HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-17-2008 Public Art Advisory Committee
Agenda
Public Art Advisory Committee
Thursday, January 17, 2008
3:00PM
City Hall Lobby Conference Room
410 E. Washington St.
A. Call to order
B. Public discussion of any item not on the agenda
C. Consideration of the minutes of the December 6, 2007 meeting
D. Discussion on revised proposal and budget for BJ Katz proposal for
Robert A Lee Recreation Center Pool Wall Project. See attached.
E. Discussion regarding future projects of Public Art Program - see
attached memo.
F. Committee time/updates
G. Adjournment
MINUTES
PUBLIC ART ADVISORY COMMITTEE
THURSDAY, DECEMBER 6, 2007
MEETING ROOM A, ROBERT A. LEE RECREATION CENTER
PRELIMINARY
Members Present: Emily Carter-Walsh, Mark Seabold, DaLayne Williamson, Patrick
Carney, Terry Trueblood, Rick Fosse
Members Absent: Emily Martin
Staff Present: Marcia Klingaman, Jeff Davidson, Mike Moran
Public Present: Holly Burkowitz
CALL TO ORDER
Seabold called the meeting to order at 3:05 PM.
PUBLIC DISCUSSION OF ANY ITEM NOT ON THE AGENDA
Holly Burkowitz presented several ideas for the Public Art Committee to consider. She
would like to see an lowa-themed mural painted onto the side of the Qwest Building.
She envisions the creation of Iowa City as the City of Murals, similar to Kansas City's
claim to the City of Fountains. She suggested adding a stained glass element to the
University Art Building. The committee noted that the University would be the
appropriate contact for that suggestion. She also suggested that a botanical garden
component would be a nice addition to City Park.
CONSIDERATION OF THE MINUTES OF THE NOVEMBER 1, 2007 MEETING
MOTION: Fosse moved to approve the minutes with minor corrections; Trueblood
seconded. The motion passed 9:0.
PRESENTATION OF PROPOSALS FOR ROBERT A. LEE SWIMMING POOL WALL
I. SAXE-PATTERSON
Hank Saxe and Cynthia Patterson focused on technical considerations of the
building (moisture, lighting, materiality, etc.) when developing their concept.
They thought about water and landscaping in the Midwest and how water is
depicted in art. They noted that there is a rhythmic representation in wave
patterns, water rivulets, and waterfalls. They were inspired by Grant Wood's
renderings of Iowa's landscape (rolling hills, patterns of plowing). They took
these concepts and incorporated them into the pattern of ceramic tiles.
The line created by the building's heating element will act as the art piece's
horizontal line. The treatments will be cement based. The tiles will be
attached to boards. There will be striations and contour lines on the tiles to
represent hills and plowing, which will be reminiscent of Grant Wood's
artwork. Coral, crinoids, and hexagenarian patterns will be reminiscent of
Iowa's geological past. Water molecules (water "babies") will break up the
horizontal landscape and will utilize the vacant space above the heating
element. These could be constructed of fiberglass discs of 2-4 ft. in diameter.
These could also be executed in ceramic tile up to 18" in diameter.
The artists are conscientious of the amount of weight that can be placed on
the wall. Glass tiles weigh approximately 1.5-2 Ibs. per linear foot. The
committee asked how much of the wall would be covered in tile. The artist
suggested that to reduce costs they bring in both hand made and
commercially available materials. A typical tile project might cost $400 per
square foot, which would include installation fees. Costs could be
dramatically reduced by covering only 10-15% of the pool wall with hand
made tile. The artists foresee approximately 30% wall coverage with entire
concept design. The committee questioned if the artists will consider using
paint effects to address the negative space. They said they would use paint
effects (not faux painting, but definitely color blocks).
The committee questioned whether or not the material will become brittle
over time and if it is similar to pool tile. Saxe noted that the tile is highly
stable. The artist has used this type of tile in pool projects before. The
material they have chosen is chemically resistant.
II. TJ. MOBERG, STOHBEEN AND LUCHSINGER
TJ. presented three concepts via conference phone. The third concept
presented was the artwork of Stohbeen and Luchsinger.
Concept 1: Arrangement A. $150,000
This piece is a series of divers representing different diving poses. The
figures will be life sized 3-D. They will be carved out of foam and covered in
epoxy resin. There will be a total of 12 figures representing different race,
age, gender. The figures will be placed at various heights across the pool
wall. He'll create 20 figure concepts for the committee to choose the final 12.
He is flexible and is willing to collaborate with the committee to determine
what the figures will look like.
Concept 1: Arrangement B. $150,000
Arrangement B is the same concept as Arrangement A with the difference of
the placement of the divers on the pool wall. These will all be diving from the
same height across the wall.
Concept 2: This is Life.....Jump in With Both Feet $160,000
Similar to concept 1, this piece is a series of professional figures (fireman,
ballplayer, policeman) jumping into the pool.
TJ. will place these figures at least 10 ft. up the wall. He will consult with
engineers for installation. Each figure will weigh approximately 50 Ibs. The
committee asked if the cost estimate includes installation. He indicated that it
will; the only cost not covered is the demolition of acoustical tiles and any
lighting.
Concept 3: Artwork of Stohbeen and Luchsinger $200,000
The images were done on a computer and represent "original" prints. They
will be printed on ceramic tile. The $200,000 fee includes installation. There
will be close to 2000 tiles. The area near the heating element will be painted.
The project will use inks with a 150 year rating. The artists are flexible and
easy to work with regarding the design. The weight of the tiles is unknown.
III. B.J. KATZ AND DEREK NADEAU
B.J.'s art is kiln cast glass. Derek presented on behalf of B.J. two options of
varying color and placement patterns. Derek brought in a sample of azure
colored glass for the committee to see. The glass will have a fluid, water-like
texture. A chrome/mirror paint will be applied to the back. This makes the
texture come alive. The pattern will flow from one panel to the next. The
piece will be viewed from only one side. Natural light will hit it during the day;
as the natural light changes, it will appear as though the piece is alive and
moving.
The glass plates will be mounted with 4" standoffs. The glass will be
tempered (5x stronger than untempered glass) and will meet safety
regulations. The total display will cover 80x5 feet of wall space. There will be
4-6 solid steel standoffs per panel. These are almost invisible once installed.
Each panel will weigh approximately 80 Ibs. There is no cost difference
between %" and 3/8", however, the %" will weigh more.
The committee asked if the artist will provide lighting. Derek noted that B.J.
wasn't planning on adding a lighting element. He suggested that simple track
lighting with quartz halogen would be attractive and inexpensive. He noted
that acoustical tile would be left in place. The artist wasn't sure how to
handle it. The committee asked via conference call if B.J. would be willing to
use the colors for option 1 and the placement for option 2. She has no
preference and would be willing to work with the committee.
IV. MARIA MIJARES
Maria was unable to present her concept plan. The committee noted that her
idea was very interesting; however, it was not affordable.
V. BAO PHAM
Bao was not present to present his proposal. His proposal will cost $48,000.
The committee questioned whether his piece related well to the space.
DISCUSSION OF PROPOSALS
The committee noted that B.J.'s piece comes closest to the budget, which
stands at $80-$85,000. They noted that there may be potential cost
increases with T.J.'s proposal. It was decided that without fundraising that
his piece would be too expensive. The committee noted that Maria's
proposal doesn't include installation fees and weight is a concern with her
piece in addition to cost.
BJ Katz - Revised Proposal
Dancing Water
22 panels
24" wide x 84" high
66.5 pounds/ panel maximum.
Budget
$53,900 - Tempered cast azurlite colored glass with dichroic bits and reflective
coating on back, pattern running between panels with holes drilled for hardware.
($2450/ panel).
$9,000 - Artist's fee
$1250 - Crating, shipping and insurance
$900 - Supervision of installation
$65,050 - Total
,~ 1
-~= -~....
t~W!:~
,,~...~
~-
CITY OF IOWA CITY
MEMORANDUM
Re:
January 11, 2008
Public Art Advisory Committee
Marcia Klingaman
Future Public Art projects
Date:
To:
From:
The Public Art Program will have approximately $60,000 - $65,000 available for public art
projects over the next six months depending upon final costs associated with the pool wall
project. Another $50,000 will be appropriated on July 1, 2008. I would like to spend some time
brainstorming about future projects at the January 17 meeting
Some things to consider:
. There are currently two Neighborhood Art projects (Melrose and Washington Hills) that
are outstanding. Melrose has already received initial approval from the committee to
proceed. Washington Hills should be making a formal request yet this spring. Average
Neighborhood Art Projects costs have been about $15,000.
. RDG Planning and Design will be providing a power point presentation for your February
7 meeting to present their concept for a sculpture garden in Iowa City.
Some ideas that have been discussed in the past:
· Murals
. Refurbishment of the old downtown fountain sculpture
· Art at the Water Plant site
. Art in City parks has not provided art on the east side of town