Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout11/10/2005 Historic Preservation Commission IOWA CITY HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Thursday, November 10, 2005 City Hall, 410 E. Washington Street Emma J Harvat Hall 7:00 p.m. 1. Call to Order 2. Public discussion of anything not on the agenda 3. Items of Consideration A. Certificate of Appropriateness: 1. 528 East College Street 2. 229 South Johnson Street 3. 821 South 7th Avenue 4. 315 Brown Street B. Minutes for October 13,2005 4. Other 5. Adjourn Application for Historic Review Application for alterations to the exterior of historic landmarks or properties located in a historic district or conservation district pursuant to Iowa City Code Section 14-4C. Guidelines for the Historic Review process, explanation of the process and regulations can be found in the Iowa City Historic Preservation Handbook, which is available in the PCD office at City Hall or online at www.icgov.orgIHPhandbook. Meeting schedule: The H PC meets the second Thursday of each month. During the summer months, the HPC may also meet on the fourth Thursday. Applications are due in the PCD Office by noon on Wednesday the week prior to the meeting. For Staff Use: . Î Ô / .'1 'I / @i. -.- Date submitted ........../.....::::: .i.........2................. f¡IJ~, Certificate of No Material Effect ;Ji4 Certificate of Appropriateness I \Q Major review o Intermediate review o Minor review Applicant Information (Please check primar~/co?tact person) _.' i / /. /) I I . 1£( Owner ..........:/.l./f.O.......':../::èÚ/.'../J¡/l::iz2J.. /Ii / .?# -C') c> <-?C/ Ph -') /' ( .' ~I one ..............~.... .. ......,.,·.7...';./......../. ................................. ,:.-,~ /J' / /.; "..J¿?-: ..... / ....j 't:':J~ Address ..·..·..,,<·~c·'..bi.....l<........I,.<..Ç.-: .I.¡i;'':.' '"t............................. / ,/ " I ......................¡.Ú................~)".;!~... '.. :.............................. email............................................................................................... o Contractor ................................................................................. Ad dress.......... .............. ................ .................................................. ......................................................................................................... Ph one .............................. .......... .............. ....................................... email .......................~.:..j~....>¿.......:í1.<?..?.........I...l.;-T.. ~ Consultant ..2:..:....";:,.¡:·í.,Ltl-""r-...I.....,.';....,..,..:. "/'-;::""/1'" Add ress .................................f. ............ ......................... ....... ...r.... ¡ ········..··········..····:.::···~···ï··········t:,····!....;..:j........................................ /--¡ -1~1-/-:?' ... ! Ph one .......... .,..I..t. ../'........ ','... (""... .... .1........ ,. ........ ..... ............. ........ --, - -, ," . / ,. ,..,.~ .................... ...:{..:). .:;':. .~.(.... /1... .,::.:. .~~.}....... .... .......... ................ ·1 -</7' ,;/,<,,'7;' /) i .j j I..~ ¡/?/;é- emal .......... ...., ..,I-. '''/'.<0;. .,..1(. .L.... .1.,... .."'..,1,/....... ....,.",.. ... ........... ~.,- ., Application Requirements Attached are the following items: o Site plan o Floor plans o Building elevations o Photographs o Product information o Other ............................................................................ If the proposed project entails an addition, a new structure or a significant alteration to an existing structure, please submit a site plan, floor plans. building elevations and photographs. If the proposed project is a minor alteration to a structure, please provide drawings and photographs to sufficiently describe the scope of the project. Provide a written description of the proposed project on the second page of this application. Property Information / ·ì¿ //./ Add f ¡'J,..,L / I- (/¡//-'.' ress 0 property ..........'....:....I.c...........t..........."':I..I...j":.::............ .................................................................................................................. Use of property .................................................................................... Date constructed (if known) ............................................................. Historic Designation o This property is a local historic landmark OR ~. This property is located in the: I o Brown Street Historic District o College Green Historic District ~ East College Street Historic District o Longfellow Historic District o Summit Street Historic District o Woodlawn Historic District o Clark Street Conservation District o College Hill Conservation District o Dearborn Street Conservation District o Lucas-Governor Street Conservation District Within the district, this property is classified as: 'f\J/ C b .,.. ontri uting o Noncontributing o Nonhistoric Project Type o Alteration of an existing building (ie. siding and window replacement, skylights, window opening alterations, new decks, porch reconstruction, baluster repair or similar) o Addition to an existing building (includes decks and ramps) o Demolition of a building or portion of a building (ie. porch, chimneys, decorative trim, baluster or similar) o Construction of new building )( ,I Repair or restoration of an existing structure that will not change its appearance o Other Project description ·......·..t·;··~·..·:....···..l·..·..........···:..··....·....·~·..7....··.....................................ï'......................~......./:~..........J.......................~..~.......¡........:.I2.................~......... ':0 -,~/) CJf D'''')/-,(. - / {' -/ '" _ i "<.4 _ -"" /1 4--;:;. //..-1' - _ _ ,-I_/7.v¡ I.or.- ,l,. y"//- /' Xl"'~ 7 Þ '/ t'f, _ A} I ..../.. .1I."f...............þ... ,..'I.....ir.L:L......:I.4/,.;.··········'1 "./'.?",I.".,(............>J....····1''1;.,··,,·1,.··/· .....7. ..{;J... ....A......"...........".,..~. ........-;, ..1."....,""'....... V / . . I, . /; / , . _ ,.- -.. ../" _ }'.. _ ,.' ,- ,~- ,/ " , .. ~ , -,'" ... .- 1 '/i/Î '.-; _ ../ .x i/',' "': /~Y1/ Ii .:,'?/i.-/,.. //~, .' .. 1..--1,1: r. .,/!"'} /-", ~/ ¿ :/1. ....... i:ç~...... /. J, .¡. <:,... .....; f..........,,:. I...:. .~¡. ........ :;: ;¡t,';.I.. ¡.... ¡.. ....." ¡t' ,;. .,: .;:..... /... ...i..'.. ([;...\:7...... t. ,.. ..,.,... !/.f..,.,. t··';"¡; n.Io..-I... ,;d.; t(-. J........................ £- . '/j .. 'r. r¿ / /ti-y},./.."·'<//i /. /, I ::>-( 47 <' !/< ¡ i '0; .1/./\7·; .( '/ ....... .... .. ............ ,...;. .J.~ ...}:.( ....... .r:::::.... ..,~ ..,.,..,...... .t.......... ,."... ".. .¡,.... .-. ..j.... ...'.t/... ..... . ......... .;".(/........ 't' ;,:'.....;;r6... ..("vi.,!...... ..< l: .t.,. :5..",,,,. ........... '../ .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... ..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ........................................................................................................................................................................................................,.......................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ..................................................................................................................................................................................................................... ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Materials to be used () (' ! (1 . '. -:-" ~,'~¿- \"."J f")/), (, . ,:., ,¡ /~../ ,\ -'¡" I/¿¿.¿, (,,-.:, L1 '; ¡C:' {r.. ,.¡. U( i ...... ...~:;.~. AI. . . ....... .................. ::,......... ....... ....... ...... .... ..... .;-; ..............;.. -;--;'..... .........~. ...~'.. ......... .... ... ... ....... .... ..... ..... ... ....... .......... .... ....... ..... ...... ...... ....... ..... ... .... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ............................................................................................................................................................................................................. .............................................................................................................................................................................................................. Exterior appearance changes . .....~:;¿¿i!......Á......../z?:c:.~~/.......;:7..j,./1]/...j;:~=.......:1~?.......ilt..:?..../;:/í:.~.....;:s..!}(.j..,..................................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ...................................................................................,............................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ............................................................................................................................................................................................................ ............................................................................................................................................................................................................. .....................,....................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ............................................................................................................................................................................................................ .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ppdadm/HP Handbook/App.p65 I OtllS VI 'JJIJ VMOI lHUlS ]9mO) '] 8lS ~f~ ~~~ ~.t: ~ ~~~ Ë ;::;8 ! ~~j NOIDn~lSNO)3~ H)~Od 3)N301S3H OHO:lHna :z C> ¡::: ;;!; :f.j;;:J_ .r a~ -6~~ "" C> :::: !æ ~ g C> ~ .~ f N I -_.~-------._._--~.~--~-~-----_.._-------~._-----------~~ -_._.._---~_._-~~~----_.._----_._-------_._-~---~---- ~ ;¡¡ E o <> ffi~ ~.8 ... >< OJ ~~ z"" ã5 -'" on ê "§ .2> 5 &J õ c OJ ª -g 1i5 8 is ü --' « r~-----,-, i I I I I I I I I I I I I "8.~ ~:s¡ ã51i Iß '" '" CI)(3 I c=J I c=J --------------1 I I i I i I I I I i I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I i I I I I I I I I I I I I I i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I i I I i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I -----1_J :z: 0 ~ LoU --I LoU ::c \",, c::: 0 Q.. . :? ::c ~ . .....'" 0 ~ :z: ~ I OHlS VI 'UD VMOI H~US ~9~110) '~ 8lS NOIDn~lSNO)3~ H)~Od 3)N301S3~ a~O~~n8 t;¡¡1i:o I ~~~ § .., ::;: z ~ ~ ê~.. '" - j¡- "'z;- !it!~ ! ~ 1 ~viO f'Z:-¡ ... .¡; ¡uJCO; . ~ Jj !: ~ ~ ~ ~ 4; ~~E ~~ ,;:; Ie t- .~ _'~9 _-=J=-_.~:-=t __~~: _ n. r¡ I è¡> I ¡... I I I I I I I ,I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ------+ , I I I I I I I I I I ... .a ... ~~~ .....c:: Q) call)"O ~ .a Cs "0 _ "O~¡g «rig ~ro .!!!. ,------------------------------- I I I I I I .c ro ..c ~ o CL ~ ~ t,,) c: S è¡> ¡... "'" ~ ..c:: II) "0 Q) 0> ro > ... - 0 ro 0 (/)"0 è¡> ¡.... c-- -.¡. ~ I "C I ~ I en I I I I I I I I L_____ ~. ----J- ~'2 C => Q) "0 C S õ~ c:..c:: o II) 'ã5ëõ g·ä -l'C ... o ëii ~ w <D (/) :::J o ::r: 0) c: :¡::¡ (/) ·x ill :z:: ::s Q.. ~ ::c: '-J cc::: .::c" ~ ~ Staff Report November 10, 200S Historic Review for 528 E College Street District: College Green Historic District Classification: Contributing Applicants, IIclen and Kevin Burford, are requesting approval for a Certificate of Appropriateness for a revised plan for the reconstruction of the back porch and shed at their property, 528 East College Street, a contributing structure in the College Green Historic District. In the revised proposal the position and dimensions of the shed and column spacing for the porch have been changed. Applicable Regulations and Guidelines: 4.0 Iowa City Historic Preservation Guidelines for Alterations 4.9 Porches Staff Comments The back porch before has been reconstructed and/ or altered many times since it was built originally. The reconstruction proposed in this application, per the applicant, is closely based on the last known design and material. The application indicates that originally 0ast known) the shed was positioned such that the condenser for the air- conditioner can be accommodated. The dimensions for the shed remain similar to the shed that was part of the previously approved application, and the column spacing in this proposal is adjusted accordingly. Staff recommends approval. At'plication for Historic Rt~iew Application for alterations to the exterior of historic landmarks or properties located in a historic district or conservation district pursuant to Iowa City Code Section 14-4C. Guidelines for the Historic Review process, explanation of the process and regulations can be found in the Iowa City Historic Preservation Handbook, which is available in the PCD office at City Hall or online at www.icgov.orgIHPhandbook. Meeting schedule: The H PC meets the second Thursday of each month. During the summer months, the HPC may also meet on the fourth Thursday. Applications are due in the PCD Office by noon on Wednesday the week prior to the meeting. For Staff Use: I ., ¡ I "), / t~; ,L, ) I \... Date submitted .......:.............................................. o Certificate of No Material Effect \.Æ1' Certificate of Appropriateness ...Ja/ Major review o Intermediate review o Minor review Applicant Information (Please check primary contact person) ø: Own e r ....c .¥,.O\~.\~... ..(.~\~.\...... .~\? .(i; .y.j.\.\.Ü. ..~...... ..... Ph one .. ..?l~. ~\ .:-:~D..). .¿. L..... ..... ....... ..... .................. ........... ....... Add re ss ...0.1.11....0..,... .[0.!~ .~Þ;;'T.... .'2I............ .......... ........ ......................................................................................................... email............................................................................................... /);t' Contractor .....,Iç,J.f...........(J..f;;.~,..k................................ Add ress .......................................... ................................................ ......................................................................................................... Phone ....0J).:.I.:~.U..}........................................................... email............................................................................................... o Consultant ................................................................................. Add ress .... ............ .................................... ..................... ................. .......................................................................................................... Ph one ... .... ....... ..... ........ ........ ..... ......... ............. ... ....... ....... ..... ... ...... ......................................................................................................... email............................................................................................... Application Requirements Attached are the following items: rsf Site plan o Floor plans o Building elevations r:¥ Photographs o Product information o Other ............................................................................ If the proposed project entails an addition, a new structure or a significant alteration to an existing structure, please submit a site plan, floor plans. building elevations and photographs. If the proposed project is a minor alteration to a structure, please provide drawings and photographs to sufficiently describe the scope of the project. Provide a written description of the proposed project on the second page of this application. Property Information ", 'ì ( ,( à '\' ~ 'I, '~, -'-\" "', - ·'ì\: ,/) ,) Address of property .................'..........;:¡..........,. .(... )..L"..í.....\......... . .................................................................................................................. 'Fb Use of property ....S.......l.................................................................. . IC .~; is ? Date constructed (If known) .........I.......¡,............,............................. Historic Designation o This property is a local historic landmark OR o This property is located in the: o Brown Street Historic District VCollege Green Historic District o East College Street Historic District o Longfellow Historic District o Summit Street Historic District o Woodlawn Historic District o Clark Street Conservation District o College Hill Conservation District o Dearborn Street Conservation District o Lucas-Governor Street Conservation District Within the district, this property is classified as: \,ÇJ/ Contributing o Noncontributing o Nonhistoric Project Type o Alteration of an existing building (ie. siding and window replacement, skylights, window opening alterations, new decks, porch reconstruction, baluster repair or similar) o Addition to an existing building (includes decks and ramps) T5:1 Demolition of a building or portion of a building (ie. porch, chimneys, decorative trim, baluster or similar) o Construction of new building o Repair or restoration of an existing structure that will not change its appearance o Other Project description .....ß.~.11'.1..Ç..>Ú~..l........\-::..f.........~:t.~..\:;!.~.W.~..ç.~......l.ç.¡..x:.Ç.~.Çð;.¿......{..q~.y.1J.Q..\.i.t.fiXJ.J.......±Q........,.ì...¥:¡:ì.:J..\.c.L:.........b..v.=.......... .....!L.)(~............p..(;. .C.t.\..\'lj.............................................................. ..................................... .................................... .......................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .......................... ..................................................................................................... ......... ~..... ........................................................ ... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... Materials to be used .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .....................................................................................................................................................................................................................:............................ .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... Exterior appearance changes .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ppdadrn/HP Handbook/App.p65 ~';....... ì \"'- ...... ~-:> ~;?-) "'" ,,~ ~ , I\~ "'_..~.'~.'~-~"~.~'~." -----I---.·'~'-~··__··..·, ,- I I I , \ ~i --//~ \ ' ..¡:; \\J ~~ ~G: "> _\J \i1 1\1 ":i (~ i ~ .--.--"..- .-..-.-----.--- " , ,,,t,-, ; '\~ ", I ¡~'\ ,\)/,1 I ¡ (~. .0'" I \f,~ 'VI ¡ 1 lI) ¡ ~ I IDS. _j ---~----~- ----,.....---.--.--..--.- I I :) \:::: V '72C¡ c 0'"""' . _r. J ohn<; 0;'\ 10 ?,O- ,~ I \ i I i I ! I I I I /1 I ! i I I I I i I ¡ . ¡ , Sf D r 22-;¡- J- ~ on Y'Só h ---"'~--- !_-~ / . ------,----~--- ---------; 5, Jo \'VìSOV\ S+ -V_~L' , , , , :<'-->.:> i? "-' --, /- ~ ,,, .i'. ,,!-~,.mJ -'~~'11 '~~-k'fugq,'0 \: p'"""-" -'b._ '_Wð,¡!/~L i "'b"Þ','w" , Staff Report Historic Review for 229 S Johnson Street District: College Green Historic District Classification: Contributing November 10,2005 Applicant, Jeff Clark, is requesting approval for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the proposed demolition at 229 South Johnson Street, a contributing property in the College Green Historic District. The applicant intends to demolish a garage to replace it with at grade parking spaces. Applicable Regulations and Guidelines: 7.0 Iowa City Historic Preservation Guidelines for Demolition Staff Comments The house was built in ca. 1910 with the influence of Queen Ann Revival style. The construction date for the single- car garage is not known. If compared with styles prevalent in this and other older Iowa City neighborhoods it appears to be built in 1 nos or 1930s. The garage appears to have borrowed some stylistic features from the craftsman style particularly the (gable) rooflines and window proportions and wide trim. The garage also has shiplap style siding and simple panel door, both commonly found on such garages. Although simple and commonly found, such older garages are frequently demolished for various purposes. As per the guidelines this application is to be reviewed based on the condition, integrity and architectural significance of the garage. Due to lack of maintenance and drainage flow toward the garage walls the structure is deteriorating where it sits on the ground/ foundation. Despite some visible deterioration staff does not feel that the structure is structurally unsound or irretrievable. The application does not provide adequate information demonstrating that the garage is irreparable. In the absence of such condition the guidelines do not allow demolition. Staff recommends that the garage be stabilized so it can be, in future, returned to the original use as a garage. Aþplication for Historic R~~lew Application for alterations to the exterior of historic landmarks or properties located in a historic district or conservation district pursuant to Iowa City Code Section 14-4C. Guidelines for the Historic Review process, explanation of the process and regulations can be found in the Iowa City Historic Preservation Handbook, which is available in the PCD office at City Hall or online at wWw.icgov.orgIHPhandbook. Meeting schedule: The HPC meets the second Thursday of each month. During the summer months, the HPC may also meet on the fourth Thursday. Applications are due in the PCD Office by noon on Wednesday the week prior to the meeting. For Staff Use: Date submitted ...~........L~¡?:..?iPS- o Çertificate of No Material Effect \ -0/ Certificate of Appropriateness "-tJ/ Major review o Intermediate review o Minor review Applicant Information (Please check primary contact person) DOwn er .........;;r. ~.~. .~.t...... s.~..¡.;'.. ........................ .................. Phone ... ..... ..3..?".:J..-:-.. f:? j.8Â... ............... .................................... Address ..........ß.6).....>..:...?P:.~..·...................................... .......................~~....4:.(t't..f....b.ì:1.="..................................... email............................................................................................... ~ Contractor ......4..~~~:4kÌ:>.Œf1..(&1.\~~.~.:Þ..~.~~.. .-J. + ~(h) Address ........5:.J..l.....~.......~~.::..................................... ......... ....................~~...?I.~....,..TA.~......................................... Phone ...............3.~::-..~~?b................................................... email............................................................................................... o Consu Itant ....... ................. ......................................................... Addres s ........ ......... ............. ..... ....... ......... ........ ... ............ ....... ......... ......................................................................................................... Phone ... .... ............ ... ....................... ....... .......... ....... ... ..... .......... ...... ......................................................................................................... email............................................................................................... Application Requirements Attached are the following items: ¡¡( Site plan ¡¡;( Floor plans I:ia" Building elevations ~ Photographs o Product information o Other ............................................................................ If the proposed project entails an addition, a new structure or a significant alteration to an existing structure, please submit a site plan, floor plans. building elevations and photographs. If the proposed project is a minor alteration to a structure, please provide drawings and photographs to sufficiently describe the scope of the project. Provide a written description of the proposed project on the second page of this application. Property Information Address of property .............S.~.l.....S.,....7...~.A.v.~.(........... .................................................................................................................. Use of property ...............~EP.{~.h~.l..:::-..5.i~~!~...F.~~J Iy Date constructed (if known) ............................................................. Historic Designation o This property is a local historic landmark OR ~/ This property is located in the: o Brown Street Historic District o College Green Historic District o East College Street Historic District o Longfellow Historic District o Summit Street Historic District o Woodlawn Historic District o Clark Street Conservation District o College Hill Conservation District œf Dearborn Street Conservation District o Lucas-Governor Street Conservation District Within the district, this property is classified as: ~ Contributing o Noncontributing o Nonhistoric Project Type o Alteration of an existing building (ie. siding and window replacement, skylights, window opening alterations, new decks, porch reconstruction, baluster repair or similar) üÝ Addition to an existing building (includes decks and ramps) o Demolition of a building or portion of a building (ie. porch, chimneys, decorative trim, baluster or similar) o Construction of new building o Repair or restoration of an existing structure that will not change its appearance o Other Project description ..........................ex.k.~........~.~~~~.....:b?.....~.~~+.....~...~.~...!?~~....~~...1.~r::!.~~t.....~.~...1º.~.................................................. ..........................f:.:.~4!;~A.......1.~.~~~~.':......~f......~.~~.~............................................................................................................................... ...........................±;.~.~~l!.......r:!.~.~.....~~.~\....~.~~..~..~~~....f.~~...f.~......................................................... ........................f.I~~.?~...~.\.!.I.....~.....~.>:':.!!.?.+.:I..~~.:.................................................................................................................................... .........................~......~~.y..~......~.~~.~.~}.....~.......~~~\.~.......~.~\\..!?.t....~.~.f.~...................................................................... ...........................W.~.I~.~~.~....(!,.~.....~.~!-..~~~....~.ç,...~.t~...~.¡I.\..~.~..~~~.....b...~.'~..tf!.?....~....'f.~'fQ............... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... Materials to be used ......................s'.&.l1Mj..:::-......Ir.~.~.~....~~...?~.~~..................................................:.......................................................................................... ít..<'M - Pl~-rtlf"-~- f:.::.-r ~_ið_ke- ....,....-,dt{: ............................................................................................................................~...........~....i?.................................................................,.................. ................!:':-!..~J?~~.f!.::-:.....~....~(......~...1::!!....~.~~....~.~~.~..~...š...4~...~...~(~:?.~......f.¡Jf.~.4.....~~~~..~..~t..~..t.:~~.t.:: -fo ~t~'.A.. £"I!>h~ :::::::::::::::::Ä~:;::::::4;;;:~+:::þ.:~;J;::;:::::~:~::~::::t.;::~~::~::::~;~~I~~::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................;.................................................................................. Exterior appearance changes .............................A.....~/.~J~.....~<f...?5....~..~~....y.~.r.~.d.......±.~.~~...~..L~~.~~..~.)..I.~...!e:1?,.....~.....~.i4............. .............................P~.~..~~4.e....~.....&.t.y.\&:...±k.....~.~?~}~J....~k~....~.~..~...e~~..!~~..~.~t~~.:' ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ppdadm/HP HandbooklApp.p65 ........ z ~;:... ..;¡ II ~~ ¡.;¡So ¡...;::;; "'" IJJ <> ~ EXISTING HOUSE 5'd' 5"010'/ GARAGE ADDITION ' GARAGE 15ff>" !j' t'011 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Z ~ IJ '..;, t;J~~ [;lo1 < . ~~~ ~~~ z 9 .;::¡ !:: ~ . ~<~ ~~ U ~r---< ~~~ [;lo1NO 00"".... ,J) Up,', z o ¡:: ~ 7; ¡,;.¡ :I: !-' ~ :I: U ¡:<: o Q., Q ~ ¡,;.¡ ~ u '" I l I l 1 I I I i .~ ¡ 01 '0\ Z ¡,;.¡ -¡ :I: u i ... i ~ j :;; 0 0 ¡:<: ~ Q :I: U ¡:<: 0 Q., Q ~ ¡,;.¡ ~ u '" .... Q( ø:: , I :E o ~ <.) § Q ¡:<: .", "Ç/~Z '~_~i L "o,")ç I' ''''''ï ~. .---- I, :E o ~ <.) ~ .J III ~ ø:: ~ r---~l I 1 I I L,..-",j,....-'-'--.. :E o o ¡:<: ~ .J \ rl is I! : ~ l:_ ¡- "1 I 1 I J r'-':- ') .... ¡:<: ;Q -·--"..-i~ I (/ &) , , ,- - €& 1 I z· 8-;;' ¡... . ¡SS:; ~~ ¡:=¡..J ~¡:". ~~ ¡:".o 00 ~..J ¡:".~ I ''''I j I ¡ì ;;.. II -0 ~~ Oz ::r::~ ~~ ~~ 1;;0 ~o ¡,.¡¡i z o ..... E-i ~ ~;., ...;¡ " ¡¡¡¡¡ ~ =~ E-i.... ~ o z I ~ ~ '" ~ '" 0 "t 0 z ~ ~~;:j ~ig ~..~ .....0 Ilì..... ð S~~ §<b ~~ u <r-< ¡::¡~:i ~&JS -;---"",,1fì fTTL II ,_"I,., " I ,II ,f+1,'FR"i ,,~i 'I \ ìtt::tr:-~ I' ,', 'i' I r~' , ,\ [i rhrr~T]~ ..,1 I! [±:it: 111 ,I "r,IJ ;1 _" ¡ IT"-'- _/ _ I I d z o - Eo-; < > ~ ¡;¡¡¡- ~ II ¡;¡¡¡ ~ Eo-; ~~ r::rJ .".' ~ ~ ¡:Q .... ~ ,., 1 <= ~ .. ~ ~~:$ ~"Ë ~h ~ S ~;:;¡. §<C:: ~~ b ~~~ ¡¡]~9 - ,,~ -,. , J ". , ; \~"(( 'Ai "-{,.' , :mK"~"-- ,;h) ,~y '''c- , ';,- " .,,- 'y "" -~ ~, ,",,'- ,Jj -FJi' ','., , ---,- -j,-; "'f " d¡ ~,4 ,~wþ jF , f _w §!L. ,'. -',!% "",f'""'" ,'?'\I"- .0'. '-} i<\:"f¡i; ,'-, \,~t;&"" /'" i!&¡'b~':4;JJ'0 '"' ~"'. "", ,x, _', "" ');>' ,¡P ,~- "",, fd ~',J' ,.;,_:'.;,;f!!f >,___,.,,/f', ." 18 ¥ - ~"',' '!':v",.- .~, _"i"exe, ~: ' "'ft.'--P'- ,cliA, :,; "_' _,)-"., ,'v,_", .,.' .,;.;, _ _,_ j "'-_,v, ,,;->_-, "-."",',-,';;;!': ''',,',' ;;,':./,,\.'¡(G;i.~'¡/':/""'~X'-;¡;¡;j!i:'\""¥I- ;;&+., _"1 'u,$;(¿~A'fl'-;';';'+~@;"I":";%'<-Yif,,¡¡¡'!jPi)\'i{ff5;'å.)¥gt&.'.;;f5f"I'\\\,1\0;\iti:1ì.\';~ý,\i;;, , ",'" ill' ,'W '.- _vw~~,_Ó',,, -,~"" ,'v"-' ,',',-,' ,,---,-, _iMn_ ,."W'" ' u " ~{.)' ,_, '''''''' , ,-"'}Ff'''''''-'-'''?'''--'''' _"," '-,,'--.-0" '",.,,-,,--" - ., d'~" ,/,'.-" fj'"f,è." -,7.*7*;''''Ú--- f",/ - _.,,,,,,-,'- p"- ',-' -" ' . -- '"" ' ",', ,', ,,"/',' ", , , , u "'<;; -,," u'~ " >w '"\. t"" ""'Þ, " · · , ~ f \ 0; t ,. · i · j ;, '-, -';.;J;;;;..\. ,,¿;h'<::'- r"" .', :"/~L~"'P '> \~.i;;;,WF;Yf-!0~:":;",:,~:;~ _._..;¡¡__ , , U·'«FL,,_·,, _.;:«5" " ^' ~,. H '.'< ~. - ~^ - ~'m_ -,- , "j. , , , , .p" , "i"V ,;/,,--' ,j'-'" ,.,,, u" ',/< , -- ,;~ ·:NWi4'" '-': ,*'" <'iiWl', '~ ' .-' , , y,. .,&f, ,^"~,, '" , - . "' ,.-",. '''''''''', , , ',W8 ',M"';""';""" -,Ù\'!¡wx "0;\911; ,,",V -,,-,"Xi" -"~,,--, ,,', _w. -,-,,- . , 'n'7'V ",,', "' ". ---~- , ,,-'S.' '.-. ~ - ,', , , "' ,þ- ~' . \ . - ""::;>-;,;,!i0~- /'" ',,, eh'" ~c_,-, ".":/. ,..,-;,' '"'0<"_ -.,. "--,'" ,w_, -K' -~-,<>:-"'-:; '.'>'>- "' .._-~" »"-'ë'0""""., ""_-,~,,,~,,^_,_ - _ ;"Ä~YYßi~:'(n;ÞÞ;¡';?--;WRPW«þ\t""'"'"!'<S"ØÄ'''',W$.l'''/N'4iMY_ ·W~'~«-·,;/ð;:M-_ '.,. ·"'i'.',' ~;'" ,. "" ,,,ó.,'.,', .!h""" '";'n _.",- ',,", _.W".'<- "/'- -""''"'',",,",'',;,,' ,""',' ,,",,",,".,' ~""";"' '>'--""". ..,0.' """;<, -'",',' ;t%?;_,~___' ',,, N"__'''''''''' '\\',_"§'j;"1.;.- _.~ -~C " '" -,',', ",,,,,,<- ,.,"",. ',,,.,,- ''''.'' _,m" "'=.·=w' """""',", "~-' ",,',' ,,---~,,^ "".",,,," 7"='. ",/&\'('-;",-",' -"., .",,#'i> "-.- "' ',', *>' ,~~" ".",,'hw. ,"'~""" -"",,"' ,,,d,c;.,, .",,,..',,v'; ",- -, ",,,,,,~.,,,, ~"=" ., do"" . ,""',~" "'N"" ,," <"."", ,,,,,,., ~'",~",- , -"..j, ",M"" ""N ',...,." -'",'" ¡".y:-" ,--" "" ,,,',, "", ',"" , ',,- --:-",:- ,m ,',,' ,""" -""--,, ,',' ¡ ,è ,,--:;2'0 ' 0þ'b¡þ,,,,,,,,tø , """~"",,, ",' ','1:;,;;\"0,,\ , ,_, i(;,~-: '_:¿1,:,,>SJi:'>Z<,~~Kit~~~ìì~:¡~~!1Þry~~?,-,.,,/!, .. ,l,,;:S\0N"k' 'F,',-,?" -" "",W,--'''!,j"''''''''-' ..t-_" ',,_ ,",'. ,"-- _,Hy , .< ',_'" .(?3/y,';~Y'1~+¡>2, ;(':,-" ':"'>;';"??;~U';';;'fg~.:lU<'il:-itft:\/p};'~:;:"NNi:t:'2~,ir:;_"{}:¥¡\:~:~::Jf,, ,_ X,/ "A;,: ,;ç~""" ,-' ;¡dW-%ttt~;:i1&':-;L9¿fW;~~;Si;;;,¡:'__¡, "r¡)\%\:'';:::-;!Æ)%~V!-!'U~$.àij0~,,º'Ì¿1\\';Si\-'t:{'%1B!'~Ä;'':0:'f,>;t\;ti;)¡<ii'!W--,~ '--'-" ,",-, ..,-- -', ,,- ,,' ,,' ',', !",'ft--, '0',..-,,'-' ," ",-',,:""," ,"" >." ""-'Yw¡ m d,,'__" ,"- F1!0B¡¡j(" ., ''''''%ì: ';¡$¥itifi~~~r~i\lf~~~~;g,î\?~Jlj~tDíll:f'1.Œ'~:~I~f~t~'I il~~:::t~ltJøì~¿!it~~~lt~{5~:t'Å-),;Ki ", '" "", ,',,,, ,,,, ,''-'' ,,-, ", ' ,-,,' " ,'" '",'",,,,,', Ji' '-',A '»' ,d;-'..__'".-,','"',--,j ';Yh_(,:v,;-, '''i'-' -_: ',,<:>-,> y,'>¡;"ó,/!',;',\'F" ~"-'-\!"';<-:þg\' ,.. Staff Report November 10,2005 Historic Review for 821 S. 7th Avenue District: Dearborn Street Conservation District Classification: Contributing Applicant, Janet Seiz, is requesting approval for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the proposed addition at 821 South 7th Avenue, a contributing property in the Dearborn Street Conservation District. The proposed addition is at the back of the existing house. Applicable Regulations and Guidelines: 7.0 Iowa City Historic Preservation Guidelines for Demolition Staff Comments The house was built in ca. 1940 with La te 19th or Early 20th English Cottage architectural style influenced with some influence of Ranch style. Original siding for this gabled house has been replaced. At the back of the house are two additions, a screened porch and a kitchen "bump-out" measuring 10 feet x 4 feet. I t is unclear if this "bump-out" kitchen is original or a later addition. The applicant proposes to extend the "bump-out" by 6 feet (effectively 10 feet x 10 feet). For the proposed addition, on the west façade, the applicant intends to use a window that is slightly shorter (by 2 inches) than tl1e existing window. The proposed window on the north façade matches an existing window on the same façade. The applicant intends to use wood for siding, trim, and windows and concrete block for foundation with similar features as the existing house. The applicant proposes to use a trim board to distinguish the house and both old and new the addition. In the absence of evidence that the "bump-out" is a later addition and to better depict the new addition, staff feels that the trim should be used to distinguish the new addition and existing structure. This could be added as a condition for approval. Staff finds that the addition generally is consistent with the guidelines and recommends approval. A~plication for Historic R~;;diew Application for alterations to the exterior of historic landmarks or properties located in a historic district or conservation district pursuant to Iowa City Code Section 14-4C. Guidelines for the Historic Review process. explanation of the process and regulations can be found in the Iowa City Historic Preservation Handbook, which is available in the PCD office at City Hall or online at www.icgov.org/HPhandbook. Meeting schedule: The HPC meets the second Thursday of each month. During the summer months, the HPC may also meet on the fourth Thursday. Applications are due in the PCD Office by noon on Wednesday the week prior to the meeting. Applicant Information (Please check primary contact person, < Owner ....&>..b.....CP..f..~~~\\.~.j~~.~.~...?trc :::~:s·~·::3::\5:::::::B[º:yj:n:::::;Sf[¿a:::::::: ................:¡;:þ.~....CA~........................................... ~:~~~~~~·;::::6:(:i~~ú::::::C6r.i$hi\dici Add,,,,.P',o.,..:&~~.;!'.tl,>.t.m. ....·..·....·...Io·~·....C.\..t:~/.I...IA........,~? Phone ..e9..Jf.-::..~.3.~'i.....................................:....... ~:~~;;=~;....&lli...~~~......... Address ...........6.r)~~.Y.)................0§............~ ...................,...........................................·····..·c:d'r·········..·········,· Phone .....ð~5..:...7.7..1.9............................................ ~·~~;;·:eEij\bifh:~n:::~::ri)~ri:~:~ Application Requirements Attached are the following items: ~e plan r::(' /1001' plans 11' ßuilding elevations 13'" ßl'r6tographs (!(' Product information o Other ............................................................................ If the proposed project entails an addition, a new structure or a significant alteration to an existing structure, please submit a site plan, floor plans. building elevations and photographs. If the proposed project is a minor alteration to a structure, please provide drawings and photographs to sufficiently describe the scope of the project. Provide a written description of the proposed project on the second page of this application. For Staff Use: . (i) 1\// () ,?/¡y:: Date submitted .................... ........:..!...:...;............. o Certificate of No Material Effect \q:( Certificate of Appropriateness \.-e('" Major review o Intermediate review o Minor review Property Information Address of property ....3.15......6..cQ.w.Q...§t..:....... ··;,çQ.~~!:Vrmm Use of property ....6.\.~\.~......~.~.Ly......b.º..~ 'e Date constructed (if known) ............................................................. Historic Designation o This property is a local historic landmark OR ~hiS ~erty is located in the: ~own Street Historic District o College Green Historic District o East College Street Historic District o Longfellow Historic District o Summit Street Historic District o Woodlawn Historic District o Clark Street Conservation District o College Hill Conservation District o Dearborn Street Conservation District o Lucas-Governor Street Conservation District Wi~the district. this property is classified as: ~ Contributing o Noncontributing o Nonhistoric Pr~ct Type []tJ""" Alteration of an existing building (ie. siding and window replacement, skylights, window opening alterations, new ~ecks, porch reconstruction, baluster repair or similar) if YJdítion to an existing building (includes decks and ramps) ~ Demolition of a building or portion of a building (ie. porch, chimneys, decorative trim, baluster or similar) o Construction of new building o Repair or restoration of an existing structure that will not change its appearance o Other Project description ~ ~p.:bq.~Pº~Ø\I~:5:\ço.Lb.~Iþ'q;?·m~ ....................a..V).~.........~ro.....£\OOC........6µ.r.).COO.ffi.~..........,........................................................................................... ....................AaÓ\}i~;-o......ð..O....}:~f.:..ëtÇ.......F.CïJ..i.¿~ï;iX:iij.....º(\¡6±;çbr ......................~lX..i.~/j.......O:f.\......óeCOr)Q...£.\ooC~......A!.e&Q.......'OO..................6~p...±....r~...º..ls:,. I~:W(.~Qdd\fiQD\âdiÙ1ei.;m0dC~;ï.~Ù?~ .......................±...................r0..~...~.....C.~.ffi....:...A....~.......eJ0.c)d~~S.....é:11...........y......±a...þg..... ···············....···..···t':C·t·..~········..···..········..·····1..]···1····································\·······.J.......................,...................~ed'..................,.................. ..,l:;;-:::r\Q.;¿CQ,QŒJ~\!\C<.\J.U~....e.¥~m~º'6.m-- ..............:.......b~.c~.m...~....~6........................±.......m~1e¿j?~:n..\........................................................ ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... Materials to be used d '\J . ~m,b.r.::.§~~~m3········A\L.TIi.v.rn.:.W:I PQ~?,,\D!\:w~\!?I::f(qt.c.a~(~e,¡çI?+¡!:',1t±r.:\~ 6~~ÛmU) .. .~Jdeþ.KdOO'.cºQooìt~ ..........................6......\~.\.~......rº.a::Ç......Lg.~.p.~.~11.)..................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ~~~~~i:~ÃírQnc±~m~æ~hº~~··SOOY\¡f¡C£m .....................\..Q..'.~Ö.u)5.......l..n.........K\.................ro....±ø.......ª~º".nYJ.c.v~i:e........COu..Û±er.s. ......................Q.n.......~........¿.\d.e....af:......hº.~9~..~....................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... ........................................................................................................................................................................................................... ppdadm/HP Handbook/App.p65 --I 1---- , , I I , i ! , I \ , '-- -- I I : , , : ~~_w-----l I ! I~ T__ i I I ' , I I I I , , -~,--) I I (---'- , , I I 'ì '" , , I I , , I I , , I \ , , I I I I , , I I , , I I , , I I , , I I , , I I , , I I , , I ! I , , I I , , I I , , I I , , I I , , I ! Q):e;:;~~FPLAN æ i I , L_____________~ \. Two .s+oíi . fíOpO~CI.. Rt:b\" Aòcll+\01ì \ 6-t ...ç\oo\" -? I~ X).4 2 ",cI -Ç leo' ~ q X ;z '-/ \' , -' pcr\Y'Y AXW bClQ..." Slo..?f? ' v NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION CORNELL-STRODE RESIDENCE ADDITION ~ I~ 315 BROWN STREET IOWA CITY, IA 52245 ~.-/ ~ JW vr¡¡:';~ 3S~~ aM Ó~{q ____ -......="< ~~..~ '",0 ,"'..."';;;; '" ,._~"u.<..",~""",,,,, --~, ,...""...""",-" ""',="--....:"""':O''-"'I''''''iI'''''=·.<'''''-~.^''' r~~~....~='.. '-. "~~'~~"-'-"'.'""".' ~ x.(Jr.'_O """"~- I Bedroom 1 ,~ -y /.' /:f/ Bedroom 2 - ~] I II à ¡ \ location. ~ ~ ..1 I // '/,~II '" /' ~ ,./" \(' ¡;." /,,/'/ "" Save door & hardware for reinstallation @ different J If' i~ ==t <-----~'----_.-.----'l'i I __-- 2. t' c\ -f \O(J)¡\ ",tL:' _-i l) .,.---.)0 NOTES 1. Patch & repair wall to match extg plaster as required 2, Protect exlg wood floors during demolition & construction. r Remo~e v, inyl nearing & )/ adhesive NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION I CORNELL-STRODE RESIDENCE ADDITION 315 BROWN STREET IOWA CITY,IA 52245 (^\/ r "'iLJ .. ':/ \¿/' ,- i I p-=~= ==:r=rr" J I· ....... ß~ 'V tV Bedroom 3 f'ìI\STbi< SW Ire Living Room .--..---......-- --->---------.-. I 6 I I Dc"¡;? I LT Rdoc.C\1e ro.c\ ''''.(0\- +0 Céll~t[ c;o.Ç. roo \'V\ Dining Room / / ,»---~ I I \ \ \3 lr¡1 "': o;¡~ : ~ - t ~ - "0 :;; :z ~..., -7) -c:: (gj .mm!. [ StAN «:OOfl\ ....-ff'.M \ 1-Y ROOM Is-\- f~oo(' FOR CONSTRUCTION I CORNELL-STRODE RESIDENCE ADDITION 315 BROWN STREET IOWA CITY, IA 52245 "__ _, "o~_.',__.'~><_"-""''''''.'.<'._"_''''''_'~'__'~ _~...._._,.__...___~c_~._.___~~....._......",""__'''''7'>«~'M.'=''_'':'~"~_~<'__"'A'~__""""~_'."~~=""'-""'~'=-"-' ,-._..·v_" .-,.,-- -.",~~",,,~. -,.~'_'_' (.: NOTES: 1, Paint addition & repaint house in 3~color scheme as noled, r--' /--- Tuckpoin\ / exl9, chimney /// /' Pnt color 2: Corner bds & water table. /' ---¡ ,_,J- Eave bd" clOwn I moulding, & fnze bd to , malch e'19 / Pnt color 2: Gable wall shingles / Fiber cement bd. wall singles - exposure to match extg Pnt color 3: Eave, frieze & bds, & window & door trim. / .-- Wdw trim & drip cap to match extg Fiber cement bd. siding· exposure to match extg. siding Pnt color 1: Clap bd siding New enlry canopy & brackels V)=d S+ü ( ,', 6óoc + b '/ i~Ct)( 4" r,¡\¡;;,! d Fn:;.:'\+ ~ Door Irim & drip cap \0 / match extg NtW PO'2..iJ . vJood P H \,IJ II\cbuJ5 \ù! +n rY\ +0 yt\C>..~h b~hJ' New stoop, sìairs & railing - pnld, 5 Pone] S-+i30\ IN.U I. \)Dor -to -eC\~ÆÎn(,{'r-t -onc, foundation - plaster. Paint in color to match extg foundation Addition II CD ~~EU,;'.~,.;LEVATION NOT FOR CONSTRUCTIOJ I CORNELL-STRODE RESIDENCE ADDITION 315 BROWN STREET IOWA CITY, IA 52245 - -"'-'-';;:- ,. -- ---~-_'-::-CO~"~- NGW V'07,7..1 ~j --- - - --I -~--= --2~Itt~~ //=1 c=c-- _Sr--:-- -\18[111 O'-;~'''' ,0 rD ~ New entry canopy & brackets· pnld New stoop, stair & baluster· pnld CD ~~~4'~':;V A TION . ~-~c_,· xlg house CeM~ brd (o.p 6\O\"~ -'rö (\\ C\..1, i£)\; o C 1,3 \ \"1 \ Cl ¡ NOT FOR CONSTRUCTIOr I CORNEll-STRODE RESIDENCE ADDITION 315 BROWN STREET IOWA CITY, IA 52245 ==-J D uu D______m_ - "-~---.._"--"_.- - ----'==~=.~,...., - - -- - -- -- -~....""'.._----~..,.~.." -._----- - -------..--. .._--'-'~.. --- ~-_._-- __pu__._ ___..__.__ I] ;=:D:1DJ~= r~ - ------- -.-...------ .' -------- --------... .---- __._·,_.__......._n_._____.___.._ _____n__n______ _____ _._.···.._.___n____m___ . ____n._ .__________ ---------_.~--.._.._._-- -. .--------------- --- Extg house J Addition NÒJJ PO'Z7; WII&J\DS --------- ------ CD ::.~:.~;EVATION NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION CORNEll-STRODE RESIDENCE ADDITION 315 BROWN STREET IOWA CITY, IA 52245 4{: ¡'t",: t ~~ v .. -"~.. _.. .--, ' o v c" I r~' v' o J~ " ;; s· f'?~ c...5 0: z c f' ",-. 'Ie g¡;I¡:~~,~ _.~,~-- ~ ~~ 01 o C' I e- o: u ~ w ::J ,~ ''''::.' i/S; '. ------ -- c' '" l) ~. ~~ I' ~ '" - - R~ r~, ~ . v '"" cr, co "', _.--~-~- Dr :l:IJlaF!iii'iF' 'i',iiT::Y U ;,..J.:":.- . ',-'. . ",.-',"'."'.::".:'.--"'. '- .___ ! _~_!~:::;i:' F _11-<: "II' ~ '''.:-=----~-.. ' 1 .~ - ~- ~"r,.,.",..-.~~,~""., ,. I ' , . ~,'?""~- -------- v '" cr: '-!O v f-, ~ '=' '--:j" ':" ~~ r--, -- : -~~ --- ',' g~ R~ r-- .:1"'_'0' ,~:.- "'it ----.-- t ~ ,... -~ - '-" ., > ~- ---- ::0 «,:"" ~s i, (" c' " z :; ~ . ,;:= ¡) ] - i @ .~ ~ g §1~oo ~~1~l~, j '~.,,::' <..> .. :: :- ~.§ ni ;~ 'Ì' ,~ '-:j"' ..;: -'" l' -f:¡ ~§ 'Ì'~ "".. o- r-- N 'v '. 0 ~ , ~ ~ ~ £ ,~ ~ c ~ fj -" .2 c- 'J ~ L: -0 .s ~ c 'D o ~ '0 ~ o CD ~ m [ S ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;: 0 ~. on 1 -: ~ ~ "' ~ "' ~ c :g ~ -5 .g \- .~ ~ j 'ª ~ GJ ~ 'D 0 : ~ i (J'I v; c <J) ro E Uì~~~ > U QJ fQ > ~ ~ ~ o « J:: ~ o 0 ru Z g f\1 [ > ~ ; ~ > 0 rtI -g ~ 0 ~~:-o~ Z~~~~ :J>-ru\lJ~ I ~ -C ~ ~ Uo ~ % ~ ~ ~ E S C D ~ 0 ~ ~ j on 0 0 s ~ ~ :0 ~ S ~ -" è ~ 0 C' ~ 'D 'D .2 ~ 'D .<õ 0 g' ~ ~ c ~ ~ ~ I u.J ~ .-J 0 -g co~ ::J ~ o ~ o :i' ~ ~ > u o ~ ~ ~ (; ~ ~ .g, ~ £ ~ 'P ; i ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~ ii; ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ rt.i > :.c ~ ~ ~ D" ~- ~ -D "ê t :~~~ L3 2 (lI:,;,,~i; 3§~ ~'O U; " ,_~- L~ i , ~ ~ ~ S f ~ ru = ,,0 \~ '0 u i' ~ ~ E <: 2: ~ Õ tlJ ,s~ ~ l-' <'J ~~~~ ~[" .2~ ~ g~~~~ ~¡;~ -"e' u ~s<D~m G''''':S: c~",ru :g~~I1! 7~3 ~ ,~ nl~ ~! ~ ~ i~! ~ ~ èj_1 ~,~ ~ U( )GJ- ~,Io~ ~Oì~ -6 -;. 08 ~~ -¡:í:;;:gi~~~ \iWL~!¡¡:ah 1 '!wHI!! ¡¡ H î! o 0 <t .;j .s 0 ~ - .c "J ;;¡ " ~ " - C D ~ U D è; D c, D U -2 Q 0 -;:; (; '" ::, r 0 , ;ë: c ;:> '" Ö <D C a· D 0 I ~ ro ~ 0 0 c ! a· 0 ~ ro 0 'D Q S ~ ~ " 0 'D 0 D " 0 'D " U cD ro 0 ~ ~ C) ~. .~ 'D :; 'D (; <D " > .2 0 " ~ ; "ô 'D ro '5 -D ~ l .2 ~ :; " j ~ 'Õ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ 0 c ?; cD 0 on - 'D 0 'D on ~ E u " D i " 0 'D ~ Õ ~ -0 0 0 L ! ª Q 8 ~ s 0 'D co 'D U ~ " ~ ~ ; s 0 w ~ 'D ~ L 'D -D E .2 'D W C 0 > ~ S ro "' ~ ~ ,¡; " 'D D ~ > 0 > ~ ,¡; -D 0 0 '0 D U 0 " ro 0 U ~ D 0 0 0 ~ E ro ~ 0 S " :'- c -c; cc 0 'D " ,. ~ co 0 E ~ ~ m " ~ l' co 3-' co ~ '6. v; U 0. 3-' c 'D I " C) 0 " u 0 , ro ro , , m Z 'D g 0 L S 0 '" D "' 0 0 ~ ~2 ~ s ~ " '~ (lI '" 0 ~ CO ~ > rc.~ ;; :s: 0 ;:; 0 ro u ~ E 0 ~ w <'J " x E 0 ~ (lI E CO ~ 0 " ~ ~ 0. 'D .2 ro ~ <'J 'D ~ ~ ~ C 0 u " 0 0 ,0 ~ " "' - ~ '¡:O s 0 0 '" 0 ~ '" 'D 0- :~ 0 ~ ¡ ~ '" 0 i ~ l 0 ~ 'D 0 ~ 0 U .'L E -5 u '§i ro D 0 "0 .;¡: ¡ 0 0 8 0 ~ ~ C ~ & ~ 0 :a 0 Õ E 0 <'J <t > 0 'D "1 D ~ " - ~ ~ ~ ~ '2 ~ ;: ~ .... ; ~ 'D ~ ëu '" 0 ~ 0. '~ 0 ~ m <'J ,ï ~ ~ 'D 0 ro U 3 0. "0 ~ 'D '" 'D E L 0. g' 'D W C '" (; "' ~ ~ ~ Õ 8 ~ ~ ru ~ 'D .~ ~ 'D ¿ 0 ~ 0 ~ ~ 0 L CO 0 0 0 '" ~ m U Z ~ ~ ro '6. ~ u 0 0< c o c ~ ~ ~ ~ Q , Rt 2 ~ " D; l~ o ô c 0 ~ ~ ~~ ~ '5 ~ o u ;;; ;¡lUt'Jlj) P'::¡'jS1ì()J L ì JUIQjl'") " _. . P·JII'dllfJ - s-;,} ...c? '2 ,:;,-:::. v, ;," ~ E l~) ~ '" ~ o o ~ co ? .~ m I .~ r\ i - \ i ~ ~j~"" .Š ::3'.,N -6' Ë:;:-' ~ ~ '~[Al~ ! ~"'1" ~' ç; ,- ~ E ~ ~' ~ g ê ~ ,~ ~ 6 ~ ' :~ §~~ ~~r¡¡s~É~' gc:g~;22' ~~g~àªg "tJ' $' " ° " " ~.~ ~ c 2 " . g. G L ~ .~ 0, " .~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ , ° ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ o ' ^ ~ ~ f '" -2 ~ q) ~ & D -~ ~ -2" ~ ~ J ~'~ ~ g 8; u c; ~ -g ~ u U -.= ~ S ê~ CJ) :~-':~2 ~~~,~.E?~ ~ _~ "-' _ > c uCi~.cU~ 23~~-~~~ > _~ ~ _"=~ "~ c g§:' ~, ~.~ ~l '" w U L ~ ~ ::J ~ <'J .2' 0' o CO <'J w c 2 0 ~ Q "0 ~ "0 <'J " 0 ~ D ! e, " 5 ::::> " ~ ~o (lI x '" "0 o o S ., ~ .~ ~ CIJ..c: ~ 0 V1 S õ