The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About05/12/2005 Historic Preservation Commission -----------~~'""'~". ,. ~~_H "":"".,"",,w,,,,, -,' ,-".Ä-_~,W" .", IOWA CITY HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Thursday, May 12, 2005 City Hall, 4to E. Washington Street Emma J. Harvat Hall 7:00 p.m. A. Call to Order B. Public discussion of anything not on the agenda C. Items for Consideration (vote required) Certificate of Appropriateness: a. 930 Iowa Avenue b. 520 Brown Street c. 503 Melrose Avenue d. 4 Bella Vista D. Other E. Adjourn -.- =__~_u _',,',,"'__' _ -w', '_. _._.~. "n " _i'. Ar ....Ucation for H istorie P , . . '"",,, -' . view } "~-d.:_ Application for alterations to the exterior of historic landmarks or properties located in a historic district or conservation district pursuant to Iowa City Code Section 14-4C. For Staff Use: Date submitted .....f1.i.jø...'b/ø.:.î................... Q Certificate of No Material Effect ~ Certificate of Appropriateness Q Major review Q Intermediate review Q Minor review Meeting schedule; The HPC meets the second Thursday of each month. During the summer months, the HPC may also meet on the fourth Thursday. Applications are due in the PCD Office by noon on Wednesday the week prior to the meeting. Applicant Information Property Information fÃ3.^ " \,1.11,\ ~/a't'<il Address of property ...7'1 .X;J.....~.\'}¿ct............%~;MA~...."........ '"'"T: n.'..!- ~'I'L E:i;¡;:;L A 0.- C: ("j .;..~.J:Hl)a:i..~;uL~u..,,~.t............w.=L......~~ZJ.t$2mt....................... Use of property ......f.($.(J..ç:Æl.~e................................................ Date constructed (if known) ..:fr.Ù?L..j-~.....L~lQ.O'................ (Please check primary contact person) )( Owner ....!P. .Q.r.~ct...~.~....w.o.1.sh............................. Phone .. (~l~l. .....ª~~(.:..çJ?J..~.O.......................................... Address ....q.j.Q......:.J.Q.JA.h:?....~v.!?..ûJ..~.................... .....:JQ.WfÃ....eiJ::t~.r.:I,A.......§.ª~.4.Q..~:$..~.Qg.. email................................................................................................. ........................................................................................................... Historic Designation o This property is a local historic landmark OR . ~ This property is located in the: o Brown Street Historic District . Q College Green Historic District o East College Street Historic District Q Longfellow Historic District o Summit Street Historic District o Woodlawn Historic District o Contractor ....................... ........................................................... Addres s ........ ..................... ..........,... ........~........ ......... ...... ................ Phone. .............. .......................... .,... ...... ......... ...... ... "'~"""""""""'" email................................................................................................. o Cons_ultant ...........................................~....................................... Address ........ ..... ......... ................. ..... ............................................... ....,...................................................................................................... Phone ...........................................................................................;... ............................................................................................................ o Clark Street Conservation District ~ College Hill Conservation District Q Dearborn Street Conservation District o Lucas-Governor Street Conservation District emaîl.........................................................................................,....... Application Rèquirements Attached are the following items: Within the district, this property is classified as: Q Contributing Q Noncontributing o Nonhistoric Q Site plan o Floor plans ¿ '6 køfch ') . Q Building elevations ~ Photographs Q Product information a Other .............................................................................. If the proposed project entails an addition, a new structure or a significant alteration to an existing structure, please submit a site plan. floor plans. building elevations and photographs. If the proposed project is a minor alteration to a structure, please provide drawings and photographs to sufficiently describe the scope of the project. Provide a written description of the proposed project on the second page of this application. . Project Type Q Alteration of an existing building (ie. siding and window replacement, skylights, window opening alterations, new decks. porch reconstruction, baluster repair or similar) o Addition to an existing building (indudes decks and ramps) Q Demolition of a building or portion of a building (ie. porch, chimneys, decorative trim, baluster or similar) o Construction of new building "" Repair or restoration of an existing structure that will not change its appearance Q Other , . -,- ________..._m~__ " M '" '" '" ==,~ ",,",',,",'"'' ,-,,- ,,"'- . i \~-,--- --'.--""" Project description .......Jhg.....~tde,......ev.i:r..1t......hßs.......~kLð.Y.Zt+~.~....W~. ... :1:0.....(1 e...a1L......Jt.1£.............. .....~ '" . . .......5Ld.i.ú9...år.J.&.....bxtr.:~s.,....~p.lace....~....wo.f!.~...aJ:'1~.....hr..tilij--...k:l:l.cl.. .........~.....o"......~e........ .k.....:5 .r.:<í?,../SLu(,!..fO.c.ch,.......................................................................................... ................................................................................................................,...................................................................................................................................... ..................,...."....".............................................,..............................,.,.........................,..................................................................,.........................,......'........... ................................................................................................,...................................................................................................................................................... ................................"................................................................................ .....................................................~............................................................................... ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... ....................................................,.................................................................................................................................................................................................. ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... .....................................................,.................................................................................................................~............................................................................... ............................................~...................~...............~...........~...~...................................a.a................................................................... ......................................................................................................~................................................................................................... ..........a..........................................................................................................................~.................................................................... . Materials to be used ,.., ...Jikec...... .. .... ..... ........6~«...... .......£..(&L~.................................................................................................. ...... .t......Cl~........!t.\)LY.td.~........(......" .... .~............................................................................................................ ~ # ~ . 1_# tf"¿nJ\" '" 1 ......~.....4............~...................................................................................,............................................................................................................................._........ , ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... ..........................................................................·....·......·.............................u................................................................................................................................. ........................................................................................................,............................................................................................................................................... ·················....·.................a........~....~.................................................................................................................................................... ················.·.·.·.............................a...................................................................................................................................................... Exterior appearance changes ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................~.....~......................................·.·.·..·....................."...,......................u........................................................................ ..·..·......·....·....··....·.......··.·.......·.......................a.............."............................................................................................................................................................... ···············.··.·.......................a............~..........~......~...................~......~................~................................................................................... ·············.···.~..·..~..................a.......~.......................~.............................................................................................................................. ·······.·....~..........a...........................~............................................................................................a................~.....~............~.................... ..........a··..·........~.................a...a......................................................................................................................~......~............................. ·~····~~~~····.····.···....~......................aa...a....................................................a..........~.........~.~............................................._......................... .............~...............~......................................a................................................................a..................................................a....aa.......~... a~................................~...........................a........a..................................................~............................................................................... ...~............................................,.........................a........a..................~.......a.............~........~.......................................................a....~..~.... ppdadm/HP HandbooklApp.p65 . I Ii I( (( I ( I! ¡ , // II ._-~---:::' ", I--L. N 1 T - o . - "" , 'i -._' cJ) "" º '" (t: W I (Ù.:f, \ z5i 00 - - . '" . I 0>-' W!:.:I "-',) ú:. -r . -7 ~ I .- ,-< ~- .~ .\ o.>:iC1i ",,-I ~ \ '" o :J:. -"-- .. $ ~ JI ~ ~ - u. 9 ç,<. ,¡ 1 '{l J'. N ~ "d; "1 ~ ~- Qt:I-;:::1/J \., L~ ~ ,rl',..,¡ -J~-tj. '" l> '>I. - Q,:.. . N.\!~.J --- I r ____ - --------._~--.._--, i 0") " ..,. , o '" ..~""".~._-~ ~"" o V> {) r ..... -t ~ J' ",I'» ~ ¿ " 1 ,', - ~~ .- '" ",.. "'J . ,,,,? s J '(; \1 J-1J - ..9 " ~ N,f. J1 J. J! ; ..,J ~ r.c ......-1' ~ 4 J j (> <Do;] ..1J '1 ct\ < '5 ~ d £-~ ¡;¡ > o , ::.- - _m___~_"~_...._.~ ..=.1........_.,._. , ~-. o Ñ .~ r- ? 3j - ~ .... 0;';- if. ,j ~ >.0 J'], __'___'m._m"__ --,.-'''_....,,-" ". , "':;'" ',' <~ ~ V ,.-to · · 0 .' r" , ,.........-,....' i I I ,.-"..- .,,' " .. T I ~ J' ir T· I:> {l, "'-L 1.0."': "'. ~...$ \I) · . , g:- ;., . I 1 t ¡ I I! N i-' · .JL ~__ i ~ 8 jI - u ? <II - <' 'a Z ,-,-,~-_._- _m'___nm'...m_'___"_"___" --"'--"-'--~. "_m____.__ . , , , Ie: -- - ':J' q. <0'h~ s . .. . i;;c..> '. ~'{, /'. :ì !,. =~:J , ~\ ~ Co' I "" I1..Jl¿11 '-' ; t.~ c?SJI ~ lLSU1, ~7=7' e.~~~~'~' ~~....---......--' -~",--=,-' t i t , , I , . o .' N I , i I I · · _.._--~---- -- ~ :¡¡. < - ..,,-'" i' ~ - 0 '" ..è'''J '"' "" J pJ i 1 ] ..;¡!:< ~ -LJ", < d,j <::!2. -::r > ~ .. ...¡ - ':': '¥ <:!J ;¡"" · , L.. I ---:-----~-"~'"--~.-~~-- c n____..._ -.........¡ '" ~ <.J Q - '" '" .. :-1 '1 , " '.., I\):.ß 1 c ... g ~' 1L 3 ::rOO "" 0 - " ." N Ã 0N t---·- -......- ," -", - .. . ---..--- ....-- .. I , . . . o , š - --"~- , "'__i_V'. -,~, -----..--1.. .. . , -,,- /1 II // ,- ;/ ;/ " -.. // 1/ I -. - o ., i0 .. "- ------,,-_. J~r" "1 ~;i .' _n____ -.--- ~""^-' ..--.._----~--- >I -_._~ -- -1' II , i , ¡ I ..____n.m__"____~ ."......,."".... -.--- ------"-",------.,_._~,.._._---- .- .~"..~..-- "" .. \..,o\c -..;-:;. '1 ;ìû ~ -'6 ~ ow_...~~g - J --- c . ,..e, ~~ q,.;_ -,.1J,;>J .V'I~· VI <I) «! 0 .~ ~ Q,;.. ",,?" - .~ 0 .::S ... ~ -\ i1 "-'7-.9 ..¡¡ .. ~r t" "3" "'1, , .. rJ á Ä I,..; ~;r¡J '" ~ "ï f' '" ~.:¡¡ \i'j'¡¡i .",,""-'" ~ "º VI:;;; 1· :l v & ð -.J .._--~~~".~.~,~~"._... ---"^- --- _·___u_ _ _ __..__....__..m~"..m.._.. """'~- . . or ,,' j;r- I - // ../ '" / '~,' () , - rC ---~~ J" i "..-- '"">,,,',j. - '~."',-"',,---..." -------~--- .~ " ^,'",,, -'''.,',"", '~"-'-' ""'~ , -,-" '"',",^ ~ ,~ ,~"""",-"" ,,', " ,"""'~'" ---"''-'-Ü'-- . " ,,-.-," '" . "'..''"""'¿",, -"-,'^>- --- _H ,M ~-"'"-"^"'''''''''''''''''- . , ________._~_.~"._'^'_____......'M_m~~ ~ ',,", ="- - Staff Report ~jstoric Review fQr 930 Iowa Avenue District: College Hill Conservation District Classification: Contributing May 05, 2005 Applicant, Gloria Walsh, is requesting approval of Certificate of Appropriateness for proposed alterations at 930 Iowa Avenue, a contributing property in the College Hill Conservation District The original structure was built with Greek Revival influence. Proposed work includes reconstruction of the small addition. The addition under consideration is on the side façade (East) set back from the street by about 50 feet. dnpliC<;Jble Regma~ons and G'!1i!ieli~e~: 4.0 Iowa City Guidelines for Alterations 4.4 Mass and RooDine 4.5 Siding 4.7 Windows 4,8 Door and 4.9 Porches 5.0 Iowa City Guidelines for Additions An addition to a historic house is often required to accommodate an expanding family, home office or modem lifestyle. These guidelines are for additions that expand the interior living space or building footprint, as well as for other attached structures such as new porches, decks and ramps. 5.1 Expansion of Building Footprint When planning an addition that expands the building footprint, consider first how a new exterior form and roof can be added to the existing house in a manner that is compatible with the design of the historic building. Often, the desired interior space dictates the location and size of the addition, and the resulting roofline and form appear awkward and inconsistent with the historic structure. The Historic Preservation Commission strongly recommends using a design professional to help evaluate space needs and plan a compatible addition. Additions to structures in districts must also comply with the guidelines in section 8.0 Neighborhood DÎ.ftrict Guidelines. Staff Comments The structure is a contributing two-story, originally built as a two-family (duplex) house, The structure appears to be a later addition and, overall, is in very bad condition, The applicant was notified by HIS to take action to make it safe and this restoration is intended to make the porch habitable and safe. This is essentially a room that might serve the function of an entry porch, Therefore guidelines in sections 4,5 Siding, 4,7 Windows and 4.8 Door and 5.0 for additions would be more appropriate, Also, sections 4.9 Porches, 4.4 Mass and Roofline would be helpful. With use of siding for façade treatment, the addition would be distinguished from the historic structure. Staff would like to recommend the use of wood or fiber cement board siding. Trim board of appropriate style, material and appearance should be used on the windows, doors and comers (in the past commission has recommended a trim of roin, 3'12'). The shed roof for the porch should use similar style of that on the house. Recommendations Staff recommends approval of Certificate of Appropriateness, provided 1) Wood or fiber cement board siding is used 2) Trim board of appropriate style, material and appearance is used on the windows, doors and comers; and 3) The roof is built appropriately to match the architectural style of the house. , -----------~_-^-"^=__'"-Ä,,''' ,,^_, "___^ . y~_/ '.~,->,,--'" _1" Application for Historic Review Application for alterations to the exterior of historic landmarks or properties located in a historic district or conservation district pursuant to Iowa City Code Section 14-4C. Meeting schedule: The HPC meets the second Thursday of each month, During the summer months, the HPC may also meet on the fourth Thursday, Applications are due by Wednesday the week prior to the meeting. For Staff Use: , () ~I tI ,'-' I At- Date submitted .........~ìð'~.~.....tr;þ..lf.f£~:;).~........... CJ ertificate of No Material Effect Certificate of Appropriateness U2f Major review Q Intermediate review Q Minor review Applicant Information Property Information (Please check primary contact person) Address of property ...S.2:~..~.tP.1~.~..$.1..~................................ [J Owner ....I~£0...~...1?9;±....~Eº.U..................................... .................................................................................................................. Phone ............................~........................................................... ..... , , , U f \:1::.'2;,¡clcrl"'"'CL, se 0 property.... .........................1... ,;. .th.... ..... ..... ..... ................. ..... ... Address ......Q.Z.º...Qr.Q;~1.\~L~.t.......................................... ......................l.(J.l~J.~...~~'.f.I,~.l....J..~....}~f~g.:r.~......H............... Date constructed (if known) ............................................................. email··..·········..·.......................................H...................................... ..............................\.qw.ß...~\±~..\......t~....gÆÆ.1::~.............. Historic Designation CJ This property is a local historic landmark OR ;t¡ This property is located in the: ):i1 Brown Street Historic District CJ College Green Historic District Q East College Street Historic District Q Longfellow Historic District Q Summit Street Historic District CJ Woodlawn Historic District )( Contractor ...::Þ..v.~.. .B.9.þ.¡!J~;\J.:1ò.J.~.r.j.. J..O~..,;.\....." ..,..." Address ..............~.º~...5±t:...~~!!f¿.......................................... Ph -:z.-:z.1 ~ D()<LL one... ..... .......... .~.,'N1 J...............;'J.:;;:~.............. ............... ............... email ...................:#;~.C.5.11..@.i.f~~;{~..:J;~:·t........................ o Consultant ...~.'..f..:..~..~9::tl.t................................................... Address ...........!æ.º..a.....s.±.!~...~'i.f?n.......................................... ............................l~~..~;t~~£&..>~...l~....~.;?~;t.S................ 4"', ~_" _ _ ,- ¡, ,,- ",-- - _'''if f '-ø, -'I, ('(- - :/:.- Ph 4}- ^ +', "" '" ,- , '-,/ '.- I" ,-' _ one ............. ....... ... ............'N ...';¡-~..................4....-... ......................... ......................................................................................................... CJ Clark Street Conservation District CJ College Hill Conservation District CJ Dearborn Street Conservation District CJ Lucas-Governor Street Conservation District Within the district, this property is classified as: .t!1 Contributing CJ Noncontributing CJ Nonhistoric email............................................................................................... Application Requirements Attached are the following items: i:I Site plan Ì!'J Floor plans i:I Building elevations .1a Photographs CJ Product information o Other ............................................................................ If the proposed project entails an addition, a new structure or a significant alteration to an existing structure, please submit a site plan, floor plans. building elevations and photographs. If the proposed project is a minor alteration to a structure, please provide drawings and photographs to sufficiently tjescribe the scope ofthe project. Provide a written description of the proposed project on the second page of this application. Project Type ~ Alteration of an existing building (ie. siding and window replacement, skylights, window opening alterations, new decks, porch reconstruction, baluster repair or similar) CJ Addition to an existing building (includes decks and ramps) 1:1 Demolition of a building or portion of a building (ie. porch, chimneys, decorative trim, baluster or similar) CJ Construction of new building Q Repair or restoration of an existing structure that will not change its appearance CJ Other ", " -'-,,"""':c/- Project description ...........R~fì.r:.i.~t!...!?7:'f\:?±.\0.J.....b,~f...rn.~,~jC)t.............................................,.................................................................................................. ......................................,......,......,.,........···...,·.~·...........,....n.............,.....,.........,............................,..,......,.......,.......,.................................. . " '," " " .............................................. ..................................................:.......,.........,..................,..,.,.....,..,.......,...........................................,.......,.....,....................,..,...,.. .. ' , ,.. ,..",.. '..,,',,' ............. ......................................... .................................................................,....,...,.......,.................,......,....................................................................,.......,..,.... ..... . ,','" "" '''', .... .............................................. ...................................................................,..~.....,.......,....................................................................,.,....................,... .. '. " ... ....... ................................................... .............................................................,........,.,....................................................................................,..,..........,..,............................................................................. ................................................................................,.......,.,.......,.......,................,.,.,......~.,..............,.....,..,.,......,.,......,.........,.,.......,.,..,................................................................... ..................................................................................,........,.....,............,...............,.............................,......,.....".......,..,.............................................................................. ..........................................................................,.........................,.................................................,.................,...........,.,....,................................................................ .............................................................,..,........,..........,......,.............,..........................................................,...................................................................................... ...............................................................,....,..,......,...,.,.............................................................................,.........,.......,.,.......,..,................................................................ ................................................,.,.'.........,....,.......................................................,..,.,...,........,..............,....,....,.,................................................ ........................................................,...............................~............................................,...,...............,.",.................................................... ..................................................,........~................,.........,....,.,.,.........,..,.....,..............................................,................................................... Materials to be used ...............S?l.~'~~~~.1....................................,.......................,.~.......,...................,..,.............................,......,......~...,...,..,..................................................................... WDcQi ..........................................................,.....,...,..,...,.,..........,......,.,.....'......,............,..................................,......,..,.......,..........,.........,.....,............................................................ .................r;;.~')J.~!~1&..............:.....H.....,.,.......,.........,.............'.......................................,...,............,......,....,..........,...,.....,....,.,..,.........,...,.................................................... . .. ................... ..................... ..... ... .. ........ ..... ......,..,.. ..,... ..... ....... . ..... ........ ..... ..... ..,..,., ...... .,.. ..,... ... ... .. ............. ... .... ......., ..,.'..,. .,.,...., ..,...~. ", ....... ...., ....... ........... ..... ..... ..... ..... .... .......................................................................,.,..,.,.....,.,..,...................,.......................,....,.......................................,....,.....,...,.........,....H.......,..,...............,....,.......................... ..................................................................................,......,.,...........,....'.............,...,...,................,......................,.........,........................................................................... .........................................................'.....................................................,.........,...,.......,.'..........,......,.......................................................... ...............................................................,..,....,.................................~..,...............,.,.....~..'......,......,............................................................. Exterior appearance changes ............... .. ... .. ... .. .................... ..... ,... .,....... .. ....,.,.. ...,~. ...... ..... ....,. ..... ~ .,.,. ..,.. ........... 'n ',' ...,.. ...............,. ... .. .,.... .,... .. ..,..',......,.... ..,..... .'.... ... ........ ..,... ........ ......................... ..... ..... ..... '"1h'£:\ ' -+hJL:r,r.+ '1\ be.. , . b ~'\\ 'I, \ t:,0 III,,'!! ......,..............,¡...,t.....W.\!......~...;:.;...........,.....-\ì....;,:.\!?.....0.,'.....,........ç,Ç?!,f.'Æ,......~Q...~~~.1.:i.............\.w.,~...I.hì~.0.Q!?)f./.".....~...,~..::I. \ \ ...................,:;:Jh4:r.e...~.kÙ.\.\......~....Q;n....'!?J.!~~.;'¡¡.';¡.......~!~.....\H,!.o.ç!,.Q.':\Ÿ.....~,~.L,..,j~....0.::~..~..,.,.y.\-!g!.!"..\&.iJ..I.."", , " ~ h .................b~,;{~....j::~,O~:;¡I;;çM;1.~~JM...~.¿;r:~::4.."'1..~.......illi\L..'£.D.\~\.cl,.....:I",....¥~.f!:'!...±..~....'S.t.H';;~,t........ ..............,~,I:~...~.!:~.~.....~;!:~.~..,:~....~~...J!\..,~::.!:ì.\<;>:)!:\.,...........,.,.,.........e."...............,."""...........,.............,.".,.,...... ~h, ........................................................,.........................,.........,.............,~..,.'...~.,....,.................."............,........'.,..................................................... ....................................................................................................................,.....,.....,......,.............,.....~'........,............................................ ........................,....................,...,.,.,...........,..,..........................,........,.........................................,.,.......,...,.,...'............................................,....... ......,.............~'.......,..,....,....,.........,.,....,.,....,...~..~...,...........,.,..............................,.,.,..,.....................,..,......,..,.........,......,...,......,.................................,...... ..,..........,...............,.......,.................................................,......,...........,.....,.......,........'......,.,.,.,.,....,..............,...........,...'........,.......................................... ........,.........................................................................................................................,...................................,.......................................... ~'---.-. ".,.-...._-_.~ ,n __._"~._.,,._._. _ _'. n,.. _, __, , fRAME ¡.JAR ~."-~~,. ~'~-="='"'=""---,,='" "-REMARí{5~-~~-"'--"--~' Mil 6TOP "1..001<. ---THiJ;W;llij¡{l~'¡;TT~ö -......-.......... --- --- I-1AR..CJit.' s _-2 M.Jc;~'-6ù5¡¡j'c;j" --I -t~-·-·- OW~~~~_~~ .~- ~I.N~~~~~_~-~"'l--- ~~J~~.- .._._ ".. '-' ---------- "------.--. -"---~" SC1-IËDULË -- ,- -='----~.~=-==:"._- - ~Dn1 f1q T 1I-!K MTl SALVA 0; E 15, 'Go- \i.~I:¡;¡''''' 1> .( ---,.-"-- ---.------"- -.-" - '-~---"-~,,_._---._. . ---- -- m,_._..__ m__'...___ ,____, __~.-- ~_" ~"'..--..v'---'''0',n'_~'.WM''~' 1"1;-,' <--J.\ , " >.. ." -------"'4 . ,.. VI'~ -r ' -r::.....", ''0- to:')[ ! ~.:J,·..A£-''''':-èl I I .. --___1 , . -' . .. ---i' -- -,,----.._"---_..... p:>oe 'Ä, -- -- ---.....-..~----... ---.."..- ~""-- ... ---r-fc" ---- Ë)!\5T1G- CR:t:.\J1L o¿:p;£.;c.E , : , '- -__""._ ____....,L..J.._ '" / C~JE\)J H€"TEG , <:Þ,Ic" ~""i<-¡ ',-- l.AIJHQ£."L JiODH .,...,. -ïl \00\&1'.-:.;;, i I I' .... , - I I I ","') ~'1"'- ~,',.,," [.< 'I "'''1v '.' Þ"_ ~.+- '. \)lAt.!.;; ,-0 ~:ENJ;.I!~,..~·t-~ ,', I , II=T il !I I: ¡ , ¡,.¡.,.'---~. ~>iJ... (f,¡ \/P"o.c., ! j \~/ r/()_7> Ci>Jj,l& , ! 1 I ~ ì r ¡ : I- . : j ~? I I: ~\1 ,-...."-- <;> ---T ! '''í\ -®''''\ '\~~ I I ¡æ¡J¡; I 2. It!!!·, .: , .J, J" \ "",' < --I li '-I, ¡Jr- , l! Ii .. ~¡ -' r"1~ \:1 c1~ r::;, ., - ...,. ,.. l ¡n I ":~ b..l1 5':/..'~ ¡'¡'iUt;. ') { ¡..--. \?AIi:"T\.1¡c¡,J , \ '- ~{~ !w~ D.C· ill ~.:~~\.~<L"_~~_~ _~~'~~_~\~~:,__ r... !ì,' "~~""'II '- ---- '".."<'1'" II :,1 . " A,[:>;,~,_,; . ',(1;1'-0" \.. \~hiJ;·- .. .. _. - . '''''L~r ~...:::'..\: ~,;i? '¡x4(;1¡) 1Li-"O,C. 1- 'If ~'&1D IiJ$U<'- ~ , lJt,.u 6lU6 1YP sq, ;;!.u..'ò ....L __ _ ~gi:f'J'A"tt'IIJI'Mµ, \ I .. , . 1 , \ '-/")µ",w \lõATW ttJl.k;, Þf.bOR:~__ . I &liúVE. '~~~~T\6: - I u)r;:}¡:~¥_ 81">.>'(;(.1 'TO- , ...\L0¡::'K OUL ",ooM ~FFLACE $(I$T'Ò" IUD'JJ @ C· t\f:w Ht,tqtQ ~öÜc fWO~ ~ , - -~ -~ .. CD . 1 I \ ..r I ...--\,- ----~ .. , , \ .. r.... 1 I !i 'H , , > '" , ~---------.._-- ¡,~iJí .. I,~IN~~ : 'I ilE""ACE.. 'I ~ Þ~\wrlt~_"-_,,"_H_"" \ jJ.JPw'·'--- _ ... "I __ , I 1 1 C0 1 i : I 1 '1 I : 'r" I-v- , j , Öl' , ~~ , .. ~ FAMILY 'ROQM WîìJwW ~ELL ·1 . _/-- .... 'j / ( , I I 1 , J , t- I , .. -. ,. .:';- -- -r- . ."'. ,'2--"..-::;:¿;;",~ : : "'-.-- ., ' ,- "-. ......... ,¡:;µl.Ag~6 _ . -'~\~T\éO WO\\i "f"1,),\.\(,----... ,bll)$T (~ ~$S ® "1"~ISi'C. \¡jÀ1~\1.. , NlISTISIL TO \\~MJ:,Ii-! ID: .. - "--.- ,,-,.- -." ,..",___,...:.:,·,.wo"..____--<-_____.._ ".. _" ..I --"."..--"'"--.~"--.'""-- ~-_.~--~~."...-._~-- ~--~--..,--.. --,,-~-_._------ -,<" fÎ' ~ 57..0 BR()(j)~ 5\QE,St 6t\~ EJAE WI flooR fl.t..\-j $CA1,:;E;: 1;;4" ~('-O}' . . mm__ -^^^,.. .'.""^"" ,-, -'-'f''-;''- ,,','" "',.',,' ^" ,__", __";'-;""_û,;;y_ " ..~- ~ "",,"V'.'.AAV'''' .,,'.' ""C ,....', ,¡,;";ù¡,,s.,~_> ;,,,",..",,AA,, ..ù..,''-'''''' -""" --. .., Staff Report May 05, 2005 Historic Review for 520 Brown Street District: Brown Street Historic District Classification: Contributing Applicants, Tom and Pat Carroll, are requesting approval of Certificate of Appropriateness for alterations at 520 Brwon Street, a contributing single-family house in the Brown Street Historic DÍstract. The original structure was built with the influence of Amerkan Four-Square style. The applicant has replacement a basement window (5' x 2') with an egress size window (5' x 4'-6"?). , Applic~bte Regulations ~.11d G.!!ídeliµ~s: 4.0 Iowa City Guidelines for Alterations 4.7 Windows Recommended: RBplaæment wincWwJ' · Replacing badly deteriorated windows with new ones that match the type, size, sash width, trim, use of divided-lights, and overall appearance of the histork windows, · Using new wood windows and sashes, if necessary, to replace historic wood windows and sashes, The use of metal- clad, solid-wood windows is acceptable, Replacement windows and trim must accept paint. Divided-lights may be created with muntin bars that are adhered to both sides of the glass, but not with snap-in muntin bars. · Replacing a bedroom window, if required for egress by the Building Code, with a new one that matches the size, trim, use of divided-lights, and overall appearance of the previous bedroom window or other windows in the house, New windowJ' · Adding windows that match the type, proportions, trim, and appearance of the historic windows. The sash width must be similar to that of the original windows. . Adding new windows in a location that is consistent with the window pattern of the historic building or buildings of similar architectural style. Disanowed: New and repJaæment wincWwJ' · Installing modem types of windows including sliding, awning, casement, and bay windows when they were not original to the building, consistent with the architectural style, or required for egress. · Installing metal, vinyl clad or vinyl windows when they were not original to the building, · Using snap-in muntin bars to achieve the appearance of divided-lights. Staff Comments Modem types of windows are disallowed per the guidelines with certain exceptions. Proposed window would be required to meet the egress conditions, which may justifY the use of sliding or casement window, In staffs view, replacement windows should simulate the appearance of current basement window or should be of similar style of other double hung windows on the house. On previous occasions of similar applications, the commission has approved casement windows where egress basement windows were proposed. The applicants have indicated that they would like to use vinyl window to avoid water seepage conditions in the basement walls. The staff would recommend use of wood or metal clad wood windows instead considering that the water problems will be addressed when the window well is constructed. Recommendations Staff recommends approval of Certificate of Appropriateness, provided the replacement windows are wood or metal-clad wood windows and simulate the appearance of other windows on the house. --------.... ,., ....""""^^^""",.,, ,-".-,^", ".'"m.. ^""--""~/ '..~/' I Application for Historic Review Application for alterations to the exterior of historic landmarks or properties located in a historic district or conservation district pursuant to Iowa City Code Section 14-4C. Meeting schedule; The HPC meets the second Thursday of each month. During the summer months, the HPC may also meet on the fourth Thursday. Applications are due by Wednesday the week prior to the meeting. For Staff Use: _ ....- "J ¡.J ~O'D Date submitted ..æ:"..:::..:/....................................... [J Certificate of No Material Effect ~·Certi~ficate of Appropriateness ~Major review [J Intermediate review [J Minor review Applicant Information Property Information ess of property ,ø:rÆ(./!..&ftff~~Lð~ ~~~ ~~ .....................~.................:~.~.~..~...................................f'!£'::.::,it!!!~.............. --" -- ;Z;.. ",q¿" . , ~ -- - - - ~ ........ ....... ....... ..... ........... ... .~~. ........ ...~......... ...~.. .~... ..... ..... ...;... ........ - - -- ~~.....~~!!.~.::~.~lft~@........~....... ......... ....... ..... ...........................................~......~.. ............ ..... .............. Histo ic Designation This property is a local historic landmark OR [J This property is located in the: [J Brown Street Historic District [J College Green Historic District [J East College Street Historic District [J Longfellow Historic District [J Summit Street Historic District [::I Woodlawn Historic District [J Clark Street Conservation District [J College Hill Conservation District [J Dearborn Street Conservation District [J Lucas-Governor Street Conservation District Q Contractor................,...........................................~....~............... Address ........ ..... ........................ ............~...........~.. ..~.... ....... ..... ....... Phone ...... ....... ....... ......... ... ..... ..~.................~.~.. '.......~..... ..... ....... ..... email............................................................................................... rfonsultant ...........................................~................-..................... Address .......,..........ØD .....................................---......-........................ ...........................~.~........~;.~.~'~.................... <Ø/ð_:::?6¿ -rr.L,/ Phone ...iM'!.~i¡,¡ln~uJ1l......................-..¥i!!!.¡'i:..~.::.................. ................~~fMfÆ;.......~...,.£..................~... email .......................... ..... '...... ..... ............ ..... ..... ............... ..........~~... Application Requirements Attached are the following items: ~te plan II!("""Floor plans I!f"Building elevations ~otographs iii'" Product information ~Other ..4~~!:.~~,..................... Within the district, this property is classified as: [J Contributing [J Noncontributing [J Nonhistoric If the proposed project entails an addition, a new structure or a significant alteration to an existing structure. please submit a site plan, floor plans. building elevations and photographs, If the proposed project is a minor alteration to a structure, please provide drawings and photographs to sufficiently describe the scope ofthe project. Provide a written description of the proposed project on the second page of this application. t Type Alteration of an existing building (ie. siding and window replacement. skylights. window opening alterations, new decks. porch reconstruction, baluster repair or similar) [J Addition to an existing building (includes decks and ramps) [J Demolition of a building or portion of a building (ie, porch, chimneys, decorative trim, baluster or similar) [J Construction of new building rlpair or restoration of an existing structure that will not change its appearance [J Other , --- "-,."-- -- --- -"'=-'" Project description ~~ .~~..~.....~é.....~~~~.....~,~~.~..f.!~¿. ...... ........, ... ....... : ......../ J ;M..._Â'¿ t:.J.4A:It' ~/y"µ~ £' ~L' ¿/~ £J f AIIf" .A' A "";f /<"7:~_-Z!" ~M;r~~;;.&fTep""'''·;øy·').''¡;¡;¿~-;;;;;,~::¿:'~'~''·''''£~''·~· .... ..~ .................. .. .. .e}~'~...it'!f:l.,:~'~'L~......................................~....~..iffIi'![;.'"¡',:7!?i;"".:}YL ....... ......~.....~......~.... ..._...................'!f'j'Et2t............. ....... ...................._............ ~ yo.$; ¥¿ ~ Yß./f ~ ¿,'N ø:::"A~/H/..:rf/ð. Z?/.~J: ,...Æ.........2!.,::.....,. ....................,..~...................'.J11...iZ....................,......,............................,...................,.......~........................ ..........................,.......................................................................................................................................................................................................,............... .....'.,........................,................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .....,.................,....................................H···~....·...·.................U.................................................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ..".,.,......,.,..........................................................................................................................................................................................................,...............,...... ..............,.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... ,..................................~...........................H....................................................................................................~....~........................................................................ .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... Materials to be used ...f¿.¿!!!!..t!{,~;y"N.:!.....,;,(~4...~~..MJ::e.~..4!é:...:!:.?!:.~~'1....,~~.../..r.<!..~T .,..d4:::R..r.!!l!.t/?!!......t£:~'!!:t:.((t..!!!..~ð:~~:!??,~.~~:2..~/f:.~~...J;.~~"C..,.. ~vrL..þ -A.JI?.i!!/",ep £M?/~~ Ø'ffH .A~<:A:"'/..~ .. ..~...... .................................... ...../!'!f(1f['tf.':'¡:D~.....!.'JlY!'1........h..ilr................u.r;I;i:;L'{!,Y!rj(~'-('!f............. ....... ........-..~.......ì!!'fE'!!'F.Ift.....................f'!íl!r:If/!'f:.... ....e4f..¿tçÆ&;".~t.~.Zfft?.....~&:..L.i!:!..~.....t!!..;f.t£e-&..?.f:..4..e4...?:..~¿¿ "...ff!~..r;:~~.~~-!!(..¿,~..f....~I:.~-!.!:.ð:¿..'.~,..ðt:!.e...~€:..,...?::.~..~~?..~l.. ,?' ,....eð:I5f..f!?~.#..~.....~4!!..(,,~..,~~/J!..Z.i!{~.....&.~.tz..~.. ..........~:!~~N. .........................................................................................................................................................................~................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... Exterior appearance changes ~,~~,(""¿.,¿¿ f..f"/lF"--/~ #ß .....,...~~~£þ TZ:1'" f':/~ .....~¿;..;.jijï. ··~N;V;¡·..·....A..'~#Älr;¡J'..·f~ðiiihi..';;:¡¡;¡:,·:·y;¡~-P ......,..........................................,.......................e'........."l!:.......,........,......,....,........................."..............................,................................................,............... .,...~iI!!:l..~~.I'f:.~~,Ij-;!;.,...............................................,..................,....,.....................,.........,..............,..............................,....,."".,. ........................................................................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... .............................................................................~.........................................................~................................................................. .................................................................................................................................~........................................................................ .........................................................~................................................................................................................................................ .....................................................................~..................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... UltSl1f' UJd&¡:'þ. ~ 'OOAaV\' fW,p'UWI:;I u¡eVII ~ lQW\$!1vJP\l~~1/ï\3N1Q'd\$l.P3roBd\:O o QIQA:;I>KEHO 81", ~~ m C\I u~ . f!:I(ì) ~o . n 0 ,... ~ e. 1;}'0 z lO~o m 'c::t of/. . . ....~ ~ ~!-~~ Cl)1 ~ ~ ~i (!) - dJ 0 O °28;;;(;19 ~ 0::.-0.. S It z-« - -xæ .0 "0",,,, .:J M Fw<:(z ~ ... ~q8~i:1~ ,q.o..t>o..IL;W 9V¡re9VI'A.U:) "MOl "3AV 3901:113f1' eog NOIÐn31:1 :/0 3.LnlllSNI SlN'tfS Atfa~I:IEUltf7:10 lS'IJHO snS3r :10 HOl:lnHO 3Hl uuu................... · .. ........... ·~c/f -',. ..,J -,~~' · ~ r"" : . .t1I1IIi.~ . .'W¡ , : Î;...:..i · ~ ~ Š ..J .. ..J !,.¡ ~; 2· ~~ o . ! .....",,, '" ~ :>; I I w [J ~ '" ~ ~ ~ s :>; ¡;¡ w ¡¡ - ~ð ¡¡~ I w. ! ~ '" '" [J ~ I . ! ~ i3 -1> æ ~ ! (þ- ~ ;¡ II! . o ~ " ~ ~ s w .1> ~ þ .. . A W upsnr' wdB~:v- GO(£: 'ooÆew' ÔNfj·$l.lCl!ì8:N'I!3I:<3-L{)90\~B.wP\lOO(í\OO:l;ø:-.¡A\3I\1.W,^$lQ3rol;d\:Ð .....¡:¡ ~ !i1~~" U)~ ~ ~~~~ ~ (') -d1d1-5 Q:ï ~ª~(;Ç;~ "'" ,,;:;~ .Q .... "'Ou;w u Q1 FlQ<,",,"...J gÔOÕXj! N _UJX'¡;¡;;. o;r""OIJ.;t.LcW ........n..........._... · . · .. · . · . , .' , ..,........ · ' , · : r:---;"1 , ,II!&.' . ''IIII'i : i.:...::..i :.,-'. ,. - --,.-"" \s,.,;","/ .~ o (BOA d!*>3H:) 917ZZ9VI 'All:) VMOI "3^V 3501:11311\1 Cog NOIÐn31:1 30 3.LOlI.LSNI SlNltfS AtfO'l:I3LUn :10 lSll:lH:> snS3f :10 H:>l:InH:> 3Hl :g~ ~(Q it; ~o "10 o-~o :g~ . ~~ ..~ ~~ h ou ~~ æg ¡ga iiì¡¡ I ,.... ~ . ~N Lq I I J I I I I I I I ð - ð ..... I « - > I ..... W I « ...... 0 > II! I IIj W .... W . I ...... z: .... J: W . I z ..... 0- I 0::: ~ I- .. 0 I (/) ~ z 0 I <C u> u I W 1/1 ~ I N I I I I I I I I I I I I .., ugsnr' Wdg~:v - ÇO[)(; 'I)) lie~' w,\¡nu:!!!J.IØ.[3 ~-LOOO\SÕMJP\.l.ooo~J!iB^tlQV\ßlJ3roucl\:O . , . '. '.. ....¡J (1)1 O~ mi :................'.....,'. . . , . ..u..u... , , . . r:"':-J .: I..:..,:.J , "·1 o 010/1.;;11)1031-1:) uj !'IM~~ (/} ~I.Ö",... ~ ~.~i~ ~§:g¡;¡¡;¡~ z~2¡ - -xu: J; j;oæW" w«z ;a: ~~ß~~~ I C\I "'~ ~~ ~g ~ <:> ~..... .~ !II .-~io ",¡:: C\I ~e. g:g il 0 ~§ z I¡¡ :g~ ~ 'ct L Ijj ø 9V~9 VI 'All:) VMOI "3AV 3S0\:l13W &09 NOIÐn3\:1 ::10 3101.l.LSNI SlNI'tS ÁtfO-l::IEI.LLtI1 :/0 lSll::IH:> SOSElf :/0 H:>l::IOH:> ElHl <s.~~~ -" .,. "'--- Œ ~ ,<\"" _'.... _<>- éC \(Jcî\>¡;'¿,{f1:\T-j))i Q'+}4;¡¡;C >;02'>+\-,,'\:1')'''''( '%¡'",-W'- Ö¡1k""\V/,~,'-\'_""{s '(;"'iiS/-¿ ">/_..o>~"_,,.._"'.,, .-_,,", <_.. z o - I- <I: > 1.1.1 -I' LIJ~ :¡::t I- .. :::>'" O~ VI~ I"') .., I "~4 I I ~ z o - I- <I: > 1.1.1 -I wtll . .. 0", m 1.1.1" N'" <I:~ O~ Ii) ð - I- <I: > wtll -I": 1.1.1", I- _. VI'" w~ 3:~ <t "'~, ,." '",,,",,,..~ 03/14/2005 10:03 FAX 3183621484 ,8~BURBAN LUMBER CO. ....",. ''Y. 4'lV) IV. D/IN' MtL IUN I..LI\~~.tJ III 002/002 NO, 9522 P. 1 --- -- "~f" nTH . as SICS Inr::orporatçd Date; 31ll/05 . Sold To; .AUQ:..K.C. FI)'lU1 Suburban Lumber Co. 2630 Wiloy Blvd. SW Cedar Rapids, IA 52404 Prepared by. Mike Grimmett Freight: Delivered to Zip 52404 . ...-.. ..~.....- .-. Project: Historical Register Phone: 31!J.362-3115 Pu.: 319-362.1484 Quantity 14 2 Diagram A D Design # 285EMN 285EMN Bottom 12" 12" Diameter "t' Top 10" 10" Diameter Pilaster Dimenaioo - - Overall Heisht 9'-0" 9'..(»' Flashing YQ Yes Ctpital Composition CornpoaitfOb Base FJ-Redwood FJ-Redwood 0+ --,,-" F1-Wwoodl '"~I Plinth IIi-Moly Plates Ifi.MoJy PJ_ + Primer Yes Yes . Asphaltum Yes Yes . Shaft Fl R.edwood F1 Redwood . . , $p1îttibg "t' No No " . Unit Prico II "HI'. (/.:1.. ,,~.U' Price lx_ion . $0.00 $0.00 . Remarb: ClauieAnlhitecCUrallØIÛC F1vted Fl Clear All Product Total: Heart Redwood &tenor CoI\tlDfts; Empire with Necking Sales Tu: Design; Attic BanJPtinth; Primer, Asphllltum. \\ Flashing ÌJ1çluded; Deliveretd lTI. Curbside· CIaøtorur Oftload. Totat: -- - -- - --, -'- -, - --- - -- - -- - - - , - Melton Classics, Inc. quotation is based upon our.standar4 item #'s and specifications Flute, will. ead appruimately)' above the base per photos. SCHEJ)ULED SH.JPMENT: 6-8 weeks fi'oœ IIf.IP'Oved drawÌlIp QUOTATION OPEN FOa ACCEPTANCE UNTn.: 30 DAYS - -t> TERMS: SOOA. AT ORDER; BALANCE DUE mOR. TO SHIPMENT Page] of! p,o, 8ox4ó5020 · l..awrence\.IÌUe, OeOl¡ÍlJ 30042-5020 . (770) ar (800) 963.3060 . FAX (770) 96.2-6988 WIWI,rlltltøncløuù;s .CQIII ~_~__ n..._ .." ,----,. "" ~ Staff Report May 05, 2005 Historic Review for 503 Mçlrose Avenue Classification: Iowa City Historic Landmatk The Corporation of the Presidh1g Bishop of the Church of the Jesus Christ Later Day Saints is requesting approval of Certificate of Appropriateness for proposed alterations at 503 Melrose Avenue, a local Historic Landmatk. The original structure was bullt in 1890, with influences of Late Victorian/Italianate and Colonial Revival styles of architecture. Proposed work includes replacement of porch columns and balustrade. A previous application for approval of aluminum columns, balustrade, replaced without prior permit, was denied, Proposed replacement will be done with wooden columns and balustrade. Ap,plicable RegmaµQns a,nd Guigelig.es: 4.0 Iowa City Guidelines for Alterations, 4.9 Porches Recommended: HÙtorÙ'porchcs · Repairing historic porches and conserving as much of the historic material as possible, · Replacing badly deteriorated components with new ones that match the historic components in design and material, Custom fabrication of columns, brackets, pedestals, and moldh1gs may be necessary, but many porch components can be ordered through lumber yards. · Using vertical-grained fit porch flooring for its resistance to weathering. · Using wood steps for a wood porch and tile, brick, or conctete steps for a masonry porch. · Leaving exposed the support piers'below the porch columns. Skirting must be added to fill the space below the porch floor and grade if this space is 24 inches or greater. The skirt must be located between the porch piers. · Constructing porch skirting using a 3-6 inch wood frame with slats fastened to the back of the frame in a vertical or lattice pattern. · Enclosing only a portion of a front porch with screens to provide a sitting atea that is to the side of the steps and front entrance of the house, The screens should be set behind the columns and balustrades to preserve the historic appearance of the porch, Wood substitutcs · Substituting a material in place of wood only if d1e substitute material retains the. appearance and function of the original wood The substitute must be durable, accept paint, and be approved by the Historic Preservation Commission. Disallowed: Ncw matcrials · Using wrought iron elements unless they were part of the historic design, · Using unpainted treated wood for elements that would have been painted in their historic applications. · Using precast concrete steps on the front or side elevation if the steps will be highly visible from the street. They are acceptable on the rear elevation. Wood substitutcs · Substituting a material in place of wood that does not retain the appeatance, function, and paintability of the original wood. Recommendations Staff recommends approval of Certificate of Appropriateness, provided the proposed construction adheres to project description provided in the application. ';\,',::':,'""j' :_- '-':,.."..j "''''.;"ÄL-_ Application for Historic Review Application for alterations to the exterior of historic landmarks or properties located in a historic di$tl'ict or conservation di$tl'ict pursuant to Iowa City Code Section I4-4C. Meeting schedule: The HPC meets the second Thursday of each month. During the summer months, the HPC may also meet on the fourth Thursday. Applications are due by Wednesday the week prior to the meeting. For Staff Use: ^/:. . Ot:;" , .-- Date submitted ,....'........,... ..C!!/::/.f!.!::.............. ŒI Certificate of No Materia! Effect ~ Certificate of Appropriateness ~ Major review Q Intermediate review Q Minor review ,¡ ¡ Applicant Information Property Information (Please cheêk primary contact person) Jð\<lcI~~ ~'''I'''<:J~:.~~l~~~~~................................................~. CJ Owner...........~~!&!.~~l~í~.~~~........................ ....~.......4................................~.~..~.~~.................................~............................ ~11~...............~~:~.::~.~~.~........~.~...~..~.....~..~.........~...~.....~............. Useofprc>þ~~u........§~~~.~~~...H.............m..m JO\~IiE!!t!i ..........~.~~~.~~~..~~~..~....«~...«...~..~~..~~~..~.....~.~~..~..~..~. Date con$tl'ucted (if known) .....J.~~9...........,................................... ..........................~~~~~'!t~.~'..~~~~~....~....«..~...~........~«.....~... ~it ~~~.~~...~.......~~.«~~....~~.~........~~..~...~~....~~«.~.~.«~~..~..~....~........~......~.....« Iowa City, IA 52240 Historic Designation Q This pro~ is a local historic landmark OR ŒI This property is located in the: II Brown Street Historic District Q College Green Historic District Q East College Str'Cet Historic Di$tl'ict Q Longfellow Historic Di$tl'ict Q Summit Street Historic Di$tl'ict o Woodlawn Historic District Q Clark Street Conservation District Q College Hill Conservation District Q Dearborn Street Conservation District Q Lucas-Govemor Street Conservation District c::I -c::~'~ ..~~.~~~~~~.....~................~................ 330-9507 f't1<:)'I1~ ..........~~..~.....~..~«..~.~~...«.......~.........~......«................................... . 2025 A Street ~clcI,.~~ ..............................~..~.............~.~..~...................................... .........................................~......................................~........44..~....4........ ~rr1¡¡j1 .......................................................................4.....4.4.............44.. !II Consultant .§11~º~I.M~Ç.~9tt~..~~~..~~._.,..~_.........u.....4..... Address ..._.....~~ª.~:Ji~~t.~SmlttJiM.......................... ..........................~~~~.~.~~1.~.~.~~~~~:.................................... ~t:)f1E! .44.4.._..~~.~~4~4'::~~.~.~4............................................~............ .....~.....~.~..~~........................~.......4...~..~...................................4.....4...4.. E!Jt1~1 ..4.............~~:~~................*............................. Application Requiréments Attached are the following items: Q Site plan II Floor plans ŒI Building elevations ŒI Photographs o Product information r::I c::>1:t1~ .....................................4.4.......4...4.......................... Within the di$tl'ict, this property is classified as: ŒI Contributing Q Noncontributing Q Nonhistoric If the proposed project entails an addition, a new structure or a signifiCant alteration to an existing structure, please submit a site plan, floor plans. building elevations and photographs. If the proposed project is a minor alteration to a structure, please provide drawings and photographs to sufticiently describe the scope of the project. Provide a written description of the proposed project on the Project Type (III Alteration of an existing building (ie, siding and window replacement. skylights, window opening alterations, new decks, porch reconstruction, baluster repair or similar) ŒI Addition to an existing building (includes decks and ramps) Q Demolition of a building or portion of a building (ie. porch, chimneys, decorative trim, ba!uster or similar) Q Construction of new building o Repair or restoration of an existing structure that will not change its appearance 'i;, "'¿ ."""-'.... Project description ~~ª~~r£9.~~rn~21]!.:..~!1I?Jâ9~~~~.J?9!J?A1~9g~gm~~,~~!.~~§~~~!\~~:£r~ç~~~~~%ll~.~~§iml?!~. QQ.~~.~9.~~~.'.~~~~~.~!!.~!~~~...~~.~!~.§£!:~~!1$ÇJ~~~£!!m~M.~!~.~~~~!!!~~.~gî!g!!~!g.~:bg~~.~.~Th~.!!~~.~... ÇQ~~.~.~tm.Q~.~J?~~~í<?!.!h$~Q~~~~~[ß1?~.Y!M~~~~~.Qf~.!!º~~:.~§.m~!!!~!Q~!'~§Q.~2J!!g~§~.~~.~f ~~.~~~a~~~~.~~.~];J~5?~.~.~~~~~:~!Jl'.~~~.~~~~.................aa..................aa.......a.................a..a............................................................. ........................n............h...........nn..............~...............,..........................................................,.....~......~........................~.................................................................... º~~.~4!~º!!:...ª~ª1!§~.!h.i§.!1Q~5!J§.l9B!!1~.~.!h~.!QP.Q!~~.§!~~R.~.~~:t~~~!1?!§~~~.§~!!-q~!Y.~Q.~2!.~.1?.~~.~g~·............. º~Q!:&Ç..~Q.J.~~ff?!.W~Ç.r.,~~.p.r.gp.Q~g.!Q,!?.9.'º~!m9!,ª!¡:ggÇ..9:~~.Qp.!h!::.Þ.i!£¥.:.9.f!;h~,Þ.:Q~~,,~.Q,fuÇ.Y.~y,J~ªy,Ç..P.riy.ª~~ ~Q,.Ë;Q.y!~Q~~.§J?~.€?:....~........u.u.........................................................................................................n........................................~............................................ .............~..~........~....~~..~........................n...............u........................+......................,.._.................H-....~...........................~..~........................~.......~..~.....~...................~........... ª~~y.~!~~!iQ!E..R~p!~.~.~~.ç!g!-!R!~::b.WÆ~ª2~§~~!lj.B~~~!1~!"!~gQQ~.*..~~~~.fu~.~f:L.Y.!Q~~Q!!.~.~Ë~!~ $ ~ ~ / 4'\ ' (j j; the bav wIll also be renatred. I' r~~ ;¡;;q ¡;:'J!2r /,$) tL~>t, l' ~:,'.; » f t:{r~7' , ,f I f, /ì ...........'Jl......u....n...u............J:::.................,..,.~....u.u....'"..h......~'"...............................u.....................u~..............................u....'~............ ~ J\,;?l: I', ',_"-!--_ .......................<"..........,................ / .., J .....................................~..a...*.a..44...a...............aa...........~...~..~...**~..*............~.......~.~.......4.....~..~.............þ......................~..............a.......... ............................~.......~..~......~...............~.~þ..~~................*............4.........a......aa............a...a..........................................~.~...................... ....................................~..+.~...~........................a..~~..~......~~..~.~...~~..~.............a~.....~..~....~....~..~.~~...................~a......~.........a........~............~~.. Materials to be used ~~!~~!1:~º~~~.!:l!!~I~~Q!!;..f~.~I£~m~~!.!?Q~ª"~~~!!';.~!þ~QQg.~.tlJªt!i9~~:.~M!.!YQ2g.~ª.~!?@r~çËw-º;Q!þQ~Q.~J.Q~ . ted. ~........n.............................n......n.........................................................................................,.......a....,............................................................................................ .................................................n................,......,.,..........,.................,......,....................H.....~........H....~..,......,.,...~....................................................................................... º~~.~~t!Q!!:..f!þ.~.~!!!~!!t~.~ª.t.~~~~.ª!!~~~X9!mª.£9!.~.~..~..![9g~4~f!.fi~!~~!!1~!!!!?Q~~.~J.~......... J?~.~!~Q:.rh~.g~£~.~H.º@.£Qn~f?!~g.gfl?~~~ª.£~~.~ª.ÿm~r.s~m~~~.~~~..I!1~.g~£~~H.~.y~rt!~~.m:~.fu.QI.ª.. ~~!~.~~fu~£.~1-!1?§!~M~.~~ª~g;!!tl~!!!!?~!1!:..T!1~.mmY§!@!.~Al.~.çf!ªª~!~.Qf£~~....................................................... .......~..................................~.......~.~..,..,~..,...~..~........~~~....;.......,...~....~...~......................~........a......................................~........................... ~~~.~!~~~t!;..~~.~ç!.~~.~~~Ç?~.~~~~~~JJi~t~~~.....................~...........a..........~.....................~...................................~..... Exterior appearance chanCe.$ ~.l19JÿºßQfths::.hº~~t!~.~!J?J~.!!"2U!Jb~.~!:MU.J!~!£i\ng~:..i1J!~.~.ª.~ç~.~çJjJiQ!1J:yiU.ºº~.~!gnffiç~ºy.~!~I.. "fu~..~~ç~...Qfth~hQY§~:...JZb~..~çr~n5(gm~b.~Ml.~.mg~.~m~~fiþls;~tkt..fh~~riWf.Û~hº~~.............~.................................. ............... .......................... .........H..~.........H.......................~............. .................................................................................................................................................... ..a...a.~................................................................................~..a.......~.,.....................'..~~.~......~.....................~...................................~........ .................................................~...~.............~~..~....~.......~.~..~...~..........................................a.......................................a..........~.............. .......................~...~.....~~~~~.~.~~~..~~..................................................................~.........................................~....~....~~.~~~..~~~~........................... .........................................~.........*..a................~.........a........+...........................~..................a.......~.........~~...........~...............a................. ......................................................~.~.......................~..........................................~.~...........~.~......................~..........~~..~..~......~.........~.......... ......þ.......a...............~............**.....".*...............................~...........a..~.....~..~.............................~.....~~...~.................~..................~........~............... ........................~..~..~~~~...~..~.......~~.....................................~........~.........~.......................~.~....~.~~...................................a..................................... [ ~t ø 0 ~ m (') ~ ^ " m " ~ õ m § ~ -j 0 Õ Q. '" Z "" ;:¡. <T 0 0> f'!. r i i , , __mm__" , 'i , , Ii . 'I " '. rl " -'I U,;;;;" ""j , "'~__,'_v_" , I', ¡I' , I.. ,T.I -~~-_....^ ~'''v'^..~~__,,__,,__''_____ , , , , __n__n__"_,._.. ;~........'·i '1'1 : ", - ,',~-j ,:' , ,,' - '1-"-"',--:;11'" ::L,J..__JJ ii ,I ...... ,_J......... ._________w_ m____mm__11 ,. .. [' --r j ,_,}__",v_1 ) 'i '>",""-'''¡ , . "L -- -Ir"=--i ~---..,\, !i " !~---;;;;;..." , . i'i~li"'"'''''''' 1 ----(""''':'1 II i:J I iL:.'-- .._..__:-::-~~, ...,J Z t;:E ~~ ¡¡;'" ",9.. '" 0> <> " 9.._ 3 g " " '" Q. .!~, I __mu____.__ ,I '. j 'I Ii Ii J¡ -">0- 1 , , :'--V"'l"""--' ¡: ; i " , , 'rn--r-'Î , n__"________r .._mV.~ -,--~-"_-C--"-----: _'..M___W______~" -('c.,.;-"c:--I~T--':::Ï! I :~,__,,,,,,wAI , . li¡,<-v<,~c<~~¡ , ,: ¡ j1 1___·___:;,.,,;',,"_0____""'J .."'-- ~.. ~.. ," , __~'_"',::_,c,',G:')i:·'O:;:'1 ! i~:¡' . ",,-11 , ),-"" ilr~",v»'1 L-----_cJ."",..1-_"'J, ~~--~- -- --- -~----,--------_.----'---,-" "'-'''' , ..--,~-~ ;u" ;u CD =(1) "0 =r"O 0> - -.;E ro ~ 0 <> <TO" 0> 0. .. '" X m- :::;- -. '" ro a "'. :.::J -. ¡;¡ <> " n ".'" co Q. '" ~lgg: CL~~ '" ¡ _[.m_ I I , ¡ , ¡: \, ¡' un"____,,_,, I 8''',:;E Q) ::f @ a :::n'O . C'... .. " ~ ... ""0 .. 0 a!¡¡¡. " .. ID !if =;' ID " ¡;¡ .. " .. Q. "0 o c¡ =r 0> " 0. "0 "0 0'" ;:¡''' ..... 0_ " '" g,5' ~f .. ~ r- '" "" o' '" ~ ;:¡; C' .. ~ "';U 0> 3'£. ¡¡¡ g . W _x ¡;:<5' = ¡I¡ !1<¡;¡ .. " 8à? " "0 3!}f ¡¡¡ .. '" ~ s: (ii. ,,= ~.g 1!r 0. " ¡g S: ,.. "'= ~ ~~ A' !i: if ¡¡¡ " if" . ~ t I'lIi,,! o"'¡;; ... ';<:;,:0-<.,.- j,;¡¡¡;!¡ §!.!;! -- - ~~-"' - - o ~ WAGNER RESIDENCE DECK ADDITION 4 BELLA VISTA IOWA CITY. IA S2145 ,,--.,.'---,....----,. ---------,- r,,;·,,;·;,..·-·..¡ ";11 :.. ',.. .,r: , -"·"'--'----"'11 i: ::___\._Ii·: " ,--------,"""-\,1 !Il_..m,.._..:i..,.....i...-.!i,_ !r..·_·_·~·~-----'t iír--^'-=:-C-F-Y"""li: j ., 1,,·',......·11 I - , , ' 11 1"=-'}'''~-'{1 if ".-------_-----__,---.....L··':o:.J'I' I ,----_.~_.- , ' <,'. -"', ì n___________ , ,\i Ij , ...........m____.m._._._·..·· . !i"^ Ii I, ?-' L....""',,....._ , ___n' , .] , "i ! . "" .. rr;=-"":-'-1"'~T~-;TI :1 : il~~.~J=~:,:T;::']1 :! !' II"^"" "'...- L-..:~:~C~^jlj ií ; ;' \ jii , ,....',....,'......,,' Ii ¡ ¡ Ii ¡ :jii " ""--"',1; lr:::::::::_::,::;:-:, ,------_...',,- I I I I I 1 "'i ,,,~...,"_,..",__......m.."""'_''''''''''''': ----~.,.._--. ""'" ;fd; .."...,.........-..... --..-~~--~.._-.;, , -:1 "" ,¡....".._í..",,_..,:¡i[U;!j'¡'I' ;i " 't,:j' '('..,--~ I. i -;, , - i·'", 11 __---"'--~._;:.:;;;-:!;..._ii -,''1 ,_.----,_..--~..,!: :j] ! --, -"'f-m¡ FJ1: ¡; -1""__.-.\"""_"]_ :Ji . . 'I t, <"""; ,_, , , I, I \~11¡ I I ;¡\, --------=--.:.-_:.~..;." ,'" '--~--.~~mn " 'en;¡ llL' ¡.,lli.,;! , ,k",,__~__,,_,J _; ..", - i",;> i;' 'i" . '.. L..L ·1"'" ~-,-~.~" :',' -I .. .... 'i!11 ' ,-, .-n"L~'1 -,,- - ri ; .1 ..,}i ~CJ)a' !',;I",;.O 9l. 0> co to -~ ~ 9t'" 0> ;::+ (J.::'" ''0 ...~ ~~ '" '" () ¡g, '" ~ 0. ,., ~ .~ w a ~ m (') , ^ ~ "U . ~ ç q z , ).[ , '" "" , q ¡¡ '7' q "'" " ~ q '7' -;! I I " n It " n ., n .' " " " " " " n " " " " ,r m " ., " R " " H B II t ft ft :: a " " " " LJ "Q --,,----....~- ,"-----,,----;<----,...-- " _~....-___''',r_-_-...._u,,____.,.,-___~_ " " " ., " " " " ., ,," n ,. L¡ " "" "H ~ I: H I: Ii H " " " " " " " " II I: H :: I: n :1 " " " " " " ., " " ,t " " » ., 'I ,t " " " u " i, :i U -, :1 :: n .r "" "j' II " "" "" ,. " " , ,- " " " ,.-j~¡-.vIh-_1i -¡j---·---II-~I: " " '1;'...."1, " " ,- " " " , " " " ,. " " .' " II ,. ¡, " " , " " ., ,. M " " " " " ,j " ,. I " .. ., " " " .' " ., " " " " " , .. " " H " " " " " ., a " " " ,0 " " » 1 " ,t " " ", it !, I' :1 it 'i , " " " " " I. " " " " " " " " " " " , " <!Þ --""'---.,.,----1'--.......---- -.-....--.. __.¡¡,____H__ __~__~____.... .""'__" " H " " " " " " " " " . , " " " "" " " " ,t ... " " " " "" " ". " " " ., , " " " ~ '" " -;! '" " -;! '" " "'" --.~.,- e___ ,--- ~. " ..-~~ "" " ~ " "" " ~ . 0 -, => ~~ S· , <s;:¡ a- :E~ ?J 0 0 a.", 0 ¡;¡ ~¡¡¡ 3 :E" -'" @~ =0<0 " =r ~~ ~ " ,. f"¡¡t~ f [ ç~ ì ~ . . - ~o ~ ¡ e>"'§ I - ~ .. n ~ ~- - $:i.è !; ;¡ -- - ~-- ~~ª ~ o (!) '" "" OJ ê:: = o => w @ (!) '" (!) a. 'C o ëJ :::r " "" 0'" ",'" 3<3 ¡¡¡ g¡ . W " '" a- ID ~ '0 '" <3 o ¡¡¡ ~ - 11'·0' w " m =0 ¡¡¡ ~ " o c 3 =0 '" "" :;;0 '" '0 ¡¡¡ " '" '" "" <0 WAGNER RESIDENCE DECK ADDITION 4 BElLA VISTA IOWA CITY. IA 51245 -~ View of back of house looking south View of bay on back of house (looking north) ~ ~ j ~ ,c. ~ (þ View of bay on back of house (looking south) View ofñ:ont of house (west side) -~-,- , ,,-,~, , ---~-,,-,,/', ,""'''~'""~ ,~ ".... :~----"' ....-¿ .. " .. -.._.~..¥ .. - ,"k'M \" ,....;/ '._, ,v.... ¡'Y" ...~.. > ¿- .", ,.. .... ,..., -'<" .. ~ .. ""'----.. .~. ~;~'z,.. "'.' -",,'\c -':I; View of back of house fÌ'Om Gilbert Street (west side) View ofnorthwestcorn.erof hom:..,w/ ~ffi nornh ".. 'i.,'''' ..., _,...,P --~- "'"- '-, ~~ Staff Report May 05, 2005 Historic Review fQr 4 Belli! Vist:,\ District: Brown Street Historic District Classification: Contributing Applicants, George and Jennifer Wagner, are requesting approval of Certificate of Appropriateness for proposed alterations atld addition at 4 Bella Vista, a contributing property in the Brown Street Historic Distract. The original structure was built with the influence of Colonial Revival style. Proposed work includes 1) alteration and repair of the existing screened porch on the North 2) removing two sets of stairs on the East elevation of the house 3) addition of a wood deck approximately of size 56' x 11' on the rear of the house 4) installation of french-doors to replace existing double window on the bay on East elevation Applicable Rc;gl1,Iª~ioq.s an;} Guiøeqnes:, 4.0 Iowa City Guidelines for Alterations 4.7 Windows Recommended: Historic windows · Preserving the historic windows by repairing sashes and frames. · Retaining historic window frames atld replacing badly deteriorated sashes with new sashes that match the historic ones. 4.8 Door Recommended: Ne/v doors · Installing a wood screen door that accepts sashes with glass or screen. · Adding new door openings that are trimmed to match other doors atld windows in the building, · Substituting a material in place of wood for doors and screen doors only if the substitute material retains the style and appearance of the historic doors and screen doors. The substitute material must be durable, accept paint, and be approved by the Historic Preservation Commission. Disallowed: New doors · Installing flush entrance doors or other modern door styles. · Installing sliding patio doors if they wcre not original to the building or consistent with the architectural style. · Installing natural aluminum storm doors, · Blocking down door openings to accommodate standard door sizes. 4.9 Porches Recommended: Historic porches · Repairing historic porches and conserving as much of the historic material as possible, · Replacing badly deteriorated components with new ones that match the historic components in design and material. Custom fabrication of columns, brackets, pedestals, and moldings may be necessary, but many porch components can be ordered through lumber yards. · Using vertical-grained fir porch flooring for its resistance to weathering. · Using wood steps for a wood porch and tile, brick, or concrete steps for a masonry porch. · Leaving exposed the support piers below the porch columns. Skirting must be added to fill the space below the porch floor and grade if this space is 24 inches or greater, The skirt must be located between the porch piers. · Constructing porch skirting u5Ìng a 3-6 inch wood frame with slats fastened to the back of the frame in a vertical or lattice pattern. ~"."^,^,,, · Enclosing only a portion of a front porch with screens to provide a sitting area that is to the side of the steps and front entrance of the house. The screens should be set behind the columns and balustrades to preserve the his toric appearance of the porch. Wood sub.rtitute.r · Substituting a material in place of wood only if the substitute material retains the appearance and function of the original wood, The substitute must be durable, accept paint, and be approved by the Historic Preservation Commission. Disallowed: Historic pon'hes · Removing a historic front porch. · Changing the original roof pitch. Newer materials including EPDM rubber sheeting and heat-sealed asphalt products make the maintenance of low-pitched roofs easier than in years past. · Enclosing front porches or other porches that are highly visible from the street with petmanent windows and/or walls, New materia1.r . Using wrought iron elements unless they were part of the historic design. · Using unpainted treated wood for elements that would have been painted in their historic applications. . Using precast concrete steps on the front'or side elevation if the steps will be highly visible from the street. They are acceptable on the rear elevation. Wood J'lb.rtitutes · Substituting a material in place of wood that does not retain the appearance, function, and paintability of the original wood. 5.2 Decks and Ramps Decks and ramps are features that are not typical to historic structures. They are modern inventions designed to meet the needs of our modern lifestyle and building codes. As such, it is not necessary that they duplicate the details of the building to which they are attached. However, they should be as unobtrusive as possible. Ramps may be approved that accommodate reasonable access and use by disabled occupants provided they do not significantly alter or detract from the historic character of the building. The Historic Preservation Commission will work with applicants to find designs that will accommodate their needs and that are compatible with the historic character of the building. Recommended: Decks · Locating a new deck on the back of a primary building, opposite tlle street-facing facade and set in from the side walls at least 8 inches. · Designing decks so that the size, scale and location do not detract from the character of the district's rear yards, if significant to the district. · Attaching decks to the building in a manner that will not damage a historic exterior wall or, other historic materials, or cause wood siding to deteriorate. · Following the guidelines in section 4.10 Balustrades and Handrai1.r, · If creating a screened porch structure, following the guidelines for porches in section 5,1 Expan.rion of Building Footprint, Disallowed: Decks · Constructing a deck between the street and the street-facing facade if it detracts from the neighborhood or is not compatible with the architectural style of the existing building. · Leaving balusters and railings unpainted if they are highly visible from the street, Recommendations Staff recommends approval of Certificate of Appropriateness, provided the proposed construction adheres to project description provided in the application.