HomeMy WebLinkAbout2017-05-16 CorrespondenceMay 9, 2017
William Leefers, Chairperson
Johnson County Board of Adjustment
913 S Dubuque Street
Iowa City, IA 52240
Re: Prairie Green School Conditional Use Permit Application
Dear William and Members of the Board:
I+d (I 3)
Pig
��'�
CITY OF IOWA CITY
410 East Washington Street
Iowa City, Iowa 52240-1826
(3 19) 356-5000
(3 19) 356-5009 FAX
www.lcgov.org
The Planning and Zoning Commission has received a request from Prairie Green
School for a conditional use permit to allow the establishment and operation of a
private school at 3520 Osage Street, within Fringe Area C of the Fringe Area
Policy Agreement, but outside of the City's growth boundary. The Johnson
County Ordinance requires that cities be allowed to review Conditional Use
Permits within their extraterritorial jurisdiction. Conditional Use Permits in
Johnson County require a 4/5 majority vote of the Board of Adjustment to approve
if the use is opposed by a vote of the City Council.
At its May 4th meeting, the Iowa City Planning and Zoning Commission
recommended by a unanimous vote that the Iowa City City Council recommend
approval of the conditional use permit.
The City Council concurs with the Planning and Zoning Commission's
recommendation and recommends the conditional use permit request submitted by
Prairie Green School be approved.
Sincerely,
JTEogmorton
Mayor
r
-��. p, CITY OF IOWA CITY r
4d(13)
`� MEMORANDUM
Date: May 4, 2017
To: Planning and Zoning Commission
From: Sarah Walz, Associate Planner
Re: Conditional Use Permit Application Prairie Green School
Prairie Green School has submitted an application to the Johnson County Board of Adjustment
for a Conditional Use Permit to allow the establishment and operation of a private school.
The subject property is located at 3520 Osage Street, within Fringe Area C of the Fringe Area
Policy Agreement, but outside of the City's growth boundary. The Johnson County Ordinance
requires that cities be allowed to review Conditional Use Permits within their extraterritorial
jurisdiction. Conditional Use Permits in Johnson County require a 4/5 majority vote of the Board
of Adjustment to approve if the use is opposed by a vote of the City Council.
The property is currently zoned Agricultural (A) and consists of approximately 17 acres of land.
Adjacent properties to the north, east, and southeast are zoned agricultural. Adjacent properties
to the west and southwest are zoned Residential (R); this includes the Black Hills subdivision,
which consists of 8 residential lots located off G Richard Circle, SW.
The applicant wishes to construct a new building in order to operate a private school for
students age 3-14 years of age. The school, which currently operates in Cosgrove, employs 3
teachers and has 30 students. Hours of operation are weekdays, 9:00 AM to 3:00 PM. The
applicant intends to grow the program to 60 students with 10 full-time teachers. The school
provides its own bus service to transport students to and from the site. The attached material
from the applicant provides more detailed information about the proposal.
As noted above, the proposed site is outside of the Iowa City growth boundary and is therefore
unlikely to have negative impacts on existing or planned development within Iowa City in the
near future. However, the future land use of the area is uncertain and as the city expands into
growth areas it is important to ensure compatible land uses. Schools are allowed within
residential zones in Iowa City and so, over time, if the City were to grow in the area near the
site, the use would be compatible with residential uses.
Staff Recommendation
Given the proposed use is not within the Growth Area and that the school use would not be
incompatible with residential future growth, staff recommends that the City forward a letter to the
Johnson County Board of Adjustment indicating that the City has no objection to the conditional
use permit.
Approved by:
Department of Neighborhood and Development Services
Attachments: 1. Location Map
2. Application Information
condition use permit application submitted by Paula
3oback for the Prarie Green School at 3520 Osage
Street in Johnson County.
4
L
SITE PLAN PR
PRAIRIE GREEN SCHOOL M
GREEN SCHOOL ••a1u - ' ii'y_t`_ _ £ __ ___ _-__ _
OVII. ENGNEERS
j5S :r'___=_' �' wvxcscvFNrze LANOPUNNERS
w LAND SURVEYORS
�_`__ -iw. LWDSC4PEARLfiIiECTS
___ _ g LECAL D[srnIPnaN: EWROINIENTAL SPECUllSTS
' ' 'LOT 2, WILLIAMS SUBOIN9CN TO JOHNSON COUNTY, 1917SDLLeEWST.
x IOWA EXCEPT AUOITOR'S PARCEL 99065: iWlAcln gWA9aw
' � •'�`i�'Y'ii,�/!'%'L.�%'r ,;;;; •,;;, �-�— nnemuul'anh.rcl
LOCATI MAP a
Nr I O S E 5,
D RICHARD CIR 5µ, ri+
-NOTES: -U2 SCHOOL
1•r i'ri". ".'-PARKMG IS BASED ON 1 SPACE FOR EACH
' r vii n�v 17 CLASSROOM SEAM.
-THE PROPOSED WELL 15 A PUBUC WELL
/ •uyev ; PERMI77E0 BY THE NINR.
-A PRIVATE WASTE WATER SYSIFY WLL BE
-STALLED.
-'- PRAIRIE GREEN SCHOOL
Ie CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
BLACK HILLS p =-''" SITE PLAN
SUBDIVISION °�
5 �(.I^COA�-17 ` LEGEND
^ W b. '? , '1 P ➢ � i.`_�'y�ly _='ATE p4 EXISTING TREE
" '---_-_ -PROPOSED EVERCREEII TREE PART OF LOT 2
-PROPOSED wnL WILLIAMS SUBDIVISION
PSS -PROPOSED SEPTIC SY51EM
® vsvomCM.w, l "" UNION TOWNSHIP
JOHNSON COUNTY
IOWA
r_
_ MMS CONSULTANTS, INC.
0
s l/. maEl mvoomL niry se arcmw A STR _W
4/20/2017
a 4,
.AX s� t�tpY
nrmq 1w
GGM x J
WNACRY
10215-001 ,,. 1
Proposed use for Conditional Use Permit
Prairie Green School
Prairie Green School is a unique non-profit that offers the Iowa City area a year-
round holistic schooling option for children ages 3-14 years old. Established in
2011, Prairie Green School currently has 30 students, 3 full-time teachers, and 5
part-time teachers. The school owns two 14 -passenger buses and provides
transportation for a majority of the families. Our hours are typical to that of a school,
Monday through Friday from 9-3, but I have included the 2017-2018 school
calendar with our application to highlight how our calendar differs from ICCSD.
We hope to eventually grow to 50-60 students with 10 full-time employees. We
propose a building that is 65'X95'. There will be 5 parking spaces including one
accessible space and 8 future parking spaces to be added as the need arises. A
private waste water system will be constructed northeasterly of the proposed
building. A public well will be installed to IDNR standards. At this point no signage is
proposed. Should the school desire signage the sign will be attached to the south
end of the building.
Prairie Green's mission is to educate and graduate happy, independent, creative
individuals who work well with others. Almost every situation can be turned into a
learning opportunity if the students are observing things around them. Students see
it as exploring "cool' things but they are also forming a love of learning. Prairie
Green is able to take advantage of these teachable moments due to our 1:8 teacher
to student ratio. These opportunities arise organically in our multi-age setting.
Prairie Green has created a multi-age environment to reflect the natural groupings
found in our neighborhoods, communities, and in the world. Integrating children of
all ages provides opportunities to exchange ideas, model behaviors, practice
responsibility and nurture, and develop leadership and social skills in a
differentiated learning environment.
Our students' passions drive our curricular focus with our state -certified teachers
planning units of study around students' personal interests and readiness. Students
are encouraged to create, ask questions, voice interest, and solve problems. As a
result, each student's educational experience is individualized, relevant and
interesting, while preparing that student for success within traditional education.
We also have a strong focus on music, which includes playing the ukulele, song
writing, recording original songs, and performing for the Iowa City community.
Prairie Green emphasizes the importance of caring for our environment.
Sustainability, concern for the environment, and natural ecology play a significant
role within the PGS curriculum. We accomplish this by incorporating plenty of time
outside each day, composting our lunch scraps, growing a school garden, cooking
together, and through Forest Fridays. On Fridays, PGS spends the entire day outside,
learning from our environment. We fill our day with a focus on the lessons available
in the natural world in a designed curriculum, unstructured play, and the abundance
of teachable moments that arise outdoors.
My vision for the 16 -acre property is to create an indoor and outdoor campus that
provides incredible learning opportunities. The 6,175 square foot schoolhouse will
include 4 classrooms with an indoor garden atrium, commercial kitchen, common
space for eating or gathering, and an office and reception area. We will offer two
early childhood classrooms, an early elementary classroom, and an upper
elementary classroom. We hope to expand to eventually include a middle school
program. The building will be served by a circle drive for drop-off and a 5 -space
parking lot for teacher and visitor parking. However, most of our students will
continue to be transported to school by bus from the Iowa City area. In the back of
the building overlooking the rolling hills, we will have a combined
soccer/football/baseball field, a playground and our outdoor learning campus.
The outdoor campus will feature vegetable garden beds, fruit trees, chickens, and
goats. Our dream is to hire a resident PGS farmer/cook who will grow organic,
wholesome food that will be used in a hot lunch program for the school. The garden
will be used as an amazing learning opportunity for students who will work hard to
help maintain, grow and harvest the food. We'd also like our farmer to help us care
for chickens and goats on our outdoor campus. These animals will also provide
educational opportunities pertaining to the life cycle, sustainability, and care. The
outdoor campus on our property will be supported by a pole barn for storage and
perhaps an apartment for the resident farmer/cook.
The use of this site for the Prairie Green School is ideal because it is close enough to
Iowa City to be convenient for our students and their families. At the same time,
however, the unique nature of the PGS makes it more appropriate in an agricultural
setting than in a highly developed, densely populated residential setting. The site is
large enough to accommodate the proposed use but not so large that the proposed
use would impose a significant burden on existing roads and other infrastructure.
The site is adjacent to other properties whose use will be compatible with that of
PGS. For these reasons, we respectfully request the issuance of a Conditional Use
Permit.
'I I i IS'• � I I
rn ' ' 1
n I j f
V, � ��.�II • I 1
��..✓....,-......J� 11 x I I, it- —� _ � ❑
L F
b\
1 1 H
�1 1
I j
� z
I
wr I
a , I
1 ,
))) l.. L I \ _� 1
r
��-- i
� �
Planning and Zoning Commission
May 4, 2017 — Formal Meeting
Page 3 of 5
Miklo noted this property is located within the two-mile Fringe Area of Iowa City, but is well
outside of the growth area and is not likely to be annexed into the city. The agreement with the
County is the City is required to review and approve subdivisions within the two-mile Fringe
Area. The subdivision is creating one buildable lot off from a larger parcel of property.
Subdivisions outside of the growth area are required to adhere to the City Rural Design
Standards contained in the Fringe Area Agreement. These standards generally conform to the
County zoning and subdivision standards rather than typical City requirements for infrastructure
and lot design.
Staff recommends that SUB17-00004, an application for a preliminary and final plat of Little Ash
Subdivision, a 1 -lot, 21.48 -acre residential subdivision located on the east side of Maier Avenue
be approved.
Freerks opened the public discussion.
Seeing no one Freerks closed the public discussion.
Parsons moved to approve SUB17-00004, an application for a preliminary and final plat of
Little Ash Subdivision, a 1 -lot, 21.48 -acre residential subdivision located on the east side
of Maier Avenue.
Theobald seconded the motion.
A vote was taken and the motion passed 7-0.
CONDITIONAL USE ITEM CU17-00001:
Discussion of an application submitted by Paula Boback to Johnson County for a conditional
use permit to allow for a private school on property located at 3520 Osage Street. This property
is located southwest of Iowa City in Fringe Area C of the Fringe Area Policy Agreement.
Miklo noted this is the neighboring property from the one just discussed and again is well
outside the City's growth area, although in the Fringe Area. The County's Zoning Ordinance
allows schools in residential areas by a Conditional Use Permit. The County ordinance also
requires that the City review the Conditional Use Permit within the Fringe Area. Miklo reiterated
that this is not an area that is likely to be annexed into the city. He added if this area were
annexed, the City also allows schools in residential neighborhoods by a special exception
(similar to the County's Conditional Use process).
Given the proposed use is not within the Growth Area and that the school use would not be
incompatible with residential future growth, staff recommends that the City forward a letter to the
Johnson County Board of Adjustment indicating that the City has no objection to the conditional
use permit.
Freerks opened the public hearing.
Seeing no one Freerks closed public hearing.
Signs moved that the City forward a letter to the Johnson County Board of Adjustment
indicating that the City has no objection to the conditional use permit.
Planning and Zoning Commission
May 4, 2017 — Formal Meeting
Page 4 of 5
Parsons seconded the motion.
Signs noted in an effort to be transparent that the applicant's spouse is his personal doctor.
Martin disclosed she one went camping with the applicants.
Dyer noted it is a wonderful school proposal.
A vote was taken and the motion carried 7-0.
CONSIDERATION OF MEETING MINUTES: APRIL 20, 2017
Hensch moved to approve the meeting minutes of April 20, 2017.
Theobald seconded the motion.
A vote was taken and the motion passed 7-0.
PLANNING AND ZONING INFORMATION:
Miklo stated that the City is continuing to work with the consulting firm that is looking at the
possibility of Form -Based Codes for the Northside and South Districts. The firm will be back in
town next week and there will be a continuation of the workshops. On Wednesday the
workshop will discuss the Northside and that will be at Horace Mann School 6:00 pm to 8:00
pm. Then on Thursday (again from 6:00 pm to 8:00 pm) at Alexander Elementary School to
discuss the South District. Miklo asked that if the Commissioners plan to attend to let him know.
Signs noted he will be attending the South District discussion on Thursday. Freerks will be at
the Northside workshop.
ADJOURNMENT:
Hensch moved to adjourn.
Parsons seconded.
A vote was taken and motion carried 7-0.
Julie
From:
Simon Andrew
Sent:
Monday, May 01, 2017 1:47 PM
To:
shmurl7@icstudents.org'
Cc:
Council
Subject:
RE: School Spanish Project
Hi Luci,
Thank you for your email. I would be happy to put you in touch with organizations and resources that could be helpful for your
project. My contact information is below — please give me a call at your convenience.
The City of Iowa City's policies and programs are inclusive of all residents and visitors, regardless of immigration status. Though
it may not fall within your topic of study, I would be happy to discuss access to City services as well.
Thank you again for your email. Have a good afternoon.
Sincerely,
Simon Andrew
Assistant to the City Manager
City of Iowa City
410 East Washington St.
Iowa City, Iowa 52240
(319)356-5010
s i mo n -a nd re w Ca)Iowa-c ity. o rQ
From: shmurl7@icstudents.org [mailto:shmurl7@icstudents.org]
Sent: Monday, May 01, 2017 12:06 PM
To: Council
Subject: School Spanish Project
Hello, I am Luci Murphy from City High and I was wondering of you know where I could find information for my Spanish
Documentary Project. I am suppose to report about Illegal Immigration's connection to Business in Iowa City, Iowa. Thank you
for your help.
City High Student,
Luci Murphy
This is a student email account managed by the Iowa City Community School District.
Julie
From:
Tim Weitzel <tweitzel.email@gmail.com>
Sent:
Thursday, May 04, 2017 9:14 AM
To:
Council
Subject:
Urban Growth and building heights.
With regard to recently approved projects as well as the building in the North Market area under review, I provide the
following comments.
We need to face the reality that Johnson County is growing and will continue to grow. Iowa City needs to participate
in this for the health and welfare of the community and as the primary city affiliated with the University of Iowa.
To continue to grow as we did in the 20th Century and first decade of the 21 st century, which was a model of urban
sprawl will leave us with hundreds of miles of utilities and streets to maintain. Traffic will continue to become worse
and our 5 to 7 story buildings are going to be all parking ramps to accommodate the people driving from the outer
boundaries of Iowa City and other communities to work, shop, and play in Iowa City.
Iowa City will grow. We need to be aware it will happen and it can take the form of one story buildings filling our
entire growth area leaving Iowa City as one giant suburb, or we can allow taller buildings, increase vibrancy and
resilience, and make our growth more sustainable.
We need to continue to protect historic buildings, but be cognizant that urban areas will not preserve all short
buildings. We need to pick which ones to save and we should have a strong rational for how to preserve buildings.
Growth in the urban core is a good thing. We need to embrace it. A 5-7 story building should not even be raising
eyebrows. We will need some additional tall buildings as well to accommodate some buildings being short, and to
provide diversity of building types. To force everything to be 5-7 stories tall will provide a monolithic feel to the city
that isn't really desirable. The height of 15 stories or so will not become the norm simply due to market forces.
Julie
From:
Jody Matherly
Sent:
Sunday, May 07, 2017 3:34 PM
To:
Geoff Fruin
Cc:
`City Council
Subject:
RE: Iowa city police training
Ms. Petersen,
Thank you for contacting us regarding this important issue. After reading your email, I listened to the Shots Fired episode and
agree it was an informative piece. The concerns described and initiatives to address them are being examined by many law
enforcement agencies across the nation. Many of the concepts mentioned by the Daytona Beach police chief are similar to our
approach here in Iowa City. We are taking a variety of steps to reassure our community that the mission of the police
department is to protect all persons rights to be free of crime, secure in their possessions and live in peace. In particular, our
officers have received training in the areas of cultural diversity and implicit bias, crisis intervention training, de-escalation, and
use of force. We continually measure the disproportionality in minority contacts and strongly support a community police
review board to help guide our actions. We have historically implemented strong outreach programs to foster trust between
the community and our officers and are in the process of making the programs more effective. We are taking steps to
continually engage with community members to help define issues and develop answers. We find that Iowa City is filled with
folks who want to be part of the solution, and that excites us. We recognize there is much more work to do and strive every
day to achieve success and mitigate chances of unfortunate events. Thank you again for reaching out and if I can be of further
assistance, please do hesitate to contact me.
Respectfully,
Jody Matherly, Police Chief
Iowa City Police Department
-----Original Message -----
From: Ericka [mailto:ericka.meanor@gmail.com]
Sent: Friday, May 05, 2017 12:40 PM
To: Council
Subject: Iowa city police training
Hello Iowa City Council Members,
My name is Ericka Petersen. I'm an attorney who practices up in Cedar Rapids, but I live here in Iowa city with my husband and
14 month old daughter.
I recently listened to a podcast called Radiolab. (Its great if you've not heard it.) They had a two part episode called Shots Fired
about police killings. They had an interview of a police chief in Dayton, FL (I could be wrong about the city) where police killings
were surprisingly low for its demographics. The police chief was taking small steps including training its officers in real life
scenarios, making its officers really get it and meet people in the community (it's harder to shoot someone you know), and
training them on implicit bias. It was very interesting to listen to and provided a glimmer of hope in an otherwise dire seeming
situation.
I wanted to know what the City was doing to help ensure that our officers don't make a fatal mistake and whether they are
being trained on implicit bias. I also wanted to encourage members to listen to the podcast episode for more information and
something to think about that I think would make our community safer and more inclusive.
Thanks!
Ericka Petersen - 14 Ridgewood Lane - 52245
Sent from my iPhone
Julie
From: Geoff Fruin
Sent: Monday, May 08, 2017 9:01 PM
To: Mary Gravitt; Council
Subject: RE: BUS SHELTERS AND PARK BENCHES
Hello Mary,
Thank you for emailing on the status of bus shelters. The City Council has authorized funding for both new and replacement
shelters. I appreciate your patience as we finalize our plans to purchase and install new shelters.
Here is a quick overview of where we stand today. The approved budget has $250,000 for new and replacement shelters.
While shelters may be spread across many routes, we will be focusing on the Lakeside and Towncrest routes. Replacement
shelters will target those that are currently in poor condition or that are undersized for the number of riders using a particular
location.
Because of the anticipated contract amount, we are getting competitive proposals from various vendors to ensure the best
design and pricing. We hope to have a vendor and pricing nailed down this summer with installations beginning in early to mid
fall.
The actual number of new shelters and replacements will be dependent on the pricing we receive. Please feel free to check in
with me over the summer if you would like an update.
I apologize for our delay and thank you again for your continued patience.
Sincerely,
Geoff Fruin
City Manager
From: Mary Gravitt [mailto:gravittmary@gmail.com]
Sent: Monday, May 8, 2017 1:34 PM
To: Council <Council@iowa-city.org>
Subject: BUS SHELTERS AND PARK BENCHES
May 8, 2017
We Iowa City citizens of Towncrest are still waiting for our promised bus shelters and park
benches (no tin because they are cold in winter and they rust) as we see builder being
promised and collecting millions for private downtown development. The downtown area is
important, but the taxpayers in the communities, who support downtown activates need bus
shelters and benches so that we can give our hard earned dollars to support the City of Iowa
City
The previous administration treated us very badly, and we rebelled. Now the members of
City Council seem to be repeating their bad behavior.
We need, more than want bus shelters on the outbound Towncrest route because of the
many disabled citizens who live in the area. Not only do this but the Hy -Vee and the other
businesses not provide shelter from inclement weather.
Soon the City will fall into deficit and there will be no funds for the promised shelters not only
in Towncrest but on Highway 1 and at Gilbert and Kirkwood Avenues.
Mary Gravitt
2714 Wayne Avenue #6
Iowa City, 52240
319.341.6230
2
Julie
From:
James Weaver <weaver.ja621 @gmail.com>
Sent:
Tuesday, May 09, 2017 8:37 PM
To:
Council
Subject:
ICPL
Attachments:
BoardofTrustees582017.odt
Susan Craig seems to be very unbalanced presently. I am involved in a very serious matter regarding her directions to her staff to lie to
me about an application I submitted. Although the event took place before Thanksgiving she is only now discussing it because I called
her on her lie which I learned of recently.
Since that time she has harassed me in every way I can think of. All she has to do is admit she lied, then we can move to the original
problem. She refuses to do so even though many people at the library are aware of this.
She is using the protection of deflection. Rather than admit her improper behavior, she is attempting to portray me as a vicious, violent
library patron (okay, I killed 5-6 people, but they were bothering me). I query why nothing of this nature matter is so serious today, but
not during the intervening months.
I am a big boy and I can take of myself. I am aggrieved by the way she is treating one of her employees. It is sufficiently cruel that I
will report it to the department of labor. This cruelty stems, again, from the despots unwillingness to admit her improper behavior.
What a leader we have here!
Truth is an absolute defense to an allegation of defamation. She, therefore, cannot take any legal action against that will stand up under
scrutiny. She has her fantasies in her office; but, sunshine (if she has ever been outside) is present outside of the building and that trial
will disclose the type of person she really has become.
I will soon organize a show of homes in Iowa City. The featured homes will be those of Craig; Logsden; Jay Semel; Diane Baker; John
Beasley; Janet Freeman; Adam Ingersoll; Monique Washington; Robin Paetzold; and, Thomas C. Martin. Come see the homes of the
rich and spineless.
Folks, for me it is time to resist bullshit! Hope to see you on the ride
JAMES A. WEAVER
426 Brown Street
Iowa City, IA 52240-5858
weaver.ja621@gmail.com
563.607.1050
5 May 2017
Dear President Semel and Trustees:
I apologize for contacting you again about a matter that your despot has allowed to
grow well beyond a point of being rational. Saturday I was working on a computer on the
second floor for approximately ten (10) minutes when an IC Police Officer served me with
notice of a one (1) year ban.
This notice was handled the way all other matters have been handled --by hiding the
ball. The document indicates the ban is based on "Harassment." There is nothing on the face
of the complaint that provides any specific information about the conduct considered to be
harassment. Frankly, it is hard for me to consider this as more than an inconvenience
inasmuch as the library staff fails to provide specifics.
I will assume for the time being the ban was filed against me because I apologized to
the affected staff person on Friday. Regardless of all the bureaucratic games you are wasting
my time with this was of great import to me.
This was the situation before you reviewed my settlement proposal. Mr. Goers
aggravated this situation by not advising me of the affected library staff person until after your
review. I consider this to be outrageous.
Obviously, the despot is an expert at employing the defense of deflection. Somehow
she has managed to deflect the issues of honesty and leadership to my character and
conduct. These are not dependent issues. Her obvious lack of veracity; her refusal to
approach this in a timely manner; and, her lack of leadership inasmuch as she never spoke to
me but compelled underlings to do the "dirty" work.
I have never been en -lighted by disclosure of the exact nature of the allegations; nor,
have I received any objective evidence to support the conclusion that I engaged in untoward
advances toward a library employee. At best what the despot possesses is this young
woman's subjective interpretation of what she heard. I do not fault this young lady for
misunderstanding my comments, but considering how quickly and thoroughly this could have
been resolved through honesty and competent management it is truly tragic that it has come
to this point.
If you or your despot believes I will bend over and accepts these reckless allegations,
the news is ---it ain't going to happen.
Before you rush to another poorly informed decision, consider these facts:
1. The only contact I have had with the affected staff member is a contact directly related to
her assigned duties, i.e. checking out of materials, or otherwise providing assistance (as she
did Wednesday of the week in which I was banned). Those contacts lasted only the time
needed to complete the assigned task, 3-5 minutes. Upon completion of the official duty, I left
her work area. I did not linger in the area or try to speak with her about matters unrelated to
her library work. I did not meet with her, follow her or, otherwise attempt to contact her in any
way outside of the library. I am sure if she were allowed to speak freely she would confirm
this. It is clear to me, since the 5t' day of May, that the employees are not being allowed to
speak freely.
Sexual harassment is, of course, a very complex matter. Since you have made a decision
regarding this matter without the use of a qualified expert I am left with the impression that
each of you has been trained in noting key components of an act of harassment. Otherwise,
you would be dependent solely on the word of a person you know to be dishonest.
2. This contact occurred 5-6 months ago. I was not told about it; nor, was my behavior limited
or monitored in any manner I am aware of while I spent several hours per day at the library. It
is particularly upsetting to me that Logsden was avoiding a discussion of this subject while
kindly handling my library business. Does no one in an administrative position at ICPL have
managerial courage?
Once I discovered that the despot is a liar, and called her on it, she then escalated this to the
level of an international crisis. Where was she in the intervening time if her concern about her
employees is so great and my conduct so heinous? Did she adequately explain to you why
she acted in this fashion toward her staff? How did she explain her justification for being a liar
to a library patron.
As aside, the only "tirade" I have ever engaged in was upon being told I had been lied to and
an event that took place six months ago. I see now that is being cited as an example of
improper behavior. What did staff expect? If they expected to walk all over me and would
accept this message calmly they were badly mistaken. How would you react? It was not
suggested moving to a more private space before telling about me about the entrenched
dishonesty. That is the fault of Logsden.
3. The woman involved is the same age range as my daughters. If you are the father of a
daughter at this age you understand the inherent repugnance of a relationship with someone
the age of your own child. I have never, and will never, attempted to "date" someone in this
age range. In addition to the age issue, I do not find most people in that age range to be on
the same page I am with respect to my interests.
4. As far as I am aware, no other female staff has complained about my behavior.
5. 1 have been involved with hundreds of cases related to domestic violence and sexual
harassment for three decades. I have a solid background in the field. Late last summer I
consulted with the director of the University's agency for dealing with domestic violence about
the status of his program and the role of the Regents in implementing the obligation to provide
safety for students.
I assume will continue to abnegate the duties assigned to you. § 336.8 enumerates
some of the duties assigned to you.
2. To have charge, and supervision of the public library, its
appurtenances and fixtures, and rooms containing the same, directing
and controlling all the affairs of such library.
3. To employ a librarian, such assistants and employees as may be
necessary for the proper management of said library, and fix their
compensation; but, prior to such employment, the compensation of such
librarian, assistants, and employees shall be fixed for the term of
employment by a majority of the members of said board voting in favor
thereof.
4. To remove such librarian, assistants, or employees by a vote
of two-thirds of such board for misdemeanor, incompetency, or
inattention to the duties of such employment.
I have spent a great deal of time in the library since 2014. 1 have enjoyed my
experience. I have developed friendly acquaintanceships with all of the staff. The petty
manner in which I was escorted from the library Saturday was extremely embarrassing. The
actions of the despot on that day have aggravated this situation to the point of no return.
If you are unwilling, or unable, to reach a fair resolution I will act to protect my rights.
believe a jury trial will provide a community-based response. I am realistically optimistic the
public will consider the position of the despot to be ridiculous.
Sincerely,
James A Weaver
Julie Voparil
From: James Weaver <weaver.ja621@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, May 10, 2017 3:34 PM
To: Council
Subject: Senior Center
I apologize that it seems there must be something wrong with me to attract such attention. I know of nothing. I am
quiet and mind my own business. I never initiated any problems in either community location, except when I am
treated with significant disrespect, or, I am lied to or about.
Obviously Ms. Craig's situation will be determined by the courts. She does not have the background to reach the
conclusions she has reached. A poor management decision on her part was the failure to consult with someone
knowledgeable in the field.
As I indicated in the information about the Senior Center, I had reached a very satisfactory agreement the designated
director. She was polite and helpful. When I learned she had not spoken with the person acting in her stead, I
realized this was a one-way, uninformed decision that would not change through the injection of reason.
Of course, Susan Craig has not shown sufficient intelligence to be the first despot in a public position.
I joined the Senior Center in 2014. My membership ran for about two years. I never had one problem that I can think of, other than I
ate a bagel 2x in the computer room. Frankly, I have never been to a public facility where the presence of food in the computer room,
stored or not, is the number one rule upon which the existence of the program exists.
This has been posted on FB.
When I look at the book of activities at the Center I assume the director would be quite busy implementing those activities.
Apparently, it is quite the opposite. She appears to have nothing to do.
She became fixated on the two occasions when I ate bagels in the computer room She pointed out that the building would
collapse if a piece of bagel touched the computer. Of course, she had no objective that this had ever been a problem with
this but her psychic abilities told her it would happen. My bagels did not jump up and attack a computer. Itjust moped around
while being consumed.
The director was away from the facility for a week in mid -2015. There was a designated director, I assume she was selected by the
director, to serve in place of the director.
The acting director and I had pleasant conversations, and reached a good resolution for both of us.
When the director returned, I was summoned to her office. She proceeded to treat me like a pre-school student as she put in conditions
for me to use the accessible computers. Needless to say these restrictions were not reality based.
Early on I asked if she had communicated with appointed acting director. She indicated she had not. Rather, she declared my
agreement with the acting director to be void.
While she was saying this, I pondered ---how big is your anal cavity that your whole head fits in there?
After this discussion she resumed her tirade against me. I patiently listened; kissed her feet; and, humbly went to the computer room.
The foregoing, is of course, bullshit. When she opened her mouth, I walked out. I recognized, as I have been taught by my mentor,
Ron White, I can't fix stupid.
3 Julie Voparil 4f(6)
From:
Note58us <note58us@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Thursday, May 11, 2017 10:10 AM
To:
Council
Subject:
LOCAL FIREWORKS USE
Dear Iowa City City Council Members:
I am writing in response to the recent signing of a bill that legalizes fireworks within the state of Iowa. I can only imagine
the number of letters, emails, and phone calls that are received by your members regarding local issues and complaints.
However, it is my hope that this letter will be read from beginning to end and that the opinions and facts stated may be
enough to spur a serious discussion about Iowa City's local fireworks statutes vs. those recently approved for the entire
state.
If there is a way to exercise any local control regarding this new law, I implore you to do it. Fireworks disrupt sleep,
traumatize people and animals, cause an untold amount of personal and property damage, and maim, injure, or kill on a
daily basis during peak seasons of use within the United States and beyond. To knowingly allow this activity within the
Iowa City limits, regardless of the recent legislation for the state of Iowa, would be dangerous, upsetting, and for some,
life -changing to say the very least.
Please consider frank, honest, and open discussions about this newly -enacted legislation and how it truly affects all people
within the Iowa City area. If there is a way to adapt a local ordinance that continues the previous ban on individual
consumer use of fireworks, please take the necessary steps to make it happen, regardless of the ability to sell fireworks
within the Iowa City area.
Many people have already been quoted as saying it seems impossible to enforce a local ordinance that bans the use of
consumer fireworks when it is now legal to sell fireworks. I would agree that the potential challenges would certainly be
numerous. If there truly is no way to propose and enact a continued ban on fireworks use within the Iowa City area,
please strongly consider a local ordinance that shortens the time span for acceptable use of fireworks.
The newly -enacted legislation states that fireworks may be purchased and ignited during the hours of 9 a.m. and 10 p.m.
from June V through July 8`h, and again for the same amount of time in the month of December. Extended hours for
use of fireworks are also listed for a few of the days that fall within the larger time frame.
To put it into perspective, for approximately 38-40 days in a row in June and into July, and again in December into
January (76-80 days or nearly 3 months total each year), Iowans are now expected to embrace and celebrate the potential
for the continuous noise and disruption of fireworks and all else that this may bring.
Perhaps a smaller window of opportunity might make fireworks and the short-term tolerance of the noise more palatable,
knowing it wouldn't be happening for nearly 40 days straight (as per the newly -enacted legislation) two separate times each
year.
A suggested local compromise to the state -mandated hours of acceptable fireworks use may be as follows:
June 30`h through July 3`d from 5 p.m. to 10 p.m.
July 4'h from 5 p.m. to 11 p.m.
December 30`h through January V from 5 p.m. to 10 p.m.
Providing a city-wide or locally -sponsored fireworks show is not out of the question at all, and is something that people of
allages may enjoy together within a small window of time on a specific day or evening. The dream situation regarding
these special events is that they are managed, operated, and supervised by adult professionals who may have a greater
knowledge of pyrotechnics and due safety.
The sad reality is that individual consumers who choose to handle fireworks are more often minors or adults who are
well-meaning, but ill-equipped to handle even the smallest of explosives. I have seen the life -changing effects of
mismanaged fireworks, and sadly have also witnessed the fatalities and accidental grass and structure foes that were
directly caused by fireworks (in public and private displays).
It has also been my experience that those whose sleep is disrupted, interrupted, or completely discontinued due to
fireworks noise and trauma are still expected to arrive at their places of employment, clear-headed and able to perform
their duties, ranging from bus drivers, pilots, restaurant workers, teachers, doctors, surgeons, dentists, Emergency Medical
Technicians, and over -the -road truck drivers.
If I were seeking medical treatment or needed the help of emergency personnel, I would hope that each individual would
be well -rested, coherent, and ready to make life -altering decisions without suffering from the effects of the previous day or
evening's fireworks -related anxiety that was beyond their own personal control.
Imagine unwittingly boarding an airplane, bus, cruise ship, helicopter, or any form of public transportation (Uber, taxi,
subway, etc) expecting a safe arrival at your destination. Sadly, it is discovered after a fatal or life -changing accident that
the driver(s), pilots, and/or engineer(s) were operating on very little sleep due to neighborhood or corporately -sponsored
fireworks beyond their personal control.
It is true that people continued to disobey the previous law in Iowa where fireworks are concerned. I can attest to that fact
in my own neighborhood, and I am usually the one who is wondering where all of the law enforcement officials are when
enormous explosives are going off from the last week of June through the fust full week of July. This, sadly, is apparently
just a fact of life, even in a state that currently has working and existing legislating limiting the use of fireworks. However,
the number of incidents under the previous law were miniscule in comparison to incidents in states where consumer
fireworks are legalized.
By legalizing fireworks in the state of Iowa, legislators chose to knowingly jeopardize the welfare and safety of others,
encroach upon the freedoms of those opposed to the proposed legislation for a variety of reasons, and have sent a strong
message to those with medical conditions that are exacerbated by loud noises and flashes of light that their well-being isn't
important.
It is obvious that we were unable to effectively enforce the previous fireworks restrictions, and it seems unlikely that local
and state law enforcement agencies have suddenly had enough time, personnel, and funding to effectively manage the now
potential onslaught of firework -related crimes, injuries, emergencies, fires, and property damage.
Additionally, the thought of legalizing fireworks and/or the sale of fireworks with the proposed date and time restrictions
of the newly -adopted legislation, seems ill-advised.. For those who are employed, there are many various hours, shifts,
and times of duty for every profession. Even if individuals were restricted to a specific window of time each day for the
use of fireworks, by reversing the current fireworks laws legislators have again sent a strong message that can be
interpreted as a complete disregard for those that sleep during the day vs. those that have a more conventional job during
daylight hours.
It was proposed that the legalization of fireworks in the state of Iowa would include a mandate that fireworks may only be
sold to people aged 18 and above. Unfortunately, it is obvious that fireworks will most certainly fall into the hands of
individuals under the age of 18, many of whom may be unsupervised during daylight hours during the summer or during a
holiday break in December if one or both parents are employed outside the home. Even those considered adults by their
chronological age make poor choices regarding the use of fireworks. For some, using alcohol or drugs while igniting
fireworks is commonplace, and further impairs judgement, reasoning, and decision-making skills.
In the summer of 2016, illegal fireworks were used in Keota, Iowa that resulted in a major structural fire in a public
school. See below for the article:
KEOTA — Fire officials say a smoldering firework shot off over the Fourth of July weekend has left Keota
Elementary School with a 15 -by -20 -foot hole in its gymnasium roof and smoke damage throughout the
building.
Sigourney Fire Chief Bill Halleran said a Keota resident walking by the school at around 6:30 a.m. Monday
noticed smoke coming from atop the gymnasium.
Firefighters from the Sigourney and Keota departments responded and were able to extinguish the fire
within 10 minutes, Halleran said. No injuries were reported, but the rubber roof melted, creating the hole.
Halleran said there is significant smoke damage throughout the building, water damage to the gymnasium
floor, possible damage to gymnasium light fixtures and extensive roof damage due to the fire burning down
to the metal decking.
Halleran said fire officials found fireworks remnants on the damaged roof and have concluded that to be
the cause of the fire. The chief, who also serves as vice president of the Iowa Firefighters Association, said
this is exactly why he's been fighting to keep consumer fireworks illegal in Iowa.
"This kind of proves our point," Halleran said. "It's going to get worse. These calls are going to go up."
By late Tuesday afternoon, the smell of smoke was still evident inside the gym, which district officials said
is used by both elementary and junior high school students. Dehumidifiers and fans had been set up
around the area, some of the gym floor boards were beginning to warp and pieces of insulation lay
crumbled on top of the roof where two construction workers patched the hole with more insulation a new
layer of black rubber sheeting.
Chris Dietrich from DRC Inc., who was helping to patch the roof, said the firework must have been
exceptionally hot in order to damage the roof.
"I know this rubber can take some heat," he said. "It's probably 140 degrees today."
Dennis Phelps, superintendent of Keota Community Schools, said insurance workers inspected the roof
Tuesday, but he did not yet have a damage estimate.
"It left a pretty good gaping hole," Phelps said of the fire. "Right now, the gym's not used. The problem is
how long this process is going to take? With construction, you just never know.
"It's going to cost a good penny."
Phelps said if the roof needs to be fully replaced, construction may go into the beginning of the school
year.
He said he hopes the person who launched the firework doesn't make the same mistake again.
"Obviously, there's a place for them," Phelps said. "in and around school areas are not one of those. Leave
the shooting fireworks off for the professionals. This is going to be an expensive thing and if someone
hadn't caught it early, we would have had a heck of a problem."
It would be wonderful to say that the incident in Keota was a rate anomaly, but it is not. To begin to include all verified
news accounts of fireworks -related damage, injuries, and destruction in the state of Iowa and beyond would be a
herculean task to say the very least.
It is my hope that the members of the Iowa City City Council will take some valuable time and consider all of the things
that have been mentioned thus far, as well as those below.
Please remember those of us who cringe when we think of the 4th of July because of errant fireworks, explosions, and
traumatized children, adults, senior citizens, and pets due to relentless loud noises that often start early in the day and last
into the wee hours of the morning.
3
Please remember those who have little to no control over their own environment, or the coping or physical skills needed
to adapt, travel, or deaden the errant sounds of explosives and fireworks, such as hospital patients, those with
developmental or brain -injury related disabilities, or those in Assisted Living or constant care facilities.
Please remember those whose lives have been forever changed by burns, hearing and/or eyesight loss, disfigurement, or
death as a result of a mishap with fireworks (big and small).
Please remember those whose lives have been forever changed by a traumatic accident, brain injury, or post-traumatic
stress from battle or military service. It is a well-documented fact that sudden and loud noises (i.e. fireworks and other
explosives) often trigger new episodes of trauma and setback.
Please remember those who suffer from Orteogene it Imperfecta, a disease that affects the bones. People with this diagnosis
may suffer fractures and broken bones that are directly related to loud noises. This disease does not discriminate regarding
age, as individuals young and old are afflicted.
Please listen to and hear what firefighters and other experts in the field of fire safety, fire damage, pyrotechnics, and fire
recovery are repeatedly saying about fireworks, especially those who have recently voiced their concerns.
Please use our valuable resources and the time and talents of those that can make a difference to truly enhance
the long-term lives of the people within the Iowa City area. There are so many who are struggling with
unemployment, sub -standard educational experiences, health-related issues, insurance and tax issues, domestic violence,
crime, mental health issues, social security and pension fraud, and homelessness. The fact that valuable time and
resources were spent on a bill that would legalize the widespread use of fireworks by anyone in the general public not only
seems incredibly shortsighted, but also irresponsible and unwise.
Please place a time limit on acceptable consumer fireworks use. The proposed time frame from early June through
early July, and again from early December through early January is too broad. Perhaps a compromise might have
permitted the sale and use of consumer fireworks from June 30'h through July 5'h, and again from December 30`h through
January 1st. Additionally, if consumer fireworks were permitted only from 5 p.m. to 10 p.m., there may be a glimmer of
hope. Knowing that some people would surely ignore that limit on a regular basis, at least there would be some backing
that might make a difference when concerned citizens discuss the rules with neighborhoods and communities.
Some may ask why I have waited so long to share my questions and concerns about the recent legalization of consumer
fireworks in the state of Iowa. The answer is simple - I haven't waited at all. I have shared my concerns before with local
representatives in my area for three straight years when this issue was brought forth for consideration. When it was
brought forth again this year, I did share my opinions and questions with elected officials that were charged with making
decisions based upon the best interest of all Iowans. It truly wouldn't have occurred to me that bright, articulate,
intelligent, and caring people would actually cast votes in favor of the proposed legislation. And even if the proposed
legislation passed and was presented to the Governor for a final decree, it truly would have never occurred to me that it
would be signed into law in its current form.
I wish that all voices would have been heard, recognized, and addressed (including those that presented themselves in
person at the Statehouse to plead their case for post-traumatic stress, including war and combat veterans). I do realize that
just because I have a specific opinion about and a desire to stop the potential use of fireworks in the Iowa City area that
my voice is unlikely to reverse a decision or significantly influence the outcome. But I also realize that if we don't take a
stand and at least make a concerted and educated effort to reach out, that there is no chance at all.
Best wishes to you as you continue to make difficult and important decisions and strive for what is best for those in Iowa
City, and thank you for taking the time to read my thoughts.
Jon Ranard
Iowa City, IA
Dear Iowa City City Council Members:
I am writing in response to the recent signing of a bill that legalizes fireworks within the'sTaie E£TcSu pk�ted
imagine the number of letters, emails, and phone calls that are received by your members regarding local issues and
complaints. However, it is my hope that this letter will be read from beginning to end and that the opinions and
facts stated may be enough to spur a serious discussion about Iowa City's local fireworks swotes vs here_
approved for the entire state. (Date) 5/15117 .
If there is a way to exercise any local control regarding this new law, I implore you to do it. Fireworks disrupt sleep,
traumatize people and animals, cause an untold amount of personal and property damage, and maim, injure, or kill
on a daily basis during peak seasons of use within the United States and beyond To knowingly allow this activity
within the Iowa City limits, regardless of the recent legislation for the state of Iowa, would be dangerous, upsetting,
and for some, life -changing to say the very least
Please consider frank, honest, and open discussions about this newly -enacted legislation and how it truly affects all
people within the Iowa City area. If there is a way to adapt a local ordinance that continues the previous ban on
individual consumer use of fireworks, please take the necessary steps to make it happen, regardless of the ability to
sell fireworks within the Iowa City area.
Many people have already been quoted as saying it seems impossible to enforce a local ordinance that bans the use
of consumer fireworks when it is legal to sell fireworks. I would agree that the potential challenges would certainly
be numerous. If there truly is no way to propose and enact a continued ban on fireworks use within the Iowa City
area, please strongly consider a local ordinance that shortens the time span for acceptable use of fireworks.
The newly -enacted legislation states that fireworks may be purchased and ignited during the hours of 9 a.m. and 10
p.m. from June V through July 8'", and again for the same amount of time in the month of December. Extended
hours for use of fireworks are also listed for a few of the days that fall within the larger time frame.
To put it into perspective, for approximately 38-40 days in a row in June and into July, and again in December into
January (76-80 days or nearly 3 months total each year), Iowans are now expected to embrace and celebrate the
potential for the continuous noise and disruption of fireworks and all else that this may bring.
Perhaps a smaller window of opportunity might make fireworks and the short-term tolerance of the noise more
palatable, knowing it wouldn't be happening for nearly 40 days straight (as per the newly -enacted legislation) two
separate times each year.
A suggested local compromise to the state -mandated hours of acceptable fireworks use nW be as follows:
u ='
June 30' through July 3' from 5 p.m. to 10 p.m.
July 4' from 5 p.m. to 11 p.m.
December 30`s through January T' from 5 p.m. to 10 p.m. = n cn r
rn s. m
Providing a city-wide or locally -sponsored fireworks show is not out of the question at al issome that
people of all ages may enjoy together within a small window of time on a specific day or nmg4 he dream
situation regarding these special events is that they are managed, operated, and supervised by adultprofessionals
who may have a greater knowledge of pyrotechnics and fire safety.
The sad reality is that individual consumers who choose to handle fireworks are more often minors or adults who
are well-meaning, but ill-equipped to handle even the smallest of explosives. I have seen the life -changing effects of
mismanaged fireworks, and sadly have also witnessed the fatalities and accidental grass and structure fires that were
directly caused by fireworks (m public and private displays).
It has also been my experience that those whose sleep is disrupted, interrupted, or completely discontinued due to
fireworks noise and trauma are still expected to arrive at their places of employment, clear-headed and able to
perform their duties, ranging from bus drivers, pilots, restaurant workers, teachers, doctors, surgeons, dentists,
Emergency Medical Technicians, and over -the -road truck drivers.
If I were seeking medical treatment or needed the help of emergency personnel, I would hope that each individual
would be well -rested, coherent, and ready to make life -altering decisions without suffering from the effects of the
previous day or evenings fireworks -related anxiety that was beyond their own personal control.
Imagine unwittingly boarding an airplane, bus, cruise ship, helicopter, or any form of public transportation (Uber,
taxi, subway, etc) expecting a safe arrival at your destination. Sadly, it is discovered after a fatal or life -changing
accident that the driver(s), pilots, and/or engineer(s) were operating on very little sleep due to neighborhood or
corporately -sponsored fireworks beyond their personal control.
It is true that people continued to disobey the previous law in Iowa where fireworks are concerned. I can attest to
that fact in my own neighborhood, and I am usually the one who is wondering where all of the law enforcement
officials are when enormous explosives are going off from the last week of June through the first full week of
July. This, sadly, is apparently just a fact of life, even in a state that currently has working and existing legislating
limiting the use of fireworks. However, the number of incidents under the previous law were miniscule in
comparison to incidents in states where consumer fireworks are legalized.
By legalizing fireworks in the state of Iowa, legislators chose to knowingly jeopardize the welfare and safety of
others, encroach upon the freedoms of those opposed to the proposed legislation for a variety of reasons, and have
sent a strong message to those with medical conditions that are exacerbated by loud noises and flashes of light that
their well-being isn't important.
In recent weeks, publications have featured different quotes from those in the Iowa Senate, one of which touted the
-legalization of fireworks as means to "get our freedom back"(Cedar Rapids Gazette article). The legalization of
P�'°h fireworks to restore freedom misses the whole point of the word. Freedom does not mean giving others license to
sb+ put the lives and well-being of others in jeopardy, not to mention the ability to willingly and knowingly employ
3 explosives (no matter how great or small) which could deprive another person of sleep and produce anxiety.
h
It is obvious that we were unable to effectively enforce the previous fireworks restrictions, and it seems unlikely that
local and state law enforcement agencies have suddenly had enough time, personnel, and funding to effectively
manage the now potential onslaught of firework -related crimes, injuries, emergencies, fires, and property damage.
Additionally, the thought of legalizing fireworks and/or the sale of fireworks with the proposed date and time
restrictions of the newly -adopted legislation, seems ill-advised.. For those who are employed, there are many
various hours, shifts, and times of duty for every profession. Even if individuals were restricted to a specific window
of time each day for the use of fireworks, by reversing the current fireworks laws legislators have again sent a strong
message that can be interpreted as a complete disregard for those that sleep during the day vs. those that have a
more conventional job during daylight hours.
N
O
It was proposed that the legalization of fireworks in the state of Iowa would include a m date the fir Ismay
only be sold to people aged 18 and above. Unfortunately, it is obvious that fireworks will_ifilst
_X Iv into the
hands of individuals under the age of 18, many of whom may be unsupervised during dayl�V hours dut" the
summer or during a holiday break in December if one or both parents are employed outsijg the home. , n those
considered adults by their chronological age make poor choices regarding the use of firev&fi P4 I� some' 8sing
alcohol or drugs while igniting fireworks is commonplace, and further impairs judgement; n1g, andicision-
making skills.
rn
In the summer of 2016, illegal fireworks were used in Keota, Iowa that resulted in a major structural fire in a public
school. See below for the article:
KEOTA — Fire officials say a smoldering firework shot off over the Fourth of July weekend has left
Keota Elementary School with a 15 -by -20 -foot hole in its gymnasium roof and smoke damage
throughout the building.
Sigourney Fire Chief Bill Halleran said a Keota resident walking by the school at around 6:30 a.m.
Monday noticed smoke coming from atop the gymnasium.
Firefighters from the Sigourney and Keota departments responded and were able to extinguish the
fire within 10 minutes, Halleran said. No injuries were reported, but the rubber roof melted, creating
the hole.
Halleran said there is significant smoke damage throughout the building, water damage to the
gymnasium floor, possible damage to gymnasium light fixtures and extensive roof damage due to the
fire burning down to the metal decking.
Halleran said fire officials found fireworks remnants on the damaged roof and have concluded that to
be the cause of the fire. The chief, who also serves as vice president of the Iowa Firefighters
Association, said this is exactly why he's been fighting to keep consumer fireworks illegal in
Iowa.
"This kind of proves our point," Halleran said. "It's going to get worse. These calls are going to go
UP."
By late Tuesday afternoon, the smell of smoke was still evident inside the gym, which district officials
said is used by both elementary and junior high school students. Dehumidifiers and fans had been set
up around the area, some of the gym floor boards were beginning to warp and pieces of insulation lay
crumbled on top of the roof where two construction workers patched the hole with more insulation a
new layer of black rubber sheeting.
Chris Dietrich from DRC Inc., who was helping to patch the roof, said the firework must have been
exceptionally hot in order to damage the roof.
"I know this rubber can take some heat," he said. "It's probably 140 degrees today."
Dennis Phelps, superintendent of Keota Community Schools, said insurance workers inspected the
roof Tuesday, but he did not yet have a damage estimate.
ti
v
"It left a pretty good gaping hole," Phelps said of the fire. "Right now, the gym's'nQt Li The
problem is how long this process is going to take? With construction, you just ne—verf�)ow. Q
"It's going to cost a good penny." cn
Phelps said if the roof needs to be fully replaced, construction may go into the 66gigning tZOhe school
year
He said he hopes the person who launched the firework doesn't make the same mistake again.
"Obviously, there's a place for them," Phelps said. "In and around school areas are not one of those.
Leave the shooting fireworks off for the professionals. This is going to be an expensive thing and if
someone hadn't caught it early, we would have had a heck of a problem."
It would be wonderful to say that the incident in Keota was a rare anomaly, but it is not To begin to include all
verified news accounts of fireworks -related damage, injuries, and destruction in the state of Iowa and beyond would
be a herculean task to say the very least.
It is my hope that the members of the Iowa City City Council will take some valuable time and consider all of the
things that have been mentioned thus far, as well as those below.
Please remember those of us who cringe when we think of the 4th of July because of errant fireworks, explosions,
and traumatized children, adults, senior citizens, and pets due to relentless loud noises that often start early in the
day and last into the wee hours of the morning.
N
Please remember those who have little to no control over their own environment, or the copit!Ror physical skills
needed to adapt, travel, or deaden the errant sounds of explosives and fireworks, such as<*Witxdpatieff%Uose
with developmental or brain -injury related disabilities, or those in Assisted Living or consf kof cax4acili iff.
N
Please remember those whose lives have been forever changed by bums, hearing and/o! Rsightt loss,M
disfigurement, or death as a result of a mishap with fireworks (big and small). ri S
Please remember those whose lives have been forever changed by a traumatic accident, burin injup, or post-
traumatic stress from battle or military service. It is a well-documented fact that sudden and loud noises (i.e.
fireworks and other explosives) often trigger new episodes of trauma and setback.
Please remember those who suffer from Osteogenesis Imperfecta, a disease that affects the bones. People with this
diagnosis may suffer fractures and broken bones that are directly related to loud noises. 'Phis disease does not
discriminate regarding age, as individuals young and old are afflicted.
Please listen to and hear what firefighters and other experts in the field of fire safety, fire damage, pyrotechnics,
and fire recovery are repeatedly saying about fireworks, especially those who have recently voiced their concerns.
Please use our valuable resources and the time and talents of those that can make a difference to truly
enhance the long-term lives of the people within the Iowa City area. There are so many who are struggling
with unemployment, sub -standard educational experiences, health-related issues, insurance and tax issues, domestic
violence, crime, mental health issues, social security and pension fraud, and homelessness. The fact that valuable
time and resources were spent on a bill that would legalize the widespread use of fireworks by anyone in the general
public not only seems incredibly shortsighted, but also irresponsible and unwise.
Please place a time limit on acceptable consumer fireworks use. The proposed time fume from early June
through early July, and again from early December through early January is too broad. Perhaps a compromise
might have permitted the sale and use of consumer fireworks from June 30th through July 5'", and again from
December 30' through January 1 st Additionally, if consumer fireworks were permitted only from 5 p.m. to 10
p.m., there may be a glimmer of hope. Knowing that some people would surely ignore that limit on a regular basis,
at least there would be some backing that might make a difference when concerned citizens discuss the rules with
neighborhoods and communities.
Some may ask why I have waited so long to share my questions and concerns about the recent legalization of
consumer fireworks in the state of Iowa. The answer is simple — I haven't waited at all. I have shared my concerns
before with local representatives in my area for two straight years when this issue was brought forth for
consideration. When it was brought forth again this year, I did share my opinions and questions with elected
officials that were charged with making decisions based upon the best interest of all Iowans. It truly wouldn't have
occurred to me that bright, articulate, intelligent, and caring people would actually cast votes in favor of the
proposed legislation. And even if the proposed legislation passed and was presented to the Governor for a final
decree, it truly would have never occurred to me that it would be signed into law in its current form.
I wish that all voices would have been heard, recognized, and addressed (including those that presented themselves
in person at the Statehouse to plead their case for post-traumatic stress, including war and combat veterans). I do
realize that just because I have a specific opinion about and a desire to stop the potential use of fireworks in the
Iowa City area that my voice is unlikely to reverse a decision or significantly influence the outcome. But I also
realize that if we don't take a stand and at least make a concerted and educated effort to reach out, that there is no
chance at all.
Best wishes to you as you continue to make difficult and important decisions and strive for what is best for those in
Iowa City, and thank you for taking the time to read my thoughts.
on }Zanud
Iowa City, IA
L/l a-
ti
0
o
.may
--C
r--
m
r m7rm- ro
CITY OF IOWA CITY 4f(7)
MEMORANDUM
Date: May 1, 2017
To: Geoff Fruin, City Manager
From: Jason Havel, City Engineer J'N
Re: Competitive Quotation Results
HMA Crack Sealing Project 2017
Competitive quotations for the HMA Crack Sealing Project 2017 were opened on April
19, 2017 and the following quotes were received:
Illowa Investment Blue Grass, IA $ 82,241.37
Fahrner Asphalt Sealer Dubuque, IA $ 83,085.01
Engineer's Estimate $ 90,000.00
Public Works and Engineering recommended and the City Manager awarded the
contract to Illowa Investment of Blue Grass, Iowa. The project will be funded through
Account #S3824 Pavement Rehabilitation.
Scott Park Gabion Repair Project
Competitive quotations for the Scott Park Gabion Repair Project were opened on April
20, 2017 and the following quotes were received:
Chris Jones Trucking West Branch, IA
$ 20,404.50
Yordi Excavating Cedar Rapids, IA
$ 21,250.00
G & R Miller Construction Washington, IA
$ 23,950.00
Engineer's Estimate
$ 18,550.00
Public Works and Engineering recommended and the City Manager awarded the
contract to Chris Jones Trucking of West Branch, Iowa. The project will be funded
through Account #M3628 Gabion Baskets Scott Park.
2017 Dover Street Drainage Channel Restoration Project
Competitive quotations for the 2017 Dover Street Drainage Channel Restoration Project
were opened on April 25, 2017 and the following quote was received:
All American Concrete West Liberty, IA $ 59,383.60
Engineer's Estimate $ 62,500.00
Public Works and Engineering recommended and the City Manager awarded the
contract to All American Concrete of West Liberty, Iowa. The project will be funded
through Account #M3631 Annual Stormwater Improvements.
Johnson
County
May 11, 2017
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
Janelle Rettig, Chairperson Lisa Green -Douglass
Mike Carberry Rod Sullivan
Kurt M. Friese
Mayor Jim Throgmorton
Iowa City City Council Members
City of Iowa City
410 East Washington Street
Iowa City, Iowa 52240
Dear Mayor Throgmorton and members of the Iowa City City Council,
We Handouts Distributed
sllid 't�
(Date)
The Johnson County Board of Supervisors is requesting that the City of Iowa City amend code section 16-
3C-10: Private Wells Restricted, to exclude water wel Is that are located on property owned by a government
entity, provided that such wells are used primarily for agriculture purposes and do not compromise the
health and safety of the City's system.
The County desires to drill a well at the Poor Farm, located at 4811 Melrose Avenue for the primary purpose
of providing water for agriculture uses. The well water will be used for the following purposes:
• Irrigation of food crops
Watering of greenhouses and plant starts
• Washing of vegetables for distribution
• Potentially, for the watering of pastured animals, orchards and perennial plantings
It is our hope that this process will occur soon so that water may be available for part of this growing season.
Please contact me if you have any questions about this request.
Sin(c//..//ee�rJ��J,ely,
Janelle'Rettig, Chairperson
Johnson County Board of Supervisors
N
O
CC: Iowa City City Manager Geoff Fruin
p
—
n
-1
CA
�--
< M
-0
M
1>
rV
•Jq
913 SOUTH DUBUQUE STREET ♦ IOWA CITY, IA 52240 ♦ 319.356.6000 PHONE ♦ 319.356.6036 FAX
www.JOHNSON-COUNTY.com ♦ johnsoncountyia.igm2.com