Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2012-05-01 Public hearingb Q, NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given that a public hearing will be held by the City Council of Iowa City, Iowa, at 7:00 p.m. on the 1st day of May, 2012, in Emma J. Harvat Hall, 410 E. Washington Street, Iowa City, Iowa, or if said meeting is cancelled, at the next meeting of the City Council thereafter as posted by the City Clerk; at which hearing the Council will consider: An ordinance vacating .27 acres of street right -of -way adjacent to lots 1 -8 Melrose Place. Copies of the proposed ordinances and resolutions are on file for public examination in the office of the City Clerk, City Hall, Iowa City, Iowa. Persons wishing to make their views known for Council consideration are encouraged to appear at the above - mentioned time and place. MARIAN K. KARR, CITY CLERK STAFF REPORT To: Planning and Zoning Commission Prepared by: Sarah Walz Item: VAC12 -00001 Date: April 5, 2012 Melrose Place GENERAL INFORMATION: Applicant: University of Iowa Board of Regents 2660 University Capital Center Iowa City, IA 52242 Contact Person: David Kieft 319- 335 -5052 Requested Action: Right -of -way vacation Purpose: To allow the applicant to acquire a portion of the street right -of -way. Location: Street right -of -way adjacent to properties under University ownership, including lots 1 -8 Melrose PI. Size: 0.27 acre Existing Land Use and Zoning: Portions of the Melrose Place right -of -way, both paved and unpaved that serve residential lots now under University ownership. Surrounding Land Use and Zoning: North: Residential; RS -5 South: Residential; RS -5 East: Residential; RS -5 West: Residential; RS -5 Comprehensive Plan: Residential File Date: February 23, 2012 BACKGROUND INFORMATION: The University of Iowa has applied for the vacation of .27 acres of street right -of -way along the east and southern portion of Melrose Place. The proposed vacation includes both paved and unpaved areas adjacent to lots 1 -8 Melrose Place. These properties, along with a driveway and rear lot at 711 Melrose Avenue, will be turned into a surface parking lot to serve the University of Iowa Hospital staff. The application indicates that the lot is necessary to serve parking areas displaced by the expansion of the University of Iowa Children's Hospital. Lots 1 -8 Melrose Place will be rezoned Institutional Public (P -2). The Institutional Public Zone provides reference to public uses of land owned or controlled by the State or Federal government, such a university campuses, regional medical facilities, post offices, and other state and federally owned facilities. This designation serves a notice function to those owning or buying land in proximity to publicly N owned land that is not ordinarily subject to City development regulations. While these public entities are not ordinarily subject to City regulations, the development standards in the code serve as a minimum guidelines for State and Federal government entities to use to help create a consonant transition between public and private uses. Melrose Place is a low volume cul -de -sac with access off of Melrose Avenue just east of the intersection of Melrose Avenue and Hawkins Drive. The street is substandard in terms of pavement width (20 feet), and paving is in poor condition. Melrose Place does not have sidewalks or storm sewer service. ANALYSIS: The following factors are to be considered in evaluating a vacation request: a) Impact on pedestrian and vehicular access and circulation; b) Impact on emergency and utility vehicle access and circulation; c) Impact on access of adjacent private properties; d) Desirability of right -of -way for access or circulation needs; e) Location of utilities and other easements or restrictions on the property; f) Any other relevant factors pertaining to the specific requested vacation. Vehicular and pedestrian circulation and access to private property: The applicant is seeking vacation of those portions of the right -of -way adjacent to lots 1 -8. These sections of the right -of -way will no longer be necessary for vehicle or pedestrian access once the University removes the structures and redevelops the property as a parking area. The portion of Melrose Place right -of -way that serves lots 9, 10, and 13 Melrose Place (properties not owned by the University) as well as vehicle access to the parking for 741 Melrose Avenue will be retained and improved as a public street. The University will widen the street to 23 feet, improve the paving, and install curb and gutter along the length of Melrose Place. The University will also construct a 4 -foot sidewalk along the west side of the street, adjacent to the privately owned property. Parking will be prohibited on Melrose Place. The connection to Melrose Place is located less than 50 feet to the east of the Melrose Avenue - Hawkins Drive intersection and thus does not comply with current intersection standards. The current proposal preserves two -way access along Melrose Place to serve the remaining residential properties, however, the entrance to the parking area will be gated to allow entry but not exit. All vehicles that pull into the university parking lot will be required to exit via the eastern driveway between 711 and 727 Melrose Avenue. The site plan shows the consolidation of two driveways (for 711 and 727 Melrose Avenue) into one. This single driveway will provide two -way access to the University parking area as well as the private property (727 Merlose Ave). During peak hours, exiting traffic will queue along the drive. While the issue of queuing does not create congestion on Melrose Avenue, it is a concern if drivers become impatient to enter traffic or fail to yield to pedestrians on the sidewalk. From a traffic safety standpoint, this drive would be better designed with a left and right turn lane. Providing the additional space for turn lanes would require an access agreement with the property owner at 727 Melrose Avenue or removal of the structure at 711 Melrose Avenue. Locating the drive further from the intersection of Melrose Avenue and Hawkins would be preferred. Our transportation planners reviewed the proposed parking area design as well as traffic data provided by the a consultant hired by the University (Anderson- Bogert) and believe the proposed traffic circulation and access is safe but indicate that turn lanes for the two -way access drive would further improve traffic flow and safety (see attached memo). Emergency and utility and service access: Because the gate will allow public access, emergency vehicles and service and utility maintenance 3 crews will be able to use the parking lot to exit via the eastern driveway. The Fire Department has reviewed and approved the proposed access and circulation. Parking Area Design and Screening Because the right -of -way vacation will allow the expansion of the planned parking area, the City may consider requiring certain conditions regarding the parking area. The University has worked with the Melrose Neighborhood Association and has attempted to address their concerns, including that the design be efficient for snow removal to minimize noise disturbance for the surrounding properties. Parking areas in the P1 zone are typically required to provide a 10 -foot setback from residentially zoned property; the proposed site plan shows an 8 -foot setback. While the University is not ordinarily subject to City development regulations, these standards serve as minimum guidelines to help create a consonant transition between public and private uses. To minimize the impact of this large parking area on significant historic properties in the residential neighborhood to the east, staff recommends the parking area be set back a minimum of 10 feet from the properties on Melrose Circle and Melrose Avenue. The submitted site plan shows parking aisles that are 24 feet wide; this is two feet wider than what is required by code. Each parking aisle could be reduced by up to 2 feet in order to accommodate additional setback. To comply with the S3 standards, the University's submitted plan shows a solid fence or wall within the setback in addition to landscaping. Landscaping is typically provided on the outside of the fence, facing the neighboring properties. For the benefit of all surrounding residential properties, staff recommends that the final parking area meet City standards with regard to terminal islands and lighting and include shade trees to minimize the heat island effect. The plan submitted by the University complies with this recommendation. Location of utilities Letters have been sent to MidAmerican, Qwest, and Mediacom to determine whether private utilities are present along this portion of right -of -way. As part of the vacation process, and proposed construction, the City of Iowa City Engineering Division would expect that all infrastructure and utility improvements be taken care of by the University of Iowa as part of this project. This would include the reconstruction of Melrose Place (paving w/ curb and gutter), sanitary sewer abandonments as needed, water main improvements, and management of storm water. The water main in this area, which has a history of problems, will need to be upgraded and shortened /terminated at the new end of Melrose Place. The water main will be located under new street paving. The storm water management has been reviewed by the City Engineering Department and is being addressed by the University in its plans. SUMMARY: Staff finds that, subject to the conditions specified below, the proposed vacation meets the criteria for right -of -way vacations as outlined in the code. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of VAC12 -00001 a vacation of a portion of the Melrose Place right -of -way subject to the following conditions: 1. Vehicle access to the parking area from Melrose Place will be one -way: a gate or other device will allow public entry to the lot but will block exit from the lot to Melrose Place. 2. The University will improve the remaining Melrose Place right -of -way, including the reconstruction of Melrose Place (paving w/ curb and gutter), 4 foot sidewalk, sanitary sewer abandonments as 4 needed, water main improvements, and management of storm water. 3. The final parking area design should meet the City's standards with regard terminal islands and lighting and should include shade trees as proposed in the submitted plan. 4. Along the east property, where the parking area abuts private properties on Melrose Avenue and Melrose Circle, a minimum setback of 10 feet should be provided with a solid fence or wall in addition to S3 landscape screening. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Aerial view of properties 2. Memo from Transportation Planner 3. Vacation Exhibit 4. Proposed parking area design Approved by: i Robert Miklo, Senior Planner Department of Planning and Community Development �—. ®art CITY OF IOWA CITY MEMORANDUM Date: March 30, 2012 To: Sara Walz From: John Yapp; Transportation Planner Kent Ralston, Assistant Transportation Planner Re: Proposed Melrose Place Parking Lot Per your request, staff reviewed preliminary designs and traffic data provided by Anderson - Bogert with respect to the proposed University of Iowa parking lot adjacent to Melrose Place. After review, staff concurs with both the assumptions /data used in the traffic study, as well as the results provided by the consultant. Staff wants to make clear that the data /plans reviewed allows full access (entrance /exit) for Melrose Place properties at the intersection with Melrose Avenue, but would disallow those using the proposed University parking lot from exiting onto Melrose Avenue at Melrose Place. This arrangement would be ensured by installing an `entrance -only' gate at the south end of Melrose Place (shown in the preliminary design). With respect to traffic operations, the information provided by the consultant shows that the proposed parking lot and associated traffic will have minimal adverse effects on existing Melrose Avenue or Hawkins Drive traffic operations. The greatest delay for motorists, as shown by the consultant, is for southbound left -turns at Hawkins Drive with a level -of- service (LOS) E. Level -of- service is graded 'A -F' with 'A' representing free - flowing traffic and 'F' representing complete break -down of traffic flow. The addition of the proposed parking lot does not worsen the LOS at this location. The second noteworthy delay shown by the data will be for northbound left -turn movements (out of the parking lot) at the proposed east driveway with a LOS E. Although some vehicle queuing will occur at this location as a result of this delay, all queuing will occur on the proposed east drive; not on City streets. One reason the northbound traffic exiting the parking lot will experience delay is due to the driveway design, which is limited to one lane for all exiting traffic. The addition of separate right and left -turn lanes for exiting traffic will alleviate some delay and congestion, reduce vehicle queuing, and reduce the chance that vehicles will be blocking the sidewalk when pedestrians are present. Increasing the capacity of the driveway will also minimize the potential for risky turning movements due to excessive delay. We recognize that due to site constraints it may be difficult to construct an additional lane for exiting traffic. Staff should review any further revisions /alterations of the proposed concept prior to approval. IN cn cc CR6S E_p [7A.0 E cc co CL O O O LU �77 iii to cc co CL O LU �77 r- 00 N N E m D_ n O 0 O iii N N I N 01 V c 6) E O tT 3 N O O N N O Q U I- ifC �ri VACATION EXHIBIT Prepared by R. Rodney Men Anderson -Bogert Engineers & Surveyors, Inc. 4001 River Ridge Dr. N.E. Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52402 NOTM 1. DISTANCES ARE IN FEET AND DECIMALS THEREOF. 2. BEARINGS HEREON ARE BASED UPON IOWA STATE PLANE HAD B3 SOUTH ZONE. CITY OF IOWA CITY I I `FND 3/8" IR 20.03' I LOT 1 ~ Adjoining Lot Line — — — — — — — — — �C-� — Building Setback Line • .... • • R.O.W. VACATED Found Iron Pipe (Unless Noted) LOT 9 411 w /Red Cap #16546 N86'40'45 "E Set h %30" Rebar ri 30.00' W1 W FND 1/2" Found Section / Quorter Corner LOT 2 I g � ~ Adjoining Lot Line — — — — — — — — — PROPOSE — Building Setback Line • .... • • R.O.W. VACATED Found Iron Pipe (Unless Noted) LOT 9 Found 5/8" Rebar w /Red Cap #16546 N86'40'45 "E Set h %30" Rebar 30.00' a Set Section /Quarter Corner FND 1/2" Found Section / Quorter Corner A REBAR (M) ---- -- l I � N LOT 8 N NSW11 ' 3 "E= P.O.B. T �. TOTAL AREA: 0.27 ACRES I N $ h = (11,676 SQ.FT.) LOT 7 I 1 r 589'1450 — — t�_ — — — QG• LOT 3 LOT 4 N89'14'43"E LOT 5 FND 7 56.09' \ i BOLT gs \ \ 5, r � LOT 6 \ N4W45'32"W i 10.01' \ FND 5/8" I — — — — — — — — — — — — lAgend Boundary Line Adjoining Lot Line — — — — — — — — — Section Line — — Building Setback Line • .... • • . ............ Found Iron Pipe (Unless Noted) e Found 5/8" Rebar w /Red Cap #16546 Set h %30" Rebar w /Oronge Cap #18646 a Set Section /Quarter Corner Q Found Section / Quorter Corner A Measured (M) Recorded (R) I Legal Description PART OF THE MELROSE PLACE RIGHT -OF -WAY AND THE PUBLIC RIGHT -OF -WAY ADJACENT TO LOTS 6 AND 7 FROM SAID MELROSE PLACE RIGHT-OF-WAY TO THE IOWA INTERSTATE RAILROAD (FORMERLY C.R.I.&P. R.R.) AS DEFINED BY THE FINAL PUT OF MELROSE PLACE, JOHNSON COUNTY, IOWA RECORDED IN BOOK 4, PAGE 292, PLAT RECORDS OF JOHNSON COUNTY, IOWA FURTHER DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: BEGINNING AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LOT 7 THENCE N89.14'43E ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF LOT 8 OF SAID MELROSE PLACE, 10.00 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LOT 8; THENCE NOS19'15'W ALONG THE EAST LINE OF SAID LOT 8, 59.02 FEET; THENCE N86'40'45'E, 30.00 FEET THENCE NO3'19'15'W ALONG A LINE PARALLEL AND 30.00 FEET DISTANT TO THE WEST RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE OF MELROSE PLACE 193.10 FEET; THENCE N89'32'47'E, 20.03 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF LOT 1 OF SAID MELROSE PUCE; THENCE S03.19'15'E ALONG THE WEST LINE OF LOTS 1, 2, 3, AND 4 OF SAID MELROSE PLACE, 253.36 FEET TO THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF SAID LOT 4; THENCE N89'14'43E ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID LOT 4, 10.00 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF LOT 5 OF SAID MELROSE PLACE; THENCE S03'19'21'E ALONG THE WEST LINE OF SAID LOT 5, 60.00 FEET TO THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LOT 6; THENCE S8T14'50'W ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF SAID LOT 6. 56.09 FEET TO THE SOUTHEASTERLY LINE OF SAID PUBLIC RIGHT -OF -WAY; THENCE S4S18'02'W ALONG SAID SOUTHEASTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE, 86.54 FEET TO THE NORTHEASTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE OF SAID IOWA INTERSTATE RAILROAD: THENCE N49'45'32 W ALONG SAID NORTHEASTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY UNE, 10.01 FEET TO THE NORTHWESTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE OF SAID PUBLIC RIGHT -OF -WAY; THENCE N4J•18'02"E ALONG SAID NORTHWESTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE, 77.40 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LOT 7; THENCE NOS22'12'W ALONG THE EAST LINE OF SAID LOT 7, 60.00 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING CONTAINING 0.27 ACRES (11.876 SO.FT.) MORE OR LESS. SUBJECT TO EXISTING EASEMENTS AND RESTRICTIONS OF RECORD. LOCATION MAP (N.T.S.) GRAND AW �^ a 0 ELR �A(VE ul m U $ CORP. L9eTS) BR LAN OAK P 01 PAR DR _ iO( MYRTLE A aTr' WOODSIDE� � OWER CT CID a' KT rn `D Tr0 ^N^ J IV/ CD V/' m 0 N N 0 N O O 00 O z z 0m m nn n m mn 00 °m y D D <C m z z n n m m MELROSE AVENUE I I I 1 I I I I 1 � 1 Fi'z I aS R� T: \ACAD \212002 \dwq \PnZ 3- 28- 12.dwg 3 -28 -12 11:32:04 AM .#303 v m S Z O Z4 (D �i O v d 5' ao 9' �w o� i MELROSE AVENUE 75M�� x x xJ —X —x x — —X —X x— x x I x I II II I x x x 0 0 T:\ACAD\212002\d.g\PnZ 3-28-12.d,g 3-28-12 03:25:17 PM ck303 Zs ;t m v; 0 Z 0 t; fA w ti ao O MELROSE AVENUE >< !t x 4 24'-0' x 0 0 x 0 It 1p 7 23-0' o x A \ % z 0 x N-- sp -s —ST c4D X-X mi Re: The University of Iowa's Proposed Parking Lot at Melrose Place To: The Planning and Zoning Commission From: Jean Walker, Melrose Neighborhood Representative April 3, 2012 Concerning the agenda item for your formal meeting on April 5, 2012 about the vacation of the street right -of -way located adjacent to 1 -8 Melrose Place, I would like to convey the following comments from the Melrose Neighborhood. In summary Because we believe that The University of Iowa will proceed with the parking lot (even though it is against the wishes of the Melrose Neighborhood), the vacation of Melrose Place is not as important an issue for us as is the possible removal /destruction of one of the Neighborhood's historic properties (711 Melrose Avenue) if the UI cannot obtain some of the neighboring property (727 Melrose Avenue) to use as part of the entrance /exit lanes to /from the parking lot. Both 711 and 727 are listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Therefore, because the City does not have any enforcement power over the UI, we are asking the City to uphold its stated commitment to the Neighborhood's preservation and to strongly urge the UI, in the spirit of cooperation between the City and the UI, to preserve the historic house and barn at 711 Melrose Avenue. That is, we encourage the City not to stand in the way of the parking lot plan and the vacation of Melrose Place as long as the house and barn are preserved in that location - see below for details. Background information: This vacation is requested because the UI wishes to construct a large parking lot in the Melrose Neighborhood. Such a structure would be very disruptive to the integrity of our Neighborhood and would not be something that we welcome, especially as it involves the demolition of eight Neighborhood properties. We have expressed our opposition to this parking lot both publicly and to the UI. However, the UI has the power to build this structure over the objections of the Neighborhood and of the City. The City, in various of its publications, has stated that the Melrose Neighborhood is worth preserving. The Neighborhood itself spent extensive time, effort, and funds to have a large portion of the properties listed on the National Register of Historic Places (an effort usually done using the resources of the City rather than of the neighborhoods). The UI's current plan will disrupt the integrity of our Neighborhood through construction of a large parking lot within the Neighborhood borders. In recent years we have seen some improvement in communication of the UI's plans to the Neighborhood. However, this project is an exception. We had recently been told that the UI did not plan to purchase any more properties in the Neighborhood but they then informed us that they were planning to buy two more properties, demolish eight properties, and build a large parking lot in our Neighborhood. We were informed of the planned lot only a few days before it was to go before the State Board of Regents, leaving us little time to express our concerns and to explore other options. In their request to the Regents to purchase two Neighborhood properties to realize their plan, the UI correctly stated that none of the eight homes that they wish to demolish are within the Neighborhood's Historic District. At first the lot was said to be temporary and the Regents were told that it would hold approximately 250 cars. It is now acknowledged to be a permanent structure and was to hold 300 cars. In addition, the survival of one house in the Historic District is now in jeopardy. We are encouraged that the UI has recently included two Neighborhood members in their planning meetings for this parking lot. At those meeting, these neighbors have expressed their concerns, such as those described below. In addition to the disruption to our Neighborhood, we have been concerned, amongst other things (such as view, noise, and light pollution, run -off affecting Brookland Park, overnight parking prior to football games, protection from the effects of additional football parking, environmental impact including replacement of vegetation for esthetics and bird /animal protection) about the effect of the lot's traffic on Melrose Avenue, especially as the entry point was originally confined to Melrose Place, which is awkwardly placed as regards the traffic lights at Hawkins Drive. Therefore, the UI has perceived a need for a second two -lane entrance and exit adjacent to 711 Melrose Avenue. It now appears that there is not enough space for these two lanes on the 711 property unless the historic house there is removed. Therefore the survival of the 711 house at its current location now depends on the owner of the adjacent property allowing some of his property to be used to facilitate the two lanes. We think that support of this plan by the City (through vacation of the Melrose Place right -of -way) could be considered at odds with the stated commitment of the City to preserve the Neighborhood. At the least, we think that the vacation of the City street is premature until it is known whether 711 can be preserved by the owner of 727 facilitating the two lanes needed for the eastern entry /exit. That being said, we are aware of the time constraints the UI has developed for the construction of the lot. We would therefore ask the City to approve the vacation of Melrose Place pending the preservation of 711. N Note 1: This request for vacation of Melrose Place is reminiscent of the UI's request for the vacation of Grand Avenue Court, where the UI's plans for the building of the Gerdin Athletic Learning Center were so far advanced that the City had little chance but to vacate the street. (The UI said that when the Center was built 'the road would be too close to it'.) We believe that the UI should request street vacations at a point in their planning where they are not totally committed to the project in question, so that the City has a better chance to decide what is in the best overall interest for the City as a whole. Note 2: As regards landscaping, we have been very concerned about the original paucity of replacement vegetation offered by the UI and are pleased that the City has recommended that the number of trees be increased and that the UI has heeded that recommendation. However, we would like to have evergreens in addition to deciduous trees, both for winter esthetics and for bird /animal protection. This parking lot is unique in that it is an unwanted intrusion in the middle of a neighborhood and so we believe that landscaping and other esthetics should have special consideration in this case. Sincerely, Jean Walker 335 Lucon Drive Iowa City Marian Karr From: Jean Walker <walkersic @yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, April 23, 2012 9:07 PM To: Council; Tom Markus Cc: Jean Walker Subject: Fw: Concerning Item 13 on the Agenda for the Board of Regents at the April 25/26 meeting. Attachments: 711 NRHP Site Inventory Form.pdf Dear City Council Members, At your May 1 meeting I believe you will consider the University of Iowa's request that the City vacate Melrose Place to facilitate the construction of a parking lot there, in the Melrose Neighborhood. Part of the UI's plan for the lot is to demolish the house at 711 Melrose Avenue. The Melrose neighbors request, based on the information below that was sent by us to the members of the State Board of Regents, that the City Council, as part of the vacation discussion, ask the UI to move the house to a vacant lot they own at 311 Melrose Court (or any other vacant area they own in the Melrose Neighborhood), rather than demolish it. Thank you, Jean Walker Melrose Neighborhood Representative 335 Lucon Drive Iowa City - - - -- Forwarded Message - - - -- From: Jean Walker <walkersic @yahoo.com> To: Jean Walker <walkersic @yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, April 23, 2012 5:38 PM Subject: Concerning Item 13 on the Agenda for the Board of Regents at the April 25/26 meeting. Re: Agenda Item 13: The proposed demolition of 711 Melrose Avenue for the building of the Melrose Place Parking Lot From: Jean Walker, Melrose Neighborhood Association Representative Date: April 23, 2012 I am writing to you with some information that I do not think you have as you make your decision about Item 13, because this is an important decision concerning the demolition of a historic 100 - year -old house in the National Register of Historic Places' Melrose Historic District. It also clears up some misinformation you received from The University of Iowa. I would appreciate if you would read this information so that your decision is more informed. Thank you, Jean Walker Summary: The Melrose Neighborhood is requesting that you do not vote to give the Ul permission to demolish the historic 100+ year old house at 711 Melrose Avenue, that is listed on the National Register of Historic Places as a contributing structure, but rather that you request that the house be moved to the UI's vacant lot at 311 Melrose Court or another of the UI's vacant properties in the Melrose Neighborhood. We also ask that you request that the new lot be given (on a sign at the lot) the name of "Melrose Place Lot" or "Melrose Place Parking Lot" in addition to its assigned number. This would be one small way to recapture some of the history of the Neighborhood (and the Historic District) that will be wiped away by construction of this parking lot. Details: The University of Iowa is asking you for permission to demolish 711 Melrose Avenue in Iowa City due to their planned parking lot at Melrose Place. We have communicated to you previously (December 7, 2011) that the planned lot is an unwelcome intrusion in our historic Neighborhood. We believe that the City would not have allowed a parking lot to be built in our Neighborhood and it is contradictory to the City's Comprehensive Plan. Thus we believe that it is only through the power of the UI being a State entity that the UI can override the City's plans and regulations and this lot will be imposed on the Neighborhood. There were various reasons why the Neighborhood thought it would not be a good idea to place the lot in the planned location, a prime one being that the only ingress /egress available was at Melrose Place, which is located in a very awkward position as regards the traffic lights at the intersection of Hawkins Drive and Melrose Avenue. Nevertheless, at your December meeting the Regents gave the UI permission for the project, for them to purchase 1 Melrose Place and 711 Melrose Avenue, and for them to demolish eight houses in our Neighborhood (1 -8 Melrose Place), that are not within the Melrose Historic District. However, the Regents did not give permission for them to demolish either the house or the barn at 711 Melrose Avenue, which are within the Historic District and listed on the National Register of Historic Places "under Criteria A and C as a contributing structure to the Melrose Historic District" (see the attached site inventory form). Initially the lot was said to be temporary, and you were told by the UI that it,was to hold approximately 250 cars. We are now at a situation where the UI says the lot is permanent, the UI planned on having 300 car spaces (where the UI assumed it would be granted vacation of Melrose Place by the City), and the UI is asking for demolition of historic 711 Melrose Avenue. (The number of spaces is now approximately 285 due to requests from the Neighborhood and the City to have more landscaping to lessen the lot's impact on the Neighborhood.) It could be concluded that this whole situation has arisen due to bad or rushed planning. There are other alternatives that could have provided parking close to the UI, such as: 1. Waiting a short while to build the new Children's Hospital until more appropriate parking could be found, for example when the UI facilities at the Iowa River Landing are complete. 2. Better timing of the building of the practice football field with the planned parking, where the bubble used to be. 3. More intensive use of parking in outlying areas and efficient transportation from those parking areas. 4. Building a ramp at the Finkbine parking lot. 5. Building a ramp in the surface lot north of the Quadrangle. 6. Even building a ramp in the surface lot west of the Athletic Learning Center would be preferable to building a parking lot in our historic Neighborhood. It appears that this is an example of the UI forging ahead with plans for a new structure without due consideration of its effect on neighboring City areas. It could be that this is due to the power that the UI has to override City regulations. We believe that with such power comes great responsibility, for example looking far enough ahead so that a neighborhood does not have to bear the brunt of any apparent miscalculations or change of plans of the UI, and ultimately has to pay, as in this case, by the destruction of one of its historic houses and the resultant bisection of its Historic District by a three - lane entrance /exit. (Last August we were told that construction of the Children's Hospital would not affect the Neighborhood.) The most egregious apparent lack of planning is that the ingress /egress at Melrose Place has been found to be unworkable (because it is not wide enough and because it is too close to the Hawkins Drive intersection with Melrose Avenue), which has led to the UI proposing demolition of the historic 711 Melrose Avenue house to achieve a three -lane entrance /exit. We do not believe the UI would appreciate if another entity demolished one of its 100 - year -old historic houses (or built a parking lot in the midst of its campus) against the wishes of the UI and against the UI's Campus Masterplan. (That is, the UI's lot in the Melrose Place location is counter to the City's Comprehensive Plan.) Now that the parking lot is going to be built, we do appreciate the efforts of the UI construction planning team, with input from Neighborhood members and the City, to alleviate some of the impact of the lot on the Neighborhood, such a landscaping, lighting, and runoff considerations, etc. We also appreciate that the 100 -year old historic barn on the 711 Melrose Avenue property will be relocated and preserved. As regards the house at 711 Melrose Avenue (see attached site inventory form from the nomination of the Melrose Historic District to the National Register of Historic Places), it has been misrepresented in the request by the UI for its demolition (and subsequently in the press). This house was built in 1910 or 1911 and thus is over 100 years old and it IS listed on the National Register, as an integral part of the Historic District. It is not a key structure, but a contributing structure, as are many other buildings that make up the Historic District. In addition, though the District does not currently have a local historic designation, the Historic Preservation Commission has thought for some time that it has urgent need to be considered for this designation and is actively pursuing this consideration. Thus this house is under consideration, along with the rest of the Historic District, for having the protections of a local designation. We take exception that the house is apparently denigrated in the UI's request for its demolition. Other houses in the Historic District have been used as rental property for students and this house was described in good enough condition to be included in the National Register in 2004 and there is no apparent significant change in its exterior condition since then. If the house at 711 Melrose cannot be retained in its present location, we request that the UI be instructed not to demolish the house but instead to move it to a vacant lot already dwned by the UI at 311 Melrose Court, or another of the UI's vacant properties in the Melrose Neighborhood. We also request that the new lot be given (on a sign at the lot) the name of "Melrose Place Lot" or "Melrose Place Parking Lot" in addition to its assigned number. This would be one small way to recapture some of the history of the Neighborhood (and the Historic District) that will be wiped away by the UI's construction of this parking lot. (Note: We also regret that the UI has asked for demolition of the house at 15 Melrose Place, as this structure is not involved in the parking lot plans.) Sincerely, Jean Walker Melrose Neighborhood Representative 335 Lucon Drive Iowa City Copies to: Iowa City City Council Iowa City Friends of Historic Preservation Iowa City Historic Preservation Commission Iowa City Planning and Zoning Commission Site inventory Form Stake Inventory No. State Historical Society of Iowa g Part of a district v (December 1, 1999) Relationship: El Contributes to a f National Register Sb 9 -Digit SHPO Review ❑ Non- Extant (ente 8 ❑ New 9 Supplemental n boundaries (enter inventory no.) 52-04500 buting ❑ Noncontributing listrict with yet unknown boundaries that apply) Z Listed ❑ De- listed ❑ NHL [:]DOE 1. ame of Props historic name Wiese. Albert & Auguste. House' Other names /site number 2. Location street & number 711 Melrose Avenue city or town lqwa Ci ❑ vicinity, county Johnson Legal Description: (If Rural) Township Name Township No.. Range No. Section Quarter of Quarter (if Urban) Subdivision _ Custer's Subdivision, Block(s) Lot (s) .See Full Legal Description 3. tats /Federal Agenc Certification Skip t As ec an 4. National Park Service Ge cation Skip this Section] S. iiassificsatien uategory of Property (check only one box) Number of Resou0ces withi Pr ert ® build`ing(s) If Non-Eligible Properly If Eligible Properly, enternumberof- ❑ district Enter number of: Contributing Noncontributin ❑ site - buildings 2 _ buildings ❑ structure sites sites' ❑ object _ structures structures objects objects Total 2 Total Name of related project report or multiple property study (Enter "N/A" if the property is not part of a multiple property examination). Title Historical Architectural Date Base Number Melrose Historic District NRHP Nomination 52 -068 B. Function or Use Historic Functions (Enter categories from instructions) Current Functions; (Enter categories from instructions) 01A01 DOMESTIC /single dwell nghesidence 01A01 DOMESTIC /sincile dwelling /residence 09B BARN 01C05 DOMESTIC /secondary structure /garage ^rcniteeturai, G1asStlnCation (Enter categories from instructions) Materials 09A01 OTHER /House/Front- Gabied Roof foundation walls roof (Ent6rcategories from instructions) 00 STUCCO (parged stone or concrete) 15B SYNTHETICS/Vinyl 08A ASPHALT /Shingle Nar ative Description Q SEE CONTINUATION SHEETS, WHICH MUST 13E COMPLETED) 8. Statementof SI ni cance Applicable National „ Register Criteria (Mark "k" representing your opinion of eligibility after applying relevant National Register criteria) R Yes ❑ No ❑ More Research Recommended A Property is associated with significant gents. Yes No More Research Recommended B Property is associated wlth the lives of significant persons. ® El Yes ❑ No 8 More Research Recommended C Properly has distinctive atchitectural characteristics. Yes 0 No 0 More Research Recommended D Property yields significant information in archaeology or history. County Johnson Address 711 Melrose Avenue Site Number -S2 -02418 City !o CAY District Number 52- 04800 Criteria Considerations ❑ A Owned by a religious institution or used E A reconstructed building, object, or structure. for religious purposes. H F A commemorative property. 0 B Removed from its original' ocation ❑ G Less than 50 years of age or achieved significance within the past ❑ C A birthplace orgrave. 50 years. ❑ D A cemetery Areas of Significance (Enter categories from instructions) Significant Dates Construction date 07 Community Planning & Development 1 910 check if circa or estimated date 02 Architecture Other-dates Significant Person ArchitectfBuilder (Complete if National Register Criterion B is marked above) Architect Unknown Builder Unknown Narrative Statement of Significance (Qi SEE CONTINUATION SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED) 9. Major Bibilographical References Bibliography ® See Continuation sheet for citations of the books, articles and othersources used in preparing this form 10. Geographic Data UTM References (OPTIONAL) Zone Easting Northing Zone Easting Northing 1 2 3 r 4 ❑ See continuation sheet for additional UTM references or comments 11.. Form Prepared By name /title Marlys A Svendsen organization Svendsen Tyler, Inc. for Melrose Neighborhood Association date 10/2004 street & number N3834 Deep Lake Road telephone 7181469 -3300 city or town Sarong state hill zip code 54870 ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION (Submit the following items with the completed form) FOR ALL PROPERTIES 1. Map: showing the property's location in a towntdty or township. 2. Site plan: showing position of buildings and structures on the site in relation to public road(s). 3. Photographs: representative black and white photos. if the photos are taken as part of a surrey for which the Society is to be curator of the negatives or color slides, a photo /catalog sheet needs to be included with the negatives/slides and the following needs to be provided below on this particular Inventory ite: Roll /slide sheet #f 12866 Frame /slot # 20. 22 Date Taken 4/12004 Roll /slide sheet # Frame /slot # pate Taken Roll/slide sheet # Frame /slot # Date Taken HSee Continuation sheet or attached photo slide .catalog sheet for list of photo roll or slide entries. Photosfillustrations without negatives are also in this site inventory fie. FOR CERTAIN KINDS OF PROPERTIES, INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING AS WELL 1. Farmstead & District: (List of structures and buildings, known or estimated year built, and Contributing or non - contributing status)` 2. Sam; a. A sketch of the frame/truss configuration in the form of drawing a typical middle bent of the barn. b. A photograph of the Loft showing the frame configuration along one side. c. A sketch floor elan of the interior space arrangements 012n8 with the ban's eAerior dimensions In feet State Historic Preservation Office jSHPO Use Only Below This tine Concur with above survey opinion on National Register eligibility: El Yes No Mbre Research Recommended This is a locally designated property or part of a locally designated district. Comments: Evaluated by (nama4itle): Date. Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs State Historical Society of Iowa Site Number 52 -02418 Iowa Site inventory Form Related District Number 62:14500 Continuation Sheet Page 1 Wiese. Albert & Augusta. House Johnson Name of Property County 211 Melrose Avenue ` lowa 94 Address city 7. Narrative Description This one -and - half -story single - family dwelling was built in 1900 according to Iowa City Assessor's Records, a date frequentiy used for older buildings when a more specific date is unknown. Johnson County Auditor's Property Transfer Records show the property separating from a larger parcel in 1910 when William and Grace Kettlewell sold the property to Albert J. Wiese for only $975, indicating that no house was yet on the property. In the city directory published in 1912, Albert Wiese was listed on the West Side (in 1911 and earlier years he was listed elsewhere in lows City), and in later directories was living at 711 Melrose Avenue. Together this information suggests that the house was built sometime between 1910 and 1911. This frame dwelling is an example of a "Front -Gable Roof" form that was commonly used for vernacular residences in the late 19 and early 2& centuries in Iowa City. It has a broad front -gable roof with gable wall dormers positioned as cross- gables on the east and west sides. A low - pitched hipped roof porch extends across the full front. The main roof has cornice returns in the gables and in the dormers. The foundation is parged stone or concrete block and the walls are presently clad in marrow vinyl siding with the original cornerboard and beitcourse detailing clad in a contrasting color. The porch has square columns at the outer comers and at the entrance opening resting on the closed balustrade that is clad in vinyl siding. Storm sash have been installed above the balustrade but the entrance step area remains open. Windows throughout the building are 1/1 double - hung sash with the bay window on the second floor centered beneath the front gable the most prominent opening. Though the pattern of beitcourses suggests that a contrasting material ``such as shingles may have been employed in the gable ends, the current owners indicate that wood siding is the only material present. At the rear of the Wiese House is the property's original two -story frame barn. It has a side -gable roof with a steep pitch and, like the house, is set on a parged foundation, It retains its original board- and - batten wood siding and an original or early standing - sepal metal roof. Access for vehicles is through sliding by -pass doors on the north side with a hinged passage door on the same side. The passage door is of vertical board construction and the by -pass doors have a board- and -batten finish, The hay door is located on the east and of the north side. Both of the gable ends have multi -tight windows. A passage door is also located on the south side with a patched opening also present on this side. The barn still retains its original dirt tloor. 'the Wiese barn is the only surviving barn in the District, which originally had severs, such outbuildings located along Melrose Avenue. A concrete slab for a chicken coop (nonextant) is located alongside the east property line slightly south of the barn. The house lot is generally level along Melrose Avenue with large shade trees and mature shrubs dotting the yard and along the foundation. The carriage barn, which is positioned along the rear property line southwest of the house is connected to Melrose Avenue by a narrow drive along the west side of the house. & Statement of Slanificance This house is a moderately preserved example of a vernacular house known as the "Front -Gable Roof' form. Construction of this house was likely associated with the population growth after the turn of the 20th century and the annexation of the West Side that occurred in 1910. The mouse is eligible for the National Register under Criteria A and C as a contributing structure to the Melrose Historic District. The carriage barn is a well-preserved example of a two -story bam and the only extant one in the district. The Melrose Historic District itself is locally significant under Criteria A and C. Under Criterion B the District has both local and state level significance. Under Criterion A, the District derives significance from its association with an important era of residential development from the 1920s -1950s along and south of Melrose Avenue adjacent to the State University of Iowa (SUI) West Side Campus. Its greatest growth in the 1920s and 1930s was associated with the establishment of the SUi hospitals and the creation of facilities for SUI's athletic programs. The mixture of small and large lots available in various additions and subdivisions encouraged a similar mix of both affordable and upscale housing. These lots provided ideal home sites in the Melrose Historic District for the staff and faculty of the SUI'hospitals and athletic programs who needed housing during this period. Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs State Historical Society of Iowa Iowa Site Inventory Form Continuation Sheet Page 2 Site Number 52-02418 Related District Number 52 -04590 ►venue Iowa City Under Criterion B the Melrose Historic District derives significance from its association with important Iowa City residents and a number of prominent SUI faculty members whose contributions were on the state and national level. Each of these individuals resided in the Melrose Historic District during the times that they made their main contributions to their respective fields. Under Criterion C the Melrose Historic District is significant as a representative collection of the architectural styles and vernacular house forms that primarily appeared in Iowa City neighborhoods beginning in; the period before World War I and continued through the post - World War Ii era. The juxtaposition of a dozen different architectural styles and house forms for single- family dwellings, duplexes, and a large apartment building testes to the architectural diversity of the District, The District demonstrates both the organic development practices seen when a rural neighborhood becomes absorbed into an urban area and the developer- homebuiider practices seen in an early automobile suburb developed. between World War i and li. A discussion of the development of this property is summarized in Richard Carlson's study of early Melrose Avenue houses. The passage below explains the possible scenarios for the construction of the house: "A 0.8 -acre parcel containing the site of the present house was separated from a larger parcel in 1910. It " was sold by William and Grace Kettlewell to Albert J. Wiese for only $975, indicating that no house was yet on'the property. Albert Wiese was listed in city directories on the West Side starting in 1912 -1913 (in 191'1 and earlier years he was fisted elsewhere in Iowa City), and was living on Melrose Avenue by the time of the 1918 city directory. The house was thus probably built for the Weses between 1510 and 1912." As Carlson notes, the Kettlewells sold the property for this house to Albert J. Wiese in 1910. At the time Wiese worked as a concrete mixer for Michael Vilihauer, a local manufacturer of concrete block. Wiese's three adult children resided with him and his wife Augusta In the residence at 1111 Rochester Avenue. He apparently retired the next year while their house was -being constructed and by 1912 city directories list him as a re red farmer residing on the West Side along with his family. In 1914 Wiese returned to employment as a cement contractor. The Wieses continued at this address until ca. 1935 when Albert died. He alternately worked as a laborer and a • +.v rr.vvr • sw continued to reside here until the early 1940s along with several of theircWdren including William O.E. who worked for a time as a watchman at the SUI Armory (1920s) and Holding (Holden) who worked as ,a clerk at the SUI Hospital. Holdine acquired the house from Augusta in April 1940 and continued to reside here by herself until the early 1950s. By 1958 she had married and city directories show the house occupied by Edward and Holdine (Wiese) Munkhoff. The couple continued here during their retirement in 1967, the cut -off date for city directory research for this survey. Current owners of the Weise House, Pat and George Turecek, have lived here since ca. 1970. George worked at Moore Business Forms for 44 years and retired in 2001. He spent the first five years at Moore's in shipping, then about 35 years as a plate maker, transferring printing to platevia negatives, and then the last years as a press operator. His wife Pat worked about ten years at the register in the UI Hospital Cafeteria and left in 1983. She also was supervisor in the lunch room of Lucas Elementary School for 10 years, retiring in 2000. The couple raised seven children while residing at 711 Melrose Avenue. 9. Maior Sibli(OMMORhic References Iowa City city directories. Iowa City Assessor's Records. Property Transfer Records, Johnson County Auditor's Office. Sanbom maps, 1920, 1926, 1933, 1933 updated to 1944, and 1933 updated to 1970. Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs State Historical Society of Iowa Site Number 52 -02418 Iowa Site Inventory Form Related District Number 52-04500 Continuation Sheet Paqe 4 Wiese, Albert & Augusta House Johnson Name of Property County 711 Melrose Avenue Iowa City Address City PhgWgraph P.O. BOX 607638 • ORLANDO, FL 32860 • (407) 886 -3100 INSERT EMULSION SIDE DOWN STYLE O. 57 -1 ARCHIVAL PRESERVERS DATE: ASSIGNMENT: DATF. ASSIGNMENT: - __ FILE NO: Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs State Historical Society of Iowa Site Number 52 -02418 Iowa Site Inventory Form Related District Number 52 -04500 Continuation Sheet Wiese. Albert & Augusta House Johnson Name of Property County 711 Melrose Avenue Iowa City Address City Photograph P.O. BOX 607638 • ORLANDO. FL 32860 -14071886-3100 INSERT EMULSION SIDE DOWN _. 4` 1 NO. $7.-} ARCHIVAL PRESERVERS DATE: ASSIGNMENT - -.__ FILE NO: Iowa Department of Cultural Affairs State Historical Society of Iowa Site Number 52-p2418 Iowa Site inventory Form Related District Number 52 -04500 Continuation Sheet Page 3 Carlson, Richard. "Early History of douses at 303 -741 Melrose Avenue," unpublished research study for Melrose Neighborhood Survey Project, April 28 —May 3, 2004. Interview with Pat and George Turecek, owners of 711 Melrose Avenue, by Jean Walker, August 2004.. Additional 'Documentation Full 'Legal Description: W 66' of E 132' of N 617' of Lot 4 Custer's Subdivision, in 16 -79-6. Sketch Map of Melrose Historic District rI MELROSE AVE 74 t ( 727 n r r (629 604 607 , i 601,E 521 ± 511 503 �� 4� 315 304 303 a7 - _ ISS 215` 13.14I�•.1 2 219`; 223 ti -- 229 228 32 123 10 � � 1 ..24 � 0 3 233 300 + it 8 W 4 .1 T 303 302 7 I 5 { 304 332 6 4 322 306 3 _.: ' 1 300 313' 308 335 i 321 ; r 310 4251 t 318 50,6 400 626 �^ j i 311 { 326 I` C3 516 l..- J-., - � PARK R �; -2 ' 625. 611 v° aat ao ; jaoz aoa7 n j�p 408 2 F f 404 t 410 I U s_7 6 r ,_ ;aj 412 421 422 3� .. _. Q tea I i 424 ! $08 i0 412 Y 408 402 316 308 0 -- -- ,. /� " (f j 521 vc�i v°, CREST ST N 501 �l 405 -_,0- -off Q J , n. � Prepared by: Sarah Walz, Associate Planner, 410 E. Washington Street, Iowa City, ORDINANCE NO. AN ORD ANCE VACATING A PORTION OF THE MELROSE PLACE LOCATED DJACENT TO LOTS 1 -8, MELROSE PLACE, IOWA CITY, 10 tEET RIGHT -OF -WAY (VAC12- 00001) WHEREAS, the applicant, The University of Iowa Board of Regents, wns certain contiguous lots surrounding the Melros Place cul -de -sac, upon which there are presently loca ed single family homes; and WHEREAS, the Uni rsity desires to construct a surface parking lot ove and across these lots, as well as over and across a port-S-1 of the Melrose Place right -of -way; WHEREAS, the Universe has therefore requested that the City vacat and convey to it that portion of the Melrose Place street right -o way located adjacent to its property; and WHEREAS, that portion req fired to be vacated will no longer serve public purpose if the University- owned houses are demolished, alth ugh a public access easement shou be retained to provide appropriate traffic circulation for the public nee associated with the remaining mes along the remaining Melrose Place right -of -way; and WHEREAS, the University has agreed certain conditions r of the proposed parking area in order to mini ize impacts on the WHEREAS, vehicle access to the parking kt from Melrose P traffic control concerns at the intersection of Melr a Place and H; WHEREAS, the University will improve the re ining public the street with paving and curb and gutter, a 4 -foot si 1n main improvements, and management of stormwater; WHEREAS, it is in the City's interest to vacate and d are no longer necessary for public access, and WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission way subject to conditions mentioned above. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE IOWA: SECTION I. VACATION. The City of Iowa City her right -of -way shown on the attached Vacation Exhibit and( r oing the design, screening, and lighting unding residential neighborhood; and will be a one -way entry only to mitigate ins Drive; and t -of -way, including the reconstruction of sewer abandonments as needed, water of public right -of -way, or portions thereof, that vacation of a portion of this right -of- L OF THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, the portion of the Melrose Place street lQed as follows: PART OF THE MELROSE PLACE RIGHT -OF -W Y AND THE PUB IC RIGHT -OF -WAY ADJACENT TO LOTS 6 AND 7 FROM SAID M ROSE PLACE RIG \ASLLOWS: OF-WAY TO THE IOWA INTERSTATE RAILROAD (FORMERLY C.R.I. P. R.R.) AS DEFINEE FINAL PLAT OF MELROSE PLACE, JOHNSON COUNTY, 10 A RECORDED IN BOAGE 292, PLAT RECORDS OF JOHNSON COUNTY, IOWA URTHER DESCRIBED BEGINNING AT THE NORTHEAST COR R OF SAID LOT 7; THENCE N89 14'43 "E ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF LOT 8 OF SAID M I SE PLACE, 10.00 FEET TO TH SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LOT 8; THENCE NO °19'15 "W ALONG THE EAST LINE OF ID LOT 8, 59.02 FEET; THENCE N86 040'45 "E, 30 0 FEET; THENCE NO3 019'15 "W ALONG LINE PARALLEL AND 30.00 FEET DISTAN TO THE EST RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE OF M LROS W E PLACE, 193.10 FEET; THENCE N89 2'47 "E, 20.03 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CO NER OF LOT 1 OF SAID MELROSE PLACE; HENCE S03 019'15 "E ALONG THE WEST LINE O OTS 1, 2, 3, AND 4 OF SAID MELROSE P ACE, 253.36 FEET TO THE SOUTHWEST CORNER F SAID LOT 4; THENCE N89 014'43' ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID LOT 4, 10.00 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER O LOT 5 OF SAID MELROSE PLACE; THENCE S03 °19'21 "E ALONG THE WEST LINE OF AID LOT 5, 60.00 FEET TO THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LOT 6; THENCE S89 014'50" ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF SAID LOT 6, 56.09 FEET TO THE SOUTHEASTERLY LINE 0 SAID PUBLIC RIGHT -OF -WAY; THENCE S43 018'02 "W ALONG b C111— 52240-,'319---356-A 39 tEET RIGHT -OF -WAY (VAC12- 00001) WHEREAS, the applicant, The University of Iowa Board of Regents, wns certain contiguous lots surrounding the Melros Place cul -de -sac, upon which there are presently loca ed single family homes; and WHEREAS, the Uni rsity desires to construct a surface parking lot ove and across these lots, as well as over and across a port-S-1 of the Melrose Place right -of -way; WHEREAS, the Universe has therefore requested that the City vacat and convey to it that portion of the Melrose Place street right -o way located adjacent to its property; and WHEREAS, that portion req fired to be vacated will no longer serve public purpose if the University- owned houses are demolished, alth ugh a public access easement shou be retained to provide appropriate traffic circulation for the public nee associated with the remaining mes along the remaining Melrose Place right -of -way; and WHEREAS, the University has agreed certain conditions r of the proposed parking area in order to mini ize impacts on the WHEREAS, vehicle access to the parking kt from Melrose P traffic control concerns at the intersection of Melr a Place and H; WHEREAS, the University will improve the re ining public the street with paving and curb and gutter, a 4 -foot si 1n main improvements, and management of stormwater; WHEREAS, it is in the City's interest to vacate and d are no longer necessary for public access, and WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission way subject to conditions mentioned above. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE IOWA: SECTION I. VACATION. The City of Iowa City her right -of -way shown on the attached Vacation Exhibit and( r oing the design, screening, and lighting unding residential neighborhood; and will be a one -way entry only to mitigate ins Drive; and t -of -way, including the reconstruction of sewer abandonments as needed, water of public right -of -way, or portions thereof, that vacation of a portion of this right -of- L OF THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, the portion of the Melrose Place street lQed as follows: PART OF THE MELROSE PLACE RIGHT -OF -W Y AND THE PUB IC RIGHT -OF -WAY ADJACENT TO LOTS 6 AND 7 FROM SAID M ROSE PLACE RIG \ASLLOWS: OF-WAY TO THE IOWA INTERSTATE RAILROAD (FORMERLY C.R.I. P. R.R.) AS DEFINEE FINAL PLAT OF MELROSE PLACE, JOHNSON COUNTY, 10 A RECORDED IN BOAGE 292, PLAT RECORDS OF JOHNSON COUNTY, IOWA URTHER DESCRIBED BEGINNING AT THE NORTHEAST COR R OF SAID LOT 7; THENCE N89 14'43 "E ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF LOT 8 OF SAID M I SE PLACE, 10.00 FEET TO TH SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LOT 8; THENCE NO °19'15 "W ALONG THE EAST LINE OF ID LOT 8, 59.02 FEET; THENCE N86 040'45 "E, 30 0 FEET; THENCE NO3 019'15 "W ALONG LINE PARALLEL AND 30.00 FEET DISTAN TO THE EST RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE OF M LROS W E PLACE, 193.10 FEET; THENCE N89 2'47 "E, 20.03 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CO NER OF LOT 1 OF SAID MELROSE PLACE; HENCE S03 019'15 "E ALONG THE WEST LINE O OTS 1, 2, 3, AND 4 OF SAID MELROSE P ACE, 253.36 FEET TO THE SOUTHWEST CORNER F SAID LOT 4; THENCE N89 014'43' ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID LOT 4, 10.00 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER O LOT 5 OF SAID MELROSE PLACE; THENCE S03 °19'21 "E ALONG THE WEST LINE OF AID LOT 5, 60.00 FEET TO THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LOT 6; THENCE S89 014'50" ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF SAID LOT 6, 56.09 FEET TO THE SOUTHEASTERLY LINE 0 SAID PUBLIC RIGHT -OF -WAY; THENCE S43 018'02 "W ALONG b C111— Ordinance No. Page 2 SAID SOUTHEASTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE, 86.54 FEET TO THE NORTHEASTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE OF SAID IOWA INTERSTATE RAILROAD; THENCE N49 045'32 "W ALONG SAID NORTHEASTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE, 10.01 FEET TO THE NORTHWESTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE OF SAID PUBLIC RIGHT -OF -WAY; THENCE N43 018'02 "E ALONG SAID NORTHWESTERLY RIGHT -OF -WAY LINE, 77.40 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LOT 7; THENCE N03022'1 2"W ALONG THE EAST LINE OF SAID LOT 7, 60.00 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING CONTAINING 0.27 ACRES (11,876 SQ.FT.) MORE OR LESS. SUBJECT TO EXITING EASEMENTS AND RESTRICTIONS OF RECORD. All ordinances and parts of ordinances in Ordinance are hereby SECTION III. SEVER AB ITY. If any section, provision or part of the Ordi . invalid or unconstitutional, suc adjudication shall not affect the validity of the section, provision or part thereof t adjudged invalid or unconstitutional. SECTION IV. EFFECTIVE DA E. This Ordinance shall be in effect after publication, as provided by law. Passed and approved this of MAYOR: Matt Hayek ATTEST: CITY CLERK Approved by ,, d � tK � at, City Attorney's Office 1/ //Z Z 2012. with the provision of this e shall be adjudged to be inance as a whole or any final passage, approval and 1 VACATION EXHIBIT I �p N8 9`14'43"E Prepared R. Rodney Klien Anderson -Bogert Engineers & Surveyors, Inc. N 1 River Ridge Dr. N.E. Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52402 0 60 tans: FEET AND 1 p5.S D� - -- — EA�w �Lgk9al e`edpti I P.O.S. n. PART OF THE MELROSE PUCE RNk1T -2F WXT M1D ME l!C 2. WARIMS HEREON ARE BASED RGHT -OF -NAY AD.MCENT TO LOTS 6 AND 7 F/DII SAID — — — — UPON IOWA STATE PLANE HAD 63 MOAO$E PE -GY TD 7AS IOWA N RIIER$G7 RIGHT -OF- SOUTH E- RAIAOU AF (FORM A DEFINED BY FINAL PW OF MFIROSE PACE..IONINSON CWNIY, DIM R m PROPOSE R.o.W. CITY CITY WW NtRT7DlSC6R�E0 As :oF JONIGON FND 3/B' IR A THENCE 16'02^4 MONO SAID SOUTHEASTERLY BEGINNING AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID LO 7: 9'32'47'E VACATED THENCE N69'1143"E ALONG ME SOUR" LINE OF 5 OF 20.03' RIGIr -OF WAY LINE" 66.54 FEET TO THE NORTHEASTERLY RIGHT- -WAY LINE OF SAID IOWA INTERSTATE RARAOAO; SAID MELROSE PLACE, IDAD FEET ro ME OORNER OF SAID LOT a; I LOT 7 THENCE NOYIS'15'W ALONG THE EAST LINE SAD LOT a. N68'40'45� 59.02 FEET: THE WW4Y32'w ALONG SAID NORTHEASTERLY -- — — — — — — — THENCE N6a'40'45'[ 30.00 FEET; LOT 1 THENCE NOY19'15'W ALONG A LIKE AND 30.00 FEET FI DISTANT TO THE WEST RIGHT -OF -RAT Di MELROSE PLACE, N-N 193.10 FEET. \ \ FEET THE NORTHWEST CORNER THENCE iIRWOF '47 MELROSE OF Lffr N GJ���p� rrw11 — — — — — — THENCE SOY19.15'E ALONG REST LINE OF LOTS 1. 2 3. y a - — AND 4 OF SAID MEXROSE 25336 FEET ro THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF 4: x. LOT Z THENCE NeP14.43"E THE SOUTH LINE OF YD tAT 4. ��O-•�II (� 10.00 FEET P ro THE CORNETT OF LOT 5 OF SAID MELROSE PUCE, 1 \ T•G7T]a+] n a LOT 2 Q a, a THENCE 503'19'21 ALONG THE REST UNE OF SAID LOT 5. �• x- 60.00 FEET TO NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAD LOT 6: h ,7 E I �p N8 9`14'43"E N THENCE N 6. 10 L`� — - -- - -- — a I P.O.S. n. 56.09 FEET THE SOUTHEASTERLY UNE OF SAID PUBLIC — — — — 0.27 ACRES RIGHT -OF- .n.. I- PROPOSE R.o.W. Q " 2°j THENCE 16'02^4 MONO SAID SOUTHEASTERLY LOT 9 VACATED QCF' LOT 3 RIGIr -OF WAY LINE" 66.54 FEET TO THE NORTHEASTERLY RIGHT- -WAY LINE OF SAID IOWA INTERSTATE RARAOAO; ¢ S m- I LOT 7 N68'40'45� THE WW4Y32'w ALONG SAID NORTHEASTERLY ^ S691 t4 50 30.00' -OF -WAY HIE" I0A1 FEET TO THE NORTHWESTERLY -OF -WAY Le1E OF SAID PUKE RIGHT -OF -WAY; � \ \ I FND 1/2- \ JI REBM 1 CA N4YIa'02'E ALONG SAID NORTHWESTERLY LOT 1 \ 3 — — — — — — — — - -OF -WAY LING 77.40 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER U 10.01' — — — — I C OF LOT 7; q FNO 5/6' I I D n NO3'22'12YN KONG THE EAST LINE OF SAID LOT 7. 60,80 TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING CONTAINING 0.27 j I" LOT 8 NW s Al LOT 4 ACRES (1 •676 SO.FT.) MORE OR LESS. N I �! 4 i 3 N69"1443"E SUILIECT T EXISTING EASEMENTS AND RESTRICnONS OF RECORD. .11 E I �p N8 9`14'43"E 1000" 10 L`� — - -- - -- — a I P.O.S. n. tOTAL AREA: I 0.27 ACRES .n.. (11,876 so.Fr.) LOT 5 O I LOT 7 NV S691 t4 50 FIND kBOLT 36.09' \ \ NV \ \ CA LOT 1 \ 3 N4745'32 -W U 10.01' I C \ FNO 5/6' I I D \ E ti- -- -- - - - - -- — 4, In 0 0 .11 Ltgend 3 Boundary Una V Adjoining Lot line — — — — 04 Section Line Building Setback Line. • ............. C4 Found Iron Pipe (Unless Noted) e Found 5/6" Rebor % w /Red Cap 016546 Set % "X30' Rebor ° V w /Orange Cop /16646 jSet Section /Ouarter Comer A Found Section /Quarter Corner ~ Measured (M) Recorded (R) .TIOhT,MAP (N.T.S.) I��1 z a m W CYO N � h w m U Iii g�a a � "0 ) z o OC y W ih-t Nn E 01 I W chi Marian Karr From: Jean Walker <walkersic @yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 01, 2012 9:58 AM To: Marian Karr Cc: Jean Walker Subject: For the City Council Marian, I would appreciate if you would give this message to the Council members for this evening's meeting. Thanks, Jean Dear Council Members, If you decide to vacate Melrose Place to the University of Iowa, we ask that you request the UI to name their planned parking lot there "Melrose Place parking lot" in addition to their lot number, to preserve some of the history of that part of the Melrose Neighborhood. Thank you, Jean Walker Melrose neighborhood representative 335 Lucon Drive Iowa City Sent from my iPad 7 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ON A RESOLUTION OF INTENT TO CONSIDER THE PROPOSED CONVEYANCE OF A CONCRETE FLUME DRAINAGE EASEMENT IN THE VACATED ALLEY NORTH OF LOTS 10 AND 11, MANVILLE HEIGHTS ADDITION, IOWA CITY, IOWA TO ALL TAXPAYERS OF THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, IOWA, AND TO OTHER INTERESTED PERSONS: Public notice is hereby given that the City Council of the City of Iowa City, Iowa, will conduct a public hearing on its intention to convey a concrete flume drainage easement to Parish Apartments, L.L.C. at 7:00 p.m. on the 1st day of May, 2012, said meeting to be held in the Emma J. Harvat Hall in the City Hall, 410 E. Washington Street in said city, or if said meeting is cancelled, at the next meeting of the City Council thereafter as posted by the City Clerk. Said resolution and easement agreement are now on file in the office of the City Clerk in the City Hall in Iowa City, Iowa, and may be inspected by any interested persons. Any interested persons may appear at said meeting of the City Council for the purpose of making objections to and comments concerning said plans, specifications, contract or the cost of making said improvement. This notice is given by order of the City Council of the City of Iowa City, Iowa and as provided by law. MARIAN K. KARR, CITY CLERK NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given that the City Council of Iowa City will hold a public hearing on May 1, 2012, at 7:00 p.m. in the Emma J. Harvat Hall of the Iowa City City Hall, 410 E. Washington Street, Iowa City, Iowa, or if said meeting is cancelled, at the next meeting of the City Council thereafter as posted by the City Clerk; at which hearing the Council will consider a Resolution approving a purchase agreement between the City of Iowa City and Robert and Doris Swartzendruber for auditor's parcel 2011092, consisting of approximately .99 acres, located immediately to the South of their home, adjacent to the Iowa City landfill, and to consider a proposal to convey said property. Copies of the proposed resolution are available for public examination in the office of the City Clerk, City Hall, Iowa City, Iowa. Persons wishing to make their views known for Council consideration are encouraged to appear at the above - mentioned time and place. MARIAN K. KARR, CITY CLERK NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ON PLANS, SPECIFICATIONS, FORM OF CONTRACT AND ESTIMATED COST FOR POLICE AND FIRE DEPARTMENT INTERIOR REMODELING PROJECTS 2012 IN THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, IOWA TO ALL TAXPAYERS OF THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, IOWA, AND TO OTHER INTERESTED PERSONS: Public notice is hereby given that the City Council of the City of Iowa City, Iowa, will conduct a public hearing on plans, specifications, form of contract and estimated cost for the construction of the Police and Fire Department Interior Remodeling Projects 2012 in said City at 7:00 p.m. on the 1st day of May, 2012, said meeting to be held in the Emma J. Harvat Hall in City Hall in said City, or if said meeting is cancelled, at the next meeting of the City Council thereafter as posted by the City Clerk. Said plans, specifications, form of contract and estimated cost are now on file in the office of the City Clerk in City Hall in Iowa City, Iowa, and may be inspected by any interested persons. Any interested persons may appear at said meeting of the City Council for the purpose of making objections to and comments concerning said plans, specifications, contract or the cost of making said improvement. This notice is given by order of the City Council of the City of Iowa City, Iowa and as provided by law. MARIAN K. KARR, CITY CLERK l� Publish 4/23 NOTICE OF MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, STATE OF IOWA, ON THE MATTER OF THE PROPOSED ISSUANCE OF NOT TO EXCEED $6,000,000 WATER REVENUE BONDS, SERIES 2012C OF THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, AND THE HEARING ON THE ISSUANCE THEREOF PUBLIC NOTICE is hereby given that the City Council of the City of Iowa City, State of Iowa, will hold a public hearing on the 1 st day of May, 2012, at 7:00 o'clock P.M., in the Emma J. Harvat Hall, City Hall, 410 E. Washington, Iowa City, Iowa, at which meeting the City Council proposes to take additional action for the issuance of not to exceed $6,000,000 Water Revenue Refunding Bonds, Series 2012C, of the City. The bonds will not constitute general obligations or be payable in any manner by taxation, but will be payable from and secured by the net revenues of the Municipal Water Utility. The bonds are proposed to be issued for the purpose of paying costs of the refunding of outstanding Water Revenue Bonds, Series 2002, dated November 1, 2002. At the above meeting oral or written objections from any resident or property owner of the City to the above action shall be received. After all objections have been received and considered, the Council will at the meeting or at any adjournment thereof, take additional action for the issuance of the bonds or will abandon the proposal to issue the bonds. This notice is given by order of the governing body as provided by Section 384.83 of the City Code of Iowa. Dated this 23rd day of April, 2012. s/Marian K. Karr City Clerk, City of Iowa City, State of Iowa (End of Notice) IZ Publish 4/23 NOTICE OF MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF IOWA CITY, STATE OF IOWA, ON THE MATTER OF THE PROPOSED ISSUANCE OF NOT TO EXCEED $7,950,000 GENERAL OBLIGATION BONDS, SERIES 2012, (FOR AN ESSENTIAL CORPORATE PURPOSE) OF THE CITY, AND THE HEARING ON THE ISSUANCE THEREOF PUBLIC NOTICE is hereby given that the City of Iowa City, State of Iowa, will hold a public hearing on the 1 st day of May, 2012, at 7:00 o'clock P.M., in the Emma J. Harvat Hall, City Hall, 410 E. Washington, Iowa City, Iowa, at which meeting the Council proposes to take additional action for the issuance of not to exceed $7,950,000 General Obligation Bonds, Series 2012, for an essential corporate purpose of said City, in order to provide funds to pay costs of the construction, reconstruction, and repair of public ways, sidewalks, overpasses, and pedestrian underpasses and overpasses; the opening, widening, extending, grading and draining of the right -of -way of streets, highways, avenues and public grounds and the removal and replacement of dead or diseased trees thereon; the construction, reconstruction, and repairing of any street improvements, bridges, culverts, and retaining walls; the acquisition, construction, improvement, and installation of street lighting fixtures, connections, and facilities; the acquisition, installation and repair of traffic control devices; the acquisition, construction, reconstruction, extension, improvement, and equipping of works and facilities useful for the collection and disposal of surface waters and streams; the reconstruction, extension and improvement of the existing Municipal Airport; the improvement of real estate for cemeteries and the construction, reconstruction and repair of cemetery facilities; the rehabilitation, improvement and equipping of existing city parks, including facilities, equipment and improvements commonly found in city parks; the equipping of the fire department; and the acquisition, construction, reconstruction, and improvement of all waterways useful for the protection or reclamation of property situated within the corporate limits of the city from floods or high waters, and for the protection of property in the city from the effects of flood waters, including the construction of levees, embankments, structures, impounding reservoirs, or conduits, as well as the development and beautification of the banks and other areas adjacent to flood control improvements. At the above meeting the Council shall receive oral or written objections from any resident or property owner of the City, to the above action. After all objections have been received and considered, the Council will at this meeting or at any adjournment thereof, take additional action for the issuance of bonds or will abandon the proposal to issue bonds. This notice is given by order of the City Council of the City of Iowa City, State of Iowa, as provided by Section 384.25 of the City Code of Iowa. Dated this 23rd day of April, 2012. s/Marian K. Karr City Clerk, City of Iowa City, State of Iowa (End of Notice) 05 -01 -12 I 12 The Council then considered the proposed action and the extent of objections thereto. Whereupon, Council Member introduced and delivered to the Clerk the Resolution hereinafter set out entitled "RESOLUTI INSTITUTING PROCEEDINGS TO TAKE ADDITIONAL ACTION FOR THE IS UANCE OF NOT TO EXCEED $7,950,000 GENERAL OBLIGATION BONDS, SE ES 2012 ", and moved: ._ that the Re \olution be adopted. to ADJOUR and defer action on the R to institute pro eedings for the issuance be held at o'clock N of , 2012, at this plaq Council Member called and the vote was, AYES: NAYS: Whereupon, the Mayor RESOLUTION ADDITIONAL TO EXCEED BONDS, SE the [ STITUTING PROC: CTION FOR THE IS ,950,000 GENERAL S2012 o tion and the proposal onds to the meeting to on the day the motion. The roll was adopted. INGS TO TAKE ,NCE OF NOT [ GATION WHEREAS, pursu nt to notice published as require y law, this Council has held a public meeting and hea ing upon the proposal to institute pr ceedings for the issuance of not to exceed $7,950 00 General Obligation Bonds, Series N12, for essential corporate purposes of aying costs of the construction, reconstruction, and repair of public ways, sidewal ; overpasses, and pedestrian underpasses and overpasses; the opening, widening, extending, grading and draining of the right -of -way of streets, highways, avenues and public grounds and the removal and replacement of dead or -3- diseased trees thereon; the construction, reconstruction, and repairing of any street improvements, bridges, culverts, and retaining walls; the acquisition, construction, improvement, and installation of street lighting fixtures, connections, and facilities; the acquisition, installation and repair of traffic control devices; the acquisition, construction, reconstruction, extension, improvement, and equipping of works and f cilities useful for the collection and disposal of surface waters and streams; the recons ction, extension and improvement of the existing Municipal Airport; the improvem t of real estate for cemeteries and the construction, reconstruction and repair of ce tery facilities; the rehabilitation, improvement and equipping of existing city park , including facilities, equipment and improvements common department; and the acquisition, constr waterways useful for the protection or: corporate limits of the city from floods in the city from the effects of flood wai embankments, structures, impounding and beautification of the banks and oth I ound in city parks; a equipping of the fire reconstructio and improvement of all lamation of prop v situated within the high waters, a for the protection of property , including ty construction of levees, areas and has considered the extent of objectio s recei to the proposed issuance of bonds; and, ac ordin considered to be in the best interests of the itvA NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOL CITY OF IOWA CITY, IOWA: / Section 1. That this Council does or c nduits, as well as the development a nt to flood control improvements, r y fr om residents or property owners as the following action is now id residents thereof: BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE tute proceedings and take additional action for the sale and issuance in the nl4nner req fired by law of 'not to exceed $7,950,000 General Obligation /Bn Series 201 for the foregoing essential corporate purpose. Section 2. To the extenhe projects or ctivities described in this resolution may be reasonably c to be included 'n more than one classification under Division III of the City owa, the Counci hereby elects the "essential corporate purpose" classificatiocedure with res ct to each such project or activity, pursuant to Section 38 he City Code of Io a. Section 3. This Resol tion shall serve as a declaratio of official intent under Treasury Regulation 1.150- and shall be maintained on file a a public record of such intent. It is reasonably exp cted that general fund moneys may e advanced from time to time for capital expenditur s which are to be paid from the proce s of the above Bonds. The amounts so advanced shall be reimbursed from the proceeds o the Bonds not later than eighteen months aft r the initial payment of the capital expendi res or eighteen months after the property is placed in service. Such advancements shall not exceed the amount authorized in this Resolution unless the same are for preliminary expenditures or unless another declaration of intention is adopted. -4- PASSED AND APPROVED this lst day of May, 2012. -5-