HomeMy WebLinkAbout2012-12-04 Correspondence4e(1)
Marian Karr ���■
From:
Melvin Kelly <kellyresearchplan @yahoo.com>
Sent:
Friday, November 23, 2012 11:34 AM
To:
ctham.AWP @gmail.com ; citymanager @hollister.ca.gov ; council @cityoffullerton.com ;
cityclerk @dalycity.org ; citycommission @salina.org ; cmomail @springfield- or.gov ;
christopherc @cityofwestsacramento.org ; citycouncil @cityoflamirada.org ;
cpucheu @gulfport- ms.gov ; cjackson @cityofdalton- ga.gov; clarissa.rowe @comcast.net ;
council @town. barnstable. ma. us ; constituenttsservice @weymouth.ma.us ; chn @chn.org;
council @suffolkva.us ; Rainbow Coalition; csierra @phenixcityal.us ;
contact @huntsvilleal.gov ; citymgr @johnsoncitytn.org ; croth @kenner.la.us ;
cshaheen @wrga.gov; councilclk @tompsc.com; cityhall @melbourneflorida.org ;
cityhall @westonfl.org ; citycouncil @cityofrichfield.org ; Council; council @altoonapa.gov ;
cshannon @baycitymi.org ; cohmayor @co.hawaii.hi.us ; cityclerk @derrynh.org ; council -
dist12 @brgov.com ;council-distll@brgov.com ;council-distlO@brgov.com ; council -dist9
@brgov.com ;council-dist8@brgov.com ;council-dist7@brgov.com ; council -dist6
@brgov.com ;council-dist5@brgov.com ;council-dist4@brgov.com ; council -dist2
@ brgov.com ;council-dist3@brgov.com ;council-distl@brgov.com ;
counciladmin @brgov.com ; clfowlerjr @suddenlink.net ;cjordan@www.greenville.ms.us ;
council @shreveportla.gov ;citymanager@cox-internet.com ;csawyer@cityofpafterson.org
;chmorrell@nola.gov ;CityClerk@quincyil.gov ;chris.mulvaney@chicagowilderness.org ;
ckohler @cantoncityhall.org ;cityhall@valdostacity.com ; contact @gov.state. la. us;
cs @odessa- tx.gov ;council@ci.peariand.tx.us ;chip.beckett @glastonbury- ct.gov ;
chris.lee @mail.house.gov ;cio@ame-church.com ;cliff@wvon.com ;
clee @bellevuewa.gov ;cityclerk@melbourneflorida.org ;Commission@largo.com ;
cjohnson5 @augustaga.gov; cpd_web_mail @hud.gov
Subject:
Youth Musical Projects 2013 by Melvin Lorenzo Kelly
Attachments:
Nationwide Musical Project.doc
From: Melvin Lorenzo Kelly
2014 Olive Rd.
Augusta, Ga. 30906
706 - 796 -3044
Email- kellyresearchplan(,yahoo.com
To: US Mayors / Elected Officials
Sub: Nationwide Youth Musical Projects vs. Violence in Music
Date: November 22, 2012
Dear Hon. US Mayors / Elected Officials,
All during this year of 2012, I have been emailing and writing you pertaining to proposed
projects towards building a better America for everyone such as:
1. Four Point Homeless to Homeowner Ownership
2. Education ( Abbott Districts and Drop -Out Factories)
3. Shelter in the Time of a Storm
4. Violence in Music
5. West Nile Virus
6. Crime Watch
7. Youth Musical Projects
Before I begin to tell you about my proposed nationwide youth musical project let me
revert to the proposed project Violence in Music to explain there relationship in contrast.
My proposed project Violence in Music is pertaining to the implementation of laws that
would abolish the usage of profanity or any lyrics in music all across America that would
entice killing innocent people for gang initiations or any lyrics that rebel against the
written laws of the USA government for the protection and safety of its people.
My proposed project number 7, from the list of projects mentioned above entitled, Youth
Musical Projects is pertaining to the creation of instrumental and vocal opportunities for
children and young adults across America within the communities they live.
Learning to read and write music along with playing an instrument is one of the best
constructive activities a child or young individual can become involved with, next to
studying the Bible. I believe the Bible will teach our young children how to live a
righteous life and studying music along with singing or playing an instrument will keep
them busy during their spare time.
Engineering and Technology have truly short changed the studying of music in our
society today. You can walk up to a musical key board (Piano) today and push one button
and you have a whole band electronically playing for you, and all you have to do is sing
along.
Learning to play an instrument or sing by studying eight notes, half notes, whole notes,
scales, key signatures, the treble clef and the bass clef etc.... is the proper way to study
and learn music. And the earlier one begins this musical learning process in life, the
easier it will be for them to perform playing an instrument or singing when they get older.
For more information about my proposed music projects please contact me.
Let's Build a Better America,
Melvin Lorenzo Kelly
"mr-rlr-
4e(2) i
MZQ
F L E
.. r
j
0 T 1112MOV21 P1112.
Cl f Y ClEpali
IOVIA cl T 6, - ,
MY naW "a-4 /LJtiffed" a,"
n kl' YC 4
SQx4 Leg S de�
o, �jan
Co
Ro Luct AV -4 Goo
tA
f) yo
D-nyo�-� ssiwqpcA.A�5-
nd
IXS
4e
CV3o'-) x 114 -e- 80 x O's Va�pcu 6
11 .. - , o � 7c. - I -- � I -�
DV SA
'7 10
001---
9 on
P44 cl, ul
ko-
0, "sk>
At BARCLAYS
Petitioning Citibank Uganda Public Affairs Officer
This petition will be delivered to:
Rita Balaka
Citibank Uganda Public Affairs Officer
Charles Ongwae
Barclays Uganda Managing Director
Chinedu lkwudinma
Citibank Uganda Managing Director
J. Kevin Jones
Citibank Pride Network
Joseph Stroble
Citibank Pride Network
Catherine Tanelli
Citibank Pride Network
Juan Vasquez
Citibank Pride Network
Ana Duarte McCarthy
Citibank Chief Diversity Officer
Richard Clarke
Barclays Spectrum Network
ti
Mark McClane
M
Barclays Head of Global Diversity and Inclusion
rr• r. "�
d�
Citibank and Barclays: Condemn Uganda's
'Kill the Gays' Bill
ff
Petition by
Collin Burton
Washington, DC
Multiply your impact
Turn your signature into dozens more by sharing this petition and recruiting
people you know to sign.
YOU
e
YOUR
c;
r
FRIENDS
170
-
avg.
= in
—
l�
THEIRrT�
v
FRIENDS
i5 j,
ZZ
ti zr
10,000
=
Approx. r-
Ugandan legislators have re- introduced the dangerous Anti - Homosexuality Bill, a proposed law
that would criminalize homosexuality in the country with extreme penalties. Under this proposed
law, LGBT people could be killed or sentenced to life in prison, solely because of their sexual
orientation or gender identity. As the bill's author, David Bahati, has said, he believes the
government of Uganda should "kill every last gay person." (1) And recently, the Speaker of
the Ugandan Parliament vowed to pass this dangerous legislation before the end of the
year, calling it "a Christmas gift." (2)
Citibank and Barclays -- two of the largest banks in the world -- have major operations in
Uganda. Citibank has nearly $300 million in assets invested Uganda, and is a major leader in a
U.S. Chamber of Commerce based in Kampala, Uganda's capital.
Barclays is Uganda's third largest bank, with more than 1,000 employees in the country and 51
branches throughout the nation.
Citibank and Barclays are also well known for supporting their LGBT employees and protecting
their employees and customers from anti -gay discrimination. Citibank is a huge supporter of
LGBT groups in the United States, and has received a 100% rating from the Human Rights
Campaign's Corporate Equality Index. And just last week, Barclays was named the most LGBT-
friendly company in all of Scotland, and regularly is ranked as one of the best companies for
LGBT people to work for in the world.
With the "Kill the Gays" bill looming in Uganda's parliament, Citibank and Barclays have
unique and necessary voices that could help stop this bill in its tracks. Their presence in Uganda
is significant, and their voices in opposition to the Anti - Homosexuality Bill could have a
profound impact in keeping LGBT people safe in Uganda.
Ask Citibank and Barclays to publicly condemn Uganda's "Kill the Gays" bill, and send a
loud message to Ugandan legislators that criminalizing homosexuality with lifetime prison
sentences and the death penalty won't be supported by major international businesses.
1. "Finding The Root Of Anti -Gay Sentiment In Uganda," NPR
2. "Official: Uganda to pass anti -gay bill this year," AP
To:
Citibank Uganda Public Affairs Officer (Rita Balaka)
Barclays Uganda Managing Director (Charles Ongwae):'.
N
r
Citibank Uganda Managing Director (Chinedu Ikwudinma)
v =s
w -
Citibank Pride Network (J. Kevin Jones)
" 3
Citibank Pride Network (Joseph Stroble
Citibank Pride Network (Catherine Tanelli)
o �;
Citibank Pride Network (Juan Vasquez)
`;"
N
Citibank Chief Diversity Officer (Ana Duarte McCarthy)
Barclays Spectrum Network (Richard Clarke)
4
Barclays Head of Global Diversity and Inclusion (Mark McClane)
As one of the largest banks in the world, I know you have major operations and many
employees
in Uganda.
You're also well known for supporting your LGBT employees and protecting employees and
customers from anti -gay discrimination.
With the "Kill the Gays" bill looming in Uganda's parliament, you have unique and necessary
voice that could help stop this bill in its tracks. Your presence in...
As one of the largest banks in the world, I know you have major operations and many employees
in Uganda.
You're also well known for supporting your LGBT employees and protecting employees and
customers from anti-gay discrimination.
With the "Kill the Gays" bill looming in Uganda's parliament, you have unique and necessary
voice that could help stop this bill in its tracks. Your presence in Uganda is significant, and your
voice in opposition to the Anti- Homosexuality Bill could have a profound impact in keeping
LGBT people safe in Uganda.
I ask you to publicly condemn Uganda's "Kill the Gays" bill, and send a loud message to
Ugandan legislators that criminalizing homosexuality with lifetime prison sentences and the
death penalty won't be supported by major international businesses.
Sincerely,
[Your name]
Read More
Pl��
C:>
"�
Marian Karr
From: Rick Fosse
Sent: Thursday, November 29, 2012 8:06 AM
To: 'davidson.ncy91 @gmail.com'
Cc: Council; Tom Markus; Marian Karr; Kevin O'Malley
Subject: Landfill Fire Insurance
Dear Mr. Davidson:
4e(3)
Thanks for your e-mail about the landfill fire and your interest in following this event for your environmental science
studies. With regard to your question about insurance coverage, we are still waiting for a determination by our
insurance company on the amount of our loss that will be covered. We estimate the total cost related to the fire,
cleanup, and reconstruction will be approximately $5M. We have sufficient cash reserves in our landfill account to
proceed with complete reconstruction prior to any insurance settlement. Cash reserves are accumulated over time from
landfill fees to help us manage unforeseen circumstances such as this fire. Whatever insurance settlement we receive
will be used to help replenish the cash reserves.
I hope this provides the information necessary for your studies.
Rick Fosse
Public Works Director
City of Iowa City of Iowa City
410 E. Washington St.
Iowa City, Iowa 52245
319 - 356 -5141
From: Nicholas Davidson [mailto:davidson.ncy91 @gmail.com]
Sent: Saturday, November 24, 2012 11:03 AM
To: Council
Subject: Landfill Fire Insurance
Dear City Council of Iowa City:
I am an environmental science student and this past summer I paid particular attention to the landfill fire in Iowa City. I
have tried to keep up with post -event reporting and have relied on local newspaper reporting for most of my
updates. In particular, I am interested in the financial implications for the city. I searched the website and didn't find
any recent staff updates to the council. In newspaper articles, staff is quoted as saying about a month ago with no
elaboration that they do not yet know whether insurance will cover the damages.
Now that it is six months after the event, I am thinking that certainly by now the Council has received a report from staff
on the financial implications and I was just unable to find it. In any event, could a staff member reply back with the
answer of whether insurance will cover the damages or not? I couldn't find the name of the city's insurance carrier so I
cannot contact them directly. For my studies I am comparing other landfill operations to ascertain whether they are
covered for a similar event, and would like to know whether the city's blanket liability coverage will cover damages. I
would also like to know whether the landfill was included in the city's list of assets to insure liability coverage. If the city
is not covered by insurance and the users will ultimately be responsible for the expense, is a plan being discussed now as
to how the funds will be assessed through increased landfill fees or other methods?
Sorry if this information is contained on the website and I overlooked it. Thanks in advance to the answers to my
questions.
Nicholas Davidson
Marian Karr
From: Monick, Martha <martha- monick @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Wednesday, November 28, 2012 7:01 PM
To: Council
Subject: Flood levy vote
Dear City Council members,
After last nights disappointing vote on the flood levy,l was greeted this morning by a page 3 story in the Press Citizen
about the University receiving an 8 million dollar grant to construct a removable flood wall around the IATL building. I
am certain that the displaced water will head straight for Parkview Terrace.
It would appear that the best way for Idyllwild to obtain flood protection is to be annexed by the University. This would
also provide relief from those pesky property taxes.
Sincerely,
John Monick
35 Pentire Circle
Iowa City, Ian
52245
Notice: This UI Health Care e-mail (including attachments) is covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18
U.S.C. 2510 -2521, is confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby
notified that any retention, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. Please
reply to the sender that you have received the message in error, then delete it. Thank you.
Marian Karr
From: Carol deProsse [mailto:lonetreefox@mac.com]
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 10:11 AM
To: james-throgmorton@iowa-city.org; Michelle Payne; Terry Dickens; Matt Hayek, Rick Dobyns; Susan Mims
Subject: Taft Levee
Our blog on the Taft Levee vote:
http://www.twoatthefringe.blogspot.com/2012/12/taft-levee.html#links
If the link does not work you can copy and paste it in your URL blog.
JIM: I will answer your post regarding the College/Gilbert Street proposal separately, though I may send
response to rest of council, too.
Council Makes Right Choice about Taft Levee
NOW LEVEES WORK.
AND, NOW THEY CAN FAIL.
Levees ore di8vjped W PrMed us, and OW C0WrT1Ltksi+5, f4019 fi*0604
Let's hope the Council's 5 -2 vote to not build a gigantic earthen levee around the Idyllwild neighborhood and Park View
Church will put an end to this controversial issue. Years ago we, along with many others, were opposed to this
development in the flood plain. Of course in those days the decision makers were thinking only of work for developers and
tax returns for the city and gave approval to this foolish plan.
With the present drought it is hard to imagine this area flooding again, but it will. And those that chose to live in the flood
plain -- and rebuild or refurbish after a flood -- will have to bear whatever consequences befall them. It's a tough life out
there in the world of climate and this time a majority of the City Council did, as Councilor Payne stated, "use logic" instead
of emotion by voting down the levee.
We love the water, we love being on the river and we understand those who want to live by the water; and the original
occupants did and do. Smart construction for riverbank lovers does not include wall -to -wall carpet, basements, expensive
appliances and areas that cannot stand flooding without being destroyed.
Permanent structures of any kind in close proximity to a river are risky because rivers meander.
— rom the creek might best be served by talking with the city about the
Future plans for New Pioneer's relocation away
possibility of acquiring a portion of city land east of the Unitarian Church and making part of the exchange the conveyance
to the city of New Pioneer's current site. Given the likelihood that any development on the corner of Gilbert and College
will result in reduction of monthly permits, some of which are used by city employees, the city could raze the old New Pi
and use the area for employee parking.
Carol deProsse
Caroline Dieterle
4'e- -5 -)
Marian Karr
From: Denise Halter <denise.halter @gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 29, 2012 6:32 PM
To: Council
Subject: plastic bag ban
Hello to all of my City Council members,
I just wanted to weigh in on the possible plastic bag ban.
I personally am an avid recycler but find a ban on plastic bags ridiculous!
What would we really do next? All ask for paper bags? and where do these come from?
Be forced to buy the reusable bags? Which I do quite often, but do not feel I should be "forced" to!
People have many options with their plastic bags. This City is great in that there are many ways to recycle them.
You can take them back to the store, you can take them to Crowded Closet or even Houseworks.
I like giving them to our Church's food pantry as they always request them.
So if you ban them, what next? A fine if you are caught with one?
Like I said, ridiculous!
I have faith in my city council members!
Thank you,
Denise Halter
718 Rundell Street
Iowa City
"Remember, there are two places you will always be accepted... church and grandma and grandpa's!"
XeC5)
Marian Karr
From: Ed Weisberg <eweisberg @gxtgreen.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 11:00 AM
To: Council; ' jennifer- jordan @iowa - city.org.'
Cc: 'Michael Vanin'; 'Bob Chatterjee'
Subject: Commnets and an alternative solution regarding a plastic bag ban
Attachments: letter to Iowa city 11- 30- 12.pdf
Dear Council Members and Ms. Jordan,
Please see the attached letter regarding an alternative to a bag ban that you have proposed. I have also
included the substance of the letter in the email below.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Edward Weisberg
GXT Green ECOgrade bags - Winner of MassTLC 2012 "Consumer Product of the Year"
Edward Weisberg
Senior VP of Marketing and Business Development
GXT Green, a division of Global Exchange Technologies, Inc.
505 Middlesex Turnpike, Suite 11
Billerica, MA 01821
0: 978.735.4367
M: 781.856.8034
F: 978.735.4369
blog: www.ECOgrade.org
eweisbers @gxtsreen.com
�7t4'
Economics meeting ecology
ABefore printing, think about the environment
This correspondence will become a public record.
Iowa City Council Members
Iowa City, Iowa
November 30, 2012
Dear Council Representatives and Members of the Iowa City Community,
We at GXT Green applaud your ongoing initiative to consider the impact of plastic bag use in the community
and your search for viable alternatives. Regular plastic bags that are littered have serious long term impact on
the environment and many communities have or are considering banning these bags for that reason. However,
communities that have instituted a ban without specifying a viable acceptable alternative are finding that
enforcement, economic impact, and resulting inconvenience have been a major challenge to the success of these
initiatives. In some cases this has resulted in a repeal of the ban or clever "work arounds" that defeat the
purpose of the initiative. Paper and reusable alternatives don't solve the key issue of harm to marine and
wildlife and /or adversely impact the environment by increasing the emission of greenhouse gases causing
devastating consequences.
I am writing to you today to bring to your attention a viable cutting edge alternative that is garnering extensive
support and interest worldwide. New technology has enabled the development of non -toxic photodegradable
bags (as certified per ASTM 5272 standards) that solve the plastic bag pollution problem, without
inconveniencing citizens or having an adverse economic impact on local businesses. These products photo
degrade from sunlight in 300 days or less to a non -toxic residue, have a lower environmental footprint than
plastic or paper, and can be recycled with other plastics. By recommending the use of these bags, either though
legislation of a bag ban or simply as a test solution as an alternative to a ban, Iowa City can truly be at the
forefront of a solution to bag pollution.
My company's product, the ECOgrade bag, is an example of these products. In fact, it recently won the
prestigious MassTLC 2012 "Consumer Product of the Year Award" in recognition of its contribution to solving
sustainability concerns. GXT Green's ECOgrade bag, which is a result of 10 years of R &D, is a non - toxic,
photodegradable alternative that satisfies the intention of bag bans while addressing concerns of all stakeholders
in the community. If littered, ECOgrade bags degrade completely within 240 days of exposure to sunlight,
thereby eliminating the impact of littering on the environment, reducing greenhouse gases, and mitigating risk
to marine and wildlife, all without compromising convenience and the economics of local businesses.
Total bans are often disruptive to the community, commerce, and may exacerbate environmental impact instead
of being a solution. Communities worldwide are coming to the conclusion that GXT Green ECOgrade bags are
the ideal alternative to single -use carry -out plastic bag ban, such as the one being considered by Iowa City. In
addition to addressing environmental impact, GXT ECOgrade photodegradable bags provide the critical
economic and convenience incentive necessary to make the adoption of an initiative successful. In fact, we are
currently working with Senator Eldridge and Representative Ehrlich from the Commonwealth of Massachusetts,
as well as several other communities in Rhode Island, North Carolina, Australia and India who have asked us to
consult on how the photodegradable bag solution fits into proposed bag ban legislations to incorporate a viable
and meaningful alternative to plastic bags.
According to many national environmental groups, over 4 billion plastic bags are estimated to be littered
worldwide each year, posing a danger to wildlife and marine life, and they are a blight on our
environment. Unfortunately, alternatives that have been proposed in most legislation have serious
environmental and economic repercussions on the short and long -term wellbeing of the community. Some
examples of concerns with these proposed alternatives include:
• Paper Bags are expensive and have tremendous environmental impact from manufacturing,
transportation, and landfill needs. They by far produce the largest amount of greenhouse gases and other
effluents when compared to any current alternative, a negative factor that is critical to a community such
as yours.
• Reusable Bags are inconvenient and can pose serious health risks, as they have been shown to harbor
bacteria and cause bacterial cross - contamination that poses a serious health risk. Additionally, these
bags must be reused over 200 times to minimize their greenhouse gas impact as compared to plastic
bags and around 300 reuses as compared to ECOgrade bags.
A Blanket Ban on plastic bags raises many serious concerns including:
• Inconvenience to consumers
• Hurts local merchants by driving shoppers to nearby towns if no viable alternative is offered to
replace plastic bags
• Does not solve the pollution problem, as plastic bags from neighboring areas will replace the in-
town reduction of plastic bags as more and more consumers shop outside the community where
bags are banned
• Can drive adoption of solutions that are worse for the environment and the health of the
community
• Increases cost to the community to legislate and enforce such bans
• Shifts tax revenue and jobs away from the community to neighboring communities which do not
have bans
• And ultimately, places a legislative and enforcement burden on the town which could be
avoided, since effective non -toxic photodegradable solutions are available that address the
concerns
ECOgrade bags both solve the pollution issue and address the concerns of the community without the cost
associated with blanket bans. ECOgrade bags:
1. Are the only true solution that addresses the negative impact of plastic bag littering:
a. If littered or lost, these bags begin to degrade in 40 days and completely degrade within 240 days
of exposure to sunlight without leaving any harmful residue.
b. Regular plastic and bio- degradable plastic bags will not easily degrade when littered.
2. Are made from natural materials using 46% less plastic resin, minimizing dependency on oil /gas.
3. Produce 34% less Greenhouse gas in pre - production as compared to plastic and 93% less as compared to
paper.
4. Use 15% less energy than regular plastic bags, 84% less energy than paper, and 94% less water than
paper in the process of manufacturing
5. Are recyclable with other plastics
6. Degrade to a nontoxic residue that reduces acidity in water and can be used as a soil conditioner
7. If incinerated at disposal, ECOgrade bags do not clump up in incinerators or release dioxins. They burn
to a non -toxic white ash. Incineration for disposal is becoming more common in the U.S. as landfills are
capped.
8. Will not adversely impact local retailers and the local economy and tax base, since they cost the same as
plastic bags and do not create any hindrance to commerce or consumer convenience.
In addition to their benefits over regular plastic bags and paper bags, ECOgrade photo - degradable bags are also
superior to bio- degradable bags. Bio- degradable bags (certified under ASTM 6400) degrade only under very
special conditions available in commercial composting facilities (only one such facility exists in the USA).
They also emit greenhouse gases when they decompose. Raw material for Bio - degradable bag manufacturing
competes with critical food resources and will increase the cost of food, thereby negatively impact the millions
of poor worldwide. Contrary to popular belief, bio- degradable bags will not degrade in your backyard compost
pile.
Photo degradable ASTM 5272)
Bio degradable (ASTM 6400 or7081
Will degrade under sunlight if littered
Needs commercial composting facility to
degrade
Does not release Greenhouse Gas
Releases Greenhouse Gasses when degrading
When made without toxic salts: Can be
recycled
Cannot be recycled with other plastics
Good for the economy because they cost about 13 -4 times the cost of plastic
the same as plastic
ECOgrade bags have been tested extensively through third party ASTM certified labs to verify their
specifications and claims. GXT will be glad to provide copies of these certifications, and make them available
to any members of the community who may wish to see them.
GXT Green is committed to bringing viable solutions to pressing sustainability challenges that meet the GXT
test of "Economics meeting Ecology ". GXT consults and advises state, local, and international governments.
The following is the proposed language that may be considered for inclusion in your legislation that will allow
effective and viable alternatives to be provided by retailers:
Acceptable bags include bags that (1) have been certified to photo- degrade in 300 days or less according
to the ASTM D5272 -08 Standard Practice for outdoor exposure testing of photo degradable plastics or
accelerated testing in accordance with ASTM D5208 - 09 Standard Practice for Fluorescent Ultraviolet
(UV) Exposure of Photodegradable Plastics, conducted by a recognized ASTM certified lab.; (2),
degrades to a material which passes US standards for heavy metals per Biodegradable Product Institute
Requirements, specifically 50% of limits set by the EPA in Table 3 of 40 CFR (Code of Federal
Regulations) Part 503.13 (3) other standards deemed acceptable by the governing officials.
We would welcome the opportunity to present to your council, or with the committee that is writing this
legislation to further inform you of the details on ECOgrade, as well as provide extensive third party
verification. Thank you for your consideration.
For more information, please visit http: / /www.ECOgradeba2.com.
Edward Weisberg
?W4."
GZr
G R E E N
A Division of Global Exchange Technologies, Inc.
Iowa City Council Members
Iowa City, Iowa
November 30, 2012
Dear Council Representatives and Members of the Iowa City Community,
Edward J. Weisberg
Senior Vice President
Marketing and Business Development
eweisberg @gxtgreen.com
Office: 978 - 735 -4367
Fax: 978 - 735 -4368
We at GXT Green applaud your ongoing initiative to consider the impact of plastic bag use in the
community and your search for viable alternatives. Regular plastic bags that are littered have serious
long term impact on the environment and many communities have or are considering banning these
bags for that reason. However, communities that have instituted a ban without specifying a viable
acceptable alternative are finding that enforcement, economic impact, and resulting inconvenience
have been a major challenge to the success of these initiatives. In some cases this has resulted in a
repeal of the ban or clever "work arounds" that defeat the purpose of the initiative. Paper and reusable
alternatives don't solve the key issue of harm to marine and wildlife and /or adversely impact the
environment by increasing the emission of greenhouse gases causing devastating consequences.
I am writing to you today to bring to your attention a viable cutting edge alternative that is garnering
extensive support and interest worldwide. New technology has enabled the development of non -toxic
photodegradable bags (as certified per ASTM 5272 standards) that solve the plastic bag pollution
problem, without inconveniencing citizens or having an adverse economic impact on local businesses.
These products photo degrade from sunlight in 300 days or less to a non -toxic residue, have a lower
environmental footprint than plastic or paper, and can be recycled with other plastics. By
recommending the use of these bags, either though legislation of a bag ban or simply as a test solution
as an alternative to a ban, Iowa City can truly be at the forefront of a solution to bag pollution.
My company's product, the ECOgrade bag, is an example of these products. In fact, it recently won the
prestigious MassTLC 2012 "Consumer Product of the Year Award" in recognition of its contribution to
solving sustainability concerns. GXT Green's ECOgrade bag, which is a result of 10 years of R &D, is a non-
toxic, photodegradable alternative that satisfies the intention of bag bans while addressing concerns of
all stakeholders in the community. If littered, ECOgrade bags degrade completely within 240 days of
exposure to sunlight, thereby eliminating the impact of littering on the environment, reducing
greenhouse gases, and mitigating risk to marine and wildlife, all without compromising convenience and
the economics of local businesses.
Total bans are often disruptive to the community, commerce, and may exacerbate environmental
impact instead of being a solution. Communities worldwide are coming to the conclusion that GXT
Green ECOgrade bags are the ideal alternative to single -use carry-out plastic bag ban, such as the one
being considered by Iowa City. In addition to addressing environmental impact, GXT ECOgrade
photodegradable bags provide the critical economic and convenience incentive necessary to make the
505 Middlesex Turnpike • Suite 11 • Billerica, MA 01821
www.gxtgreen.com
di►�""
G R E E N
adoption of an initiative successful. In fact, we are currently working with Senator Eldridge and
Representative Ehrlich from the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, as well as several other communities
in Rhode Island, North Carolina, Australia and India who have asked us to consult on how the
photodegradable bag solution fits into proposed bag ban legislations to incorporate a viable and
meaningful alternative to plastic bags.
According to many national environmental groups, over 4 billion plastic bags are estimated to be littered
worldwide each year, posing a danger to wildlife and marine life, and they are a blight on our
environment. Unfortunately, alternatives that have been proposed in most legislation have serious
environmental and economic repercussions on the short and long -term wellbeing of the
community. Some examples of concerns with these proposed alternatives include:
Paper Bags are expensive and have tremendous environmental impact from manufacturing,
transportation, and landfill needs. They by far produce the largest amount of greenhouse gases
and other effluents when compared to any current alternative, a negative factor that is critical
to a community such as yours.
• Reusable Bags are inconvenient and can pose serious health risks, as they have been shown to
harbor bacteria and cause bacterial cross - contamination that poses a serious health risk.
Additionally, these bags must be reused over 200 times to minimize their greenhouse gas
impact as compared to plastic bags and around 300 reuses as compared to ECOgrade bags.
A Blanket Ban on plastic bags raises many serious concerns including:
o Inconvenience to consumers
• Hurts local merchants by driving shoppers to nearby towns if no viable alternative is
offered to replace plastic bags
• Does not solve the pollution problem, as plastic bags from neighboring areas will replace
the in -town reduction of plastic bags as more and more consumers shop outside the
community where bags are banned
• Can drive adoption of solutions that are worse for the environment and the health of
the community
• Increases cost to the community to legislate and enforce such bans
• Shifts tax revenue and jobs away from the community to neighboring communities
which do not have bans
o And ultimately, places a legislative and enforcement burden on the town which could
be avoided, since effective non -toxic photodegradable solutions are available that
address the concerns
ECOgrade bags both solve the pollution issue and address the concerns of the community without the
cost associated with blanket bans. ECOgrade bags:
1. Are the only true solution that addresses the negative impact of plastic bag littering:
a. If littered or lost, these bags begin to degrade in 40 days and completely degrade within
240 days of exposure to sunlight without leaving any harmful residue.
b. Regular plastic and bio- degradable plastic bags will not easily degrade when littered.
2. Are made from natural materials using 46% less plastic resin, minimizing dependency on oil /gas.
505 Middlesex Turnpike • Suite 11 • Billerica, MA 01821
www.gxtgreen.com
�
3. Produce 34% less Greenhouse gas in pre - production as compared to plastic and 93% less as
compared to paper.
4. Use 15% less energy than regular plastic bags, 84% less energy than paper, and 94% less water
than paper in the process of manufacturing
5. Are recyclable with other plastics
6. Degrade to a nontoxic residue that reduces acidity in water and can be used as a soil conditioner
7. If incinerated at disposal, ECOgrade bags do not clump up in incinerators or release dioxins.
They burn to a non -toxic white ash. Incineration for disposal is becoming more common in the
U.S. as landfills are capped.
8. Will not adversely impact local retailers and the local economy and tax base, since they cost the
same as plastic bags and do not create any hindrance to commerce or consumer convenience.
In addition to their benefits over regular plastic bags and paper bags, ECOgrade photo - degradable bags
are also superior to bio- degradable bags. Bio- degradable bags (certified under ASTM 6400) degrade
only under very special conditions available in commercial composting facilities (only one such facility
exists in the USA). They also emit greenhouse gases when they decompose. Raw material for Bio-
degradable bag manufacturing competes with critical food resources and will increase the cost of food,
thereby negatively impact the millions of poor worldwide. Contrary to popular belief, bio - degradable
bags will not degrade in your backyard compost pile.
Photo degradable (ASTM 5272)
Bio degradable (ASTM 6400 or7081)
Will degrade under sunlight if littered
Needs commercial composting facility to degrade
Does not release Greenhouse Gas
Releases Greenhouse Gasses when degrading
When made without toxic salts: Can be recycled
Cannot be recycled with other plastics
Good for the economy because they cost about
the same as plastic
3 -4 times the cost of plastic
ECOgrade bags have been tested extensively through third party ASTM certified labs to verify their
specifications and claims. GXT will be glad to provide copies of these certifications, and make them
available to any members of the community who may wish to see them.
GXT Green is committed to bringing viable solutions to pressing sustainability challenges that meet the
GXT test of "Economics meeting Ecology ". GXT consults and advises state, local, and international
governments.
The following is the proposed language that may be considered for inclusion in your legislation that will
allow effective and viable alternatives to be provided by retailers:
Acceptable bags include bags that (1) have been certified to photo- degrade in 300 days or less
according to the ASTM D5272 -08 Standard Practice for outdoor exposure testing of photo
degradable plastics or accelerated testing in accordance with ASTM D5208 - 09 Standard
Practice for Fluorescent Ultraviolet (UV) Exposure of Photodegradable Plastics, conducted by a
recognized ASTM certified lab.; (2), degrades to a material which passes US standards for heavy
metals per Biodegradable Product Institute Requirements, specifically 50% of limits set by the
505 Middlesex Turnpike • Suite 11 • Billerica, MA 01821
www.gxtgreen.com
G' ,!
G R E E N
EPA in Table 3 of 40 CFR (Code of Federal Regulations) Part 503.13 (3) other standards deemed
acceptable by the governing officials.
We would welcome the opportunity to present to your council, or with the committee that is writing
this legislation to further inform you of the details on ECOgrade, as well as provide extensive third party
verification. Thank you for your consideration.
For more information, please visit http: / /www.ECOgradebae.com.
a,O
Edward Weisberg
505 Middlesex Turnpike • Suite 11 • Billerica, MA 01821
www.gxtgreen.com
1-t , ( S-)
Marian Karr
From: cliff pirnat <cpirnat @mchsi.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 1:13 PM
To: Council
Subject: plastic
Plastic bags eliminated is great.
But when taxing , Iowa City should lead the way and tax
all plastic water bottles.
cliff pirnat
Marian Karr
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Tracking:
FYI
Marian Karr
Friday, November 30, 2012 11:00 AM
matt hayek
Tom Markus; Geoff Fruin
FW: GE Labeling Resolution Work Session Request
Recipient
Tom Markus
Geoff Fruin
matt hayek
From: Matt Ohloff [mailto:mohloff @fwwatch.org]
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 10:59 AM
To: Council
Subject: GE Labeling Resolution Work Session Request
Dear Iowa City City Council,
Read
Read: 11/30/201212:01 PM
Read: 11/30/2012 11:47 AM
L'e-
I gave public comment at the City Council meeting this past Tuesday asking the Council to take up and vote on
the resolution Food & Water Watch has submitted regarding support for labeling of genetically engineered
foods. I was under the incorrect impression that the City Council would be meeting on Dec. 11. That being said,
I would like to request that the City Council bring this resolution up at the work session meeting on Dec. 18.
Please let me know if this can be added to the agenda for that meeting. And please let me know if you have any
thoughts or questions on the issue or on the process for moving this resolution forward.
Sincerely,
Matt Ohloff
Regional Organizer
Food & Water Watch
351 E. College St.
Iowa City, IA 52240
office: 319- 512 -7825
fax: 319- 512 -7835
cell: 515- 988 -3737
mohloff ffwwatch.org
www.foodandwaterwatch.orq
LIKE us on Facebook:
https:// www.facebook.com /FoodWaterWatch Iowa
This correspondence will become a public record.
Toronto plastic bag ban nixed by city council (Print- Friendly Version) Page 1 of 3
Distributed from City Manager
4
Print this Page
.0
• Text: AA
• =Sign up for News Alerts
Toronto plastic bag ban nixed by city council
11/28/2012 1 Showwei Chu, CityNews.ca
Map
City council has voted to kill Toronto's controversial plastic bag bylaw after considering confidential advice from its city
solicitor.
The vote was 38 -7.
Council also voted Wednesday in favour of a motion by Conn. Janet Davis asking the deputy city manager to report to the
public works committee on June 19, 2013, on the pros and cons of reducing the use of plastic bags.
http: / /www.cityW. com/toronto /citynews /news/local /Article /print/238244 11/30/2012
Toronto plastic bag ban nixed by city council (Print- Friendly Version) Page 2 of 3
City staffers drafted the bylaw that prohibits retailers from distributing plastic shopping bags. It would have gone into effect
Jan. 1, 2013.
But Coun. Denzil Minnan-Wong introduced a motion eliminating the recommendation to implement the bylaw. The motion
also adopted recommendations that were kept confidential and kept a confidential attachment secret as it related to litigation.
Earlier this month, the Ontario Convenience Stores Association, which opposes the planned bylaw, filed a lawsuit against the
city. And the Canadian Plastics Industry Association has called on the city to overturn the ban.
There were reports that the city solicitor would advise council not to finalize the ban right away so that the city could consult
with industry groups.
"This is very cryptic. This leaves a certain amount of uncertainty in the public which is regrettable," Minnan-Wong said.
But he said adopting the recommendations allows the city solicitor to go back to the parties in the litigation.
"I'm optimistic we'll finally clean up this mess, create clarity and move forward," he added.
Coun. David Shiner, whose proposal for a bag ban was approved in June, said he supported Minnan- Wong's motion, not
because he thought the ban was wrong, but because council didn't follow procedure to have the bylaw drafted before his
proposal.
"The problem was there were errors in the process," he said. "We're going to do it in the right way. It's the right thing for the
future.
Other meeting matters
Councillors considered several other items Wednesday, including Christie's bakery jobs and holiday shopping, among other
items.
Earlier this month, Mondelez Canada announced plans to close its Mr. Christie's bakery at 2150 Lake Shore Blvd. W. near
Park Lawn Road in fall 2013 which would affect 500 bakery employees. Some councillors fear that the company will seek to
rezone the area residential without this preemptive measure. After debating the matter, council voted unanimously to ask the
province to consider declaring the area there as "a provincially significant employment area." Many councillors stated that
they believed there was better long term economic potential for the city if the site wasn't rezoned.
Councillors also debated whether to allow retailers to open during Victoria Day between the hours of 10 a.m. and 6 p.m.
Stores are required to be closed on nine statutory holidays in Ontario: New Year's Day, Family Day, Good Friday, Easter
Sunday, Victoria Day, Canada Day, Labour Day, Thanksgiving and Christmas. After council debated the issued and heard
from members of the public Coun. Mary Fragedakis moved for a receipt of the report. The motion passed 36 -7.
The public works committee recommended that the city and the TTC work together to develop and implement a streetcar and
cyclist safety strategy. This study, which cycling advocacy group Cycle Toronto has called for, comes after a Toronto man
died in August when his bike wheel got caught in an abandoned track on Wychwood Avenue, near St. Clair Avenue West and
Bathurst Street.
Council began discussing an item on Toronto water rates and fees, but ended up holding the item until Thursday.
There were a number of other councillor motions being considered including:
• Coun. Cesar Palacio wants the city to request that the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission review a uranium
processing plant's operations in the city's west end. Davenport Village residents near 1025 Lansdowne Ave. were
shocked to learn in recent weeks that GE- Hitachi processed uranium pellets at that location and have been doing so
for more than 50 years. The councillor also wants the nuclear agency to get the company to disclose its activities to
Toronto Public Health and provide soil samples and air emission tests. Furthermore, Palacio wants the company to
establish a five -year plan to discontinue its production of uranium pellets at the Lansdowne plant. The matter was
referred to the planning and growth management committee.
• Coun. Janet Davis wants city staff to explore with the Toronto District School Board and others the potential uses
for two schools slated for closure. She wants the parties to consider such uses as child care, recreation and other
community services for Victoria Park Elementary School and Parkside Elementary School.
• Coun. Adam Vaughan wants the city to call on the federal government to commit to a $2.5 billion a year
investment after the mayors of Canada's largest cities agreed earlier this month to match such a pledge to rebuild and
improve their infrastructure over 20 years.
After a lengthy debate Tuesday evening, council voted 32 -8 to have the Toronto Zoo's remaining three elephants transferred to
the PAWS facility in northern California.
http: / /www.citytv.com/toronto /citynews /news /local /Article /print/238244 11/30/2012
Toronto plastic bag ban nixed by city council (Print- Friendly Version) Page 3 of 3
Council voted last fall to send the remaining elephants, Iringa, Toka and Thika, to the PAWS sanctuary in San Andreas after
animal rights groups raised concerns about their welfare. But the move was delayed after concerns about infectious disease at
the facility, as well as permits and flight arrangements.
On Tuesday afternoon, councillors amended and adopted the city ombudsman's recent recommendations about how to better
handle parking ticket disputes. Last Thursday, Fiona Crean said that, on balance, drivers are getting reasonable service, but
there are some flaws, such as information on tickets that downplays the option for a trial.
Click here for the agenda.
.20
• Text: AA
• MSign up for News Alerts
http: // www.citytv.com/toronto /citynews /news /local /Article /print/238244 11/30/2012
Marian Karr
From: Holden, Palmer J <pholden @iastate.edu>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 10:34 AM
To: Council
Subject: Plastic bags
I oppose any ban on plastic bags. We usually use totes but forget them now and then. What are the alternatives? Paper
destroys forests. Plastic can be recycled at all groceries in IC. Lets quit penny ante regulating. We already have to much
government.
These "feel good" things are a waste of time and money. Like being nuclear weapon free, sanctuaries, etc. Some people
need a life and quit wasting my tax money.
This correspondence will become a public record.
Dr. Palmer Holden
ISU Emeritus Prof.
15 Mary Court
Iowa City, IA 52245
515 - 231 -5543
Marian Karr
From:
Marian Karr
Sent:
Friday, November 30, 2012 11:00 AM
To:
matt hayek
Cc:
Tom Markus; Geoff Fruin
Subject:
FW: GE Labeling Resolution Work Session Request
Tracking:
Recipient Read
Tom Markus Read: 1113012012 12:01 PM
Geoff Fruin Read: 11/30/2012 11:47 AM
matt hayek
FYI
From: Matt Ohloff [mailto:mohloff @fwwatch.org]
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 10:59 AM
To: Council
Subject: GE Labeling Resolution Work Session Request
Dear Iowa City City Council,
I gave public comment at the City Council meeting this past Tuesday asking the Council to take up and vote on
the resolution Food & Water Watch has submitted regarding support for labeling of genetically engineered
foods. I was under the incorrect impression that the City Council would be meeting on Dec. 11. That being said,
I would like to request that the City Council bring this resolution up at the work session meeting on Dec. 18.
Please let me know if this can be added to the agenda for that meeting. And please let me know if you have any
thoughts or questions on the issue or on the process for moving this resolution forward.
Sincerely,
Matt Ohloff
Regional Organizer
Food & Water Watch
351 E. College St.
Iowa City, IA 52240
office: 319- 512 -7825
fax: 319- 512 -7835
cell: 515- 988 -3737
mohloff _fwwatch.org
www.foodandwaterwatch.orq
LIKE us on Facebook:
https:// www. facebook.com /FoodWaterWatchIowa
This correspondence will become a public record.
New Pi is a Vibrant Business
• $24 Million in Revenue
• $5.7 Million in Payroll /Benefits
• Strong Financial Position
— $9 Million Balance Sheet, No debt
• 26,000+ total members
N:7A
WIN v N
Fair Compensation &Support of Local
• 190 Employees
— 75 %+ Full Time with benefits
— Health Care, PTO /Vacation, 401(k)
• $1.7 Million in purchases from local farmers &
producers
Community &Environment
• $71,000 donated to community last year
— $20,000 Local Foods Connection
— $43,000 in donations /sponsorships
— $8,000 bag fee to Crisis Center
• Earthsource Community Gardens
• Soilmated Education program
• 10,000 Ibs/ waste stream composted monthly
New Pi is an Economic Engine for IC
What does a new store mean?
• + $6 Million in Revenue
• + 40 new jobs ($1.5 Million payroll & benefits)
• + $500,000 in purchases from local farmers &
producers
• + 250,000 customer visits to downtown Iowa
City
We pull significant business into Iowa City
Vjr
We Can Invest Today!
• Extensive market and site analysis
— Financial models sound under any stress test
— We have financing lined up
• IC store property owned by co -op
— Can be part of "package" development
Marian Karr 16
From: Tim Weitzel <tweitzel. email@g mail. com>
Sent: Monday, November 26, 2012 2:44 PM
To: Council
Subject: New development in the Chauncey Swan Park and adjacent properties
I wanted to indicated I have studied the proposals and recommend the following be considered as the final
option: Chauncey Gardens, then 4Zero4. I think the Chauncey Gardens proposal offers the most innovative
design solution and is a good fit with the area of the City and the community as a whole. The others all appear
to be lacking one or both of these aspects. 4Zero4 as a LEED Platinum building is a good second choice but its
siting fails to capitalize the property in the innovative way of the Chauncey Gardens.
Best Regards,
Tim Weitzel
Marian Karr
From: Van Wye, Susan <susan- vanwye @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Tuesday, November 27, 2012 8:24 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: The Chauncey
I strongly believe the Chauncey design for redevelopment of the northeast corner of College Street and Gilbert
Street is the most practical and innovative solution for the location and space. The design and features will appeal to all ages and
backgrounds (students, professionals and families) and provide the opportunity for Iowa City to come together as a community. I would
personally enjoy following the progression of the project and look forward to spending time with my friends and family in a fun and
creative environment. Once again, let's prove that Iowa City is a great place to live regardless of age!
Susan VanWye
2412 Crestview Avenue
Iowa City, IA 52245
s u sa n -va nwye CcD. u i owa. ed u
Notice: This UI Health Care e -mail (including attachments) is covered by the Electronic Communications
Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510 -2521, is confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that any retention, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this
communication is strictly prohibited. Please reply to the sender that you have received the message in error,
then delete it. Thank you.
Marian Karr
From: Gail falk <gail.falk @live.com>
Sent: Tuesday, November 27, 2012 9:47 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: New development
Hello. The two most important things for me in the new development is that New Pioneer Co -op is part of it, and that
alternative energy sources and conservation issues are prominent.
Thank you, Gail Falk
416 Douglass Court
Iowa City, IA
Marian Karr
From: Axelson, Eric D <eric- axelson @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Tuesday, November 27, 2012 12:09 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College and Gilbert Suggestions
My input would be:
The higher the better within reason as density is always more sustainable than sprawl.
Must include the New Pi coop in plan
The Ryan Companies Plan is aesthetically poor, ugly
Eric Axelson
Notice: This UI Health Care e-mail (including attachments) is covered by the Electronic Communications
Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510 -2521, is confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that any retention, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this
communication is strictly prohibited. Please reply to the sender that you have received the message in error,
then delete it. Thank you.
Marian Karr
From: Gregory Delzer <gdelzer @msn.com>
Sent: Tuesday, November 27, 2012 12:44 PM
To: Council
Subject: Developing Gilbert- College site
Dear Council Members,
There are five proposals before you for the Gilbert - College site, each with their merits. Personally, my
preference would be for The Chauncey, as I think that would add more value to the nightlife /cultural scene of
Downtown, which seems to be what the Council is hoping for given the development /renovation occurring all
over Downtown. I do understand, however, the pull to provide a new space for New -Pi Co -op. Anyway, I am
glad that is your decision and not mine. As you consider these proposals, what I would advocate is that the
City, given the plentiful options, take into consideration the developers as well as the development. As you
seek out someone with whom to work with on this important project, I would suggest you look out the
windows of City Hall at the monstrosity slowly and inefficiently going up across Washington St. As the Council
seeks to put its faith and trust in a vision for the Gilbert- College site which will help move this city forward. Ask
yourself if the developer of the 517 Washington St. site is the person who knows how to best build with the
neighborhood in mind. I ask you to remove Chauncey Gardens from consideration, given the track record of its
developer, Jesse Allen. The evidence is right outside your windows.
Sincerely,
Gregory Delzer
417 Kimball Rd
Iowa City, IA 52245
Marian Karr
From: Mary Duncan <mary.duncan1 @yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, November 27, 2012 12:48 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Building Project Input
Dear Iowa City Council,
I would like to email my personal preference of support for Ryan Companies/IceBerg Development's proposal
for a new downtown building.
Although I am not an Iowa City resident, the livability and open feel of the Iowa City community was my sole
reason for moving back to Johnson county after two years in Des Moines. I love Iowa City! Iowa City boasts a
strong history of ecofriendly decisions - looking at the development proposals, Ryan Companies seems to take
in environmental factors more than any other plan.
If the team is looking to longterm sustainability, a building designed to bring in natural lighting, save on energy,
and create it's own energy and resources is the smartest plan. Every building and home that is built should really
be looking to do this. When I stepped in as Executive Director for the Summer of the Arts in 2008, one of the
first decisions I made was to make the festivals have a more positive environmental impact. Four years later, the
festivals are diverting over a ton of garbage from the landfills simply by requiring compostable foodware be
used by vendors, and asking the community to use compost bins. Although I am now with another organization,
Summer of the Arts is now called upon by other organizations across the country for advice and leadership,
simply because of the example set in thier environmental standards.
My hope would be that the Ryan Companies project could set the same sort of example for the community and
other builders. By encouraging and emphasizing the eco connection in this design, solar power, etc., Iowa City
would be showing the residents and greater Iowa Community how important environmental care is to the
overall impact of the City. Our environment should always be considered when we build. This could spur future
planning that is ahead of it's time and environmentally focused.
If for some reason the council chooses another direction, my hope is that New Pioneer Co -op be included in the
plan.
Thank you for making Johnson County a great place to live and thank you for being a leader for our
community!
Mary Duncan
North Liberty
Marian Karr
From: wheeperk @aol.com
Sent: Tuesday, November 27, 2012 2:08 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Duilding Proposals
believe the Council should select the Ryan proposal. I dont believe that location should
have such hi rises as the other porposals. Those are better suited for the land
development south of Burlington St.
J. Perkins
Coll Drive I.C.
Marian Karr
From:
Tim Dwight <tim.dwight @ipowercorp.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, November 27, 2012 5:11 PM
To:
Council
Cc:
Jake Christensen; Justin Doyle; Mark Seabold
Subject:
Thank youNision /Follow up questions
City Council of Iowa City,
Thank you for the opportunity to present our vision for the future of Iowa City.
We hope you saw that 4zero4's project balances the needs of the community by maintaining the
downtown scale and transitioning with a mid -rise building to the historic neighborhood beyond. 4zero4
also takes sustainability seriously with the goal of providing a project that balances renewable energy with
a thoughtfully designed building of quality construction and materials. We feel this project reflects not
only Iowa City's community but will serve as an example for development in the future and will create a
sustainable icon for Iowa City. We also feel that 4zero4 successfully provides New Pioneer Co -op with a
fantastic new location that will activate both College Street and Chauncey Swan Park.
We appreciated your questions and hope that we provided you with the answers you needed to make
4zero4 your project of choice.
Please don't hesitate to contact members of our team if you need any additional information or have
further questions regarding our project. Again, thank you for your time.
Tim Dwight
Business Development
Integrated Power Corporation/4zero4
448 Ignacio Blvd. #188
Novato, CA 94949
C 319.631.2006
O 415.884.5555
F 415.884.5557
This e -mail may be privileged and/or confidential, and the sender does not waive any related rights and
obligations. Any distribution, use or copying of this e -mail or the information it contains by other than an
intended recipient is unauthorized. If you receive this e-mail in error, please advise me (by return e-mail or
otherwise) immediately.
Marian Karr
From: Gidal, Eric <eric- gdal @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Wednesday, November 28, 2012 2:02 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College / Gilbert Redevelopment
Dear Council Members,
I find the five finalist proposals for College / Gilbert Redevelopment very distressing. Each seems more
hideous than the next, with the only discernible difference being in just how egregiously they wish to dismantle
the livable environment of our downtown.
The proposal from Ryan Companies/Iceberg Development at least has the merit of restraining its depressing
industrial architecture to five stories, as opposed to the eight, thirteen, eighteen, or, lord help us, twenty stories
proposed by the other firms.
All seem determined to continue the mortification of our city center to a hulking jumble of concrete, glass, and
steel with a few narrow passages and dwarfed remnants of our city's heritage in between.
Rather than enabling this chaotic mess inflicted upon our public space by the interests of private profit, the city
could explore some true alternatives: architectural designs in proportion to the surrounding park and structures,
built with a sense of aesthetic integrity and a commitment to the long -term health and pride of the community.
The relocation of the New Pioneer Co -op and the possible creation of a space for FilmScene are worthy goals.
So too is the creation of viable and attractive office space. And there is always a demand for downtown
apartments, though not necessarily by the young professionals envisioned by the developers.
But these goals are achievable without creating a closed in tunnel of over -sized construction along a major
artery of our downtown. I urge the council to reject these five proposals and put out calls for a more
appropriately scaled and harmonious design.
Sincerely,
Eric Gidal
328 Brown Street
Iowa City
Marian Karr
From: Lewin, Ellen <ellen- lewin @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Wednesday, November 28, 2012 1:42 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Film Scene
Dear City Council:
I hope you will give positive attention to the proposal to develop a state -of- the -art two - screen cinema as part of the
Chauncey, one of the finalists for the building at the corner of Gilbert and College. Iowa City has long been a film desert,
and the possibility of getting a really good independent cinema is incredibly exciting, particularly as other cultural
resources reemerge with the rebuilding of Hancher in the near future. I would put this project on par with Hancher and
with our outstanding bookstore, Prairie Lights, as resources that make life worth living in Iowa City.
Sincerely,
Ellen Lewin, PhD
Professor, Anthropology and Gender, Women's & Sexuality Studies
Department of Gender, Women's & Sexuality Studies
210 Jefferson Building
University of Iowa
Iowa City, IA 52242
President - Elect, Association for Feminist Anthropology
Marian Karr
From: Genie Maybanks <g mayban ks@newpi. coop>
Sent: Wednesday, November 28, 2012 4:30 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: New Pi Member input
I am in favor of a design that incorporates New Pioneer Food Co -op.
We really need a new facility and I would really like our store to be able to remain downtown.
I love Iowa City.
Thanks!
Genie Maybanks
1916 Hughes Circle SW
Cedar Rapids, IA 52404
14:�_
Marian Karr
From: Joan Falconer <joan- falconer @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Thursday, November 29, 2012 4:31 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: finalists
I retired from the University after 15 years of employment. I have lived in IC for over 25 years; in earlier years
I lived, among other places, in Albany, NY, New York City, Chicago, and Bloomington, IN. Since coming to
IC in 1985 I have been a member of Trinity Episcopal Church and of the New Pioneer Coop. Here are my
views, starting with the least attractive proposal:
Chauncey LLC: A 20 -story building is inappropriate for this town at any location, but certainly at this one,
surrounded as it is by comparatively low structures. There would not be sufficient parking space to
accommodate patrons of the bowling alley and the hotel and offices, even with the parking planned for
residents. Some claim the Chauncey Swan ramp is half empty much of the time, but that is likely the view of a
casual observer who walks through now and then. Especially during home games and the Farmers' Markets it is
jammed, and many other evenings and weekends it is quite full. Worst of all, the plan makes no provision for
the relocation of the New Pioneer Coop, the needs of which were a mainspring for this entire exercise in the
first place. One letter to the Press Citizen favored this building for the "vibrancy" it would bring to
downtown. Evenings and weekends the downtown- -and especially the ped mall - -are hopping, plenty "vibrant"
enough for the current police staff, and I have rarely seen that area deserted during daytime or evening
hours. I have also heard that a 20 -story structure could inhibit changes down the road that might be envisioned
for the Municipal Airport. This seems a pretentious design, and one of the three that would not be seeking
LEED certification.
Chauncey Gardens LLC. Again, too high for the area. Parking and airport concerns also apply, and lack
of LEED certification.
Sherman Associates. The design as shown and described in the PC seems unimaginative. A plus is the
intention that all the living units would be designed for workforce housing. But I think the city could do better.
Ryan Companies/Iceberg Development. This, in my view, is definitely better. The environmental proposals
(LEED, roof -top cistern, etc.) put this on the right side of history, in keeping with present trends in this city. It
also seems more affordable.
4 Zero 4 Development. This has my vote as the best option. It recognizes the existing clienteles in the
neighborhood for the New Pi Co -op and the Bike Library, it wouldn't overwhelm buildings on the adjacent
corners, and its "environmentally friendly design elements" would place it in the vanguard of like- minded
designers. (It also, not incidentally, would be most in keeping with the values of Trinity Church as I perceive
them.) I also find commendable the wish of the developers to locate it at the north end of Chauncey Swan
Park, provided the ground could be raised above flood -plain level; but even if this cannot happen, this design
seems most appropriate to the neighborhood. (There might be some concern about possible reflectivity of the
solar panels.)
Thank you for considering my views.
/4:�-
Marian Karr
From: ryan durbin <durbinr1750 @hotmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, November 29, 2012 8:30 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: The Chauncey
I am a resident of Iowa City and a close follower of urban development projects locally, statewide, and nationally. With
that in mind, I say with confidence that the 20 -floor Chauncey building is the best of the choices for the space at College
and Gilbert. Chauncey Gardens would be second best, but the Chauncey is more of a signature building than the other
four finalists... by a long shot. Go with the Chauncey.
Thank you for listening.
Ryan Durbin
Marian Karr
From: Julie Gabrielson <julie.gabrielson @g mail. com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 10:40 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: College /Gilbert project input
Dear Council Members,
After extensive analysis of the short- listed proposals, I would like to voice my full support for
The Chauncey. It contains the perfect combination of NEW amenities that Iowa City needs to
enhance downtown and make it a true destination for all ages. The addition of cinema theaters and
bowling alleys satisfies a completely new and needed market for downtown. Unlike the other
proposals, The Chauncey contains a hotel in addition to the residential portion of the upper
floors. Providing at least 20% of the residential units for much needed work force housing creates an
ideal mix and diversity of units and allows a broad mix of people to make this building their
home. The project team is also made up entirely of local members. With tax payer dollars being
spent on this project, it should be awarded to an all local team, especially when that team has put
forth the best proposal. The building is beautiful and would be an instant icon of Iowa
City. Sustainability is a core principal to the project and is incorporated in a more elegant way rather
than in the most visible but less efficient way of strapping Photo - Voltaic panels to the front of the
building.. PV panels have low efficiency rates of energy conversion as they are, especially with our
relatively limited solar access in this geographic region. Placing immovable PV panels at inopportune
angles on the front of the building that are unable to change angle to respond to the sun's movement
is more of a gimmick than an appropriate sustainable approach.
All proposals contain commercial space and residential space on the upper floors so one of the
biggest determinants should be the proposed ground floor program. A cinema theater, public
art/sculpture gallery, bowling alley, and cafe /restaurant are much more successful at energizing the
pedestrian streetscape than a grocery store and offer NEW destinations for downtown. I am a Co -Op
member but think it would be short sighted and a major missed opportunity to choose a project that
simply relocates an existing grocery store already having great success in their current building and
location when there is an opportunity to select a project that adds new amenities that would enhance
and enliven downtown far more than another grocery store. This site is far from ideal and frankly
problematic to house a large grocery store. There is not sufficient service access and turnabout
space for the daily shipments from large semi trucks. This concern was addressed in the Chauncey
Garden's first proposal to build on the site of the current Chauncey Swan Park where there is better
service access for the large and frequent semi truck deliveries. We are largely shielded from this
function at the current site of the Co -Op because there is a pull through alley directly adjacent to the
building that allows this function to occur off a major busy city street. If the Co -Op is relocated to the
Gilbert street site, everyone who transits the area should be aware and prepared to accept daily
blockages of traffic in this area while large semi trucks service the store. I hope the Co -op always
has a downtown Iowa City location but at a site with the necessary service access it requires.
Lastly, the city stated a primary reason for issuing the RFP for this project was to get this site
back online paying taxes. From the list of proposals, The Chauncey would pay by far the highest
annual property taxes and represents the greatest long term tax benefit to the city. I hope you select
The Chauncey and help elevate downtown Iowa City to an unprecedented level of entertainment and
excitement for all ages
Julie Gabrielson
Iowa City
Marian Karr
From: Roxane Mitten <roxane- mitten @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 10:48 AM
To: CGProject
Cc: roxane- mitten @uiowa.edu
Subject: College - Gilbert Proposals: Support for New Pioneer Coop proposal
I favor a design which includes New Pi for the upcoming decision on the College - Gilbert Proposals
Roxane Mitten
Iowa City Resident
14;�o
Marian Karr
From: Jim <j.schlott @mchsi.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 10:57 AM
To: CGProject
Thank you for the opportunity for input. The council has five very interesting, and potentially viable proposals, to chose
between. As a business owner in Iowa City for over 30 years I would like to present a few points I hope the council can
address, or at least consider, before they make a final decision.
1. The council has a unique opportunity to fundamentally change the demographics, and subsequent retail make up,
of the downtown area with this project. Currently the housing market in the downtown area is primarily high
density student housing. How will these proposals change that? If you want a diverse and vibrant down town
population you need to attract working people, young professionals, young families and empty nesters to live
there. A number of the proposals identify the goal of providing a certain percentage of 'workforce housing'. What
exactly does that mean and how is it enforceable? The council can specify that the living units be primarily owner
occupied one and 2 bedroom condominiums as opposed to rental units. If you as a council don't do that you need
to clearly explain how you plan to prevent this from becoming another high density student housing project. If the
council thinks more high density student housing is desirable in this location you need to explain to the public how
that will add to a more diverse and sustainable downtown population and business environment.
2. The council should give extra weight to the proposals that incorporate New Pioneer co -op on their plans. I am not
a member of the co -op and rarely shop there. However, I think there are two fundamental reasons to favor those
plans. First and foremost New Pioneer is an established business with a large and loyal client base. They are
established in this general geographic area. There is little chance of other competition moving in that would
threaten them. That makes them a very stable tenant to anchor the entry level of this development. Simply put,
they have a business model and financial history that proves they can pay the rent. Second, if the council wants a
diverse population to live and work in the down down area, there need to be amenities for them there. Grocery
stores near their living area are a critical component to that.
3. Finally, the proposal that incorporates movie theaters and a bowling alley seems attractive. There are currently no
movie theaters downtown and the areas ability to support more bowling has been well researched and
documented. Central States Theaters closed their theaters in Old Capitol Mall just a few years ago because they
weren't economical viable. The were a very large regional company that had access to all the first run releases.
They were a well established, experienced company that couldn't make the downtown location work. If they
couldn't make the business work why will Film Scene be able to? And if Film Scene closes in three years what
will go in that space? The same questions apply to a bowling alley. If the University puts a bowling alley in the
basement of the Memorial Union will this business be able to survive subsidized competition? Both of these are
untested businesses with no guarantee of long term viability. But they will initially occupy a great deal of square
footage. The council needs to know if the developer has a plan 'B' if these businesses don't survive.
Thank you for the opportunity to provide input.
Sincerely,
Jim Schlott
JS &JS Investments
14
Marian Karr
From: Joanne Seeberger <joanne- seeberger @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 11:03 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: New Pi for College - Gilbert Proposals
I wish to express my preference for choosing one of the design which includes the New Pioneer Co -op in it for the
College - Gilbert Proposals.
Thank you very much.
Joanne Seeberger
Marian Karr
From: Mary Blackwood <blackwood13 @msn.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 11:32 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: College - Gilbert proposals - New Pioneer Co -op should be included
Dear Committee,
I strongly support the selection of a design for the College - Gilbert site that would include the New Pioneer Co -op. This
would be an excellent use of the space. The beloved New Pi is a valuable, long- standing part of our community -- one
that fully supports the timely and important goal of providing local, sustainable and healthy food as well as education
about such food -- but it needs bigger space. Keeping it in the heart of downtown is very important as well.
Best,
Mary Blackwood
E
Marian Karr
From: Weiner, Joshua <josh ua-weiner@uiowa. ed u >
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 12:41 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Comment on College and Gilbert proposal
Greetings,
I understand that you are soliciting public opinion on the various proposals
that are accessible online for the College and Gilbert corner of Iowa City.
Having read through the proposals, I would like to express my strong
support for the 4 Zero 4 proposal. I think the key elements of the proposal-
- focusing on the important New Pi Co -op, including the much - needed
Bicycle Library, a strong commitment to sustainability and seeking LEED
Platinum certification — coupled with the very attractive (and different, not
"cookie- cutter) design, make the 4 Zero 4 proposal the best overall. The
proposal was also, by far, the most well- documented and well - planned.
Please count this as one citizen's vote for this project!
Thanks,
Joshua A. Weiner, Ph.D.
Associate Professor
Associate Chair for Graduate Education
Department of Biology
The University of Iowa
143 Biology Building
Iowa City, IA 52242
Office: 319 - 335 -0091
Lab: 319 - 335 -1328
Fax: 319 - 335 -1069
E -mail: joshua- weiner@uiowa.edu
i
I�
Marian Karr
From: Megan Drake <megan.drake17 @gmai1.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 1:48 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Chauncey Gardens
City Council Members-
The redevelopment of Chauncey Park is an important step in the growth and enrichment of the downtown Iowa
City area. Having grown up in Iowa City, I believe the downtown Iowa City area is unique in it's ability to
support a vibrant mix of pedestrian traffic, small businesses, and community events. In my opinion
the "Chauncey Gardens" proposal, presented by Chauncey Gardens, LLC, is the best option for expanding this
already unique area. The team has show their investment in the Iowa City community and is already highly
invested in the downtown area.
The thought included in their proposal shows that they are thinking of the larger picture and about what will
most benefit the community as well as the project. For example, the idea that the buildings might be placed on
the opposite side of the site shows that they have put a lot of educated thought into how the building
would function and how it would fit into the larger community most effectively. Similarly, one of the reasons I
believe Chauncey Gardens offers the best opportunity for the future of downtown is the focus on connecting to
the community. The stepped back design of the tower and proportions of the lower building faces make the
building more approachable and creates an appropriate streetscape that people will want to walk
near. Interweaving the green space up the building creates a convenient pathway that will help connect the
different elevations surrounding the building and will encourage traffic to and from the project's various
components and the heart of downtown.
The inclusion of the Pioneer Co -Op offers an important anchor for the building and a needed new space for a
business that has been a staple in the community for many years. The possible test kitchens and classroom offer
the possibility of educational classes and events that would help bring a large variety of residents to the area.
The mix -use opportunities of the building, including, retail, residential, and event space, will be a destination
for people of all ages and interest. The layout of the Chauncey Garden's green space offers
expansion opportunities for events like the ever expanding Farmer's Market, or Jazz Fest, which could use the
space for another stage.
The layout of the building and site encourages people to interact with all sides and levels of the project
and visibly displays and encourages environmental stewardship. From the quality residences, to the publicly
accessible rooftop, the community garden's to the integrated solar panels Chauncey Garden's could become an
icon and model for urban agriculture, sustainability, and how a project can serve all levels of the community. It
is obvious that the project team is invested and experienced in creating a building the is not only efficient to run
but is conscious of how it effects the environment we live in.
These are just some of the reasons I think the Chauncey Gardens proposal as well and the Chauncey Garden
L.L.C. team are the correct decision for the city of Iowa City. Chauncey Gardens will become a project Iowa
City can be proud of.
Thank you for your consideration,
Megan Drake
(�O
Marian Karr
From: David Drake <davidcdrake @icloud.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 1:37 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Chauncey Gardens
Tou name av tgnoptiavti Sextatov do gaKs tv DEXEg(3Ep tirJati (00A PS�XEXti 0V T116 �utiupe o� So()V tioc)V S
e skongevti fop SexaSEa, ao I ag wpttitvy YOU TO ritnxtyllti (puati a sec) o� tine gavyr Seatpap%s e44E
vtia oo XilauvXEyr rccpSEva. I PsXtems tiriati Xr1auvXEy1 rapSEva atiav8a outi Opog tine ovnspa RExaua
E OO T11e tirJovy11ti irlati wevti tVxo tine nponoaax, auXII aa:
xilauvxeyf r0cp8eva tvxxioutov oo tine NEW MOVEEp Xoon O)IX,% (3ptvy a xpoaa aeXtitoV 00 apea peat&vti
Cr do brie Xoxatitov SuptVy ire Xovy rloupa tirleyr (xps o7tEv, avS on%,% tvX,%uSE XoggepXtaX avS peticaX a
gevttitea apouVS tine eVtitps put',Stvy 7ceptgeiep.
Tree Ag7r1ttigsatiep anXX RE a 8eatpocPX6 gu),tit —vaE apea tirJati c00A atitipaXti a Xpoaa aEXtitov 00 apea p
Eat&vtia atitisvStvy a maptsryJ oo uvSep tine atiapa EMEVtia, eaatkyr axXEaatPxE do SowviowVEpa aV8
YIatiuSEVtia.
XriauvXEyr FapSEVa (OWL atitipaXti aVS gtvyXE Wapynvy aye ypou7Ca.
Tile peatSEVtitaX tiowEp to aST P(XXx Opog tine aScpotvtvy atipeeia, ao as Voti do Sogtvatie T1JS 7CE8eatiptav
OtecO.
Chauncey Gardens will integrate community gardens, terraces and a public rooftop with a spectacular
view of the city.
Chauncey Gardens makes public green spaces a priority, visually tying it to Chauncey Swan Park.
Chauncey Gardens will enhance and encourage more use of Chauncey Swan Park, making it the
destination of choice in downtown Iowa city.
The Chauncey Garden Development will seek input from the community to make certain it will fit their
needs.
The Chauncey Gardens development team has a stellar reputation for green design and projects that work
for their clients. They have proven they are invested in the future of the Iowa city area by their
actions.
Just a few of the reasons why, as a resident of the area, I believe Chauncey Gardens is the best option for
the corner of Gilbert and College Streets
David C. Drake
l6
Marian Karr
From: Sara Krieger < sara .krieger @iowacityhospice.org>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 2:33 PM
To: Council
Subject: Chauncy Gardens
Iowa City Council Members,
I am writing in support of the Chauncy Garden's LLC proposal for the corner of Gilbert and College
Street in downtown Iowa City. The Chauncy Gardens building is not only the most visually appealing building, it
has the most coherent design. This group has clearly considered how their design can best serve the Iowa City
greater community and our environment. This building will draw all ages of people downtown and create a
greater sense of community. This team of professionals live in Iowa City and have contributed many other
successful projects. They care about Iowa City and understand our culture. They also appeared to be the only
group interested in hearing public opinion throughout the process.
Thank you for considering my opinion as you make this difficult decision and thank you for serving our
community through your participation on the Iowa City Council.
Respectfully,
Sara Krieger
Member of the Iowa City Community for 8 years and lifetime Iowan.
63 Wakefield Court
Iowa City, Iowa 52240
319 - 325 -8304
l�
Marian Karr
From: Sandalwood Heart <sandalwood heart@yahoo. com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 3:07 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: To: Iowa City & City Council Re: CG Project Opinion From: Laura Dowd
Dear City of Iowa City and the Iowa City City Council,
I am writing to state that I believe the proposed College and Gilbert Streets building projects which include
space for the New Pioneer Co- operative store will best serve the needs of the Iowa City community. I believe
having a new, energy - efficient store for New Pi - one that will accommodate the needs of its growing member
base and form a stronger link with the Iowa City Farmers' Market - will be embraced by the people of Iowa
City.
Sincerely,
Laura Dowd
502 Kimball Road
Iowa City, IA 52245
(319) 338 -2010
I�
Marian Karr
From: bethandjoe2smith @gmail.com on behalf of Beth Smith <bethsmith @southslope.net>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 3:09 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Gilbert street proposal
I vote for the Four Zero Four development!
Beth Smith
16
Marian Karr
From: Mark Palmberg <palmberg @gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 3:49 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College - Gilbert proposals
I'm writing to express my approval -- as a Co -op member and longtime Iowa City resident -- of the original
Chauncey Gardens proposal for the new development at the corner(s) of Gilbert and Washington/College
Streets.* Which is to say, the proposal featuring the building at the north end (Washington St. side) of the
proposed site.
Having the open area exposed to the south will add days of use to that space each year; accumulated snow will
melt faster; wet ground will dry faster; flowering plants and grass will thrive. Why have a tall building cast its
long shadow over an outdoor green space when it can cast it instead over a street and a civic building?
Thanks for your consideration.
Mark Palmberg
1802 E. College St.
* My brother works at Neumann Monson Architects.
I�O
Marian Karr
From: Porth, Catherine <CPorth @unitedfiregroup.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 3:41 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: CG Project Input
To City Council of Iowa City -
I would first like to preface this letter by saying that I have never felt compelled to give input regarding a new
development in Iowa City until I started looking over these proposals. The main reason that drew me to want
to give "my two cents' is that New Pioneer Coop is involved in this development. After reviewing the
proposals provided, I without a doubt believe The Chauncey would be a wonderful addition to the downtown
area. It's time the downtown became more family friendly with something to offer besides bars and great
restaurants. Having a nice movie theater and bowling alley along with a wonderful grocery store and an
outdoor entertainment area offers more variety for everyone visiting the downtown area. I can only assume
that this update will also increase the amount of patrons to the Farmers Market during the summer.
My only negative comment is the name. The Chauncey just doesri t strike me as fitting for downtown Iowa
City. We're a college town, not a quaint village in England. The name may seem insignificant, but it can have
as much to do with the success of the new development as the development itself. Perhaps a name change
could be considered?
I cannot emphasize enough how excited I am at the prospect of having this new addition to the downtown. I
sincerely hope you take my comments into consideration at your December 18th meeting. Thank you for your
time.
Sincerely,
Catherine Porth
This email may contain confidential, copyrighted or privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient or if you have received this email in error, please
notify the sender immediately and destroy this email. Any unauthorized copying, disclosure or distribution of the material in this email is strictly forbidden. United
Fire Group cannot warrant the integrity of this communication, or that it is void of errors, viruses or interference.
As the Internet is not a fully secure environment, United Fire Group cannot ensure that this or any other email has not been interfered with during transmission.
The sender, therefore, does not accept liability for any errors or omissions in the contents of this message that arise because of email transmission.
Marian Karr
From: Hannah Papineschi <hannahpapineschi @gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 3:41 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College and Gilbert St.
Dear Council Members,
R
I am writing to comment on the College and Gilbert St. development. I feel that the 4 Zero 4 development
project offers the most exciting growth opportunity for Iowa City. Not only does this development include
cornerstone operations of the Iowa City Community (the Bike Library and the Coop), it is the only project that
is aggressively green. A LEED Platinum building in downtown Iowa City would bring us in trend with the
growth of green building throughout the nation and the world. As a statement piece to the community (which
this project will inevitably be) this building will say that the City recognizes the need for sustainability and
resilience in a world that is being devastated by extreme climate events. 4 Zero 4 is a progressive opportunity
for Iowa City to develop not just for the sake of business, but to also make a statement about the shape of our
community and the values that we hold. As a member of this community I would be excited to see Iowa City
support sustainable and resilient growth. I hope the council will echo these thoughts and vote for 4 Zero 4.
Sincerely,
Hannah Papineschi
905 S. 7th Ave
Iowa City, IA 52240
(319) 400 3328
IL
Marian Karr
From: sandra dyas <sandy @sandydyas.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 4:12 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: FilmScene at The Chauncey
I am writing in big support of FilmScene at the Chauncey. I have been privy to some of
the planning that has" went into this huge endeavor. I also looked over all five of the
contenders.
The Chauncey Project is the only project that is 100% LOCAL. Period. Yes, a local
architect, developer, contractor and management team - all LOCAL. In my opinion
this is the best project for many reasons and that is one of them.
Iowa City needs to update its downtown. WE are growing as a city. The downtown
should be a central hub for our arts and culture. The Englert is proving how important
that is. More people are being drawn to our city because of Englert events. Prairie
Lights is another example of an independent book store making it despite many
bookstores all over the country closing their doors. Prairie Lights is successful because it is in Iowa
City -
and it draws people from everywhere. We can attend a book reading by a well -known
author for free by going to our locally owned independent bookstore. How many cities in Iowa
can say this?
A downtown locally owned theatre featuring independent film makes so much sense. We have one
of the best film schools in the country at the university. We have a population who
would attend a film theatre such as FilmScene. Having a film theatre such as FilmScene
would be very advantageous to our downtown. Again, this would add to our downtown
in a vibrant way - bringing people from all over to enjoy independent films and film
festivals. FilmScene would be a welcome addition - and in many ways be similar
to Praire Lights and the Englert.
The bowling alley proposed sounds amazing. I know students as well as community members
would love to have a "boutique" bowling alley in our town. This will also be a major
attraction for people in the surrounding areas and visitors looking for something to do
besides shop.
I love the design! This is absolutely the best looking building design! It fits Iowa City.
Keep Iowa City Unique. It is not Coralville and it is not Des Moines. We are a university
town and we need to embrace our uniqueness - -- but at the same time we must allow for
positive growth in the downtown creating an even more inviting and special Iowa City.
I cannot wait for FilmScene!
1
Sincerely,
Sandy Dyas
Sandra L. Dyas
Art Department
Cornell College
htta:/ /www.sandvdvas.com/
htta:l /www.50states P ro sect. net/
hftp://sandvdvas.blogspot.com
www.etsy.com /shop /sandvdvasphotoaraphy
http : / /twitter.com /sandyiowacity
http: / /Www.youtube.com /user /sandylowaC!ty
http : / /www.facebook.com/nages/lowa- City- IA/Sandy- Dyas- Photog aaphy /307087386844 ?ref =ts
E
Marian Karr
From: Carol deProsse <lonetreefox @mac.com>
Sent: Saturday, December 01, 2012 9:20 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: Proposal Comments
Proposal comments.
http : / /twoatthefrinize.blogspot.com /2012 /12 /and - winner- is.html
(the link should work, but if it does not please copy it and paste it in the URL bar.)
Thank you.
Carol deProsse
1401 Burry Drive
Iowa City, IA 52246 -4513
Everyone looks at the issues from a different perspective. This is ours, sometimes individually, sometimes as a duet.
And the Winner Is .. .
The Chauncey
The best choice for the redevelopment of the old Wilson's Sporting Goods /Greyhound Bus Depot
site is The Chauncey, a planned 20 -story structure with a 150 seat theater managed by FilmScene;
two six lane bowling alleys; a cafe; an art and sculpture gallery; a 35 room hotel; Class A office
space and workforce housing units. It makes sense financially, culturally and aesthetically.
The plan incorporates LEED certification, geothermal and solar power, and permeable pavers; and it
would be a 100% local project — a big plus — led by Marc Moen who is known for his commitment to
developing only in downtown Iowa City; and Moen has his private funding sources firmly committed.
There are two drawbacks to this exciting proposal: the planned use of Tax Incremental Financing
(TIF) and the proposed height of 20 stories. At the public meeting Moen stated that this
development could be built at 16 stories, which would be more in keeping with the general height
limits already in place. Since we heard in a previous presentation by Moen that he needed TIF ($2
million) to put the top two stories on the Wells Fargo site building, it seems reasonable to posit that
taking four stories off the Chauncy making it 16 stories instead of 20 would eliminate the need for
TIF support for this project.
The Chauncey is clearly a project that would bring an exciting diversification of entertainment
opportunities to downtown and without reliance on TIF would start returning 100% of tax dollars to
the city, avoiding the strong citizens' objection regarding the use of TIF for private development that
does not create affordable housing or other direct benefit to low and moderate wage earners in Iowa
City and Johnson County.
Downtown Iowa City has a fine public library, the lovely Englert, unique stores, decent restaurants,
banks, grocery stores, and just enough bars now to make the area attractive for many people.
Developing the College /Gilbert Streets site with the attributes noted above would round out this area
quite nicely. I think more people who come downtown are interested in going bowling or to the
movies than in going grocery shopping.
Carol deProsse
l�
Marian Karr
- - - -- Original Message---- -
From: pephrave @oaknoll.com [mailto:pephrave @ oaknoll.com]
Sent: Sunday, December 02, 2012 8:43 PM
To: *Contact
Subject: Online Contact Form Submission
From: Patricia Ephgrave
Phone: 319 - 466 -3057
Email: pephrave @oaknoll.com
Dear Council Members
The proposed building plans for the property on Gilbert and College Street are of great interest to the whole
of Iowa City, not just the downtown interests. Therefore I thank the City Council for soliciting opinions from
all its citizens.
In their book "Adapting Buildings and Cities for Climate Change" authors Sue Roaf, et al, argue for new
standards to help cities become more livable by meeting the challenges of climate change. One way to cut
energy costs is to cut down on radiant heat from buildings and mitigate what is present with more green
space and garden roofs, following the Chicago model. Another is cut usage by better planning and design —
buildings over 10 stories require a much greater energy use in constructing and in operation than lower
structures. The site proposals under this height are better for our energy use and for our city.
We pride our selves in being a model city---with its current ambience. If we drastically change our profile,
the traffic and parking increases in the downtown area will significantly decrease the human scale and the
pedestrian friendly atmosphere of the area. The change in wind and shade patterns will adversely affect
existing structures and residents, a point also addressed in Roafs book. Furthermore, a very tall structure so
near to the two story City Hall will send a mixed message on decision - making in our city.
I hope you will consider the long -term energy use, the rights of existing property owners, the ambience of
human scale structures for our citizens, and the future direction of our city as you decide on the building
proposals.
Jb
Marian Karr
From: d.jesse.damazo @gmaii.com on behalf of D. Jesse Damazo <jesse- damazo @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Sunday, December 02, 2012 4:18 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Comment on Proposals from Executive Director of Bijou Cinema
Attachments: FilmScene Support Letter.pdf
Dear City Council,
Please find attached my letter in support of The Chauncey & FilmScene.
Sincerely,
Jesse Damazo
Executive Director Bijou Cinema
tha
to Mtff"aws
09inW c
Dear City Council,
As the Executive Director of the Bijou Cinema, I am writing this letter in support
of The Chauncey proposal for the redevelopment of College Street /,Gilbert Street. The
Chauncey proposal features a space for the local non - profit cinema FilmScene. For
several years, we have planned to incorporate the operations of The Bijou into
FilmScene, and our board of directors has unanimously voted to put all of our financial
resources and all of our equipment at the service of FilmScene. We are in complete and
unconditional support of this venture.
The Bijou has been screening films for students and community members for
more than forty years. I have been the Executive Director for three of those years, and I
can personally attest that Iowa City needs a cinema in downtown Iowa City. A student
cinema is not enough to serve the needs of a market as large and as culturally
sophisticated as Iowa City. Instead, Iowa City needs a professional, first -run cinema with
more than one screen that is open year round. Iowa City needs FilmScene.
Cinema is a major contemporary and historical art form, and Iowa City deserves
a venue for its display. I firmly believe that FilmScene, housed in The Chauncey
development, would become an important asset for the cultural life of Iowa City.
Sincerely,
RMCO
D. Jesse Damazo
Executive Director of the Bijou Cinema
l/
Marian Karr
From: Brian Gotwals <b.gotwals @mchsi.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 02, 2012 10:14 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: CG Project Input
I am writing in support of the 4zero4 proposal.
6 reasons to choose 4zero4 over the other proposals:
1. 4zero4 is a net zero design, meaning the proposed building will produce as much energy as it consumes. Net zero
designs are the future and are still rather rare, especially for multi -story uses. The other 20 story designs have large
expanses of glass that will require a lot of energy to heat and cool. The net -zero design of 4zero4 will distinguish Iowa
City nationally. But more importantly, it is the right thing to do. Who are we and what do we stand for ?!!!!!!
2. 4zero4 is scaled appropriately to the neighboring buildings. The other serious proposals are 20- storey buildings that
will overwhelm the park and cast a long shadow over activities there.
3. The New Pioneer Coop needs a new home. 4zero4 places the New Pi at the heart of their proposal.
4. 4zero4 will not transform Chauncey Swan park into an environment that is unfriendly to seniors and children, with so
many level changes and ramps. Look at the images of 4zero4. Chauncey Swan park looks familiar, as it should.
5. 4zero4 will dedicate a percentage of the units to workforce housing. This means that an individual who works in the
Coop on the first floor will be able to afford a unit in the building. This is the GREEN AMERICAN DREAM!
6. 4zero4 brings back the Bike Library to the site. Why? Because the Bike Library stands for the same common sense
idea of low energy usage that is good for the community. THIS is what distinguishes Iowa City from neighboring cities,
and nationally.
Ask yourself: who are we and what do we stand for? 4zero4 is only unique proposal among the five finalists. It is the
only proposal that puts forward a substantial vision for the future of Iowa City that more than just an image.
Thanks
Brian Gotwals
1�
Marian Karr
From: Jan Locher <Iocherj @mchsi.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 02, 2012 4:40 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: CG Project Input
Please keep the the skyscape low.
l
Marian Karr
From: Tom Martin <tsm167 @live.com>
Sent: Saturday, December 01, 2012 11:54 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: public comment
think this project is a tremendous plus for the future of the city. I favor a shorter building rather than a taller
building for several reasons. 1. 1 think it would fit better aesthetically on that corner and be more pleasing to
the eye rather than a tall building sticking up in the air. 2.1 am concerned about the traffic created by the
facility and naturally the shorter building would create less traffic. I have seen little discussion about parking
and this concerns me. Especially if New Pioneer Co -op is located in the new building. What is the plan for
parking? I would favor Tim Dwight's project. A building with net zero energy usage could bring some nation
wide positive attention to downtown Iowa City. Good Luck and Keep Moving Forward.
Tom Martin
167 Notting Hill Ln
Iowa City IA 52245
Cell: 319 - 530 -1010
Home: 319 - 351 -1239
1
01
Marian Karr
From: Huelsbeck, Mark <MHuelsbeck @flagler.edu>
Sent: Saturday, December 01, 2012 11:04 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: The Chauncy & FilmScene
What a tremendous opportunity for Iowa City! Please make the two screen FilmScene a reality. This would truly enhance
the Downtown area and once again put Iowa City at the forfront of the arts.
As a former resident of Iowa City and a frequent visitor (my mom still lives in IA City) I must say that this proposal looks
like just what the city needs to revitalize the downtown for use by others than just students doing pub crawls. What can
we do to get this project underway?
Sincerely,
Mark Huelsbeck
Mark Huelsbeck
Assistant Professor
Department of Communication
Flagler College
74 King Street
Saint Augustine, FL 32084
904.819.6421
This email contains CONFIDENTIAL information intended only for the use of the addressee(s) named above. If you are
not the intended recipient of this email, you are hereby notified that any dissemination or copying of this email is strictly
prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please notify us by reply email and delete this email from your
records. Furthermore, the contents of this email do not necessarily represent official policy of Flagler College.
1�
Marian Karr
From: Josh Eklow <josheklow@g mail. com>
Sent: Saturday, December 01, 2012 10:37 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: The Chauncey!
To Whom It May Concern (And That Means You)
Hi. My name is Josh Eklow. I've been a resident of Iowa City for going on nine years, seven of which were as a
student at the University of Iowa.
One of the interesting things about living in Iowa City for so long, and past two separate matriculations, has
been to discover that Iowa City is actually a place beyond the University of Iowa.
Though the campus is blended into the town so very nicely, my relationship with the University has gone from
it happily being my sole provider of art and culture in Iowa City, to one of a few (and I mean few) sources.
As I began to consider myself less of a citizen of the U and more of a citizen of The IC (television show idea in
there, I think), I often became frustrated that so few opportunities existed outside of the University.
Let's talk movies, for example. I received a degree in Cinema from the University, so they (and my mother)
should appreciate that I am finally finding a way to get some mileage out of that degree.
If I want to see a movie that's about something other than Megan Fox talking to cars, my options are few. I can
take my money to the chain video stores (our local video store closed, remember ?) or I can go to the Bijou.
Now, don't get me wrong. I love the Bijou. Love it. I have spent many an evening there and will continue to do
so as long as I am in Iowa City.
However, I'm not a student. Quite frankly, it's starting to get my goat that I have to go to campus to see a film.
I'm an adult! I might like to have an adult beverage. I might like to spend a night in Iowa City, not at the
University of Iowa. I might like to give my money to a local business, not some arm (though it is my favorite
arm) of an institution that holds a sign in one hand proclaiming the need for alcohol alternatives while using the
other to monopolize most of the opportunities in town for independent art and culture (and toss their logo onto
the beer cans that litter our lawns after every homegame).
I can't blame the U for trying to make cool things happen for their large population of students (though I have to
admit that most of them, as far as I recall, were pretty lame and quickly ignored for house party invites and bar
specials). However, I would like to ask the City to consider that the need for intellectual stimulation not be
pawned off on the University entirely.
It's easy to forget, but there are people who live in Iowa City, work in Iowa City, and spend money in Iowa
City, that are in no way affiliated with the University and do not want to depend on the University for their
entertainment.
One such person is Andy Brodie. I've known Andy quite a while and I can remember many afternoons at the
Iowa City Senior Center (a shining example of non - academic culture), talking about his dream to have an
arthouse cinema in town. Places like Austin, TX have them, and Iowa City is cool too, so why not here? I would
leave these conversations thinking, "That would be so cool ", with a silent "but cool things like that just don't
happen in IC ". Well, it turned out that Andy had higher hopes and aspirations for moving pictures show in our
city, and he stuck with it. The idea became a conversation, a proposal, a project, a plan, and now, emails such as
this.
Iowa City needs an art house movie theater. We deserve it. Iowa City can be a cooler place. The fact that this is
even being considered has given me new hope that when someone says, "Why doesn't Iowa City have a movie
theater downtown? Or a bowling alley ? ", the answer will no longer be, "Yeah, I wish ". It will be "yeah, they're
working on it."
Josh Eklow
319 - 855 -0160
2
0
Marian Karr
From: Patricia McNichol <pmcnichol48 @g mail. com>
Sent: Saturday, December 01, 2012 10:21 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: CG Project Input
I watched all the proposals on my computer last night and I want to weight in with my vote for the Chauncey Gardens
project.
1. All stakeholders are local folks.
2. 1 really like the amphitheater in the park, because that park is already often used for musical venues. The added
seating and amenities would be a perfect adjunct to our vibrant Farmers Market
3. 1 really like how the second story is designed to be public space.
4. 1 like the green elements of this design, both in the garden spaces and in the design /construction.
5. It seemed to me that the presenters of this project considered every impact possible on the surrounding area and
addressed them with their design, to make the development attractive and livable.
I can easily see myself using this space. It appears, even from an artist's rendering, to be very inviting. Not so with much
with the other projects.
Thank you for giving me an opportunity to share my opinions on this very important decision,
Patricia McNichol
I ('
Marian Karr
From: Nathan Morton <nathan- morton @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Saturday, December 01, 2012 8:53 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: support for 4 Zero 4 proposal.
Hello,
I am writing in support of the 4 Zero 4 proposal.
I believe it is among the most aesthetically interesting and with a LEED platinum rating the most progressive /energy
efficient /eco- friendly building. It is of moderate height and in the middle of the pack as far as costs. I think it is a good
fit for Iowa City.
I also am excited to see NEW PIONEER co -op at this site and happy to see that this proposal includes keeping the bike
library.
Sincerely,
Nathan Morton
Academic Advisor
The University of Iowa
1214 Highland Ave
Iowa City,lowa
Sent from my iPad
dp
Marian Karr
From: Evan Evans <evan @whitedogauto.com>
Sent: Saturday, December 01, 2012 9:16 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: CG Project Input
The prospect of having movie theaters once again in downtown Iowa City is exciting. Before 2007
there had always been several theaters downtown that drew large numbers of people who shopped
and spent money at other businesses. This is an ideal location for all of the proposed uses of the
Chauncey project building and, I believe, will greatly enhance Iowa City as a destination for arts and
entertainment. It will complement the Englert Theater, already a successful venue for live
performance as well as complement the many festivals and events that have done so well over the
years in making downtown a vibrant place. There is a growing interest in independent films and film
festivals, and venues such as the FilmScene theaters have done well in many locations. Along with
new arts campus buildings coming in the next few years it seems like a perfect response to the two
market studies that identified movie theaters as a major desired venue currently missing from
downtown. The Chauncey project makes the best use of this space and will attract many new people
to the downtown area. As a business owner (not downtown , but close by) since 1975, we see more
and more competition from nearby areas that tend to divert people from shopping or visiting Iowa
City. Our strength as a unique community that is closely associated with a world class University arts
campus, lies in enhancing the visual, literary, and performing arts scene in our downtown. The
Chauncey project really fulfills that role and should it become a reality will make our downtown an
even more attractive cultural destination.
Best regards -Evan Evans (FilmScene Board member)
owner:
Whitedog Inc.
424 Highland Ct.
Iowa City, IA 52240
319- 337 -4616
www.whitedonauto.com
1�
Marian Karr
From: David McCartney <dfmcc @yahoo.com>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 7:17 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College - Gilbert project input
Greetings,
Thank you for this opportunity to provide input concerning the proposed development plans at the NE corner of
College and Gilbert. All of the proposals are very attractive in different respects. While I can't recommend one
proposal over the others, I ask that the Council consider one that incorporates both FilmScene and the New
Pioneer Coop. Involving these two entities would both expand cultural opportunities in the downtown district as
well as enhance the long -term stability of a well - established business. New Pi, to remain viable and a part of the
downtown landscape, would contribute substantially to the success of any plan that is accepted, thanks to its
large and loyal membership base. FilmScene would introduce a new and vibrant cultural element. Combining
these would ensure a balanced and exciting development that would bring long -term benefits to downtown.
Again, thank you for your consideration.
David McCartney
1302 Muscatine Ave.
Iowa City, IA 52240
(319) 341 -3597
dfincc&yahoo.com
Marian Karr
From: Drake, Karen <karen- drake @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Friday, November 30, 2012 4:29 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Support for Chauncey Garden LLC project
I am sending this message to voice my support of the Chauncey Garden LLC project for the College and Gilbert property.
Not only is this the best looking project with upper end environmentally responsible features, it serves many positive
needs for the community. I feel the inclusion of New Pioneer Coop is a great advantage. This will encourage people such
as myself to shop there rather than going to Coralville as I currently do to avoid the cramped, dated original store. While
in the area I'm much more likely to head downtown to take advantage of stores as Prairie Lights, Active Endeavors, Dick
Blicks or Beadology or eat at one of the many excellent restaurants there. This is an all day draw 7 days a week as
opposed to anchors in some of the other projects that would have more spotty appeal focused more in the evenings,
week -ends or just for special event. I also love the proposed public gardens which along with the coop support the
Healthy Living appeal promoted for the area. (How about more Blue Zone appeal). This would be an extra draw for
myself and many others who might some day want to live in the building and could feed their gardening needs there.
This proposal, including moving and improving the park and adding the Ampiheather, also offers great opportunities for
those special events and relaxing everyday activities. The developers have been very thoughtful in placing the building
back on the lot to softens its foot print and moving the park to take better advantage of the sun. The fact that they
include many public spaces throughout the building fits the mission of the City to be inclusive. This would be a great
draw for the area and a brilliant choice for the council.
Thanks for you consideration,
Karen Drake
Notice: This UI Health Care e-mail (including attachments) is covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18
U.S.C. 2510 -2521, is confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby
notified that any retention, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. Please
reply to the sender that you have received the message in error, then delete it. Thank you.
Marian Karr
From: Cynthia Broderick < Cynthia _Broderick @hillsbank.com>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 11:31 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: CG Project Input
All of the proposed projects seem a bit out of scale with Iowa City. I don't see the need for this particular project to be
on such a large scale. I think that a large amount of landscaping around the property would be a positive feature.
Thank you,
Cynthia Broderick I Mortgage Post - closing Specialist
Hills Bank and Tmst Company
131 Main St, PO Box 160, Hills IA 522351319-679-5014 1 fax 319 - 679 -5573 1 www.hillsbank.com
Cynthia broderick(,hillsbank.com
NOTICE: This electronic mail message and any attached files are confidential. The information is exclusively for the use of the individual or
entity intended as the recipient. If you are not the intended recipient, any use, copying, printing, reviewing, retention, disclosure, distribution
or forwarding of the message or any attached file is not authorized and is strictly prohibited. If you have received this electronic mail message
in error, please advise the sender by reply electronic mail immediately and permanently delete the original transmission, any attachments
and any copies of this message from your computer system. Thank you.
M
Marian Karr
From: McBride, Bunny A <bunny- mcbride @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 12:31 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: move
My main concern is the integrity of the shop philosophy with the inventory, and, available parking!
Professor B. McBride, Emeritus
Ceramics Area Head
Studio Division Coordinator
Director of Studio Graduate Studies
School of Art and Art History
University of Iowa
Iowa City, Iowa 52242
Ph 319 - 331 -3421
1 L
Marian Karr
From: Ben Lewis <benjamind @gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 3:48 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College Street / Gilbert Street Redevelopment
To Whom it May Concern:
I am writing in support of either the 4 Zero 4 or the Chauncey Gardens proposals for the College Street / Gilbert Street
Redevelopment project.
Chauncey Gardens looks like it creates a beautiful outdoor amphitheater which could be used in many ways, gives the
New Pioneer Coop a place to move to, and provides needed office space.
4 Zero 4 is an opportunity for Iowa City to have one of the greenest buildings ever built, and could have a positive impact
on future development projects for years to come.
I don't think Iowa City needs a bowling alley or an additional independent film house downtown. We already have the
Bijou on campus, and FilmScene already has space in the pedestrian mall. Iowa City's downtown needs to have practical,
walkable businesses and services that make a real difference in citizens' everyday lives, and the Coop does just that.
Choosing an option that includes the Coop solidifies their future in downtown Iowa City.
Sincerely,
Ben Lewis
520 Grant Street
l6
Marian Karr
From: Jackie Wellborn <jackiewe @mchsi.com>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 5:26 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: New Pioneer
Importance: High
I am writing to encourage you to chose a model for the project that includes the New Pioneer Cooperative. New Pi has
been an essential and valuable part of Iowa City and essential to downtown. I work in the Cedar Rapids area and almost
every day I have people tell me they wish they had a New Pi in their area.
Though there is a store in Coralville it does not meet the needs of people who live in Iowa City and also, the students of
the University of Iowa. I trust you will make the right decision and vote for the model keeping the valuable New Pi in
business downtown.
Thank you
Jackie Wellborn
1318 Whiting Ave
Iowa City, IA 52245
14
Marian Karr
From: jim walters <jcmwalt @infionline.net>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 6:50 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College & Gilbert Proposals
To Whom It May Concern:
I remember the "charette" (nothing to do with BBQ) that preceded the "decision- making" on the Chauncey Swan
parking ramp. Nancy Seiberling (those of you who don't know her should do a little research) begged and pleaded -
almost on her knees - not to put it where it was put, but instead directly to the south, behind the Recreation Center - for
all sorts of aesthetic and architectural reasons. Nobody paid the slightest bit of attention to her.
Now we've got the monstrosity in the 500 block of E. Washington nearing completion, and soon (I expect) another
monstrosity where Agudas Achim used to sit.
Commenting on any of this seems almost pointless.
So, I say go for the biggest, ugliest, nastiest building you can go for - offer to add a few more stories and give them a
lifetime tax break. Why stop now, when you can totally destroy the charm, personality, and liveability of our eastside
neighborhoods?
Jim Walters
1033 E. Washington St.
Iowa City, IA 52240
319 - 466 -1134
P.S. It's really sad that New Pioneer Co -op is a component of 4 out of 5 of these proposals!
1 ta
Marian Karr
From: Tom Carsner <carsner @mchsi.com>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 7:44 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: New Pi AND Film Scene
My first choice for the CG Project is to combine any of the proposals that includes New Pioneer with the one
proposal that includes Film Scene. This would ensure two great pillars of the community have a home for
years to come.
The Chauncey proposal will anchor another arts and entertainment facility to downtown which is crucial to the
life of the downtown district and to enhancing opportunities for students. This proposal will return real
cinema to downtown Iowa City. This has been missing for several years. As a lifelong resident, I remember the
vibrancy of downtown when there were four movie theaters plus the Bijou downtown. Adding one high
quality theater will make a significant difference to the life of downtown.
The Chauncey Gardens offers the best concept for New Pioneer. Any of the other three proposals are less
compelling, but acceptable.
Tom Carsner
1627 College Court Place
Iowa City
319 - 338 -9335
carsner @mchsi.com
B
Marian Karr
From: Katherine Kelly <klkiowa @gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 7:53 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: New Pioneer Iowa City
I believe the project 4zero4 is the project fits with New Pioneer's vision.
Sent from my Whone
l�0
Marian Karr
From: Gerald Sim <gsim @fau.edu>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 9:06 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Letter of Support for THE CHAUNCEY
Dear Mayor Hayek and members of the City Council:
I am writing in support of THE CHAUNCEY as the project for redeveloping the property on the northeast corner of College
and Gilbert Streets. I believe that its advantages are an ideal fit for the community's stated needs, and for the City
Council's vision for the downtown area.
I speak as a former and future resident of Iowa City. I lived in the Northside neighborhood for 9 years while earning my
PhD in film studies at the UI. I continue to visit regularly, and fully intend to return when I retire. I have great affection
for the City, and understand how it can build on its natural strengths. THE CHAUNCEY's inclusion of Film Scene, in
particular, will bring a much needed and desired cultural component to downtown.
I can personally vouch for Andy Brodie as a committed citizen who is perfectly qualified professionally to helm the
enterprise; he has the crucial combination of being simultaneously committed to art and culture, while remaining
fully adept at navigating economic /business realities.
The independent film venues around the country in very similar towns, that have served as important models for
the Film Scene vision, further convince me that Iowa City and Film Scene can mutually benefit. Mr. Brodie's
intentions to make Film Scene the centerpiece of a film festival befits the city that houses perhaps the country's
oldest, and certainly one of its proudest academic film studies programs.
I now work at Florida Atlantic University's School of Communication and Multimedia Studies, whose partnership
with the Living Room Theaters is a shining example of what a public - private partnership can achieve. It
excites me to think that a similar cooperation can occur between Iowa City and the UI. It would clearly exceed
former movie venues like the Englert and the Old Capitol Mall, and overcome the structural limitations currently
experienced by the UI's Bijou Theater.
For these reasons, I am convinced that your support of THE CHAUNCEY will serve to bolster Iowa City's cultural
reputation, enhance one of the University's most noteworthy academic programs, and contribute mightily to continuing --
and meaningful -- economic growth downtown.
Sincerely,
Gerald Sim, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Film Studies
Coordinator of Multimedia Studies & SCMS Honors Program
School of Communication and Multimedia Studies
Florida Atlantic University
777 Glades Road; Boca Raton, FL 33431
tel: 561 -297 2050
http: / /www.fau.edu /scros /sim.php
I�
Marian Karr
From: MARY CROOKS <patchworkmaryj @msn.com>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 9:11 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Input for building at College and Gilbert
Hello,
I am an Iowa City resident and a loyal member of New Pioneer Coop. I am thrilled to hear of plans
for a new building that will meet the needs of our growing membership. New Pi does so much to
support our community. It is great to know that the city wants to partner with us for a new location.
I would like to see a building that fits in design -wise with the other buildings in this part of Iowa
City. We need an energy efficient building with alternative energy such as solar and /or
geothermal. It would be great to form a stronger link to local food growers, such as providing a
year -round farmer's market location. Iowa City is lagging behind other communities in supporting
local foods, gardening, ecological landscapes and sustainability. This project could help to create
new opportunities for these important and emerging priorities.
Thank you for the opportunity to give my ideas on this project.
Mary Crooks
l(
Marian Karr
From: Jason Paulios <jason pau I ios@g mail. com>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 10:00 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College - Gilbert Proposals
I have looked through the proposals and feel that the best way forward is to use the New Pioneer Coop as the anchor.
Although The Chauncey project looks interesting, I think the community will be better served by a larger downtown
grocery with a proven history. I support Film Scene but feel they will be able to work equally well in another location
downtown. The Chauncey Gardens project is beautiful but ultimately, I feel, too large of a project for the downtown. I
also have reservations about the amount of glass as well as the height, the impact of these types of structures on
migrating birds has been well documented : http: / /www.abcbirds. ore / newsandreports /BirdFriendlyBuildingDesien.pdf
I feel the best choice is the 4 zero 4 proposal. They use the Coop as the anchor and incorporate many interesting
renewable energy and sustainability ideas, it also looks unique and would stand as something different from the Moen
tower designs downtown. I also appreciate that they will allow the Bike Library to be a part of the plan. The apartments
are affordable as well, hopefully there is a plan involved that wouldn't turn this into a tower of Ulowa students.
Jason Paulios
Iowa City, IA
I' L
Marian Karr
From: Protheroe, Jerry G <jerry- protheroe @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 10:11 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Chauncey Gardens LLC Proposal
I'm writing with my enthusiastic support of the Chauncey Gardens LLC proposal.
The reasons to embrace this proposal are simple and fundamental to what has made Iowa City an Oasis in the Midwest.
First and foremost, when you read about and listen to the proposed Chauncey Gardens LLC proposal, it's abundantly
clear that the developers are intimate with Iowa City and understand what makes this community such a special place to
live and visit. References to New Pioneer Coop, Riverside Theater, The Pedestrian Mall, functional green spaces, a focus
on bicycle friendly environments - all these things combine to weave an important message of community — organic,
diverse and vibrant.
Now, add to this solid base concepts like a roof top terrace, the Farmers Market, Urban Gardens, a priority to use all
feasible energy saving concepts; geo- thermal, solar, building controls (something I know a little about as a data center
manager) and you have a real winner. Plus, I have to ask you, how many of the other proposals cared enough to design
the residential tower so it is stepped back specifically to allow daylight into the Park? A small thing, but at the same
time not.
In closing, I urge you to favorably consider this local teams' clear and thoughtful vision to create an oasis that the entire
community —the Iowa City Community — can work, live and play in. And what a better team than people — successful,
caring, and visionary local Iowa City residents that understand what a special place we live, work and play in.
Jerry Protheroe
Data Center Manager
The University of Iowa
Mobile: (319) 400 -6977
Office: (319) 384 -2153
I�
Marian Karr
From: Kathy Campbell <kathycampbell @ccaschools.org>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 8:22 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: Chauncey Gardens
I'd like to take this opportunity to say I've looked at the proposals for the "Private Development of College
Street/Gilbert Street Northeast Corner Site" and feel that the proposal from Neumann Monson Architects is the
best. Chauncey Gardens was the most attractive overall proposal and I hope you will support it.
2
Marian Karr
From: Sara Riggs <mamasarika @gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 8:55 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: corner of College and Gilbert
As a longtime resident of Iowa City (since 1990) and a New Pioneer Co -op member, I cannot think of a more
perfect match for the proposal in this location. Every part of me says that the first floor of whatever structure is
placed on this site should include the Co -op! The current Iowa City location has served its purpose, but every
time the creek waters rise, we have to worry about flooding. The current building has also seen better days and
since the membership and board agree on proceeding with a new location and building, I can only hope that the
city agrees and grants our wish.
Thank you,
Sara Riggs
629 Diana Ct.
Iowa City, IA 52240
P
Marian Karr
From: Deanne Mirr <dmirr @me.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 9:32 AM
To: CGProject
Subject: my thoughts
Hi,l like the ideas of a movie theater and bowling alley in addition to a grocery or the Coop. The movie theater with
maybe a couple of screens and the bowling alley will bring families to the downtown area and provide no alcohol venues
for students.
The questions I have are about height and apartments /condos. How do you make the housing work force? Is it legal to
discriminate against students? And as many of them have jobs how does that work? Can the prices of the housing
component be in a affordable range? Not just $500,000 to a million dollar penthouse variety. How many units does
downtown need? Realistically how many people want to live downtown that aren't students? Haven't the condos in
Hotel Vetro and on 5th in Coralville remained empty?
Thanks for providing this opportunity to comment Deanne Mirr
3411 Ireland Drive
IC
354 -5678
Marian Karr
From: Cecile Kuenzli <cecile.kuenzli @g mail. com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 12:31 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College /Gilbert St. proposals
Dear Mr. Yapp,
In real estate the old axiom is that location is everything.
Well, among the five proposals for the College /Gilbert St. location, the ONLY proposal that takes into account its location
and surroundings is the proposal from the Ryan Group. It is the only one that realizes that what will be built there should
make the TRANSITION from downtown high rises to the historic residential area lying east of the site and for that reason
alone, it should be adopted.
The huge structures proposed by the other developers seem to reflect more the egos of their developers than the reality
of the IC environment. We need development that reflects the human scale and mass and proportions, not some gigantic
megaliths in and around which no one feels comfortable.
One of the most beautiful cities in the world, Paris, realized that when its inner core was threatened with high rise
construction decades ago. Their civic authorities had the wisdom and courage to limit high rises to the outside edges of
the city rather than destroy the human proportions of the inner city where structures are rarely higher than four to six
stories high.
Tim Dwight's LEED project is a modest six stories high, but it is just plain ugly to look at.
If you don't take into account the adjacent nineteenth century residential College Green area you will be dooming its
attractiveness and residential appeal for the future.
Sincerely,
Cecile Kuenzli
705 S. Summit St.
Iowa City, Iowa.
1
/E
Marian Karr
From: Matthew J. Hayek <mhayek @hhbmlaw.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 12:53 PM
To: Marian Karr
Subject: FW: Response to Jim Throgmorton
From: Carol deProsse [mailto:lonetreefoxC@mac.com]
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2012 3:30 PM
To: Michelle Payne; Terry Dickens; Matt Hayek; Susan Mims; Rick Dobyns
Subject: Response to Jim Throgmorton
Below is my response to Jim, who was kind enough to e-mail me regarding my blog, which I also sent to the
five of you (Connie apparently has no city e-mail address):
Hi Jim,
First, you state, I seriously doubt, however, that Marc Moen or any of the other four developers would agree to
proceed without some kind of public support. Which creates a bit of dilemma for us. If you start from a weak
position (seriously doubting rather than having concrete evidence) then you have capitulated any developer of
any project in the downtown TIF district. Your task as a councilor is to get the get the best deal for the
taxpayers of Iowa City and other entities impacted by TIF. You don't get the best deal by making the
assumption that no development will occur without the inclusion of TIF.
My point in the blog is not to be taken lightly. If Moen were required to lower the height of his project it would
cost considerable less to build. I know that the cost per floor of the upper four floors can't be directly equated
with the cost of the two floors with the bowling alleys or those that would comprise the hotel, but it would lop a
considerable chunk off the total cost of the project. If Moen states that the project is completely funded and the
development is requesting $16.5 million in TIF, taking four floors off could drop the amount of the needed TIF
or even eliminate it entirely if the TIF was thought of as being necessary to build 20 stories instead of 16 stories.
All of this discussion would be more meaningful if we had a per square foot cost for the project, not just a
projected total cost.
I fail to see the reason of stating a TIF amount that would be acceptable if TIFs for this type of development are
not satisfactory to a large segment of the citizenry. I assume the council could continue to go around and around
on this with the "antis" submitting petitions calling for a vote on the issuance of bonds and the council doing an
end run by using revenue bonds. We both know doing an end run is not in the best interest of taxpayers for
more than one reason and in any event can only be done to a limited extent.
My frustration is how the city seems to always be in the weaker position and I don't know whether it's the
council that put itself there, the planning department, the city manager, or all three. But it's not palatable, to say
the least, to feel that the council is negotiating from a position of weakness.
I refer you to an article on the front page of The New York Times yesterday (Sunday, December 3), which is
an in depth story of the financial problems that cities have gotten into by erroneously (or maybe not
erroneously) believing that they had to do whatever the developers wanted to get them to build. The piece of
property in question here (GIlbert/College) is without a doubt one of the most potentially lucrative spots
remaining in the "old" downtown; I suggest the council take more seriously what they might be able to milk
from those that will profit privately from its development.
Thank you.
Carol
0
Marian Karr
From: mschut @aol.com
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 2:44 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College - Gilbert
Hello and thank you for the opportunity to comment. I am in strong support of a LEED building, at
least 8 stories and New Pi inclusion.
Martha Schut Iowa City
Sent from my U.S. Cellular® Android - powered device
B
Marian Karr
From: m feagler <mfeag ler@g mail. com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 2:53 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Chauncey Gardens
To Iowa City City Council Members,
I would like to express my support for Chauncey Gardens. What I like most about this
project is the number of community spaces located throughout the building. Also, this
project will incorporate alternative heating and cooling sources and locate green spaces in
various parts of the building. the building will be good for student housing, but also for
residents of other age groups who want to live closer to town. Please give Chauncey
Gardens your careful consideration.
Michael Feagler
(c0
Marian Karr
From: Patti Zwick <pzquiltz @gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 3:16 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: College and Gilbert street project
I feel that the 5 story building is best suited to the neighborhood.
Marian Karr
From: Amy Boelk <abtck5 @gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 3:34 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: Gilbert/College St Proposals
Dear City Council,
I am writing to provide comment on the five proposals submitted for College /Gilbert Street intersection. I strongly urge the
City Council to consider the message we are sending by the choice that is made and also to support 4Zero4's proposal.
1. Scale - This is not the right place to put the tallest building in Iowa City. Scale is extremely important due to
this area being a transition from downtown business district to residential. From a height standpoint 4 Zero 4's
project is scaled to maintain Iowa City's downtown core and transition to the historic neighborhoods to the east.
2. Sustainability — Sustainability is a must for a project this significant. The City of Iowa City has a tremendous
opportunity here to make a statement about the future of City of Iowa City buildings and how important our impact
is on the environment. Iowa City is a research town and not too long ago an article was written citing University of
Iowa researchers regarding our impacts on the environment and how we need to be more aggressive in our
efforts to preserve our environment. Let's actually back up the people who live and breath our community and are
saying this is a problem! 4zero4 has been a project from the beginning that has sustainability as one of the
defining goals of the project. This is the first project in Iowa City that is providing a Net Zero Living solution in
Iowa City showcasing responsible development from an energy use standpoint. It's time to stop building glass
boxes that are sucking up energy and contributing to the depletion of our fossil fuels.
3. 4Zero4's incorporation of New Pioneer Co -op has been carefully thought out, even down to how and where
the trucks will access a loading dock. 4Zero4's design activates both College Street and Chauncey Swan Park
while also preserving the park.
4. 4Zero4's incorporation of Iowa City's Bicycle Library at the Chauncey Swan Park level is an extremely
important aspect to this project. The Iowa City Bicycle Library has become a successful endeavor that leaves
more and more people in Iowa City choosing to travel by bike and reduce their carbon footprint.
5. 1 understand the attractiveness of Mr. Moen's proposal but there is a reason The Englert doesn't show
movies anymore as well as Old Capitol Theatres. There is also a reason Iowa City /Coralville used to have 3
bowling alleys and now only has one. These are just not venues that are going to activate this corner and bring
vitality to this area on a regular everyday. 10am to 10 pm basis. In addition, what is the message we are
sending to developers who are wanting to develop projects in downtown Iowa City if the City Council will only
award and support (TIF) significant projects that are proposed by Mr. Moen?
6. 1 sincerely hope the City Council understands that there are a lot of factors that determine a building size and
the three large scale projects are not financially viable unless they incorporate a tower. It is very unlikely the # of
floors could be reduced and have their financial models still work.
7. 4Zero4 is the only proposal showcasing a balanced response from a community, building scale and
sustainability aspect. Much thought has been given and time invested by 4Zero4 to provide a well thought out
solution that should reflect the future of development in Iowa City.
Sincerely,
Amy S. Boelk
/4
Marian Karr
From:
Matthew J. Hayek <mhayek @hhbmlaw.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, December 04, 2012 3:56 PM
To:
Marian Karr
Subject:
FW: Rumor?
From: Carol deProsse fmailto:lonetreefox(amac.com]
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 3:00 PM
To: fames- throgmorton @iowa- city.org; Michelle Payne; Terry Dickens; Rick Dobyns; Matt Hayek; Susan Mims
Subject: Rumor?
I have heard from a good source that the planning department is going to push for one of the four proposals that
has New Pioneer on the first floor. Could this because one of the NP board members is also employed by the
city in the planning department? In any event, I hope this is not true because I feel strongly that it is now a
decision that should be made between the citizens, the developers and the council ONCE the financial
information is made available to the general public and that the planning department should not be "pushing
anything" as this is partly why people sometimes get so upset with the city.
Without the financial information I fail to see how a final decision could be reached by any of the
aforementioned.
I have also heard that the reason the planning department is pushing this is because they want the site of the old
NP for parking. Parking for city employees is not in and of itself a bad idea (particularly if the city used
permeable pavers, something that should have been in use for years), but I think it would be nice for them to
consider a location directly east of the church where they now provide parking for police, etc. for the Coop.
This would be a perfect location for NP because it's practically out of the flood plain and if the council would be
willing to relax the height restrictions so that the entire block (Washington, Gilbert, Iowa, Van Buren) was a
cohesive unit it would be about perfect and keep a fair number of people happy.
Anyway, it may be just a rumor, but that's what I've been hearing (along with a hundred other things, as well!)
Marian Karr
From: Mark Patton <mark @iowavalleyhabitat.org>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 4:11 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: workforce housing?
Please define the income levels for "workforce housing" for any proposed project going forward so
that the public can be clear who the intended audience is. Will it be to 80% of area median
income? 100% of area median income. And what will the lower end of the spectrum be, 50%
AMI? Thank you in advance.
Mark Patton
Executive Director, Iowa Valley Habitat for Humanity
2401 Scott Blvd., Iowa City, IA 52240
office: (319) 337 -8949 fax: (319) 354 -3527
mark(cMowavalleyhabitat. ors
www.iowavallevhabitat.org
The difference between doing nothing and doing something is everything. Fr. Daniel Berrigan
Marian Karr
From: Melroy, Virginia Anne B <virginia- melroy @uiowa.edu>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 4:17 PM
To: CGPrc ject
Subject: College- Gilbert Proposals
To members of the Iowa City City Council:
As a life -long Iowa City resident, and a long -time member of New Pioneer Coop, I am writing to voice my support for any
of the proposals that include New Pioneer in the plan for development. Iowa City needs New Pioneer and New Pioneer
needs a new space.
Thanks for your consideration.
Virginia Melroy
1512 N. Dubuque Rd.
Marian Karr
From: Meg Tisinger <mltisinger @g mail. com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2012 4:17 PM
To: CGProject
Subject: 4 Zero 4
To whom it concerns,
As a Johnson County resident and long -time community member, I strongly encourage the city to choose the 4
Zero 4 proposal. Maintain the integrity of our small town with a big city feel is so essential. Our community
shouldn't be a place of high- rises, but should continue it's small, but mighty 'shop local' experience. Please
select the 4 Zero 4 project for The Bike Library and New -Pi and continue the community feeling that makes
Iowa City a place people want to stay.
Meg
(Trinity Episcopal Church Response to the five building proposals across the street at the
corner of Gilbert and College, presented by Rev. Benjamin Webb to City Council at its
meeting on December 4, 2012.)
Mayor Hayek, City Council members and fellow citizens, my name is Rev.
Benjamin Webb, and I speak tonight on behalf of Trinity Episcopal Church,
which has been located downtown at College and Gilbert since 1871. (gmnr,
of
We first want to thank the city planning staff for discussing these building
proposals with our church leaders and members on three previous occasions.
Members of our governing board also attended the work session on
November 26. Tonight's response is a summary of our parishioner's / r-f JC
questions and concerns (which we are also submitting as a signed petition) °— t
We thank City Council for hearing us out this evening. A
Common themes have arisen about how these proposals might affect the
needs of church members and other building users and how they do or don't
speak to our values and desires for our downtown neighborhood. Very
briefly, I would like to speak to two needs — parking and light — and two
values — affordable housing and environmental stewardship. As I do so, I
also want to emphasize that Trinity welcomes development downtown that
brings more people into the neighborhood to live and work.
When Trinity was built in 1871 on its current site, automobile parking was
obviously not an issue. Over time, as Trinity parishioners have committed
repeatedly to stay in our downtown location, we have enjoyed access to city
parking facilities. We are grateful for those facilities and understand the
need to share them. That said, we are concerned that parking, especially for
our less mobile parishioners, remain as near to the church as possible. In the
Chauncey Swan parking structure, this means spaces on the College Street
level. As for off - street parking, it may be the case that we need to speak to
city staff about increasing the number of disability parking spaces on
College near the church, at least on Sundays.
In addition to parking, we have a need for light. The church was originally
designed to enhance the presence of natural light as an integral part of
worship. Trinity's sanctuary has stained glass windows on all four sides,
and the morning light in particular is stunning. In 2011, we completed a
gold level LEED - certified, $1.8 million renovation designed to protect the
Z.-,
historical integrity of our worship space. We value having neighbors across
the street and understand that any building there may shade Trinity at times.
Nonetheless, we would appreciate seeing the results of a careful shade study
of all proposed buildings in the mornings Year-round. Such information
might well affect our response to p rticudr proposals. Above all we hope
the city council and staff will seriously consider moving the building site to
the north end of the city's property, where the current park is situated. This
would not only keep Trinity in the light, but assure the new park enjoys good K
sunlight. We know there are floodpTam issues to resolve, u�t eipect they
w6ube manageable through good design.
In addition to Trinity's two needs -- assuring our access to pa rkin and
access to light -- we also have two values by which we measure each of
these proposals. The value most at the core of our mission is affordable
housing. While Trinity has had several opportunities to move to an outlying
area of town, each time we've felt a deep connection to the people
downtown — the poor, the homeless, and the hungry, as well as university
students, staff and faculty, and other workers and residents. Every day,
Trinity people work to make downtown residents' and workers' lives better
— but we cannot house them. That's why we hope your definition of
"workforce housing" will take all of the workforce into consideration,
inclu m
c g our members and those we serve. Although the city's expressed
goals address housing for people of diverse age and incomes, so far we've
only heard passing reference to age diversity, especially as it relates to
limited, fixed incomes. In fact we've heard a definition of workforce
housing that would not insure units are affordable for some of our own
employees and many of our parishioners. As currently planned, we are not
persuaded that these proposals go nearly far enough to address the housing
needs of those with less than median income in the county. We hope the
winning proposal will, with the City's help.
Lastly, as witnessed by our own major investment in LEED - certified
renovation, Trinity is committed to environmental stewardship, which is no
long'e'r-'a luxury but a necessity. We applaud the aspiration of LEED
certification in some of these proposals, but even more we support those
innovations that will greatly decrease fossil fuel energy consumption and
otherwise be sustainable well into the future. We would welcome a
neighbor that took environmental stewardship seriously. We urge city
council to make environmental stewardship a significant part of their
decision - making process by setting a new standard with this building.
In conclusion, we would like to add our whole- hearted admiration of the Co-
op as a neighbor and our attraction to the idea of an independent movie
theatre and bowling alleys downtown. We would especially welcome the
opportunity to continue working with the city and the named developer to
meet our parkin and light needs. And we look forward to final designs that
accommodate environmental sustainability and truly affordable housing as
values a healthy city and just society cannot do without.
Thank you very much. (DISTRIBUTE COPIES OF SUTARY)
• ►
1
�MJMI- I �01 I
br, 0- Lj M N e ,y
%, 0 XAZ�
U
1 ► If
1?A,
f
/ 7
1
�i■r
OaO( 4. W'"'
� �r
l-
I
,r
et-.)
a 09W 4- 0 /l."
p I
i
�JO
�I '
/ . .i
kill
Ire