy and Wanda, Johnson, signed by Wanda Johnson, requesting preliminary andlfinal plat approval of Randy and Wanda Subdivision, a subdivisiqn described as being located in the NW 1/4 of the NE 1/4 of Section 26; Township 79 North; Range 8 West of the 5th P.M. in Johnson County, Iowa (This is a l-lot, 15.0 acre, residential subdivasxon, located on the south side of Rohret Road SW, approximately 1/2 mile west of the Rohret Road and Cosgrove Road SW intersection in Hardin Tx~p.). Application S9760 of AI Wells requesting final plat approvaI of Lake Land Subdivision, Part One, a subdivision described as being ll/JZ/9? 69:ZZ To:ZOI~ CZTY CLERK From:Jo Hogarty 319-354-4ZZ3 Page ~/! Sally Smtsm~, Ch~irperso~ Joe Bolke~m Chsrlas D. Duffy Jo~at!~n ~ordshl St~nn P. L~ins BOARD OF SUPERVISORS November 13, 1997 ~2 INFORMAL MEETING Agenda 1. Call to order 5:00 p.m. 2. Review ofthe formal nfinul~s of November 6th Business from Bruce National Company re: discussion Ahrem, Senior Farm Manager of Farmers Conservation Reserve Program at the county farm. 4. Business from the Board of Supervisors a) Letter from Stephen N. Greenleaf from Lynch, Greenleaf & Michael, L.L.P. re: resolution of the City of Oxford assenting to the vohmtary annexation of property owned by Robert B. Kasper and Margaret E. Kasper. discussion (Carol) b) Discussion re: representative from Johnson County to the Urnted Way/Joint Funding Hearings. c) Reports d) Other 5. Discussion from the public 6. Recess FORMAL MEETING TO FOLLOW 913SOUTHDUBUQUE ST. P.O. BOX1350 IOWACITY, IOWA 52244-1350 TEL:(319) 356-6(X)0 FAX:(319) 356-6086 11/14/97 11:11 To:lOtdfi CZTY CLERK Froa:Jo Hogarty 319-354-4213 Page 1/1 November 17, 1997 NATIONAL GUARD OF IOWA HEADQUARTERS 925 SOUTH DUBUQUE STREET IOWA CITY INFORMAL MEETING A~ud~ Call to order 8:30 ~rn_ b) Work Session to discuss Strategic Planning a) Discussion re: the following: 1. Review of goals and adoption 2. Redefine priorities 3. Adjourn hz~r, md~1997~l I- 17.doc 913 SOUTH DUBUQUE ST. P.O. BOX 1350 IOWA CITY, IOWA 52244-1350 TEL: (319) 356-6000 FAX: (319) 3 City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM TO: City Council FROM: City Manager DATE: November 13, 1997 RE: Out of the City I plan on being out of the City from Wednesday November 26 (3:00 p.m.) until Friday, November 28 at 7:00 p.m. Lisa will have my itinerary. ANNUAL REPORT OF BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS FISCAL YEAR 1997 ~ ¢ltlt of STAFF SUPPORT Airport Commission .............................................................Ron O'Neil ........................356-5045 Airport Zoning Board of Adjustment ................................... Ron O'Neil ........................356-5045 Airport Zoning Commission .................................................Ron O'Neil ........................356-5045 Animal Control Advisory Board ...........................................Misha Goodman ...............356-5295 Board of Adjustment ............................................................Melody Rockwell ..............356-5251 Board of Appeals ..................................................................Ron Boose .......................356-5122 Board of Library Trustees ....................................................Susan Craig .....................356-5200 Board of Review ...................................................................Dan Hudson .....................356-6066 Broadband Telecommunications Commission .................. Drew Shaffer ....................356-5046 Civil Service Commission ....................................................Sylvia Mejia ......................356-5026 Design Review Committee ...................................................Jim Schoenfelder .............356-5044 Historic Preservation Commission ..................................... Scott Kugler .....................356-5243 Housing and Community Development Commission ........ Steven Nasby ...................356-5248 Human Rights Commission .................................................Heather Shank .................356-5022 Parks and Recreation Commission ..................................... Terry Trueblood ...............356-5110 Planning and Zoning Commission ...................................... Bob Miklo .........................356-5240 Riverfront and Natural Areas Commission ......................... Brad Neumann .................356-5235 Senior Center Commission ..................................................Linda Kopping ..................356-5225 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Airport Commission ................................................. 1 Airport Zoning Board of Adjustment ..................................... 3 Airport Zoning Commission ........................................... 5 Animal Control Advisory Board ........................................ 7 Board of Adjustment ............................................... 9 Board of Appeals .................................................. 11 Board of Library Trustees ............................................ 13 Board of Review ................................................... 15 Broadband Telecommunications Commission .............................. 17 Civil Service Commission ............................................ 19 Design Review Committee ........................................... 21 Histodc Preservation Commission ...................................... 23 Housing and Community Development Commission ......................... 27 Human Rights Commission ........................................... 29 Parks and Recreation Commission ..................................... 33 Planning and Zoning Commission ...................................... 35 Riverfront and Natural Areas Commission ................................ 41 Senior Center Commission ........................................... 43 AIRPORT COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The Iowa City Municipal Airport Commission is a five-member commission responsible for formulating policy and directing administration of the Iowa City Municipal Airport as a public facility in accordance with local, Iowa Department of Transportation and the Federal Aviation Administra- tion regulations. The Commission was established by public referendum under Iowa Code in 1941. The Commissioners are appointed by the Mayor and approved by the City Council, with a six (6) year term of office. The Airport Commission meets monthly, with additional meetings as required. ACCOMPESHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 1. Began implementation of the 1996 Airport Master Plan. 2. Drafted Airport commercial business minimum standards. 3. Drafted the Airport Aircraft Emergency Plan. 4. Initiated plans to build an additional T-hangar building. 5. Sponsored the sixteenth annual Airport Open House. 6. Initiated plans to lease approximately 55 acres of Airport property to increase Airport revenue. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Complete the Land Acquisition and Easement project. Complete the Airport Aircraft Emergency Plan. Complete the Airport commercial business minimum standards. Determine engineering needs to renovate the Airport Terminal and Maintenance Shop. Develop a plan to lease approximately 55 acres of Airport property. Develop a five-year business strategy plan. Complete construction of the SE T-hangar building. Implement the projects in the 1996 Master Plan as FAA and IDOT funding becomes available. PLANNED PROJECTS Implementing the 1996 Master Plan has begun with the removal of some obstructions on City- owned property. A consultant has been selected to assist with the easements and land acquisition project. ACSG, from Naperville, Illinois, completed Phase l in June and was given a ' Notice to Proceed ' with Phase II on June 20th. In an effort to increase Airport revenue, the Commission began a project to develop approximately 55 acres of Airport property. The property was surveyed and appraised. The Commission is debating the best way to develop the property. Among those expressing interest in locating at the Airport are the Iowa City Science Center, the Iowa City Public Works Department, Iowa City Landscaping, and two private developers. COMMISSION MEMBERS Pat Foster, Chairperson Richard Blum, Vice Chairperson/Secretary Howard Horan Rick Mascari John Penick Ronald J. O'Neil, Airport Manager 2 IOWA CITY-JOHNSON COUNTY AIRPORT ZONING COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES In accordance with Chapter 329 of the Code of Iowa, the Board of Supervisors of Johnson County and the City Council of Iowa City co-established the Johnson County-Iowa City Airport Zoning Commission. It is the duty of the Commission to advise and make recommendations to the Board of Supervi- sors and the City Council as to the appropriate zoning requirements and other matters pertaining to the physical development of areas of the county and the city surrounding the Iowa City Municipal Airport, so as to maximize compatibility between Airport uses and the uses of the adjacent land. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 The Commission did not meet in FY97. PLANS FISCAL YEAR 1998 As Iowa City expands to the south and west, a careful analysis must be made of the impact to the Iowa City Airport. The Commission will review the zoning in the approaches to the runways at the Iowa City Airport and will develop recommendations for zoning in the approach areas to prevent uses incompatible with Airport operations. The Commission will work with the Planning and Community Development Department to establish the most beneficial use of Airport land for development. The land uses must be compatible with Airport uses and with surrounding property uses. This Commission will review the proposed zoning changes to be requested by the Iowa City Airport Commission for industrial development of airport property. Implementation of the 1996 Master Plan may require some zoning review. COMMISSION MEMBERS Richard Blum, Chairperson Pat Foster Don Sehr Kae Wild 3 4 IOWA CITY- JOHNSON COUNTY AIRPORT ZONING BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES In accordance with Chapter 329 of the Code of Iowa, the Board of Supervisors of Johnson County and the City Council of Iowa City co-established the Johnson County-Iowa City Airport Zoning Board of Adjustment. It is the duty of this Board to hear and decide appeals where it is alleged that there has been an error in any administrative action in the enforcement of the ordinance and to hear and decide on special exceptions that are specifically provided for in the ordinance and to authorize variances from the terms of the ordinance on appeal in specific cases. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 The Board did not receive any appeals, requests for exceptions, or requests for variances during the 1996-97 year. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 The Board will respond to appeals and other requests as it receives them and will make recom- mendations regarding the Zoning Ordinance. BOARD MEMBERS Jonathan C. Carlson, Chair Stephen Radosevich Eldon Moss Scott Reynolds Sue Bender ANIMAL CONTROL ADVISORY BOARD GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES To provide such recommendations and advice as are required by the 28E agreement, or as may be requested by the City Council or City Manager of Iowa City or by the City Council or City Administrator of Coralville. ACCOMPMSHMENTS IN RSCAL YEAR 1997 Received approval from the the City Council to install the wildlife reflector warning system on Dodge Street between the cemetery and 1-80. Amended the 28E agreement between Coralville and Iowa City. Started the process of a formsl contract between The University of Iowa and Iowa City Animal Control. Installed new phone system to give the public better service and add to availability of phone lines. Worked with City Council to approve and adopt a new permit ordinance. Started new program on City infovision to give the public access to information about the shelter, animal care, and animal laws. Photos and descriptions of available animals also appear. New Sunday cable access television show filmed live at the shelter. Started advertising weekly radio spots in conjunction with local pet shops and pet food companies to assist in the adoption of specific highlighted animals. Started renovation of old shelter building and repairs needed to newer portion. Held our first annual Adoptathon to promote animal adoptions. Through the Florence Unash Fund, assisted needy families in the spaying and neutering of approximately one hundred animals. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 Work on contract with local veterinarians for medical treatment service and Rabies vaccinations. Apply bequest money to a specific project yet to be determined. Paint the inside of the building. Forrealize contract for service with The University of Iowa. Consider formal microchipping program. 7 BOARD MEMBERS Diana Lundell, Chair Janet Ashman Dennis Cowles Julie Seal Martin Shafer BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The Board of Adjustment is empowered through Chapter 414 of the Code of Iowa and Section 14-4B of the Iowa City Code to grant special exceptions as provided in the Zoning Chapter and to hear appeals to decisions made in the enforcement of the Zoning Chapter. The Board has the authority to allow variances to the Zoning Chapter for individual properties where provisions of the Chapter impose a unique and unnecessary hardship on the property owner and where the granting of a vadance is not contrary to the intent of the Zoning Chapter or to the public interest. The Board may also submit recommendations to the Planning & Zoning Commission and the City Council regarding amendments to the Zoning Chapter. The Board is a quasi-judicial body whose decisions may be appealed directly to District Court. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 The Board of Adjustment met 10 times dudng FY97 and made the following decisions: Appeals: 0; Special Exceptions: 6 approved, 25 approved with conditions, 5 denied, 1 amended, 3 extended; Variances: 2 approved with conditions, 5 denied The Board's decisions in FY97 resulted in: Reducing off-street parking requirements in 3 cases; allowing parking in the Central Business (CB-10) zone in 2 cases; permitting tandem parking in a front yard in 1 case Modifying front yard requirements in 10 cases, the side yard requirements in I case, and the rear yard requirements in 2 cases Allowing a religious institution to be established in the Low Density Single-Family Residential (RS- 5) zone; allowing 2 religious institutions to be expanded in the RS-5 zone; allowing a bed and breakfast inn to be established in the RS-5 zone Modifying the separation distance requirements for a zero lot line structure in the Medium Density Single-Family Residential (RS-8) zone Permitting administrative review of development on property containing cdtical and protected slopes in the Highway Commercial (CH-1) zone Allowing a small animal clinic to be established in the Commercial Office (C0-1) zone; allowing a beauty shop to be established in the C0-1 zone Modifying the screening requirements for a parking area in the Community Commercial (CC-2) zone Allowing 3 auto-and truck-oriented uses (car wash/gas pumps, muffler/brake shop, used car sales lot) in the CC-2 zone, and 1 (car wash/gas pumps) in the Neighborhood Commercial (CN-1) zone Permitting temporary outdoor storage of tires and appliances in the General Industrial (I-1) zone 9 PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 The Board will continue to consider appeals, special exceptions and variances to the Zoning Chapter as they are requested and to make recommendations to the Planning & Zoning Commis- sion and the City Council regarding the Zoning Chapter. BOARD MEMBERS Patdcia Eckhardt, Chairperson William Haigh, Vice Chairperson Susan Bender Lowell Brandt Kate Corcoran Melody Rockwell, Secretary 10 BOARD OF APPEALS GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The responsibility of the Board of Appeals as set by City ordinance is to review the Uniform Building Code, the Uniform Fire Code, the Uniform Plumbing Code, the Uniform Mechanical Code, the National Electrical Code, and the Uniform Code for the Abatement of Dangerous Buildings and recommend amendments for these regulatory codes; to assist the building official in making interpretations; to hear appeals for any person that is aggrieved by a decision of the building official and pass judgement on that appeal; and to consider alternate materials and methods of construction. The Board consists of seven citizens who live within the corporate limits of the City of Iowa City. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 1. The Board heard one appeal of a Housing Code violation. That appeal was denied. 2. The Board heard four requests for variances from the Housing Code. All were granted. The Board heard two appeals of the Building Official's interpretation of the Building Code. One was denied, the other withdrawn by the applicant. The Board heard three requests for modifications of the Building Code. Two were ap- proved, one denied. The Board heard four requests for use of alternate materials or methods of construction. Three were granted, one denied. The Board heard two requests for code amendments. One was approved, the other is pending. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998: 1. Contir~ue to work with the Home Builders Association to clarify code issues. 2. Begin process of amending and adopting the 1997 Uniform codes. Continue to hear appeals, requests for variances and modification, requests for alternate materials and methods of construction and requests for code amendments. BOARD MEMBERS Robert Cadson, Chairperson Tom Werderitsch John Roffman Anna Buss C. Wayne Maas John Staska Gary Haman 11 12 BOARD OF LIBRARY TRUSTEES GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The Board of Trustees of the Public Library is a semi-autonomous body of nine persons empow- ered by state law and city ordinance to act as the goveming body of the library. The Board's specific list of legal responsibilities includes: determining the goals and objectives of the Library in order to plan and carry out Library services; determining and adopting written policies to govem all aspects of the operation of the Library; preparing an annual budget and having exclusive control of all monies appropriated by the City Council and the Johnson County Board of Supervi- sors or given to the Library through gifts, bequests, contracts, grants or awards; employing a competent staff to administer its policies and carry out its programs. The Board is also an arm of City Govemment with members appointed by the City Council and its principal operating funds approved by the City Council. The Board therefore seeks at all times to work in harmony with City policies in all areas that do not conflict with its statutory powers. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 Worked with City Council to revise original building plans to include Library expansion as part of a multi-use facility including current library site and parcel 64-1a. Celebrated the Library's centennial with a series of events. Four thousand people attended the January birthday party. Successfully sought funding to keep the Library open most summer Sundays (all except August) for the first time in 85 years. Added position of Circulation Services Coordinator, after requesting for three years, by reclassifying an open position. Supported improved access to electronic information through purchase of a full-text magazine database. Improved staff efficiency through purchase of catalog records from OCLC, the largest service provider. 7. Adopted update to strategic plan and reviewed bi-annual progress reports. Reviewed and revised policies related to Hours of Service, Use of Cardholder file, Fi- nance, Volunteers and Public Relations. 9. Proposed a contract for service to University Heights with the Coralville Public Library. 10. Supported state program to provide funding for local libraries. 13 PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 1. Build support for downtown library expansion proposal. 2. Conclude celebration of the Library's Centennial. 3. Expand Sunday service to all year. 4. Conduct a community survey in preparation for next long range planning cycle. 5. Explore drop-off sites for return of library materials other than the downtown building. 6. Increase development activities available to Board members. 7. Increase Board understanding of, and involvement in, strategic planning. 8. Expand access to wodd wide web information in the Library and plan for needed upgrades in technology. 9. Review orientation process for new Board members. 10. Support state-wide efforts to increase state aid to public libraries. 11. Revise form used for annual director evaluation process. 12. Review policies as needed. 13. Encourage cooperation with area libraries and organizations, including the Johnson County Community Networking Group. 14. Assist the Fdends Foundation in the development of a capital campaign. BOARD MEMBERS Chades Traw, President Stephen Greenleaf Mark Martin Margaret Cox Philip Hubbard Mary McMurray K. Jesse Singerman Anne Spencer Jim Swaim 14 BOARD OF REVIEW GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The Board of Review is established and govemed by the Code of Iowa, Chapters 441.31 to 441.44, for the purpose of equalizing assessments by raising or Iowedng individual assessments as established by the Assessor. The Board also makes the final rulings each year on exempt properties. The Board of Review is issued a manual by the Iowa Department of Revenue & Finance to guide them in their work along with forms for the odginal meeting daily meetings and the final meeting. The Board must also file with the State Director of Revenue & Finance within 15 days of adjourn- ment, a report on their session. The Board's meetings are subject to the open meetings law. Since it is extremely important that the Board keep accurate minutes of its proceedings, the Board has a separate clerk to keep these minutes. The Board must also include in their written notice to the petitioner the specific reasons for their actions. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 The following is a report on the activities of the Iowa City Board of Review since adjournment on May 22, 1996. The Iowa City Board of Review met on 6 days during the period of May 1 to May 23, 1997. The Board received a total of 114 petitions. These have been broken down into classification along with their outcome and listed below. 81 Residential 30 Upheld 51 Denied 31 Commercial 18 Upheld 13 Denied 0 Agricultural 0 Upheld 0 Denied 2 Industrial I Upheld I Denied 114 Total 49 Upheld 65 Denied In addition to these 114 petitions, the Board reduced seven residential and two commercial properties at the request of the assessor or on their own volition. These were due to late inspec- tions of estimated listing of properties, or due to comparable properties being changed by the Board. By the filing deadline of June 20, 1997, six property owners representing six total parcels have filed in District Court. Two of the appeals are for residential property, and the other four are for commercial property. No court cases were tried during FY97. All of the pending cases were either dismissed or settled. Of the nine 1995 cases, seven were settled and two dismissed, and both of the 1996 cases were dismissed. 15 PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 Since the Board of Review hears only protests brought to them by others, there is no way to predict the amount of work for next year. But, because next year is not a reassessment year, the workload is expected to be less than the session just finished. Additionally, it is expected that the Iowa Depar[ment of Revenue & Finance will be issuing orders adjusting the value of agricultural property in Iowa City. If the State orders any increases in value, the Board of Review would have to meet in late October to hear any appeals of the increases. BOARD OF REVIEW MEMBERS Janice Sweet, Chairperson Haywood Belle Ernie Galer Keith Wymore Jack Yanaush Norwood Louis, Clerk 16 BROADBAND TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The Broadband Telecommunications Commission (BTC) is a City commission comprised of five Iowa Citians and is mandated to facilitate and to regulate the smooth and effective development and operation of the City's Broadband Telecommunications Network (BTN) the City's cable television system, as well as advise on telecommunications-related matters. The Commission makes its recommendations to City Council in matters pertaining to the BTN, resolves disputes about the operation of the BTN, conducts pedoclic evaluations of the BTN operation, and, in general, facilitates BTN use by the citizens of Iowa City, which includes the promotion and facilitation of the access channels and community programming. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 Assisted subscribers in retaining WGN for the Iowa City area. Facilitated challenges regarding TCI's rate increases where possible and appropriate. Oversaw and facilitated the Community Television Service (CTS) Community Programming effort, a new service offered through the Cable TV Division. The CTS supported by the pass-through funds has, in 8 months, produced 47 hours of community programs. Continued overseeing the allocation of local programming fee (pass-through) funds to benefit all local access channels and providers. In the last year, over $17,000 went to purchase a remote studio for the Iowa City Public Library and new editing equipment for the Senior Center. Continued work on public access performance guidelines. Received progress reports from the Educational Access Channel 11, Library Access Channel 10, Public Access Channel 2, and Government Access Channel 4. Channel 4 has aired 270 new programs dudng the last year and produced 135 of those programs. Channel 11 produces the School Board meetings among other shows. Channel 10 produces Storytime, among other shows from ICPL Room A. SCTV produces Mature Focus and a range of programming for senior citizens. Monitored the collection of the franchise fee from the grantee and assisted in determining how those funds should be spent. Received and reviewed subscriber complaints reported by the Cable TV Administrator. Over 130 complaints were received and processed in the last year. Monitored developments in legislation, the FCC, and the courts that were cable TV- and telecom- munications-related. The Cable TV Administrator represented in the League of Iowa Cities' new Telecommunications Task Force. 17 Monitored PATV via reports presented by the PATV Director and/or PATV Chairperson. PA'!'V has cablecast 497 new programs in the last year, produced with the use of PATV equipment. Promoted the growth and development of Iowa City's access channels. Monitored developments of the Iowa City Community School District Technology Council. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 Facilitate the development of a Telecommunications Ordinance for Iowa City. Continue oversight regarding the cable TV plant rebuild and new franchise implementation. Oversee plans and make recommendations concerning formation of a Joint Telecommunications Facility. Attend PA'I'V meetings. Complete performance guidelines for PATV per the new PA'!'V contract. Evaluate PATV's performance and compliance with their new contract. Continue to monitor cable company performance to ensure compliance with the Iowa City cable ordinance and contractual agreements. Proceed with the rate regulation oversight and process according to FCC rules. Continued oversight and facilitation of community programming services and allocate local programming fee (pass through) funds as approved by Council. COMMISSION MEMBERS Cordell Jeppsen, Chair Betty McKra.v. Vice Chair Steve Hoch Howie Vernon Cathy Weingeist 18 CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES Chapter 400 of the Code of Iowa and Section 2-111, Code of Ordinances, establish and govem the Civil Service Commission. Three citizens who are residents of the City are appointed by the City Council to serve four-year terms. The Commission establishes and publishes rules relating to examinations for civil service positions, establishes guidelines for conducting such examinations, and certifies lists of persons eligible for appointment to respective positions. The Commission has jurisdiction to hear appeals and determine all matters involving the rights of employees under civil service law and may affirm, modify, or reverse any administrative action on its medts. The Commission meets when necessary. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 In maintaining full compliance with Code of Iowa Chapter 400, development and use of Civil Service selection procedures continued for all covered entry level and promotional positions on a City-wide basis. Seventy-three positions were filled from a total of 1456 applicants for non-Po- lice and Fire Civil Service covered positions A certified list of 10 was approved by the Civil Service Commission for the position of Police Officer. Three hundred thirty six applications were mailed to individuals who expressed interest in the position. One hundred eighty seven applications were completed and returned for this position, 111 applicants took the written test, 51 applicants took the agility test and 40 applicants were interviewed. A certified list of 20 was approved by the Civil Service Commission for the position of Firefighter. Six hundred fifteen applications were mailed to individuals who expressed interest in the position. Two hundred seventy four applications were completed and returned for this position, 192 applicants took the written test, 61 applicants took the agility test and 54 applicants were interviewed. Promotional testing was conducted for two command positions in Police. Three applicants tested for Police Captain, one was hired and two applicants tested for Police Lieutenant, one was hired. There were no disciplinary appeals to the Commission during FY97. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 During FY98, Commissioners will oversee the selection process for Police Officer, as well as promotional testing for positions in the Police and Fire Department as necessary. COMMISSION MEMBERS Michael W. Kennedy, Chair Lyra W. Dickerson Lon Moeller 19 20 DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The Design Review Committee is comprised of seven citizens who make recommendations to the City Council based on review of preliminary and final design plans for downtown urban renewal parcels, Near Southside urban revitalization projects, as well as general design plans for proposed public improvements in these areas. In addition, the Committee reviews design plans and makes recommendations to City Council for structures which extend into City Plaza. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 Reviewed and recommended to the City Council approval of the Taco Bell addition to Old Capitol Mall; approval of the design for the Science Center butterfly garden; approval of the design of the College Street News awning; approval of the design of the Magna Bank extedor signage; and disapproval of the design for the Transit Interchange Facility. · Performed a courtesy review of the design of the proposed biology building pedestrian bddge over Dubuque Street. · Made recommendations to the Planning and Zoning Commission and the City Council regarding projecting signs, awning signs, portable signs, and changeable copy signs. Recommended to the City Manager that the City remove the white plastic fencing from the City Plaza planting beds and that no other temporary fencing measure be taken while the City waits for the redesign of City Plaza by a consultant. · Recommended to the City Manager that the design of modular newspaper vending machines be incorporated into a comprehensive streetscape plan. · Reviewed and evaluated mobile cart design as shown in the applications for City Plaza vending permits. This is part of the permitting process for vendors. · Successfully recommended to the Planning and Zoning Commission and the City Council the adoption of the Design Review Oveday Zone Ordinance. · Began preparing first design review district and report. · Representatives from the Committee participated on the Downtown Strategy Committee, the Snelson Sculpture Committee, and the Chamber of Commerce Banner Committee. · Held 20 regular and special Committee meetings. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 1. Continue to review design plans and make recommendations in a timely fashion to the City Council for new construction and rehabilitation projects within the Committee's review authority. 21 2. Continue to prepare first design review distdct report and ordinance. 3. Continue to educate the community regarding the benefits of good design and design review and regarding techniques on achieving good design. 4. Continue to participate in the implementation of the Near Southside Design Plan and the Downtown Strategy. 5. Prepare for the 1998 Awards for Design Excellence. COMMrI"rEE MEMBERS Nancy Footner Marty Haynes Karyl Larson Gary Nagle Bill Nowysz Phillip Reisetter Randy Rohovit Clare Swan Daryl Woodson HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The ten-member Iowa City Histodc Preservation Commission is authorized to conduct studies for the identification and designation of local histodc districts, conservation districts and historic landmarks. The Commission either proceeds on its own initiative or upon receipt of a petition from any person, group, or association. The Commission furthers the efforts of historic preservation in the City by making recommenda- tions to the City Council and City commissions and boards on preservation issues by encouraging the protection and enhancement of structures, objects, or sites with historical, architectural or cultural value; and by encouraging persons and organizations to become involved in preservation activities. The Commission reviews applications for housing rehabilitation and rental rehabilitation assistance through the Community Development Block Grant Program to evaluate the effects of the pro- posed projects on properties over 50 years old. Modifications of activities are recommended in instances where the proposed alterations would have a negative impact upon the histodc or architectural qualities of structures which are determined to be eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. The Iowa City Histodc Preservation Commission is committed to working with other preservation organizations to implement a strong educational program designed to increase Iowa City residents' awareness and sensitivity to the cultural, architectural, and historical value of local structures, neighborhoods, and districts. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 Proposed the designation of the first sedes of Iowa City Historic Landmarks, approved by City Council in September 1996. The first series consisted of individual properties already listed on the National Register of Historical Places, but outside of existing historic district boundaries. Developed a plaque program to provide recognition for properties designated as Iowa City Histodc Landmarks. Funds have been donated by Friends of Historic Preservation to assist the Commission in purchasing the plaques. The first plaque was presented to the Summit Apartment Building at a ceremony held on June 29, 1997. It is anticipated that the rest of the plaques will be available and installed on historic landmark properties by Autumn 1997. Nominated the College Green and East College Street Areas for designation as Iowa City Historic Districts. The districts were approved by City Council in March of 1997 and brings the total number of histodc districts in Iowa City to six. Supervised the completion of an architectural-historical survey and evaluation of the Longfellow Neighborhood which was partially funded by a Historic Resource Development 23 o o 10. 11. Program (HRDP) grant of $7,500. The Commission retained the services of Molly Myers Naumann to conduct the survey. A series of neighborhood meetings was conducted as part of the survey process. The survey report recommends the designation of a Longfellow Histodc District upon the completion of additional survey work in the neighborhood. Applied for and received a certified local government grant of $4,450 to fund the survey and evaluation of the Longfellow Neighborhood, Phase II. This project will complete the survey of this neighborhood and provide information necessary to determine the proper boundaries for the proposed Longfellow Histodc District. Completed a survey and evaluation project of the Dubuque StJLinn St. corridor. The survey was partially funded by a Certified Local Government grant of $9,000. Molly Myers Naumann was retained to conduct the survey, which was completed in August of 1996 and contained recommendations for the designation of individual buildings as historic landmarks, and for a conservation distdct along portions of Dubuque and Clinton Streets. Supervised the nomination of the College Green and East College Street Historic Districts to the National Register of Historic Places. Consultants David Arbogast and Patricia Eckhardt completed the nominations, which are now pending before the National Park Service. The project was partially funded by a Historic Resources Development Program grant of $2,500. Supervised the survey and evaluation of the portion of the 1839 Original Town Plat that lies north of Davenport Street between Linn and Governor Streets. Tallgrass Histori- ans, LC has been retained to conduct the survey, which should be completed in Ju- ly 1997. A $9,000 Certified Local Government grant was obtained to assist in the comple- tion of this survey. Applied for a $16,400 Historic Resources Development Program grant to fund Phase II of the Original Town Plat survey covedng property bounded by Davenport Street, Gover- nor Street, Jefferson Street, and Linn Street. Continued to advise the Department of Public Works, the Department of Planning and Community Development, and the City Council about the historical importance of the Montgomery-Butler Residence and the need to consider stabilizing and protecting it for future preservation. Observed National Historic Preservation Week with an awards program at the Johnson County Courthouse on May 14. The program was co-sponsored by Friends of Historic Preservation, the Johnson County Historic Preservation Commission, and the Johnson County Historical Society. The Historic Preservation Awards for Residential Rehabilitation were presented to Steve and Barbara van der Woude for 222 N. Govemor Street, and Veronica Vieland and Roffman Construction for 802 S. Summit Street. Residential rehabili- tation special merit awards were presented to Julia Hagstrom and Thomas Wendt, 1009 E. College Street; Iver and Ann Cairns, 1033 Woodlawn; Douglas S. Russell, 722 N. Lucas Street; Amy and Geoffrey Lauer, 1813 C Street; and Mark and Karen Mannes and Newport Building and Design, 722 Kirkwood Avenue. In the category of Commercial or Institutional Rehabilitation/Construction, the Histodc Preservation Award was presented to Clarence and Dorothy Haverkamp for 619 N. Linn Street. Special merit certificates in that category were presented to The University of Iowa, 219 N. Clinton Street; St. Mary's 24 Church, 226 E. Jefferson Street; and Danette and John Raley, 24 N. Van Buren. Extedor painting awards were presented to Steve and Barbara van der Woude, 115 N. Gilbert Street; Margaret Frueholz, 421 S. Lucas Street; Mark Wagner, 2131 D Street; Josef Blair and Robin Ballard Simeonsson, 1017 Bowery Street; Victoria Walton, 430 N. Gilbert Street; Susan Brigham, 460 Wales Street; Paula and Lowell Brandt, 824 N. Gilbert Street; and Robert and Lorraine Bowans, 510 S. Governor Street. The Margaret Nowysz Preser- vation Person of the Year Award was presented to departing Commission members Douglas Russell and Susan Licht. The Nowysz Award recognizes individuals for their outstanding service to the citizens of Iowa City in the cause of historic preservation. 12. Pursuant to the Historic Preservation Ordinance, the Commission reviewed and approved seven certificates of appropriateness for additions and alterations of residences in the Summit Street, Woodlawn, Brown Street, College Green, East College Street, and Moffitt Cottage Histodc Districts. 13. Evaluated seven housing and rental rehabilitation projects for compliance with Section 106 of the National Histodc Preservation Act. 14. Held twelve regular and four special meetings. Also held two neighborhood meetings in association with the East College Street and College Green Historic District Nominations. 15. Completed a report to the City Manager outlining the history of the Commission's preser- vation activities over the past decade. 16. Worked with the Johnson County Historic Preservation Commission to implement the histodc properties tax abatement program provided for by State law. The Johnson County Board of Supervisors passed a resolution to allow county residents to take advantage of the program in February 1997. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 Conduct annual review sessions for the purpose of ensudng implementation and updating of the Iowa City Historic Preservation Plan. Supervise the completion of the nomination of the College Green and East College Street Historic Districts to the National Register of Histodc Places. Supervise completion of the Longfellow Neighborhood and Original Town Plat surveys and consider recommendations they contain for designation of historic districts, historic landmarks and conservation districts. Consider pursuing recommendations contained in the Dubuque Street/Linn Street Corridor survey report. Distribute plaques to the owners of properties included in the first series of Iowa City Historic Landmarks. Research project proposals for grant funding from sources such as the Certified Local Government (CLG) program, the Historic Resource Development Program (HRDP) and the National Trust for Histodc Preservation. 25 As recommended by the Histodc Preservation Plan, consider additional area surveys for the Kirkwood Avenue, Goosetown, and Downtown areas, and to study fraternity and sorority houses in Iowa City. o Review the Histodc Preservation Ordinance for proposed updating, amending, and tightening. 9. Prepare nominations for the second sedes of Iowa City Histodc Landmarks. 10. Continue to distribute educational material such as the Iowa City Neighborhood Design Book and A Guide to Histodc Iowa City, and consider updating these materials as needed. 11. Continue to advise City Council and other boards and commissions regarding matters of historic preservation policy, including the historic Montgomery-Butler House on the new water treatment plant site. 12. Continue to review Applications for Certificates of Appropriateness or Certificates of No Material Effect and to review housing and rental rehabilitation projects involving federal funds. 13. Prepare for the 1998 Historic Preservation Awards Program and for Preservation Week activities. 14. Continue liaison and cooperation with the Iowa City City Council, Johnson County Board of Supervisors, Iowa City/Coralville convention and Visitors Bureau, Johnson County Historical Society, Johnson County Histodc Preservation commission, State Historical Society of Iowa, and Fdends of Historic Preservation. COMMISSION MEMBERS Betty Kelly Ruedi Kuenzli, Summit Street District Representative Lars Anderson Doris Malkmus, Moffitt Cottage District Representative Michael Pugh, Vice Chairperson Michaelanne Widness John F. Shaw, Chairperson, Brown Street District Representative Ann Caims, Woodlawn Distdct Representative Frank Gersh, East College Street District Representative Pamela Michaud, College Green District Representative Reference City of Iowa City Code of Ordinances: 14-4C-1 to 14-4C-10, Historic Preservation Regula- tions; 14-6J-3 Historic Preservation Oveday Zone, and 14-6J-4 Conservation Overlay Zone 2. By-laws of Iowa City Historic Preservation Commission. 26 HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILmES The Housing and Community Development Commission (HCDC) consists of nine residents of Iowa City appointed by the City Council. They represent as nearly as possible a cross-section of the Iowa City population in background, ideas, geographic location, age, and socioeconomic status. Committee members serve for three years. The purpose of HCDC is to advise the Council on community needs in general and on the use of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Investment Partnership program (HOME) funds in particular, from a citizen viewpoint. To accomplish this the Commission provides systematic communication between citizens and policymakers with regard to community develop- ment projects. The Commission's work has been pdmadly directed at developing, coordinating, and reviewing the City's activities carded out in conjunction with the City's Consolidated Plan (CITY STEPS). In addition, the Commission reviews CD Division and Iowa City Housing Authority policies and periodically makes recommendations to the Council regarding these policies. ACCOMPUSHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 CDBG and HOME funds are allocated in conjunction with the City's fiscal year. The HCDC advertised the availability of funds for FY98 and held three public meetings to receive proposals. HCDC utilized a systematic process of funding allocation and held four meetings to hear and rank proposals and allocate CDBG and HOME funds. A total of $1.7 million was allocated to 18 projects, plus aid to human service agencies, program administration, and planning and contin- gency reserves for FY98. The following is a list of the FY98 projects: Micro-enterprise Training -- Small Business Development Center Micro-enterprise Training -- Institute for Social and Economic Development Business Expansion -- Heartland Candleworks Acquisition and Rehab -- Crisis Center Facility Improvements ~ United Action for Youth Residential Backflow Prevention ~ City of Iowa City Furniture Project ~ Domestic Violence Intervention Program Job Training ~ East Central Iowa Employment Training Consortium Youth Leadership Program -- Community Corrections Improvement Association Shelter Renovations ~ Emergency Housing Project Transitional Housing Support Services ~ Emergency Housing Project Aid to Human Service Agencies Small Repair Program ~ Eldedy Services Agency Housing Rehabilitation ~ City of Iowa City Manufactured Home Fire Safety -- City of Iowa City/University of Iowa Acquisition and Rehab -- Greater Iowa City Housing Fellowship Homeownership ~ Habitat for Humanity Homeownership ~ Swenson and Associates Construction of Rental Housing ~ Meadow Wood Senior Housing 27 To ensure that community needs are being met, HCDC members monitor projects during their implementation stages. The FY97 projects that were completed are: Emergency Housing Project -- Support Services City of Iowa City -- Housing Rehabilitation (approximately 35 projects) Elderly Services Agency Small Repair Program (approximately 45 projects) East Central Iowa Employment & Training Consortium -- Job Training (7 people) Domestic Violence Intervention Program -- Furniture Project City of Iowa City/D & K Properties: Acquisition of a Single Room Occupancy Building (21 units) LIFE Skills, Inc. -- Housing Counseling Program (approximately 60 households) Domestic Violence Intervention Program -- Shelter Renovation Institute for Social and Economic Development ~ Microenterprise Program (50 persons) Mayor's Youth Employment Program ~ Employment Training (approximately 20 youth) Free Medical Clinic Renovations Aid to Human Service Agencies Neighborhood Centers of Johnson County -- New Facility HearUand Candleworks m Equipment Purchase/Business Expansion (8 jobs) Greater Iowa City Housing Fellowship ~ Acquisition/Rehab (12 units) HCDC sponsored the ninth annual Iowa City Community Development Celebration. An awards ceremony honoring outstanding CDBG subrecipients and contractors was held on Apdl 30 at the newly rehabilitated Free Medical Clinic. The program featured community development activities for FY97. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 The monitoring of all ongoing projects as well as F'Y98 projects will continue. The purpose of this new commission will be to assess Iowa City's community development needs for housing, jobs, and services for low and moderate income residents, and to promote public and private efforts to meet such needs. COMMISSION MEMBERS Gretchen Schmuch, Chair Ann Donovan, Vice Chair Daniel Cilek Charles Eastham Denita Gadson Sandy Kuhlmann David Purdy Kathleen Renquist William Stewart 28 HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The Iowa City Human Rights Commission enforces the Human Rights Ordinance, Title 2, Iowa City Municipal Code. The Human Rights Ordinance is Iowa City's anti-discrimination law. The law gives the Human Rights Commission the jurisdiction to investigate allegations of discrimina- tion in the areas of employment, credit transactions, education, public accommodations and housing. It is the mission of the Human Rights Commission to eradicate discrimination in Iowa City, based on age, color, creed, disability, marital status, national origin, race, religion, sexual orientation or gender identity. In the area of housing, discrimination based on familial status, presence or absence of dependents or public assistance source of income is also prohibited. The Human Rights Ordinance gives the Commission the authority to enforce the law prohibiting discrimination and upon a finding of probable cause, to conciliate an agreement between the parties involved in a complaint. The Commission also has the responsibility of educating the public on the various forms of discrimination that exist in the Iowa City area and protecting citizens from unfounded charges of discrimination. The Human Rights Commission is a quasi-judicial body composed of nine volunteer members appointed by the City Council. Each member serves a three year term. Appointments to the Human Rights Commission take into consideration men and women of various racial, religious, cultural and socio-economic groups in Iowa City. The Commission meets once each month at 7:00 p.m. in the lobby conference room in the Civic Center. The meeting site is accessible to persons with disabilities. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 Revised the Human Rights Ordinance to make the law substantially equivalent to the Fair Housing Amendments Act. The changes in the law were made pursuant to recommenda- tions from the Department of Housing and Urban Development. The revised Ordinance was passed by the City Council and became law on May 28, 1997. The Ordinance was then sent to HUD for review. Initiated film sedes to depict discrimination in its various forms. The first film, 'Gentleman's Agreement,' dealt with anti-semitism. Human Rights Commissioners and representatives from the University met with Mr. Frank Tribble from the Iowa Civil Rights Commission to discuss community diversity teams. Organizational meetings are continuing. A speech on local, state and federal disability law given to the Multiple Sclerosis Support Group at Mercy Hospital. 29 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. Provided training on gender identity to employers and the Iowa City Police Department, the Johnson County Sheriff's Department, Campus Security, and the Coralville Police Department. Taped interviews with individuals participating in the Human Rights Commission's film on gender identity. Provided a seminar on discrimination to students in the University of Iowa School of Social Work. Addressed students from City High School regarding discrimination and the law. Attended National Transgender Conference to discuss gender identity protection under Iowa City's Human Rights Ordinance. Spoke to students at the University of Iowa Business School regarding discrimination. Co-sponsored Martin Luther King celebration with the Iowa City/Johnson County Senior Center and the Iowa Humanities Board. The 13th Annual Human Rights Breakfast was held on October 10, 1996. Recipients of this year's awards were Susanne Watson for individual contributions to human dghts (the Isabel Turner Award), Cynthia Coffin, for individual contributions to human rights in a service organization, and Goodwill for contributions made by a business to human dghts. Created an additional Human Rights Award to honor the memory of Commissioner Rick Graf who died of AIDs. The Rick Graf Award is given at the discretion of the Commission to an individual, an individual in a service organization, or a business, when the candidate has demonstrated an outstanding, long term commitment to a specific cause or for the benefit of a specific group of people. The first recipient of this award was Teresa Kopatich for her work in providing transitional housing for the homeless. Participated in Cultural Diversity Day at The University of Iowa. Made recommendations to the Iowa City City Council regarding the City's Affirmative Action Policy. Requested the Iowa Civil Rights Commission discuss the issue of recommending to the legislature the addition of sexual orientation to the protected categories in the Iowa Civil Rights Act. Attended HUD conference in Chicago regarding mortgage lending discrimination. Provided instruction on disability issues at LIFE Skills. Provided three seminars on sexual harassment to an area business. Participated in meetings held by a group of Iowa City citizens referred to as Human Rights Iowa City. This group is attempting to make Iowa City a 'Human Rights Community." 30 21. Participated in organizational meetings for celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1998. Addressed the public at the Gay, Bisexual, Transgender Pdde Parade regarding the Iowa City Human Rights Commission's meeting with the ICRC on June 27, 1997, where the Commission will request the ICRC recommend to the legislature that sexual orientation be added to the State Civil Rights Act. Also provided information on discrimination, the Iowa City Human Rights Commission, and Domestic Registry. 23. Increased half time investigator position to full time in the Office of the Human Rights Coordinator. 24. The Human Rights Investigator and a Commission member attended training conference in Des Moines. The training was sponsored by the Iowa Civil Rights Commission. 25. New Commissioners attended training session conducted by the Human Rights Coordina- tor. 26. Fair Housing Public Seminar with speaker Carol Leach from the Iowa Civil Rights Com- mission. COMPLAINT ACTIVITY During the period of July 1, 1996, to June 30, 1997, nineteen (19) new formal discrimination complaints were filed. Of the 19 complaints, 6 (31.5%) were complaints of disability discrimina- tion, four complaints (21%) alleged sex discrimination, three (15.7%) were complaints of discrimi- nation based on national origin, three (15.7%) were allegations of discrimination based on sexual orientation, two (10.5%) were race based complaints. One (5%) complaint alleged madtal status discrimination. The majodty of the formal complaints, (17) of discrimination occurred in the employment setting while the remaining complaints (2) alleged public accommodation discrimination. Three housing complaints, (one alleging national origin discrimination and two based on familial status) were filed by the Iowa City Human Rights Commission and sent to the ICRC for investigation. An additional complaint, o~ltside the Iowa City jurisdiction, alleging employment discrimination based on sex and disability was also sent to the ICRC for investigation. COMPLAINT RESOLUTION IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Two right to sue letters issued. Two withdrawals. Three administrative closures. Two predetermination settlements. Four successful mediations. Eight no probable cause decisions. One probable cause decision. One removal to state at Complainanrs request. TOTAL RESOLUTIONS = 23 31 PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 1. Completion of transgender film for employers. 2. Premier of above-cited film for employers at public forum. 3. Presuming HUD certifies the Iowa City Human Rights Ordinance as substantially equiva- lent to the Fair Housing Amendments Act, the Human Rights Commission will hire a housing specialist to investigate complaints regarding housing discrimination. 4. Increased outreach on housing discrimination. 5. Commissioners will attend a training session at Iowa State Civil Rights Commission in the Spring of 1998 in Des Moines, Iowa. 7. Film sedes that depicts the various forms and types of discrimination will continue. 8. Advertisements will continue to be placed in the Daily lowan and other newspapers to alert the public that housing discrimination is against the law. 9. Annual Human Rights Breakfast will be held on October 30, 1997, at 7:30 AM. The scheduled speaker is Mary Sue Coleman. 10. Human Rights Commission will consider revising Human Rights Ordinance to include Administrative Closure as an option when on its face, the complaint does not state a claim for which there is a remedy. 11. Development of a Community Diversity Appreciation Team and/or Hate Cdme Response Team. 12. Continue to develop forums to educate public on discrimination issues. 13. Public speaking engagements will continue. 14. Consider fund raising activities. COMMISSION MEMBERS Patdcia A. Harvey, Chair Pamela (Mel) Dautremont Tom Dickerson Dereck A. Hall Joan Jehle Diane Martin Ann K. Shires Mary C. Theisen Jan Warren 32 PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILmES The Parks and Recreation Commission recommends and reviews policies, rules, regulations, ordinances and budgets relating to parks, playgrounds, recreation centers and cultural functions of the City, and makes such reports to the City Council as the Commission deems in the public interest. The Commission also exercises broad responsibility for the development of parks, recreation centers, playgrounds and cultural facilities to serve the City, including the creation and appointment of advisory groups to make studies. ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN RSCAL YEAR 1997 Received copies of regular monthly reports from the Parks, Recreation, Forestry, Cemetery and Central Business District Divisions, providing the Commission with valuable insight into the daily operation of each division. Received pedodic reports from the Iowa City Parks and Recreation Foundation. Received monthly reports from the Director on the progress of all ongoing projects, construction, etc. Conducted annual tour of parks and facilities. Continued active representation on the Riverfront and Natural Areas Commission (and the Iowa River Corridor Trail Study Committee). Recommended City Council approve Recreation Division Fees and Charges proposed for FY98 and tentative proposals for FY99-O0. Reviewed PIN grant applications submitted for 1997. Cooperated with the Old Capitol Youth Hockey Association to provide ice skating facilities in City Park and Mercer Park. Received approval from the City Council to enter agreement with professional fund raiser to complete feasibility study for MPAC expansion, and Task Force created. Cooperated with the City of Coralville to obtain REAP Grant for the Iowa River Dam Trail Connec- tion Project. Held numerous public headngs to receive input on Neighborhood Open Space Plan. Entered into agreement with Mekus/Johnson to develop "Master Plan" to maximize space in Oakland Cemetery. Endorsed FIRS'Cs position and recommendation re proposed Iowa River Trail development between Burlington Street and Sturgis Ferry Park. 33 Recommended City Council accept according to the Neighborhood Open Space Ordinance open space in the Walden Hills Subdivision and Court Hill Subdivision. Recommended City Council accept according to the Neighborhood Open Space Ordinance a portion of required open space, with remainder satisfied by payment of fees in Village Green South Development. Adopted Oakland Cemetery Tree Pruning and Removal Policy. Supported Iowa City Gids Soflt)all proposal to install lights on Napoleon Park softball fields on shared-cost basis. Active representation on Regional Trails Committee to develop recommendations re trail and parkland on either side of the Iowa River Power Dam. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 Develop a Neighborhood Open Space Action Plan to implement the Neighborhood Open Space Ordinance. Continue efforts to improve/upgrade the Central Business District playground equipment. Continue investigation and resolve issue of expanding Oakland Cemetery. Continue interaction with City Council and periodically schedule joint meetings regarding issues facing the Commission and Department. Continue efforts to improve the Commission's contact with the public. Continue and enhance activities of the Parks and Recreation Foundation. Continue the development of the soccer complex to address soccer needs for all age groups. Continue to pursue expansion of MPAC to help meet the need for additional recreational space. Continue commitment to and development of trail system. Determine improvements that can be made to parks with small amounts of money. Explore and strengthen relationships with the School Distdct and Neighborhood Associations. COMMISSION MEMBERS Matt Pacha, Chairperson Rex Pruess, Vice-Chairperson Barbara Endel Ken Fearing Judith Klink Bruce Maurer Allen Stroh Kathy Wallace Ross Wilbum PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES Act as the Zoning Commission of the City. Direct surveys and studies to be conducted and maps, plans, or plats to be made related to the City's Comprehensive Plan and zoning regula- tions. Recommend amendments and supplements to the City Council for the Comprehensive Plan, Zoning Chapter and Subdivision Regulations. Make recommendations to the City Council on development proposals, such as planned developments, subdivisions, street vacations and annexations. ACCOMPUSHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 During FY97, the Planning and Zoning Commission held 20 formal meetings, 17 informal meet- ings, and I Comprehensive Plan Workshop. Dudng the pedod of July 1, 1996, to June 30, 1997, the Commission made the following recom- mendations to the City Council: Comprehensive Plan Amendments: I Recommendation for Approval To amend the Comprehensive Plan to increase the density from 2-8 dwelling units per acre to 8-16 dwelling units.per acre at northeast comer of Scott Boulevard and Lower West Branch Road. 4/3/97 Annexations: 2 Recommendations for Approval 140.5 acres east of Scott Boulevard, north of Highway 6. 2/6/97 Approximately 7 acres located west of Dubuque Street (portion of water plant property). 8/15/96 Rezonin(3: 6_Recommendations for Approval 2.38 acres at northeast comer of Scott Boulevard and Lower West Branch Road from RS- 5 to OPDH-12. 4/3/97 3.74 acres on Mall Ddve from CC-2 to I-1. 3/6/97 140.5 acres east of Scott Boulevard and north of Highway 6 from County M1 to C1-1 and I-1. 3/6/97 40.7 acres north of Rohret Road and east of Highway 218 from RS-5 to OSA-8. 12/5/96 5 acres west of Dubuque Street from County RS to P. 8/15/96 7.06 acres at 2400 North Dodge Street from CH-1 to OSAVCH-1. 8/1/96 Rezonin.q: I Recommendation for Denial 43 acres north of Foster Road, west of Laura Drive, south of 1-80 from ID-RS to RM-12. 6/5/97 35 Subdivisions: 7 Recommendations for Preliminary Plat Approval Windsor Ridge, Parts 7 and 8, a 22.05 acre, 41-1ot residential subdivision north of Amedcan Legion Road, west of Taft Avenue. 4/17/97 Scott-Six Industrial Park, a 140.5 acre, 42-1ot commercialAndustdal subdivision east of Scott Boulevard, north of Highway 6. 4/3/97 Court Park Subdivision, a 1.66 acre, 6-lot residential subdivision at 2729 East Court Street. 2/6/97 Hollywood Manor, Part Six, an 8.2 acre, 24-1ot residential subdivision west of Sycamore Street, south of Bums Avenue. 12/19/96 Walden Hills, a 40.7 acre, 53-1ot residential subdivision north of Rohret Road, east of Highway 218. 12/19/96 Westport Plaza, an 11.41 acre, 2-lot commercial subdivision south of Ruppert Road. 10/17/96 Saddlebrook Addition, a 22.2.62 acre, I 0-lot residential subdivision south of Highway 6 and Heinz Road. 9/19/96 Subdivisions: 8 Recommendations for Final Plat Approval Windsor Ridge, Part 8, a 13.31 acre, 25-1ot residential subdivision on north extension of Barrington Road. 4/17/97 Court Park, a 1.69 acre, 6-lot residential subdivision at 2729 Court Street. 4/3/97 Walden Hills, a 40.7 acre, 53-1ot residential subdivision north of Rohret Road. 4/3/97 Westport Plaza, an 11.14 acre, 2-1or commercial subdivision south of Ruppert Road. 2/20/97 Saddlebrook Addition, Part' 1, a 62 acre, 4-lot subdivision south of Highway 6 and Heinz Road. 9/19/96 Hunters Run, Part 8, a 7.58 acre, 17-1ot residential subdivision north of Rohret Road and east of Goldenrod Drive. 9/19/96 Meadow Ridge, Part 2, a 2.29 acre, 4-lot residential subdivision east of Dubuque Street, south of Meadow Ridge Lane. 9/19/96 Village Green, Part XlV, a 40.19 acre, 1-lot residential subdivision north of Village Road, east of Oxford Place. 8/15/96 Subdivisions: 3 Recommendations for Preliminary/Final Plat Approval West Side Park Addition, a 1.24 acre, 2-lot residential/commercial subdivision east of Westside Drive, south of Ead Road. 4/3/97 Mt. Prospect Addition, Part VIII., a 9.02 acre, 14-1ot residential subdivision. 4/3/97 Jacob Ricord's Subdivision, a resubdivision of a portion of lots 5 and 6, a 1.26 acre, 6-lot residential subdivision. 9/19/96 Subdivisions: I Recommendation to Rescind Preliminary/Final Plat Saddlebrook Addition. 9/19/96 Text Amendments: 17 Recommendations for Approval To increase the parking requirements for residential uses in the CB-5, Central Business Support Zone. 6/19/97 36 To amend the parking requirements for rooming houses converted from fraternities/sorori- ties without the need for special exceptions approval. 5/1/97 To amend the vision tdangle requirements. 5/1/97 To allow portable signs in the CB-2, CB-5, and CB-10 zones. 5/1/97 To amend the regulations conceming elderly housing alternatives. 4/3/97 To amend the parking requirements for rooming houses converted from fraternities/sorori- ties. 3/20/97 To amend the off-street parking requirements for commercial uses in CB-5, Central Business Support Zone. 2/6/97 To amend the regulations conceming child care centers. 12/19/96 To indicate that parking reductions may be approved for non-residential uses as part of the Sensitive Areas Oveday rezoning. 10/3/96 To amend the Land Subdivisions chapter, Article A, Section 4 entitled "Establishment of Control" pertaining to City review of subdivisions within 2 miles of the City's boundaries. 9/19/96 To amend the location restrictions of satellite receiving devices in residential zones. 9/19/96 To allow communications tower as a special exception under certain conditions in the Public zone. 9/19/96 To add definitions associated with cellular facilities. 9/19/96 To revise the definition of "construction area" 6/15/96 To add the definition of "slopes, regulated." 8/15/96 To amend the Sensitive Areas Ordinance. 8/15/96 To allow limited retail sales in the I-1 zone. 7/18/96 Text Amendments: I Recommendation for Denial To allow projecting signs in the CB-5 and CB-10 zones. 5/1/97 Vacations: 3 Recommendations for AI313roval A portion of alley south of Bowery Street between Governor and Lucas Streets. 2/6/97 Gable Street. 1/16/97 The north 12.5 feet of the F Street right-of-way for 75 feet west of First Avenue. 11/21/96 Fdn(~e Area Rezonin(~: 4 Recommendations for Approval Property at 4819 Rapid Creek Road NE from A1 to RS-3. 1/16/97 22 acres north of Highway 1, I mile west of Sharon Center Road from A1 to RS-5. 10/17/96 8.64 acres west of Prairie du Chien Road, 1/4 mile north of Newport Road from A1 to RS- 3. 10/17/96 38.22 acres west of Prairie du Chien Road, 1/4 mile north of Newport Road from A1 to RS-3. 9/19/96 2.75 acres north of American Legion Road, 1.7 miles southeast of Iowa City from A1 to RS. 12/19/96 40 acres north of Highway 1, west of Landon Avenue from A1, RS-10. 12/19/96 37 Frin.ae Area Rezonina: 1 Recommendation for Denial 1,58 acres in Fringe Area 4, 1/4 mile east of Corporate Boundary on Lynden Heights Road from A1 to R2. 7/18/96 Frin.qe Area Subdivisions: 2 Recommendations for Preliminary Plat Approval William Woods, a 22.99 acre, 4-lot residential subdivision north of Highway 1 West, one mile west of Sharon Center Road. 3/20/97 Meadow View, a 32.4 acre, 10-lot residential subdivision west of Buchmeyer Bend at the intersection of Highway 1. 8/1/96 Fdn(~e Area Subdivisions: I Recommendation for Preliminary Plat Denial Scott-Six Industrial Park, a 140.5 acre, 41-1ot industrial/commercial subdivision east of Scott Boulevard, north of Highway 6. (This property was annexed into the city and a preliminary plat was approved on 4/3/97.) 10/17/96 Frin.cle Area Subdivisions: 3 Recommendations for Final Plat ApDroval William Woods, a 22.99 acre, 4-lot residential subdivision north of Highway I and I mile west of Sharon Center Road. 5/1/97 Meadow View, a 31.5 acre, 10-lot residential subdivision west of Buchmeyer Bend and its intersection with Highway 1. 5/1/97 Woodland Ridge, Part One, a 55.95 acre, 19-1ot residential subdivision east of Dane Road at its intersection with Osage Street. 8/15/96 Frin.qe Area Subdivisions: I Recommendation for Preliminary/Final Plat Approval Furrows Edge, Part II, a 16.4 acre, 2-lot residential subdivision in Fringe Area A east of Highway 1, and north of Penny Lane. 12/5/96 Fdn.~e Area Subdivisions: I Recommendation for Preliminary/Final Plat Denial Highland Heights, Part Three, a 15.52 acre residential lot in Fringe Area A east of High- way 1, and south of Dingleberry Road. 12/5/96 Frincle Area Items: 2 Recommendations for Approval Approve conditional use permit within Fringe Area B at 3880 Owl Song Lane, SE. 6/5/97 That the 2-mile extraterritorial review area in Fdnge Area B not be extended. 2/20/97 Other Recommendations: To advise the Scott-Six Urban Renewal Plan is in conformity with the Iowa City Compre- hensive Plan. 4/17/97 To designate East College Street as a Historical District. 1/16/97 To designate College Green as a Historical District. 1/16/97 To consider prohibiting parking on North Dodge Court. 9/19/96 38 To forward a letter to the Johnson County Board of Supervisors recommending attention to traffic safety problems at Buchmeyer Bend on Highway 1. 8/1/96 To allocate staff time on pdodty basis to review high density residential and parking issues in the CB-10 zone. 8/1/96 PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 Review existing tree regulations, especially for parking lots that exceed the minimum required parking spaces. Review definition of awnings. Develop an entranceway overlay zone. Provisions to assure neighborhood compatibility for new multi-family buildings in estab- lished neighborhoods. Consider amendments to permit longer terms of stay for transient housing and to permit apartments above special exception uses in the C1-1 zone. Amend the RM-12 zone to allow limited commercial uses by special exception. Review of performance standards for industrial zones. Review of requirements for commercial floor area in the CB-5 zone. Develop a bonus system to promote better design, more pedestrian use and reduction of parking in the CN-1 zone. Consider establishing guidelines for the design of communication towers. Consider amending the CC-2 zone to permit hotels/motels. Review floor area limitations in CN-1 zone. Review parking requirements for fraternities and sororities. Land Use and Zoning Studies: Area north of Highway I bounded by Miller, Benton and Harlocke streets. Vicinity of County Administration Building. Near Northside commercial areas. RS-12 zoning in the vicinity of Foster Road. Evaluate PRM Zoning for consistency with the near Southside design plan and amend zone, as appropriate. Update Comprehensive Plan in accordance with Iowa Citv Beyond 2000. Area Studies for individual Planning Districts. Review development ordinances for barriers to affordable housing. Review of subdivision regulations, including design provisions. Review of Floodplain Management Ordinance. COMMISSION MEMBERS George Starr, Chairperson Ann Bovbjerg, Vice Chairperson Lea Supple, Secretary Benjamin Chait Pam Ehrhardt Richard Gibson Phil Shive 39 40 RIVERFRONT AND NATURAL AREAS COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The Iowa City Rivedront and Natural Areas Commission is charged with protecting, preserving and restoring important environmental features of the community, including woodlands, wetlands, waterways, and, especially, the Iowa River and its tributaries. Development of the Iowa River Corridor Trail from the Coralville Reservoir to Napoleon Park is a pdmary focus of the Commis- sion. The Commission consists of eleven members, five from Iowa City, three from Johnson County, and one each from the City of Coralville, the University of Iowa and the Iowa City Parks and Recreation Commission. While the Riverfront and Natural Areas Commission serves as an advisory body to the City Council, it is actively involved in implementing programs, projects and activities that achieve Commission goals. Additionally, the Commission continues its efforts to create an awareness among all citizens of the importance of the care and preservation of the Iowa River, its tributaries and the riverbank, as well as the significance of the preservation and restoration of woodlands and wetlands in the Iowa City area. ACCOMPUSHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 Began investigating possible uses for the Iowa City peninsula area. The review included field trips to the area and the gathering of information from nature reserves and nature centers. Participated in a joint committee to determine the future of the Butler House located on the City's new water plant site. The committee was made up of three representatives each from the Riverfront and Natural Areas Commission, Histodc Preservation Commission, and the Parks and Recreation Commission. Sent [hree representatives to the University of Iowa's campus lighting master plan devel- opment meeting. Began review of the Iowa City flood plain ordinance. Amended the RNAC by-laws so the commission could better educate new members. Sponsored an Arbor Day celebration at Ryerson's Woods. The program included a tree planting ceremony, an awards ceremony, and a tree giveaway. Continued river corridor trail development efforts, including support of applications for funding vadous trail segments. Continued to work with Friends of the Iowa River Scenic trail (FIRST) on river trail issues. Participated in a Iowa River Corridor Trail walk to review signage. Provided a representative to JCCOG's Regional Trails and Bicycling Committee (RTBC). 41 PLANNED ACTIVrnEs FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 · Review and comment on the Iowa City Comprehensive Plan. · Participate in joint committee in preparing plans for Iowa City peninsula area. Continue to assist in the future planning for the Butler House on the Iowa City water plant site. Assist in developing a creek maintenance program. Review flood plain ordinance. Advocate for an inventory of natural and sensitive areas on the Iowa City Peninsula area. Continue to support and advocate development of the Iowa River Corridor Trail. Continue to involve FIRST on dver trail issues. Improve RNAC review of development projects impacting the river front and natural areas. Develop ad-hoc committees as needed. Continue participation in the review and development of the Sensitive Areas ordinance and other ordinances as required, · Continue to send a representative to JCCOG's Regional Trails and Bicycling Committee. · Sponsor events focusing on sensitive areas. · Participate in the Ralston Creek Cleanup event. COMMISSION MEMBERS Cortney Daniels, Chair, Iowa City representative Catherine Pugh, Vice Chair, Iowa City representative Jim Pugh, Iowa City representative Richard Hoppin, Iowa City representative Lori Goetsch, Iowa City representative David Thayer, Coralville representative Ken Fearing, Iowa City Parks & Recreation Commission representative Gretchen Gdmm, Johnson County representative Joe Kral, Johnson County representative Tom Riley, Johnson County representative Larry Wilson, University of Iowa representative 42 SENIOR CENTER COMMISSION GENERAL RESPONSIBILITIES The Senior Center Commission was established by the City Council and is composed of nine members with three year terms which may be renewed once. Six Commission members are appointed by the City Council and three by the Johnson County Board of Supervisors. The following duties and powers are assigned to the Commission: to serve in an advisory role to the City Council with regard to the needs of the Senior Center; to make recommendations with regard to policies and programs of the Senior Center; to join staff and other interested persons in seeking adequate financial resources for the operation of the Senior Center; to encourage full participation of senior citizens in Senior center programs and activities; to ensure that the Senior Center is effectively integrated into the community and cooperates with organizations with common goals in meeting the needs of senior citizens; to serve in an advocacy role with regard to the needs of senior citizens; and to assist the City Manager in the evaluation of personnel. ACCOMPUSHMENTS IN FISCAL YEAR 1997 Sent two representatives to work with Steve Atkins and the City Personnel Department to interview candidates and select the new Senior Center Coordinator, Linda Kopping. Revised the Senior Center Mission Statement and developed Senior Center Goals for 1997-2000. The Goals and .Mission Statement were widely circulated among participants and other members of the community as well as City Council and Board of Supervisors members. Endorsed a county-wide survey of people fifty-five years of age and older. The survey was undertaken to provide senior citizens throughout Johnson County with an opportunity to voice their opinions about the current and future direction of the Center; to provide information related to perceived enticements and barriers to participation in Senior Center activities and programs; to solicit information which will help enhance current programming and volunteer opportunities; and to identify programming and volunteer opportunities that will appeal to the upcoming generation of senior citizens. In conjunction with the Center's fifteenth anniversary celebration, hosted a volunteer recognition breakfast for 700 volunteers who contributed 48,000 hours of service. 5. Organized a ribbon-cutting gala affair for the Center's fifteenth anniversary celebration. Supported participation in community activities, such as The Walk of the Stars, that widely promoted recognition of the Senior Center as a valuable downtown resource for seniors and other members of Johnson County. Established a scholarship plan with several funding options to provide financial assistance to eligible participants. 8. Revised policies regarding the use of the Center on nights and weekends. 43 9. Encouraged Gift Fund donations. 10. Wrote a monthly column reporting on Commission activities for the Senior Center POST. An additional column, offedng personal commentary on topics relevant to Senior Center operations or activities, intermittently was published in the POST. 11. Sent Commission representatives to monthly meetings of the City Council and County Board of supervisors to provide Senior Center act'n/fly and program updates. 12. Endorsed recommended HVAC modifications to improve the Center's heating and cooling systems and thereby promote the comfort of participants. 13. Helped establish a uniform refreshment policy for Senior Center programming. 14. Reviewed Senior Center parking issues and developed position statements related to available volunteer and participant parking. 15. Endorsed structural building changes to meet ADA specifications and promote overall access to the building. 16. Revised Gift Fund expenditure policies to support Senior Center programming and riscally sound Gift Fund usage. 17. Approved the purchase and installation of safety devices and equipment for the lapidary and woodworking areas of the Senior Center. 18. Modified programming policies to clearly establish non-volunteer instructors as indepen- dent contractors. 19. Working with a group of interested participants, oversaw changes in the woodworking shop intended to promote shop usage and woodworking instruction. 20. Endorsed the purchase of a new hardwood floor for the Assembly Room after exploring many options. 21. Investigated ideas brought forth from the June 1996 Town Meeting and implemented as many as possible. Sent representatives to the Post Advisory Committee to review and revise the content of the Post. 23. Endorsed the purchase of updated video equipment for the use of SCTV with $9,370.00 funded by the BTC franchise. PLANS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1998 1. Continue to implement established Senior Center Goals. Continue to support the development of classes, programs, and volunteer opportunities that meet the needs and concerns of Johnson County residents ages fifty-five or older. o o Seek ways to enhance the ability of present staff members to serve our constituency. Ensure that the Center is a strong community within the Johnson County community characterized by a spidt of open communication and cooperation between the two. Further facilitate open lines of communication between the Senior Center Commission, staff and participants. Continue to explore a vadety of building modifications that will maximize the use of Senior Center space and promote participant satisfaction while respecting the historical signifi- cance of the building. Review and update the Senior Center operational handbook. Reexamine, and if necessary revise, lease agreements the Senior Center currently has with Senior Dining, Elderly Services Agency, Visiting Nurses Association, AARP, and Senior Peer Counseling. Implement educational workshops in the normal sensory changes of aging and successful aging. These workshops, which will promote positive images of aging, will be offered to a vadety of groups within Johnson County. COMMISSION MEMBERS *M. Kathryn Wallace, Chair *Wilma Conner, Vice-Chair Terri Miller, Secretary Bebe Ballantyne *Joanne Hora Robert Kemp Kenneth Mobily Chevalier A. Monsanto Philip Zell Appointed by Johnson County Board of Supervisors All other members appointed by the Iowa City Council 45 11/17/g7 BB:42 To:I064~ CITY CLERK From:Jo Hogartv 319-354-4Z13 Page l/Z Sally Slutsman, Chairperson Joe Bolkcom Charles D. Duffy Jonathan Jordahl Stephen P. Lacina BOARD OF SUPERVISORS November 18, 1997 INFORMAL MEETING Call to order 9:00 a.m. Agenda - 2. Review of the formal minutes of November 13th o Business from Kay Hull, General Assistance Directdr for Department of Human Services re: proposed rent increase in General Assistance Guidelines by $50.00 per assist. discussion Business from Bev Clearman, Chairperson for Nutrition Committee and Mike Foster, Director for Senior Dining re: FY '98 Nutrition Contract. discussion o Business from Deborah Conger, Johnson Count. Re~order re: Recordefts Office budget for staff. discussion Business from the County Attorney a) Report from the County Attomey b) Other Business from the Board of Supervisors a) Reports b) Other amending 913 SOUTH DUBUQUE ST. P.O. BOX 1350 IOWA CITY, IOWA 52244-1350 TEL: (319) 356-6000 FAX: (319) 356-6086 11/17/97 88:42 To:IOl~q CITY CLERK Froe:Jo Hogarty 319-3§4-4213 Page Agenda 11-18-97 Page 2 8. Inquiries and reports from the public 9. Recess FORMAL MEETING TO FOLLOW 11/17/97 89:23 To:IOWA CITY CLERK From:Jo Hogartv 319-354-4213 Page 1/3 Johnson Cm~' ~!OWA m.~ Sally Stutsman, Chairperson Joc Bolkcom Charles D. Dui~' Jonathan Jordahl Stephen P. Lacina BOARD OF SUPERVISORS November 18, 1997 FORMAL MEETING Agenda 1. Call to order following the informal meeting. 2. Action re: claims 3. Action re: formal minutes of November 13th 4. Action re: payroll authorizations Business from Christy Scheetz, Coordinator for Health)' People 2000 re: proclamation for World Aides Day. discussion/action 6. Business from the County Auditor a) Action re: permits b) Action re: reports 1. Clerk's October monthly report c) Other 913 SOUTH DUBUQUE ST. P.O. BOX 1350 IOWA CITY, IOWA 52244-1350 TEL: (319) 356-6000 FAX: (319) 356-6086 11/17/97 89:23 To:IO~6q CITY CLERK Froe:Ja Hogarty 319-354-4213 Page Agenda 11-18-97 Page 2 7. Business from the Planning and Zoning Administrator a) Second and final consideration of application Z9729 of Fobian Farms, Inc. b) Final consideration of application Z9742 of Richard Rossman. c) Final consideration of application Z9743 of Robert Rummelhart. d) Final consideration of application Z9744 of William MacKenzie. -. e) Final consideration of application Z9745 of Arlene Hotz. : ' Business from the Assistant Planning and Zoning : a) Discussion/action re: the following Platting applications: Application S9768 of Robert Rununelhart requesting preliminary and final plat approval of Rummelhart's Second Subdivision (A Resubdivision of Lot I of Rummelhart's 1ST Subdivision) a subdivision described as being located in the SW 1/4 of the NW 1/4 of Section 21; Township 78 North; Range 6 West of the 5th P.M. in Johnson County, Iowa (This is a 2-lot, 7.9 acre, residential subdivision, located on the north side of the "Y" intersection of Observatory Avenue SW and Ruppenkamps Road SW in Liberty Twp.). Application S9761 of William MacKenzie requesting preliminary and final plat approval of Mackenzie Manor, a subdivision described as being located in the NW 1/4 of Section 9; Township 78 North; Range 6 West of the 5th P.M. in Johnson County, Iowa (This is a 2-1or, 28.99 acre, one lot residential and one lot farmstead split, located in the SE quadrant of Dane Road and 480th Street SW intersection in Liberty Twp.). 11/17/97 B9:23 To:IOWA CITY CLERK From:Jo Hogartv 319-354-4213 Page 3/3 Agenda 11-18-97 Page 3 b) 3. Application S9760 of A1 Wells requesting f'mal plat approval of Lake Land Subdivision, Part One, a subdivision described as being located in the SE 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of' Section 22; and the SW 1/4 of' the SW !/4 of Section 23; all in Township 81 North; Range 6 West of the 5th P.M. in Johnson County, Iowa (This is a 6-lot, 30.76 acre, residential (A2) subdivision, located on the north side of. 180th Street NE, approximately 7/8 of' a mile west of Solon in Big Grove Twp.). 9. Business from the Count)' Attorney a) Report re: other items 10. Business from the Board of Supervisors a) $50.00 per assist. b) Other Action re: proposed rent increase in General Assistance Guidelines by 11. Adjournment 30 Year Concel~t Oak]and Cemetery Master Expansion Plan 10 Acre Concept Oakland Cemetery l~Iaster Expansion Plan Iowa City, Iowa 1997 40 Acre Concept Oakland Cemetery Master Expansion Plan Iowa City, Iowa City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM Date: November 8, 1996 To: From: Re: The Honorable Mayor Naomi J. Novick and Members of the Cib/Council Linda Newman Woito, City Attorney Summary of Conclusions Regarding Legal Opinion: Is the Land East of the City Cemetery Restricted to Cemetery Use? In light of the up-coming joint meeting with the Parks and Recreation Commission on Wednesday, November 13, 1996, I have completed research concerning the above question. However, the facts and law are complex -- so I present you here with a summary of my conclusions. I will follow up with a more detailed explanation of the facts and the law next week, under separate cover. The approximately 40 acre tract now being considered for partial cemetery expansion, located east of the eastern-most portion of the City cemetery, was a private land grant to the City from Chdsfian and Theresa Galoucher. This land grant was for the express purpose of cemetery use -- as indicated in the heading of the original 1913 contract to purchase land, as well as the resolution authorizing execution of the purchase contract, see attached contract and resolution. However, I think it is fair to say the restrictions are not strongly worded, and are not found in the deed itself. As for .the applicable law, the general rule regarding changing uses of public land is that a particular public use can be changed by legislative act, namely, the City Council can pass an ordinance or resolution dedicating certain land as parkland, or accepting certain land as a park or cemetery. Iowa follows a different rule where land is given or sold to the City as private land for a particular purpose -- in this case for cemetery purposes. However, in the case of private restriction grants, Iowa law provides that the proper party to enforce such land restriction is the private party or their representative, namely the Christian Galoucher family. This mear~ that in the absence of the Galoucher family's asserting the cemetery restrictlone on the approximately 40 acres (now being ueed as Hickory Hill Park), the City may corttinue to use these 40 acres as parkland, as cemetery, or both. Stated other,vise, a member of the general public has no standing to enforce the private restriction on the 40 acres Ga[Jlocher tract for cemetery uses only. The City may want to attempt to contact the Galoucher family and seek out their wishes, if any t as we d'td in 1980 when the Council changed the 40 acre Woods tract from I will have a more detailed legal opinion, with factual background and legal analysis for your meeting on Wednesday, November 13, 1996. cc: Ter~/Trueblood, Parks and Recreation Director City Manager City Clerk ~tant City Manager Attachments November 15, 1996 Ms. Gretchen Gaulocher Lobdell 3374 Pattie Place Palm Harbor, FL 34685 Ms. Ruth Kelleher 1137 Burlington Street Iowa City, IA 52240 Re: Request for Family Wishes Concerning 40-Acre Sale of Gaulocher Tract to City for Cemetery Purposes in 1913-1919; Possible Expansion of Current Cemetery Into Gaulocher Tract Dear Family Members: By way of introduction, I am the City Attorney for the City of Iowa City, and have been requested to contact you, as members of the Gaulocher family, concerning your wishes as to whether the land sold to the City in 1913-19 should be, in whole or in part, preserved for cemetery purposes. As you can see from the enclosed memo from me to the City Council dated November 8, 1996, your grandparents, Theresa and Christian Gaulocher, entered into a contract with the City of Iowa City to sell two tracts to the City; approximately 40 acres, plus 8 acres. This sale was "for cemetery purposes." Attached to my memo is the odginal contract for sale of land for cemetery purposes dated February 17, 1913, together with the resolution passed by the City Council February 7, 1913. Both of these documents indicate that the intent of both parties, namely your family (Gaulochers) and the City intended to use these two parcels (8 acres and 40 acres) for cemetery purposes. I also enclose a copy of the deed--which is silent as to the purposes for the two tracts of land, see Attachment E (3 pages). Also enclosed please find Attachment A, which is a diagram indicating the historical chain of events in terms of acquisition for Oakland Cemetery, commencing in 1843. You will notice in Attachment A that the eastem-most land crosshatched and marked "(Christian Gaulocher)" is the land subject to my inquiry today. The westem-most portion, namely 8.75 acres, was put to cemetery use many years ago. However, the 39.83 acres, delineated by a heavy black line is the land in question -- and as you will note is labelled "Hickory Hill Park" and is being used as parkland. It is this heavy-marked area that your family, and apparently the City in 1913, originally intended for cemetery purposes. Finally, I enclose a copy of a memo from Parks and Recreation Director Terry Trueblood, dated November 7, 1996 and directed to the C~ Council and the Iowa City Parks and Recreation Commission. You will note the memo suggests three different options for a very minimal intrusion into the area now being used as Hickory Hill Park (which is the land your family sold to the city "for cemetery purposes"). The current wishes of the Parks and Recreation Commission and the City Council appears to be to not expand the city cemetery any more than CIVIC CE~4TEI · 410 ! WASHI~iGTON ST IO1¥A CITY IOI/A $224e-II1i PHONE (]1~) 3$1.~eee FAX(JIg) ]$i.$ee9 Ms. Lobdell Me. Ketleher November 15, 1996 Page 2 ~s minimally possibHnd ctearty not any more than 5 acr~ into the park. However, as noted in my memo conceming your legal rigid, the City Council would k you to indicate your farlilly wishes as to whether you want the ~ now being ueed m Hlcl~,o~ I-BI Park, to be u~ed ellher partially for cemetery purl:x~ (e.g., no more than 5 acr~, or 2 acres), or whelher you ~ the area to remain in its current atate v,~ich i~ · portion of Hickory Hill Park. A~ I uncleintend it, the 40 acre tract outlined in heavy marker in Attachment A has been uaed as · park ~nce the late 1960s. Once you have reviewed theee documente, pleaae write me or call me at (319) 356-5030---or I can arrange a telephone conference call with family rnembem, Parks and.Recreation Director Terry Trueblood and my~elf.--to dil~--~t these mattere. Thank you very much for your assistance in thi~ matter. Cordially youre., LirYda Newman Woito City Affomey 410 E. Washington St. Iowa City, I^ 52240 Enclosures cc: Judy Slezak [daughter of Ruth Kelleher] Ruby Fleming Terry Trueblood, Parks and Recreation Director City Council, FYI Irving Weber, FYI Dick Dolezal, FYI RECEivE · November 18, 1996 Linda Newman Wioto City Attorney City of Iowa City 410 E. Washington Street Iowa City, IA 52240 Dear Ms. Wioto: This is in response to our wishes for expansion of the Oakland Cemetery into the Gaulocher tract. As granddaughters of Christian Gaulocher, we would like the entire forty acres to stay as cemetery land. At the present time, five or more acres could be used for cemetery expansion. The remaining acres could still be used for Hickory Hill Park until more acres from this tract are needed for future cemetery needs. Sincerely, Ruth Kelleher 1136 E. Burlington Street Iowa City, Iowa 52240 Ruby Fleming 1600 Tenth Street Coralville, Iowa 52241 (Signed by Judy Slezak, Power of Attorney) 1688 Tenth Street Coralville, IA 52241 November 28, 1996 ~' ",:-':R,'~E',-'$ ~FFICE Ms. Linda Newman Wioto City Attorney City of Iowa City 418 E. Washin§ton Street Iowa City, Iowa 52248 Dear Ms. Wloto: This letter is In regard to Input from heirs of Christian Gaulocher concerning the expansion of Oakland Cemetery. I am his Oreat- granddaughter. I would like mu ancestral wishes to sUII be recoonlzed, that beln!l, the forty acres of land In the Gaulocher tract remalnino as cemeterlJ land. I feel that the maximum number of acres needed now for the expansion should be used. Hickory Hill Park then could use the remainIn§ land until more acres from this tract are needed for future cemetery needs. Christian Gaulocher made this decision concerning the cemetery land after seruing on the Iowa City City Council. I haue enclosed a short biography of mu great-grandfather to let you and the Council know a little bit about the person whose land we ale discussing. This blo was taken from the Leadinn Euents in Johnson Countu Io,-a Histop,. Biographical, Uolume II, 191:3. If I can be of further assistance, please feel free to contact me. Respectfully, Judy Slezak Great-granddaughter to Christian Gaulocher November 25, 1996 3374 Pattie PI. Palm Harbor, FL 34685 TO: The City of Iowa City From the documents you sent to me, regarding the Christian Gaulocher 39.8 acres of land, it is obvious that both the City and Christian Gaulocher's intentions were that the land be used for the expansion of the existing cemetery. Apparently, the City gave to the Park Board the entir 39.8 acres to be used for a park. We believe the city did not have the legal right to do this without an agreement and permissiion from the heirs. We believe that there should have been a limited use provision made to the Park Board, subject to the need for future Cemetery purposes. It is our belief and wishe~ that at least ten acr~ be desi~ for fuIure cemetery use, and that the Park Board may use the said ten acr~ part or all, until needed by the cemetery, and the balance of the land be dedicated for pink use. GRETCHEN GAULOCHER LOBDELL Date: To: From: Re: City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM December 13, 1996 CONFIDENTIAE The Honorable Mayor Naomi J. Novick and Members of the City Council Linda Newman Woito, City Attorney ~ Update on Legal Opinion Requests: Is the land east of the City Cemetery restricted, in whole or in part, to cemetery use; and if so, does the City have an obligation to honor those restrictions? ISSUES Possible expansion of the city-owned Oakland Cemetery first raised the question of whether 'the land to the east of the cemetery, now being used for parkland, is legally restricted to cemetery use - either in whole or in part. After presenting my preliminary legal opinion to you at your joint City Council/Parks and Recreation Commission meeting on November 13, 1996, and now having received wdtten responses from the Gaulocher heirs, the question is now whether the City has an obligation to honor those restrictions. Summary of Conclusions Having heard from four direct descendants of Christian and Theresa Gaulocher, all of whom express a desire to have at least 5-10 acres set aside for cemetery purposes, it is the opinion of this Office that the City has some obligation under Iowa law to respect the Gaulocher heirs' wishes. While it may be argued that the Gaulocher heirs have "rested on their dghts" for some 30 years and are now estopped from asserting the cemetery restrictions because the 39.83 acre tract has been used as parkland since the 1960s, I think the family can make a colorable claim, perhaps even a successful claim, that the land purchase was a "contract" with certain restrictions imposed thereon, and that the wishes of the sellers' heirs should be followed. Because the land was purchased by private contract, refusal of the City to abide by that contract may result in I'rtigafion. Background: History of Cemetery Growth The land now being used for a City cemetery, namely Oakland Cemetery, includes land grants from both public entities and private parties. For example (and according to research completed in 1973 by Gene Chubb, Parks and Recreation Department), the first land grant for the cemetery was in 1843 from the Iowa Ten'itodal Commission, see map marked Attach- ment A. Although Chubb's memo notes this 1843 land grant to be from the "State of Iowa," the grant was actually from Iowa as a territory since Iowa did not become a state until 1846, see attached memo marked Attachment B. Because Mr. Chubb was not an attorney, I find this misstatement of fact (state vs. territory) to be minor in nature, and will continue to rely on the information collected by Chubb. The land now being considered for po. ssible.expansiQn of Oakland Cemetery is located to the east of the eastern-most portion of the Cemetery, and is designated as "Hickory Hill Park 39.83 acres" on the attached map marked Attachment A. This 39.83 acres was purchased by the City over a six-year pedod by virtue of a "contract to purchase", with payments by the City from 1913 to 1919, see attached document entitled "Copy of Contract with Chris Galoucher [sic] for land for Cemetery purposes" marked Attachment C. This contract was approved by the City Council at a formal meeting on February 7, 1913, when the Resolution authorized the Mayor's execution of the contract, see Attachment D. This 1913 purchase was finally consummated by the Gaulochers executing a warranty deed in 1919, see Attachment E. The deed conveyed both the 8.75 acres now being used as part of Oakland Cemetery, as well as the 39.83 acres now being used as Hickory Hill Park. The deed was properly recorded in the Johnson County Recorder's Office March 11, 1919. Even though the 1913 resolution and the 1913 Contract indicated that both tracts were to be used for "cemetery purposes," there is no restrictive language in the deed itself, see Attachment E. Under an old and somewhat misleading doctdne of "merger," which is a concept of property law, the City could make the argument that the contract restrictions "merged into" the deed and thus disappeared because not recited in the deed. However, this archaic merger doctrine is falling out of favor with modem courts, see CRIBBETT, ET AL, CASES AND MATERIALS ON PROPERTY (March 1991), pp. 1280-81 and cases cited therein. Indeed, the Uniform Land Transactions Act would abolish the doctdne completely, Id. Because of this changing law on "merger," it is my opinion that the Gaulocher Heirs could likely be successful in arguing that even though the deed contained no restrictive cemetery purpose language, the combined Resolution and Contract clearly survived the deed - and that the +40 acres is restricted to cemetery use. It goes without saying that if such language were in the deed, much of the confusion during the last 30 years might well have been avoided. Nonetheless, whether or not the cemetery purpose was stated in the deed, the City Council's clear intention in 1913 was to use the land for cemetery purposes, as seen in the resolutions' intent clauses: '~/hereas, the Committee on Public Grounds and Buildings of the City Council of Iowa City, Iowa, having been instructed at a previous meeting to investigate and report the advisability of the City of Iowa City acquiring additional real estate to be used for cemetery purposes; and, Whereas, the said Committee has this day reported, which report is is [sic] hereby referred to and made part hereof; and, Whereas, the same has been adopted and approved; .... " See Attachment D. The 8.75 acres of the Gaulocher Tract was put to cemetery use, but according to Jim Wonick, Cemetery Director, the 39.83 acres was mowed by the City and sometimes used as pastureland until approximately 1980. This indicates that the land remained available for cemetery purposes. Another indication that the 39.83 acre Gaulocher Tract was to be used for cemetery purposes ~s that both the 1913 contract and the 1913 City Council resolution recited that the Gaulochers agreed to remove trees on the land when directed to do so by the City. see Attachment D. Taken together, this language indicates m at least in 1913 - that both the Gaulochers and the City intended both parcels - 39.83 acres and 8 acres - to be used for cemetery purposes. Records also show that City warrants were issued on cemetery funds to pay at least a portion of the City's cost to purchase the Gaulocher Tracts, see Attachment F. It is unclear at this time, without more extensive research, as to whether these funds were proceeds from selling cemetery bonds. By way of explanation, a "warrant" is a claim asserted against the City's coffers or treasury, as opposed to a check which is payable from a bank entrusted with Cit~ funds. Without going into great detail to explain the legal differences between a check and a warrant, suffice it to say that at least a portion of the two Gaulocher Tracts were paid from City Cemetery funds. In 1950, the City purchased from Claude and Mabel Woods the 40 acres to the north of the land in question off Conkiln lane, for further expansion of the Cemetery. This "Woods Tract" is now where the park shelter is located in the upper portion of Hickory Hill Park. Although the then-City Council intended this 1950 purchase to be for cemetery purposes (see attachment G), in 1980 the City Council chose to dedicate this 40 acres as parkland, see Attachment H. Pdor to taking this step, however, then-Parks and Recreation Director Dennis Showalter contacted the pdvate grantors of this 40 acre tract, namely Mrs. Mabel Woods -- one of the two original grantors. Mrs. Woods had no objection to changing the use of the land from cemetery to parkland, and thus agreed with the City's official dedication of the land for park purposes, see memo dated January 3, 1980 and marked Attachment I. You will also note that Attachment K shows that the 1980 City Council initially considered dedicating both the 40 acre Woods Tract and the 39.83 Gaulocher Tract as dedicated parkland, see 1979 memo from Dennis Showalter and the proposed ordinance marked Attachment J. For whatever reason or perhaps because the Council knew the 1913-19 Gaulocher Tract purchase was intended for cemetery purposes, the City Council in 1980 chose to only dedicate the 40 acre Woods Tract as parkland, see Attachment H. This left the 39.83 acre "Gaulocher Tract," as least for then, as parkland stating that this "means that the cemetery could expand into a portion of it [Gaulocher Tract] at a later date," see Attachment K. Update on Family Wishes Now in 1996, with the City considering expanding the cemetery to the east and into the 39.93 acre Gaulocher Tract now being used as part of Hickory Hill Park, the question is whether the City's use of this land is subject to any legal restrictions. Based on the facts apparent to me at the time, I issued a summary memo to you and the Parks and Recreation Commission dated November 8, 1996, wherein I suggested that, absent an expression of wishes from the Gaulocher heirs, the City was free to use the land as either cemetery land, parkland, or a combination of both. After discussion at your November 13, 1996 joint meeting with the Commission, you directed me to attempt to contact the Gaulocher heirs, as to whether they preferred the land to remain as parkland or be used for cemetery purposes. Thanks to Dick Dolezal and Irving Weber, I soon spoke directly with Gretchen Gaulocher Lobdell, of Palm Harbor, Florida, and asked if she wished to express a preference as to whether the land sold by her grandparents should be, in whole or in part, preserved for cemetery purposes. She told me that she and Ruth Kelleher, of Iowa City, Iowa were granddaughters of Christian and Theresa Gaulocher; and on November 15, 1996, I forwarded information to these two direct heirs. [A copy of this letter was previously sent to you, FYI.] As I was preparing the letter, I discovered that Ruby Fleming of Coralville, Iowa was also a direct descendent and granddaughter of Christian and Theresa Gaulocher, and that Judy Slezak was a great granddaughter. Thus, I sent the same information to all four of the heirs on November 15, 1996. I received a telephone call from Dennis Gaulocher of Iowa City, Iowa -- but he is a great nephew of Christian Gaulocher, not a direct'clescendent. I sent the same information to him on November 21, 1996. Now as of December 13, 1996, I have received the expressed wishes of the three granddaugh- ters (Gretchen, Ruth and Ruby) as well as the great granddaughter (Judy Slezak), see attached. As you can see from the letters, all four of the direct descendants of Theresa and Chdsfian Gaulocher prefer that the entire 39.83 acres be held for cemetery purposes, and that at least 5-10 acres now should be put to cemetery use. A majority of the family also agrees that the remaining portion of the land is suitable for park purposes m at least until the land is needed for cemetery purposes, see attached letters. Based on my legal research to date, it is dear that at least ten acres of the land known as the "39.83 acre Gaulocher Tract" is restricted to cemetery use by virtue of the 1913 contract, but there may be room for negotiation regarding the remaining 30 acres. In any event and absent litigation, I recommend that at least ten acres of the Gaulocher Tract be formally rededicated for cemetery purposes, and that negotiations ensue as to the remaining thirty acres. Legal Analysis: The recent discussion of possible expansion of the cemetery into land now being used for parkland raises the ultimate question of whether public uses of publicly-owned property must continue, in perpetuity, for that same public purpose and use -- regardless of changes in circumstances resulting from time, City needs or objectives, or uses of land in surrounding areas. The general rule in Iowa is that a City has the authority to change the use of publicly-owned property from one public use to another, so long as three conditions are met: 1) resolution; The change is done legislatively and formally, meaning by way of ordinance or 2) There are no private restrictions on the land imposed by the pdvate grantor (meaning the person who dedicates, donates, gives or sells property to the City); and 3) No special damage or private rights are claimed by reason of improvements on adjacent property made in reliance on the permanency of the particular and original public use. Carson v. State. 38 N.W. 2d 168, 174-175 (Iowa 1949). In other words, so long as there are no pdvate restnctions on the land given or sold to the City and no one claims their property nghts will be damaged ~f the public use is changed, the City ~s free to change city-owned land. from one public use to another public use. An example of this general rule was demonstrated when the Chauncey Swan Park, across from the Civic Center, was converted to a combined parking facility and small park. At that time, the City Council took formal action by approving the design and specifications for the parking facility, and then formally accepting the completed work as a "public improvement." Thus, the land was changed from parkland to a combined public use of"parkland" plus "parking facility." This does not mean, however, that the former Chauncey Swan Park area could only be used as a public park, in perpetuity --which is apparenfiy the rule in some states. Rather in Iowa, the general rule is that absent private restrictions, if a city council formally decJares its intent by official action such as ordinance or resolution, the public use of the property can be lawfully changed: "The rule is repeatedly stated by McQuillin that property devoted to public use, such as parks, cannot be alienated [sold] or diverted without legislative authority [cite omitted]." Carson. at 174. However, a different rule applies where private property is given, sold, dedicated or otherwise conveyed to a city, and where that private property grant contains conditions covedng the grant. In such a situation, the Iowa Supreme Court views the restrictions as a form of contract, and thus requires the city to respect the wishes of the grantor. This means that where private property has "...by its owner been dedicated to public use and accepted by the public for the purpose specified in the dedication .... " that public use must remain on the dedicated property. Carson, at 172. The Iowa Supreme Court in 1949 explained the reason for this "pdvate grant/dedication" rule: "It is based upon the theory of a contract between dedicator and public which is binding on both parties .... We do not question the soundness of the proposition as limited to such dedication of private property. Undoubtedly in such case the dedicator, or one claiming under him, can maintain suit to prevent diversion in violation of the contract dedication." Carson, at 172 [emphasis added]. In applying this Iowa law to the facts before us, the first question presented to me was whether a general member of the public, e.g. a taxpayer, has standing to enforce the restrictions of the Galoucher 39.83 acre Tract purchased for cemetery purposes. This question, of course, assumes that the language in the 1913 City Council Resolution and the 1913 contract signed by the City and the Gaulochers place certain restrictions on the Tract now being used as Hickory Hill Park. As noted in my November 8, 1996 memo to you, the answer is that only a representative of the odginal grantor [Gaulochers] or one claiming through the odginal grantor has standing to assert restrictions on a public use which were part of the odginal transaction. 6 A s~m~lar question as to whether a taxpayer had standing to assert a restnction in a "pnvate conveyance" was raised in a case entitled Coilis v. Board of Park Commissioners of City of Clinton, 38 N.W. 2d 635 (Iowa 1949), where a member of the public brought a lawsuit against the city and park commissioners for changing the use of a levee or dike near the Mississippi River into a park. In the Coilis case, the Court found a general member of the public had no standing to enforce such private dedication. However, the Iowa Supreme Court pointed out that the attempt to enforce the restrictions might make a difference if the person filing the lawsuit was asserting a claim through the original dedicator of the land, or was alleging private damage; but in the absence of either, the plaintiff had no standing to enforce such "private dedication as a levee." Coilis, at 637. See also Warren v. The Mavor of Lyons City. 22 Iowa 351 (1867) [property dedicated to city as a "public square" could not later be sold as a pdvate subdivision, where the original grantor, or persons claiming through the odginal grantor, asserted the pdvate restrictions]. Now, having received wdtten correspondence from four direct descendants of the odginal grantors, [Gaulochers], indicating they wish to assert the "private restrictions," the next legal question is whether the transfer documents create a "private restriction" on the 39.83 acre Galoucher Tract in question, and whether such restrictions are enforceable by the Galoucher Heirs in a court of law. As noted above, the doctdne of merger under property law generally means that whatever promises were made in a contract of purchase or other preliminary documents, said promises would be "merged" into the final document (warranty deed) and terminate unless restated in the deed. As you will note in the warranty deed (Attachment E), there is no reference to conveyance of this land for cemetery purposes, or for any other public purpose. However, it is questionable that this doctdne survives. This means that Gaulochers can make a colorable claim that the City is legally obligated to respect and abide by the "private restrictions" placed on this conveyance by Theresa and Christian Galoucher and accepted as such by the City. On balance and if the Galoucher family heirs chose to press the issue, a court would likely give considerable weight to the restrictive language, and may well find the land was sold and dedicated for cemetery purposes sufficient to tdgger the "private restriction law." At this point, the courts would "strictly construe" the private restriction language, and may well find the language binding on the City, Carson. at 174. In other words, the mere passage of time or change in circumstances would not necessarily change the plain meaning of the restrictions stated by the City Council resolution of 1913, and the "contract for purchase for cemetery purposes" executed by both the Gaulochers and the City in 1913, see ,Attachments C and D. Conclusion While the restrictive language was not found in the deed, it is my considered opinion the City Council is legally obligated to take into account the expressed preferences of the Galoucher heirs. It would be my preference that the City make an effort to accommodate the Galoucher heirs' wishes, and to at least seriously consider dedicating or rededicating by resolution ten acres to Oakland Cemetery, and begin negotiations with the family to dedicate thirty acres of the remaining land to Hickory Hill Park. I have no feel, one way or another, as to whether the Gaulocher family would initiate litigation. 7 I will be available for questions dudng executive session on Monday, December 16, 1996, at 6:30 p.m. NOTE: This memo can be a "public memo" if you so choose. Attachments cc: City Clerk City Manager Assistant City Manager Terry Trueblood, Director Pmt~e & Recreation '~ "k', I~. ~--')2....,~... Setting the '98 City Agenda What do these issues have in common? · Full funding of property tax credits · Timely remittance of local option sales tax · Establishment of a two-year study of Iowa's tax system IOWA LEAGUE of CITIES They are now the law in Iowa, thanks to the efforts of League membership. What do these groups have in common? · Master Builders · Associated General Contractors · Doctors · Local governments ¢ All were designated as "winners" for the 1997 legislative session by the Des Moines Register. As a city official... You have the power to capitalize on the successes of 1997 by continuing the momentum in 1998. The Iowa League of Cities' annual Legislative Day is on Wednesday, March 4, at the Airport Holiday Inn in Des Moines. Activities begin at 10 a.m. with question and answer sessions with legislative leadership. We will then take our message to the Statehouse and visit with lawmakers one-on-one throughout the afternoon. Your participation determines the fate of Iowa's cities. The League invites you to join city officials from around the state in giving a voice to the '98 city agenda. Mark your calendars for this upcoming event. Registration information will be available in future issues of Cityscape and Legislative Bulletin. out. DISTI~ICT PLAN Iowa City: Beyond 2000 Comprehensive Plan Dr ~.; EJulV 1 997 DRAFT: 7-11-97 SOUTH DISTRICT PLAN The South Planning District encompasses an area of Iowa City located south of Highway 6 and east of the Iowa River, and extends south and east to the growth area limits, which mark the boundaries of the area that will be served by sanitary sewer service in the future. The Snyder Creek Bottoms, a large wetland conservation area located southeast of Sycamore Street, cannot be developed and thus serves as a natural growth area boundary. (See Exhibit A, South Planning District Map) The South District contains approximately 3,000 acres or 4.7 square miles; approximately 60% of the district is located within the corporate boundaries of Iowa City. The remaining 40% is unincorpo- rated property located along the south and east edge of the district. This land is likely to be voluntarily annexed into Iowa City over the next two to three decades and be devel- oped as new neighborhoods in the city. The South District Plan describes the history, current land uses, existing environmental features and potential, future land uses for this developing area of the community. Guidelines for future residential, commercial and industrial land uses and supporting public facilities, including streets, sewers, stormwater drainage, an elementary school, and open space, are set forth for the district. A major commercial area located along Gilbert Street in the northwest portion of the district is examined separately from the new residential neighborhoods that will be developed to the south. The South District Plan is the first in a series of district plans to be included in Iowa City's new Comprehensive Plan, Iowa City: Beyond 2000, and has been developed coop- eratively with citizens, who own property and/or live in this area of the community, and participated in a series of interviews, meetings and workshops to envision future plans for this district. This district was selected as the initial planning district due to construc- tion of the South River Corridor Interceptor Sewer, which will link the north and south wastewater treatment plants in Iowa City. When the sewer is constructed and opera- tional, opportunities for residential neighborhood development will occur in the west portion of the district (west of Sycamore Street), where rezoning and development in Iowa City have slowed in recent years due to inadequate sanitary sewer capacity. The east portion of the planning district, located generally east of Sycamore Street, is served by the Southeast Interceptor Sewer and the South Sycamore Trunk Sewer. A new regional stormwater and green space corridor will enhance drainage and flood con- trol for the area east of Sycamore Street; making development of the area more feasible while providing recreational trail/park opportunities. The design, improvement and ex- tension of arterial streets, including Sycamore Street, Gilbert Street/Sand Road, Sioux Avenue, and an east-west parkway, are integral to the full development of the South Planning District. (See Exhibit A) Historic Context. Although there are few visible, physical signs that remain of early human settlements in the South Planning District, there is archaeological, historical and prehistoric evidence that the South District has been the site of human occupation for millennia. (See Exhibit B: Map of Archaeological Sites in the South District.) In 1996, a 2,000 year old dwelling and associated features were excavated at Napoleon Park; this archaeological discovery represents the first prehistoric structure found in the entire Iowa River valley. Native Americans encamped in this area along the Iowa River for many years before white settlers arrived. The first white settler to call Johnson County his home was John Gilbert, who in 1826 established a trading post near the mouth of Snyder Creek, just south of the South Area study boundaries. At that time, a Mesquakie Indian village existed to the north of the trading post, and is thought to have had a population of around 1,000 people. In or near Napoleon Park, the early, white settlers founded the town of Napoleon, which served as the first county seat for Johnson County from July 4, 1838 to November 14, 1839. It was reported that in May of 1838, there were 237 settlers in the general area. When Iowa City was estab- lished in 1839 as the territori- al capital and county seat, the competition from this new community one mile to the north marked the beginning of the end for the fledgling town of Napoleon. Phillip Clark was one of the in- dividuals Gilbert persuaded to settle in this area. The McCollister-Showers farm- stead located at 2460 S. Gil- bert Street is on land that was Sketch of ff~e first Johnson County Courthouse, which was located at Napo- part of Clark's original claim, staked in 1837. (See Exhibit C, South District Property Ownership) The first county courthouse in Johnson County, the one permanent struc- ture that was built within the town of Napoleon, was located across Gilbert Street from this property. In 1863, the property was purchased by James McCollister and over the next few decades grew to be a farm containing about 750 acres. The McCollister-Showers home was constructed in 1864 and expanded in 1880. The barn on the property was constructed in the early 1880s. The ten acre farmstead that remains is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and is one of the few remaining links to the early settlement of this area. c. 1880s Photo of the McCollister-Showers Residence. c. 1880s Photo of Barn on McCollister-Showers Farmstead Photographs provided courtesy of Portia Cooper, a McCo/lister descendent. Another mid-lath century home is located just to the north of the McCollister-Showers farmstead at the south terminus of Waterfront Drive. Based on its Greek Revival design and architectural style, it likely pre-dates the construction of the McCollister-Showers home, although little is known about its history or past occupants. Like the McCollister-Showers farmstead, most of the South Area was used by early white settlers for farming. Today, almost half of the land area within the planning district is still used for agricultural purposes. Urban development first began in the area in the mid- 1950s with the development of the Fairmeadows Subdivision. Throughout the 1950s and 60s, additional subdivisions developed as the city grew outward. Grant Wood Elementary School was built in 1969 to serve these new subdivisions. In the 1960s, the construction of Highway 6 as a bypass had a significant effect on the definition of the South Planning District. The highway separated the South District from existing residential, commercial and industrial developments to the north, but also acted as a catalyst by creating access and visibility for commercial development (K-Mart, Econofoods, Pepperwood Shopping Mall and a mixture of office and heavy commercial uses in the Southgate Avenue area) and allowing for the extension of streets to serve residential subdivisions and mobile home parks developed south of Highway 6 through the 1970s, 80s and 90s. Parks, including Wetherby Park (1975) and the Whispering Meadows Wetlands Park (1991) were developed to serve the growing population. Whis- pering Meadows Park also serves as a wetland preserve. As the South District continues to grow, it is important to preserve links to the early history of the area, including the remaining elements of the McCollister-Showers farm- stead and significant archaeological discoveries. Naming important elements of the new neighborhoods, such as streets, the elementary school, and parks, after early settlers and Native Americans, who lived in this area, will serve to remind future generations of the important history of the district. Ex/stinq/Future Development. Although there may be some redevelopment of the exist- ing commercial and residential areas south of Highway 6, the character and major infra- structure of these developments have already been established and major changes are not anticipated. Community commercial land uses and entryway enhancements are proposed for the Gilbert Street commercial corridor located between the Iowa River and the CRANDIC Railroad south of Highway 6. For the largely undeveloped tracts of land to the south, planning concepts are outlined for the new neighborhoods, which will be designed to complement and be compatible with existing development. For the new neighborhoods section of the plan, the South District has been divided into four subar- eas, including the River Corridor Area, the Sycamore West Area, the Sycamore East Area, and the Sioux Avenue Area (Exhibit A). The following section discusses opportunities for redevelopment and development of land in the commercially-zoned Gilbert Street corridor that serves as an entryway to Iowa City. Gilbert Street Commercial Corridor The South Gilbert Street commercial corridor (Exhibit D) is generally located along Gilbert Street between Highway 6 and the CRANDIC railroad. Increased levels of traffic and greater demands for retail commercial uses are expected as a result of the residential growth that is anticipated will occur in the South District. This will lead to an increase in the importance of this corridor as an entryway into Iowa City. However, most of the vacant commercial land located along Gilbert Street between Highway 6 and the CRANDIC railroad is presently zoned for intensive commercial uses, permitting outdoor display and storage of merchandise and materials, and near industrial uses such as auto body shops, contractors' yards, lumberyards, and warehousing. These land uses are not consistent with use of this area as an attractive entryway into Iowa City and as a retail commercial area. 4 General commercial development within this entryway corridor should be encouraged with careful consideration given to the site planning of property fronting on Gilbert Street, creating an attractive, well-landscaped corridor to serve as a major entryway into Iowa City from the south. Existing, attractively landscaped properties at the north end of the corridor, such as the Hills Bank property, can serve as a model for future develop- ment in the area. General commercial zoning is also recommended for properties situated along upgraded Stevens Drive and an extended Southgate Avenue, which will carry significant levels of traffic between Gilbert Street and existing commercial development east of the railroad. Areas to be considered for general commercial zoning are illustrated on Exhibit D. The areas west of Stevens Drive, which are currently developed with intensive commercial uses, would retain Intensive Commercial zoning. A proposed extension of the Iowa River Corridor Trail through this commercial area will be located along the east bank of the river from Highway 6 south to Napoleon Park, and potentially beyond the park into the future residential neighborhoods in the South Area. A trail is also planned to extend along the south side of Highway 6 from the residential areas in the east part of the district to the Gilbert Street commercial area. Integration of this trail system with the future retail commercial development in this area is encouraged to provide a bicycle/pedestrian link, not only between the Gilbert Street commercial development and the residential development to the south, but also a connecting link to downtown Iowa City. Sidewalk linkages within the commercial area are also strongly encouraged. Existing environmental constraints may preclude the development of portions of the vacant property within the commercially-zoned area. These features include the Iowa River flood plain and potential wetlands. The City is in the process of conducting a floodplain study to determine whether undeveloped properties in the floodplain that were flooded during the flood events of 1993 will have some development limitations. Development may occur in wetlands east of Gilbert Street if the Corps of Engineers allows replacement wetlands to be created/expanded west of Gilbert Street and south of the railway. If portions of the commercial area are unable to be developed, they should be considered for potential use as a trailhead wetland park or passive recreation/observa- tion area. This type of a facility in this location would serve to enhance the appearance of the Gilbert Street entryway, provide a measure of flood protection for the Iowa River, and secure a natural buffer along the proposed Iowa River Corridor Trail. South Area New Neighborhoods The new neighborhoods will be extensions of existing residential development to the north, including the Grant Wood and Pepperwood neighborhoods as well as the Bon Aire and Hilltop mobile home courts. Planning for these new neighborhoods takes into ac- count existing residential uses, including four rural subdivisions, a few farmhouses, some riverfront cottages and three apartment buildings that are located in the largely undevel- oped area of the district. It also recognizes the manufactured housing parks and medium density single-family residential development planned for the Sycamore Farms area in the southeast portion of the district. Environmental constraints and opportunities, sand mining operations and their eventual reclamation, and existing and potential recreational and passive open space are also considered. South District Environmental Features. In accord with the Beyond 2000 principles, plan- ning for new neighborhoods in the South District will respect environmentally sensitive areas by protecting "the urban forest, the Iowa River and its environs, open space and wildlife habitat," by securing "a balance between natural areas and development," and supporting "acquisition and ecological management of watersheds, floodplains, wet- lands and greenways." Wooded wetlands and floodplains within the Iowa River Corridor and the Snyder Creek Bottoms are significant environmental features in the South Dis- trict. The area also contains upland woodlands, large areas of hydric soils, sand mining operations, several watershed/drainage areas, archaeological sites, and potentially, a popu- lation of terrestrial box turtles, which are on the State threatened species list. (See Exhibit E, South District Sensitive Areas Map). The environmental features considered in the planning for the South District are discussed in detail in Appendix A. South District Planninc~ Guidelines/New Nek7hborhoods Scenario. The planning guide- lines embodied in the South District Plan are based on the Bevond 2000 policy state- ments that relate to new neighborhood planning. These statements focus on creating a sense of community by ensuring that neighborhoods are designed to be accessible, compact, and pedestrian-oriented, and contain an appropriate mix of housing types, land uses, connecting streets and open space. The Bevond 2000 neighborhood policy statements were further defined and tailored to the needs and attributes of the South District in a series of public participation efforts. (See Appendix B) Based on the policy statements of Beyond 2000 and the consensus arrived at through meetings and citizen workshops, planning guidelines were developed to address future development in three subareas of the South District: the River Corridor Area, Sycamore West Area and Sycamore East Area. Although the Sioux Avenue Area was not included in the citizen workshops, the general planning guidelines developed for the other subareas of the South District can be applied to its future development. In addition, a general land use scenario (Exhibit F, South District Land Use Scenario) was developed that illustrates how these planning guidelines may be applied to development in the South District. When annexations, rezonings, planned developments and subdivi- sions are proposed within the South Planning District, these planning/land use guidelines will assist the City Council and the Planning and Zoning Commission in evaluating devel- opment applications. They should also serve as a guide for developers and their engi- neering/architectural consulting firms as they design developments. The land use scenario is intended to be general guide; an indication of how development may occur in the South District. It is possible that specific land uses shown on the land use scenario may not develop in the exact locations depicted, but decisions regarding developments in the South District should adhere generally to the land use guidelines set forth in this plan. The land use scenario illustrates a neighborhood commercial center (red), a mix of housing types (single-family/yellow, duplex-townhouse/gold, apartments/ brown), open space (parks/green, trails/purple band), and two alternatives for a potential elementary school sites (purple). The new neighborhoods planning guidelines apply primarily to the Sycamore East and Sycamore West areas. Given the environmentally sensitive nature of the River Corridor Area, it may be advisable to limit development in this subarea to the three parcels of land located near Napoleon Park and adjacent to Gilbert Street that contain few environmen- tally sensitive features and have soils that are suitable for structural development. Con- sideration will be given to establishing parks, greenways, trails and open space for the larger part of the River Corridor Area. The following sections describe the commercial, housing, parks and school elements of the plan. Streets and a fire station location are also addressed. Neic~hborhood Commercial. Located along Sycamore Street, south of the South Pointe subdivision, the neighborhood commercial center should be centered within the neigh- borhood to provide convenient shopping opportunities and activities for residents of the surrounding area. An accessible mix of commercial, residential, institutional and public uses should be clustered around a main street "marketplace" to provide an active focal point for neighborhood residents. The design of the neighborhood center should incor- porate pedestrian and bicycle accessibility for neighborhood residents and include a town square or plaza area to create an active, all-seasons neighborhood gathering place. In addition, a smaller commercial area with a convenience center/gas station may be located at the edge of the neighborhoods on an arterial street, such as Gilbert Street/ Sand Road. Guidelines to address these neighborhood commercial goals are listed be- low: 6 Concept of a 'main street' design for a neighborhood commercial center... Centrally locate the neighborhood commercial center along the north-south seg- ment of Sycamore Street, or at the northwest corner of Sycamore Street/Sy- camore L intersection. Design direct access to the uses within the center from a side or frontage street, not an arterial street. Use a "main street" design with a pedestrian orientation that incorporates fea- tures, such as on-street parking; parking lots behind or between buildings; mini- mal or no building setback from the sidewalk adjacent to the street; accessible, upp_~r floor r~_dential use of cq_m_m_e_.r_cial buildin__gs; townhouses and small scale apartment buildings located in close proximity to the commercial areas; public spaces, and trails that connect the commercial center to the surrounding neigh- borhood. (Zoning Chapter text amendments will be required.) [] Because of the proximity of this area to the Highway 6 commercial area, develop the neighborhood center at'a smaller scale on a site that is seven to ten acres in size, and include a mix of small businesses as well as residential and institutional uses to serve the day to day needs of the new neighborhoods area. Encourage small commercial and institutional uses either in or near the commercial center, including light retail businesses, a pharmacy, a transit stop, a branch bank, small restaurants, outpatient medical/dental clinics, adult and child daycare centers, a postal substation, a convenience store, a neighborhood center, a recreation cen- ter, a small grocery store, and a religious institution. Incorporate a "town square," green space or plaza into the neighborhood center design to buffer the commercial area and to provide opportunities for neighbor- hood gatherings and recreation. Create residential uses in and near the neighborhood center by locating apart- rn~nts_o_rL~the upper floo[s ~of_ co..m__mercial buildings, and by clustering small apart- ment buildings and townhouses around the cente~. [] Connect the neighborhood center to the loop trail system and open spaces in the South District through the use of bicycle/pedestrian trails. In addition to the neighborhood commercial center, locate a small convenience commercial area of approximately one-half acre, containing a gas station/conve- nience store, at the edge of the neighborhoods, such as at the corner of Sand Road (Gilbert Street) and the Sycamore L. Provide adequate separation from the neighborhood commercial center (one-half mile minimum) and direct access to an 7 arterial street. To assure compatibility with adjacent residences, provide adequate buffering and minimize paving for the convenience commercial area. Housinq. The predominant land use in the South District new neighborhoods will be detached, single-family residential. However, the neighborhood will also contain areas where low to medium density multi-family, townhouse and duplex style housing will mix compatibly with single-family housing. The medium density housing options should be carefully designed and located to take advantage of major infrastructure investments, such as arterial streets, and goods and services, which are provided in the neighborhood commercial center. Medium density housing should be compatible in scale and density to blend with single-family neighborhoods. As housing density increases and lot sizes are reduced, attention will need to be paid to design issues, such as garage and driveway locations, to assure that the new neighborhoods are attractive and livable. Guidelines designed to help achieve the housing goals are as follows: [] Ensure that all housing types are accessible for persons with disabilities. Detached, single-family housing will be the predominant land use in the South District. Locate this type of housing primarily in the central portions of the neigh- borhood away from arterial streets. Use small lot, single-family housing and duplex development to serve as a gradual, density progression between single-family homes located more centrally in the neighborhood and the multi-family or townhouse buildings located near the com- mercial center or along arterial streets. Locate low to medium density multi-family housing in the form of townhouses and small apartment buildings at the edges of the neighborhood along arterial streets, and near the neighborhood commercial center, trails, major open space areas, and institutional uses, such as a school or religious institutions. Limit the size of individual parcels zoned for such development, so that the scale of build- ings is compatible with surrounding uses and the traffic generated from such developments is adequately accommodated. Provide landscaped front yards and parking in the rear for townhouse and modest- sized apartment buildings that face arterial streets. This will provide a boulevard or parklike buffer along the street, and create a more attractive appearance than expanses of paved, parking lots or walls of back yard fences lining such streets. Design medium density housing to be similar in height and appearance to large, single-family housing. Use design guidelines, such as requirements for the place- ment of parking behind buildings, and provisions for attractive visible entryways on multi-family buildings, to help assure that such buildings are compatible in design with nearby lower density housing. Ensure a variety of housing stock and provide controls on scale and density by providing small multi-family lots of approximately 12,000(~16,000 square feet for low density multi-family housing at the intersections of collector and arterial streets. Lots of this size will assure that the resulting apartment buildings will be no more than four to six units per building so that there are no more than 24 units at any one intersection. [] Provide accessible apartments above ground floor commercial uses in the neigh- borhood commercial center. [] Improve the appearance of streetscapes by using alleys for access to garages. This is especially important for residential developments with narrow lots. [] Revise the front yard setback requirements of the Zoning Chapter to allow houses with front porches to be built closer to the sidewalk. Parks/O~en Soace. In the South District, neighborhood parks three to seven acres in size should be provided as a focal point for informal gatherings and recreation within easy walking distance from residences in the neighborhood. Neighborhood parks should be centrally located within the Sycamore East and Sycamore West neighborhoods, and be designed as an integral part of an interconnected system of open space. Wherever possible, parks should be connected by accessible trails, and located near schools, water- ways and wooded areas. In addition, two larger, neighborhood parks should be developed in association with the reclamation of the pond (sandpit) east of Gilbert Street and as an enlargement of the new, regional stormwater and greenspace corridor east of Sycamore Street. A regional or community park is envisioned around the pond (sandpit) located west of Gilbert Street. A conservation area that provides protection for a threatened species of turtle, perched wetlands on a sandy knoll, archeological and prairie relicts should be considered on the McCollister property. The wooded wetlands along the Iowa River should be reserved as natural open space and a floodplain reservoir. Open space should be incorporated into the design of developments in the South District to assure green buffers between me- dium and low density housing, between commercial and residential uses, and along Sycamore Street. Guidelines for parks and open space development are listed below: Create three to seven acre neighborhood parks that are centrally located, intercon- nected and accessible in terms of trails, parking areas, play equipment and picnic shelters. Ensure that neighborhood parks have benches and rest areas accessible for elderly p_~ersons and people with disabilities. Accessible basketball courts, play equip- ment, shelters with picnic areas, cooking areas, running water and restrooms should be standard features of the new neighborhood parks and be incorporated into the existing 24 acre Wetherby Park. Accessible, raised gardens should be considered in Wetherby Park. Create access, a parking area and neighborhood park features in the south part of Wetherby Park. There should be no north-south through street bisecting Wetherby Park. Design parks in association with trails, schools, waterways and wooded areas, including larger parks designed in conjunction with the development of the re- gional stormwater basin and the reclamation of the two ponds (sandpits). The parks located adjacent to ponds may feature boating (small, non-motorized craft), fishing and other water-related activities. Preserve sensitive features, including the environmentally sensitive areas on the McCollister tract, and waterways and wetlands throughout the South District, particularly the wooded wetlands along the Iowa River and the contributing drainageways and wetlands associated with the Snyder Creek Bottoms. Incorporate green space to assure landscaped buffers between different land uses, to create a landscaped, green buffer along Sycamore Street, and to provide a green square within the neighborhood commercial area. Trails. Pedestrian/bicycle trails help support pedestrian oriented neighborhood design by providing off-road connections between key neighborhood destinations. A trail system throughout the South District will connect parks, schools, commercial areas, and neigh- borhoods. These trails will be designed for a variety of users and purposes, including pedestrians, people with disabilities, bicyclists, joggers and roller skaters, and for trans- portation as well as recreation. The trails, as well as the parks, schools, and commercial areas they connect, should be accessible. An off-road loop trail through the South District should be constructed as the area develops, taking advantage of utility ease- ments and drainageways within the new neighborhoods. (Exhibit G, South District Potential Trail System) The main loop of the trail system will connect with the south extension of the Iowa River Corridor Trail at Napoleon Park. From Napoleon Park, the trail will run southeast along the South River Corridor Interceptor Sewer easement to the south soccer fields. It will then turn northeast along the Snyder Creek Bottoms, and then north through the re- gional stormwater detention area to be established on the Gatens tract. The trail will also connect with the trail proposed to run south from the Whispering Meadows Wet- lands Park through the Saddlebrook development. The main loop will be linked at the north by a trail to be constructed along the south right-of-way line of Highway 6. An- other connecting trail from Napoleon Park to Wetherby Park to Grant Wood School to Whispering Meadows Wetlands Park is also proposed, and will serve as a central loop connection trail through the middle of the South District. Guidelines for establishing trails in the South District are listed below: Plan off-road, accessible trails for a variety of users. Design these trails as best as is practical for pedestri- ans, bicyclists, joggers and other non-motorized means of transportation. Use the trails to connect sig- nificant traffic generators, such as schools and com- mercial areas. The trails should be more than scenic and recreational, but should also be an integral part of the city's transportation net- work. [] As subdivisions develop, tie Potential River Corridor Trail area near Sand Lake. trails into the main loop wherever possible through the use of branch trails or wide sidewalks (generally eight feet wide). Also tie key neighborhood destinations, such as a commercial area, parks, or a school, into the trail system to provide pedestrian-scale access. Elementary School. As the South District develops, the population will increase to a level that will support the construction of an elementary school. The school should be centrally located and near an arterial street to allow easy access for bus and other school- related traffic. Two potential elementary school sites have been identified. One is near the northwest corner of the Sycamore Street L, and the other is just north of the south soccer fields. The Sycamore Street L site is more centrally located in the developing area, and will be within closer walking distance of more households. It will also be more accessible in the street system of the developing neighborhoods. A school campus just north of the south soccer fields could be integrated with the soccer fields, and share parking facilities as well. Guidelines for locating and developing an elementary school site are listed below: [] Connect the school to the trail system and locate it adjacent to a park or natural area. Ensure that the school has access from the arterial street system, but allow inter- vening land uses, such as townhouses or open space to buffer the school from the arterial street. Locate outdoor play areas back from the arterial street. Locate the school site in combination with or close to other recreational and institutional uses, such as parks, team sports facilities, adult and child daycare, and encourage the school to function as a neighborhood meeting place. 10 [] Design safe crossings for pedestrians near the school, especially arterial street crossings. Streets/Roads. Gilbert Street (Sand Road), Sycamore Street and Highway 6 are the principle streets that currently serve the South District. These arterial streets serve as neighborhood edges, and provide the framework for development in the South District. Segments of these streets need to be upgraded to city design standards, and an east- west arterial street or parkway aligned with the Sycamore L will be constructed to con- nect Gilbert Street/Sand Road with Scott Boulevard/Sioux Avenue/Highway 6 to the east. Long-range plans show this arterial street extending to the west and crossing the Iowa River. This river crossing is not likely to be constructed within the next 20 years, because it would be located beyond the growth boundary for Iowa City, would heavily impact a large area of wooded wetlands within the River Corridor Area, and would be extremely expensive to develop. Also, there is sufficient capacity on Highway 6 such that an additional arterial river crossing is not warranted in the short-term. A major collector street is proposed to skirt the south boundary of Wetherby Park and provide a fairly direct connection from Gilbert Street east to Sycamore Street. A modified grid of collector and local streets are envisioned to complete the necessary street network. The location and design of the street network will have a major effect, not only on the transportation patterns of the planning district, but will also effect the quality of life of the new neighborhoods. Careful consideration should be given to the design of these streets so that they become pleasant elements of the surrounding neighborhoods rather than undesirable intrusions into the neighborhood. Guidelines for streets in the South District are listed below: Use arterial streets, including Gilbert Street/Sand Road, Sycamore Street, and the new east west parkway to form the boundaries of the new neighborhoods in the South District. Use landscaped medians and wide landscaped areas at the sides of arterials, such as Sycamore Street, to create a pleasant streetscape for passersby and make the streets compatible with the surrounding residential development. Landscaped arterials will create an environment more conducive to orienting the front of hous- ing instead of fenced rear lots toward arterial streets. [] Align collector streets across arterial streets to provide for the safe crossing of neighborhood boundary streets, particularly for pedestrians and cyclists. [] Within the neighborhood, design collector streets so they are not continuous through streets, but are arranged in an offset grid pattern. Arrange local residential streets in a modified grid pattern. Enhance the local neighborhood streets and encourage pedestrian activity by narrowing the pave- ment, providing trees, benches and attractive lighting along the streets, and en- courage alternatives, such as alleys or narrow drives at the side of the house to access a recessed or rear yard garage, and to minimize extensive curb cuts and paved front yards. Provide safe, attractive and accessible street crossings at key locations, such as the entrances to the neighborhood commercial center, parks and school sites, and where designated trails cross arterial streets. Fire Protection. The South District is in the "first response area" for Fire Station No. 3, located at 2001 Lower Muscatine Road, just north of Highway 6. The engine company from this station is responsible for being the first to respond to a call from the South District. According to a 1991 Fire Station Location Study produced by the Johnson County Council of Governments, the area south of Highway 6 is adequately protected by the existing fire station locations. The average time for the area east of Sycamore Street 11 was under 3 minutes, considered optimal. The average response time modeled for the area west of Sycamore Street was between 3 and 6 minutes, and is considered adequate, although not optimal. The distance of the fire station from the scene of the emergency, and the continuity of the arterial street network both have an effect of travel time. An interconnected, modi- fied grid street system will serve to increase the number of access points, and will potentially reduce the response time. The emergency vehicle response time for firefighting apparatus to respond to the South District is considered adequate to the current city limits, and no additional fire department facilities are planned at the current time. Urban growth and the extension of the south city limits will prompt the need for an additional fire protection facility and emergency response apparatus to serve the growing popula- tion within this area. Sioux Avenue Area Although the Sioux Avenue Area was not specifically studied by the neighborhood plan- ning workshop participants, it is considered an extension of the South District New Neighborhoods. With its access to Highway 6, the Sioux Avenue Area is a major entranceway to southeast Iowa City. As this area develops, the City should ensure that residential, commercial or industrial developments maintain an attractive appearance through the use of landscaping and architectural standards. The location of the Sioux Avenue Area makes it appropriate for both residential and general industrial land uses. To the west are existing multi-family residential develop- ment and manufactured housing land uses as well as large tracts zoned for future apart- ments and manufactured housing parks. General industrial areas are located across Highway 6 to the north. The area adjacent to the Highway 6 corridor may be suitable for an extension of the light-industrial zone. If industrial zoning is established south of Highway 6, a buffer will need to be created between residential areas to the west and the potential industrial development. The preservation and enhancement of the Snyder Creek stream corridor may serve as a natural buffer. The east-west parkway will be extended through the Sioux Avenue Area as development occurs. This parkway will tie into Highway 6 either at the Highway 6/Scott Boulevard intersection, or by intersecting with an improved Sioux Avenue. It is likely Sioux Avenue will become an extension of the Scott Boulevard north-south arterial street along the eastern limits of the city. These infrastructure improvements will enhance the potential for residential and/or general industrial development in the Sioux Avenue Area. Implementation Full development of the South District will likely occur over several decades. The City will influence the pace and character of this development through the extension of infrastructure, such as sanitary sewer and arterial streets. However, the housing market will have the greatest influence on the time frame in which the South District develops. The City's decisions regarding annexations, rezonings and subdivisions can have a great bearing on the quality of the physical design, and on the long term quality of life of the neighborhoods to be built in the South District. Implementation of the South District Plan will occur as development proposals are approved and the neighborhood planning concepts are incorporated into these developments. Amendments of City Codes, includ- ing the Zoning Chapter and the Subdivision Regulations, will be necessary to implement some of the concepts set forth in this South District Plan. Implementation of the open space policies will occur as the City acquires parkland and trail corridors as part of development plans and as the City or other entities acquire environmentally sensitive areas, such as wooded wetlands in the Iowa River Corridor. Acquisition of such properties may involve the expenditure of considerable funds; there- fore, outside sources of funding, such as REAP (Resource Enhancement and Protection) 12 should be considered. The Iowa City Community School District will have a role to play in the overall design and functioning of the South District neighborhoods through its choice of a school location. The City will work with the school district and developers to allow the district to reserve or acquire a desirable school location. The City will also influence the charac- ter of the South District through the design of the street network. Consideration should be given to incorporating landscaped medians or green buffer strips along Gilbert Street, Sycamore Street ~ the east-west parkwayz .~,.~ H~,~.~% ~. ? pp<:ladmin~oage~soutarea.p65 I x ~... , ,% " ~ o* ~'"~ ............ ,~ ~ ~ lB ~." ' ....... · · ...... :::... : ........... _'...~ ~ I 2 ~ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::i~ (.&. ' z~Z , ~~ ...... ~ ...................... ~ ' ., , ~ ~ .... ~.--:~:~..~ ..... ~~ ~" ~'~ t?;~::' ======================================== D~~ ~( ~ ~ ~::: =================================== :::::~::Z:::::--~. ~Q~~ .~ '~ ~ ,' =================================================== ~ , ~ ' , ~ :~ ..... ====================================== ~ ~Jh~t~/ I ~_ ~..~',~ ============================================= ~. ,,,~,~~~~~z~.~/ ., ==================================================: ~1~'~ ~'.~ 'Z~' ~' :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: .::':~ ::.:. ~~~ -~. j-,, ~.,. . ...... X ....~..~.~....~ ~ . ~1 /z ; - ~' ~'. : ~ =============================== ::::::'..:.~:''.:I ~ , .~ ~ :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: :.:1':' ::: ' 'I ~.! ~ ..... ~_.._...~~ ..............., ..............~.~ .... , I,I , .- - ~ ................................................. ~ /~ ~ ', ~ ........ "' ', "~--": ~ · ~ ~ I :: ' :~ ' ~ /~ ~ .. ........ t...~ ,.-,~ ~ ~ ~...~ .........I.. ~..~U~TK' -* ",~" ,"~ '-' '" ----" / ~ ~ ' ~ ~ :" ' ': ': ........ ~t'~ ',~ ..'.:~'~,~=, '.==?.:.·~ ' ~ : ~ ~'::::: . "."~-~::~~:~ ~ ~· .., ~ r I~, ; ......· .- ~ '77" ' ~ ~ .... ' ...........~ ......................~ .....~ ~ " ~ ~/ ~ :1:11: 1:::::'' :::' 11':::::'':::::::;-' .-- ..1:::;::~ ~ ~ j -..:. ~c~~ "~ ........... --'-~. .............. ~ ....... I[ ~" ' ~ ; ¢ ' ~:'~ :~ ~~ ~ c~ :;;':: :::':::::'~':::':: :1" ~ ' '~' , ~ % A~.' .. ;;.. : ::.;.;:~:%:::: ;;:.. ',~e '.~ · Le ~ ~ . ' .......... ~ ..........~ .~- .....,~-' ~e =~ ~ ~ ~ ~ , -'-.. ~',.. ; .... ~ ~:'; ''-: ;'.. ~ -- ~ ~ ~ ~,.~'... :~...~:...:...%:¢:::. · ~ : ..- .. % & , ~ · ~ ~:. .., .¢Y" ~.~,~ , - i ~.=- . ~. I -~ I --'~' , ~-~-'~-¥--~--~ i ilk. Section 27 22 22 22 22 22 22 & 27 25 25 & 26 26 26 26 26 26 & 35 26 & 27 27 35 22 South Planning District Recorded Archaeological Sites East Lucas Township (T79N-R6W) Section Division SW 'A SW IA SE V, SE ¼ SE ¼ SE ¼ SW ¼&NW IA NW'A NE~A&NW¼ NW V, SW ¼ SW ¼ SW IA SW V, & NE I/, SW ¼ & SE ¼ SW SE ¼ SW ¼ EXHIBIT B Site No. 13JH35 Wapashashiek's Village 13JH250 Napoleon Town Site 13 JI-I251 13JI-I292 13JH293 13JH716 13JH774 13JI-I337 13JH335 13JH336 13 JI-I749 13JH750 13JH751 13J'I-I752 13JH131 Old McCollister Farm 13JH765 13YH512 13JH743 Site Type and Cultural Affiliation Meskwaki village, historic period (location unconfirmed) habitation, Woodland & early Johnson County settlement penods mound. Woodland period possible camp, prehistoric camp, prehistoric artifact scatter, historic period dump, recent artifact scatter, Woodland period artifact scatter, prehistoric artifact scatter, prehistoric artifact scatter, recent artifact scatter, recent artifact scatter, prehistoric artifact scatter, prehistoric habitation, Woodland period artifact scatter, prehistoric artifact scatter, prehistoric late fur trade/early settlement penod ISOUTH DISTRICT PROPERTY OWNERSHIP I[1111111111 EXHIBIT C HARCH 1997 ~ '4',., ~ ,.,r,. ~' -- ~ 200' DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, CI,'i-Y. OF- IOWA CITY GILBERT STREET COMMERCIAL CORRIDOR 3RD ST -'~ I ~- HIGHLAND AVE STURGIS FERRY PARK IMPERIAL IIIII EXHIBIT D MARCH 1007 NORTH m / ~ SOUTHGATE AV: · "-.'.~ PROPOSED REZONING TO GENERAL COMMERCIAL DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT. CITY OF IOWA SOUTH DISTRICT SENSITIVE AREAS EXHIBIT E ~) ................ ¢~$¢ ...................... DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, CITY OF IOWA CITY SOUTH DISTRICT LAND USE SCENARIO I EXHIBIT F ISOUTH DISTRICT POTENTIAL TRAIL SYSTEM J r. · ~."t~ ' L2..~-:~.~.JI:~2?.%..L h,,,'~,..,--__.LLU.J~ ..;~/-..y.,:_-.. ~.,,. .... - ~.- ""--'"~ ~ =~,--= ~!1~:~, ~=~-='~ "~-~'2'-~f~.~'"~- . ~ . ~- , :~ ~, ~'~, . ._ , ..-.. -~.~ , :~_~ ~-~ ,. . ~ '-~:.~ - .. ' ' ~ ;-' - ,, ~':; ~ '~'k~" ~ - '- '- " ~: ~-- ' ~ ' i i · ~ '- --~ ~ - · ~ .~-. /. ~ .. % ~' , ,~: · ~. . m ~ .~ . ., / . ~ , . -- - · · lL ~/ . .',' : ' ,;'" ~ ':t fJ r--- · '. ~% I ~1 Appendix A ENVIRONMENTAL FEATURES IN THE SOUTH DISTRICT SUBAREAS: RIVER CORRIDOR AREA, SYCAMORE WEST AREA AND SYCAMORE EAST AREA September 1996 Wooded wetlands and floodplains within the Iowa River Corridor are significant environ- mental features in the South District, particularly west of Gilbert Street. The area also contains upland woodlands, large areas of hydric soils, sand mining operations, several watershed/drainage areas and potentially, a population of terrestrial box turtles, which are on the State threatened species list. These factors all impact the planning and development of new neighborhoods in the South District. The Sensitive Areas Inventory Map - Phase I (See ExhibitS, South Distdct Sensitive Areas) depicts the location of these features. ~ Estimates of environmentally sensitive areas in the three South District subareas: the River Corridor Area, the Sycamore West Area, the Sycamore East Area, and the Sioux Avenue Area indicate that: 520 acres (17%) are potential wetlands 180 acres (6%) are potential, wooded wetlands 40 acres (1%) are upland woods 640 acres (21%) contain hyddc (water-saturated) soils Approximately 45% of the four subareas are comprised of sensitive features. Not including hydric soils, approximately 24% of the four subareas are potentially a sensitive area. More detailed consideration was given to the sensitive features in terms of their resource values as well as their impacts on development within the three separate subareas. Some of the environmental features are noted as being located on certain properties within the subareas. (See Exhibit C, South Distdct Property Ownership). See Table 1 below for sensitive area acreages in the four South Distdct subareas. TABLE I. SOUTH DISTRICT SUBAREA ACREAGES Sensitive Areas - Acres Wooded Total Potential Potential Upland Hydric Acres Wetlands Wetlands Woods Soils % of total Acres (%) Acres (%) Acres (%) Acres (%) River Cord- 370 (12) 130 (25) 100 (56) 10 (25) 20 (3) dor Sycamore 900 (30) 20 (4) 10 (6) 20 (50) 260 (41) West Sycamore 1430 (48) 320 (62) 70 (39) 10 (25) 240 (38) East Sioux Ave- 300 (10) 50 (10) 0 (0) 0 (0) 120 (19) nue Total 3000 .520 (17) 180 (6) 40 (1) 640 (21) FIGURES IN PARENTHESES REPRESENT A PERCENT OF TOTAL. NOTE: All figures are approximate. River Corddor Area Much of the River Corddor is located within the 100-year floodplain of the Iowa River. Existing residences located along the fiver on two properties south of Napoleon Park were heavily damaged dudng the 1993 floods. A few other residences are located in the River Corridor Area, but the dominant land use in the area is sand extraction; sand mining operations exist on three of the seven properties in the River Corridor Area. Much of the land, particularly the area of potential, wooded wetlands adjacent to the dyer, has been retained in its natural state. A 26 acre park, Napoleon Park, which is largely devoted to softball fields, is located adjacent to the Iowa River in the north part of this subarea. The soils in the River Corridor Area are primarily composed of permeable soils that are subject to flooding and have relatively high water tables and are highly erodible. These wet soils are located on the west portions of properties adjacent to the Iowa River, and are consistent with the areas shown as potential wetlands and hydric soils on the Sensitive Areas Inventory Map - Phase I. According to the Johnson County Soil Survey (1983), there are moderate to severe limitations in such soils for various types of construction, including shallow excavations, dwellings with or without basements, commercial structures, landscaping and local roads. However, according to the soil survey, these soils are suitable for trails as well as for trees and native vegetation. Given the environmentally sensitive nature of this section of the South District and the limitations on development within the soil types located along the Iowa River, develop- ment should be allowed on a very limited basis. Three parcels adjacent to Gilbert Street contain some land that is not considered environmentally sensitive and have soils that are suitable for development. The reclamation plans for areas that have been mined should be evaluated, and consideration given to establishing parks, greenways, trails and open space for the larger part of the River Corridor Area. Public acquisition of these properties may be appropriate. Retention of areas in their natural state will provide absorptive flood plains and abundant wildlife habitat along the Iowa River. With proper planning, the Iowa River and its environs can provide a significant environmental amenity to the residential development east of Gilbert Street. The City's adopted arterial street plan proposes an arterial street through the River Corridor which would cross the Iowa River and provide a connection between the interchange of Highway 218 and Riverside Drive and the intersection of Sand Road (Gilbert Street) and Sycamore Street. This river crossing has been in City plans for several years. However, detailed plans or a time frame for its construction have never been established. Construction of the fiver crossing would provide an alternative for traffic on Highway 6, which is expected to have capacity problems in the future. Given the environmentally sensitive features in this area, if and when detailed plans are developed for the fiver crossing, consideration must be given to a design and alignment, which minimizes environmental damage. Sycamore West Area The Sycamore West Area is located generally west of Sycamore Street and east of Gilbert Street. A drainage area runs south through the Prospect Farms, Pleasant Valley and Campbell properties. A sandy ridge containing an unknown number of ornate box turtles is situated on the McCollister property, and also contains two small potential wetlands that were formedy sandpits. Wethe. rby Park (24 acres) is located on the northeast edge of the McCollister property, immediately southeast of the Pepperwood Subdivision. A sand mining operation is currently excavating an area on S&G property adjacent to and east of Gilbert Street. The presence of 260 acres of hyddc soils that are stdated across the Sycamore West Area indicates the probability of a high water table and the potential for wetlands for a majority of this area. Development of these properties will involve consultation with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to determine whether or not any of the hydric soils areas are jurisdictional wetlands. If the Corps determines that wetlands exist on property within the City or being annexed into the City, the wetlands will need to be delineated and protected in accordance with the City's Sensitive Areas Ordinance. Areas of hydric soils that are not wetlands can be developed, but may require special construction practices for streets, structures and stormwater management facilities. Hyddc soils that are located adjacent to wetlands and the drainageway (stream corridor) should be treated as environmental assets; to provide stormwater detention, wetland enhancement or buffers, protective greenways along the stream corridor and neighbor- hood open space. Because a preponderance of the soils in this area are subject to ponding, wetness, poor drainage and high water capacities, planning for adequate drainage and stormwater management for this area will be needed prior to development. A few, small potential wetlands and the only woodlands within this area (approximately 22.5 acres) are located in the northwest portion of the Sycamore West Area. There are indications on the McCollister property that omate box turtles (Terrepene Omata) may exist on and around a sandy ridge located on the site. These turtles are listed as a State of Iowa threatened species. As such, these turtles are accorded a certain level of protection, and cannot knowingly be destroyed. The owner and/or developer of the property will need to plan development accordingly, and should consult with the Iowa Department of Natural Resources to determine whether the turtles can be relocated and the appropriate procedures to ensure a successful relocation of this threatened species, or to create a suitable preserve or conservation area to protect the turtles if it is determined that they cannot be moved to a different location. Sycamore East Area The Sycamore East Area is located east of Sycamore Street, and west of current city limits. The Sycamore East Area also has problems with a high water table and poor drainage due to the relatively flat topography and the irapermeability or ponding charac- teristics of many of the soils. The potential wetlands and wooded wetlands in this area are primarily located along a drainageway that extends from the Barker property south to the Gatens Trust property and then further south, then west through the Apel and Lake Calvin properties, where it flows into a large protected wetland area, known as the Snyder Creek Bottoms, and on in a more westedy direction through the City wastewater treatment plant site. The drainageway on the west edge of the Barker tract and south- ward on the Gatens tract has been cited as an area to be acquired by the city and improved into a wider, chain of wetlands to facilitate drainage and flood control for this area. A fanned set of wetland basins may be sited ~ southeast ~ of the Gatens Trust tract. A six acre potential wetland is located east of the Makada Subdivision, and other smaller potential wetlands are scattered throughout this subarea. The predominance of potential wetlands and hydric soils on most of the properties in the Sycamore East Area underscores the need for developers to consult with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers prior to proceeding with development. Most properties in this subarea will 4 require either a Sensitive Areas Site Plan or a Sensitive Areas Oveday rezon- ing/Sensitive Areas Development Plan, and special construction practices, as indicated for the Sycamore West Area. Sioux Avenue Area The Sioux Avenue Area is located east of the cun'ent eastern city limits, south and west of Highway 6, and north of the city growth area limits. The most significant environ- mental feature of this area is Snyder Creek, which runs from the northeast to the southwest portion of the Sioux Avenue Area and empties into the Snyder Creek Bot- toms. The Sioux Avenue Area contains large areas of hydric soils, which indicate the potential for wetlands. Development can occur in areas with hydric soils that are not wetlands; special con- struction methods may be required, however, for streets, structures, and stormwater management facilities. When hyddc soils are located next to wetlands and stream corridors, they serve valuable environmental purposes, such as: stormwater detention, wetland and stream corridor buffering, and neighborhood open space. Given the hydrologic qualities of these soils, particular drainage and stormwater management planning must take place before development can proceed. APPENDIX B: Citizens Participate in Planning New Neighborhoods in the South District of Iowa City In September 1995, the Iowa City urban planning staff formed a team to collect background infor- mation on the South Distdct of Iowa City located south of Highway 6 and east of the Iowa River. Major street and sewer extensions, regional stormwater management, and parks and trails planned for the area were noted on a base map that was developed showing existing land uses, property ownership, acres of land in individual tracts, and environmental resource areas, such as wetlands, woodlands, stream corridors and flood plains. Soil patterns were evaluated, and known ar- chaeological and historic sites were noted. In November 1995, a letter was forwarded to property owners in the largely undeveloped portions of the South Distdct informing them that the South District study was underway. The prop- erty owners were invited to par- ticipate in a public meeting in eady 1996 to help plan for the area and were asked to submit their comments on future devel- opment of the area at any time. Similar announcement letters were forwarded in November/ Citizens working on South District neighborhood plans, Gmnt Wood Elementary School, March, 1996 December 1995 to neighborhood associations (Grant Wood, Pepperwood, Hilltop), the Johnson County Board of Supervisors, Iowa City Commissions (Parks & Recreation, Riverfront & Natural Areas, Planning & Zoning), environmental interests and major developers. In January 1996, the urban planning staff conducted individual meetings with major property own- ers and developers to brief them on the study and to elicit information/plans they might have for future development of their properties. The staff also conducted informational meetings with the ! Citizens working on South District neighborhood plans. Grant Wood Elementary School, March, 1996 Grant Wood Neighborhood As- sociation, the Pepperwood Neighborhood Association, residents of subdivisions lo- cated in the County south of the city limits, the Parks and Rec- reation Commission, the Neigh- borhood Open Space Commit- tee, Iowa City Community School Distdct officials. and the Environmental Technical Advi- sory Committee. At each meet- ing, the planning staff gained additional specific information on properties. land uses. envi- ronmental constraints and plan- ning preferences concerning development of new neighbor- hoods in the South District. In late February, 1,500 post cards were mailed to South Distdct residents, property owners, devel- opers and others inviting them to the new neighborhood planning workshops in the evening on March 11 and March 25 at the Grant Wood Elementary School, a neighborhood school. People, who wished to participate in the "hands-on planning workshops," were asked to call in their reser- vations. Informational packets on the South Distdct were forwarded to people who indicated an interest -- whether they were able to attend the meeting or not. On March 11, 40 people gathered at Grant Wood Elementary School. Following an introductory slide show and presentation of land use scenarios, the workshop participants divided into seven planning teams to discuss and map their ideas for neighborhood commercial areas, schools, parks/trails and housing. Each team presented their map and report at the end of the March 11 session. The ideas generated at the March 11 workshop were used to formulate two new land use scenarios, and to determine common issues/preferences among the teams. On March 25, these concepts were refined by the seven teams, and have been integrated by the urban planning staff into the planning document for the South District. ppdadmin page sdpapenb pm6