HomeMy WebLinkAbout08-11-2022 Historic Preservation CommissionIowa City Historic preservation Commission
J / L d 'i 1111
Thursday
August 11, 2022
5:30 p.m.
nr„
7 , /
Sally.
Emma Harvat Hall
City Hall
IOWA CITY HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
Thursday, August 11, 2022
City Hall, 410 E. Washington Street
Emma J. Harvat Hall
5:30 p.m.
Agenda
A) Call to Order
B) Roll Call
C) Public discussion of anything not on the agenda
D) Certificate of Appropriateness
HPC22-0052: 411 South Summit Street — Summit Street Historic District (garage demolition and new
garage construction)
E) Report on Certificates issued by Chair and Staff
Certificate of No Material Effect —Chair and Staff review
1. HPC20-0001: 921 East Burlington Street— Summit Street Historic District (brick repair to front
porch)
2. HPC22-0051: 26 East Market Street (Old Brick) — Local Historic Landmark (internal gutter
repair)
Minor Review —Staff review
1. HPC22-0047: 713 Iowa Avenue - College Hill Conservation District (new rear step railing)
2. HPC22-0050: 111-113 East College Street — Local Historic Landmark (commercial sign
installation)
3. HPC22-0034: 914 Dearborn Street — Dearborn Street Conservation District (rear sliding door)
4. HPC22-0053: 426 Church Street — Goosetown/Horace Mann Conservation District (synthetic
siding removal and repair of original wood siding)
Intermediate Review —Chair and Staff review
HPC22-0046: 516 South Lucas Street — Governor -Lucas Street Conservation District (rear pergola)
F) Consideration of Minutes for July 14, 2022
G) Commission Discussion
1. Historic Preservation Awards
H) Adjournment
If you will need disability -related accommodations in order to participate in this meeting, please contact Jessica
Bristow, Urban Planning, at 319-356-5243 or at Jessica-bristow@iowa-city.org. Early requests are strongly encouraged
to allow sufficient time to meet your access needs.
Staff Report August 4, 2022
Historic Review for HPC22-0052: 411 South Summit Street
District: Summit Street Historic District
Classification: Contributing
The applicants, Leslie and Rudd Nelson, are requesting approval for a proposed demolition and new
construction project at 411 South Summit Street, a Contributing property in the Summit Street Historic
District. The project consists of the demolition of the existing, deteriorated garage and the construction of a
new two -car garage with attic storage above.
Applicable Regulations
and Guidelines:
4.0 Iowa City Historic Preservation Guidelines for Alterations
4.3
Doors
4.11
Siding
4.13
Windows
4.14
Wood
6.0 Guidelines for New Construction
6.2 New Outbuildings
7.0 Guidelines for Dem olition
7.1 Demolition of Whole Structures or Significant Features
8.0 Neighhorhood District Guidelines
8.1 Longfellow Neighborhood
StaffComments
Originally constructed in c. 1900, this house features some of the typical characteristics of Free Classic Queen
Anne houses. It features a pyramidal roof with cross gables, projecting bays, flared belt course and a Palladian
window on the front gable. A full width porch, which wrapped around the south comer, was also part of the
original scheme. The porch was removed some time after 1945. The existing garage is a combination of a
small single -car garage and a two -car garage that was in place in this configuration by 1920.
In 2007, the Commission approved the replacement of three non -historic windows and the addition of a new
window in the kitchen. In 2019, roof shingle replacement was approved.
The applicant is proposing to demolish the existing, deteriorated garage and construct a new two -car garage
with attic storage. The new garage will be set 5 feet in from the alley setback and set in 3 feet from the side lot
line per the zoning code. The garage will be a 26-foot by 26-foot garage with wood lap siding in a 3-inch to 5-
inch lap. The garage will have typical wood trim including corner boards, flat casing around all windows and
doors, and a frieze board at the top of the wall. The roof edge at eave and gable ends will project 1 foot and
will have closed soffits. The garage will have rectangular windows, a passage door and two single -car wood
overhead doors with a carriage house door design.
The guidelines recommend retaining historic garages. Where it is not possible to save an existing garage, the
guidelines recommend designing replacement garages to be compatible in design with the primary structure
and/or other outbuildings in the neighborhood. New outbuildings should be constructed to the rear of the
property and subordinate in size and ornamentation to the primary structure but should reflect the style of
the primary structure. Carriage -style garage doors may be used if they are a style appropriate for the property.
Windows should be relatively small and rectangular.
In Staffs opinion, the existing garage shows a high degree of deterioration. The tongue -and -groove siding is
splitting and has gapped in many places. The roof and several of the roof framing members are collapsing.
While the garage has been in place in this configuration since 1920, it is deteriorated to the degree that staff
recommends approval of its demolition if the Commission can approve the replacement garage design.
In Staffs opinion, the proposed garage design is appropriate for the house. Staff has been working with the
contractor on the information submitted for the project. In the most recent update, staff had several
comments about changes that the contractor has replied are changes he can make. The staff comments were
as follows:
• The opening trim and comer boards as listed in the materials will only be 3 '/z" wide which is too
small. It should be a full 4 inches.
• The lap siding is an 8-inch board. That could be used for a 4" reveal but there will be a great deal of
waste. Plus an 11/16" butt end is too thick. We recommend a 6 inch board for a 4" lap.
• The gable window is a 24" x 24" square. It should be rectangular. The 24" tall is appropriate but then
it should be 18" wide. There should be a window or vent in each gable.
• The 33" x 52" windows in the material list are just too large for a garage. The windows in the
drawings are the largest we could approve for a garage. They are 24" x 42". I recommend something
still rectangular but that size or smaller.
• The passage door would ideally be a half-light door, not a door without windows.
Staff recommends approval of the project with the above changes implemented and with conditions.
Recommended Motion
Move to approve a Certificate of Appropriateness for the project at 411 South Summit Street as presented in
the staff report with the following conditions:
• Changes suggested by staff in the staff report are implemented,
• All windows are rectangular, follow the guidelines, are appropriately sized, and are approved by staff,
• The passage door is approved by staff.
C
"LL,j ---
411 South Summit- interior of garage looking south
C q
u
o
a
i E ao
N
=
^ W1
}I
D
O
0)
L
N
T
(�
Q T
}�
Ln
ry
c
O
}! O
� II
W
N v
r
W
0
0
N
8
3
v
N
F
O
u
u
- y
T
0 3
0
c
O
4-1
ru
v
W
4
o
V
O
N
0
3
O
�
� H
a
c � m
0
N
0
0
3
a
�
V
a
•N
�
N
a v
ESTIMATE FOR:
barTcy S CC.
5694 Q2arry Heichs :.n Na
NOPt1t Ll_er Ly, IA
523--7-9350
Ph: (319) 621-1314
PROJECT CESCR:PTIO_V:
Giro-e
Estimate From
Estimate # 16066
STORE#3091IOWA TAX: (319)35R-9G05 rage 1 Of 5
2605 Naples Ave ISSMAIL: IOWABui!dingMaterials`ylnenardR.com
Iowa Cary, lA 52240
ESTIMATE BY F.STIMATF DATE'
HAROLD C. 00/p U:'.2
SKU NUMBER
DESCRIPTION
QTY'TO
ORDLR ADDITIONAL ITEM INFORV.ATION
102-ICCc
2X2-9' F7RRI\C STRIP 94S PINE/SPRCCE
14
lsiicl
Soffit Na1:Cr
102 2143
2X4 1S- R2&BT2 3Rr cosisT./FRALNU
2
EACH
«.42 Dvernang Frellirg
102-1334
SX6-104 5/6" SFF S701)
LC3
EACH
Nell Stud
'32-1758
2X6-u' STUD/42&u'7R F.pr CONST./PRAFTNG
_
EACH
hoar Crack Hratnzng
1C2-1761
2X6-:0' STJD/d2&G"IR SFP CONST./PR.AMINC
4
TACK
Door _'rack Fran=nq
10-1.114
2X6-'2 E2&STR SPP CONST./FRAMING
a
3ACH
I'np plate
103-1790
2X6-1E' Tr2&BTR SPF CONST./FRAM': NG
lc
SACK
Top Plate.
_32-1884
2X8-8' 42&-TR SPF CONST./MAtP-NG
1
EACH
Window. Oahle Header
102-1804
2X8-11' 42&3TR SPF C.01757./ERAK71aG
2
EACH
Ser,7e Lypr Eave Header
102-166L
2xe-9' 42&BT_i SPi COXST./T2AM-Nn
2
EACH
Hcndo.9 Save Header
104-1204
;-7/4^X9-11Z'- 12' LVL -.9E
4
EACH
overhead Duos Cabe Header
177-1149
1X2-a' CRRAR S1E2E 3.1117117/V NOMINAL
2
EACH
Door Stoo EOr-rant.!
107-_148
_X2 u' CEDAR 5152E S+RI'k7/8' -NOMINAL
4
EACK
Door Sco? verp_pal
107-:342
1X4-8' CEDAR E-62£ 31STR 7%S" SOM:NAL
4
£ACtI
overhead Dour --Lr.
137 Li42
.1X4-11' CFd]AR S1s24: 3+nTR 7/S" NTN4i NA 1,
5
EACH
ROOT And Window 7r1R.
1-nia is an sslimats. ll is Fiven only for Reneml p:ice infor-Talicn. This is .Dl a.-. e1Ter and that can be ne legally- binding ee rin ct bctwea+l
the panics based upon Ih15 cstiam. The Prizes sralctl 7erein ale stnjerl fo change doyending upon Ile mmkct wrditions. The prim sralcd
on 1hi s esE:naM an- no( Finn fur any time Feria: u_less specifically wnrten odseewiao an IN, Inrn and am no( inOluaivp Of Taxes, dowry,
packaging er any rtlter charges which may nr Maly not aa,d in he add:Al rl4n: till i, nosily pu noharng prod ucb from this estimate.
The urailabilily cf,unte, al. is cubjaa lu atvculciv condiiioue A1ENARDS IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY LOSS 1NCURREn RY
T11E CUES]' WHO RELIES ON PRICES NETFOR'TH HEREIN Olt O\'THE AVAILARII.rTY OF ANY OF T!IE MATERIALS
STATED HFRFJPL All inwnia!ioa oil his fommotheriwaprice,Ims beer p-ovided'lyI,.,[mid Mc:ands is not mspnlnlhle for any enoa GUEST COPY
in the i:.:onnasien al this s6tnito.:ac14ding hot art.imiicdm gonntity, din isn and qualiy. Plccx ccailiw;Iriscvjolots raNrully.
MYNARDSMAKES NO REPRFSENTATrONS.ORAI., WRITTEN OR OTHERWISE THAT TIIE MATERIALS LISTED ARE 1
SLIT.ABLE FOR ANY PURPOSE BEING CONSIDERED BY THE GL EST. BECAL'SE OF VIDE. VARIATION'S IN CODES, PAGE 1 OF J
THERE ARE NO REPRESENTATIONS THAT THE 19A77RIA1S LISTER I[ERVY MEET YOUR CODE REQuiRkHESfS.
ESTIMATE FOR
uazsay 6 Cn.
3694 Quarry }:eights lr. HE
North Mharty, IA
Estimate From
1
Estimate ## 16066
STORL N 3091 IOWA FAX: (319) 358-9605 Page 2 of 5
26G5 Nap:c6 Ave EMAIL:[OWABuildingMRterialstii;munards.cnln
Iowa Ciry,LA 52240
ESTIMATE BY ESTIMATE DATE
HAXCL+ C. 08/01/22
SKti NUMBER DESCRIPTION
QTY TO
ORDER
ADDITIONAL ITLM INFORMATION
107-1355
1X4-10' CEDAR S-52E 31BTR'.'/ell N0411TAL
2
LACII
Overhead Door Tria
lc7-:355
1X4-10' CEDAR S1S2E 34STR7/8" NOdI=yIAL
s
I;AC�I
❑oar And window Trlx
137.1_335
1X4 1C' CEDAR S1S2E NOWNA],
8
EACH
011twice Coiner
l0')-1.3CR
-:X4-12' CEDAR 5142E 3-DTR7/9• NOMINAL
1
EACH
Door Arrd W!ndov Tripe
107-14SE
:X6-12' CEDAR S182E 3-BTR718" NOMINAL
S
RAM.
E•o 3C is
107-'_504
1X6-16' CEDAR S1S2E 3+BI27/8" NO.MINAL
4
RA:F.
Fascia
-07-LB62
1X8 8' CB➢AR S1S2E 3+8TR 7/9" NOIMINA-.
6
EACH
Overhead Door .;air:,
Iol-EC'60
11116X8X12' CEDAREEVELIA36QUARE EJTT
51
EACH
Siding
1C7-8C86
11/16X8X_4' •CRDARRFVRT,r,APEQOARE B---TT
30
EACH
Siding
1C7 -8109
11/16XSX_6 CEDA1lHL'VELLAP$QQARG 31p77
63
FACE
Siding
_11 L040
AX6-12' AC2 CREL•'N-•R6ATEDGRDUND COAPACC
_
F1tCH
nn�tcm` pla�P
ILl-1066
2X6-16' AC2 GREEN FREAP='CRbHND c^iqiAr.-T
5
-AC:i
Bottom Plane
124-2728
7/i617/16CATi4X8 DSE 3-NHIT� S'1'31pHS
34
EACH
ON SALE THkD C8/Cl/22
Was— St:eac Ling
124-2809
1/211/2CA714X8 CSH 2wil ll1X S'I'a LPI;
32
EACH
ON SALR TIrRU C8/C3/22
Roof Sheathing
145 10S6
'rRXTUR3DNOGROOVE SOFFIT
4
EACH
so`f't
Phisrsanesr:mxue.It.s BSenonty foe gpic:al Trice infonnaiun. Tbiss 11C anofferand themcanbe n, legally binding wreac:heoveea
die parlla>bawd upun ilia eslimuru.Thmprices Mamd lmreinanmWb tmeheupodependingupon the marvel m:lditionsTheprrtiss81ed
on this •stineG am not firm for sny limp period unless specifically wrillen Mhenrix an this.."ann and ere not is rlusira nFpsai; tleliverv;
packi[,'lll$ 01Mly other ahargirs wbicl miy or trL'ly not Cued to be Ed[ed IV Ilan uffilmsrly pineli69i Ilg 2loduCla Beat dlislestbne'x.
Theavoilsildityof. mterialsis sub*tlo inwrto:y conchilons. MENARDS IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY LOSSINCURRED BY
THE GEESI' WHO RE;Ll US ON PRICES SKI' 8'ORTH HEREIN OR ON THE AVAILABILITY OF ANY OF T1fE MAI'ERIAL.S
STATED HEREIN. All in Io,iYWlon on ilia ruin.ufnur dwit price- hesheen provided hy RucsL dvlcnards is notxspoltrible for any apron GUEST COPY
in the Wil.aon on This enema c, :acludinS but.w: Ihatred to gaai0y, dimension and qua itv. Please ussin¢Ic this rstirirtc carxlully.
Mr..NAn n5 MA14FS NO RRPRESENTATIONSI ORAL: WRriT&4 OR OTHER W ISE THAT THE. MAYER [ALS LISTED ARE
SOII AULK FOR ANY PURPOSE HEING CONSIDERED BY TRIP, GUEST. BECAUSE OF WJUE VARIAlION81N CODES, PAGE 2 Or 5
THERF.ARF. NO RRpRESENTATIONSTHATTITE MATERIALS LISILD IILRL'1N hIEETYOLR CODE REQUIREMENTS,
ESTIMATE FOR:
narney fs co.
3694 ,h,larry I[a:ghts In NP:
Ncrnh Liberty, :A
523:7-935C
ph: 13131 62.--1:4
PROJECT- DESCRIPTION:
Garage
Estimate From
Estimate # 16066
STORE # 3091 IOWA FAX; (319) 358-9605 Page 3 of 5
2605 Naples Ave EMAIL: IOWABuilding.Materials(e�mer.arrs.can
Incas Ci[v, TA 52240
^STIMATE BY ESTIMATE DATE
-TAROLD C. OF/O1/22
SICU NUMBER DESCRIPTION
QTY TO
ORDER ADDITIONAL ITEM INFORMATION
151-L799
415 1INC'RT.Aw A='rA -4869 3T%14V (9 90)
2
PALM
Root Tel-
-51-1827
2S¢ ICEMRA" WEAT-ER_OCK G02 GRANULAR
2
EACH
IL'e & watFr 3arrin"
lb1-191C
OC STAR -ER STRIP 105 LP/ECNOFF.
1
BNCL
Shingle Starter
ISI-2368
HLR PROFXIGE CC 31 LP DS'CATE STRAY
1
9ND:,
Hip dad Ridge Shingles
-5:-318D
DURATION R$TATP. GRAY
25
BND-
Shingles
151-811,01
1C 07, IRO ALL I4EATHER RCCP CENENR
1
HACE
Roof_ng Cene_t
1S7�1398
12' S=TL.E D ALM ROOF EDGTAIIH
10
IiA(;II
ROOT Edge
COLOR^.AG:0L-WisiLe
Colo-: White
-61-2996
9' X 73' SLCCX-IT [VUSK yIRAP
2
EACH
Hc'ase Wrap
lei 3033
1/d"X >.y"x 50' FOAMS EALRS LL_ SEALER
2
rACB
gill 9-al
161-3240
1.89"X56.67 YARD WIITTF. n1.00K-:T TAFE
_
EACH
N.ouse Wrap Tape
206-2_65
1-1/4" COIL ROOFING NAIL 730OPC
_
e:x
ROO£ong Nails
227-2303
1/2"PLYWD CL-P 5:EEL 25/31112:2 BMC IOBGS/
y
T•:A ,;!
ROOf EheaLhinq C_ips
227 16L7
TRUSS SPACER 24^O.C. 10' TSX24 20/
5
EACH
T-vss Spacer
',29-2957
9D SS SIDING NAIL 11,8 BOX
-
Sex
�cor Sap Fasteners
Thisislaestimale II isgivcaony grEc.-.vT•. pricem ornwaon.'I:ris is actmnoft'er and: here cmbeno IQVAIybindingcarpactbeu•eer.
lhu panics eased Loon this eadmax.'rhe prcrs stated herein Nita anT:jec: io chpngc dcpri alms upon The mu to road itians. 111c pticcs stated
on III'.., estimate am not Oml I'ar any rime Ilerioc tar. ess spmi:Tcally wriRcn cthrn, Ise at iris foam hall art Ica; inclusive o5laxcs, ddivcry,
packapngor any olhercharges whirl may or auy no: need a no adced when u10mmic y pumboxi ng n'odlats Tent This Iasi note.
The ovailaht_cy nfmucrials issohject In inventwy co %diliois. MENARDS IS NOT RESPONSIBLE: I -Olt ANY LOSS INCURRED BY
THE. GUEST WHO RELIES ON PRICES SET FORTH HEREIN OR ON THE AVAILAnILTTV OF ANY OF THE MA'I'ER1.4LS
STATED IIEREIN-All ln!bnuulor.nc'cis l'enn.ol^-er llui•: priuc. husbeen pms•ided by guest and Yhmanls is not sespons:ble for any alias /�yT Cs
in die inlhncalinn cn this csti,nulc, Inc udiuybutnet limimDUES�dto quandly.dimentonnnd qu.-'ty. Pleax ex..mine thi6 estimate nrcfully. COPY`'
NIENARDS MAKLS NO )tF:P1tF:SF,N'IA71OVS,ORAL, WRITTEN OROTHERWISETIIAI`11Ha MATERIALS LISTED ARK
SUITARI.F. FOR AA'YPI7 RPOSE BUNG CONS [TIERED BY'111EGULSI'. BECAUSEOF W'IDEV4RIATIONS IN CODES, PAGE 3 OF 5
THERE ARE ND It EPRY,SENTA (TONS THAT THE MATERIALS LISTED HERE6Y MEET YU1!It GOOF: NEQI!IRFLVIEN'I},
ES'IIMAI'E FOR,
Barrey 6 Cr..
369C Ooarty HolghLs La NE
Nnrrt, :.inP.Yrv, -A
52313-9a50
Ph: (329; 621-13=4
PROJECT l)BSC.kI1J1'tGN-
Garage
Estimate From
Estimate # 16066
STORE #3091 IOWA FAX: (319)358-9605 Page 4 of 5
2605 NbFhes Ave LMAIL:IOWABuildineMatcrials'rynicnrrds.cala
Iowa City, IA 52240
ESTIMATE 13Y ES'r[MATF, DATE
HAROLD C. 08/01/22
SKU NLMSER DESCRIPTION
QTY TO
ORULR ADDITIONAL ITEM INFORMATION
aD 99 SIDIVC NAIL
113 Box
z
Box
FFO FaSLeLDrS
229-IQJi
EC S?LI:LESS CEDAR NAIL
1LB M 167 S22Yf,
9
EACH
Siding PnELesers
229-5341
SD V.C. ErNKIP NAIL
SLR nox
5
3cx
Sheatttiag Fasteners
229 5363
16U V.C, SINKER NAI_
5LB Box
6
RICK
Frarclnp Nail&
233-0042
6" TIH@2k:.OK 50PK
FVLTLOK06-50
1
HACII
'trues vastener
23D-0104
3LATLOK 3-112^ 5DPK
FMFL312-50
L
HACH
Headcr Fastener
13_-2C y4
5/-S" STAPLES
51)1C.2 SM
L
EACH
House wrap Staples
232-9028
_/2" x IO"Oct ANCH 3CLT NN25PC
1210HGA323
1
EACR
Ari hor 3clts
425-1031
HI-FI AC CHAIN DRIVK
BETTER CHN .5HP
2
l CH
Uuerhedd Eoor OUerer
42S-1011a
RRAR TRACK HANGING FIT
IDEAL
c
EACH
overhead Door Hardvare
425 "31
S7PP0RT S-RV" K"X9
$103710= 240
2
RAGE
Overiaad Door St2uLrY
425-1.632 GARAGE DOOR OPEN HANG KTT24999 2 RACE
Over -Read Door flanging Kit
431-6799 DOCR INSTALLATTCA XI.- ?IEN1019 1 BACF:
Service Dnnr Kit
1,33-1222 PINE TAFSR3D SHIKS 12 CT 3/SX1-L/4X8 " 2 EACH
Opening SI[i•n
436-4-00 41-1t33' ASP11Ar:r';APE TE433 2 EACH
Onsr:ng Plashing
TI'.:s Is au, rslunate. It is glven only Ibc general price information. This is not an offer and dmx can be no legally bindi-g mnrmct hens'ecn
the Pei ties teased 'poll 1M3 Pannone. The prigs alaled herrin arc subject, to change depending upon the market cvldilio: s. The prices soled
o:: L".is eVJrrntr arC Rol hnn fnr' any thne pCl'iod Unless fpaClf Bally lvriltrn othelW LYC otl [Ills faun 111d a�0 `.ti tnclUSiVC Gf 1,iSei, dCliVcly.
piCkaj}rng D! all}' OtkelChnl'_L'CS N'hleh ITYy nr mny'r.at: L'�Y. hl 112 a']ded W ACII Ull�nalel}' paChYYnI$ jradYC[Y flClln d1:Y CStIIDaN.
The availahility of rlaledals is subject to i::vcntary c.n dhi.ra. MENARDS IS NOT M9PONSIRLE FOR ANY LOSS INCURRED BY
THE GUESTWHO RELIES ON'PRICES$F.T FORTH HEREIN OR ON THEAVAIL.ABILl IV 01 ANY OF I F'. MATERIALS i��slCOT)1/
STATED Nnn PRCIN.All:uioxtio youd,isfu_,ll, neer Yman price: hnsbeenprorided Dy guest ard)kn.rds is Rol i<sponslble rcranycn'ors rTTT•
in the irubnnacv..v.1-.is eslir.,llo. itcludiug bulnollimited loquanuty. dimensianand quality, Please cm.rinc lls.scsli'naR caniully. GUIE 1
MEVARDSMAKESNO REPRESENT'A'rIONS,ORAI.,WRITTENOR OTHERWISE THAT THE MATERIALS LISTED ARE r�l�l`.
SUITABLE FORANY PURPOSE BRINGCONSWERED BY THE GUEST. BECAUSE OF WIDE VARIRIIONS IN CODFS, PAGE 4 OF 5
IMERK ARF NO RF.PRFS F.NTATIONS THATTIM MA'I'HRIALS LISTED HEREIN MF.PT YOUR C UDF RFOUIREMENTS.
Estimate From
I FSTIMATE FOR: I
3arney & Cc.
3694 pcarry Heights _n NE
Norch Liberty, IA
52317-935C
Ph: f319: 621 1314
PROOECT DESCRi PTIONe
Garage
Estimate # 16066
STOREx3091 IOWA FAX: (319)358-9605 Page 5 of 5
2605 NapIES AVc EMAIL:IOWABuildipgMater'.uls•@incnards.cain
Iowa Chy, !A 52240
ESTIMATE BY ESTIMATE DATE
HAROLD C. da/V1/22
SKU NLMBEA DESCRIPTION QTY TO ORDER ADDITIONAL ITFM INFORMATION
450-320? SC COMBO RACTSON /DB SVC "RUBOLT 1734365 _ MACH
Service Door Lock
561-4131 bi- A&D SILICONE ULTRA C'LR9 02 WL31191o10 4 EACH
Siding Ccclk
y63-S:j42 'AFL 'W&I: ICCO S=L RUBR CLR _OOZ WL31111010 i aAp1
Opeo:ng Ca,.lk
af1-4342 RI. W&D 1DO% SIL RU31t C1R 10OZ WL31122010 2 RACH
Cve"head ?uo_ Tri:n Caulk
••• It purchaacd today, you save $74.40 ea+
Tn¢is an eslionakJtis girrn only for ycnnnl pr'e; iafnrmuion,'fhis is not on prier and dierstai be no lagally binding ecni;mt between
-]`Le
TODAY'S SUB-TOTAI.: 12,692.83
the ;,a ries based upnc this esibuhip, 71m prices staled huu.0 are subject to change dcpc:d i:y upon the market mnditpn& prices In.
REGULAR SUB
"I OHS estf'MIe4rsnot F..foranytimyrriod unhspecifiedly wiitmn otitemAcon this form arld a:e:ol incl':a.ve of Laxes,delivery•,
-TOTAL: 12, 767.2.5
ptt kagi.:g or say aCxrcMgres which n:ay o: inxy' na[ ncti W he sddM when ullimafetY Dunitasing p:nducts from dtis esLuwR.
The avadobilily of ,",IR,atl $ is suujrd Lo iaven:ory condition. J'IENARDS IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY IASS INCURRED B!'
TH L• QUEST WHO RELIES ON PRICES SET FORTH HRRF.7N OR ON THE AVAILABILITY OF ANY OF"111 E MA'ITRIALS
STATEDHEREIN, All i'fo; malicil on lh:s fenn. ellierhan p:iee. has been pmv ided by gi est and 91"nldsts not respnnsme rat any ermis
�j Fs,, �
G ES Copy
in the:nfcnnallon on ltis eslimam,itvhling but not limited to quanfily,dimensio.:m arectulky. Plem uxaina this esthnam ce:cfulLy.
`F+
MFNARDS NLARBS NO REPRESENTATIONS, ORAL, WRITTEN OR O'1'IILRIe'ISETHAI' THE NIA "rER1A1.5I TSSTED ARE.
SGI.['ABLE FOR AN PURPOSE BEING CO N'SWERF.D BY THE. GUEST, BECAUSF.OF HIDE VARIA'LWNS IN CODES,
PAGE 5 OF 5
THF,R BARE NO REPRESENTATIONS THA'I711E MKI LR1ALS L151'1•:D HEREIN MEV I-YOVR CODE RFQUIREMENTS.
2605 NAPLES AVE �vt'aa����� Design It: 309154652285
IOWA CITY, IA 52240 " Saav+ E1Q
(31935-9Design&Buy'-WINDOWS Estimated Price: $2,304.80
(319)358%05 �OS
Hew m purchase at the store: How to recall and purchase a saved design &theme:
1. Take this packet to Bcry Mena ads store.
2. Have a Mena, di, Teem Member enter the VesJgn IU Into the Window Designer
Program.
3. Have a Mena, ds Team Merrlbe, pis nt pur chase rig duc'um ents.
4. Take the Special Order Contract tothe register and pay.
LOO-1 1
Bough Opening: 24.75 x 24.75
Actual Size: 24 A 24
Boom: None Assigned
Unit Is Plewed7rerm the outside looking in.
1. Go to Menards.com
2. Loll to your account.
3. Go to the Window Designer from the Project Center and alert Search Saved
Designs.
4. Easter the Design 10 or sei from your open prajem to land imp the Window
Designer.
S. Add your design to the cart and purchase.
Wood W-2500. $474.89 $474.89
Direct Set,
24 x 24
Pfod.UT le BackendName=JELD-WEN W-2500 Wood Picture NF
Assembly - Full Unit,
Ertenor Trim Type = 9rkkRlould,
Hrterlor i H. Gel lens = No,
C9vntry Where Unit WRI Be Installed =USA (Certified)
Measurement Type = Actual Sire,
Frame Width = 24",
Frame Height =24",
EgeHor Td m Width = 2/,
Esterdr Tfl no Height = 26.4375
I men0f Material Type=Auralaet Pine,
Interior Finish Type = Primed.
Interior Finish = Primed.
Enter for Finish = PH med
Gleosion lamb - 4 9/16"
Performance Grade Rating - PG 35
Glass Energy Effisi mi y = Energy Star,
Installation Zip Code • 52240,
Energy Star Zone = Energy Star- Northern,
Energy Star Low Options = SunStable with HeatSave,
Glans Type = Standard,
Neat Glass = Yes,
Glatt Thickness = Standard Default Thickness,
Protective Film = Pmletliva Film,
Glace Spacer Color = Nark Spacer,
Air Space Opt -ions =Argon
Grille Type = 5/g" Flat CBS,
Gfflle Finish = Bit liam White,
Grille Pattern � Colonial,
Number of Squares Wide = 2,
Number of Squares High = 2
Window Egress= Does Not Meet fill
1.1-Factor=0.12,
Solar Heat Gain Coefficient - D.29,
MON a Light Transmittance = 0.54,
Cundenaatioo Resistance =49,
CPok=1EL-N-713-0693g-00OD2,
Energy Star qualified = Northam; North-Central
Is this a Reorder? = No
Manufacturer=JELD-WLN, Rontoul(IL),
Catalog Version Date=176715/2022,
Catalog Version = 22.2.11-0
5/0" Flat Cl Between Glass (i
Culonial,
2W2H
pilot o+te: 7/31/202)9:29�20 Panes: 1 of 2 NULL 13092
Line Item Quantity Product Descriptiun Unir urire Total Pri:r.
Rough Opening: 34.125 x 53.25
Actual Size: 3"75 x 52,5
Room: None Assigned
Unit is vieteeJ from the welide looking in.
„N
107
Aaxues Sraa • 33 375•
s— FO • 34 125'
Double Hung,
33.375 a SM
ProduRrleBackendName=1EU>WLN W-2500 Wood Dnubie H unit NF
Amemi Full unit,
Eater'or Trim•7ype= B Ickmould,
ExtedorTrim Optiorss=No,
Country Where Unit WIII Be Installed = USA (Certified)
Sash Split =Even Olylde,
Meewrement Type= Rough Opening Site,
Rough Opening Width = 34 1/B",
Haugh Opining Neigt t = 531/4",
Llderlor Trim Width = 36,
tAterlor trim Height = 54.22125
Interior Material Type=Auralast Pine,
Ini Finish TYPE = Primed,
(Merton Finish =Primed,
Exterior Finish - Pd med,
Sash to Match Earn for Frame Finish =Yes,
Exterior Sash Finish = Primed
Extension Jamb - 4 9/16-
Hmdware Finish - Interior = White,
N umber of Locks =1.
Screen Options= UltreVue Mesh,
Screen Frame Final - Brilliant White
Glass Energy Ffficsency = Energy Star,
Installation Lip Code = 52240,
Energy Star zone = Energy Star - Northern,
E nelgy Star low F Options =SurtStable with HeatSave,
Glass Type =Standard,
Neel Glass = Yes,
Glass Thickness = Standard Default Thickness,
ProteetlYe Film = Protective Film,
Glaze Spacer Color = Black Spacer,
Air Space Options a Argon
Grille Type - No Grilles
Secondary Vent Stop /Sash Olniter= No Window Opening Control Device,
Jamb Liner= White Jamb Dner,
Jamb Liner Options =Corn pression Jamb liner,
Finger Plows = No Finge r Flown
Window Egress = Does Nat Meet Egl ess
J-Facior = 0.26,
Solar Heat Gain Coelhciem a0.27,
Vill ble Lien Transmittance =0.5,
Condensation Resistanre • 47,
CPDB =JEL-M 57841932-00(1
Energy Star Qualified = Northern; North-Central
h th is a Hai r7 c No
Manufacturer=MD-WEN, Banloullll),
Catalog Version Date=0W1Sr1D'l2,
Ceti log Version = 212.11.0
None
Total: $2a304.80
Print Mr.. 7131y20229:29.20 POEM: 2 of 2 NULL/3091
2605 NAPLES AVE
IOWA CITY, [A 52140
(319) 358-9708
(319) 358-9605
How to purchase at the store:
Design #: 309154651951
rSG:[r"R.+y` Estimated PriCe: $3,979.68
Deoign&Huy-GARAGE DOORS
1. Take this Packet to any Menards store.
2- Have a Menards Team Member Peter the Design ID into the Garage Door Designer
Program.
9. Have a Menards Team Member print purchasing documents-
4- lake the Special Order Contract to the register and pay.
1001 2
Aetua15"; 96" s 84"
Room: None Assigned
Unit is vievieaf f am the outside iapking in.
.0
!1'
How to recall and purchase a saved design at home:
1. Go to Menards.com
2. Login to your account.
3. Go to the Garage Door D elgnerfrom the Pro)ert Center and select Search Saved
Daeigns
4. Enter the Design ID or acted from your open projects to load Into the Patlo Uao
neaigner-
b. Add your design to the cart and purchase.
Premium Handuatted Good $1.989.94
Garage Door
Garage Door Width = R Ft 0 In
Garage I Height - 7 it D In
Assembly Type = Complete Door
WIndCode Rating =WO Most locations
Doer Grade = Point
Wood Type = Hemlock
Wood Panel Type = Smooth
Detign = 2P
Factory Finish - Primed Wood
Insulation R-Value - Non -Insulated
Door Model - MH
Windows = I
Glass Style • Clear Glass
Glass Type = Non -I nsulated
Opener Ready =yes
Headroom Available Wical (11" - 32"1
Track Slse - Moum = 2" Bracket Mount Track
I rack uR = Standard oft
Track Radiul ISS
SPIIng = U-SLTTorslon
Headroom Ret{uirad=IV'
Lock = No Lock
Type of Reinfo¢emerdStrut n 2-1/4e Strut
Standard Struts - number - 3
Standard Reinforcement Souts.3 SMn (2-1/4"]
Hi nge Drilling = Spot for Lags (Standard for Wood Doors)
Decal. Hardware -No
Grooves = No Grooves
53,979.68
Total: F $3,979.68
Print Doh: 7/31/2822 2:51:24 Paaal 1 of 1 NULL/3091
Dale: 51on Aug 01 15:55:07 CDT 2022
Design -Name: Mastercratt Designer
Design 1D: 309154669758
Estimated Price: $529.50
'Todgh estimated priet, fotorc pricing may Coup nr dm.n.TaT, labor, and dethery am Included.
MENr - - - -
How to recall and purchase your design at home:
How to purchase your design at
Scan acru tU:'ccall 3mirdcslgn of
the store:
1 On hfcnnrds.com, enter "Design
&Buy" in
chat with a spwiahs[
the search her
1. !toter Design Id: 3119154669758 at the
[i JIC. ?.Select the Your Door, Your Way
Designer
Design -it Center Kiosk in the Building
' OR
3t 3.Rccall your design by entering Design
Materials Department
r
I, Follow the on screen purchasing
a ID-309154669759
imtnlctions
4.F•ollow• the on -screen purchasing
See a Menards Team Member if you have
instructions
questions.
QTY
1) f•.SCR I PI ION
SKU
Prehung 36" x 80" 6 Panel, Singh; Duor, Smooth Piber<class
4000440
Left Hand hiswing
Bore and Mortised for hinges with DCadbLllt Horn
6 9./16" [20 construction] White steel frame (6 9116 - 7 112) frame
ADA Approved Handicap Sill
Satin Nickel Tlinges
No Kickplate
No Peepsite
Interior Reudy Lu Finish. Exterior Ruddy to Finish
Rough Opening 37" X 80 314"
Brick Opening 40 3A" X 82"
•* FSLimated lead Lime for this item is 7 days
Features
Glass
Outside View
ImsideNdew
P. olsom
M r
•I
"PLEASE NOTE
THE FOLLOWING"
TODAYIS ESTT114ATED PRICE
Steel frame supplied with compression weather-stripping. Door image
$529.50
and accessories are for representation only.
Prxi; is good for all items on this page.
Total price for all items I 5529.50
Ttit is a I tttilrraa. is is.l.: i cov rul ,:--1 , lac inrwmrinn.l'vi• n ma a. R Ixrvnl an,. can he no k3M1, -,Inn,,, ,.I*oo,00 Ar orgies MIMI Jpm• III • shlwr. III rdc a nnxd 6::111 nm,uh zl
n::ba,ga&,,ald,, eon. lt.L to IIkd:I-Cl:Iu n' 7 se ccao.m!his a:iman:u•., st,'� oydiw,-I.Iulc..
,llm�fWlrhritivluIN:wi.ena 7us lumar . TFnviWRiN nrm:xninia, *.F b F.
inven.nm Lo,dkio.: W EN, RCS K NOT K-SIIOVSIRLE FOR ANY WIN IN' W It RLD BY IRL GULP 1' I, III) R [CCs
ON MUMS ALT IYMTT l I IFRTM nR ON TRG AVAIL A BILITY DF AV1• OF
THr MATERIALS SYA I W HLRL I e All ItivlmmunmIII, I..alenlul puce, ha her..6driMn•=-t nor,hk".L6 it n"I rtsponeb rfu: mn : mr, it db i:dL-one.,... d9s xim.ar. FmhldinabIa
nr. lhnaA al,u*Rt Jis--In aryl juali:, Mt:wr IN. Ruimmc amRdh.VF.NARTiS MAf(P.i SI I RRI•RF9:NTATVU
. ORA L. WRI'I'I'hNl 't-D II. 1511 T111'I"I'I IF, %IATMAL5[$TIT,
A RCAllrARLE rOR INY III I RI`ML BEICp I:ONSIDERd1 BY THE nDEST. BEC1DSE DF wmt••ARr❑ONS IN MIMI.TI?"-ItF. A AE$O R I'!.RRI'S F.\-AnnsN PLiT THr MATrR JAI%
LISTED FEREA MEET 1'OUR COD- RLO IRLMLy'rh.
For other helpful Designers starch "Design & Buy" on Menards.com
PAGE 1 OF I
MINUTES
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
JULY 14. 2022
EMMA HARVAT HALL
PRELIMINARY
MEMBERS PRESENT: Kevin Boyd, Carl Brown, Kevin Larson, Noah Stork, Deanna
Thomann, Nicole Villanueva, Frank Wagner, Christiana Welu-
Reynolds
MEMBERS ABSENT: Margaret Beck, Jordan Selllergren
STAFF PRESENT: Jessica Bristow
OTHERS PRESENT: Simon Andrew, G.T Karr
RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL: (become effective only after separate Council action)
CALL TO ORDER: Chairperson Boyd called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
PUBLIC DISCUSSION OF ANYTHING NOT ON THE AGENDA:
There was none
SECTION 106 REVIEW
Bristow explained the purpose of a Section 106 Review. It is the compliance part of the 1966
Preservation Act, protecting historic properties and resources on government projects when
federal funds are used. The project under current review is an FCC project, which typically
involves cellular equipment. There is a nation-wide agreement about this type of work. The
agency needs to determine the scope of the potential effects. It could be just the building itself,
or the impact could be on an entire district. Specific distances, etc. are written into the
agreement for FCC projects.
Bristow described the current project under review. The proposed plan calls for T-Mobile
equipment mounted on City High School. City High School has been determined to be eligible
for the National Register, so it is protected under Section 106. Bristow displayed the detailed
drawings that were included in the packet. She also covered an historic resources report that
was included. The T-Mobile report states the potential affected area is 1000 feet, but the
national agreement calls for a half mile for equipment this high. Bristow displayed maps of the
area showing that the antennae would not be visible from over 1000 feet or a half mile. She also
stated that there would be no adverse effects to the high school building or the visual
characteristics of any historic areas. She recommended that HPC remain a consulting partner
on the project.
MOTION: Brown moved to respond to the request for comment on the T-Mobile project on
1900 Morningside Drive as follows: The Iowa City Historic Preservation Commission requests to
be considered a consulting party on the project. The Commission further requests the half mile
APE prescribed by the programmatic agreement and that the Commission agrees with the
determination that the project will have no adverse effect on historic structure or historic
resources. Wagner seconded the motion. The motion carried on a vote of 8-0 (Beck and
Sellergren absent).
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
July 14, 2022
Page 2 of 4
CERTIFICATE OF NO MATERIAL EFFECT:
1024 Woodlawn Avenue
Repairing deteriorating wood, failing brick foundation, siding, roof membrane on flat roof.
1118 East Court Street
The concrete stairs will be replaced.
619 North Linn Street
The original railing was replaced years ago, but it deteriorated fairly quickly. The new contractor
provided an excellent report on the cause and how to redo it.
MINOR REVIEWS:
732 East Davenport Street
This was originally work without a permit. They are now in discussions with staff about siding
removal and repair.
814 Church Street
Simple deck set in from the side walls of the house.
529 Brown Street
Front door replacement of ill-fitting door.
530 South Governor Street
Simple deck installation
728-730 Brown Street
Changing four sets of sliding doors to French doors.
324 Fairchild Street
Deck construction
845 Maggard Street
Work was done without a permit. Railing will now be revised to follow the guidelines.
INTERMEDIATE REVIEWS
837 South 71h Avenue
Duplex converted to single family dwelling. Replacing some exterior doors with windows and
removing some steps.
701 East Davenport Street
Work was being done without a permit. Removing Parapet wall to reveal historic house behind.
CONSIDERATION OF MINUTES FOR JUNE 9, 2022:
MOTION: Wagner moved to approve the minutes of the Historic Preservation Commission's
June 9, 2022, meeting, as written. Stork seconded the motion. The motion carried on a vote
of 8-0 (Beck and Sellergren absent).
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
July 14, 2022
Page 3 of 4
COMMISSION DISCUSSION
724 Ronalds Street: Boyd gave a short history of the property at 724 Ronalds Street. The city
purchased this property several years ago. HPC reviewed its classification from contributing to
non-contributing based on alterations. City staff determined that it needed to be demolished and
notified HPC. The Iowa City Council is preparing to sell the lot. Simon Andrew, Director of The
Housing Fellowship, addressed the Commission as the potential buyer. He provided an
overview of the organization and the affordable housing project that is being considered for this
lot. They will partner with IC School District and the Homebuilders' Association to construct a
student -built affordable rental home on the property.
Boyd stated his disappointment with how city leaders approached the project, but he supports
The Housing Fellowship's vision.
G.T. Karr, representing The Vocational Training Council, also spoke to the commission about
their partnership on the project and his desire to work with HPC on plans. Bristow added that
there will be a good neighbor meeting to discuss plans with the community. The planning is in
the initial stage and Boyd expressed his hope that the final plan comes for approval with only
minimal, and necessary, exceptions to the guidelines. He suggested that the City add this to the
purchase agreement.
New Commissioners: Boyd welcomed new commissioners, and everyone introduced
themselves.
Historic Preservation Awards:
Bristow presented slides with award nominations.
MOTION: Thomann moved to approve the awards as presented. Brown seconded the motion.
The motion carried on a vote of 8-0 (Beck and Sellergren absent).
Election of Officers:
MOTION: Brown moved to approve Kevin Boyd as Chair for next year and Jordan Sellergrin as
Vice Chair, unless she declines to serve in that capacity. Wagner seconded the motion. The
motion carried on a vote of 8-0 (Beck and Sellergren absent).
ADJOURNMENT:
Villanueva moved to adjourn the meeting. Welu-Reynolds seconded. The meeting was
adjourned at 6:40 pm.
Minutes submitted by Kathy Fitzpatrick
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
July 14, 2022
Page 4 of 4
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION ATTENDANCE RECORD
2022-2023
TERM
8/12
9/09
10/14
11/18
12/9
01/13
2/15
3/10
4/14
5/12
6/9
7/14
NAME
EXP.
BECK,
6/30/24
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
--
X
O/E
O/E
MARGARET
BOYD, KEVIN
6/30/23
X
X
X
X
X
X
O/E
X
X
X
X
X
BROWN,
6/30/23
X
X
O/E
O/E
X
O/E
O/E
X
X
O/E
X
X
CARL
DEGRAW,
6/30/22
X
X
X
X
O/E
X
X
X
X
X
X
--
SHARON
KUENZLI,
6/30/22
O/E
X
X
X
X
X
O/E
X
X
X
X
--
CECILE
LARSON,
6/30/24
O/E
X
O/E
X
X
O
X
O
X
X
X
KEVIN
SELLERGREN,
6130/22
X
X
X
O/E
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
O/E
JORDAN
STORK, NOAH
6/30/24
X
O/E
X
X
X
X
X
O/E
X
O/E
X
X
THOMANN,
6/30/23
X
O/E
X
O/E
O/E
X
X
O/E
X
X
O/E
X
DEANNA
VILLANUEVA,
6/30/25
--
X
NICOLE
WAGNER,
6/30/23
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
--
X
X
X
FRANK
WELU-
6/30/25
-
X
REYNOLDS,
CHRISTINA
KEY: X = Present
O = Absent
O/E= Absent/Excused
--- = Not a Member