Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout07-12-2007 Planning and Zoning Commission PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION Monday, July 9, 2007 - 5:15 PM Informal Meeting Iowa City City Hall Lobby Conference Room 410 E. Washington Street Thursday, July 12, 2007 -7:30 PM Formal Meeting Iowa City City Hall Emma J. Harvat Hall 410 E. Washington Street AGENDA: A. Call to Order B. Public Discussion of Any Item Not on the Agenda C. Comprehensive Plan Item: Consider setting a Public Hearing for July 19 for an amendment to the Northeast District Plan modifying the plan map for the Lindemann Hills Neighborhood to incorporate a large institutional use into the conceptual street pattern north of the public square along Lower West Branch Road. D. Annexation/Rezoning Item: ANN07-00002/REl07-00010: Discussion of an application for annexation of 14 acres of land owned by Henrietta Miller and 1.89 acres of land owned by the City of Iowa City located north of Lower West Branch Road, north of Brentwood Drive and Broadmoor Lane and the rezoning of 14 acres from County Residential (R) to Low Density Single Family Residential (RS-5) and approximately 1.89 acres from County Residential (R) to Neighborhood Public (P-1 ). E. Development Items: SUB06-00003: Discussion of an application submitted by Dav-Ed Limited for a preliminary plat of Galway Hills Parts 10 & 11, a 53-lot, 21.75 acre residential subdivision located at Dublin Drive & Shannon Drive. (45-day limitation period: July 23,2007) SUB07-00004/SUB07-00005: Discussion of an application from Tyler Rogers for a preliminary and final plat of North Fifty First Subdivision, a 3-lot, 3.00 acre residential subdivision located west of Kansas Avenue, south of IWV Road SW. (45-day limitation period: August 2, 2007) F. Vacation Item: VAC07-00004 Discussion of an application submitted by University of Iowa to vacate a portion of Court Street west of Madison Street and Front Street south of Burlington Street. G. Adjournment Informal Formal City of Iowa City MEMORANDUM July 12, 2007 To: Planning and Zoning Commission From: Karen Howard, Associate Planner Re: REZ07 -00010 - Comprehensive Plan Amendment and Conditional Zoning Agreement When the City received applications for annexation and rezoning from St. Patrick's Church for a 14-acre property north of the proposed public square along Lower West Branch Road (ANN07- 00002/REZ07-00010), the question was raised whether such a large institutional use in this location would be compatible with the principles, goals, and objectives of the Northeast District Plan. The plan describes this area of the Northeast District as the "Lindemann Hills Neighborhood," which features traditional neighborhood development served by a grid-like street pattern radiating out from an approximately 2-acre public square located along Lower West Branch Road. The public square is intended to function as a neighborhood focal point. To that end, the plan emphasizes interconnected streets extending from the four corners of the square, with sidewalks and trail connections that ensure good vehicular, pedestrian, and bicycle circulation between residences, the public square, and other important neighborhood destinations, such as neighborhood commercial areas and the linear open space along the stream corridors that flow north-south along both the eastern and western edges of the neighborhood. The plan states that the modified grid street system will help disperse vehicular traffic more evenly throughout the area and will further the goal of having parks and neighborhood commercial areas that are accessible by foot or bike, as well as by car. There are several factors that will make it challenging to incorporate a large church property into the plan for the neighborhood: · The church property extends more than 1000 feet north of the public square, thereby reducing the number of east-west street connections possible within the neighborhood; · The church is purchasing property on three sides of the public square; · The church will generate a significant amount of traffic concentrated at times when services are being held. To explore ways of accommodating the church, the City hired a land planning consultant, Brenda Nelson of Nelson Design P.L.C, to develop an alternative street pattern that might mitigate the factors cited above and maintain the principles of the Northeast District Plan. Ms. Nelson has submitted the attached plan map for the Lindemann Hills Neighborhood. Staff finds that this alternative plan successfully incorporates the following elements: · Streets that connect to the public SQuare and provide aood traffic circulation - The 14- acre church parcel includes street connections to the northeast and northwest corners of the public square to ensure good public access to this focal point of the neighborhood. On the plan map these streets radiate out from the square in a curvilinear pattern to provide a collector street to serve future residential areas east and west of the church property and provide connections to arterial streets, Taft Avenue and Herbert Hoover Highway. A second collector street located east of the church property would provide a north-south connection from Lower West Branch Road to Herbert Hoover Highway. A number of the blocks along these streets are illustrated with rear alleys, similar to what is 1 currently shown in the District Plan. These alleys will allow for an increased number of home lots along these higher volume streets without sacrificing traffic and pedestrian safety. · Street access to the church property from the north - There is a local street illustrated along the northern edge of the church property to provide a future means of access to the church from the north. An institutional use of this size is likely to generate a significant amount of traffic when services are being held. Providing for a second means of access to the property will help to disperse traffic during these peak times. · East-west bicycle/pedestrian connections to and across the church property - Potential pedestrian connections are illustrated on the map that extend to the church property from future neighborhood streets east and west of the church. Staff recommends that at the time of development, the church determine a location for a public access easement extending east-west across the center of the property to allow east-west pedestrian and bicycle travel as an alternative to streets that would have otherwise been built in this location. · Parks and trails that take advantaoe of natural features - The plan map illustrates two linear parks with trails connections centered on the stream corridors in the eastern and western sections of the neighborhood. The park to the west shows how the existing pond, currently located on a large estate, could be retained as open space if this property were ever to be subdivided and incorporated into the city for urban development. Similar to the current Northeast District Plan, a linear park and trail connection is illustrated along Ralston Creek as it parallels Taft Avenue in the eastern section of the Lindemann Hills Neighborhood. A designated pedestrian connection between these two linear parks is shown along the future street along the northern boundary of the church property. A wide sidewalk would be appropriate along this street to accommodate pedestrians and bicyclists traveling between these trail corridors. · A variety of housino options - In keeping with the original principles of the Northeast District Plan, this alternative plan map illustrates how a variety of housing types can be integrated into the Lindemann Hills Neighborhood, including detached single family, attached single family (townhouses and zero lot line dwellings), and multi-family. Development of townhouses would be particularly suited to areas where there are single-loaded streets, such as along park boundaries and along the street just north of the church. Multi-family and townhouse development is also appropriate along arterial streets, which will be designed to handle the amount of traffic generated by these higher density housing types. Incorporating rear alleys along collector streets within the neighborhood will provide the opportunity for smaller, more affordable home lots. Staff finds that the attached alternative plan map retains the general concepts and principles of the Northeast District Plan, while accommodating the future development of a large institutional use on property north of the public square along Lower West Branch Road. The principles of the plan can be achieved by ensuring street connections to the northeast and northwest corners of the public square; providing an east-west pedestrian link across the church property; and ensuring that street access will be available in the future along the church's northern boundary. Staff recommends that these elements be illustrated on the plan map for the Lindemann Hills Neighborhood and incorporated into the Northeast District Plan by amendment. Conditional Zoning The church is in the beginning stages of site planning and is not ready to build. In addition, it may be years until the surrounding land is annexed into the City for development. Staff finds 2 certain conditions necessary to ensure that the church is integrated successfully into the future residential neighborhood that will develop around the church: 1. Dedication of the land and associated construction easements to the City for future street connections to the NE and NW corners of the public square along Lower West Branch Road - Ensuring street access to all corners of the public square will help to establish the public square as a focal point for the surrounding neighborhoods; 2. An agreement that if the church decides to develop one or both of the parcels of land that abut the east or west sides of the square prior to construction of the connecting streets leading from the square bY the adiacent property owner(s). the church or any successor in title will be responsible for constructing one or both of these street connections to the square; The City is in the process of building the street around the public square. The church benefits from this City project because it will then have a good means of access to Lower West Branch Road. The street connections leading from the corners of the square will largely benefit future residential neighborhoods located east and west of the church, so can be required as a condition of development of those properties. However, if the church decides to develop or sell off for development the parcels of land east and west of the square, the church or the party to whom they sell the properties should be responsible for constructing these necessary connections. 3. A requirement that at such time as the church property is developed. the church will be responsible for constructing and granting a public access easement over an a-foot wide sidewalk extending east-west across the center of the church property. the exact location to be determined through the special exception process - this will be in lieu of building a street to provide a means of east-west travel through the neighborhood. 4. Dedication of a 3D-foot-wide strip of land along the northern boundary of the church property to the City for use as future public street right-of-way. At such time as the this northerly street is constructed. the church also agrees to construct an access drive from this street to the developed portion of the church property so that it will be possible for users of the property to access this northerly street - The church is likely to generate a significant amount of traffic during special events and when services are being held. A second means of access to the property would help to disperse traffic in a more efficient manner. However, establishing more than one point of access for the church is not possible at this time. To ensure that the church has at least one other means of access in the future, staff recommends that the church dedicate land equal to half the right-of- way width for a future street along its northern property line. Typically, a development such as this would be responsible for constructing or contributing toward the cost of construction of necessary streets. However, since it is unknown when the property north of the church will be developed or when surrounding streets will be built it is impractical to ask the church to contribute funds for construction of this northerly street at this time. However, it should be noted that if at some time in the future the church expands at a time when construction of this street is imminent, they may be asked through the special exception process to share in the cost of constructing this street. Staff Recommendations: 1. Staff recommends that the Commission set a public hearing for July 19 to consider an amendment to the Northeast District Plan modifying the plan map for the Lindemann Hills Neighborhood to incorporate a large institutional use into the conceptual street pattern north of the public square along Lower West Branch Road; 3 ATTACHMENTS: 1 . Location Map 2. Alternative plan map for the Lindemann Hills Neighborhood 3. Current Lindemann Hills Plan Map and description 4. Graphics from previous powerpoint presentation requested by the Commission Approved by: ~#'. Robert Miklo, Senior Planner, Department of Planning and Community Development 4 ~ t3 ~ ~ ~ ~ t3 a ,.... a a a ~ a N w a: N- a a a a I ...... a Z Z <( 'U as o a: J:: o c: as ~ m ..... C/) ~ ~ Q) ~ .9 a v ,..... v Z o ~ 5 o ...;j ~ ~ ~ 00 zzl o Cl . (/)-l.! ,.J(/)..J LL1LL1lL ZCI z 0 Z 0 <t t/) :I: Z -...Jcl<t Lfi...Jo...J o - c:l Q, J z:I::I: _ 0 ...J Gj Z 1m z - [I] w ~ ~ ~~ 1 ~ j - ~a Ii ~1i~ h ! ~ ~ .. 00 ~>. ~ ~ ~ !6 "t :; 5 61 fI:I ~ ~,~ il: ~\~ .. ~ ;; g ;;'~ "'1 ",,,:, c: c::'.c ~ 0 ~:; ... f-o ...::0 i= ~ r.J':J ,....-I ,....-I .~ :c: = = ra 8 QJ "'C = .~ ~ -~; rL':2,'::i:t.;.;r(;,-,.,i<Y,(",.:. '(;~ .~. I'>. Ii;: a..""" 'i."<>'/;' . ".': Tn " ," ",,>; "" ,/ :'!_/~E"ntJ1~~~o,\iW'.k " .',f~ ~ S',t~1 t'i \~' ,;":,:,;,:: ~"""!:>~:;; 1~!'b~~"'~JW!:~':U~!~, I, ,.~~I ", 1'::;'.,,1 ' ~~,\; . ~.,.,-,.., l ~\" <11 . I ,', \\ .""" K'~ -. :=": . .. ""~' ,\,' / / '. __ __ .: ~ ...... ~ n " ~ ,f .7' . I:' ,>, \\ ,:.5.0" V , "" ~,""" .' " <I "iJ~I:"J I~ ~/ ;\ \:?~.:// . . I", /.' :E:~:/A';;;;{%S '- 'i~~ ]. :~I~'-~: ..,,+;.:L ~ -. ,.",,' 0 ~..(,:, ;;;.:....:.' '., ,~ 7:'~'~7 ~--; .:._:.z \'~"~' ",' :~>~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ f~.~'::., J,t. 1': ~.flti~ j ! i\\~ ;:~ ( ~};:I l.;~< '~~/ ~?f52j ~~: . ~":;,,, 'I ~~~, .f, ~.,,~~\ !-:1 ~ ,{ !~,',:,,> ".; '-:;" ~". II"';~;'" ;~. 'l"', ',:- ~7; , .:' r " \<<.. :. ;~f~' .:!!>,...:,,' '" 'I" .., " ..,.,....~, ;~ :;'~ ", ~ ';]1-1 ' ':" ;:;,,\' , I"" _ ' 'I / ~ . ' ~, J ~:'.\ ;:0 '. .;:'. I I,,: ," '. '~T"7.. '_ " ':" ~'Ic;, . "'~ ' " "',' I If -1, (: to" -=- ',-- I ,J J, . .. / ',!, ",' ( . - / _.~_. ;' , ::. ' ",_. .", ".' ., I c<: - ~. '> ,', ':f ~~/; ];1! i (" I, "-' "....1' . JIi"~ ,,~., ., g:0, ' 0; ;J; 'I~~~::~' ::;-c'; .' , ." " ' ',., c.. "I..J /I ;" ,:.' ._ ,.' I ' I, ,/ .t:. '---' ,_.., n ::)i'" -''-', 'J lIlli' , :~~~(/8 <"~"~'t ~,:~~ .,:\~,; ~ I]i "'h \~""",;,,~ "',-.-=.- ",,'." I""'~''': '. ':' ~r ..' "8;~\ \ 0";;,_ " _..,~; ~rJ1 ~ "I" ~ ~,~:i'\"';;;:4:~~~:~' l~';l"~"J~:. "'.:,J'~..'-" . .~.......,./.(~:~~~.,~3j /' ,\8~\ · "' .:'," _ ~[%~1~~~;, K"" ' =-:::-'\,.r'.~'.-1'/i( ,: ,.'" Ii' ,'fff, '~', -i'. <c' . '~ ....I-'....J..... ...'....... -- it., "~T ""-."'". . ,c. I d.. '.' I l .' ~+t.~t',.o<...". (- ..~'>:":" t:5" ::,..<-F/;"': I-_'l-:~': .1 ;,,:G1'" ,~':2:\tf .'. . -- ..?;c?~," .'\"..' "..'.:::-':',"1.:. ":".:.'~.' .... ':-'1~.;-...' .. .~, (,'k:?;;> . f:,\.;\":' (,;1(>~,?;~';;;'it. " 'j~ '" ,.' mJ:m ,,'" :,~!!~,;:..; :.~"::.. ;1'~4r:;~' .o;;rl-:~...." "fi"t"?'\lIIOI o '.. -'l--- r.; /.: -;..., I ',11 "" I \xF,\~,. __ 711!'tCl ;:::.;;;.aii'.'11/' , (~~~~L,., .... :H.o" ..' ~.~ ..;:.l=~:; '~7~' l~ [I \~"-:;'{'ij:.R .:}' :~.,;'~ 7;h.'C....~~~l:D~~~.}B;&~/. Gt C~\:' ; /.~~,. J:;>J;,WAJ;jiJli "h",d~..' ; , "I -.:) ~ c. . JL~ "j<;~g.t', ,..'W'"I.I'-~i ;1.1.1 I'm :;<~. " :.<.. .: (/) "0 o o ..c S- O ..0 ..c 01 .- 0) c ~ 0) c o -1-1 C .- ..c u S- :J ..c u 0) ..c -1-1 01 C .- -1-1 CO ~ o c. ~ o u c ....... "~;=~!r::=J[=,M .!:r..~~. -J.. ..... .r. ...:-.' , ; .......... , ' ' .' . ~" .;fr\\'j-\~ ..........~......I '. ,.~... ' ,. .".-..:. !:::%::' ol ,~i~;-,~t · C:.. __~2 ; '~7~ , II [:~ " -.'-'... -~~ ~ "." ~ ~: :~ lJ ~ ' .l,!\.. .~.; i r"u'.~~' ! ,i ..1Ie j." "I-,"I'f ~ ,~"" ::,~::;~~"';: ;'.'~ ~~~."'.',!1.J.....,... -c;..', 'Cr.. .. ...-...i~'~. ~..'...:.-.". ".1 'f.P. :.".' ". .3.'."'. J.......'..~ ..:L...._,~~:.... ~ ,... '.. . ''''...... fiIIIll"l. -,,~ "''''' ..;!!~,...~I. .'.' .~ !!I.. "',v .*'. '~". 'It"l.' .Jt!l.~, ..'," . ..... '. .1... . ~,- ..""...lI"!N!.....el!l'~" .. '\. i!' "..... ~... _.l "'101- ~,. ~~ ! , :': L'""",, '--" -: :u "HItM . ~..:.... 4 I h",!~,..,~","~,M*t~'" r ~"'"" ,t., .) " . ;I J t.~l"'_"" '. . ~ .' '. '.... '''-. .... I....._.".........~... ..~....... -.' .;,.... "". ! .~, j~l""'" r.........' "l!l;. , \,~..\. -1.. '. t.,. '''',J I 5 I.. . '. "., J' ... .. ; '1:' .,....,.,.,...~,...... I "'-\ \..1\>&."'...1 a....... . << .r"i!!I.~."_.,~.,.~,,;.;: "'\. ~...... .!tl.......... '. '. ..,~ 'II!'~ ~. <<,., .- ,"~'; '~ Ii '..... '" ~ ." , ... ;:.,. "'0 ..cc -l-lro o ~ ..ero 0)- ~ ::J ::J .u Vl..c c 0) LU > . o -1-1 Vl 0) Vl ~ 0) ro U ::J Ucr ro Vl c c U ro . ro:::: ..c ~..e Vl -1-1 ::J .- Vlc....e 0) ro "'00)-1-1 O)..c Vl c.. -1-1 LU ~-I-I 0) ~ Vl -1-1 -1-1 ro OJ roC OJ 0) OJ ::J .0 Vl ..c ~ cr -1-1 "'0 -1-1 1I)-I-IO)~0...... 0) ro"'Oro ::J 0 0 ..c U ..c . > -1-1 Vl J.... ~ 11) -I-IcO)UOO),- ro~"'O ..0>..... C OJ .- ~..c ::> U ~ -1-1 > tE Cl J.... 0) -1-1 0 ro .- "'0 ::J ==ro~~OJC..c ro 0.. 0.. -1-1 C ro u . 0) -1-1 ro Vl ::J Vl crO) 0) U 0) ~~..c ......-1-1 c 0 ~ ro~J2 O)OJVl..c J.... ..0 -1-1 U ::J E c J.... Vl .-::J C::JO..c LU c c..u . STAFF REPORT To: Planning & Zoning Commission Prepared by: Sunil Terdalkar Item: SUB06-00003 Galway Hills Subdivision Parts 10 & 11 Date: July 12, 2007 GENERAL INFORMATION: Applicant: Dav-Ed Limited 18 Donegal Place Iowa City, IA 52245 (319) 337-4818 Contact Person: Scott Pottorff MMS Consultants, Inc. 1917 South Gilbert Street Iowa City IA 52241 Phone: (319) 351-8282 Requested Action: Subdivision Preliminary Plat Purpose: Development of 53-lot single-family residential subdivision Location: West of West High School on Shannon Drive and Dublin Drive Size: Approximately 21.75 acres Existing Land Use and Zoning: Undeveloped - RS-5 Surrounding Land Use and Zoning: North: Undeveloped and Residential - RS-5 South: Residential - OPD-8 East: School- P-1 West: Residential - RS-5 Comprehensive Plan: Single-family Residential Neighborhood Open Space District West High (SW6) File Date: June 06, 2007 45-Day Limitation Period: July 23, 2007 SPECIAL INFORMATION: Public Utilities: Sanitary sewer and water lines are available and can be extended from adjoining subdivisions Public Services: The City will provide police and fire protection, 2 refuse and recycling collection services. Currently, no regular transit route serves this area, however, Westside Loop serves this area during the school-year for the students of the community schools in the area. After the completion of the development, the Westwinds transit route could be extended to serve this area. BACKGROUND INFORMATION: Development of the first phase of Galway Hills Subdivision was approved in 1990 and since then approximately 110 single-family residential lots have been developed. In 2006, approval of Part 4 of the subdivision increased the total by 24 single-family residential lots. Galway Hills also includes a retirement community and a church on Dublin Drive. The applicant, Dav-Ed Limited, is now requesting approval for the preliminary plat of Galway Hills Subdivision Parts Ten and Eleven, a 53-lot residential development with three outlots on approximately 21.75 acres of land. The property is located south of Melrose Avenue and west of West High school, on Shannon Drive and Dublin Drive. This application was deferred at the March 6, 2006 meeting of the Planning and Zoning Commission, due to the unresolved issues related to the phasing plan and construction of the connection of Shannon Drive to Dublin Drive. In a memo, dated April 6, 2006, staff provided a report to the Commission about the necessity of the north-south connection of Dublin Drive and Shannon Drive. The applicanthas submitted a revised preliminary plat addressing the issues noted in the previously presented staff report and memoranda, including the north-south street connection. ANAL YSIS: Comprehensive Plan and Zoning: The property is located in the Southwest Planning District, and the Southwest District Plan identifies this area as appropriate for 2-8 dwellings per acre. The Plan specifies the importance of well-designed, diverse neighborhoods served with interconnected streets, sidewalks, trails, neighborhood commercial centers, institutional uses, and open spaces with appropriate designs to suit the surrounding single-family residential development. The current RS-5 zone for this property allows for a single-family residential development with a maximum density of five dwelling units per acre and a minimum lot area of 8,000 square feet. This zoning is consistent with the future land- use scenario of the Southwest District Plan and is compatible with surrounding developments in the area. Subdivision Analysis: All of the lots in the proposed subdivision exceed the minimum 8000 square feet lot area standard and meet the minimum 60 feet lot width requirement. The design of the subdivision is generally consistent with the subdivision regulations. The proposed subdivision can be accessed from Dublin Drive from the north, Tiperrary Drive from the west and Shannon Drive from the south. With the proposed development of the 53-lot single-family subdivision, approximately 392 trips per day would be generated. Including the proposed phases, the traffic generated from the entire development of Galway Hills (with approximately 187 single-family residential lots, and excluding the traffic generated from retirement community with 80 units and a 1636 person capacity church), ppdadminlstfreplsubOS-00003 galwaypartx-xi-prelim_revisedjuly07 3 will reach up to 2,500 vehicles trips per day. Considering the amount of traffic generated, at the time of the review and approval for Galway Hills Part 7, 8 and 9, it was noted that a north-south street connection between Melrose Avenue and Rohret Road is essential for orderly development, access for emergency and service vehicles, and efficient traffic circulation. Accordingly, the applicant is proposing to provide such a connection with the construction of Dublin Drive, Tiperrary Drive, and Shannon Drive in the next phase (Galway Hills Subdivision - Part 10), which includes lots 180 through 204, and outlots A and B. These streets, however, are designed such that the connection would not encourage cut-though traffic. Rather the connection will function only as a collector street for Galway Hills Subdivision and Walden Hills Subdivision. The subdivision will also be served by Limerick Lane. The plat shows sidewalks on both sides of these streets. An 8-foot wide sidewalk is shown on the west side of the Shannon Drive and is continued further on the east side of Tiperrary Drive and Dublin Drive. The property contains environmentally sensitive areas including regulated slopes, wetlands and a portion of a stream corridor. The applicant has provided a Sensitive Areas Site Plan that shows the stream corridor, wetlands and their associated buffers. Most of the sensitive areas are part of Outlots A and B. The sensitive areas will remain undisturbed except for the installation of necessary infrastructure-road construction. Therefore, a sensitive areas development overlay rezoning is not required. The applicant is also proposing to dedicate the two outlots to the City as part of the neighborhood open space dedication requirement. The Willow Creek Trail runs east-west though Outlots A and B in the southern section of the subdivision. The trail is proposed to be continued further to the west as part of a regional trail network plan. A temporary recycled asphalt trail now connects it to the existing sidewalk on Tiperrary Drive. With the development of this subdivision and release of the trail easement on proposed lot 231, this trail should be removed and replaced with appropriate vegetationllandscaping. The wide sidewalks along the proposed streets in this subdivision will become part of this network connecting Melrose Avenue and Rohret Road. Outlot C contains a portion of an existing storm water management area. The proposed subdivision will share this area with the adjoining Galway Hills Subdivision - Part Three. Neighborhood parkland or fees in lieu of: The Neighborhood Open Space Plan identifies the proposed subdivision as part of the West High Neighborhood Open Space District (SW6). At the time of development of previous phases of Galway Hills Subdivision, a dedication of park land in the southern part of the overall subdivision was agreed upon. With the proposed dedication of Outlots A and B, an area covering approximately 3.03 acres, the dedication requirement will be satisfied. The resulting neighborhood open space, including Outlot #3 of Galway Hills Subdivision, Part Three, will be approximately 6 acres in area. Storm water management: As mentioned above, this development will share the existing storm water management area on the west side of this property with Galway Hills Subdivision - Part Three. The storm water from the southern section of the proposed subdivision will drain into the wetland area and to the stream corridor. Adequate erosion control measures must be taken to protect the ground around the existing trail and ensure that the stream corridor is not affected by the drainage. These issues should be addressed in the Sensitive Areas Site Plan, that will be reviewed and approved by staff. Infrastructure fees: Water main extension fees at the rate of $395.00 per acre (a total of $8,591.25 for 21.75 acres) apply to this subdivision. ppdadminlstfreplsub06-00003 galwaypartx-xi-prelim_revisedjuly07 4 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that SUB06-00003, a preliminary plat for Galway Hills Subdivision Parts Ten and Eleven, a 53-lot residential subdivision with three outlots on approximately 21.75 acres of land located west of West High School, on Shannon Drive and Dublin Drive, be approved. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Location Map 2. Preliminary Plat Approved by: ~ ~ Robert Miklo, Senior Planner, Department of Planning and Community Development ppdadmin\stfrep\sub06-00003 galwaypertx-xi-prelim_revisedjuly07 ~~ --+-. ,~ AAPa:1:1lI II PIll' ,.... PRELIMINARY PLAT & SENSITIVE GALWAY HILLS SUBDIVISION IOWA CITY, AREAS SITE PLAN PARTS TEN IOWA & ELEVEN PUT PREPARED BY' ),lUS CONSULTANTS INC 1917 SOUTH GILBERT ST. IOWA CITY, IOWA 52240 OWNER/SUBDIVIDER: DA V- ED UUITED 18 DONEGAL PLACE IOWA CITY, IOWA 52245 OWNER'S ATI'ORNEY. PAIWP A. LEFF 222 SOUTH WiN STREET IOWA CITY, IOWA 52240 PLAT/PLAN APPROVED by lhe City of Iowa City elt Clerk Dete" UTILITY EASEMENTS, AS SHOWN HEREON, t.IIAY OR t.4.I,Y 1'101. INClUDE SANITARY SEWER UNr$, ANa/OR STQRt.4 'iEWER LINES, ANO/OR WATER lINES: SEE CONSTRlJCl1ON PL,l.NS fOil OET.o.lLS. """ l. PA~T 10 COHSIS", Of' Ul", 1110 _ a04. AND OlIn.OTS 0,," NolO ... l. PAAT 11 CONstm OF lOT' lC~ - 232..vID OUTlOT "e" PA'ofilENIWlDTN.2I'I,C.-I,C. IJIlIIICII.ANI'l'll'PIWIY~AIl(1I.9f0l1ll.llllll' DIM:.IJID YIllTO, IlVIllJtl PiM) TYPICAL STREET SECTION NOT TO SCAlE ~lt, 'MPltl 0( ""PE~""y IlO/IO COl-I)[-$JlC IJU\.I 15 2~' \ 1-- ~tGII''''''III''''''''orljItloe'''''._compllO<l''''''.'''.''''PICII'QI :::~uCII.~ :::::::- ~ 'J.::~'1~::"~~~2-i ~rlllS;B:'~~ =:'=.'~;~~~~':_'":;,<~O:~ ~~\:':=~"'~ ;,lor~C: 1l1J'~'37'\If. 01 1!l.~ L ll!Z ( I ~ 1l!~ I k I I 1~ III !i, 'I 1W f I !It =~s:b.il_-.f _; ..co s;":'2~~~l ':';'~~=",-L~4~~'~:' \I.... s.,,," lln., ".00 r..l: n....c. "'~'411'!lo8'[, 0101111.010 SouIllLlnt, _,~4 _. \0 u... ~""1 .r ........~. Sold t..... of I~d _'oIn. 71.7$ ..".., "'... "'r...._I._)ocll._.......d'..l"eli...o1ro..... z o ~ g ~ LOCATION MAP NOT TO SCALE sa CIlADIIlC AAtI €ROSIOIl CONlROL PI.AIl rOR E~'SllllC" PROPOSED CIl~()[ COtH0Ull5 4.HD PIIQPOSE:O EROSIOIl COIllROL 1.![~$UIl[S \lf41[_[)lttNSlOIlI'USJl[QI-*'t[D.'JI~/4CfI( BS/MIsl ~~ ~ . Afl}.. _RCroRIIEOlll""IlSlONS _ CI.lIIVE ![CU[Il' IlUlol.~ _EOl$T_ ~P~llfI_ <$ ;. :~11~%A.IlHOLE ".~ . _ flII[ Hl'D/l.......' '0' A -'ll"-I[IlV4l'll: ~ g ~,-,~- ~'--I-- -((-(1------ &'---1...- _COHTOt)IIIJI<[S{l'IIlTtRV....) -OlSTlNClREEUIlE o $ = ::~ ::;; :~s UNl.ESSflO1[l)OMJftlS(IIl.lIlllEN!llllS,...m:1NlOIUPIEtllII5 THt $In: NtO LOC..T<OIl Qf I<l.l. Jtfl(IP(I5[O UlIUlllS SItO\\foI :rn:cS':;;:TSI~~~~~1I~~~~4~L= ~::r~RClr~~~iJr~u~\':.1f'T~~ TO'.........,......_.,..,...,,(o.......1j TO'....~I'U.,......-.>O .tJ8lURI[D.',:"..(o.tlfOQlU) E=.J ~ [)lUV~l1ON STOCI<"'1.n ~-WE:llAhO!lOf'f'[Il E:=J - ~~ ~_SlR[~IIC/lf1l1l\OO1lAKlBUrrER iii ~~~ ~~;;l~?( o ;;2?:r:: o g;OF ~ ~ Zfj; ~i!<:B mCJ!l ~II ~~ nnll~ Ulllil lMl! mm uJni ';:~~~\\., i~1 .Ih~~~1 u~II!IUln~ t,;, \,~OO\2~.,G24\,~,1()2.P DWl< 8/~J<OO: To: Planning & Zoning Commission Item: SUB07-00004 GENERAL INFORMATION: Applicant: Contact Person: Phone: Requested Action: Purpose: location: Size: Existing land Use and Zoning: Surrounding land Use and Zoning: Comprehensive Plan: File Date: 45 Day Limitation Period: 60 Day Limitation Period: STAFF REPORT Prepared by: Doug Ongie, Planning Intern Date: July 12, 2007 Tyler Rogers 2965 IWV Road Iowa City, IA 52240 Scott Ritter, LLS Hart-Frederick Consultants PC 510 E. State PO Box 560 Tiffin, IA 52340 (319) 545-7215 Preliminary and final plat approval To establish a three-lot single family residential subdivision West of Kansas Avenue SW, approximately Yt mile south of IWV Road SW Approximately 3.0 acres Agricultural/Residential; County NR North: South: East: West: Agricultural; A Agricultural; A Agricultural; A Agricultural; A The property is in Fringe Area C of the Fringe Area Agreement between Iowa City and Johnson County. The property is outside the Iowa City growth area. June 18, 2007 August 2, 2007 August18,2007 2 BACKGROUND INFORMATION: The applicant, Tyler Rogers, is requesting preliminary and final plat approval of North Forty-First, a 3-lot residential subdivision on 3.0 acres of land. The property is located west of Kansas Avenue SW, approximately ~ mile south of IWV Road SW in Union Township. The proposed subdivision is situated within the two-mile extraterritorial area (Fringe Area C) and outside of the City's Long-Range Growth Boundary. The applicant recently submitted a rezoning application for the property under consideration. Upon approval, the property for the North Forty-First Subdivision will be rezoned from County Agricultural (A) to County Residential (R), and 3 acres of property approximately ~ mile south, will be rezoned from R to A. ANAL YSIS: Frinoe Area Aoreement: The Fringe Area Policy Agreement between Johnson County and Iowa City states, "In the portions of Area C which are not within Iowa City's growth area and which are zoned for non-farm development, development may occur in conformance with Johnson County's Unified Development Ordinance and City Rural Design the Standards." City Rural Desion Standards: Streets: The proposed street, Kansas Lane SW, will be a 22-foot wide chip seal street, which meets the minimum surface width standard. The proposed right-of-way of 60 feet meets the requirement for streets without curb and gutter. Water Distribution: The subdivision will be served by private water wells and septic system, which must be approved by the County Health Department. Due to possible expansion of the City of Iowa City Landfill, a Conditional Zoning Agreement requires the private wells on this property to be closed if the landfill expands within 1000 feet of the subdivision. The City would provide an alternative water source. This stipulation should be noted in the legal papers. Fire Ratina: Before the plat can be approved, a fire rating must be established by the Volunteer Fire Department. It is the responsibility of the Developer's Engineer to obtain a letter from the fire department which serves this area. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends this application be deferred until a fire rating is established. Upon resolution of this issue, staff recommends approval of SUB07-00004, a preliminary and final plat of North Forty-First, a 3.0-acre, three-lot residential subdivision located on the west side of Kansas Avenue approximately ~ mile south of IWV Road SW, subject to staff approval of legal papers and construction drawings prior to City Council consideration. PC DIStaff Reportslsub07-00004 kansas ave 3 ATTACHMENTS: 1. Location Map 2. Preliminary and Final Plat Approved by: ~ Robert Miklo, Senior Planner, Department of Planning and Community Development PC DIStaff Reportslsub07-00004 kansas ave c 0 CJ) > \J .0 :J en +-' CJ) ~ I..L I ~ +-' ~ 0 I..L ..c +-' ~ - 0 - z . . z 0 ~ ~ u 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ rJ) -, ~ Jr/ I (~,~~1'"'9 \ ,E~-l I Q ,'_~ ~lf::~,t .. i-t~ ~7;J :@1?fJ . ~ ~I~.~-.~~~ <5: . Y "'.\ r-~' 6- _____ . 17Y!:;K -1 - = \Y1J . Yh:11'.l' \~=__= SSS1);;iLh~~ I r~-\--' ~J-"-L...... ~ ~* //) ~ -let (f ~ e '\ // ./7 <1'"" ,"YO dlKlO A10 YMOl JO AllO II _J . ~ I o I I I -_.~---.-.- ------------------------------ I ,:\.,; .:..:).~;'- i -----._-.-.-..-- j,.;,., ...>. , / ~ I: o i ~ ~' 1--.... ~~--~+~- o . I I I L I I n~~ "" ~ L!) o o o o I "" o co :) en --- ~ o o o o I "" o (1) :) en -., . ~ ' .' I ~ ~ > b e. ',,- ;i~! :I __- ~ ~ '--. .... ~~~I<! ~ \ ~ ~ \ ... H_. -- r~;' -ll!r~~~~,;~~:;::-:: ; _\ i - n -" KANSAS A:S::~::::~~~::~;I(::~~~ - -. :=::::~;:,::~~~,_::~~~~~-~ ~.~~-~~~-~~ ~:~~'!- n n n n -- -- n n -- U U n {;i , , VI,;!' :-SO'''''IN~''s(",NT -- -------.-----. ;~u;: ; ~~~; ~'ll ~--r:--=-----=t---- ~~: ...: : ~~:~; ;~..t ~~i:! 1 ;6~~~ : I .:,~ji:::,-.." l;i ~ -$- ~E~:!~l ~~_~~.~ '-.Q !Ii !Ii <cwd I i jg!;; . ~ ~::: lL.:,;~~' ". :. ...., : ~}- _ _.0" ; :1~, : ~ 2OI.n~ - ....... . : ~~~~ .... ({) . . '~I" I "~ '. I- : ujre~ g ~ - - -.' "i ;rj'i -c~" ~i:!,~' ". ~ ' ~ g : i ~ ~~ 0 ~-- ------",;. ~ ~,,1Il E:~ ~ ',__ F:~. "" ~ :c : ~i ~ a _ .__ _, <L1~tP:~ _ ~'" 1',= ""'-" """~ ~ : : > u ~t '~'" t!' "~' L \ 1,' _"1" "\ " z: ~ i I ~ : : : ~ 8 ~ u ......... - - " r, I', :2 ' , ',- \ ~ \ fj I '" a e. ! U liS! D ; ~ R I : : H! ~ ~- :~!'\~~N-=~~~;' ~\~ ~I~I!~:!~ 11~;P; Ii ~t : : ". P.. tiJ"'---.."s,\ ~I r'", \ ! k; ;;: i, tl ~~~~U.~e~~B!~ ~ @.:" :~ ~ ~~~~ t>::l5 1. :;1 I d . .g~ -(ij do.Ph:u.~ ~: ~ i~ h~ ~_.M ~i I a ..)I! it' R1~t/ M ,U~ ..~'~ <1~~.xOi! Ii i i! j! oi~ \ , < z: ' rl- .J i" ~ / ,tv ' a~ ~ a '~ : ' \ ~~;; i I J/ I ",,/~ ./ '-I' r ~./ ~ / -< en !~ ;;: ~ j'....-:~af : /L ~'~_;..---J / " i A j '0 +' ::: ~ ::~ %~: I t ./NOO"06~2'W 26/1.11' ~l~ ~~ ~~~~W~ib'O~~~~~ ti ~ ~I .. .. l' :1 ~:~ ~:-~.t::l:;:;;~ IIIl 1 e: ~~~ ~ .~ : ::;; ~;~;;;::~~~:;~~~~~] :~ .,: ~~"c-'~'~"~' \':" 0_..", ~:~O~;28~lo'l:~g;'O'Ob~; I:'~ ~ I _ :g;;5: a> ~> .. ~.!'.!'o lc ~ ~ 2. ~,~..;i ~: ~! I ~ c:"'.O ~,..~~~ l~:::~::~~~~r ~ ~: ::- y. 't'f\j !{. I ~ ~~~~~ =~~~~ii~':o%~~~::S~ t,'. I : I ~ ~~:~: .!':~J:~";!"'ilr~'ii'ii'Ur::: 5 I 1; : , ~: ' ~ a :Hti htl:1~fi~~~~;;:t;~ ~ ~ :~ ~.. I'" 'Q "I, ~ ... 0'" i r- .. C1"'~.9 ... "8~ M.... c.... I ~: ~.~ ~I ; "~ .' I I _I i. I !JI. ~ s'Oz~~ l o'oi3tr~2~Ciry;~~~~\. ~ ~ I i!iJ3~i ~~ ~ ~ i <. ~ ]~~i: :;~~:t:~~:s;~j~~:~~ ;~r-!Q: <- . .. "~f' . i <? 'Il, ~ ..l'h f~' _-::0 '!~~ 0=1"' ~".u3. > ig".i'"o~. f~. : ~;~"i.- ~ ~ ~15..i;; : f- = =:ii~ ~i~E~8~i~~ti~~:~ f~ ~;:~:~~: I .-~-"lf~:- f- Ittli'i I % \.101l.'J rO~L-I"l..Q.9~:l"'$9gg.t~'i: ~~ .11:; I ~~.t~~;'~: : ~~-l~ :;~!i.. t 1 K &t:~t s:8t5:f..tE:1'1~~.t!:"2: ~:!~Q~i:i: ~~-:;~,.' : ~~h~~ ii~ia~ : ~ d_...& u_~z_woo"'om", ili!~m: ! Hi~H~ i?:~"-~~-n n nn __ -'V-- n n nn L>&~_ n.. nn m_____ __~~___ __m_________________~.,--- nU _. -- -_ __ __ -- n.--S ~c>-.t~;~] : NOO"09"J2"W 7t.tO.Il2' : : -~.!::l.t: I I I g... 00...1''' : ~: : rr: \.1 t... ~ I 1 <l'l I o~H~!!: : ! \: \ :;~.o ~1:1~~!. ~i ~ ~~ ~ ! U1 ~ ~ ; ~ -J ~ ~ a ~~~I. ~:~;~~jf-~:iii~~j~ ~~~!~~ ! ~ " I a ~ 1 t ~ ~~rjl ~r:-g;"k ..~ou.ll)o.i...~ l' E~~::~ I ~ 5 t.. "."" ""Q -;. I," - _ " u \..CII~.ti""-i~ ~:t ">'!~ r: ~... ..> yl, W \ 11 0:0: 0: ~ ~ ~:o:>.~ 8 .....~l..t...'e. 1'" rye ~"''a:>:::t ~ a:: u~ ~:~ H S~~. ~ ; ....; ~it~; t€~~}::.,o:;~;~~j8~t i~~;;~;; ~?: '\ .' ~!! - M k:l ~ !~s;-:x::~...~~~'S~~...i~ ...~8_0~9~lo lJ_'" ~~ ~ . :0- ~l",~\. ..l1"~....,,~t>1\,! ~ ~~.... ."':;1"- - ~~~"'.,j ::1\1 lJ ~ Q.r- .. k... .~~o::~ 0 Q.'M"t)o.!.~ .~t~ ~ >" !.;;'O S ? e....'" ll. :t r- ~ fi 11 ~ z ... ~ ., ~ 01..1 I t. , "~~~; ~ ~ ~ O""~. !f~~:gt!l:8~8J!(f.;~ ~u2."~~ru : I ::::zr'>ll.'" Q i;~:<.'~ ...~oQ:~~\.;~z3;~...'01: ~~.,$!-'l: -- ';". ' I %0 Iol_ ~~: I<!._ ~: J'~ ~ :~k:~'08~:....~iw~t:.. r~t\")o.giOl ~ ll'I : Y: ~53l!(~ -' ~:.n~~ ~n ~0.~>F'~~ >.~..;i~ ::-8~;~. '~~".'~ ll!G:~ 1 : z:::l......__ ~ O~ It"l\. s-""....~I"I....,.tLO'i:{\IJ:...!' .,~~. ~ ~8~ t i ~ ; ~H; i !H~~!iHjjam! mHlti au. ~ . ~ ~ II a E ~ \ ~ \ ~ Z D ...... C/) > ...... ~ ~ ~L... 00 ~ :J ~~ a:(/)~~? ~" ~ ~ ~~~~ i: (/) ~~~>-' ~ ~ ~:~~ : L- ~~~8 ~ ~~-z z>-<t ZD ! ~ ~~~~ L:1 ~ ~~tj~ ~D ~t-VI Ln.... o " I I- ~ D Z " :> 8 @' " :> 8 ... o ,. >- iJ w ;: ,. '" B > '" '" <L <L " '" ,. ~ : u !;' ,. 0 >- '" U ~ " '" '" 51 :> '" w w >- <L " :J a '" ... o a '" " ~ ~ Z :J 8 z 51 z I o .., w ;: i j hl~ _IJ~ .~~ I:.. 're!.! i-~ i~ , .H :IH reo z '313, ~ i 1 5 ~1i1 go ;~l ;;- I U -I ... o <(I z >- w W I Vl Z D ...... (/) <I \ > ~ :<a:l .i::J ...(/) " z CI- a(/) :i~ ,....... ~L z ~>- dl- :l'~ D L I I- ~ D Z '0 U'" '<D 0..0 I .00 ~ ~~ Z "'~ < <D ~ E-< <<l- ....l .~ ::> o!:!. en - " Z -c "... 0:':: u~ ....~ ~ .;~ U ~, - ~~ t>:: ...~ ~ cn~ ~ ~: ,_ ~ 0 _ en 0 1 if E-<.; Ct: <0 :1::;;; ~U ~ ~ ~.... " u Vl t I ~~I ~ ~ !:ll 9 ~ fl ... " z o " <L ii' ~ t w, '" :. ., w ~ '" ci z z o ~- '" STAFF REPORT To: Planning & Zoning Commission Prepared by: Adam Ralston, Planning Intern Item: VAC07-00004 Portions of Court St and Front Street Date: July 12, 2007 GENERAL INFORMATION: Applicant: George Hollins University of Iowa Business Manager's Office 305 PCO Iowa City, IA 52242 Phone: (319) 335-0126 Contact Person: Dennis Gritsch Requested Action: Street vacation Purpose: To facilitate redevelopment by the University of Iowa for a new recreation center. L.ocation: Front Street between Burlington Street and Harrison Street and Court Street between Front Street and Madison Street Surrounding Land Use and Zoning: North: University of Iowa South: University of Iowa East: University of Iowa West: University of Iowa (P-2) (P-2) (P-2) (P-2) File Date: June 14, 2007 BACKGROUND INFORMATION: The University of Iowa currently owns all property between Burlington Street, Madison Street, Front Street, and Harrison Street. The University has plans to construct a new recreation center on the block immediately south of Burlington Street and west of Madison Street. The University has requested this street right-of-way vacation to help facilitate this development. There have been other vacation requests approved in nearby areas (these are shown on the attached map). Item VAC02-00004, considered in 2002, vacated the 100 block of Harrison Street and the east half of the 100 block of Prentiss Street to facilitate development for the University of Iowa. At issue with this item was public access to the Iowa River, a point identified in the Near Southside Plan, adopted in December 1995. The Planning and Zoning Commission passed a motion to approve the request while asking that an easement for public access be created for the vacated areas of Harrison and Prentiss Streets. The City Council ultimately passed an ordinance approving this vacation with a public access easement in place. Another item that has affected this area is item VAC02-00002, also considered in 2002. This application was brought forward by the CRANDIC Railway Company as a means to clear title on a 2 land sale between CRANDIC and the University of Iowa. This application resulted in passage of an ordinance vacating four small parcels of land, now owned by the University. ANAL YSIS: Requests for vacation of public streets are reviewed with regard to the following factors: 1) impact on pedestrian and vehicular access and circulation; 2) impact on emergency and utility vehicle access and circulation; 3) impact on access to adjacent private properties; 4) desirability of right-of-way for future access or circulation needs; 5) location of utilities and other easements or restrictions on the property; 6) potential use of the property for a public use, such as parkland; and 7) any other relevant factors pertaining to the specific requested vacation. Impact on pedestrian and vehicular access, as well as emergency and utility vehicle access, will be negligible. An observation of the area showed that Front Street and the 100 block of Court Street are used only as service drives for University buildings while Burlington Street and Madison Street are used for general circulation. The portion of Front Street between Court Street and Harrison Street has been fenced and gated by the University. This indicates that Front Street is not needed for general pedestrian or vehicular circulation. There will be no impact on access to adjacent private properties since all surrounding property is owned by the University. It is unlikely that these portions of Front Street and Court Street would be desirable for future circulation needs or for another public use. The Near Southside Design Plan adopted in December 1995 proposes a "green link" from the courthouse/post office area west towards the river. Vacating the 100 block of Court Street should not impede this goal for two reasons. First, the plan looks to Harrison Street as more appropriate street to accomplish this objective. Court Street would be a less desirable "green link" route as it terminates at the southern end of the University power plant building. Second, the ordinance passing item VAC02-00004 retained an easement for public access over Harrison Street. With access to the river via Harrison Street, public access via Court Street becomes unnecessary. The Near Southside Design Plan also foresaw redevelopment by the University for the two square blocks bordered by Burlington, Madison, Harrison, and Front Streets. It has the northern half of this area projected as a "potential University parking ramp" while the southern half was projected as "potential university development." Although the University now has plans to place a recreation center on this property, the Near Southside Design Plan shows that redevelopment was expected. Private utilities have been contacted and asked to identify any utilities currently on-site. MidAmerican Energy has indicated that it has utilities in the area. Easements will need to be retained for these utilities, and other utilities that may exist, should these streets be vacated. Alternatively, the utilities would need to be relocated. It should be noted that the City would no longer assume responsibility for maintenance of street right-of-way should these streets be vacated. This would include street, sidewalk, and signage maintenance. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that VAC07-00004, a request to vacate Front Street between Burlington Street and Harrison Street as well as Court Street between Front Street and Madison Street, be approved subject to the retention of any necessary utility easements. 3 ATTACHMENTS: Location Map Location Map (showing VAC02-00002 and VAC02-00004) Aerial Photo Approved by: /0~.; Robert Miklo, Senior Planner, Department of Planning and Community Development ~ ............. C\I"- c..aJ ~ tj ~ ~ ~ ~ tj ,,,:==="'~>----- ""~'= w,...,.,,,..,,..,:~:~:: 0""-' ,,, ~ ~ ~ a: IS NOSIO\fV'l ^-,,-,''''~'':,.,,~<' a :z <( 0:: (.9 c. IT [ /./ Or wruno:; c.. i f- (/) IS NOSIO\fV'l IIC """ o o o o I ...... o o <( > (f) +-' Q) Q) Lo- +-' C/) +-' C 0 L0- U. "'0 C ct1 +-' Lo- C\I :J 0 c.. 0 . . z 0 1-0( ~ u 0 ~ ~ ~ 1-0( en ~ ~ ~ :E a: ~ tj ~ ~ ~ ~ tj C\I D. [I........ C\I ~ I 00 i 00 . 00 00 [ c\J c\J 00 00 <(<( >> I~ Q) en ::J (ji D.. lS lOlld'v'J //Or aJ~TunOJw~ I f- (f) f- (f) f- 0::: =::) o () lS lNOtU '/' . .[ ~ () I I~CO ~cn 0::: a: C\I D. en +-' Q) Q) lo- +-' Cf) en en '+:i c Q) l0- a. "0 c ctS c o ,en lo- lo- ctS I ....:- c o l0- LL - o en c o 't o Q.. "0 Q) +-' ctS U ctS > >- en ::::J o > Q) l0- a. ~ o o o o I I'-- o o <( > ~ (j ~ ~ ~ ~ (j CJ) +-' Q) Q) l.... +-' Cf) +-' C o l.... LL l:J C ctS +-' l.... ::J o o . . Z o ~ ~ U o ~ ~ ~ ~ rJ)